@c3d
BLUF: Documenting the galaxy-constants errors I mentioned by email. The
Milky Way and Andromeda share identical mass/dark-matter values and several
mis-attributed references in constants.cc/constants.md. Corrected values below;
fix lands in the reference-cleanup PR (issue #1706),
as Reference 30–35.
Bugs
MG and MNGC224 are both 1.5E12_M☉ ± 0.5E12 — identical value and
uncertainty for two different galaxies (copy-paste artifact). Same for
fDMG = fDMNGC224 = 0.85 ± 0.05.
- Mis-attributed references:
[11] (Andromeda mass/radius/distance) = Peñarrubia et al. 2014 — a paper
on the Large Magellanic Cloud, not M31.
[12] (Andromeda mass) = Veljanoski et al. 2014 "M31 satellite plane" —
not a mass measurement.
Corrected values (sourced)
MNGC224 = 1.4 ± 0.4×10¹² M☉ — Watkins, Evans & An 2010 (recognized value,
keeps M31 ≳ MW); corroborated by Zhang et al. 2024.
DNGC224 = 2 482 000 ± 36 000 ly — Li & Riess 2021 (761 ± 11 kpc, most
precise to date). The previous value's reference was the LMC paper.
fDMG = 0.95 ± 0.02 and fDMNGC224 = 0.92 ± 0.03 — both derived within
r_vir as fDM = 1 − M_baryonic/M_vir, on a common aperture so the two galaxies
are comparable (M31 has more stars for a similar halo → slightly lower fDM).
- New sources: Li & Riess 2021, Ibata 2005, Sick 2015, Licquia & Newman 2015,
Bland-Hawthorn & Gerhard 2016, Nieten 2006 (Reference 30–35).
Note
Fix belongs in the consolidated cleanup PR (post a/b/c merge) so the new 30–35
numbers don't collide with the astronomy reclassification (27–29).
@c3d
BLUF: Documenting the galaxy-constants errors I mentioned by email. The
Milky Way and Andromeda share identical mass/dark-matter values and several
mis-attributed references in constants.cc/constants.md. Corrected values below;
fix lands in the reference-cleanup PR (issue #1706),
as Reference 30–35.
Bugs
MGandMNGC224are both1.5E12_M☉ ± 0.5E12— identical value anduncertainty for two different galaxies (copy-paste artifact). Same for
fDMG=fDMNGC224=0.85 ± 0.05.[11](Andromeda mass/radius/distance) = Peñarrubia et al. 2014 — a paperon the Large Magellanic Cloud, not M31.
[12](Andromeda mass) = Veljanoski et al. 2014 "M31 satellite plane" —not a mass measurement.
Corrected values (sourced)
MNGC224= 1.4 ± 0.4×10¹² M☉ — Watkins, Evans & An 2010 (recognized value,keeps M31 ≳ MW); corroborated by Zhang et al. 2024.
DNGC224= 2 482 000 ± 36 000 ly — Li & Riess 2021 (761 ± 11 kpc, mostprecise to date). The previous value's reference was the LMC paper.
fDMG= 0.95 ± 0.02 andfDMNGC224= 0.92 ± 0.03 — both derived withinr_vir as fDM = 1 − M_baryonic/M_vir, on a common aperture so the two galaxies
are comparable (M31 has more stars for a similar halo → slightly lower fDM).
Bland-Hawthorn & Gerhard 2016, Nieten 2006 (Reference 30–35).
Note
Fix belongs in the consolidated cleanup PR (post a/b/c merge) so the new 30–35
numbers don't collide with the astronomy reclassification (27–29).