Fire Protection System
Fire Protection System
PRESENTED BY:
IR. TAN YOKE LEE
MIEM, MI-FIRE E
yokeleetan71@gmailcom
For fire to commence, 4 elements must be present at the same time, thus
Fire tetrahedron
Fire tetrahedron
Fire tetrahedron
18 18 30
Fire appliance access level is defined not as ground floor but the road level
outside the building and height is measured from road to highest habitable
floor level.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
2. Check FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM provision
requirement from UBBL 2021
– Schedule Tenth –Table of Requirements for Fire Fighting
System, Fire Detection, Public Address System, Fire Control
Room/ Fire command centre.
– Part VIII UBBL 2021 specifies other requirements such as
relevant design standards, requirements for fireman
intercom, PA system, Fireman switch for electrical isolation
and wet/ dry riser.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
3. Determine requirement and design accordingly to the relevant
standards mentioned earlier. Skip to slide 24
(smoke alarm)
Only service apartment requires public address system, Flats up to 40 storeys are allowed
to have self contained smoke detectors. However, this would pose problem during fire as
nobody would know where the fire is except for neighbouring units to fire units. This
recommendation is only suitable for stay put strategy.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
3. Determine requirement and design accordingly to the relevant
standards mentioned earlier.
Type IV is for office purpose. No change in new UBBL 2021. Smoke detector is
required in building above 18 and less than 10,000 m2. Sprinkler is required for
building 30m and above or exceeding 10,000m2.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
3. Determine requirement and design accordingly to the relevant
standards mentioned earlier.
Type V shall be used for shop houses and shopping mall. It is strange that the higher
storeys are less stringent than single storey for sprinkler application.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
3. Determine requirement and design accordingly to the relevant
standards mentioned earlier.
Type VII is for place of assembly including convention center, community center,
private club, cinema, concert hall, amusmement centre, transport terminals, etc.
Place of worship is waivered from any requirement.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
3. Determine requirement and design accordingly to the relevant
standards mentioned earlier.
Type VIII is for storage area and car park. It seems that open structure car park can be
waivered from sprinkler system. Ware house is divided into storage for non combustible
and storage with combustible. For non combustible storage such as cement, bricks, etc,
there is no requirement for sprinkler.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
3. Determine requirement and design accordingly to the relevant
standards mentioned earlier.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire design approach:-
3. Determine requirement and design accordingly to the relevant
standards mentioned earlier.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Pressurised Hydrant , item H in schedule tenth UBBL
2021 (MS 1489- Part 2:2012)
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire Hydrant (MS 1489- Part 2:2012, UBBL 2021 Clause 133 © )
– Intended to be used by fire fighters. Hydrants are normally with high flow rate
and high pressure when compared to hosereel, thus requires careful handling
due to the force from the nozzle.
– Intended to be used by public for fighting small fire, thus need not be placed
in protected lobbies but to be in prominent position easily accessible.
– Note that distance of 30 meter should be measured from hosereel along path
accessible to any rooms and not drawn as radial 30meter circle.
– Pipe material- BS 1387 class B for internal and class C with bituminous
wrapping for underground piping. Generally for jkr design, use GI class C. Pipe
sizing hydraulically limiting the pump head to say about 110feet, min 50mm
diameter.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fire Hosereel (MS 1489- Part 1:2012)
-Tank requirement
• Minimum 2250Litres with 1125litres for each additional
hosereel up to maximum of 9000litres (which is about 2000
igallons). Normally, we use 2400igallons HDG tank or
3200igallons. 3200igallons tank is about 8’ x 8’ x 8’ dimension.
– Height >18m but less than 23m, 100mm diameter pipe to be used with 2
way breeching inlets.
– Height between 23m and 30m, 150mm diameter pipe to be used with 4
ways breeching inlet.
– Siting of dry riser UBBL 2021, clause 230 (3), hose connection shall be
provided in every fire fighting access lobby or adjacent to fire fighting staircase
on every floor (to prevent smoke ingress to staircase during fire fighting).
– 25mm diameter Drain valve is required to drain away water at the bottom of
riser.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Wet Riser (MS 1489- Part 2:2012)
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Wet Riser (MS 1489- Part 2:2012)
– To be provided for building more than 30m height.
– Siting of wet riser UBBL 2021, clause 231 (3), hose connection shall be
provided in every fire fighting access lobby or adjacent to fire fighting staircase
on every floor.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Wet Riser (MS 1489- Part 2:2012)
– UBBL 2021, clause 231 (4) states each
stage of wet riser shall not exceed 150m
and pressure for each stage shall not
exceed 20 bar. Distance between lowest
and highest landing valve shall not exceed
75m. (This clause should be taken with
precaution as 150m will only permit
design pressure of landing valve to be
4bar, as 150m= 15bar static + 4bar= 19 bar
allowing only 1 bar for friction loss. If we
were to follow BS9990, we should restrict
each stage to 60m as previously to ensure
that pressure at pump outlet does not
exceed 20bar as shut off pump pressure
should not exceed 1.4 x operating
pressure. )
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Wet Riser (MS 1489- Part 2:2012)
– Tank Sizing
• When there is automatic in flow of water at 455L/min to tank, use 2 nos
of tanks which are interconnected to give total capacity of 45m3.
• Note that the above tank capacity and pump sizing allows only 2 wet riser
landing valves to be in operation and last only for 45mins. This means
multiple fire on subsequent floors scenario are excluded, thus no
provision to fight fire propagating from external façade fire.
• Tank and pumps shall be positioned so that 2/3 of the effective capacity
is above the level of top of casing of pump. Otherwise individual suction
pipe with foot valve and separate priming tank is required.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Wet Riser (Guides to Fire Protection Malaysia: 2009, not to latest UBBL)
– Wet Riser Stages
• Each stage (ie one set of tank and pumps) limited to 61m (measured
between pump and highest wet riser landing valve).
• First stage pump to pump into breaktank. The incoming to breaktank shall be
complete with motorised valve which opens upon activation of second stage
pump.
• When serving more than one buildings, the distance of remote riser must be
less than 90m from the fire pump. Otherwise requires new set of tank and
pumps for the other building.
FIRE ALARM SYSTEM
Components of the system - Fire Alarm Panels
Components in the fire alarm
system consists of the followings:-
• Cheaper wiring.
Class A wiring is superior because any break in the wiring will not disconnect any
devices. Thus Class A wiring is more preferred for redundancy and reliability.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
Used where water is not suitable as medium to extinguish fire, eg:
• Substation, data centre, control room, etc.
Fire tetrahedron
• Control panel to actuate the cylinder, trip ventilation, actuate fire curtain,
lit up warning/ evacuation lights, upon confirmation of fire signals.
• HFC-227ea also known as FM200 has very high global warming potential
and is banned in some countries.
• Pyrogen
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
CO2 system
Method of application:-
• Total flooding systems
• Standpipe systems consists of just piping and nozzle system without fixed
supply of CO2. During fire, portable CO2 mounted on mobile vehicle shall
be fixed to standpipe.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
CO2 system
Design guidelines using NFPA 12
• Total flooding systems
➢ Cylinder storage either low or high pressure
1. High pressure where CO2 is stored in liquid form at room
temperature. Design pressure for calculating pipe thickness is
2800psi.
CO2 system
Design guidelines using NFPA 12
• Total flooding systems
➢ Piping system for high pressure system
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
CO2 system
Design guidelines using NFPA 12
• Total flooding systems
➢ Pipe fittings for high pressure system
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
CO2 system
Design guidelines using NFPA 12
• Total flooding systems
➢ For low pressure system, schedule 40 pipe can be used throughout
➢ Design concentration used
1. Deep seated fire, use 50% design concentration which requires
flooding factor of 1.60kg/m3 for spaces up to 2000ft3 and 1.33kg
/m3 with a minimum of 91kg for spaces greater than 2000ft3.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
CO2 system
Design guidelines using NFPA 12
• Total flooding systems
➢ Design concentration used
2. Surface fire such as from flammable liquid,
acetylene 66% design concentration, gasoline is 34% design
concentration, propane and butane 36%.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
CO2 FIXED FIRE EXTINGUISHING SYSTEM TO NFPA12
• TOTAL FLOODING SYSTEM
• DESIGN CONCENTRATION FOR SURFACE FIRE
• IF DESIGN CONCENTRATION IS 34%, FOLLOWING VOLUMETRIC TABLE CAN
BE USED.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
CO2 FIXED FIRE EXTINGUISHING SYSTEM TO NFPA12
CO2 system
Design guidelines using NFPA 12
• Total flooding systems
➢ Pipe size estimation only
➢ Nozzle pressure shall be 300 to 750Psi
for high pressure system.
➢ Nozzle pressure shall be 150 to 300Psi
for low pressure system
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Fixed Gas Extinguishing System (NFPA 12 AND NFPA2001)
For inergen gas of a 150 bar system the manifold pressure @ 180 Bar,
then after flowing through pressure reducer, System pressure @ 80 Bar
(1160psig) , Nozzle pressure @ 20 Bar.
• For eg. CO2 extinguisher is suitable for class E fire involving electrical
equipment and class A. (type of media must not contain any water
that will conduct electricity to the operator, thus water and foam are
not suitable)
• For eg, some combustible metals react with water to cause explosive
environment by dissociating water to hydrogen, etc. Thus it is
advisable to use class D fire extinguisher for metal fire.
• Fat fire are oil based. Using water may cause it to sink below the fat
and vapourise, thus causing an explosive condition. Class F fire
extinguisher which is wet chemical agent is normally sited in large
kitchen.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Portable Extinguisher (MS 1539-Part 3: 2003)
Design Procedure-
Select the correct type of fire extinguisher based on expected class
of fire.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Portable Extinguisher (MS 1539-Part 3: 2003)
Design Procedure-
Siting of extinguishers.
• Not more than 20m travel distance between occupant and
extinguishers.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Portable Extinguisher (MS 1539-Part 3: 2003)
Design Procedure-
Siting of extinguishers.
• Should be close to fire risk area.
• Should avoid exposure to excessive heat and cold.
• Normally located at conspicuous positions following an exit route.
Suitable areas are
– Room exits
– Corridors
– Staircases
– Lobbies
– Fire control room
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910 :2017)
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910 :2017) – type of sprinkler heads
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910 :2017)- type of spray patterns
Conventional type has a spherical discharge with some water thrown up.
Spray type has hemispherical discharge with little water thrown up.
Sidewall type has got ¼ spherical discharge.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Sprinkler head types and sizes for various hazard class
10mm
10/15mm
15/20mm
20mm
15/20mm
Note that 10mm should only be used in hydraulic calculation sized sprinklers
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Sprinkler head temperature rating
Note that quick response sprinkler shall not be used in pre action sprinkler system.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Types of systems:-
• Deluge system- sprinklers connected are of open type nozzle, ie there is
no glass bulb. On activation, water is discharged SIMULTANEOUSLY from
all sprinklers connected to the deluge valve. Example of use in oil and gas
for cooling of storage tank, etc where rapid fire spread is a concern.
Activated by manually operated pull station or automatic detection
system much like CO2 system. THERE IS NO WATER FROM DELUGE VALVE
TO NOZZLE DURING NORMAL TIME.
• Wet pipe system- precharged with water all the time. Commonly used
where there is no risk of water freezing inside pipe causing expansion and
bursting of pipe.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Wet Pipe System
Design Procedure:-
Calculate tank size.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Types of systems:-
• Dry pipe system- precharged with air normally. When normal, the balance
of pressure between air and water at the sprinkler control valve will close
the valve. When sprinkler head bursts, the air pressure drops resulting in
the opening of sprinkler control valve. Used when to prevent water from
freezing in the pipe. For eg. Cold room environment. This normally results
in slight delay in water application.
2. Locate the sprinkler heads as per spacing requirement and draw the pipe
layouts. (Min distance is 2.0m to avoid the spray patterns interfering with
each other)
4. Draw out tank, pump and sprinkler pipe and calculate pump size. For OH
category, there is standard pump size up to 45m. Each stage of sprinkler is
limited to 45m. For OH category, the pipe is sized for friction loss of less
than 500mbar from design point to control valve.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Wet Pipe System
Design Procedure:-
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Wet Pipe System
Design Procedure:-
Coverage for ceiling/
roof sprinklers as per
Table 19 of MS1910.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS
1910:2017)
Wet Pipe System
Design Procedure:-
Coverage for
side wall
sprinklers as
per Table 20 of
MS1910.
Note that room width is actually room depth ie distance from door to far most wall.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Sprinkler (MS 1910:2017)
Wet Pipe System
Design Procedure:-
Calculate tank size.
FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM
Standard OH pumps characteristic when pump is located same level with control valve.
Determine h which
is height of each
stage designed.
Pipe material:
GI class B for internal
GI class C for external.
External underground
To be wrapped bituminous