02 Intel Strategic Innovation
02 Intel Strategic Innovation
into the mid-1980s, and the capacity of the throughout the system almost instantly.
Israeli plant lay dormant, Intel was forced to While Intel has been challenged at the low
rely upon Israeli government capital grants. end of the market in recent years, and lost
the plant at Penang. In 1996, acknowledging As president Barrett recalls, "We were also share as a result, its problem has not been
that at last they had "basically exhausted short of cash, which made the capital grants the ability to compete at a profit, but rather
the available work force [in Penang]' Intel there very attractive. More recently, Intel has just how much of its existing profits it
built a $100 million green field facility—25 announced its interest in building a new wanted to sacrifice. Intel's profits are in fact
miles away in Kulim Hi Tech Park. A similar $1.6 billion fab in Kiryat Gat, an Israeli extremely high. Before the recent fight with
pattern appears in Ireland, where a 1989 special economic zone. According to a pre- AMD began, its margins were in the range of
system board manufacturing facility was existing incentive package passed by the 40 percent—amazing for a capital intensive
followed, in 1997, by a $1.5 billion Israeli government, investment in this zone business. And that leads us to Intel's third
fabrication plant. would qualify for a grant covering 38% of advantage, cash on hand—billions and
the investment— worth in this case billions again. If ever Intel is beaten, it won't
In choosing sites for its overseas plants, approximately $600 million. be because it lacks the resources to invest.
Intel is also apparently not immune to the
enticements of capital incentives. Strengths and Weaknesses
Semiconductor fabrication, assembly and
testing are, after all, extraordinarily Intel has some powerful advantages in
expensive; and between 1994 and 1997 the manufacturing and marketing
price tag for these facilities has tripled. microprocessors. First, it has the software
Unlike its competitors, moreover, Intel tends "legacy." To quote Carl Sagan. there are
to build these expensive facilities before "billions and billions'' of dollars worth of
demand for its product has even emerged. software programs out there that are
This implies, potentially at least, a very risky designed to operate only with Intel's x86
investment strategy, and one which Intel is architecture. Even if Intel's CPUs slipped
eager to mitigate through incentive behind in performance relative to the So what are Intel's weaknesses? One is
packages from local governments. Early in competition, it wouldn't be enough to cause technology. Its CPU's have typically just
the , 1990s, for example, when Intel was all those software developers to go to the equaled the most ambitious cloners, and
seeking locations for two new fabrication tremendous expense of rewriting their have rarely been performance leaders vs.
facilities, it sent formal requests for programs to run on a different CPU family the RISC world. This is deceptive, however.
proposals (RFPs) to several western U.S. (one of the problems they would have is Just as the legacy software is an advantage
states; according to an Oregon newspaper which different CPU). So. Intel would have to for Intel, it is also a problem; the company
report, "at the time, Oregon couldn't offer not merely slip, but really fall behind, to can't easily follow radical new design
major tax incentives. Intel chose Rio make people reconsider its CPUs for either strategies because it always has to worry
Rancho, New Mexico, which offered to waive software development or purchase. about "backwards compatibility." So far, it
all property taxes on Fab 11, which then was has done a great job of both staying
valued at $1 billion. While this particular Intel's second advantage in the market is its compatible and keeping its best CPUs near
account may bear the geographical bias of tamed skill at manufacturing. Unlike many the top in power. It has also consistently
its source, Intel's systematic practice of big companies that get sloppy when they beaten everyone in price/performance ratio.
soliciting RFPs for potential locations does dominate a market, Intel has given fanatical,
Intel's other weakness is the breadth and
direction of the microprocessor market as a trends," he suggested, "and in three years consuming more power or generating
whole. You would expect a company with the chips will rival a nuclear reactor, in two additional heat. Real-time voice and face
more than 80 percent market share to be more years, a rocket nozzle, and in another recognition, computing without keyboards,
engaging in regular discussions with flinty- two years, the sun's surface." What does and smaller computing devices with higher
eyed lawyers from the Justice Department. this mean? According to Intel, a failure to performance and improved battery life are
In fact, Intel has had very little scrutiny, find a radically different way to build chips examples of the applications the TeraHertz
largely because it is a manufacturer of would bring Moore's Law, and advances in chip is expected to make possible.
microprocessors, not just CPUs for desktop the personal computer (PC) industry as well,
computers. Viewed from this broader to a screeching halt. How were Intel's researchers able to
perspective, covering devices from develop the TeraHertz chip? What process
mainframes to cell phones, Intel's share is Intel had significant resources to face this does Intel use to consistently and
strong but not dominant. challenge. First, the firm had built a successfully innovate so it can generate
substantial R&D capability, especially in the new products such as the TeraHertz chip?
form of its stable of scientists and
Evidence shows that Intel's innovations,
including the ones leading to development
of the TeraHertz chip, result from a four-step
process:
(1) carefully and correctly defining the
problem to be solved through
innovation,
(2) assigning the "right" people to each
project,
(3) eliminating project-specific barriers
between R&D and manufacturing, and
(4) balancing autonomy with guidance for
each project's researchers.
In terms of the TeraHertz chip, here's how
the process worked. First, the limitations of
existing technologies were specified as the
problem or constraint when it came to
continuing to fulfill Moore's Law. To deal
with this problem, a performance goal of
quickly designing the world's fastest
transistor was established. Second, in 1998,
a small group of "elite" scientists was
formed and assigned to the project. To
break down barriers between R&D and
manufacturing, the scientists were located
adjacent to a full chip-development factory
and were encouraged to immediately test
new ideas in a "clean room" environment.
By quickly developing and testing actual
prototypes in the production facility,
scientists could immediately determine what
Intel's Innovation Process engineers. Supporting these individuals' did and didn't work. Lastly, Intel's top-level
work is Intel's more than S4 billion annual executives resisted the temptation to
Moore's Law suggests that the number of allocation to R&D. In fact, Intel tends to micromanage the project. This temptation
transistors (the microscopic, silicon-based spend more on R&D during recessions (as could have been great, given the project's
switches that process the digital world's was the case during 2000, 2001, and 2002) significance to Intel's future. During
ones and zeros) on a chip roughly doubles than it does when the economy is robust, in quarterly review meetings, executives
every two years. This doubling creates more order to take advantage of opportunities provided feedback to verify that the
features, increased performance, and available when competitors are likely to scientific team's work remained on target.
reduced cost per transistor. But in the spend less.
1990s, it became obvious that the limitations They also assigned additional personnel to
of existing technologies would rather Intel's continuing work on the problem with the project that could help solve unexpected
quickly prevent continuing repetition of current chip technologies yielded significant problems outside the team's expertise.
Moore's Law. Essentially, the problem results in late November 2001, when the firm However, the top-level managers did not try
facing chip manufacturers such as Intel was announced that its researchers had to unduly influence the direction of the
that as microcircuits continue to shrink pioneered an innovative transistor structure group's work.
while becoming more powerful, they run and new materials that enabled "dramatic"
improvements in transistor speed, power Intel's scientists continue to work on the
hotter and hotter, making it impossible to
TeraHertz chip. However, the firm believes
that its four-step innovation process has
helped it develop a chip that will prevent the
PC industry from grinding to a halt and that
has the potential to make Moore's Law a
continuing reality. In addition, the firm
believes the chip will help it win its
marketplace battles with competitors.
S-curve is closely related to the ability to these transistors smaller so that more of requirements are. Intel also has a
manipulate matter at a very small scale. At them could be fitted onto the same area of development programme to increase the
some point, this will mean going to the silicon, making the chips more powerful. capacity of a microprocessor. This fits with
subatomic scale of quantum circuits. This came at a price. Until recently, the the two-year cycle in which the
Another S-curve might possibly be biochips. smaller the transistors, the hotter the chips microprocessor is adapted or a new product
The approach of Intel to innovation has tended to run. In 2007 Intel developed a is launched.
been consistent in having an internal focus breakthrough in the materials used to
on process improvements and a small set of construct the transistors. Not only can these Research and development
external collaborations with universities. transistors work faster, they can also do this
while generating less heat. Intel has started Research and development help to:
This is not the approach of distributed
to use this new material for its latest • create new and better products
innovation, which relies on systematically • improve the methods for making the
managed, multi-actor projects forgeneration of processors. These are made
from transistors only 45 nanometres in size. products
breakthrough developments. Indeed, the • develop new market opportunities to
distributed innovation system would This means over 2,000 of them could fit on
sustain or accelerate growth.
provide Intel with a way forward if it decides the full stop at the end of this sentence. A 45
to launch a large development of one of the nanometer transistor can switch on and off Research involves designing new ideas to
technologies mentioned above by bundling approximately 300 billion times a second. A solve a problem or to create an opportunity.
together external and internal forces in a beam of light travels less than a tenth of an An example is the development of a new
major project. As indicated it is difficult for ainch during the time it takes a 45nm microprocessor for a mobile phone to give it
company to shift from one technology to a transistor to switch on and off. access to the Internet.
radically different one, 'jumping' from one S- Gordon Moore Intel’s founder predicted that Intel conducts research in two key areas:
curve to another. Certainly Intel is a the number of transistors on a chip will
company that has the chance to be an
Research into manufacturing capabilities chooses locations
and material. This type of research led to where there is
the introduction of the 45nm high-k metal enough land to
gate silicon manufacturing technology. build such large
plants. These need
More broad research focused on what to be close to
technology can offer. This can cover how skilled labour, its
to integrate multiple different types of markets and to
wireless technology into a single device or customers. For
how to use silicon technologies to act as example, Intel
sensors. The research reaches into areas fabricates 45nm
such as robotics. chips in New
Mexico, Oregon and
Intel invests large sums in its research Arizona in the USA,
laboratories all over the world. Intel’s as well as in Israel.
leadership in silicon technology, combined Each new factory
with the R&D capability to develop new costs up to $3
products and new ways of making products, billion (around £1.5
makes it one of the leaders in its field. The billion) to construct.
result of this research is the creation of The refitting costs for older plants can be Intel’s product research, development and
products customers want, which can be over $1 billion (around £0.5 billion). Intel manufacturing capacity to deliver improved
manufactured easily in large volumes. uses a methodology called ‘copy exactly’. products every year. This regular
Examples include notebook computers This ensures factories are built in exactly improvement will ensure continued market
containing Intel Centrino Processor the same way, no matter where they are, and leadership. In ‘tick’ years Intel will introduce
Technology. gives a consistent approach. This is critical a new manufacturing process (of which the
when manufacturing such sensitive and 45nm process is the latest). ‘Tock’ years will
Research generates many ideas but only the see the introduction of new designs
highly complex devices.
best will be chosen for development. (architectures) of CPUs (central processing
Development involves converting good The manufacturing process requires the units).
ideas into a commercial product, for highest standards of ‘clean environments’.
example, by improving a microprocessor to This is thousands of times cleaner than in Intel is competitive because:
run multiple computer programs at the same an operating theatre. Intel’s employees wear • It has a regular cadence (or rhythm) to the
time. The development of the selected special suits to ensure no dust or hair falls development of new products or
products must meet specific timetables for onto the wafers. The air is so clean that one improvements to existing ones.
• It integrates teams from R&D and all areas
launch worldwide. cubic metre of air contains less than one of manufacturing, all working to the same
particle of dust. The production process is a schedules. Intel is the only company that
The end products resulting from an
highly complex one. It takes an average of can combine and optimise manufacturing
intensive R&D programme benefit the process technology, product design,
200 people working full time for two years to
customer. These might include a smaller leading-edge capacity, design tools,
design, test and have a new chip ready for
and faster computer or mobile phones at masks and packaging in-house.
manufacture.
lower prices. Technological advances can • It sets the highest standards in high-
also mean less energy consumption, Intel provides computer chips for many quality clean production. The company
reducing the carbon footprint of consumers different market segments. A market invests vast sums in R&D and
and businesses. manufacturing. This makes it is difficult
segment is usually defined, for example, by for rival companies to match Intel.
age, gender or geographical position. Intel • It designs quality products. Intel
Before manufacturing, Intel produces a
identifies its market segments by product
‘blueprint’ or design of what a particular continually develops new technologies
use, e.g. notebooks, desktops, servers. that combine product-led, user-led, and
microchip will be needed for. This outlines
Some products are for the business market, market-led features.
all the functions it will need to support, such • It is able to leverage its manufacturing
for example, desktop computers and
as wireless capability or image software. capability. This means it can increase
laptops for companies. Other products are
The design has to answer key questions: production to bring product to market in
• What type of chip is needed and why?
for personal use, for example, notebook
large volumes. Increasing volume and
• How many transistors can be built on the computers for students. getting the product onto the market as
chip? quickly as possible are important
Intel is continually developing new
• What is the best chip size? elements in creating and maintaining a
• What technology will be available to
approaches to keep it ahead of the competitive advantage.
create the chip? competition. Vertical integration gives it a
• When does the chip need to be ready? strong advantage. This means Intel does not In order to protect its advantage it is
• Where will it be manufactured and tested? outsource any of its work for research, essential that Intel registers intellectual
development or manufacturing. For property and patents in new product
To answer these questions, Intel works with example, many companies do research and development. This registration is vital for
customers, software companies and Intel’s some development but give the product Intel. This gives legal protection against
marketing, manufacturing and testing staff. design to another company to produce. Intel copying by its competitors. The protected
Intel takes all the responses to define a does all three processes itself. Its time allows it to sell its products without
chip’s features and design. The designs are manufacturing process is capital-intensive direct competition. These help to recover
put together in the form of a computer- because of the specialist equipment. For the investment costs of designing,
simulated chip that can be tested using example, Intel spent more than $7 billion researching and developing the new
Computer Aided Design (CAD). The CAD (£3.5 billion) on manufacturing plants using products.
system tests, for example, how the the latest 45nm process technology. Intel
transistors turn on and off. It also tests how believes this investment is worthwhile, as Conclusion
the chip performs an action such as this highly competitive approach gives it a
launching a computer operating system. competitive edge by: Since 1968 Intel has contributed to
• ensuring quality improving people’s lives, work and leisure.
Manufacturing • protecting its ideas The company’s work is at the heart of the
• meeting its timescales. Internet, personal computing, mobile
Intel has been described as a phones, games consoles and home
‘manufacturing monster’. It can develop and Competitive advantage entertainment systems. Intel products drive
bring a product to market faster than the technology we use in homes, hospitals,
anyone else. Intel’s production process is Competitive advantage means a company schools, offices, factories and airports.
automated using sophisticated robotic has or does something better than its rivals. Intel’s commitment to continual innovation
equipment to ensure accuracy. This is a The ‘tick-tock’ strategy was announced in and investment in research and
good example of production in the September 2006 by Intel’s CEO, Paul development in product and manufacturing
secondary sector of industry. Intel has Otellini. It is a blueprint for Intel to maintain technology ensures competitiveness and
plants around the world manufacturing its technology leadership and competitive growth. It also provides customers around
different processors for different markets. It advantage. It plans to take advantage of the world with the latest developments.