Tears of the Black Tiger

Having been in love since a young age, Dum and Rumpoey are destined to be together and arrange to meet and marry. However Dum (aka The Black Tiger) is held up in a large gunfight and misses her. Tragically her father has her married off to a police chief while Dum remains with his gang, run by boss Fai and including his own blood brother Mahesuan. Dum hopes to still find his true love but suspicion from Tai leads to betrayal by Mahesuan and Dum finds fate stacked against him as he tries to reunite with Rumpoey and keep his word of years ago.

Recently I watched Sin City and one of my criticism of that film was that it seem to be a lot of visual style without a great deal of substance and, although I liked this film more, I could not shake the feeling that the style and homage elements were more important to the director than the story and the characters. With Sin City the homage was noir, with this film it was the Thai films of twenty years ago and a form of hyper-homage to westerns in general. In regards the former we have hammy acting, bright colours and imaginative backdrops. These all work and even viewers unfamiliar with the style of the genre will take something from it because it is still recognisable (to a lesser extent) in more modern Bollywood films (and some Thai movies!). In regards a western, the hyper-violent style will certainly appeal to modern audiences with its comic presentation and bloody set pieces.

However, as I said, my problem with this film is more that the substance is not quite all it could be. Although the film has some beautifully observed moments, the characters and their emotions are not as well developed as they could have been and I didn't find myself as emotionally involved in the people as I was in the style. The acting is pretty wooden but I think that is deliberate. Specifically Kitsuwon's makeup, facial expressions and hammy laugh all hark back to a different period of making films (like I said – it can still be seen in some Bollywood films) and it is matched by the performances from Ngamsan, Malucchi and Metanee. They are enjoyable in terms of continuing the tone and style set by the director.

Overall this is an interesting and engaging film, mostly thanks to the homages, visual style and real experience of watching a rather unique film. The substance in regards characters and stories is not all it could have been but the plot is still good enough to keep you interesting. A strange mix of styles and genres it may be but it works well and is worth trying to find despite the inherent weaknesses.