Midterms STS
Midterms STS
WEALTH
– While some live as if wealth were the ultimate
aim of human life, they are incorrect in doing
so, for wealth is only an instrumental good
and is not an end in itself.
– For the highest happiness, moderate amount DISCREPANCY BETWEEN EASTERN AND WESTERN
of wealth sufficient to provide a person’s CONCEPTION REGARDING SOCIETY AND HUMAN
physical needs is better than superfluous FLOURISHING
wealth.
WESTERN CIVILIZATION
– A person should use his wealth liberally in the • More focused on individual
service of others and of good causes, but • Primary concern on human flourishing as an
should not spend beyond his means. end
• Aims for eudaimonia as the ultimate good
PRUDENCE o A person who has achieved such state
– The virtue which one must develop in order to would want to serve the community, but
attain moral virtue and to find the correct that is brought upon through deliberation
mean in all of one's actions is prudence. based on his values rather than his belief
– Prudence is an intellectual virtue, and is the that the state is greater than him, and
ability to deliberate well regarding human thus is only appropriate that he should
actions. recognize it as higher entity worthy of
– “without prudence virtues cannot exist," but, service.
“where there is prudence, all the others are
present“. EASTERN CIVILIZATION
– Prudence and ethical virtue are inseparable, • More community-centric
much like two sides of the same coin, "for • Community takes the highest regard that the
while virtue makes the end in view right, individual should sacrifice himself for the sake
prudence makes the means towards it right“. of the society
o Chinese Confucian System – focuses on the
FRIENDSHIP importance of personal ethics and morality
– Friendship is necessary for a happy life, o Japanese Bushido – code of behavior
because human beings are social beings. valuing honor above life
– There are three types of friendships: based on • Encourage studies of literature, sciences, and
useful, based on pleasure, and based on art – in service of a greater cause
virtue
– Only the third type of friendship is friendship – Such stereotypes cannot be said to be true
in the complete sense. given the current stance of globalization.
– Friendship requires that the friends wish the – Flourishing borders allowed people full
good for one another and share in some of access to cultures that as a result, very few
life's activities together. are able to maintain their original
– A friend is another self, and the love one has philosophies.
for a friend is analogous to proper self-love. – It is in this regard that we would tackle human
FRIEND = LOVE flourishing – in global perspective and as a
man of the world.
– Acquiring those mentioned qualities will
surely bring the seekers happiness, which in
– Every discovery, innovation, and success
contributes to our pool of human knowledge.
– One of the most prevalent themes is human’s
perpetual need to locate himself in the world
by finding proofs to trace evolution.
– The business of uncovering the secrets of the
universe answers the question of our
existence and provides us something to look
forward to.
– Having a particular role, which is uniquely – The earliest criterion that distinguishes
ours, elicits the idea of self-importance. philosophy and science.
– A discipline is science if it can be confirmed or
SCIENCE AS METHOD RESULT interpreted in the event of an alternative
The Scientific Method hypothesis being accepted.
– Takes into account those results which are
1) OBSERVE measurable and experiments which are
• Determine if there are unexplained repeatable.
occurrences unfolding
2) DETERMINE THE PROBLEM The Vienna Circle
• Identify the factors involved – A group of philosophers and scientists drawn
3) FORMULATE HYPOTHESIS from the natural and social sciences, logic and
• Through past knowledge of similar instance. mathematics who met regularly from 1924 to
• The goal is to reject the null hypothesis and 1936 at the University of Vienna.
accept the alternative hypothesis for the study – They believed that only those which can be
o Alternative Hypothesis (H1) – the observed should be regarded as meaningful
hypothesis that we are interested in and reject those which cannot be directly
proving. accessed as meaningless.
o Null Hypothesis (Ho) – the commonly – “This apple is red.”
accepted fact
4) CONDUCT EXPERIMENT – American philosopher Thomas Kuhn warned
• Setting up dependent and independent us against bridging the gap between
variables evidence and theory by attempting to
• Trying to see how independent ones affect interpret it according to our own biases.
dependent ones o Example: Lea has a (not-so-scientific)
5) GATHER AND ANALYZE theory that her classmate Ian likes
• Results throughout and upon culmination of her. “Good”, she thought, “I like him
the experiment too. But how do I know that he likes
• Examine if the data gathered are significant me?”
enough to conclude results Observation:
6) FORMULATE CONCLUSION AND PROVIDE • His interactions with her
RECOMMENDATION • Gestures (exchange of jokes, big smile,
• In case others would want to broaden the study going out of his ways to greet her)
Conclusion:
SCIENCE VS. PSEUDOSCIENCE • Ian does like her. (“why would anyone
2 Distinct Features that give Science edge over do something like that for a person he
other schools of thoughts: does not like?”)
1) Experimentation Verification:
2) Empiricism – states that knowledge • Ian is just generally happy to meet
comes only or primarily from sensory people he knew
experience (five senses) • Ian known Lea since they were in 1st
PSEUDOSCIENCE – refers to beliefs and practices year
that claim to be scientific but lack the true • “I will never assume again.”
method and essence of science. (objects scientific
procedure)
VERIFICATION THEORY FALSIFICATION THEORY
– Sciences cease to belong solely to gown-
– Current prevalent methodology in science. wearing, bespectacled scientists at
– Asserts that as long as ideology is not proven laboratories.
to be false and can best explain a – The new view perpetuates a dimension which
phenomenon over alternative theories, we generally benefits the society.
should accept the said ideology. o Far-off places in South America where
– This theory allowed emergence of theories many tribes remain uncontacted, do
rejected by verification theory. not regard western science as their
– A way of determining science from non- science. Whatever their science is, it
science. can be ascertained that it is in no way
– It suggests that for a theory to be considered inferior to that of globalized people’s
scientific it must be able to be tested and science.
possibly proven false.
o For example, the hypothesis that "all SCIENCE AND RESULTS
swans are white," can be falsified by – People who do not understand science are
observing a black swan. won over when the discipline is able to
produce results.
KARL POPPER – Science is not the only discipline which is able
• Proponent of falsification theory to produce results – religion, luck, and human
• He states that up-and-coming theories of the randomness are some of its contemporaries in
time, such as Marx’s Theory of Social History the field.
and Sigmund Freud’s Psychoanalysis Theory, – For some communities without access to
are not testable and thus not falsifiable, and science, they can turn divination and
questioning their status as scientific. superstition and still get the same results.
• For Popper, science should attempt to – Science is not entirely foolproof.
disprove a theory, rather than attempt to o Weather reports, illustrate fallibility
continually support theoretical hypotheses. and limitations of their scope, as well
• There is no known rule as to the number of as their inability to predict disasters.
instance that a theory is rejected or falsified in o The best that can be done during an
order for it to be set aside. upcoming disaster is to reinforce
• There is no assurance that observable event materials to be more calamity proof
or “evidences” are indeed manifestations of and restore area upon impact.
certain concept or “theories”.
• Falsification method is more accepted, but SCIENCE AS EDUCATION
scientists are still not convinced that it should – There is no such thing as a singular scientific
be regarded as what makes a discipline method, offering instead a variety of
scientific. procedures that scientist can experiment with
to get results and call them science.
VERIFICATION VS. FALSIFICATION – If one is really in pursuit of human flourishing,
– “Verification” refers to statements that are it would make sense for them to pursue it
shown to be true. (“Ian likes me.” – Leah) holistically.
– “Falsification” is to be understood as the – Mastering science and technology would be
rejection of statements. (“Lea doesn’t like inadequate if we are socialize with people or
me.” – Ian) ruminate on our inner self.
– The goal of science is to create knowledge by – Aristotle’s eudaimonic person is required to be
identifying true statements as true (verified) knowledgeable about science, among other
and false statements as false (falsified). things of equal importance.
– Popper showed that hypothesis cannot be – They are supposed to possess intellectual
empirically verified but only falsified. virtues that will enable them to determine
truth from falsehood or good reasoning from
SCIENCE AS A SOCIAL ENDEAVOR poor reasoning.
– The inclusiveness of the methodologies – A true eudaemon recognizes that flourishing
previously cited, a new school of thought on requires one to excel in various dimensions
the proper demarcation criterion of science (linguistic, kinetic, artistic, socio-civic).
emerged.
– One should understand that one should not
focus on one aspect alone. THE HUMAN CONDITION BEFORE COMMON ERA
Advancements in medicine, technology, health, and Trough technology, a myriad of new questions
education ushered in humanity’s best, and show no begins to mount.
sign of stopping. Rather than thinking that humans have clear idea
of what to expect in a good life, it can be stated
Notable comparisons then and now: that technology allows humans to confront the
MORTALITY RATE unknown and see how they would react.
Due to technology, lesser women and children die Technological revelation is but one of the many
during birth, assuring robust population and ways to perceive the world.
strong workforce. As long as humans are invested in growth and
Medical care for premature infants allows them to development, we cannot distance ourselves from
survive and develop normally. this perspective.
In the name of growth, we view the world as a Theoretical sciences (aim: “truth”) – logic, biology,
field of resources, vent in attributing monetary physics, metaphysics, among others
value on seemingly priceless entities. Practical sciences (aim: “good”) - ethics and
We begin to categorize nature as renewable and politics
nonrenewable instead as seeing it as it is. One must find the truth about what the good is
Humans are reduced into the amount of before one can even try to locate that which is
productivity they are able to render during their good.
lifetime, and our current mindset is geared toward
which would utilize our own skills. ARISTOTLE
A good life is one which is practical in essence; a The first philosopher who approached the
life which makes use of our labor and which we problem of reality from a “scientific” lens.
get compensated fairly upon. The first thinker who dabbled into the complex
Since humans appear not to really know what problematization of the end goal of life:
they are seeking for, the search continues. happiness
It is a looming fear that the path we are treading
will not take us to the right direction, leading us in PLATO
endless circles in our pursuits of the good life. Aristotle’s teacher and predecessor.
This is the danger presented by too much reliance Thought things in this world are not real and are
on technology. only copies of the real in the world of forms.
Humans lose track of things that matter, reducing Change is so perplexing that it can only make
their surroundings to their economic value. sense if there are two realities:
The world of forms
The world of matter
Plato recognized change as a process and as a
Lecture 10: THE GOOD LIFE phenomenon that happens in the world, that in
fact, it is constant.
The Concept of Being Good Plato also claims that despite the reality of
The term “good” is commonly used interchangeably change, things remain and they retain their
with the term “right”. They are related in meaning but ultimate “whatness”.
are not synonyms. You remain to be you despite the pimple that now
sits atop your nose.
Taking the right action means correctly applying a Plato was convinced that reality is full of these
norm, premise, presupposition, rule, standard or law. seemingly contrasting manifestations of change
This explains that the term “right reasons” are being and permanence.
used to justify the principle and its application. This can only explained by postulating two aspects
of reality:
Being good involves having the character and personal The world of forms and the world of matter
qualities that were justified by reasons as having
moral worth. In the world of matter:
Things are changing and impermanent
IN THE ANCIENT GREECE Imperfect
Long before the word “science” has been coined, the In the world of forms:
need to understand the world and reality was bound The entities are only copies of the ideal and the
with the need to understand the self and the good life. models.
The forms are the only real entities.
FOR PLATO Things are red in this world because they
The task of understanding the things in the world runs participate in what it means to be red in the world
parallel with the job of truly getting into what will of forms.
make the soul flourish. In attempt to understand
reality and the external world, man seek to ARISTOTLE
understand himself, too. Embarked on a different approach in figuring out
reality.
FOR ARISTOTLE Aristotle, for his part, disagreed with his teacher’s
Gave a definitive distinction between the position and forwarded the idea that there is no
theoretical and practical sciences.
reality over and above what the senses can
perceive. MATERIALISM DEMOCRITUS & LEUCIPPUS
It is only by observation of the external world that First materialists, atomists
one can truly understand what reality is all about. Led a school whose primary belief is that the
Change is a process that is inherent in things. world is made up of and is controlled by Atomos.
We, along with all other entities in the world, start Atomos (seed) – tiny invisible units in the world.
as potentialities and move toward actualities. Democritus and his disciples believe that the
Consider a seed that eventually germinates and world, including human beings, is made up of
grows into plant… The seed that turned to matter.
become the plant underwent change – from There is no need to posit immaterial entities as
potential plant (seed) to its full actuality (plant). sources of purpose.
Aristotle declares that even human beings are Atomos simply come together randomly to form
potentialities who aspire for their actuality. the things in the world.
Every human being moves according to some end. Only material entities matter!
Every action that emanates from a human person In terms of human flourishing, matter is what
is a function of the purpose that the person has. makes us attain happiness
Every human person, according to Aristotle,
aspires for an end. HEDONISM
This end, is happiness or human flourishing! EPICURUS
Aristotle claims that happiness is the be all and The Hedonists see the end goal of life in acquiring
end all of everything we do. pleasure.
We may not realize it but the end goal of Pleasure should be pursued, and pain should be
everything that we do is happiness! avoided.
When Aristotle claims that we want to be happy, For them, life is about obtaining and indulging in
he does not necessarily mean the everyday pleasure because life is limited.
happiness that we obtain when we win a Mantra of the School: “Eat, drink, and be merry
competition or we eat our favorite dish in a for tomorrow we die.”
restaurant. This school of thought does not buy any notion of
What Aristotle actually means is human afterlife just like the materialists.
flourishing, a kind of contentment in knowing that
one is getting the best out of life. STOICISM
A kind of feeling that one has maxed out his EPIRICUS
potentials in the world, that he has attained the The Stoics espoused the idea that to generate
crux of his humanity… happiness, one must learn to distance oneself
and be apathetic.
HAPPINESS AS THE GOAL OF LIFE APATHEIA – to be indifferent
For the Stoics, happiness can only be attained by
GREATEST HAPPINESS PRINCIPLE careful practice of apathy.
Declared by John Stuart Mill We should, in this worldview, adopt the fact that
States that “an action is right as far as it some things are not within our control.
maximizes the attainment of happiness for the The sooner we realize this, the happier we can
greatest number of people”. become.
Mill said that individual happiness of each
individual should be prioritized and collectively THEISM
dictates the kind of action that should be Most people find the meaning of their lives using
endorsed. God as a fulcrum of their existence.
The Philippines, as predominantly Catholic
The ethical is meant to lead us to the good and happy country, is witnessed to how people base their life
life. Through the ages, man has constantly struggled goals on beliefs that hinged on some form of
with the external world in order to reach human supernatural reality called heaven.
flourishing. The ultimate happiness of theists is the
communion with God.
History has given birth to different schools of thought, The world where we are in is only just a
all of which aim for the good and happy life. temporary reality where we have to maneuver
SCHOOL OF THOUGHTS
around while waiting for the ultimate return to Hormones may also be injected in order to alter
the hands of God. the sexual chemicals in the body.
HISTORY OF COMPUTERS
CHARLES BABBAGE
A 19th century English Mathematics
professor.
Designed the Analytical Engine which
was used as the basic framework of
the computers even until the present
time.
32