Article 25
Article 25
Indian Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 3 No. 12 (Dec 2010) ISSN: 0974- 6846
                                                          Abstract
A pristine world of silver sands, clear blue seas, coral reefs, swaying palms, tropical forests, volcanic mountains and a
gently undulating landscape is what the Andaman and Nicobar islands are all about. The islands comprising of 572
islands/islets, extend over an area of 8,249 km2. Located between 6o 45” N and 13o 41” N latitudes and 92o 12” E and
93o 57” E longitudes, the islands offer exciting ecotourism products with natural and cultural settings. The present study
dealt with tourism products, what attract tourists to the Andaman and Nicobar islands, preferences and choices among
the touristic places and products. The scope of the present research work includes the assessment of positive and
negative impacts of ecotourism in the Andaman’s as perceived by the domestic and international tourists. It provides
suggestions and recommendations on the basis of the analysis of field data on the tourist profiles, tourism products
and tourism infrastructure. Furthermore, on the basis of the outcome of this research; the research has suggested to
the tourism planners and administrators suitable proposals for the development of ecotourism in the Andaman’s. More
than 60% of the tourists have informed that they received information about the Andaman and Nicobar islands from
their friends and relatives. The age composition of the tourists indicates that 57% of the tourists were in the age group
of 31-50 years and 92% of the tourists were highly educated and none of the respondents in the sample was illiterate.
The occupational structure of the tourists was found mixed, 70% of the total tourists comprised of technicians,
government servants, private sector employees, students and teachers. Occupation wise, money spent by the tourists
indicates that the government sector tourists earned a mean monthly income of about Rs. 28,000 and spent an
average of Rs.72, 000 on their tour. Further, their sources of funding for the tour came from the leave travel
concessions (LTC) schemes. According to the scores given by the visitors, for the natural tourism products, landscapes
topped with 93.4% of the visitors, beaches with 90.5% and scenery with 88.9%, reserved forests with 86.8% and
limestone caves with 68%. Similarly, the cultural and historical tourism products scored 82.2% for the natural history,
historical sites 81.89% and museums 74.7% and heritage sites 72.4%. This clearly indicates that the Andaman has
abundant natural beauty with a rich cultural heritage to become an ecotouristic destination.
Introduction                                                                  2007). This need for recreational hunting zones led to the
    Travelling from one place to another for different                        creation of protected areas, national parks, and game
purposes has been a part and parcel of the human                              reserves. In the 1980s, the concept of ecotourism
civilization since its beginning. In the ancient period, it                   became much more widely known and studied around the
might not have been organized the same way as we do                           world.
now, in the modern world. Wealthy people have always                             Over the years, ecotourism has become more and
travelled to distant parts of the world, to see great                         more popular because people have begun to realize the
buildings, works of art, learn new languages and                              importance of preserving the environment. More and
experience new cultures and to taste different cuisines.                      more people are aware and scared of what might happen
Long ago at the time of the Roman republic, places such                       when the earth's natural resources run out or run low.
as Baiae were popular coastal resorts for the rich. The                       With knowledge, people are more curious about exploring
word tourism was used by 1811 and tourist by 1840                             natural environment and doing good deeds at the same
(William & Theobald, 1998). In 1936, they defined foreign                     time.
tourist as "someone travelling abroad for at least 24 h". Its                    Tourism is travel for recreational, leisure or business
successor, the United Nations, amended this definition in                     purposes. The world tourism organization (WTO) defines
1945, by including a maximum stay of six months                               tourists as people who "travel to and stay in places
(William & Theobald, 1998). The history of ecotourism                         outside their usual environment for more than 24 h and
started in the 1950s. Before that, the concept was not                        not more than one consecutive year for leisure, business
widely recognized or understood. In the history of                            and other purposes not related to the exercise of an
ecotourism, it existed in a few different forms that                          activity remunerated from within the place visited" (WTO,
primarily try to achieve the same thing that the current                      1995). Tourism has become a popular global leisure
ecotourism does. Ecotourism was first introduced in                           activity. In 2007, there were over 903 million international
Africa in the 1950’s with the legalization of hunting (Miller,                tourist arrivals, with a growth of 6.6%. Also the
Popular article                                                 “Eco-tourism: Andaman”                                  Thulasimala & DevDass
©Indian Society for Education and Environment (iSee)              http://www.indjst.org                                     Indian J.Sci.Technol.
                                                                                                                                    1248
Indian Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 3 No. 12 (Dec 2010) ISSN: 0974- 6846
international tourist receipts were USD 856 billion in 2007          due to the large intake of money for businesses with their
(WTO, 2008).                                                         goods and services and the opportunity for employment
                                                                                                in the service industries
                                                                                                associated with tourism. These
                                                                                                service      industries     include
                                                                                                transportation services such as
                                                                                                airlines, cruise ships and taxis,
                                                                                                hospitality services, such as
                                                                                                accommodations,           including
                                                                                                hotels     and     resorts,     and
                                                                                                entertainment venues, such as
                                                                                                amusement parks, casinos,
                                                                                                shopping malls, various music
                                                                                                venues and theatre. The
                                                                                                narrowest definition of tourism
                                                                                                has been presented by the
                                                                                                World tourism organization.
                                                                                                According to this definition,
                                                                                                tourism is any form of travel
       Fig. 1. Study area.                                                                      that involves a stay of at least
                                                                                                one night but less than one
                                                                                                year away from home. But,
                                                                                                generally, tourism is simply
                                                                                                defined      as     domestic       or
                                                                                                international travel for leisure
                                                                                                and recreation (Roe et al.,
                                                                                                1997). Within the huge group of
                                                                                                different     types    of    tourist
                                                                                                activities, we can distinguish
                                                                                                some        major       segments.
                                                                                                Basically, tourism consists of
                                                                                                two major parts: mass tourism
                                                                                                and       alternative       tourism
                                                                                                (Mieczkowski,        1995).     The
                                                                                                alternative "branch" may be
                                                                                                divided into many other parts
                                                                                                like:    agro-tourism,       wildlife
                                                                                                tourism, adventure tourism,
                                                                                                nature and ecotourism.
Indian Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 3 No. 12 (Dec 2010) ISSN: 0974- 6846
groups of islands, the Andaman and the Nicobar are                   peak the highest peak of these islands is 732 m and
separated by a deep, ten degree channel.                             permission must be obtained from the range offices at the
    The main aboriginal groups in the Andamans are the               Arial bay. The nearby Austin islands are also worth a visit.
Onges, who live on the Little Andaman. They are food                 Mayabunder which is a small town situated in the North
gatherers who hunt fish and collect honey. Most of the               Andaman Island (242 km away from the Port Blair) and
Great Andamanese are settled today on the Strait Island,             the district headquarter for the north and middle Andaman
north of the South Andaman. The Jarawas, who were                    district.
originally located on the preserved site of Port Blair now               The Rangat and Baratang come under the middle
live on the western coasts of the middle and the South               Andaman group of islands. Rangat which is a small town
Andaman, hummed in by the Andaman trunk road (ATR).                  situated in the middle Andaman Island (170 km away
The most evasive tribe of all, the sentinelese, lives on the         from Port Blair). The grand trunk road links Port Blair to
north Sentinel Island west of the South Andaman and all              the middle Andamans. The Baratang contains the mud
are of Negrito origin. The Nicobarese, the largest group,            volcanoes and the beautiful limestone caves are a major
seem to be of mixed Burmese, Malay, Aron and Shan                    tourist attraction in the islands. The other volcanoes in the
origin. The Shompen of the Great Nicobar live on the                 area are the Barren islands volcanoes, which are the only
coast and barter in honey, cane and nuts.                            active volcanoes and also the known examples of
    In the north Andaman, Diglipur and Mayabunder which              volcanoes in India. These have erupted sporadically, with
come under the study areas of the North Andaman                      recent eruptions of 2005 believed to have been
islands, whereas the Rangat, Baratang and the Havelock,              associated with the 2004 Indian Ocean earthquake. The
Neil Island cover the middle Andaman. Similarly, Port                previous major eruption recorded was on 18th Feb 2003
Blair, Sippighat Creek, Carbyns Cove Beach, Chatham                  and the Narcondum volcano is considered as a dormant
islands, Ross Island, Rutland islands and Chidiyatapu                volcano.
areas come under the south Andamans and finally the                      Port Blair, Chidiyatapu, Wandoor, Rutland and
Hut Bay, in the Little Andaman islands. The Andaman                  Havelock islands come under the South Andaman group
and Nicobars are fringed by one of the most spectacular              of islands. Port Blair, the capital city of the Andaman and
reefs in the world and currently they are not only                   Nicobar islands is the communication link to the Indian
significant for the Indian Ocean region, but are also,               mainland. Wandoor is the central part of the south
globally (Kulkarni, 2000; Vousden, 2000; Turner et al.,              Andamans, which lies in an area of primary forest
2001; Andrews & Sankaran, 2002).                                     patches, mangroves, farmland and paddy. The Mahatma
    From a tourist point of view these islands have                  Gandhi marine national park (MGMNP) is one of the two
immense potential. The clear waters and white sandy                  marine national parks of the Andaman and Nicobar
beaches make the Andamans a perfect tropical paradise.               islands (30 km away from the Port Blair city). The park
These islands are separated from one another by narrow               consists of 15 islands, with rich corals and mangroves
straits. The four straits which divide the Great Andamans            covering an area of 281.50 km2. Chidiyatapu is a small
are the Austen strait, Humphrey’s strait, Middle or                  village at the southeastern tip of the south Andamans,
Andaman strait and Macpherson's strait. On the extreme               some 30 km from Port Blair.
north away from the North Andamans, lies the Landfall
Island; the Labyrinth islands are off the south-west coast           Methodology
of the South Andamans off the east coast of the same                     The study was based on both primary and secondary
island lies the Ritchie's Archipelago also known as the              data. The data for the study had been collected through
Archipelago islands. The Baratang lies in between to the             questionnaires from major tourist places in Andaman
east of the middle and south Andaman and Rutland                     islands namely- Port Blair town, Cellular jail, Carbyns
Island near the southern end of the south Andamans. At               cove, Ross Island, Jolly Bouy, museums, zoo, mount
the southern end of the southern group of the Andaman                Harriet, Neil island, Havelock island, Baratang and all the
lies, the Little Andaman Island. It is completely flat and           resorts on the beach and hills.
separated from the Rutland Island by the Duncan                           Altogether 305 samples were taken, 286 from the
passage in which lies the Cinque Island and a few other              mainland Indian travelers and 19 from the foreign
tiny islets.                                                         nationals from different countries. The data have been
    Diglipur and Mayabunder come under the north                     collected from the different tourist places but sequential
Andaman group of islands. Diglipur is a small town                   period from April 2008 to June 2008. The secondary data
situated in the north Andaman Island (290 km away from               have been collected from the department of forest,
the Port Blair). It is the northern most point of the                tourism department and other wings of Andaman and
Andaman chain. 9 km in land from its harbour at Arial Bay            Nicobar administration have also helped to provide such
is a bazaar. There are small beaches beside the                      needed help in the form of photographs, documents and
mangrove swamps. A sandy beach, 11 km further one at                 literature. The demographic details have been collected
Kalipur is connected by road and further Lamya Bay                   from the census office at Port Blair.
beach are easily accessible. The thickly forested, Saddle
Popular article                                        “Eco-tourism: Andaman”                                   Thulasimala & DevDass
©Indian Society for Education and Environment (iSee)     http://www.indjst.org                                      Indian J.Sci.Technol.
                                                                                                                                 1250
Indian Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 3 No. 12 (Dec 2010) ISSN: 0974- 6846
    The interviewing process consisted of a direct                   percentage analysis has been done for all variables
personal approach to 305 tourists within the study area,             extracted from the questionnaire and put into data set.
the respondents from various parts of India as well as               First a simple frequency of each of the fields with column
various parts of the world (national & international                 percentages has been made and then two way tables
tourists). Qualitative and quantitative methods were                 using certain pairs of variables have been carried out, in
combined to obtain data about the structure of the eco-              order to analyze variations. The analyst begins to explore
tourism and the tourism attitudes and perceptions. The               the data, by measuring the central tendency of the data,
questionnaires focused on 4 categories of questions: (1).            and more importantly, the dispersion of the data around
Personal information, (2). Tourism products, (3) Tourism             this central tendency. Frequency analysis is particularly
Infrastructure, (4) Tourism planning and development.                useful for describing discrete categories of data having
The response rate was high with very few individuals                 multiple choices or Yes/No response formats. This
approached refusing to participate in the survey                     analysis involves constructing a frequency distribution.
(Appendix 4.1 for the questionnaire used in the study).              The frequency distribution is a record of the number of
Data collection                                                      scores that fall within each response category. The
    The extent of data that had to be collected and the              frequency distribution, then, has two elements: The
location-based challenges, a range of instruments was                categories of response; and The frequency with which
used for data collection from different groups. Both                 respondents are identified with each category. The only
qualitative and quantitative data from primary and                   technical requirement of the frequency analysis is that the
secondary sources were collected. The choice to use                  categories of response be mutually exclusive and
qualitative research methods for a research will be                  exhaustive. This means that the same observation cannot
shaped by the dimensions of research questions. For the              be counted as belonging to more than one response
collection of primary data from the field, along with                category. The frequency analysis must be exhaustive in
observations, the questionnaire and personnel interview              the sense that all respondents must fit into a category.
with the tourists are done. A simple random sampling                 The tables so generated are numerous, only select tables
method (SRS) has been used for the collection of                     are therefore included in the text while others are so as to
information from the tourists from selected tourist spots            show the variations therein.
by using the questionnaire. The secondary data have
been collected from various organizations like the Results and discussion
department of tourism, the forest department, department              This has spoken of the national and international
of Statistics and state library of the Andaman and Nicobar arrivals in the Andaman and Nicobar islands and the
islands and census of India, India tourism development personal details of the tourists, their purpose of visits,
corporation and online information through Internet. For frequency of visits, sources of information, their
the present study, field observation has been used as expectations, age composition, educational levels,
another important instrument for collection of qualitative occupational structure of the tourists, incomes and money
data, especially for that on the socio-cultural and spent by the tourists, funding sources for the tours and
environmental impacts of tourism activity. At each field finally the visitors’ satisfaction
site, we observe tourist behaviour, the interactions of about the tour/visit episodes. Apart from this, a detailed
tourists with local people and the impact of such analysis of the different tourism products and
interactions. Further, interviews have been conducted infrastructure services and the nature of visitor services,
with the tourists for seeking their views on development of hospitality services and the tourism products such as the
the Andamans as an ecotouristic destination, the positive natural, ecological, cultural and historical were made in
and negative factors existing in the tourism practiced. The order to understand the responses and scores and also
statistical analysis was undertaken using procedures from the perceptions of the tourists to the islands. Finally, as
the statistical packages for social sciences, known per the views and suggestions expressed by the tourists,
popularly as the SPSS and described in          Table 1. Nationality of tourists. tourism planning and development was
Brayman and Cramer (1997). This                      Country        No.      %    also dealt with in some detail. The
package has been used to develop an in-                                           nationality of the tourists is predominantly
                                               India                286 93.80
depth analysis of questionnaire surveys.                                          domestic (93.8%) and only 6.2%was of
                                               Australia             05    1.60
The      frequency      distribution,    cross U.K                   04     1.30
                                                                                  the international arrivals. This may be
tabulations     of     various     indicators, Canada                03     1.00  due to the off season for the foreign
correlation between variables, pie charts      Finland               02     0.70  tourists when the field data was collected
and graphs have all been generated             The Netherlands 01           0.30  (Table 1).
using SPSS, to strengthen the analysis         Israel                01    0.30      As regards the purpose of visits,
and recommendations.                           New Zealand           01     0.30  91.8%   of the tourists have come to the
    For the purpose of description of          Switzerland           01     0.30  Andamans for holidaying only and the
sample       and      respondent       related Italy                 01    0.30   remaining (6.6%) have come for
characteristics,     a     frequency       and Total                305     100   employment purposes (Table 2). 90% of
Popular article                                        “Eco-tourism: Andaman”                                  Thulasimala & DevDass
©Indian Society for Education and Environment (iSee)     http://www.indjst.org                                     Indian J.Sci.Technol.
                                                                                                                                          1251
Indian Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 3 No. 12 (Dec 2010) ISSN: 0974- 6846
the tourists were the first timers who                  Table 2. Purpose of visits of tourists.     Money spent by tourists belonging to
                                                             Purpose             No.         %
have never visited the Andamans                                                                     different occupations indicated that
                                                       Holiday                   280       91.80
before (Table 3). Out of the remaining                                                              the government sector tourists earned
                                                       Employment                 20        6.60
10% only a few were repeaters for the                  Medical tourism            03        1.00
                                                                                                    a mean monthly income of about
second and the third time.                             Business                   02        0.70    Rs.28,000 and spent an average of
   Of the samples surveyed, 61%                        Total                     305        100     Rs.72,000 (Table 10). Further, their
have informed that they received                                                      sources of funding for the tour were:
information about the Andamans from        Table 3. Frequency of visits of tourists.  32%       government      and      semi-
their friends and relatives (Table 4).      Frequency         No.             %       government where the money came
Another 28% of the tourists have          First time          275          90.10      from the leave travel concessions
received information from books and       Second time          21           6.90      (LTC) schemes. The affordability of
media. Only 4% of the visitors have Islanders                  07           2.30      the      government       and      semi-
shown that they have received the         Third time           02           0.70      government employees were due to
information     from     the    tourism   Total               305           100        the LTC facilities extended by the
department. It is important therefore                                                  government to visit the Andamans
that the tourism department and the       Table 4. Information sources of tourists.    after the Tsunami. Further, 87.5% of
government must take adequate                  Sources          No.           %        the tourists expressed that they were
steps for proper dissemination of        Friends                131         43.00      fully satisfied with their visit to the
information for the benefit of the       Relatives               56         18.40
                                                                                       Andamans.
tourists and tourism development for                                                       A number of suggestions were put
                                         Books                   50         16.40
the Andamans.                                                                          forward by the visitors. Some of the
     As for the expectations of the      Media                   34         11.10      important views regarding the
tourists, 84% of the visitors have said  Internet                13          4.30      problem with the present Andaman
that their expectations were true and    Tourism dept.           12          3.90      tourism had lack of transportation,
found what they expected to get          Islander                08          2.60      accommodation and food and
(Table 5). In the age composition of     Employment              01          0.30
                                                                                       drinking water. As for the positive
the tourists visiting the Andamans,                                                    things about the Andamans and
                                         Total                  305          100
57% were in the age group of 31-50                                                     ecotourism potentials, the visitors
years and the educational level of a                                                  showed that beautiful landscapes and
majority was of the University level      Table 5. Meeting expectation of tourists    beaches, good climate and corals
(71%) and another 21% were of the             Expectation       No.           %       and underwater life as potential
collegiate level (Table 6 & 7).                   True          257         84.30     elements. Replying to the tourism
Accordingly, it may be concluded that             Real           48         15.70     planners’ concerns, the tourists
about 92% of the tourists were highly             Total         305          100      suggested that the Government
educated      and     none     of    the                                              should take full responsibility for
respondents in the sample was                                                         tourism      development     and     the
                                             Table 6.Age composition of tourists.
illiterate. The occupational structure                                                planners should carefully develop
                                          Age (Years)             No.         %
of the tourists was found mixed,          Up to 20                 33       10.80
                                                                                      nature-based tourism. The tourists
comprising         of       technicians,  21-30                   49        16.10     suggested that all basic facilities of
government servants, private sector       31-40                   93        30.50     transport, accommodation and food
employees, students and teachers. 41-50                           80        26.20     and beverages should be developed
These groups represented about            51-60                   47        15.40     through         proper      government
70% of the total tourists visiting the    Above 60                 03        1.00     interventions.
islands (Table 8). As for the average     Total                   305        100
incomes and monies spent by                                                           Conclusions
different age groups of tourists, it has      Table 7. Education of the tourists.           The nationality of the tourists is
been noticed that generally the higher    Education             No.          %        predominantly Indian (93.8%) and
monthly income groups spent more          Elementary             02         0.70      only 6.2% was of the international
money, with an exception of the age       Secondary &                                 arrivals. This was due to the fact that
                                                                 21         6.80
group 60 plus years above. The            Senior secondary                            the interviews were held not in the
visitors below 20 years of age had Collegiate                    65        21.40      ‘season’ for international arrivals. As
shown a very low average monthly          University            227        71.00      regards the purposes of visits,
income, even though their share of        Total                 305         100       91.8%of the tourists have come to
expenditures was relatively high. This was due to the fact the Andamans for holidaying. Regarding sources of
that the age groups were generally dependents on the information about the Andaman and Nicobar islands, 61%
income earning members of the family (Table 9).                 of the tourists received information from their friends and
Indian Journal of Science and Technology Vol. 3 No. 12 (Dec 2010) ISSN: 0974- 6846