|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Guojing
*
| 1250818370
| 9781250818379
| 1250818370
| 4.06
| 31
| Feb 18, 2025
| Feb 18, 2025
|
really liked it
|
As our lives are increasingly swallowed up by the demands of labor, families find themselves spending more time with their technology than each other.
As our lives are increasingly swallowed up by the demands of labor, families find themselves spending more time with their technology than each other. Oasis, a bittersweet and gorgeously illustrated graphic novel from Guojing, finds siblings JieJie and DiDi spending their days in a barren wasteland of a desert braving sandstorms to find water and travel to a payphone booth for a daily chat with their mother. Their mother works in the nearby city and cannot yet afford admission to the city for her children, but when the siblings stumble upon a discarded AI robot they may have found a replacement mother to care for them. With breathtaking art that further crafts a heavy atmosphere of loneliness and frustration punctuated by tenderness, Guojing harnesses a whole slew of modern anxieties around labor, technology, family, financial stability and meeting basic needs into a succinctly haunting sci-fi fable. A beautifully heart wrenching tale that can be equally enjoyable and poignant for readers of any age, Oasis is a quiet little gem. [image] Oasis managed to really move me in a short space of time. The art is breathtaking and Guojing is able to instill so much life into the two siblings that you can immediately empathize with them. They are so cute and care for each other while having to survive alone in a desert. [image] While the recent adaptation of The Wild Robot retaining it freshly in cultural memory may garner a few passing comparisons, Oasis feels rather original in its simplicity. The children find a destroyed AI, fix it, and program it to be their mother. While the older sibling is apprehensive, the AI Mom quickly wins them over and truly does take care of them. [image] Yet when the mother returns, she is initially horrified to find herself replaced by an AI that isn’t actually a mother with real emotions. It nudges our increasing social reliance on technology and the aide of AI, with AIs being able to mimic human interactions and people even turning to AI for companionship (the internet is full of articles about people dating an AI), and how the absence of the mother has pushed the children closer to the AI. The AI Mom fills a need and instill hope in the children, real authentic hope and real feelings of closeness. The story, for how short it is, does a good job of addressing this nuance. ‘May we all be blessed with long life. Though we are far apart… …we are still able to share the moonlight together.’ Something Oasis does best, however, is capture the plight of parenting and the struggles to find financial footing even with a full time job. The percentage of stay-at-home parents has declined significantly over the past two generations while the percentage of parents feeling financially secure despite having a full-time job has plummeted. And the cost of daycare almost negates having a part time job in order to pay for daycare. Oasis looks at the anxieties over how, despite greater technology to assist us, people are finding they are working more, longer, or struggling to find jobs they enjoy. In Oasis, the mother works around the clock ‘like a robot’ in a blue-collar job that looks like something out of the film Metropolis to uphold the city now mostly run by AI robots yet still cannot afford to bring her kids to come stay in the city with her. [image] There is a moment near the end where she crumbles under the duress of having to always miss her children in order to work while still never having enough money. ‘I wish we could survive without money’, she says. While Oasis is a beautiful yet heartbreaking slice of life story, it does end on a note of hope and optimism that really ties the whole thing together gorgeously. A lovely little story with great artwork, I really enjoyed Oasis. 4.5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Hardcover
| ||||||||||||||
4.24
| 2,973,878
| Oct 16, 1950
| Aug 1970
|
really liked it
|
To enter the novels of Narnia is not unlike taking the first few steps through the titular wardrobe itself. As a good fantasy ought, it pulls you from
To enter the novels of Narnia is not unlike taking the first few steps through the titular wardrobe itself. As a good fantasy ought, it pulls you from the world around you into a new realm of possibility, or magic and mystery, of epic quests filled with fierce battles and friendships that withstand even the darkest of hours to keep hope burning bright. Over the years I’ve returned to C.S. Lewis’ The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe having read it myself as a child and then again to my own children when they reached an age to follow along. Each time I find the journey to be just as magical, yet increasingly more joyful as I can bring a new young reader into the world for their first time and experience the magic with them. I can remember many days of reenacting scenes from Narnia with my oldest in our apartment living room when she was 6 and we even went for Halloween as Lucy and Mr. Tumnus. The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe is a delightful story to kick off a rather delightful series that isn’t without issues but never fails to bring a smile to my face. How can you not love beavers dispensing whiskey to kids to get them to sleep or a Santa passing out weapons, and for a story of good and evil the series does a fairly nuanced look with morally grey elements. A tale of good and evil, warfare, betrayal and redemption, bravery and hope, and a tale that has lasted for generations. [image] First published in 1950, Lewis wrote The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe for his granddaughter, Lucy Barfield, and dedicated the novel to her. Her namesake becomes one of the great fantasy characters, a young, kind, and brave girl who is ‘a good leader’ at a time when most fantasy leads were still boys. For the uninitiated, this first story takes the four Pevensie siblings—Peter, Susan, Edmund, and Lucy in descending age order—out from under the bombs of the London Blitz into a magical world where The White Witch rules with a ruthless and violent grip on the talking animals and spirits who live there. A world where it is ‘always winter and never christmas,’ but the arrival of these ‘Daughters of Eve’ and ‘Sons of Adam’ may be the spark to light the fire of revolt and liberate Narnia. If they don’t get caught by the witch first… The first in the series, it isn’t necessarily Lewis’ strongest writing and at times it may feel a bit dry for children (at least in the modern day) whereas the style feels more fluid in later books. Still, it is magical, fun and full of unforgettable characters like Aslan, a Father Christmas who hands out weapons, and my personal favorite, Mr. Tumnus, who was Lewis’ initial idea for the tale all the way back when he was 16 with ‘a picture in my mind — of a faun carrying an umbrella and parcels in a snowy wood.’ The infamous lamppost, the symbol of light that connects the two worlds, also preceded the novel with Lewis walking home from Malvern pub one snowy night with fellow ‘Inklings’ J.R.R. Tolkien and George Sayer, commenting that the imagery of the lampposts aglow in the snow would be perfect in a novel. It is also rumored to have been in response to Tolkien’s insistence that a lamppost was not suitable for a fantasy novel. While this may be just a rumor, Tolkien did write something similar about electric lights in his essay On Fairy Stories : ‘The electric street-lamp may indeed be ignored, simply because it is so insignificant and transient. Fairy-stories, at any rate, have many more permanent and fundamental things to talk about. Lightning, for example. The escapist is not so subservient to the whims of evanescent fashion as these opponents. He does not make things (which it may be quite rational to regard as bad) his masters or his gods by worshipping them as inevitable, even “inexorable.” And his opponents, so easily contemptuous, have no guarantee that he will stop there: he might rouse men to pull down the street-lamps.’ Given the competitive nature between the two (and the Inklings at large) I’ll choose to believe Lewis put this in just for the dig. It’s more fun that way. ‘The whole story, paradoxically enough, strengthens our relish for real life. This excursion into the preposterous sends us back with renewed pleasure to the actual.’ —Lewis, On Stories: And Other Essays on Literature Fantasy is often thought of as escapism, yet Lewis takes the children from his tale from one war into another. They escape the bombings to a quiet home in the country but quickly find themselves running from the White Witch in Narnia and doing battle with great beasts. There is a sense of Lewis demonstrating that war is inescapable and hardships follow us wherever we go, but there is also an impression that we cannot try to avoid evil and must confront it. In Narnia the children are able to be the heroes, to stand up to evil in a way they could not against the Nazi bombs falling upon their city, and it is empowering. ‘Fairy tales do not tell children the dragons exist. Children already know that dragons exist,’ G.K. Chesterton once wrote, ‘Fairy tales tell children the dragons can be killed.’ And in Narnia, children learn that evil can be conquered, wrongs can be righted, and redemption can be had. ‘All shall be done, but it may be harder than you think.’ I’ve always loved the character Edmund, such a shit in the first book but later one of the best characters (Eustace follows a similar trajectory later on). He initially sells out his siblings to the White Witch for a taste of Turkish Delight—a food that was made with sugar which would have been hard to come by under WWII rationing and also would remind him of good times. I enjoy how it is in keeping with Fairy Tale tropes that eating food within the fairy tale is always a bad idea and we see the Turkish Delights become a symbol of temptation. But, with the love of family that is willing to take him back, Edmund is able to find his redemption. ‘We have nothing if not belief.’ There is a very moral message underpinning much of this novel and many are quick to point to it as a Christian parable. One can read it this way, of course, or enjoy the surface fantasy, and I think both are held fairly well in his text. In An Experiment in Criticism, Lewis writes: ‘We sit down before [a] picture in order to have something done to us, not that we may do things with it. The first demand any work of any art makes upon us is surrender. Look. Listen. Receive. Get yourself out of the way.’ Lewis argues for approaching a book by allowing it to consume us and wash over us, not to approach it with the intent to pick it apart on the first go and I think this is also the best approach to a first read of Narnia. But one cannot escape the Christian stories going on either. Aslan as a symbol for Jesus and the resurrection for instance. But in his article Sometimes Fairy Stories May Say Best What’s to Be Said, which appeared in the New York Times in 1956, Lewis states that the story is itself just some images that made a fun story and were never written with the total intend to be a “Christian fairy tale”: ‘Some people seem to think that I began by asking myself how I could say something about Christianity to children; then fixed on the fairy tale as an instrument; then collected information about child-psychology and decided what age-group I’d write for; then drew up a list of basic Christian truths and hammered out “allegories” to embody them. This is all pure moonshine. I couldn’t write in that way at all. Everything began with images; a faun carrying an umbrella, a queen on a sledge, a magnificent lion. At first there wasn’t even anything Christian about them; that element pushed itself in of its own accord.’ Of course, later on Lewis would write in a letter to a friend a much more Christian focused idea of creating Aslan: ‘[Aslan] is an invention giving an imaginary answer to the question, ‘What might Christ become like if there really were a world like Narnia and He chose to be incarnate and die and rise again in that world as He actually has done in ours?’”’ The idea of Aslan as a Christian symbol for God is quite clear in later novels too. Lewis does have a religiousness but even if religious stories aren’t your thing this story is still just as fun. I also greatly appreciate the effort towards a moral greatness where characters can be flawed but still not bad. It’s quite refreshing. ‘People who have not been in Narnia sometimes think that a thing cannot be good and terrible at the same time.’ Okay, sure there is an element where Lewis gets criticism for some not great moments around women. Lucy is assured her bravery isn’t questioned when told to stay out of battles but that battles get ugly when women are involved. Which, okay??? What? Sure, battles are pretty ugly when men are involved too. And there’s some pretty old timey “my damn wife” style of humor around the beaver couple which didn’t age great, so be advised. Yet on the whole it’s pretty fun still. I have long loved The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe and I am thrilled to find that I enjoy it again and again with repeat readings. While not the strongest in the series, it makes for a good start and plenty of good fun. Especially when you share it with others. 4/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Feb 17, 2025
|
Mass Market Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||||
1668082438
| 9781668082430
| 1668082438
| 3.27
| 1,136
| Jul 04, 2024
| Jan 07, 2025
|
really liked it
|
‘This is not a place you might encounter a ghost. Did you expect to, want to?’ The elusivity of memory and shadowy strands of the past and thwarted asp ‘This is not a place you might encounter a ghost. Did you expect to, want to?’ The elusivity of memory and shadowy strands of the past and thwarted aspirations swirl like smoke through the poetic pages of Anita Desai’s Rosarita. Two decades since her previous novel, The Zigzag Way, Desai returns with a kaleidoscopic work pared down to succinct surreality and prose so perfectly polished you’d swear it refracts light. Written in 2nd person to pull the reader further into the spiraling mysteries and confusion, Rosarita follows Bonita, a young student from India studying in Mexico, as an encounter with an older woman presents a shocking tale of her mother’s past. Though she can hardly believe it had been hushed into obscurity, Bonita fumbles through a series of journeys to determine if her mother may have once been an artist living abroad of if the old woman’s head is ‘a teeming pit of fantasies.’ Is this a new revelation or has she been tricked into a ‘charmed moment embroidered by recollection’? Still, shadows of the past haunt the present as the novella takes on wings of a fabelistic quality where the search may unearth more than a few examinations of the past and Desai’s Rosarita delivers a compact and compelling tale of memory, family dynamics, and the struggles of women in pursuit of their own dreams under patriarchal demands. ‘How could it be possible to live parallel lives with no apparent connection?’ Desai’s approach in Rosarita rather brilliantly straddles both poetic clarity and slippery surrealist confusion, conjuring gothic undertones despite residing almost entirely in stark realism. There were wisps that recalled some of my favorite artists associated with the movement of surrealism in Mexico, such as Remedios Varo or Leonora Carrington. Desai, however, was inspired by the art of Satish Gujral who studied with Diego Rivera and other Mexican muralists and drew an artistic connection between violence of the partition of India in 1947 and the Mexican Revolution in 1910. Bonita imagines an event that would have led her mother to Mexico featuring an art lecture comparing the two events. Images of trains oozing blood and other horrors create such an effect she flees the exhibit. ‘At their feet corpses left for vultures to gorge on. Wounds, mutilations thrust in the faces of those who survive to declare: this is Man, intrinsically, this is his history: look!’ Desai herself has spent plenty of time in Mexico. Having moved from India to the United States in 1980s to teach at M.I.T., she found the winters too harsh for her tastes and began to winter in the Mexican city Oaxaca. ‘Getting to know Mexico opened up another world for me, another life,’ Desai told the New York Times, ‘It’s strange because it’s so like India, I feel utterly at home there. And yet there’s something about Mexico that’s surrealistic rather than realistic.’ This effect certainly shines through here. [image] From The Aztec World, a mural by Diego Rivera ‘You will see her as she had never shown herself and you had never seen.’ The aspects on the elusivity of the past in Rosarita move as circuitously through the narrative as Bonita does the streets of Mexico. There is an aspect that reminded me much of French Nobel Laureate Patrick Modiano yet Desai’s is uniquely her own as it points towards examinations of women’s lives under cold, controlling men. Recalling both her mother and grandmother’s quiet resignation to domestic duties, she begins to understand how a life of art could have been swallowed up into her ‘unwilling martyrdom’ under a husband who would not approve of a wife with artistic aspirations. Especially one who’s past is never discussed leading Bonita to consider being an artist was another element that granted an ‘unsuitability as a wife’ that made her parents all the more a curious match. The only evidence, however, of this potential artist life resides in the insistence of the strange old woman (first termed The Stranger and, later, The Trickster) island a yellowing memory of a ‘sketch in wishy-washy pale pastels’ that hung in her room. The painting featured a mother and child that ‘could have been one here in San Miguel,’ but this is mere speculation. The impression in the photo that the mother and child are not looking at each other or even close ‘as if they had no relation to each other, each absorbed in a separate world, and silent’ makes for an excellent impression of her and her own mother’s hardly mentioned connection, now gone totally silent with her mother in the grave. ‘You had resisted her fantastical tale but now find you would like to believe it. Could she, like a wizard or a magician, bring your mother to life again even if it is a life you never knew or suspected?’ Through episodes of meetings, misdirection and even a flight to The Trickster’s ancestral home, Bonita finds the truth constantly slipping through her fingers. Is she on the trail to truth, is the old woman losing her mind or is this ‘all a piece of theatre she has arranged’? Or is this, perhaps, Bonita herself falling into disarray? ‘You realize how far you have been dragged into a fantasy of her life. But is it her fantasy, or yours? Yours or the tricksters?’Desai shirks easy resolution and tidy understanding in favor of a more surreal and introspective look at memory and family history as a concept rather than a mystery to solve. It makes for an excellent atmospheric read with a lightness of touch that may leave some readers wanting something more concrete, yet the effect of its elusivity is heart enough and, coupled with such crystalline prose, makes for a worthwhile read. 3.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 14, 2025
|
Feb 14, 2025
|
Feb 14, 2025
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
059338122X
| 9780593381229
| B0BRMP8R6N
| 4.42
| 858
| Feb 06, 2024
| Feb 06, 2024
|
really liked it
|
‘Poetry gives a voice to the voiceless,’ Turkish poet Gonca Özmen once said of poetry’s power, ‘it makes the invisible visible.’ Harnessing the gift o
‘Poetry gives a voice to the voiceless,’ Turkish poet Gonca Özmen once said of poetry’s power, ‘it makes the invisible visible.’ Harnessing the gift of words and poetry is especially empowering for those who feel overlooked, cast out, misunderstood or simply desiring to be heard. Such is the desire of Sudanese-American teenager Samira in Safia Elhillo’s powerful novel in verse, Bright Red Fruit, a YA coming-of-age tale where poetry becomes an outlet for Samira to examine her identity and interpersonal relationships. Stifled by a “bad girl” reputation with her aunts back home, Samira heads to New York City for a fresh start in poetry workshops only to find the path littered with manipulative men and never quite free from her mother’s grip. A moving and poetically elegant novel that integrates the myth of Persephone as thematic texture to Samira’s own story, Bright Red Fruit is as empowering as it is inspiring. ‘i am going to show him i'm a serious artist just like him, that i'm grown, just like him not a kid, but a poet, a woman.’ Having rather loved Safia Elhillo’s poetry—her collection Girls That Never Die is simply outstanding—I was excited to check out her YA novel in verse. Addressing many of the themes that appears in her adult work, yet gorgeously reconfigured into a narrative for a YA audience with relatable characters struggling with one another and their own destructive impulses, Bright Red Fruit tackles rather heady and heavy topics with grace. I really enjoyed the way the novel is in poetic form, befitting it’s narrative, with the use of emails and text exchanges threaded in quite effectively. Samira’s own poetry appears and Elhillo does an excellent job of crafting them in a way to show her improve and edit her own ideas that felt appropriate for a novel about poetry workshops. ‘In New York I think I can finally be free.’ Samira is a character who admits ‘ever since i was small i’ve wanted to be loved,’ but often finds the love of family to be cloying and seeks affirmation in unhealthy spaces—such as the attention of an older man who’s poetry she admires. Yet she is determined to be her own person and leaves for NYC knowing her reputation back home is a false impression of her where those who know her are quick to assume the worst. ‘here's the story: in sixteen years my lips Her mother will not allow her to continue poetry workshops if she has any romantic entanglements, yet she has caught the eye of Horus and is deeply infatuated with his gaze meeting her in desire. It is a well done look at how Samira, in her wish to be desirable, acts older than she is and is willfully ignorant to the red flags displayed by Horus who is manipulating her vulnerabilities. ‘It’s intoxicating,’ she thinks, ‘to be cared about like this / to have someone want so badly to know me.’ The reader, however, can detect a clear sense of grooming and a Elhillo does well by giving a narrative arc around Samira being able to recognize it herself and find a sense of identity and strength not dependent upon the desires of a romantic partner. ‘In the tale of Persephone which should be read as an argument between the mother and the lover— the daughter is just meat.’ —Louise Glück, from Persephone the Wanderer The tale of Persephone is integral to the narrative yet, as Elhillo points out in an interview ‘rarely had I read a version of that myth that centered on the agency of the daughter, where it is like the battle of wills between the mother and the kidnapper.’ Like the above Glück poem, which serves as an epigraph to the story, we see how Samira feels like a mere piece of meat caught between the wills of her mother and Horus. Glück’s poetry was a major influence of Elhillo as a poet. In an interview with Service 95, Elhillo recommends the collection Averno ‘Louise was one of my most important teachers and this is my favourite of her books. Blunt and plainspoken and austere and still so vivid, so pretty. Such surprising musicality. My novel Bright Red Fruit owes a lot to the Persephone poems in this book.’ I enjoy the way Elhillo shapes this novel not necessarily as a retelling but with enough touchstones to the myth to make it relevant while also rectifying the tale by centering the Persephone-like character and giving her agency and a voice. ‘the girl, throughout history is still silent a blank space for us all to color in with whatever we already believe’ Safia Elhillo’s Bright Red Fruit is a lovely novel of poetry and identity. Exploring cultural and familial expectations, the struggles of finding a voice, navigating toxic relationships and surviving the teenage years, Elhillo writes with beauty and empathy for a rather engaging novel. 4.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 09, 2025
|
Feb 09, 2025
|
Feb 09, 2025
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||
0316381993
| 9780316381994
| 0316381993
| 4.20
| 93,287
| Apr 05, 2016
| Apr 05, 2016
|
really liked it
|
The natural world can be a cold, cruel place full of the inevitability of danger and death. What purpose do we serve in such a world, what reason can
The natural world can be a cold, cruel place full of the inevitability of danger and death. What purpose do we serve in such a world, what reason can we find so we are truly living and not just killing time (and each other)? When Rozzum unit 7134, or Roz for short, is activated in an island wilderness she begins to look for a sense of purpose–a robot designed to serve needs a task to complete. Yet along the way she discovers that kindness, community and love shared can be a purpose that makes such a world one worth having lived in and The Wild Robot by Peter Brown is certainly a book worth having read. Written with a middle-grade audience in mind, The Wild Robot is quietly moving and thought provoking in a way that can touch any reader regardless of age and adults will find this just as charming as younger readers. Its sort of like Becky Chambers’s Monk and Robot books but for a younger audience. A tender story that doesn’t shirk away from the darker parts of life, Brown crafts a modern classic of children’s literature that certainly warmed my heart. ‘As you might know, robots don’t really feel emotions. Not the way animals do. And yet, as she sat in her crumpled crate, Roz felt something like curiosity.’ Last year, an article appeared in the New York Times by Craig Fehrman (you can read it HERE) about why sad books for children can be healing and how The Wild Robot became his child’s favorite with him even dressing as the robot for Halloween. It was a great article but what really caught my attention was the opening line: ‘Last summer, my wife and I took our kids to Reader’s World, a wonderful bookstore in Holland, Mich.’ Reader: I was the person working at Reader’s World bookstore that day. I remembered the interaction, I remembered how our children’s librarian at the library I also work at has long said it was a favorite and was often the book I recommended because of that. Now that I’ve finally seen the film I realized I too should probably read it. And I have loved it. I think you will too, its such a charming story of life, death, love and community and Brown’s illustrations really add a lovely element of fun to it with art that perfectly matches the tone of the story. [image] As the article above discusses, it is a sad book at times. But it is also a really creative one that sparks the imagination and gets the reader thinking about how our mind and emotions work. Sure, Roz doesn’t have emotions as the narrator tells us (the narrator speaks directly to the reader a very wise yet whimsical tone that is really endearing and effortlessly flows as it pulls us through the story) because she is a robot, but as Roz begins to meet the memorable cast of animals and learns to care for Brightbill, Roz discovers there might be something inside her nobody expected to occur in a robot. I love the way Roz comes to live with the animals and, with a mind for problem solving, first sets out to decode their language and learn their ways. ‘She discovered that all the different animals shared one common language; they just spoke the language in different ways. You might say each species spoke with its own unique accent.’ This is a quiet and cozy story that balances out the darkness with a lot of warmth and humor, with great quips like ‘the robot's programming stopped her from being violent, but nothing stopped her from being annoying.’ Which is all really great because, admittedly, this book gets fairly heavy. It is an exploration of life, togetherness, family and kindness, but with life we inevitably have death. And in the wild…well its animals killing one another for survival. Luckily Brown approaches the discussions in really productive ways that show there is a balance and this inevitability of death isn’t something to be bothered by but something we must all embrace as a fact of life. ‘[I]t was a quiet spring. There were fewer insects buzzing, fewer birds singing, fewer rodents rustling. Many creatures had frozen to death over the winter. And as the last of the snow melted away, their corpses were slowly revealed. The wilderness really can be ugly sometimes. But from that ugliness came beauty. You see, those poor dead creatures returned to the earth, their bodies nourished the soil, and they helped create the most dazzling spring bloom the island had ever known.’ Characters do die and there are many sad moments (not all of the death is natural however, and environmental issues come up such as poisoned water killing a nest of turtle eggs), but ultimately the book still feels uplifting. And very, very healing to be honest. The aspects of motherhood and caring for one another are enough to move even the coldest of readers to tears and feelings, not unlike how even an unfeeling robot operating on basic programming can learn to feel. ‘Maybe Roz really was defective, and some glitch in her programming had caused her to accidentally become a wild robot. Or maybe Roz was designed to think and learn and change; she had simply done those things better than anyone could have imagined. However it happened, Roz felt lucky to have lived such an amazing life. And every moment had been recorded in her computer brain. Even her earliest memories were perfectly clear. She could still see the sun shining through the gash in her crate. She could still hear the waves crashing against the shore. She could still smell the salt water and the pine trees. Would she ever see and hear and smell those things again? Would she ever again climb a mountain, or build a lodge, or play with a goose? Not just a goose. A son. Brightbill had been Roz’s son from the moment she picked up his egg. She had saved him from certain death, and then he had saved her. He was the reason Roz had lived so well.’ The bits with Brightbill are so lovely. But so are all the other bits and all the animals learning to live in a better harmony with one another even if death and needing to eat will still be an inevitable part of reality. ‘If I could do it all over again, I'd spend more time helping others. All I've ever done is dig tunnels. Some of them were real beauties too, but they're all hidden underground, where they're no good to anyone but me.’ This book is teeming with great themes that are all handled with lightest of touches and paints in rather broad strokes of metaphor that work really well when housed in a children’s story. It makes them accessible and thoughtful but still manages to not feel overly heavy handed, which I really appreciate. It comes with equal parts hope and despair and handles it all quite well. ‘You’ll never be the perfect mother, so just do the best you can. All Brightbill really needs is to know you’re doing your best.’ So, sure, The Wild Robot is a sad book, but it is also a very moving, optimistic and healing book. It makes for a heartwrenching look at motherhood and all the efforts that go into it, with a really lovely take on ideas of adoption and found family. It is aimed at younger readers and have plenty of big themes for them around family and bullying and more, but adults are sure to enjoy this as well. A quick read with a big heart that will likely become a modern classic, I really enjoyed The Wild Robot.’ 4.5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Sep 30, 2024
|
Oct 28, 2024
|
Sep 30, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0358394740
| 9780358394747
| 0358394740
| 4.29
| 1,864
| Jun 11, 2024
| Jun 11, 2024
|
really liked it
|
Fixing up a house is not the same as fixing up a home, but for 14 year old Almudena the three months she spends fixing up an old Brownstone with her f
Fixing up a house is not the same as fixing up a home, but for 14 year old Almudena the three months she spends fixing up an old Brownstone with her father might be the opportunity to make both happen. An adorable coming-of-age graphic novel centered on family and identity, Brownstone from Samuel Teer and artist Mar Julia is a heartwarming hit. When her mother has to leave for a dance tour for the summer, Almudena is sent to stay with her father for three months, the catch is that she has never before met him. Suddenly immersed in a Guatemalan culture she was previously unaware of and unable to speak Spanish, Almudena navigates the frictions of her new community in this excellent story with plenty of space to breathe and let the nuance shine through explorations of community, gentrification and family. [image] A big shout out to Hope and their review for inspiring me to read this as they are always correct when recommending a book. This was an adorable graphic novel and I was pleased to see how much space it gave to exploring the topics within while keeping the pace comfortably forward moving. Mar Julia’s artwork is wonderful with excellent depictions of city life and characters that are able to display a wide range of emotions quite effectively. In a story where the main character is outside the culture and language and must rely on visual cues and translation, the book using a strong sense of visual literacy to tell the story was nice. Suddenly dropped into a culture she had no idea was her own is a lot to Almudena, struggling to not feel like a fraud while her neighbors teasingly call her “off-brand” and trying to make sense of her new identity. It is empathetically presented with a good use of humor, particularly around her finding the food too spicy and being told she needs to check the “white people aisle” of the grocery store. [image] There is an excellent cast of characters here that allows the story to wind through a lot of other examinations of identity, such two characters coming to terms with their queer identities in a community that isn’t always the most accepting or supportive. There is also the issue of gentrification closing stores and whitewashing the predominantly Guatemalan area as well as her father’s backstory of coming to the United States. It makes for a very well-rounded story that gives a lot of room for character development and understanding that I quite enjoyed. It does occasionally feel like issues or disputes are resolved rather quickly, though with a cast of teenagers it is easy to dismiss, especially as it is the collective cast coming together and interacting that makes this such a charming story. [image] Brownstone is a gorgeous tale of family and identity and quite a heartwarming read. Almudena spends much of the story trying to fix not only the house with her father, but also everyones problems and relationships and has to learn she can’t do everything herself. But her efforts and the changes she can make mean a whole lot A cute read that will charm readers of any age. 4/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jul 29, 2024
|
Jul 29, 2024
|
Jul 29, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1959030558
| 9781959030553
| 1959030558
| 3.73
| 5,108
| Jun 04, 2024
| Jun 04, 2024
|
really liked it
|
Making lemonade out of a lemon life sounds like a pretty good alternative when life hands you a pile of rubble instead, and Charles could probably use
Making lemonade out of a lemon life sounds like a pretty good alternative when life hands you a pile of rubble instead, and Charles could probably use a glass since he’s had to battle sobriety for 22 years now. Fire Exit, the debut novel from Morgan Talty who awed critics and readers alike with his short story collection Night of the Living Rez, interrogates personal history caught in the teeth of governmental gears where heritage and identity are questions of paperwork and lived experiences are subjected to the erasure of time and failing memory. It is a sobering story of swallowing guilt and regret that would melt under its own melancholia were it not for Talty’s ability to make each scene so direct and gut wrenching as if the prose were being drug through the shattered glass of the American dream. ‘I knew and still know what it was like to both not belong and belong,’ Talty’s narrator states, and this dichotomy is something Charles will grapple with as we watch the slow burn deterioration of his life lead up to a decision to tell his daughter the truth about her past while also watching the deterioration of his own mother to dementia, taking the untold stories of his life along with her. Fiercely moving and heartbreaking, Fire Exit is an empathetic look at navigating the labyrinthian mazes of genetics and grief in a country that would just as soon wipe the whole of indigenous peoples under the rug. ‘We are made of stories, and if we don’t know them—the ones that make us—how can we ever be fully realized? How can we ever be who we really are?’ Set around the Penobscot Reservation in Maine, the site of Talty’s own childhood upbringing, and delves deep into the opaqueness of federal laws surrounding reservation requirements and jurisdiction. As he told Chicago Review of Books in an interview, the novel was conceived while wrestling with fellow indigenous author Louise Erdrich’s own interrogation of Federal Laws as he read her National Book Award winning novel The Round House. Talty says: ‘Federal Indian Law makes no sense. None. And so in reading her novel—in seeing how Erdrich looked at the law—I wondered, what is a situation that could arise out of the nonsensical structure holding up Indian Country? Blood quantum jumped into my head and that was the genesis.’ Blood Quantum—a rather controversial measurement put into law by 18th century white colonial settlers to determine the amount of indigenous blood a person possesses—reduces identity to a percentage in order to restrict who can belong to a tribe or live on a reservation and how that passes along to children. And while Charles makes frequent variations on the refrain of ‘all blood looks the same,’ blood is the dilemma assailing Charles’ entire life. Able to live on the reservation as a child due to his step-father, Fredrick, Charles loses his claim to heritage at the moment of Fredrick’s shocking death. Yet now in the present Charles is forced to watch his daughter, Elizabeth, from across the river where she lives in the reservation, her mother having married another man and claiming the child as his in order to secure enough of a claim to blood in order to stay there. ‘I wanted her to know who I was—who I really was—instead of a white man who lived across from her all her life and watched her grow up from this side of the river.’ The novel is two-fold. One is Charles’ moral conundrum over whether or not he tell Elizabeth the truth against the wishes of her mother. This is less about meeting his daughter, or so he claims, and more about giving her a key to her past. ‘All I wanted was that she know the history that was hers, that this history wasn’t lost or wasted because of the illusion we’d tried to live in so neatly, that there was a life she could have lived and been a part of, and that she know she was as much a part of me as she was not.’ The other issue is that his mother is quickly losing herself to dementia, and not only is the time running out to tell Elizabeth her history, but also to learn his own as she begins to forget who he is beyond her caregiver. Private history sometimes tumbles out his mother’s mouth, but more frequently it slides off the cliffs of memory and into oblivion. Interestingly enough I have recently just read another novel about a man considering his estranged daughter named Elisabeth (Ali Smith’s Spring) and a novel about history washed away by the loss of memory (Julie Otsuka’s The Swimmers). Talty’s combination of the two themes really hit hard and heartbreakingly so as he manages to give each the attention they deserve as a fully realized part of the novel while also functional commentary on one another through their juxtapositions and parallels. There are many, with births and deaths juxtaposed, or dementia and depression paralleled in the shared horrific treatment, and while, admittedly, the constant use of parallels feels a bit contrived at times in order to land a larger emotional blow, the effect is so shattering that it hardly matters. ‘There was this history I was a part of. A history my body had experienced and moved though. But I never knew it. It made me wonder how much I didn’t know. We had that much in common, Elizabeth and I, and I felt she should know her body was special and she should know its history. Especially the one it would not tell her and the one it could not see.’ For a novel about indigenous identity, Talty opts for a narrator who is, effectively, outside it. Both in terms of blood and in terms of his exile from the reservation. ‘To think that the reservation is what makes an Indian an Indian is to massacre all over again the Natives who do not populate it,’ Charles offers, extending the harm caused by racist lawmaking and attempts at erasing indigenous identities (another novel from this year, Wandering Star by indigenous author Tommy Orange—who provides the cover blurb here—rather effectively addresses these issues and is a great companion read to Fire Exit) not only to non-reservation indigenous peoples but everyone. In her book What White People Can Do Next, author and activist Emma Dabiri drives home the point that what enshrines harmful and racist laws is the belief that, if you are white, it does not harm you but calls attention to how the harm is spread across class lines and the hard from such laws oozes over everyone. ‘I just need you to recognize this shit is killing you, too,’ she write and here Talty has done an excellent job of crafting a similar vantage point on how Charles, not indigenous, is suffering because these laws. Talty shows how we are all pulled down into the slaughterhouse of these Federal Laws but also does so in a way that doesn’t center whiteness and ensures the Penobscot nation is the focus. In an interview with The Rumpus, Talty was asked 'do you feel it’s your responsibility, or purpose, to tell Native stories?' to which Talty responded: 'On one hand, I feel like it’s not my responsibility—I will write and have written stories that do not have Native characters in them—but on the other hand, colonialism and a dominant white readership has made it my responsibility. But then again, maybe it’s not about responsibility in terms of storytelling but rather a responsibility to be a story-keeper, a person who holds onto the stories and passes them down.' There is a strong cultural heritage throughout the story and Talty nets a lot of nuance in reservation life. The struggles are bountiful for Charles, such as the rampant alcoholism and addictions faced both on and off the reservation. It is a bleak portrayal of life but Talty reminds us that we are all, in some ways, complicit. ‘It was Fredrick’s love that made me feel Native. He loved me so much that I was, and still am, convinced that I was from him, part of him, part of what he was part of. That was how I felt about Elizabeth—in truth, she was a descendant only from her mother’s side, and if that were to come out and she were taken off the census, would she feel any less Native? I didn’t think so.’ Talty writes that ‘we are made of stories’ and so much of history is the struggle over the dominant narrative and who tells the story. Frederick made him feel he belonged, and what is Charles denying Elizabeth if he doesn’t tell her the truth. But also is it his place to override the story of her life she has always believed? It is an issue he will go back and forth on—Charles can be a frustrating character as he is so much blown about by the wind and while we are empathetic due to the lifetime of damages that have made him this way, it is still painful to watch—but the metaphor extends beyond the personal. The country itself is competing stories, such was the way colonialism took root, and these are the stories of those who have been brought down into generational poverty and addictions with little way out. Early on there is a rather chilling metaphor when Charles thinks about the various stories he has heard about the reservation being built over a graveyard. Regardless of which story is true, the fact remains there is death beneath their feet and we will all add our bones to the pile some day. The only story that is fixed. ‘I wanted to say it all: wanted to give her all the history that is hers. This past. This family. I wanted her to know, wanted her to understand what it meant that she was being stretched beyond the walls of her parents' house,’ A big thank you to Isabel’s lovely review which inspired me to read this. Fire Exit is a haunting and harrowing tale, and Morgan Talty expertly pulls at all the heartstrings. On the large scale it is a cutting look at the legacy of trauma and hardship caused by harmful Federal Laws around indigenous identity, yet it also functions as a tragic personal tale of a family caught in these machinations. We are all stories of our history and such histories are subject to the fallibility of memory but with Fire Exit, Talty asks of us to ensure we do not let such history be washed away. 4/5 ‘all that remained was the charred, burnt wood of the story that is hers.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Jun 10, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
3.72
| 64,023
| 1984
| Sep 08, 1998
|
really liked it
|
I realized while I was [image] This book has EVERYTHING: bleakness, desire, shame, novella length, devastating self-reflections, perfect prose, class commentary, power dynamics, depressing family dynamics, queer desire, smadding—you know that thing where the book is so sad it makes you smile because depraved and depressing novels are very much your jam, you freaky little book nerd, you—regret, French people, critiques of masculinity, critiques of colonialism, metafiction, unhinged decision making, this is a festival of fucked and feverish feelings in 120pgs and a pleasure unto death. I read this in a single sitting and I’m sitting here hours later still emotionally shaken. This is very much my sort of thing. Oh wait, I’m getting ahead of myself, we should do a Review right? Stefon, this is a GOODREADS. Okay, okay, you’re right, here goes: Memory is a butterfly flitting by in flashes and if we try to pin it down, to put our finger on the fluttering of the past, it often turns to powder upon our fingers. Memory fades or is altered by our act of trying to capture it, yet memory also has the ability to seemingly fold time. ‘Very early in my life, it was too late,’ French author Marguerite Duras writes in The Lover, a statement that directly addresses the method for which past and present become intertwined and timeless in her recollections much the way this novelistic memoir blends biography and fiction. The result is pure literary bliss. Winner of the 1984 Prix Goncourt and presented here in beautiful translation by Barbara Bray (for which she was awarded the Scott Moncrieff Prize in 1986) that captures the endlessly poetic potency of Duras’ prose, The Lover is a novel of memory, but it is also an examination of desire and navigating the self amidst family, death, social class and social taboos. This is also a novel of crossings such as the girl’s crossing of the Mekong river that often feels like the center of gravity to the narrative, the crossing of culture and age between the girl and the older Chinese man who becomes her lover, and even a crisscrossing of the timeline found in the fragmentary narrative style. A whirlwind of reflections and the ravages of desire, The Lover is as crisp as it is confident and completely shook up my heart. [image] From the 1992 film adaptation by Jean-Jacques Annaud Duras constructs a portrait of a woman across her many ages, all spiraling into one, and opens on a pitch perfect look at the course of a life all within one face: ‘One day, I was already old, in the entrance of a public place a man came up to me. He introduced himself and said, “I’ve known you for years. Everyone says you were beautiful when you were young, but I want to tell you I think you’re more beautiful now than then. Rather than your face as a young woman, I prefer your face as it is now. Ravaged.’ This was a book that completely ravaged me as well. With Duras’ exquisite prose punctuated by bold assertions and harsh assessments, with the exhaustion of fragile love at the mercy to society yet burning with unquenchable passion, with the haunting looks at family and identity in the clutches of social order and colonialism, and with the rapid fire of memories that are practically flung into your face. The story is told in brief vignettes that ignore any linearity. The reflections come almost at random and almost all at once, as if Duras has dropped and shattered a jar of memories and is frantically gathering them up as they attempt to roll away underfoot. These memories are based in biography (though no previous knowledge of Duras is necessary) but take wings of fiction, almost as if to impress the theme that to touch memory or to try and understand or shape it is to rewrite it and overlay the elusive past. It’s as she writes herself: ‘The story of my life doesn’t exist. Does not exist. There’s never any centre to it. No path, no line. There are great spaces where you pretend there used to be someone, but it’s not true, there was no one. The story of one small part of my youth I’ve already written, more or less — I mean, enough to give a glimpse of it. Of this part, I mean, the part about the crossing of the river. What I’m doing now is both different and the same.’ You can feel this strong lifeforce in every sentence and word as Duras transforms herself into art upon the page. The story bears many similarities to the film Hiroshima mon amour , for which Duras’ wrote the screenplay, and plays with Duras’ own experience in Vietnam when it was still called French Indochina. It was her most popular novel, published when Duras was 70, though while working on the 1992 film adaptation she would lament over the popularity of the book. In her biography Marguerite Duras: A Life by Laure Adler, Duras is quoted as telling director Jean-Jacques Annaud ‘the Lover is a load of shit…it’s an airport novel. I wrote it when I was drunk.’ Personally I found it delightful but I do enjoy the admission of intoxication during the writing process as the cavalcade of observations strung across tenuous connections does indeed feel like the confident logic of a brilliant mind greased up and ready to rant after a few drinks. ‘She wasn’t sure that she hadn’t loved him with a love she hadn’t seen because it had lost itself in the affair like water in sand and she rediscovered it only now, through this moment of music flung across the sea.’ The novel is best remembered for the relationship between the teenage girl and the older, wealthy Chinese man she meets after crossing the Mekong River. Crossings are a large theme of the novel, and while the girl only crosses the river twice, the second time to leave the man behind and return to France, the narrator is now crossing for a third time—metaphorically—to reinvestigate the site of her memories. It is a taboo relationship, though the focus is less on the torrid love affair and more on the curious power dynamics between them. He is wealthy, experienced and much older (it is mentioned he would be arrested due to her being so young), yet, socially, she holds all the power. She is French and white and he is Chinese. She is the colonizer and he is the colonized. Even her poverty seems to not matter and she admits he is only able to obtain her because of his access to wealth. ‘poverty had knocked down the walls of the family and we were all left outside, each one fending for himself. Shameless, that’s what we were. That’s how I came to be here with you.’ A lot of this book takes a swift swipe at the house of cards that is patriarchy and masculinity. The girl (the unnamed characters make them fairly symbolic as a larger social critique, perchance?) has no masculine figure in her life (her father has been in the ground a minute) and often adopts elements of gender-role-reversal. It is in order to obtain a way away from this life as she understand that the goal in life is ‘not that you have to achieve anything, it’s that you have to get away from where you are.’ Her most distinguishing visual element frequently referenced in the text is a large, flat-brimmed hat usually worn by men. While being noted as a discounted hat to nudge the aspect of her poverty and resourcefulness, it also shows her taking on a masculine role almost as a costume and a symbol of her desire for independence. It works, as it does attract her lover and gives her access to his money, and we see how she frequently describes him in terms of weakness and subservience to her. Even his sense of dominance as sexually experienced is described in terms as a response to fear: ‘he’s a man who must make love a lot, a man who’s afraid, he must make love a lot to fight against fear.’ This stems from another element of the strange power dynamic too. Even despite the inappropriateness , legally and socially, of him sleeping with a minor she is still in a position of dominance due to her status as a white, French family. There is a startling moment where he is trying to impress her family, showing them the sights and cuisine and they refuse to even acknowledge he exists. The man is in tears asking why they abuse him so as they ignore him, gorging themselves on food and insulting the city. It is a powerful moment that shows the rampant racism embedded in obdurate social hierarchies where even this millionaire is less than human to the poor, white family. ‘I am worn out with desire.’ More on the family in a moment but I can’t move away from the erotic aspects of the novel and the discussions on sex and the body as a sort of metaphor for land being colonized without also bringing up the queer desires in the novel. The narrator reflects on Hélène Lagonelle and her nude body, bold and unashamed as if oblivious to the desire and power her naked figure represents. It is through her that the narrator wishes to pass her sexual appetites for the man into her, almost as if conquering Hélène’s body by having his be the one to take it as he does her own. ‘I’d like to devour and be devoured by those flour-white breasts of hers,’ she thinks, ‘I am worn out with desire for Hélène Lagonelle.’ ‘We, her children, are heroic, dersperate.’ Her family is another major theme of the novel, such as her disdain for her older brother, her passion and awareness of mortality found in her younger brother and most notable, the struggles to keep a family and her own mental state together found in the mother. The Lover is as much a portrait of the mother as it is the daughter. It is a family held together by shame, disgraced by their fall from financial security yet still higher on the social hierarchy in French Indochina. But also this passage completely slayed me: ‘We're united in a fundamental shame at having to live. It's here we are at the heart of our common fate, the fact that all three of us are our mother's children, the children of a candid creature murdered by society. We're on the side of the society which has reduced her to despair. Because of what's been done to our mother, so amiable, so trusting, we hate life, we hate ourselves.’ While society is constantly seen as the oppressor—more so for the lover, who is even threatened to be cut off from his family fortune if he continues with the girl—they also, shamefully, cling to society in the ways it gives them a leg up. It becomes rather self-effacing. Though the brother, who is a real shithead, also further represents colonialism, refusing to find work and spending his days engaged in theft and perversion to uphold himself. The younger brother, however, becomes the doorway through which the narrator learns ‘immortality is mortal.’ His death shakes her and makes her realize life is fleeting and death is inevitable. ‘its while its being lived that life is immortal, while its still alive. Immortality is not a matter of more or less time, its not really a question of immortality but of something else that remains unknown’ All this culminates into her turning both inward and backward on her life in reflection. It is notable that her reflections tend to focus on photographs and images of herself, as a primary theme of the novel is the idea that the self shown to the world, ones image, is what society values. There is a strong juxtaposition of interior self versus exterior self, and her reflections attempt to bridge the gaps. ‘It's as if they were happy, and as if it came from outside themselves. And I have nothing like that.’ In her novel Shame, French Nobel Prize winner Annie Ernaux contrasts her ideas of memory with that of Marcel Proust, for whom memory is exterior to the self. She explains his perspective of memory found in ‘things linked to the earth that recur periodically, confirming the permanence of mankind.’ For Ernaux, however, she finds ‘ the act of remembering can do nothing to reaffirm my sense of identity or continuity. It can only confirm the fragmented nature of my life and the belief that I belong to history.’ Duras’ The Lover seems to align more with Ernaux, particularly in the fragmented nature of the self as reflected by the narrative style, but also that the external self is a false self that does not serve as a reliable compass towards identity. It is more fit for social hierarchy and posturing, though she also finds this serves a purpose that the interior self cannot achieve. It is only late in life with a ‘ravaged face’ that she feels her external and internal self align more authentically. A moving and often devastating read, The Lover contains multitudes in its succinct space. It is no wonder this has become a classic work and Duras certainly demonstrates her exemplary prowess of prose and thought. 4.5/5 ‘And it really was unto death. It has been unto death.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||||
1250908264
| 9781250908261
| 1250908264
| 4.39
| 5,801
| Jan 09, 2024
| Jan 09, 2024
|
it was amazing
|
Valentine's Day had long been the favorite holiday for Valentina. Named after the day and annually visited by an adorable cupid only she can see, Vale
Valentine's Day had long been the favorite holiday for Valentina. Named after the day and annually visited by an adorable cupid only she can see, Valentina spent her childhood bringing love to everyone on Valentine’s Day until one year the day brings nothing but stressful surprises that completely upends her life. Now she has one year to prove she can find true love or she must give her heart away to never feel either the joys or pains of love in a faustian deal not with the devil but the ghost of St. Valentine himself. So begins Lunar New Year Love Story, the sweepingly gorgeous and emotional graphic novel from Gene Luen Yang (of American Born Chinese fame) and brought to life through eye-popping illustrations from LeUyen Pham. This is a beautiful, multi-faceted story that explores much more than romantic love as Valentina confronts family and cultural identity in a story rife with symbolism and dualities. With mesmerizing artwork and a story that is as heartbreaking as it can be heartwarming, Lunar New Year Love Story is an incredible YA coming-of-age graphic novel that will steal your heart (they let me have mine back, don’t worry). [image] I didn’t always hate Valentine’s Day One thing I really appreciate in a good graphic novel is when the story is given the room to breathe. This is on the longer side for a YA but it really lets all the nuances and textures of the story have space to flourish and the slower pace lets each frame squeeze out every drop of emotional intensity. There is a large set-up that completely grabbed me and I enjoyed the way it shows how the things we love in childhood start to fade or become a source of embarrassment in teenage years. The shift from loving Valentine’s Day is really heartbreaking here as it descends into a bleakness about the realization opening oneself to love also means being vulnerable to heartbreak and betrayal, perfectly rendered in the eerie moment when her cute cherubic companion melts into a ghastly ghoul of St. Valentine. There is a really extraordinary blend of various cultural spiritualities and customs here showing the way an immigrant family, for instance, may contain multitudes and Val spends much of the story sifting through the interplay of her Vietnamese heritage and grandmother’s christianity. All of this in an attempt to understand herself through her history and hope to break the family curse of being unlucky in love. [image] Caption: “Our family is unlucky in love” The dualities here are wonderful, such as how Val’s involvement in the Korean Bukcheong lion dance juxtaposes with the story of christian martyrs facing down the lions, the way life is juxtaposed with death, or the way the two potential love interests—cousins Leslie and Jae—are all placed in proximity to examine the idea of yin and yang. [image] There is also a really adorable romance going on amidst all the self-discovery of her culture and (view spoiler)[the surprise that her mother never died but simply left (hide spoiler)]. We see how Les may make her happy but is not a source of stability or loyalty, a rather heartbreaking lesson to learn. And with Jae we see how grief can cast a long shadow over our lives, but that love can be a light in the darkness. It is a moving story full of both sadness and laughs while the deal over her heart is always haunting her every move. [image] ‘Lions roam the world…majesty and misery…there is no hiding. How good it is, then to find someone with whom you can become the lion.’ This was such an extraordinary graphic novel with a really lovely story, a lot of excellent exploration of culture and heritage, and a art style that was an absolute joy to get lost within. The colors are incredible, movement is wonderfully captured and the art beautifully and seamlessly flows between reality and the metaphysical aspects. Lunar New Years Love Story is a massive success. 5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1662513747
| 9781662513749
| B0BXQ2MX5B
| 4.17
| 2,418
| unknown
| Apr 27, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
‘Being a woman in the greatest curse,’ a woman recalls her mother telling her at the start of Etaf Rum’s Mother Country, ‘one day you will understand
‘Being a woman in the greatest curse,’ a woman recalls her mother telling her at the start of Etaf Rum’s Mother Country, ‘one day you will understand what I mean.’ A heartbreaking yet harrowing look at generational trauma and the struggles to escape from stifling traditions, Rum weaves the story of a second-generation Palestinian-American woman trying to assert herself while being packaged into a traditional life of marriage and motherhood told through a letter written to the mother she has long resented. While her attempts at discovering ‘how to live an authentic, fulfilling life’ collide against cultural and expectations of gender and responsibility, our narrator still feels she must find a sense of self beyond following in her mother’s footsteps ‘trying not to pass my pain along’ and break the cycle of trauma. A gorgeously written story, Mother Country is a stirring look at family and gendered expectations that reaches out a comforting embrace to both an understanding of the past and emboldening of the future. ‘I would do important work, create something meaningful. I would make a difference in this dark, lonely world. How? I wasn’t sure. Why? Because I wanted the pain to mean something.’ First off, thank you to Liv ❁ and her wonderful review for recommending this one to me. Etaf Rum’s stories often focus on the experience of diaspora while centering the struggles of women and Mother Country is a swift yet devastating statement that the lingering traditional gender role and expectations in the present make women feel they must remain subdued and live their life as in sacrifice everyone else in their families. Our unnamed narrator spends the duration of the story trying to grapple with the pain of her past and a disdain for a mother that allowed it to happen. ‘You make it sound like you were tortured, like I was some sort of monster,’ her mother counters, showing that from her perspective she ‘gave you everything I had, sacrificed my life for you.’ Written in retrospect, we trace the course of the narrator’s deeper understanding into the suffering of her mother in an attempt to make peace with her memory but also to ‘unlearn all the shame’ and break the mold towards a brighter future for her own daughter. ‘My plan was to be the best mother I could be. That meant being the opposite of you. I was going to be present and tender and not sad all the time. I was going to set a good example of what it meant to be a woman. Less powerless, more hope. More fuck off. The problem was, I didn’t know how.’ Rejecting tradition, she wishes to chart her own path and in the solitude she feels confined into the role of mother and homemaker. Having departed from tradition, she has no role model herself in her life and finds her actions raise alarm in others. Even her success is met with a coldness from her mother for being outside expectations and she sees no map to self-actualization in her elders around her, ‘no example of what it would look like for a woman to be free.’ We see how not only can tradition be stifling, but that only looking towards the past means ideas of the future will be dominated by those of the past. ‘Growing up, the path of my future was already mapped out for me. All I had to do was look around…domesticated lives governed by marriage and motherhood. No one I knew dared defy tradition; I had no example of what it would look like for a woman to be free.’ Without guidance in her own life, I appreciate how she looks to the words of writers for guidance. As someone who also finds ‘books had become my closest friends,’ in times of great uncertainty or loneliness, this hit hard. In her quest to discover a way of living that honors the words ‘to thine own self be true’ from William Shakespeare, the narrator dives into the revelations she discovers in writers like Rainer Maria Rilke, Brené Brown, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, Christopher Ryan or René Descartes among others. I really felt for her, however, when she was told 'those books have gone to your head' and her frustrations at understanding how harmful the world can feel are dismissed. ‘What do you think and feel?’ That we are doing this all wrong. While we see her plight to escape from a life where her worth is entirely made up of serving family—’you’re useless to them unless you provide a son’ he own mother tells her—Rum also touches on how traditional gender roles can be harmful to men as well. Her husband, for instance, holds a lot of resentment towards his father who only offered him one path in life to take over running the family gas station and a life of education or outside the station was not permitted. The idea of a future without oppressive boundaries of expectations, however, also causes her to reassess her hatred for her mother and better understand the forces that cornered her into the life she led. ‘Why am I writing to you now. To tell you that I understand. To say I'm sorry, to finally forgive you, to ask if you can forgive me.' This has been my first foray into the work of Etaf Rum but certainly won’t be my last. Rum writes with such grace and poise, examining difficult and painful subjects in ways that unpack a lot of emotion and trauma but orchestrates the telling in a way that offers hope, understanding, and a will to break the cycle. Mother Country also reminds us that, though the past was difficult and even the narrator’s mother expresses that her hard life still seemed better than the refugee camps they fled in Palestine, that hardships of the past do not mean they should be perpetuated into the future. That we should look forward to find ways to unlearn the shame, to do better for the next generation, to find ways to offer a better freedom and brighter future. A lovely little read that delivers an incredible emotional blow. 4.5/5 ‘I wish I had understood what you endured back then, how much you sacrificed. I wish I had learned to reserve judgement. Dear Mama, I begin. Maybe this way I can reach you at last.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Feb 07, 2024
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||
1662515278
| 9781662515279
| B0BXQDZMQ3
| 3.81
| 1,685
| Apr 27, 2023
| Apr 27, 2023
|
really liked it
|
‘There aren’t many secrets in this world, just people who choose to look the other way.’ How does one pick up the pieces of selfhood when a lifetime of ‘There aren’t many secrets in this world, just people who choose to look the other way.’ How does one pick up the pieces of selfhood when a lifetime of identity is suddenly washed away in a flash flood of truth? Charmaine Wilkerson’s Deluge is a succinct storm of revelations and shattered emotions when a woman discovers that the family narrative she has always been told concealed a shocking lie about her parentage. Gorgeously written in a way that reflects the assemblage of truth revealed from the lies like a puzzle’s image slowly becoming clear with each new piece, Deluge is about ‘what it felt like to discover yourself to be missing from the world,’ and the strength it takes to accept a new reality midlife and rise from the ashes of the old. ‘Because a person can fail another person and still do right by them. It happens all the time. This is the way of relationships. This is the way of family.’ Wilkerson excels at the experience of a life rocked by the discovery of a twist in family history. Her novel, Black Cake, navigated this with grace and here Wilkerson has managed to pack such an emotional punch by focusing on the immediacy of emotions during such a discovery, sharpening it down to a brief tale that cut but also heals. It is about the wound but, like a salamander that ‘can grow back its own limbs and organs, after a trauma,’ it is a powerful statement on the ability to ‘ become whole again.’ First the narrator must learn to sort out the truth from the lies and recognize that even under false pretenses, there was always love in a home that was never her own. ‘Sometimes people do the wrong things for the right reasons,’ she accepts, though the hurt is still real. ‘So often in life, there is no either-or. That as much as the mind might fight the idea, the heart makes room for opposing truths.’ I really enjoyed this story and was blown away by the impact resonating from these brief pages. Deluge makes stylistic choices that really enhance the experience, feeling the truth sliding into place with each new memory uncovered feeling like a slap of betrayal to the narrator. In an era where genealogy research mixes with more accessible DNA testing we frequently hear family narratives completely unravel and secrets surfacing and Wilkerson captures this sort of experience in a very thoughtful and gorgeous way. 4/5 ‘There was life before the flood and life after.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 02, 2024
|
Feb 02, 2024
|
Feb 02, 2024
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||
0241207029
| 9780241207024
| 0241207029
| 3.80
| 23,035
| Nov 02, 2017
| Nov 02, 2017
|
it was amazing
|
‘Where would we be without our ability to see beyond what it is we’re supposed to be seeing.’ The winter months are a time of cold and dark, but also a ‘Where would we be without our ability to see beyond what it is we’re supposed to be seeing.’ The winter months are a time of cold and dark, but also a sense of beauty and calm in the muffled silence of a world blanketed in wet snow. The winter ‘invites a turning in, a quieting, an upped interiority,’ writes Nina MacLaughlin in her essays on winter, and it is in this introspective spirit of the season that Oscar Wilde asserts ‘wisdom comes with winter.’ But there is a duality to winter, for there is also the harshness, the chilling reminder of our frailty and mortality, and often we withdraw indoors and into ourselves. The political metaphor is right there for the grasping and Ali Smith manages to take and transcend it brilliantly in Winter, the second book of her seasonally thematic tetraology. The prose of Winter drifts down through puns and politics (there’s enough wordplay here to make Nabokov and Pynchon envious) as the novel becomes a kaleidoscopic expression of the essence of winter. Yet it is so much more than that, functioning as an investigation into the interplay of art, identity, truth, beauty and culture on social levels both political and personal as well as an effective publishing experiment to capture a current moment of social discordance as it unfolds in real time. It is a tale of British politics and British artists, yet it also feels a universal exploration of truth and beauty in a time of great anxieties. Set during the days surrounding Christmas and matching the intimacy and interiority of the season, Winter is as sharp and insightful as it is comical and redemptive and makes for the perfect cozy winter read. ‘That’s what winter is: an exercise in remembering how to still yourself then how to come pliantly back to life again.’ While this is the second of a four-set seasonal trilogy, Winter could still serve as a standalone. That said, there is a thematic unity with the previous book, Autumn, beyond capturing a literary expression of it’s titular season. Smith deftly knots past and present on both personal and political levels and garnishes the political landscapes in narratives of under-recognized women artists (the inclusion of Barbara Hepworth here isn’t as pronounced as that of Pauline Boty in Autumn yet her artistic story is still deeply integral to the themes) and fraught family dynamics. The fallout of the Brexit vote is less a backdrop and more the landscape upon which the narrative plays out, and Smith manages to position the reader in almost real-time of the events taking place. The story is set Christmas 2016 though by the end we have references to the Grenfell Tower fire and Donald Trump telling a crowd he will make retail employees say “merry christmas” at an October 2017 event with Winter being published just a month later in November. [image] Barbara Hepworth This is particularly impressive as this event leads to a perfect closing statement in the novel, one that is a play on the final lines of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol to mirror the playful opening reference. I had read Smith’s God is dead, to begin with as a great punchy opening only to watch later that day, Christmas Eve no less, a favorite Muppets adaption of the book and when the banter over the line ‘The Marleys were dead, to begin with’ came I had a eureka moment. I enjoyed how this was in keeping with the opening line of Autumn being a play on the opening to A Tale of Two Cities. The novel works within the framework of Dickens’ holiday classic as the story slips seamlessly into hauntings of Christmas past and visions of the future—‘That's one of the things stories and books can do, they can make more than one time possible at once’—complete with a seasonal spectre of a floating child’s head. ‘Spring, summer, and fall fill us with hope; winter alone reminds us of the human condition.’ - Nina MacLaughlin The plot, as far as there is a “plot” in an Ali Smith, is a bit of a riff on a whole slew of familiar christmas narratives. Arthur, or Art—a name that’s usage in the book would seem heavy handed in lesser hands but the consistency of Smith’s witty and whimsical wordplay miraculously makes it work—hires Lux to be play the role of his recently ex-girlfriend, Charlotte, for a holiday trip to his mother’s in Cornwall. The Hallmark rom-com vibes are especially enhanced when Lux insists they phone mother Sophia’s estranged activist sister, Iris, to join them. And so the family drama and false personas all descend upon Cornwall (which was particularly charming to me because it nudges my absolute favorite rom-com film, About Time) and the family friction is bound to spark fire. ‘It isn’t a good enough answer, that one group of people can be in charge of the destinies of another group of people and choose whether to exclude them or include them. Human beings have to be more ingenious than this, and more generous. We’ve got to come up with a better answer.’ But this is a Christmas story at heart, and Dickens and all his holiday hoopla is not the only classic work integral to the Winter. William Shakespeare’s Cymbeline becomes a redemptive touchstone as fake-Charlotte/Lux, a Croatian woman with an uncertain future in the mindfield of Brexit laws shows a greater love of English literature than those of birthright citizenship, elucidates the plot almost as a metaphor for present day politics. ‘[Characters] living in the same world but separately from each other, like their worlds have somehow become disjointed or broken off each other's worlds. But if they could just step out of themselves, or just hear and see what’s happening right next to their ears and eyes, they’d see it’s the same play they’re all in, the same world, that they’re all part of the same story.’ The telling of the story is an emotional turning point in the novel, especially juxtaposed with Sophia’s defense of her vote to leave the EU, with the reader clearly recognizing the importance of ‘a play about a kingdom subsumed in chaos, lies, powermongering, division and a great deal of poisoning and self-poisoning,’ but also Lux’s admission she came to the UK because of the way Shakespeare could take that and end it with balance and grace where ‘lies are revealed and all the losses are compensated.’ Smith ingeniously uses literary and art criticism as expressions of her own works, such as Sophia’s impressions of Hepworth’s sculptures: ‘It makes you walk round it, it makes you look through it from different sides, see different things from different positions,. It’s also like seeing inside and outside something at once.’ The way her structure weaves in and out of perspectives, memories, visions, etc. lets us move about the story from a variety of vantage points. It isn’t just a family narrative, or a Brexit narrative, but a narrative of individual struggles, of political activism of the now and Iris’ history protesting nuclear stockpiling, of single-motherhood after giving up the love of one’s life for ones own life (view spoiler)[and having a child with who is plausibly Daniel Gluck from the novel Autumn, though he is only referenced briefly as Danny here (hide spoiler)], and of all the hopes, dreams, fears, flaws, and possible futures a human life can have. I just need to interrupt the flow of this review because I need to scream that this book is just so unbelievably good. Honestly, thinking about it makes me want to weep it’s just so good. There’s so much I can’t fit into this review but like, the way a remembered story is an amalgamation of two different storytellers and the implications in that, of the history of the anti-nuclear protests, or the ways Smith puts you in the minds of the two characters who are indifferent to the Brexit vote so a lot of the story is tongue-in-cheek but in a way that really slaps…this book is miraculously good. Okay I just needed to say that because this book is just intensely beautiful in a way that makes all the shit that life can be seem worthwhile to know a human can make something like this. ‘We all mine and undermine and landmine ourselves, in our own ways, in our own time.’ Truth, lie and beauty are central to the story. People living as characters of themselves are rampant in the novel and Smith nudges the way internet culture and personalities are more marketing than authentic selves. We see how truth has fallen second fiddle (Charlotte is a violin virtuoso, supposedly) to stories that satisfy, how we trade facts for useful details, and posturing for clicks replaces authenticity. ‘It is the dregs, really, to be living in a time when even your dreams have to be post-postmodern consciouser-than-thou.’ ‘There was furious inteolderace at work in the world no matter when or where in history’ And so we asked ‘into who’s myth do we choose to buy?’ There is a literal sense, such as buying Sophia’s products that are new but made to look vintage, or the duality of present day Boris Johnson versus Samuel Johnson’s fight for reality, ‘A man interested in the meaning of words, not one whose interests leave words meaningless.’ Sophia calls Iris a “mythologizer,” though under Smith this seems more a compliment than anything else, Smith who is in turn mythologizing the Brexit era. Do we believe the government, or do we believe Iris and her friends trying to expose political and corporate corruption and pollution harming people. And this is why we have art. ‘I said, Art is seeing things. And your aunt said, that’s a great description of what art is,’ Smith playfully writes about Art’s hallucination, though it also hits home the idea that art mythologizes reality in order to see, process, and understand it better. And such is the purpose of Winter. And why artists are valued over politicians, because artists represent the human at the cost of power. ‘He thinks about how, whatever being alive is, with all its pasts and presents and futures, it is most itself in the moments when you surface from a depth of numbness or forgetfulness that you didn't even know you were at, and break the surface.’ The French writer and philosopher Albert Camus once wrote ‘in the depth of winter, I finally learned that within me there lay an invincible summer.’ Such is the lesson here, that in this season of cold, of withdrawing, or introspection, we can choose to release ourselves from the shackles of the characters we choose to present ourselves as and find the beautiful summer of truth and hope within us. This is a gorgeous novel, one that moves slowly yet surely through both the heart and mind and balances both the personal and political in a way that transcends them both. Winter, like Autumn before it, is an impressive expression of its season and a story that warmed my heart like a yule log during the holidays. I only hope winter passes quickly so I can read the next seasonal installment. 4.5/5 ‘Mind and matter are mysterious and, when they come together, bounteous.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
Jan 2024
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0008608032
| 9780008608033
| 0008608032
| 3.76
| 6,377
| Jun 11, 2024
| Jun 11, 2024
|
it was amazing
|
**Easily a top favorite of the year and I was oh so thrilled to discover this: [image] *** To be burnt out and drowning in anxieties and familial dys **Easily a top favorite of the year and I was oh so thrilled to discover this: [image] *** To be burnt out and drowning in anxieties and familial dysfunction is one thing but if the world is quite literally drowning in the endless rains of climate catastrophe you better hold on tight to the ones you love. Such is the case in Julia Armfield’s Private Rites, a feverishly haunting tale loosely modeled as a queer retelling of William Shakespeare’s King Lear with the passing of an estate to the three daughters of a celebrity architect in a water-logged near future teetering on the brink of utter collapse. Armfield delivers her signature blend of literary horror that truly sinks under your skin through jittery examinations of grief, love and family in a society seemingly resigned to its own extinction. It’s a sort of catastrophe apathy that aches with the dull yet distressing pain of a bruise, one that conjures up memories of society haphazardly attempting to be the same as it always was amidst the recent pandemic, with Armfield keeping much of the calamity in the background and scene setting of taking ferries to work over sunken portions of the city or the endless chaos of closures due to rain. Much like her previous novel, the extraordinary Our Wives Under the Sea, Armfield always resonates deeply with me in a way that reminds me of Jeanette Winterson using horror to shine a light on concepts of love and loss instead of fairy tales as Winterson does. With a disquieting gaze at a society resigned to its own destruction, the violent reactions in those overwhelmed by such loss, fraught interpersonal relations that juxtapose the hardships of fixing a breaking world with the difficulties of love, Private Rites hits high notes of anxiety and trauma both past and present in a story utterly drenched in dread. ‘What happened, then? Two mothers and a father. Three sisters and a house. A house which, once invaded, could not be closed again, was left open to the elements, to whomever wished to come inside.’ The famous passage from King Lear, ‘We that are young, Shall never see so much, nor live so long,’ takes on an eerie new layer of meaning in Armfield’s reconfigured Lear tale as the young sisters at the center of the story live under the growing dread that the number of possible tomorrows is rapidly reaching an end. It is a slow burn apocalypse of rain as ‘seasons and weather patterns blur into one,’ something that becomes so steady it seeps into normalcy. It remains a constant tone soaking every passage, omnipresent like a thorn in the mind yet left to fester as an overwhelming problem to hide behind a bandage of carrying on instead of addressing. ‘The great washout of the world and no sense that it might have been otherwise.’ Like in a western this watery landscape becomes a character in its own right with Armfield even giving “the city” its own perspective to chronicle the slow collapse and resignation of society in the face of impending doom. ‘It is difficult, these days, to know how to be. Not a new phenomenon, of course, but one lent a certain urgency by the situation. People protest, or forget to protest. People hoard food, medical supplies, use them up and hoard them again…they suspect that there is less time than predicted, throw parties to celebrate the endless ending, pretend the coming on of something new. It’s always been this way, always worsening. A contradiction: the fact of something always being the case and yet that case being flux, deterioration.’ In the overbearing hopelessness we find ‘Archaic practices resurfacing the way trends will,’ and cult behavior and erratic interactions begin to infest society. One might think of the ways society pushed to return during the recent pandemic and all the rhetoric of the “new normal”. In interview with Country Town & House, Armfield addresses her ideas around this: ‘Something I’ve been preoccupied with throughout my career is the concept of a pervasive norm – the way that banality and dailiness always assert themselves no matter the extremes people find themselves in. This can be a good thing, inasmuch as it shows how adaptable people can be, but it also signifies a kind of apathy and powerlessness in the face of an overriding system, and I’m extremely interested in that.’ The concept of drowning in the overwhelming weight of it all is expertly metaphor as literal drowning, with oceans and water being a common theme in Armfield’s works. ‘I looked around and realised how prevalent the ocean and the water is in a lot of really formative lesbian media,’ she explains. She has previously spoken on this in an interview with Them Magazine while discussing Our Wives Under the Sea with water as ‘a symbol of something forbidden,’ that functions as ‘a very natural setting for coming-out narratives…the sea can be very calm on the surface, and something can be going on underneath. That speaks to the way that we as queer people have to be so many different things to so many different people.’ Such imagery permeates Private Rites as the turmoil beneath the surface of everyone begins to boil over under the constant stress of the world. ‘Death, after all, puts an end to the argument, but it also prolongs the silence forever.’ At the center of this is the Carmichael family, who’s patriarch, Stephen Carmichael, passes away as the story sets out. Praised as a ‘true genius’ for his architectural marvels that make him ‘the hero of the domestic space…snatching homes from sites grown uninhabitable and lifting them up out of harm's way.’ He is like a Frank Lloyd Wright responding to climate crisis, yet creating homes with a price sticker that cannot act as a life raft to the average person. Left behind are three sisters, Isla, Irene and Agnes, the latter born from a second wife who arrived after the tragic end of the elder sisters’ mother and quickly vanished after Agnes’ birth. It is a family where resentment has grown in the absence of trust and love and each plays out the role of a villain in the minds of the other. ‘Sisterhood, [Irene] thinks, is a trap. You all get stuck in certain roles forever.’ Yet as the world becomes increasingly hostile, each seeks to fill the wound left by a lost mother and frequently finds only disappointment. ‘The rain falls, the night continues–black horizon and the pull of what’s beneath.’ An aspect that hit hard are the ways problems seems to compound upon problems and avoidance only worsens them. ‘The problem is’ becomes nearly a mantra amidst the prose, each exposing another facet of issues, each amalgamating towards apocalyptic distress. ‘The problem, of course, is the general worsening of things—things being housing, and the weather, and The State Of It All. The problem is private companies springing up every other week to mishandle the business of dealing with it and siphon off funding in the process. The problem is the fact that there’s no money, and nowhere to put people, and the fact that they’re working on a skeleton staff with no time and no way to do more than they’re already doing…They are, as Jude reflects, a ship being mended as it sails, except that they aren’t really being mended and their sailing has become less a smooth progress and more the basic act of staying afloat.’ The novel is effectively anxiety inducing as it speaks exactly to the growing issues in our own time. Working a library, for instance, one can see the ways for-profit privatization erodes public goods and grows a class divide where private services become more expensive and public services, like Jude’s job, are understaffed and underfunded. And we consider it all just the way things are and dismiss any attempt at deconstructing or attempting sustainable alternatives. ‘The problem, of course, is that there’s always something, and it can be easier on occasion to ignore it and take your partner back to bed.’ The problem is, hardships are easier to ignore and hope they go away. Global catastrophe feels beyond a singular person and easier to hope for a miracle. Cults appear who have ideas around sacrifice, for instance, and little beyond magical thinking seems to be occurring. To fix the world is hard, yet to live in a failing world is harder. ‘We love people before we notice we love them, but the act of naming the love makes it different, drags it out into different light.’ Something Armfield does so effectively, however, is examine love in the light of all these hardships. With each sister, Armfield examines relationships—Irene has recently separated from a partner, Isla’s Jude (they are possibly the best character in the book) remains calm and loves her despite her rather thorny personality, and Agnes is slipping into a partnership with Stephanie who provides a stability in an unstable world. But love is hard. ‘The problem with love, of course, is that it frequently asks too much of unlovable people. It can be hard, on even the best of days, to compel oneself to be selfless and patient and undemanding or even halfway reasonable when one is not given to any of those behaviours. But these are nonetheless the qualities that love demands. Despite the hardships, love is viewed as being worth it, something that could be applied to the world itself. To save the world would require great sacrifices and a lot of effort but, like love, it could be worthwhile. I’ve always believed love makes it all bearable, a bad day of crisis washes away when you see the one you love, when they show they care by bringing you food (like Jude), when they hold you as you break down and keep your pieces together (like Stephanie). Love gets you through. ‘I could be good with this, if I could have this,’ thinks Agnes, ‘I don’t think it would matter if things had been different or we’d had a different world or more to hope for. I could be happy here.’ ‘Any horror story could be said to work in two pieces: the fear of being wholly alone and of realizing that one has company.’ Private Rites is, ultimately, a horror novel though one that keeps the horror pushed aside until it becomes too much and bursts upon everyone. ‘This is the wrong genre’ Agnes thinks as the dramatic conclusion begins, which perfectly mirrors the horror faced by society as the terror of collapse bursts in after decades of trying to push climate crisis out of their minds. The violence of the ending is shocking and alarming because we see it enacted by the long plans of people and at their hands, however is the climate collapse not also the slow work of human hands either actively bringing about the violence or passively allowing it? Armfield juxtaposes the two for sharp, searing effect and while it arrives as rather jarring it is a reminder that the problems we push aside never vanish. They fester and, eventually, attack. ‘You can hear it if you listen; the slow dissolution, the panic becoming something else.’ A slow burn of a novel spiraling between perspectives and giving the city a space to chronicle its own decay, Private Rites slowly seeps into the reader and shakes them to the core. Haunting and hellishly relevant, it is a tale of family, of resentment, of collapse and consequences. But at the heart of matters, it is a story about love. Endlessly engaging and eerily compelling, Armfield has delivered another masterful novel. 4.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jun 28, 2024
|
Jul 28, 2024
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
145214270X
| 9781452142708
| 145214270X
| 4.37
| 1,755
| Feb 08, 2022
| Feb 08, 2022
|
it was amazing
|
This is a perfect picture book that is endlessly fun. Bathe the Cat from Alice B. McGinty and illustrated by David Roberts (you may recognize from the
This is a perfect picture book that is endlessly fun. Bathe the Cat from Alice B. McGinty and illustrated by David Roberts (you may recognize from the series that includes Rosie Revere, Engineer) is an adorable story about a family frantically trying to clean the house before Grandma arrives that is simple, sweet, and reads with a fun and naturally sing-songy cadence that only gets sillier as it goes and the chore list begins to fall apart. [image] When dad makes a to-do list which includes bathing the cat, this reluctant feline decides to take matters into their own hand to avoid a bath. But with each rearrangement of the chore list things get zanier and the cat continuously adjusts the list to avoid now being assigned to be vacuumed or mowed. [image] Its rather charming and goofy, with the family assigned tasks like feed the floor, rock the mat, scrub the fishes, etc. I also love that, despite not ever calling attention to it, the story features a queer couple so it also offers really good representation and depictions of a loving family in a book that works well for a young age group. It is a quick read that is just as enjoyable for adults as the children being read to and is guaranteed to get a lot of laughs. I love this book and the art is also really cute! [image] This was such a big hit in my house, so much so that my four year old insisted on being the specific cat from this book as her Halloween costume: [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0147514010
| 9780147514011
| 0147514010
| 4.16
| 2,342,286
| Sep 30, 1868
| Nov 17, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
Some books read like a lifelong friendship, each page a warm or comforting embrace as you laugh and weep along with the characters. Little Women by L.
Some books read like a lifelong friendship, each page a warm or comforting embrace as you laugh and weep along with the characters. Little Women by L.M. Alcott is an enduring and endearing classic that will nestle its way so deep into your heart that you’ll wonder if the sound of turning pages has become your new heartbeat in your chest. To read the novel is a magical experience, and we are all like Laurie peering in through the March’s window and relishing in the warmth within. I have long loved the film adaptations and make it a holiday tradition to ensure I at least watch it every December (it has Christmas in it, it counts), so it was fascinating to finally read the actual novel and return to character I feel I’ve always known yet still find it fresh and even more lovely than ever before. Semi-autobiographical, Alcott traces the lives of the four March sisters, Meg, Jo, Beth and Amy, and their struggles to make their own way in a society that offers little use for women beyond the household. An emotional epic and moving family saga full of strong characters, sharp criticisms on society and gender roles, and a beautiful plea to dispense with the worship of wealth and find true purpose and value in simplicity, nature and generosity. ‘I've got the key to my castle in the air, but whether I can unlock the door remains to be seen.’ Little Women will leave your heart full and your pen dry from underlining the seemingly endless lovely passages. I’d like to thank Adira and her wonderful review for convincing me to finally actually read this and not just watch the movie again (I did last night though, because who doesn’t want to relive the joy of yelling “Bob Odenkirk?!” in a theater and later sobbing) because, just when I thought I couldn’t love this story more, now I’m fully engulfed by it. Surely enough has been written about this book already, but i like to ramble about things I love so here’s a more I guess (I’ll try to keep it shorter than usual [having finished writing it now, I failed]). But how can you not be with such incredible characters? Jo is of course the favorite, but I think part of loving this book is wanting to be Jo and realizing you are Amy, but each character touches your heart in their own way. Mr. Laurence and Beth’s connection with the piano and lost daughters makes me teary just writing this. Alcott based the story on her real family and one can read a genuine love for the characters pouring from every page. ‘Wealth is certainly a most desirable thing, but poverty has its sunny side, and one of the sweet uses of adversity is the genuine satisfaction which comes from hearty work of head or hand, and to the inspiration of necessity, we owe half the wise, beautiful, and useful blessings of the world.’ Alcott was a transcendentalist and many of her beliefs shine through in the novel. Much of this came from her father and one will be pleased to learn that the real Mr. March—Amos Bronson Alcott—was as radical in his time as his fictional counterpart. An abolitionist who also advocated for women’s rights, Amos became a major transcendentalist figure along with his friend, Ralph Waldo Emerson. Alcott’s mother was equally radical for her time too, and many of their teachings arrive here through Mrs. March to her children. There is, of course, the belief in nature as the ideal, such as when the March girls, having little jewelry, adorn themselves in flowers instead. Even Laurie states ‘I don’t like fuss and feathers,’ another instance of a return to simplicity over flashy status symbols. There is also the belief in generosity, which is seen throughout with the March family always involved in helping others, and the belief that hard work is important, but not for profit reasons but because it leads to spiritual and emotional happiness and freedom. ‘Then let me advise you to take up your little burdens again; for though they seem heavy sometimes, they are good for us, and lighten as we learn to carry them. Work is wholesome, and there is plenty for every one; it keeps us from ennui and mischief; is good for health and spirits, and gives us a sense of power and independence better than money or fashion.’ Towards the start of the novel, the mother advises the children to be like Christian from John Bunyan’s allegorical novel The Pilgrim's Progress and we can see how Little Women follows a similar fashion of Pilgrim’s being knowledge gained through the travel of a life lived, and each daughter is shown to face certain trials and must learn to bear their burdens, like Jo’s anger, Amy’s desire to be liked, Meg’s desire for vanity, Beth’s passivity. But the largest burdens here are those of love and labor. ‘Women, they have minds, and they have souls, as well as just hearts. And they’ve got ambition, and they’ve got talent, as well as just beauty. I’m so sick of people saying that love is all a woman is fit for.’ The relationship to work is threaded through the entire novel. We have Jo and Amy who wish to be great and break from the traditional mold for women in society. Jo wants to be a writer, though she only publishes scandalous stories under a false name, and Amy desires to be a painter. And neither will settle for anything less than greatness ‘because talent isn't genius, Amy states, ‘and no amount of energy can make it so. I want to be great, or nothing.’ Meg and Beth, on the other hand, show different routes a woman can take. The novel questions if women can find happiness outside marriage and caring for a household, and these struggles bash against social expectations along the way. ‘ I'll try and be what he loves to call me, 'a little woman,' and not be rough and wild; but do my duty here instead of wanting to be somewhere else.’ ‘ I can't get over my disappointment in not being a boy,’ Jo quips, and a major part of Little Women is a critique of gender roles and how they stifle people in society. Laurie is an excellent foil to Jo, in many ways, but is also a way that Alcott addresses and subverts gender expectations. Jo and Laurie both use shortened versions of their name that seem to cross gender expectations (even though Laurie didn’t like being called Dora) and in many ways Jo tends to represent more masculine behavior while Laurie often a more feminine role. While Meg dresses in finery and tries to fill the traditional role of a woman, Jo prefers to romp in nature in simple or dirty garments and behave, by her own admission, like a boy. Recently there has been a lot of discussion on the author’s gender and sexuality, with even the New York Times writing an opinion piece wondering if Alcott or Jo was a trans man. I know that frustrates some people but personally I find it interesting to think about, even if a bit anachronistic, but it seems to be a genuine question people investigate about authors who subvert gender expectations (think how often it was avoided to discuss Virginia Woolf’s sexuality in the past and now we have letters and look at scenes in Mrs Dalloway and think “oh yea, that makes total sense”). Honestly, I say Jo is whatever you want Jo to be. Trans, lesbian, ace, or just a girl pushing back on gender norms. I think the key detail is that Jo was breaking out of the mold, so let that empower you as you best see fit. Personally I thought the marriage to Friedrich felt tacked on anyways (I enjoy the way the Gerwig adaptation addresses this) but, side note, I do see how Alcott weaves in the transcendentalist notion of the “universal family” and belief in learning about and supporting other cultures here. Friedrich is German, Meg marries the English John, and Laurie is said to be half-Italian, which all comes as a rebuttal to the anti-immigration sentiments of the times. ‘I like good strong words that mean something,’ Jo says and that appeals to my love of language as well. This book deals with love in many ways, but feels like a romance between book and reader as you enjoy every page. Little Women was ahead of its time and still stands proudly today as an endearing work that dares challenge social convention. But most importantly, it feels like a friend. Finishing is hard as now I’ll miss the days with the March sisters, and I find books that take you from childhood to adulthood often hit the hardest because you feel as if you’ve grown up together. An emotional read, also a genius one, Little Women is a favorite now forever. 5/5 ‘ Watch and pray, dear, never get tired of trying, and never think it is impossible to conquer your fault.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Dec 04, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
0062699229
| 9780062699220
| 0062699229
| 4.12
| 54,078
| Jul 24, 2018
| Jul 24, 2018
|
really liked it
|
‘From the ground, we stand. From our ships, we live. By the stars, we hope.’ Storytelling is at core of understanding a culture as culture is, in its o ‘From the ground, we stand. From our ships, we live. By the stars, we hope.’ Storytelling is at core of understanding a culture as culture is, in its own way, a type of collective narrative. Though, as in Becky Chambers’ Record of a Spaceborn Few’ one begins to wonder if the connotative division between patriotism and propaganda is blurred when perpetuating such a narrative is essential to upholding a civilization where the reality is at odds with the stories being told. The third novel in Chambers’ Wayfarer series, Record of a Spaceborn Few is the quietest book yet though also one of the most complex and interesting to me. Set aboard the Exodant fleet and following a large ensemble cast of characters (one being the family of Cpt. Ashby’s sister, Tessa), Chambers examines a sort of eutopia where everyone’s basic needs are met but overall it is beginning to crumble, especially in the eyes of the younger generation for whom ‘survival alone wasn’t enough’ compared to their dreams which can be as vast as the cosmos. Chambers excels at crafting cultural thought experiments as sci-fi narratives and this volume furthers their extraordinary ‘We are a longstanding species with a very short memory. If we don’t keep record, we’ll make the same mistakes over and over again.’ Chambers gift to make stories out of what basically amounts to sci-fi anthropology is endlessly entertaining to me and feels very indebted to the works of the late, great Ursula K. Le Guin who also told stories via cultural examinations such as in The Left Hand of Darkness. Like that novel, Chambers inserts fictional historical accounts and anthropological writings between chapters that create context for the galaxy at large, though much of how we learn about galactic politics and daily life is gleaned through the actions and conversations of characters. Often dubbed “cozy sci-fi” for the rather heartwarming messages and characters, I would add that these books also feel so cozy because they allow you to experience them as if you are nestled inside the world which comes alive and makes sense through the complexity of its construction. Though it is perhaps Le Guin’s The Dispossessed that Record feels most akin too as much of the book sets about looking at a civilization that seems to be a sort of eutopia and examining the cracks forming in the perfect veneer their own self-mythologizing would have you believe. Because, when it comes down to it, this is a hippy commune in space that is not everything they want you to think it is. ‘What was better – a constant safeness that never grew and never changed, or a life of reaching, building, striving, even though you knew you’d never be completely satisfied?’ The Exodant fleet boasts there is a home and food for every member and no job is seen as “lesser” This also includes sex work, like the character Sunny, which is seen as a form of being an entertainer not unlike a musician and Exodants are a very sex-positive culture—though this is no less embarrassing to teenagers to hear their parents speak so openly about sex which was a detail that was both humorous but also felt true (I enjoy how so much of this series is asking “how does this species think about sex?”). Self-worth is not tied to capitalist instincts and all are viewed as equally valid. ‘There is no such thing as a meaningless job in the Fleet. Everything has a purpose, a recognisable benefit. If you have food on your plate, you thank a farmer. If you have clothing, you thank a textile manufacturer. If you have murals to brighten your day, you thank an artist. Even the most menial of tasks benefits someone, benefits all.’ However, the fleet technology is old (it opens with a ship equipment failure that causes a mass death), the people live meagerly, and propagating one’s own narrative is losing its luster. Particularly with younger people for whom the possibilities of the wider cosmos full of danger and potential glory seem quite attractive. This is best explored through the character Kip, who, as only a teen can so eloquently put it, says ‘Stars, fuck this place. Fuck these stupid rules and stupid jobs and fuck being sixteen. He was getting out...anything was better than here.’ (I LOVE how Chambers has characters say ‘stars’ like a curse word like everyone yelling ‘frak’ in the rebooted Battlestar Galactica). And there is also Tessa’s daughter, Aya, who is scared of space and wants to live on the ground. Yet, for all its shortcomings, we see how the fleet can be attractive to someone like Sawyer who seeks refuge there: even a poor home and meager living is better than being broke and unhoused. As Le Guin once wrote, ‘Every eutopia contains a dystopia, every dystopia contains a eutopia.’ ‘That’s a poisonous thing, thinking your way is all there is.’ The interactions between archivist Isabel and a Harmagian, Ghuh'loloan, were exceedingly enjoyable and ponderous (I love the aspect that humans smell bad to other species, sort of like humans to Vulcans in Star Trek) because in this way the Exodant’s cultural narrative is lit up against the larger narrative of the Galactic Commons for a more dynamic picture of everything. The Exodants are caught either falling behind keeping their old ways or accepting help and adapting, though a big lesson is ‘ I worry about those who think adopting someone else's story means abandoning their own.’ I really appreciate the angle of looking at the cultures and the galaxy as a whole as a big narrative (I mean, we process experience as a narrative in general) and how, sometimes, we need to access if the narrative is useful or harmful. ‘Our species doesn’t operate by reality. It operates by stories. Cities are a story. Money is a story. Space was a story, once. A king tells us a story about who we are and why we’re great, and that story is enough to make us go kill people who tell a different story. Or maybe the people kill the king because they don’t like his story and have begun to tell themselves a different one. When our planet started dying, our species was so caught up in stories. We had thousands of stories about ourselves – that’s still true, don’t forget that for a minute – but not enough of us were looking at the reality of things. Once reality caught up with us and we started changing our stories to acknowledge it, it was too late.’ This of course details the Harmagians rejecting their own empire when faced with the consequences and horrors of their wars and creating the Commons to try to do something good and cooperative, but another aspect of Chambers novels is always how excellently their sci fi worlds correlate to present-day social issues. In the US, for example, there has been huge pushback against any mentioning of negatives in the US, like the history of slavery, leading to mass book bans and attacks on public institutions to control the narrative. But nobody is perfect and we must learn responsibility to our stories and accept reality. ‘Show me a species who has never wronged another. Show me a species who has always been perfect or fair…either we are all worthy of the Commons or none of us are.’ Chambers shows how storytelling can quickly become propaganda and that facing the harsh truths is always better than dismissing them and mistaking it for patriotism. But, will the Exodants be able to adapt and how will they maintain their culture if they do (okay but it is super heartbreaking when Tessa brings up that she doesn’t understand why her brother, Ashby, is so upset over replacing his AI…). ‘learn nothing of your subjects, and you will disrupt them. Learn something of your subjects, and you will disrupt them.’ Narratives, however, also show what cultures value and I find Chambers always does a wonderful job with this in their books. Family and home are a big one here, but also death. It is noted ‘socially unsettled [humans] become around death,’ and how much this seems connected to their ideas of family, something the Harmagians find quite odd. For Eyas, this also means that in her role as caretaker for the dead she too becomes a sort of cultural narrative but she is struggling with how stifling this all feels ‘because I always have to be Eyas the symbol…I can only ever be this one thing.’ How much do we find ourselves living stories that tell of our culture, nation, family or perhaps become a mere symbol of ourselves instead of an authentic self (paging Jean-Paul Sartre), and is this useful or merely propagating our own myths. Speaking of, I love the aspect that Exodants want to use names of the past on Earth but are bad at it, like intending to name a child Wolf but ending up with Walrus. ‘Knowledge should always be free,’ she said. ‘What people do with it is up to them.’ The quietest of the series but also the most focused, I really loved Record of a Spaceborn Few. I like the whole aspect that the hippie-commune place is both cool but also becoming impractical and the message about adapting to change can be a way to benefit all. I loved the family dynamics in this one (the adorable older lesbian couple is great) and how it just offers another heartfelt look at what its like to live in this world. Another solid read. 4.5/5 ‘We are the Exodus Fleet. We are those that wandered, that wander still. We are the homesteaders that shelter our families. We are the miners and foragers in the open. We are the ships that ferry between. We are the explorers who carry our names. We are the parents who lead the way. We are the children who continue on.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Sep 11, 2023
|
Sep 25, 2023
|
Sep 11, 2023
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1638930368
| 9781638930365
| 1638930368
| 4.13
| 25,533
| Mar 07, 2023
| Mar 07, 2023
|
really liked it
|
‘One believes the stupidest things in grief,’ Gerardo Sámano Córdova writes in his debut novel, the literary horror Monstrilio. There are few griefs m
‘One believes the stupidest things in grief,’ Gerardo Sámano Córdova writes in his debut novel, the literary horror Monstrilio. There are few griefs more shattering than the death of a child and one might do the strangest things in grief to try and recover that loss, often with more sadness to follow. Take Maud Gonne for instance, the Irish revolutionary and long time love interest of poet W.B. Yeats, who reunited with the father of her deceased son and had sex on his coffin thinking it would bring him back (and the sadness that the conceived child, Iseult, was never considered her daughter after and left out of Maud’s will). Or look how this sort of grief arrives in fiction, such as Pet Sematary by King or even the reincarnation of dead body parts in Frankenstein. Not unlike the latter, Monstrilio involves life being created from dead organs—a lung in this case—and the subsequent struggles of parenting this creation. Luckily for Monstrilio, or M as he is later called, he is loved despite his ravenous appetite for flesh (working his way up from cats to whole humans over the course of the novel), and over the four perspectives in the novel Córdova explores ideas of family, both found family and blood lineage. A slow burn of a novel offering an excellent blend of horror, folktale and examinations of queer identities, Monstrilio confronts ideas of grief, family, sexuality and, ultimately, that we cannot hide our true selves. ‘This thing—an actual fucking monster—was loved.’ For a horror novel, the tone in Monstrilio tends towards tender affection as the story spirals away from a shocking opening scene when Magos cuts open her dead son and removes his only lung. Born with only one lung, Santiago was not expected to live but made it 11 years before his death. Returning home to Mexico City, she hears an urban legend of a woman feeding the heart of a dead girl until it grew up into a beautiful man and undertakes a similar experiment. Amidst the grief of the deceased, Monstrilio is born and, despite some initial shock and fear, those around him decide to love him no matter what. Like a shockwave from the blast occurring in a particularly tragic scene of grief, the story is pulled from Mago’s perspective into 3 subsequent perspectives over the years: Lena, the best friend; Joseph, the ex-husband and father; and finally Monstrilio himself. It is a stylistic choice that (mostly) works and allows us to see how these events radiate outward across many lives. ‘They are happy to believe I forget how they maimed me.’ Grief is shown as arriving in many forms. For Mago, there is magical thinking (which turns out to actually work) and action, whereas for Joseph he seems to struggle with his own inability to grieve how he, or Mago, feels he should. Which brings tension between them. ‘I wanted him to snap, to finally and absolutely lose it. To break. He was withering. To wither is not the same as to break; to break is to have pieces to put back together, and to wither is to dry up, to wilt, to lose bone, to die, and death is the most boring.’ But we also see how it affects those around us, such as Lena who allows her judgement to be clouded by the wills of others and performs a surgery that will alter Monstrilio forever. M’s perspective being saved for last is not just because it is the best section of the novel and wraps up all the disparate elements into a tight punch of a finale, but because M’s feeling and needs are constantly being pushed aside to fit the ideas of what the other character’s think they need (this is most evident in the surgery aspect). This makes for an excellent look at the way the push and pull of families affects everyone, especially the younger ones caught up in it, and is made more ominous and chilling through the lens of horror. ‘Hunger can be magnificent.’ Which also nudges the theme of the body that is always present in the text. On one hand we have the fact that M is quite literally a monster created out of a dead child’s lung, yet despite his form he is no less a part of the family or loved like a child. But in later portions of the novel he transforms into a human form which helps him disguise who he is inside. And what he hungers for cannot be hidden. Hunger is a quite a dynamic symbol here, being both his literal hunger but also as an investigation into sexuality. The majority of the primary characters are queer, with Joseph marrying Paul after his divorce from Mago which is perhaps a hidden “hunger” that he was finally able to reveal, but it does all sort of touch on the idea that queer sexuality is often othered or seen as unnatural despite being very normal and natural, especially to the person having those emotions. Which parallels M’s feelings about hunger, and in the latter half of the novel we see how hiding oneself for the benefit of “polite society” and whatnot doesn’t mean you don’t still feel this way. Trying to pass myself off as totally straight was awful and I could take the teasing for like things that were socially-coded as for women (I will not apologize for my vast love of Beyonce or the color pink) but to feel like I couldn’t just be like no I’m pansexual and nonbinary and that doesn’t change the me you know but I’d like to not have to feel I have to keep that hidden. Sure, being a horror novel where this is quite literally a flesh-eating monster muddies the waters here but you get the point. The parallel of M eating flesh and Mago being a performance artist that eats the written word is quite charming as well, if a bit on the nose. I do love how this fits in with a lot of the more literary horror of BIPOC and queer voices such as Stephen Graham Jones, Carmen Maria Machado or Alison Rumfitt (to name just a few) that are using the genre in subversive ways to really discuss themes of identity and expanding the genre to the folklore of other cultures. I think there is a lot going on in this book that is really great, however at times it felt in some ways far longer than it needed to be (this would absolutely destroy me if it was a crisp novella) but then the individual sections almost felt undercooked. At times it seemed like two books being blended into one and the cracks show on occasion. And while I like a direct prose, there were times this felt like pulling the story forward along a screenplay where it’s assumed the emotion will be infused later by the actors instead of actually injecting emotion into the scenes. Not that this was devoid of emotion—there is a particularly amazing scene at the beginning of crushing grief juxtaposed with a rather slapstick-seeming struggle beforehand that made me think YES, Gerardo Sámano Córdova can really bring it!—but the novel is perhaps too up close to the details and loses its own context, like a photo of a face so close up that the overall impression of the face gets lost. That said, I’m over-emphasizing here to try and pin down what sort of felt like an itch distracting me the whole time and for a debut this is still quite good. But I know he can tighten it up and I will definitely be back for his next book. Monstrilio is an impressive literary horror that takes us around the world and deep into family dynamics. Gerardo Sámano Córdova certainly has something special here and I love the infusion of Mexican folkhorror with this rather tender examination of family and grief. Admittedly the individual sections are a mixed bag, but it all pulls together at the end for a rather memorable, shocking and moving experience. 4/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Aug 03, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
B00ZP64F28
| 4.18
| 167,069
| Jul 29, 2014
| Aug 18, 2015
|
it was amazing
|
‘The universe is what we make of it. It’s up to you to decide what part you will play.’ This book left me speechless, and with some tears. I love this ‘The universe is what we make of it. It’s up to you to decide what part you will play.’ This book left me speechless, and with some tears. I love this book with my whole heart. I imagine reading A Long Way to a Small Angry Planet, the debut novel from Becky Chambers, to be what it is to a dog when they get a really good belly rub. You know, the kind where their leg is twitching and it just seems like pure bliss. Who hasn’t fantasized themselves in some fantastic future world, soaring amongst the stars with a headful of heroics? I spent many days as a kid wishing I could be part of these epic adventures. Chambers, offers such an opportunity aboard the ship The Wayfarer. The novel is practically an immersive experience in a sci-fi galaxy so well constructed and narrated that it feels very lived-in, and by the novels end you feel as if you are a part of the crew, having spent so much time amongst the endlessly lovable cast of characters. This is enhanced as, while most sci-fi epics put us with the elite heroes, the chosen few upon which the fate of a galaxy rests, Chambers lets us see how the average citizen of their Galactic Commons lives, loves, works and dreams. ‘The people we remember are the ones who decided how our maps should be drawn. Nobody remembers who built the roads,’ yet Chambers creates a blissful drama full of life aboard a ship that does just that: builds “roads” between planets across space. Often described as “cozy sci-fi”—an apt description if there is any—this first book of the Wayfarers plunges us into an exciting cosmos to live amongst the regular folks and look at how a universe of multiple species would feasibly coexist and is an excellent exploration on themes of cooperation, plurality, friendship, and identity while also a condemnation of war and power. In short, this book is a universe unto itself. In epic space films we often see entire ships or planets destroyed and just move along, death on such a large scale it becomes that Stalin quote about one death a tragedy, a million a statistic. Long Way to a Small Angry Planet zooms in to the individual level and shows how for the regular person caught up in these cosmic struggles just a single death could be a universe of grief. It brings us to the level of what goes on with the Red Shirts in Star Trek, the transport crews in Star Wars, the regular staff in Dune, a crew full of non-combatants just trying to live their life in the universe. I love this crew. I can’t help it after feeling their kinship, engaging with their struggles, and watching them learn and love with each other. We are brought aboard the Wayfarer along with Rosemary, a young woman with a new identity fleeing a mysterious past and welcomed in to their crew. I’d tell you about them all, but I’d rather you get to meet them for yourselves. It’s been a few days since I finished the book and I rather miss them, so say hello for me. ‘Perhaps the ache of homesickness was a fair price to pay for having so many good people in her life.’ What really grabs me about this book is the emphasis on how to make the universe work, even just aboard a ship staffed by a variety of different species. Details like Aandrisk-friendly cups to accommodate a lack of lips or other alterations and safety procedures for ease of access on ships for certain species, discussions on cultural or species differences or examples of interspecies frustrations due to them, and even a sort of sci-fi racism is present (the term “lizard” is a massive slur). Working a DEI committee for a library and often thinking on accommodation and equity I really enjoyed how much attention to these ideas Chambers includes as a brilliant way of making the world feel real and lived-in. Communication is key to much of this, such as language barriers and attempting to ‘not judge other species by your own social norms,’ even a interesting discussion on how the human language is biased against reptilian species (‘cold blooded’ having negative connotations, etc). ‘Feelings are relative. And at the root, they’re all the same, even if they grow from different experiences and exist on different scales.’ This applies to cultural aspects too, and Chambers includes exceptional drama with trying to decide the “right” thing to do when there is a clash in cultural beliefs. ‘This is so fucking Human of you,’ Captain Ashby is told at a critical moment, ‘Lie back and let the galaxy do whatever it wants, because you’re too guilty about how badly you fucked up your own species to ever take the initiative.’There are interesting discussions, such as Sissix finding it strange humans view a baby dying as more tragic than an adult (a baby has not accomplished anything while an adult has and has knowledge that could be passed on is the Aandrisk perspective), there is a species that finds taking anything more than you need to be not only wasteful but immoral, and the variations of sexuality and family structures is fascinating (Aandrisks have a “hatch-family” and a “feather-family” for instance, with the chosen family being more important than biological). It all makes for a great commentary on our own times and the need to accommodate plurality, something that is under political attack in the US from which Chambers wrote this novel. It is in the novel as well, with the uneasy alliance with the Toremi—a warmongering species thats inclusion into the Galactic Commons (GC) drives the main plot points—further frustrated by their rejection of plurality and belief in full consensus (they see the universe is complex patterns but reject multiple interpretations being allowed to co-exist). ‘You Humans really do cripple yourselves with your belief that you all think in unique ways.’ I enjoyed how it is mentioned Corbin, who is white, is a rarity and almost all humans are people of color which feels akin to the sci-fi futures of Ursula K. Le Guin who usually applies a wide racial cast and has stated her lack of white people in the future is because ‘why wouldn’t they still be either a minority, or just swallowed up in the larger colored gene pool, in the future?.’ That is certainly present here, with other nods to Le Guin including the nod to the galactic communication device being called the “ansible,” a tech from her books. The humans here have come from our Earth, which is now unlivable due to human destruction and wars (I enjoyed the digs at cults like the highly xenophobic Gaiaists wanted to abandon the galaxy and return to Earth or the Survivalists who reject technology or vaccines wanting a human surpremacist society) but in this future amongst the stars they are fairly mediocre and not exactly highly respected. They are viewed as too emotional, weak and fragile, and there is a comedic moment when characters playing an old human game (chess) joke at how human games used to be about conquest but in the present the idea of humans being conquerors is laughable. ‘The only reason Humans stopped killing each other to the extent that you used to, I think, is because your planet died before you could finish the job,’ we are told. It is a good warning in a book largely about cooperation. ‘No good can come from a species at war with itself,’ Chambers writes, and this hits at a major theme in the novel. We have the humans, but also the tragic history of the Grum and why they are going extinct after years of developing more and more lethal technology to kill each other in horrific fashion in their wars. There is an excellent political narrative in this book and while it mostly exists in the background, the repercussions of it constantly arise and often harm the regular people just doing their jobs and living their lives despite it being so much larger and beyond them. ‘The thing is, a lot of laws are stupid, too, and they don't always keep people out of danger,’ we are told, and often we see how the politics of the galaxy is far more about feeding the powerful than protecting the people. Ownership of resources drives much of the politics and becomes an excellent commentary on our own global politics as it is the future’s politics. A rich person selling weapons to both sides of a war for personal gain (a narrative threaded through the newscasts) is decried as wrong and punished, but a government doing the same thing is “business as usual” and rewarded with power. And people die for these power struggles while being hardly a blip on the news. World building is a strong gift for Chambers and, like many Le Guin novels, this reads like a sociological exploration of a galaxy via a cozy narrative. It is incredibly well constructed and while she throws a multitude of in-world terms at you, she excels at putting them in contexts for you to learn them without having to explain them. By the end of the book what sounds like gibberish to an outsider is perfectly understandable to the reader. It is accomplished without much exposition either, having passages that are “historical texts” or essays that provide context and much of the explaining is done via conversations between regular people in the ways regular people would talk about events. It allows you to experience and learn on the ground level instead of being lectured, and it really works. You feel like you exist in their world, its quite impressive. The book is also rather episodic while following a fairly basic narrative forward, giving you cool windows of insight to the galaxy through short, contained narratives inside the larger one. This is a very character driven story and one in which discovering or being true to your identity while also being part of the larger world is a major theme. This can be tricky in a dangerous universe full of corruption. ‘You are capable of anything. Good or bad. You always have been, and you always will be. Given the right push, you, too, could do horrible things. That darkness exists within all of us.’ It is also about rising above all that, and doing the right thing. It is about exploring what it means to live and feel and coexist. Things are frightening but ‘scared means we want to live,’ as Kizzy says, and pushing on despite fear and struggles is key to being alive. What really drives the point home in a cool way is how two of the moments that most humanize the characters involves characters not considered “people” in the galaxy (like a clone, or an AI), and the biggest moment of grief allows for a tragic but beautiful look at love in a sci-fi future. ‘A black hole is a perfect place to contemplate death.’ Honestly I could go on and on about this book forever. It isn’t one for everyone, and if action or a strong plot is what you seek, perhaps look elsewhere. But for a gorgeous, lived-in universe full of fascinating characters and a look at how that would feasibly work, this is an absolute gem. It’s cozy, its comforting, its often hilarious and touching, but it also critiques society, war and the power structures that make war and societal suffering happen. We see how the average person is so small and fragile against the scope of political struggles of the rich and we see how it is the average person that becomes expendable pawns in their games. But most of all, we see how being alive is a joy when you can share it with others, even sharing pain and fear, and great things can happen when we try to work together. Love is the message here, and we have interspecies romantic love and familial love, both of which are necessary and good. It’s so charming. A Long Way to a Small Angry Planet was a burst of sunshine in my life, and I hated finishing it because I just want to sail the stars with that crew. Come aboard, there is much to see. 5/5 ‘You're Rosemary Harper. You chose that name because the old one didn't fit anymore. So you had to break a few laws to de it. Big fucking deal. Life isn't fair, and laws usually aren't, either. You did what you had to do.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Apr 11, 2023
|
May 07, 2023
|
Apr 11, 2023
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||||
014303944X
| 9780143039440
| 014303944X
| 3.45
| 2,843
| 1950
| Nov 28, 2006
|
liked it
|
That the best laid plans of mice and men often go awry is something John Steinbeck is very familiar with, making this idea thematically central to man
That the best laid plans of mice and men often go awry is something John Steinbeck is very familiar with, making this idea thematically central to many of his works, yet in Burning Bright we see this idea befalling his own book. It is a ‘play-novelette’ as he called it, not unlike The Moon Is Down, though here the mixture of prose and play-format dialogue swings heavily towards the dialogue. It tells the story of a couple, Joe Saul—one of Steinbeck’s signature ‘everyman’ characters—and his with Mordeen who, wanting to give a child to her husband but fearing he is sterile, gets pregnant with Joe’s arrogant assistant, Victor. Rounding out the cast is Ed, Joe’s best and most loyal friend, and across four different settings the characters discuss their situation and muse about life in typical Steinbeck fashion. Unfortunately, this comes across rather stilted and while the dialogue has some beautiful moments it is also a tad overwrought. This would perhaps work much better as a radio play or on the stage, but feels rather lifeless upon the page. Still a worthwhile read with glimmers of what makes Steinbeck such a beloved classic writer, Burning Bright is a rather dim light in his impressive oeuvre. There is much to enjoy in Burning Bright, however. The play breaks into four scenes with a different setting for each: a circus, a farm, a boat and a hospital. While their personalities and present drama remains the same, each setting has the characters with different backgrounds to fit the setting (they all live in nearby farms in one, or are all sailors in another). Steinbeck tries to make the story a universal one, a story that fits over any social circle or setting, which is a really cool concept and while it is a bit jarring I think it would look cool in a play. It also plays into the idea that Joe is the ‘everyman,’ a concept that Steinbeck often worked into his novels and characters like Joe, or, say, Ethan from The Winter of Our Discontent, become a bit of a barometer of the soul and social values of mid-century United States. The whole plotline with his Mordeen sleeping with the completely despicable Victor, who is portrayed as an usurper, has some Biblical seeming vibes but is also just a bit not great. It makes her function almost solely for her role in upholding the emotional states and legacies of the two men and serving mostly for her childbearing abilities than as a person with her own agency. Nobody has ever called Steinbeck a feminist writer for sure, but this felt a little egregious here. I do enjoy Ed, however, and his name recalls Steinbeck’s good friend Ed Ricketts who is the inspiration for many Steinbeck characters such as Doc in Cannery Row. Ed is quite likeable here and helps Joe through his existential crises once he realizes he is, in fact, infertile and there is no way the baby can be his. It does all lead up to a satisfying conclusion, with an large idea that ‘every man is father to all children and every child must have all men as father.’ This is classic Steinbeck, the idea that we are all one family and must care for each other and raise the human race together. I just feel like he did this more effectively in other books. Burning Bright is a curious and interesting experiment in the lengthy list of Steinbeck books, and it is nice to see him playing with his own craft. While it didn’t fully work here, there are some lovely moments and at least Steinbeck was pushing himself to create in fresh and dynamic ways. A worthwhile read, though one that will likely most interest long-time fans while I would caution newcomers to try some of his other books first. 3/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jan 23, 2023
|
Jan 23, 2023
|
Jan 23, 2023
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
080216014X
| 9780802160140
| 080216014X
| 4.32
| 123,171
| Feb 2010
| Nov 01, 2022
|
it was amazing
|
‘I feel at such a loss for words but this is a new place, and new words are needed.’ I love when a novel is deceptively simplistic, seeming sparse on t ‘I feel at such a loss for words but this is a new place, and new words are needed.’ I love when a novel is deceptively simplistic, seeming sparse on the surface but revealing intricacies of emotion and meaning the more you unpack each scene. In this case, you unpack a sucker punch of feelings straight to the heart and we are all better for it. Claire Keegan’s Foster is such a book, being taut and economical in Keegan’s pitch perfect prose but delivering an emotional resonance far surpassing its brief 80pgs. Originally published in 2010 in Ireland where it garnered awards and school curriculum reading, Foster has finally arrived on US shelves, no doubt aided by the success of her recent novella, Small Things Like These , which was nominated for the Booker Prize this year, and the film adaptation of this book. I found Foster to be even tighter and more succinct, which was to its benefit though Small Things was fantastic itself, and this novella manages to say so much in all the unsaid moments. Thriving through a story taking place beyond the grasp of the pre-teen girl who narrates the story, Foster is a tiny, bittersweet masterpiece that captures the aches and living and comforts of love all set against a lush Irish landscape. ‘“I try to remember another time when I felt like this and am sad because I can’t remember a time, and happy, too, because I cannot.’ Foster is a simple enough story, a young girl is sent to live with distant relatives for a summer while her mother is pregnant with yet another child and the short time together builds a deep emotional resonance in the lives of the girl and the Kinsellas who take her in. While it is a tight and succinct novel, Keegan depicts gorgeous landscapes and has an ear for dialogue that brings this story to life and makes you feel like you are with them as they run to the Irish sea or play cards amidst the laughter of the night. While there are only a few passing scenes of domestic life—a shopping trip, life around the house doing chores together, walks through nature and a wake—a whole world of emotions explodes from every sentence, even if the narrator can’t quite corral them into words. ‘I have learned enough, grown enough, to know that what happened is not something I need ever mention.’ There is a beauty in the way Foster exists most in awkward spaces, in the silences between words, the space between dark and light, or between understanding. ‘Everything changes into something else,’ the narrator observes, ‘turns into some version of what it was before,’ and we are met with frequent references to the world around her in moments of flux. This is a very loving household, though one that values both openness and knowing when words are not necessary. Mrs. Kinsella is upfront about this from the start: ‘‘Where there’s a secret,’ she says, ‘there’s shame – and shame is something we can do without.’’This seems to contrast with the narrator’s home life, one we are lead to assume has landed her here because the father drinks and gambles too much and they have too many mouths to feed than they can afford with another on the way. We also have Mr. Kinsella’s thoughts on not always needing to speak: ’‘You don’t ever have to say anything,’ he says. ‘Always remember that as a thing you need never do. Many’s the man lost much just because he missed a perfect opportunity to say nothing.’’ Better to be quiet than be a fool. Though this is also reflective of the novella itself and how so much understanding is in the unsaid. Much of this is built through the perspective of the narrative that is attempting to recount ‘things I don’t fully understand, things which may not even be intended for me,’ and written only through how she is able to comprehend the world around her. There are cute flourishes such as the narrator mentioning Mrs. Kinsella asking for ‘Aunt Acid’ at the pharmacist (presumably antacid) and other misreadings that no attention is called to and brings the narrative voice alive. It is a massive success and sticks the emotional landing through the dramatic irony that we are watching the narrator just on the cusp of understanding while ourselves knowing how her heart will inevitably crack open when it sinks in deeper in the time after the novel has concluded. The idea of silence, however, also plays into the political backdrop of the novel and the culture of silence that permeated Ireland during The Troubles. The wrong words, or any words at all, could land you on the wrong side of the violence. Midway through the book there is a brief conversation about a hunger striker who has died, reminding us of the violence lurking within the idyllic landscapes of Ireland and Kinsella questions if he has earned being well fed while people are starving for freedom. 'A man starved himself to death but here I am on a fine day with two women feeding me.' Of course this also juxtaposes the girl's family and her starving sisters and asks us if they deserve to go without due to the sins of their father. Perhaps some of the darkest aspects of the book go in silence as well, only hinted at—Kinsella teaching the girl to run the very specific distance from a house to a road, her bed wetting and avoidance of her own father seem to possibly imply an abuse that is never vocalized. ‘He looks happy but some part of me feels sorry for every version of him.’ There is a tender, sore spot at the center of the novella that is only addressed briefly and directly once, but the bruise is felt throughout. The Kinsellas are a loving family now without a child, trying to do best by the girl now in their care while also trying to not resent her family who have many children growing up without care. This novel drifts dreamily through the summer towards an inevitable end and a final paragraph that is certain to tug your heartstrings into tears. We see the girl being as much a gift for growth to the Kinsellas as they are for her, with the girl observing ‘I feel I have her balanced,’ about Mrs. Kinsella. In a scene ripe with symbolism, the man is only able to find her footprints to retrace home and jokes ‘You must have carried me there,’ though this is the sort of joke that reveals a deeper emotional truth about their attachment. My heart skipped a beat when, looking out over the sea, he points to the three lights in the sky and says that earlier there had only been two. 'There, the two lights are blinking as before, but with another, steady light, shining in between.' The imagery is beautiful. 'My heart does not so much feel that it is in my chest as in my hands, and that I am carrying it along swiftly, as though I have become the messenger for what is going on inside of me' I can’t stress enough how beautiful and emotionally charged Foster was for me. David Mitchell has compared it to Anton Chekhov which isn’t wrong, as each sentence feels carefully crafted and chosen in construction of this sturdy and succinct little story that has a power as deep as books thrice it’s size. Keegan has an ear for dialogue and a gift for perfect sentences that feel like squeezing an ocean from a stone and Foster is a miraculous novella of the ways love can creep in and fill our hearts. 5/5 ‘As soon as he takes it, I realise my father has never once held my hand, and some part of me wants Kinsella to let me go so I won’t have to feel this. It’s a hard feeling but as we walk along I begin to settle and let the difference between my life at home and the one I have here be.’ **Update: Finally watched the film adaptation— An Cailín Ciúin (The Quiet Girl)—and it was absolutely wonderful. I cried again. Shoutout to my partner finding it online as it’s not in the US yet. Great performances, they change Mr Kinsella at the start a bit but it builds nicely due to that, and I loved that it’s mostly in Gaeilge. The interpretation of the final scene is great and I like how it shows the duality of the final line. Watch the trailer here.** ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Dec 22, 2022
|
Dec 27, 2022
|
Dec 22, 2022
|
Hardcover
|
s.penkevich
>
Books:
family
(33)
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
|
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Guojing
*
| 4.06
|
really liked it
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
|||||
4.24
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Feb 17, 2025
|
||||||
3.27
|
really liked it
|
Feb 14, 2025
|
Feb 14, 2025
|
||||||
4.42
|
really liked it
|
Feb 09, 2025
|
Feb 09, 2025
|
||||||
4.20
|
really liked it
|
Oct 28, 2024
|
Sep 30, 2024
|
||||||
4.29
|
really liked it
|
Jul 29, 2024
|
Jul 29, 2024
|
||||||
3.73
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Jun 10, 2024
|
||||||
3.72
|
really liked it
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
||||||
4.39
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Feb 14, 2024
|
||||||
4.17
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Feb 07, 2024
|
||||||
3.81
|
really liked it
|
Feb 02, 2024
|
Feb 02, 2024
|
||||||
3.80
|
it was amazing
|
Jan 2024
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
||||||
3.76
|
it was amazing
|
Jul 28, 2024
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
||||||
4.37
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Dec 31, 2023
|
||||||
4.16
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Dec 04, 2023
|
||||||
4.12
|
really liked it
|
Sep 25, 2023
|
Sep 11, 2023
|
||||||
4.13
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Aug 03, 2023
|
||||||
4.18
|
it was amazing
|
May 07, 2023
|
Apr 11, 2023
|
||||||
3.45
|
liked it
|
Jan 23, 2023
|
Jan 23, 2023
|
||||||
4.32
|
it was amazing
|
Dec 27, 2022
|
Dec 22, 2022
|