COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF ENGINE ANALYZER
1                                                 3                                            2
-        Name of Local Supplier                                                            Tower Trade Corporation                               Celestial Tech (Main Offer)                 Engineering Architect. Cons. Ltd
-        Name of Principal Supplier                                                        Omitec Interro Inc, USA                               Grace Time Ltd, Hong Kong                   Advance 13 Engineering & Trading,
                                                                                                                                                                                             Singapore
-        Name of Maker                                                                     Omitec Interro Inc, USA                               Crypton, UK                                 Sun Tech Systems, Netherlands
1.       Name of the Equipment. Engine Analyzer.                                           Engine Analyzer.                                      Engine Analyzer.                            Engine Analyzer.
2.       Purpose. Engine Analyzer will be used in the vehicle workshop of                  Engine analyzer can test all vehicles listed, tests   Complied                                    Complied
Bangladesh Navy for diagnostic measurement of ignition, electrical and fuel injection      include- ignition analysis, fuel system analysis,
systems of all petrol as well as diesel driven motor transport such as Bus, Truck, Jeep,   cranking and charging test, diode test, automated
Pickup, Car and Motor Cycle. The equipment should have following functions:                sequential test
a.       Messages identify faults automatically.                                           Yes                                                   Complied                                    Complied
b.       Displays multiple measurements.                                                   Yes                                                   Complied                                    Complied
c.       Test and inspect report for user repair records.                                  Yes                                                   Complied                                    Complied
d.       Dynamic test on road.                                                             Yes                                                   Complied                                    Complied
e.       Prints display readings.                                                          Prints display readings                               Complied                                    Complied
-                                                                                          Four gas emissions Analyzer-measures HC, CO,          -                                           -
                                                                                           CO2 and O2 vehicles emissions, California BAR97
                                                                                           certified
-                                                                                          Omi Smoke - Smoke meter (Diesel analyser)- UK         -                                           -
                                                                                           MOT certified
3.       Quantity.01 (one) in number complete set.                                         01 (one) in number complete set.                      Complied.                                   01 (one) in number complete set.
4.       Make/Brand/Model.           To be mentioned.                                      Omitec-PDWPC2104 w/OmiSmoke                           Crypton Technology/CRYPTON CMT              Sun Modular Platform SMP 4000
                                                                                                                                                 3010-EN131/CMT 3000
5.        Name of the Manufacturer. To be mentioned.                                       Omitec Interro Inc, USA                               Crypton Technology                          Sun Tech Systems, Netherlands
6.        Year of Manufacturing.         2003 or later.                                    Comply                                                Complied                                    2003 or later.
7.        Country of Origin. USA, Japan, Australia, Canada, Malaysia, South Korea,         USA                                                   UK                                          Netherlands
Singapore, Taiwan and EU countries.
8.        Qualification of Bidders. The genuine Manufacturer/ Principal can submit         Manufacturer submitted the quotation through local    Principal submitted the quotation through   Manufacturer submitted the quotation through
quotation through their authorised local agent in Bangladesh.                              agent in Bangladesh.                                  local agent in Bangladesh                   local agent in Bangladesh
9.        Ambient Condition. The general ambient conditions in the area of operation       Comply                                                Complied                                    Complied
are as under:
a.        Air temperature      0°C to 50°C                                                 Comply                                                0°C to 50°C                                 0°C to 50°C
b.        Humidity             Up to 98%                                                   Comply                                                Up to 98%                                   Up to 98%
10.       Scope of Supply. 01 (one) in number engine analyzer will have to be              Comply                                                Complied                                    Complied
supplied as per specifications with all standard accessories/ attachments, etc and         01 (one) in number engine analyzer complete set       01 (one) in number engine analyzer          01 (one) in number engine analyzer complete
complete in all respect for immediate operation.                                           will be supplied.                                     complete set will be supplied.              set will be supplied.
11.      Technical Specification.
                                                                                                                       1
a.         Type       PC based having interfaces of multi channel scope to work either   PC based system with full ability to disconnect        Complied                             Complied
on line in real time or remotely and reconnect to upload test data.                      engine/ignition analyzer for on-the-road testing and
                                                                                         reconnected later for viewing captured data.
                                                                                         System Includes:
                                                                                         (1) Shop roll-around cart
                                                                                         (2) PC running Win. XP with printer
                                                                                         (3) Portable full function engine/ignition analyzer
                                                                                         (4) Portable four-channel lab. scope
                                                                                         (5) Four gas (measures - CO, CO2, HC, O2)
                                                                                         (6) Diesel analyzer - smokemeter
b.        Model To be mentioned.                                                         PDWPC2104 w/diesel analyzer                            CMT 3010-EN131/CMT 3000              SUN SMP 4000
c.        Make       To be mentioned.                                                    Omitec Interro Inc, USA                                Crypton Technology, UK               Sun Tech Systems, Netherlands
d.        Operating system: PC based with Microsoft windows. To be mentioned.            PC based with Win. XP                                  Complied                             PC based with Microsoft windows
e.        Interfacing module To be mentioned.                                            PDA2100A                                               EAM                                  Serial, parallel, cable boom, sun gas module,
                                                                                                                                                                                     universal cables
f.       CPU. Pentium IV or equivalent having clock speed not less then 1 GHz.           Comply                                          Complied                                    Pentium Processor
g.       Hard Drive.    Not less than 80 GB.                                             80GB                                            For the purpose of the job for which this   80 GB or higher
                                                                                                                                         PC is dedicated you don't need a 80 GB
                                                                                                                                         Hard Drive. On the country this may slow
                                                                                                                                         the progarm. The capacity we provide is
                                                                                                                                         more than sufficient to store all the
                                                                                                                                         engine testing data on a day to day basis
                                                                                                                                         for at least next 25 years.
h.        Floppy Drive.    3.5 inch conventional                                         Comply                                          Complied                                     3.5 inch conventional
jj.       CD ROM Drive. Speed not less that 52 X. To be mentioned.                       52X / 48X                                       52X                                         53X
k.        Monitor 17 inch SVGA colour monitor.                                           Comply                                          Complied                                    17 inch SVGA color
l.        Printer To print A4 paper. Type and model to be mentioned.                     Standard HP type PC compatible printer          Model: OKI-B4200                            OKIPAGE LED Printer
m.        KeyboardTo be mentioned.                                                       Standard PC keyboard                           102 key UK layout. Long back space key.      Standard 101 Key Keyboard
n.        Mouse To be mentioned.                                                         Standard PC Mouse                               PS 2/2, 2 button                            Standard two button mouse
p.        Software          To be mentioned.                                             Microsoft Windows XP, Omitec PC-Link automatic ICID2, SRD1-4                                SMP 4000 Windows
                                                                                         diagnostic software & PDAGBSW emission
                                                                                         analysis software
q.        Test leads/links    Type and particulars to be mentioned.                      PC-Link model PDAPC-Link                        Battery clip set (position negative),       Advanced multi-meter, current clamp on, oil
                                                                                                                                         Ignition coil clip set, Ampere probe, RPM   temperature probe, vacuum probe, strobe
                                                                                                                                         pick up, HT pick up, DISA test lead temp    timing light
                                                                                                                                         probe, sample probe
r.        Adapter To be specified.                                                       12 V battery adapter, AC adapter                Ignition coil adapter set                   Capacitive RPM adaptor and wasted spark
                                                                                                                                                                                     /DIS KV adaptor (8 cycle)
s.        Emission analyzer: Analyzer with display HC, CO, CO2, O2 and oil.              PDA4GBA-4gas analyzer, California BAR 97               Complied                             Analyzer with display HC, CO, CO2, O2 and oil
                                                                                         certified
t.     Diesel tester     Diesel smoke meter                                              Omi-Smoke-UK-MOT certified                             Complied``                           Diesel smoke meter
u.     Data bank         Up dateable vehicle data bank of NISSAN, MITSUBISHI,            Field updateable vehicle database                      Complied                             Complied
TOYOTA, ISUZU, SUZUKI (Model: 1990 and onward).
v.     Dimension (Length x Breadth x Height) and weight.       To be mentioned           31"x26"x56" approx. (LxWxH)                            2000 x 1150 x 900 mm                 860 x 760 x 1650 mm
                                                                                         Weight - 240 lbs                                       Weight: 120 kg                       Weight: Not mentioned
                                                                                                                     2
w.        Other details        To be mentioned.                                                  Optional ECU scanner can be added                   Nil                                        Pentium processor, floppy disk drive, CD
                                                                                                                                                                                                ROM drive, infra red remote control etc.
12.       Electric Power Supply. 220V, 50 Hz, Single Phase or 12 Volt Battery.                   PC is Powered through mains: (220 V, 50 Hz) other   Complied                                   230V - 15%, + 10%, 47-62 Hz, Single Phase.
                                                                                                 components (engine, gas analuzer, smoke meter)
                                                                                                 can be powered via mains or 12 V battery
13.        Standard Accessories. Standard accessories must include every item and                Will be supplied                                    Complied                                   Complied
accessories, which are essential to install and operate the engine analyser at bay and           List attached                                                                                  List attached in Annex 01
on the road, whether those are mentioned in the specification or not. A list of such
essential accessories with item wise price must be included in the quotation.
14.        Standard. The engine analyser must fulfil the requirements of national and            Provided                                            Complied                                   Complied
international standards. The standards, which the engine analyser complies with, are
to be mentioned.
15.        Quality Assurance Certificate. Quality assurance certificate of the engine            Provided                                            Complied                                   Quality assurance certificate of the engine
analyser from concerned authority is to be provided (if any extra cost involved to be                                                                                                           analyzer from concerned authority will be
mentioned).                                                                                                                                                                                     provided. A CE Certificate will cost Euro
                                                                                                                                                                                                2,000.00 in addition to FOB.
16.       Spare Parts. A list of recommended spare parts required for 3 years trouble            Will be provided                                    Complied                                   Will be provided
free operation of the equipment is to be provided with the quotation indicating item wise        List attached                                       List attached                              List attached in Annex 02
price.                                                                                           Total Price: US$ 1,135.20                           Total Price: £ 255.80                      Total Price: Euro 475.00
17.       Special Tools. A list of special tools (if any) required for operation,                N/A                                                 Nil                                        Not required
maintenance and repair of the equipment is to be provided with quotation indicating
item wise price.
18.       Optional Items. Optional items if any, to be mentioned showing item wise               OBDII Scanner (P/N OM100/US)                        Nil                                        Will be provided.
price.                                                                                           Unit Price: US$ 755.00                                                                         List attached in Annex 03.
                                                                                                                                                                                                Total Price 3,080.00
19.         Documents. Two sets of following documents (in English) are to be supplied           Manual and necessary document will be provided      Complied                                   Complied
with the items:                                                                                  at the time of shipment
a.          Instruction Manual
(1)         Detail particulars and technical specifications of the automatic engine                                                                                                             Complied
analyzer and all of its components.
(2)         Operation manual.                                                                                                                                                                   Complied
(3)         Service/maintenance manual.                                                                                                                                                         Complied
b.          Spare parts catalogue/ordering book.                                                                                                                                                Complied
c.          Electrical circuit diagram if any.                                                                                                                                                  Complied
d.          Factory test certificate.                                                                                                                                                           Complied
20.         Training.          The supplier will arrange training for 07 (seven) working days    As required                                         Four days training will be provided free   Agreed
for a team of selected personnel of Bangladesh Navy in installation premises at                  Free of cost                                        of cost by the manufacturer's local        Supplier will arrange free training for 07
Chittagong on repair, maintenance and operation of the equipment. Cost of training                                                                   agent.                                     (seven) days for a team of selected personnel
(day wise) is to be mentioned.                                                                                                                                                                  of BN
21.         Installation, Tests and Trial. The equipment will be installed at the vehicle        As required                                         Complied                                   Complied
workshop at BN Dockyard, Chittagong. The supplier will arrange its installation, test and
trial at his own cost. After completion of satisfactory tests and trials, an acceptance
certificate will be signed jointly by the supplier and the representative of purchaser.
22.         Certificate.          Original manufacturer’s certificate is to be provided at the   Comply                                              Complied                                   Will be provided
time of delivery of the item.
                                                                                                                             3
23.        Warranty.     Warranty of trouble free operation is to be given by the            12 months from the date of acceptance of the      Complied                                     Agreed
bidder/manufacturer for all the supplied items for a period of atleast 12 months from the    goods                                             12 months from the date of acceptance        12 months after satisfactory installation, test,
date of acceptance by the buyer. During the warranty period if the engine analyser                                                             by the buyer.                                trial and acceptance by BN.
remains non-operational for any action pending by the supplier, the warranty period is
to be extended for that period. The manufacturer is to repair/replace the defective items
in Bangladesh at manufacturer's own cost. The warranty covers all parts and labour
(including service engineer's) costs throughout the warranty period.
24.        Guarantee. The Principal/Manufacturer will guarantee to supply the spares         15 years from the date of supply in exchange of   Complied                                     Agreed
for at least 15 years with reasonable price. Yearly increase of price of spares should       cash consideration                                To supply the spares for at least 15 years   At least 15 years and yearly increase in price
not be more than 5% of the price list for spares to be supplied with the quotation.                                                            with reasonable price                        of spares shall not be more than 5% per
                                                                                                                                                                                            annum.
25.        Delivery.                                                                         Comply
a.         The supplier will arrange transportation of the supplied items at Chittagong in   Comply                                            Agreed                                       Agreed
the following address:
The Commanding Officer, Naval Stores Depot,
New Mooring Chittagong, Bangladesh
b.         Delivery Time. Within 3 (three) months of opening L/C.                            120 to 180 days approx                            Within 150 days from the date of LC          Complied
                                                                                                                                               opening
26.        Validity of Offer. The offer should remain valid upto 30 June 2004.               30 June 2004                                      30 June 2004                                 30 June 2004
27.        Terms of Payment. L/C for full purchase amount is to be opened in favour of       Agreed as per tender terms                        Complied                                     Agreed
the principal but payment will be made as follows:                                                                                             Irrevocable letter of credit
a.         80% of CFR value is to be paid on delivery of the items described under the       80%                                               80%                                          80% as per DGDP rules
scope of supply on production of necessary documents.
b.         Remaining 20% L/C amount is to be paid on producing ‘Acceptance                   20%                                               20%                                          20%as per DGDP rules
Certificate’ following successful test, trial and commission jointly carried out by
purchaser’s representative and supplier’s representative.
28.        Price.      To be mentioned in foreign currency. FOB value (which includes        Detailed mentioned in price quotation             Complied                                     Agreed
accessories, spares, tools, documents and training), freight and agency commission                                                             Detailed mentioned in price quotation        Detailed mentioned in price quotation
must be mentioned separately.
29.          Other Information.          Following information/ documents should be
provided/supplied alongwith the offer:
a.         Quotation in duplicate alongwith detailed particulars of the engine analyzer.     Enclosed                                          Enclosed                                     Enclosed
b.         Two copies of original catalogue/brochure with the quotation.                     Enclosed catalogue                                Enclosed catalogue                           Enclosed catalogue
c.         Any other feature of the engine analyzer.                                         Not required                                      -                                            -
30.        Condition for Acceptance of Quotation. If detailed information regarding                                                            Provided                                     Provided
specifications of the engine analyzer and its accessories, scope of supply, documents
etc. as mentioned above are not given in the offer, the quotation will not be accepted
without giving any justification to the bidder.
                                                                                                                          4
31.       Compliance Statement. A clear and complete compliance statement of the            Submitted                                    Submitted          Submitted
tender specification supported by original catalogue is to be submitted with the offer.
Mere mentioning of Yes/No will not be enough and detailed technical data/information
are to be provided as applicable. Incomplete compliance statement may attribute to
cancellation of the offer. If any clause of this specification does not commensurate with
offered machine practically, the deviation has to be spelt out clearly.
-         Price
a.        FOB value                                                                         US$ 22,680.00                                £    15,030.00     Euro 23,000.00
b.        Sea Freight                                                                       US$ 1,350.00                                 £        300.00    Euro 1,060.00
c.        C&F value in Foreign Currency                                                     US$ 24,030.00                                £     15,330.00    Euro 24,060.00
d.        C&F value in Taka                                                                 Tk 14,36,994.00                              Tk 16,39,575.42    Tk 16,25,563.90
-         Position                                                                          1st Lowest                                   3rd Lowest         2nd Lowest
e.        Spare Parts                                                                       US$ 1,135.20                                 £         255.00   Euro     475.00
f.        Optional Items                                                                    US$      755.00                              -                  Euro 3,080.00
g.        Quality Assurance Certificate                                                     -                                            -                  Euro 2,000.00
j.        Total Price in Foreign Currency                                                   US$ 25,165.20 (with out optional items)      £      15,585.00   Euro 26,535.00 (with out optional items)
                                                                                            US$ 25,920.20 (including optional items)                        Euro 29,615.00 (including optional items)
k.        Total Price in Taka                                                               Tk 15,04,878.96 (with out optional items)    Tk 16,69,854.83    Tk 19,15,734.13 (with out optional items)
                                                                                            Tk 15,50,027.96 (including optional items)                      Tk 21,38,099.35 (including optional items)
-         Position                                                                          1st Lowest                                   2nd Lowest         3rd Lowest
Note:     US$ 1.00 = Tk 59.80           £ 1.00 = Tk 107.145           Euro 1.00 = Tk 72.1965       (As on Mar 2004)