Vidya's Reviews > Encore in Death
Encore in Death (In Death, #56)
by
by
Standard, below par Eve Dallas book.
Well written and formulaic, but the story fails to stand the test of logical reasoning in the central scene. This is the one where Eve intuits who she thinks the killer is. That chain of thinking is weak and hinges purely on "instinct".
If investigators everywhere used their "instincts" like that, God help the innocents who get caught in the cross-fire.
There's a deliberation about the writing in the first chapter leading upto the murder and Eve's introduction, it looks like it was "bolted on" with thinly buried clues, purely to substantiate the eventual killer.
It seems like the author wrote herself into a dead-end, then used the investigators "instinct" to force fit another central character into the role of the killer and finally edited in a bunch of cues and clues in the first chapter to tie it together.
Like a recipe with salt sprinkled on instead of cooked in.... its not bad, but its missing something in terms of smoothness and flow.
This book is the straw that breaks my personal value for money equation - the reason I stop reading JD Robb, 20 years after I started, with "Seduction in death" in 2002.
The quality of the writing is still great, still very visual; but the characters have stopped resonating... I suppose its fair to say that this series and this author isn't relatable anymore.
I guess, I've finally outgrown her.
Good bye. Thank you for 20 years of good books.
It was nice while it lasted!
Well written and formulaic, but the story fails to stand the test of logical reasoning in the central scene. This is the one where Eve intuits who she thinks the killer is. That chain of thinking is weak and hinges purely on "instinct".
If investigators everywhere used their "instincts" like that, God help the innocents who get caught in the cross-fire.
There's a deliberation about the writing in the first chapter leading upto the murder and Eve's introduction, it looks like it was "bolted on" with thinly buried clues, purely to substantiate the eventual killer.
It seems like the author wrote herself into a dead-end, then used the investigators "instinct" to force fit another central character into the role of the killer and finally edited in a bunch of cues and clues in the first chapter to tie it together.
Like a recipe with salt sprinkled on instead of cooked in.... its not bad, but its missing something in terms of smoothness and flow.
This book is the straw that breaks my personal value for money equation - the reason I stop reading JD Robb, 20 years after I started, with "Seduction in death" in 2002.
The quality of the writing is still great, still very visual; but the characters have stopped resonating... I suppose its fair to say that this series and this author isn't relatable anymore.
I guess, I've finally outgrown her.
Good bye. Thank you for 20 years of good books.
It was nice while it lasted!
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Encore in Death.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
February 7, 2023
– Shelved
February 7, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-2 of 2 (2 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Chrissie
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Apr 23, 2023 08:44AM
reply
|
flag