NOTE IMDb
5,7/10
1,1 k
MA NOTE
Ajouter une intrigue dans votre langueAt the end of the Civil War, an embittered Southern belle joins forces with a Confederate guerrilla leader to raid Union towns.At the end of the Civil War, an embittered Southern belle joins forces with a Confederate guerrilla leader to raid Union towns.At the end of the Civil War, an embittered Southern belle joins forces with a Confederate guerrilla leader to raid Union towns.
Shepperd Strudwick
- Ed Shirley
- (as John Shepperd)
Paul E. Burns
- Sergeant
- (as Paul Burns)
Joe Sawyer
- John Cole
- (as Joseph Sawyer)
Joe Downing
- Jim Cole
- (as Joseph Downing)
Herbert Ashley
- Jailer
- (non crédité)
Hooper Atchley
- Carpetbagger
- (non crédité)
Matthew 'Stymie' Beard
- Young Jake
- (non crédité)
Histoire
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesAlice Faye was the first choice to play the title role.
- GaffesSam Steele was not only never in the Confederate army, he was a Native American. In fact, the version presented in "Stories of the Century" was a lot closer to the mark than was Randolph Scott's version.
- Citations
Maj. Thomas Grail: I'll hang him from the highest tree... and his friends with him.
Belle Shirley, later Belle Starr: Wouldn't that require a great deal of rope?
Maj. Thomas Grail: Fortunately, we have an ample supply.
- ConnexionsFeatured in 100 Years of the Hollywood Western (1994)
Commentaire à la une
That's an actual line of dialog from the script. Really.
The Belle Starr story, never actually told in the movies (partially because the real story isn't that interesting..) is told here in early Hollywood color and all the vim and vigor with which they revered the South. The plot hook is that one of the aforementioned "darkies" actually tells the fable as the narrator. Without spoiling the movie, Belle and her husband continue fighting after the War Against Treason, using those traditional Civil War Southern values of robbery, assassination, treason and protecting known criminals to keep Missouri safe for, well,the same people it was safe for before the War. Hey, it works in the movie.
The point made by vitaleralphlouis in his review is well taken. How dare we criticize Hollywood for showing how a loving mammy would help keep Belle safe, or that another "darkie" (their word, not mine) shows Belle's antagonist how disgusting he was. We all know that negroes formerly held as slaves had nothing but love for their former (or in this case present) slaveowners.
This is a classic example of a movie obviously made with care, but looked at today 99% of its viewers would wonder what was in the coffee they served at the story-pitching conference. Because even as a joke, this kind of movie could never be made again, and if there's one good thing you can say about Hollywood, that's it.
Oh, and by the way: a moment of silence for black actors like Louise Beavers who could only find work like this in her era.
The Belle Starr story, never actually told in the movies (partially because the real story isn't that interesting..) is told here in early Hollywood color and all the vim and vigor with which they revered the South. The plot hook is that one of the aforementioned "darkies" actually tells the fable as the narrator. Without spoiling the movie, Belle and her husband continue fighting after the War Against Treason, using those traditional Civil War Southern values of robbery, assassination, treason and protecting known criminals to keep Missouri safe for, well,the same people it was safe for before the War. Hey, it works in the movie.
The point made by vitaleralphlouis in his review is well taken. How dare we criticize Hollywood for showing how a loving mammy would help keep Belle safe, or that another "darkie" (their word, not mine) shows Belle's antagonist how disgusting he was. We all know that negroes formerly held as slaves had nothing but love for their former (or in this case present) slaveowners.
This is a classic example of a movie obviously made with care, but looked at today 99% of its viewers would wonder what was in the coffee they served at the story-pitching conference. Because even as a joke, this kind of movie could never be made again, and if there's one good thing you can say about Hollywood, that's it.
Oh, and by the way: a moment of silence for black actors like Louise Beavers who could only find work like this in her era.
- spiritof67
- 17 févr. 2011
- Permalien
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Belle Starr?Alimenté par Alexa
Détails
- Durée1 heure 27 minutes
- Rapport de forme
- 1.37 : 1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant