Cav's Reviews > What the Taliban Told Me
What the Taliban Told Me
by
by
Cav's review
bookshelves: americas, biography, culture, islam, middle-east, military, politics, real-life-saga, technology, war
Sep 05, 2024
bookshelves: americas, biography, culture, islam, middle-east, military, politics, real-life-saga, technology, war
"TO BE ON A GUNSHIP is to be a god..."
What the Taliban Told Me was a mixed bag for me. I generally enjoy books about war, warfare, and the Middle East. Unfortunately, I found much of the writing here to be a bit slow for my picky tastes.
Author Ian Fritz was an Airborne Cryptologic Linguist in the United States Air Force from 2008-2013. He became a physician after completing his enlistment. Now, he writes.
Ian Fritz :
The book covers the author's time as an Airborne Cryptologic Linguist in the United States Air Force, mostly during his deployment to Afghanistan. He opens the book with the quote above, and it continues below:
Colloquially known as "DSO's," he expands further on his role in the war:
Unfortunately, as touched on above, I found a lot of the writing to be fairly dry. I am very particular on how engaging my books are, and this one fell a bit short for me.
The author also did the narration of the audio version I have. Sadly, I was a bit disappointed with this, as well. I found that he tended to mumble his way through the book. He speaks in a very monotonous fashion, and I became frustrated numerous times...
There was also quite a large chunk of writing in the latter ~half of the book that extensively detailed the author's inner dialogue surrounding the ethics of his job. I found this to be way too long, and was also becoming frustrated here. I get that his duties in the armed forces left him with some serious mental health issues, but this part read like a long-form journal entry.
******************
What the Taliban Told Me was an interesting historical record, but the delivery left a lot to be desired for me.
2 stars.
What the Taliban Told Me was a mixed bag for me. I generally enjoy books about war, warfare, and the Middle East. Unfortunately, I found much of the writing here to be a bit slow for my picky tastes.
Author Ian Fritz was an Airborne Cryptologic Linguist in the United States Air Force from 2008-2013. He became a physician after completing his enlistment. Now, he writes.
Ian Fritz :
The book covers the author's time as an Airborne Cryptologic Linguist in the United States Air Force, mostly during his deployment to Afghanistan. He opens the book with the quote above, and it continues below:
"...This is not to say that flying in these magnificent monstrosities provided me with some sort of spiritual moment or religious exaltation. This is to say that to be on a gunship, to carry out its mission, is to feel as powerful as any deity from the pantheons of old. But these gods, like all gods, are not interested in creation. To use the 105, a gun that is loaded with forty-five-pound bullets, a gun that, when fired, causes the 155,000-pound plane it’s mounted on to buck so far to the right that the pilot must actively correct the flight path, is to be Zeus hurling Hephaestus’s bolts. To fire a Griffin missile from an altitude so great that the men on the ground could only know of it in the same moment that it kills them is to be Mars flinging his spear."
Colloquially known as "DSO's," he expands further on his role in the war:
"Being a DSO in Afghanistan meant making life and death decisions (and not or). We could decide who lived, and who died. When we had flown a mission, and done our job right, it was no lie or even an exaggeration to say we had done something that very few other people were capable of doing.
When I did it, I was one of only two DSOs who spoke both Dari and Pashto; there was only one other person on Earth who had received the training I had, who could do the work I did.
Because I experienced all of the things I did in the Air Force at a young age, it might have been impossible for them to be anything but formative.
Because very little else that followed was imbued with the same amount of life and death, other things will always pale in comparison. Or maybe it really was the most important thing I’ve ever done, or will ever do. And so, though everything in this book is true, and most of it is about me, it is not a memoir, as I don’t know how to tell you who I am. Nor is it a war book, as I don’t know how to make you understand war. All this book can do—all I can do—is show you what I was.
I was a DSO.
And this is what I heard."
Unfortunately, as touched on above, I found a lot of the writing to be fairly dry. I am very particular on how engaging my books are, and this one fell a bit short for me.
The author also did the narration of the audio version I have. Sadly, I was a bit disappointed with this, as well. I found that he tended to mumble his way through the book. He speaks in a very monotonous fashion, and I became frustrated numerous times...
There was also quite a large chunk of writing in the latter ~half of the book that extensively detailed the author's inner dialogue surrounding the ethics of his job. I found this to be way too long, and was also becoming frustrated here. I get that his duties in the armed forces left him with some serious mental health issues, but this part read like a long-form journal entry.
******************
What the Taliban Told Me was an interesting historical record, but the delivery left a lot to be desired for me.
2 stars.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
What the Taliban Told Me.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
August 28, 2024
– Shelved
August 28, 2024
– Shelved as:
to-read
September 3, 2024
–
Started Reading
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
americas
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
biography
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
culture
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
islam
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
middle-east
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
military
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
politics
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
real-life-saga
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
technology
September 5, 2024
– Shelved as:
war
September 5, 2024
–
Finished Reading