The Last Alarm

It's truly astounding how a show built around a family can fall do far from it's peak. It's incredible that a bunch of randos had more screen time and emotional exploration than the actual main cast (except Athena). Where was Buck's grief? Eddie's? Hen's? Fantastic job at taking a well set up season and tanking it.

The fact that Eddie was told off screen, that he returned off screen, that the random family of nobody's had more screen time than almost all of the main cast is a great way to make us all deeply uninterested. There was so much potential this season and then even within this (awful) storyline there was potential and it was all squandered.

Incredible.

As a long-time viewer of 9-1-1, I'm deeply disappointed by the direction the series has taken in its eighth season, especially after episode 16. Bobby's death wasn't just an emotional blow - it was a clear sign that the people behind the show have stopped valuing their connection with the audience. Bobby wasn't just another character; he was the heart of the series, and the way his death was handled felt cold, lacking the emotional depth and narrative care he deserved.

On top of that, many fans are exhausted by the way the relationship between Buck and Eddie has been treated. For years, the show has built a strong emotional connection between them - filled with subtext, meaningful moments, and undeniable chemistry. And yet, it refuses to take a clear step forward in developing that bond. Instead, we're given breadcrumbs, vague hints, and ambiguous scenes, as if stringing us along is part of the entertainment.

This isn't new. We saw the same thing happen with Supernatural, where the fear of fully committing to a fan-beloved relationship like Destiel resulted in frustration and heartbreak. Now 9-1-1 seems to be repeating that same pattern - and it's painful to witness.

This isn't just a fan complaint; it's a wake-up call. Because when a show strays so far from the emotional core of its characters and the impact they have on their audience, it doesn't just lose narrative coherence - it loses the trust of those who supported it for years.

There was a tacit agreement with the audience, that's where the magic was. It's not fun anymore and I'm out.

There was no good reason for this to happen. None. You got bored and wanted to do something extreme, but you forgot you only have a show when people want to watch it.

1 star is the lowest rating. That second star I gave was entirely for the actors, who are doing their best, and who we love. I'm sure there are crew members who can share in that too, but I can't give anymore stars than this. It needs to reflect that I will not be watching anymore.

I reset my password to get back into this account I haven't touched in years, specifically to leave this review.

One of the primary reasons killing off Bobby Nash was a bad idea is that he was a beloved character. Bobby Nash wasn't just important on his own-he was also integral to the dynamics between other characters. Killing off a character like Bobby can have an emotional cost that extends beyond the fictional world. Fans often build a connection to these characters over time, and when that character dies, it can feel like a personal loss. If not handled carefully, this emotional upheaval can lead to narrative fatigue. One of the most compelling reasons why killing off Bobby Nash was a bad idea is that it deprived the story of a rich source of potential character development.

I'm beyond disappointed. Bobby Nash was the heart and soul of the show - the captain, the leader, the emotional center - and they barely gave him the tribute he deserved. Half the episode was wasted on a pointless mystery instead of focusing on Bobby's legacy. There should've been more flashbacks, more heartfelt scenes, something to truly honor his impact. The grief was mostly off-screen, and the reunion with Buck and Eddie felt rushed and empty. It genuinely felt like key moments were cut. Bobby Nash deserved better. This episode was a letdown and the show just isn't the same anymore. Im so sad.