Divorce by Jane Deegan, CTS Explanations Series
I was pre-disposed to like this book as Tina Beattie had recently savaged it on the Tablet’s blog, as recorded and fisked by Deacon NIck Donnelly here.
On the basis that anything that causes the blessed Tina to get her knickers in a twist is likely to be good stuff, I expected to enjoy it.
I did. What I had not expected was how thorough, thoughtful, thought-provoking and well-referenced it would be. Mrs Deegan draws extensively on the Catechism of the Catholic Church, the documents of the 2nd Vatican Council, Humanae Vitae, Evangelium Vitae, and above all Sacred Scripture to explain the Church’s teaching. In 62 pages of text there are 128 footnotes and references.
So she starts by looking at the original meaning of marriage in creation: 'Their bodies make visible and invisible truth: that man and woman are created through love, for love'. Love is the primary meaning of marriage, and into that love God has placed the gift of fertility and procreation. Then, very unfashionably, she discusses the effect of the Fall and Original Sin: it is only by understanding this that we are able to make sense of our experience: 'Where the love of God and each other had filled their hearts, now the self takes centre stage.'
She then considers Marriage in the new covenant: Marriage as sacramental, ordained by Christ, and the essential truths of fidelity and indissolubility, made possible by His grace. She highlights how divorce contradicts both the internal meaning and the external sign of marriage.
That leads naturally to a consideration of the obstacles to Grace in the Sacrament of Marriage: a wrong understanding of reality, individualism, hedonism and sin, including a long examination of the dreadful effect of contraception on love and communion. (It was this, in particular, that so exercised Professor Beattie, of course.)
She then examines the impact of divorce on children, and goes on to consider why remarriage is impossible, pointing out that it is out of love for the individuals involved (among other reasons) that the Church has to hold firm to the teaching handed on by Christ Himself.
Finally, she explains a number of issues that are sometimes misunderstood or need further explanation: the true meaning of ‘the Internal Forum,’ abandoned spouses who remain faithful, invalid marriages and the Pauline and Petrine privileges.
At a time when marriage is so besieged, when so many, Catholics included misunderstand it and misrepresent it, when divorce is seen as normal and acceptable, and when the government is threatening to redefine marriage all together, it is important for Catholics to educate themselves thoroughly about marriage.
This booklet provides an excellent starting point for that, particularly if the reader follows up the references assiduously.
Learning and loving the truth about marriage leads us into the heart of the mystery of the Church; rejecting us leads us... well, ask Professor Beattie...