This book spoke to me on multiple levels—as a teacher, an advocate for diverse children’s literature, and as the daughter of immigrants. It was truly This book spoke to me on multiple levels—as a teacher, an advocate for diverse children’s literature, and as the daughter of immigrants. It was truly everything my heart needed. Honestly, I picked it up for an extra credit book club, but it ended up being so much more.
Finally Seen discusses the importance of diversity, inclusion, and acceptance while also shedding light on the damaging effects of book bans and censorship on children. On top of that, through Lina's journey from China to America, it also tackles the challenges of assimilation and immigrantion. I especially loved Lina's resilience navigating her life despite so many ongoing struggles. Each character contributed some sort of added layer to the overall story and I appreciate the complexity Kelly Yang managed to intertwine through these stories despite this being a shorter middle grade book. I think each layer of the story showed that we might have a lot going on, but we are strong and capable enough to continue on and conquer these large challenges.
As someone completing their Masters in Elementary Education, with a focus on literacy and English language learners, I appreciated how Kelly Yang subtly referenced educational concepts like Mirrors, Windows, and Sliding Glass Doors. It added authenticity not only to Lina's experiences but also to the educational aspect of the book. There a million and ten other reasons I admire what Kelly Yang did with this story, but I don’t want this to be 30 pages long!!
So, to wrap it up, I encourage everyone to read this because it truly is a story with a message that resonates regardless of age and experience....more
I love how I could empathize with both Colin and Penelope. Penelope, often overlooked by society, has grown used to her wallfl**spoiler alert** 3.5 ⭐️
I love how I could empathize with both Colin and Penelope. Penelope, often overlooked by society, has grown used to her wallflower status because of societal constraints. Despite her intelligence and inner strength, she can't even begin to believe someone like Colin could have romantic feelings for her. Colin, on the other hand, struggles with feeling inadequate compared to his older siblings despite appearing to have everything he could ever want, a feeling I can relate to as a younger sibling.
I think their relationship complements each other's strengths and vulnerabilities. I know some say Colin makes “dumb” choices, but I think they reflect his internal struggle and confusion. Going from viewing Penelope as a friend to something more should be challenging and uncertain. I mean, this is someone you have seen as a friend or friend of your younger sister for 10+ years… it would be difficult when all the sudden you are starting to see them in a different light. Did I feel like Colin was forceful and demanding and hiding behind a “joke” or being “mischievous”? Yes *eye twitch*. But, we pick our battles with these books lol.
Something that can NEVER do me wrong is the Bridgerton family dynamic! Hyacinth, Eloise, and Violet bring so much joy to the story. I also loved getting the little snippet with Daphne as well. Although Benedict and Sophie's story was more thrilling for me, each chapter's mini cliffhangers kept me saying “ok one more chapter” too many times. I’m super excited to see how Netflix takes this story and makes it their own!
“A clear path back then might not be a clear path now.” - The concept of this book is so interesting to me and I especially loved the addition of the pa“A clear path back then might not be a clear path now.” - The concept of this book is so interesting to me and I especially loved the addition of the past princess’ experience to not only increase Elodie’s chances of survival but support her mental battle. Elodie’s personal battle against the elements and herself really is the heart of the story. However, I felt that it could have been explored in more depth. I think a lot of this story could have. Despite touching on heavy topics, a lot of the narrative felt superficial. But, Evelyn Skye does do a great job of embedding themes of female empowerment throughout the story.
Really my main critique is the juvenile writing style. While I enjoy and read a majority of YA (and occasionally middle grade books), this story felt almost too juvenile?
Overall, the story itself was interesting, and the ending took me by surprise. But, I think it could have delved deeper into the complexity of certain plot points....more