Skip to content

Galaxy constants: Milky Way and Andromeda have identical masses and mis-attributed references #1707

@Wiljea

Description

@Wiljea

@c3d
BLUF: Documenting the galaxy-constants errors I mentioned by email. The
Milky Way and Andromeda share identical mass/dark-matter values and several
mis-attributed references in constants.cc/constants.md. Corrected values below;
fix lands in the reference-cleanup PR (issue #1706),
as Reference 30–35.

Bugs

  1. MG and MNGC224 are both 1.5E12_M☉ ± 0.5E12 — identical value and
    uncertainty for two different galaxies (copy-paste artifact). Same for
    fDMG = fDMNGC224 = 0.85 ± 0.05.
  2. Mis-attributed references:
    • [11] (Andromeda mass/radius/distance) = Peñarrubia et al. 2014 — a paper
      on the Large Magellanic Cloud, not M31.
    • [12] (Andromeda mass) = Veljanoski et al. 2014 "M31 satellite plane" —
      not a mass measurement.

Corrected values (sourced)

  • MNGC224 = 1.4 ± 0.4×10¹² M☉ — Watkins, Evans & An 2010 (recognized value,
    keeps M31 ≳ MW); corroborated by Zhang et al. 2024.
  • DNGC224 = 2 482 000 ± 36 000 ly — Li & Riess 2021 (761 ± 11 kpc, most
    precise to date). The previous value's reference was the LMC paper.
  • fDMG = 0.95 ± 0.02 and fDMNGC224 = 0.92 ± 0.03 — both derived within
    r_vir as fDM = 1 − M_baryonic/M_vir, on a common aperture so the two galaxies
    are comparable (M31 has more stars for a similar halo → slightly lower fDM).
  • New sources: Li & Riess 2021, Ibata 2005, Sick 2015, Licquia & Newman 2015,
    Bland-Hawthorn & Gerhard 2016, Nieten 2006 (Reference 30–35).

Note

Fix belongs in the consolidated cleanup PR (post a/b/c merge) so the new 30–35
numbers don't collide with the astronomy reclassification (27–29).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions