A.22:4.2 - Structure claim reliance relation selection
When a structure claim relies on something beyond the selected structure, identify the reliance relation and apply the definition or test that supplies its participants and conditions. Use that definition for the relation’s required fields and use limits.
| Reliance relation kind | What is named | Definition or test to apply |
|---|---|---|
| Source-description relation | source episteme, source view, publication form or rendering where relevant, described structure or structure claim, source-basis pins or structure-use return condition, admissible use, and any grounded non-admissible use | A.7 when nearby objects need distinguishing; C.2.1 and E.10.D2 for the episteme and describing use; E.17.0 for claimed view membership; A.6.3 for a source-to-receiving construction; E.17 for a source-backed reader face; E.24.PUB and local rules for publication |
| Base-dependence or basedness | dependent and base, named direct predicate, and an optional C.2.1 assertion episteme; scope, time and evidence only when the relation or receiving use needs them; admissible use and any needed return condition | A.6.6 for direct-relation recovery and optional assertion content; the subject-specific relation pattern supplies participant meanings, applicability, obtaining predicate and any needed occurrence identity |
| EntityOfConcern or empirical grounding | claim-bearing episteme, its EntityOfConcern, and effective ReferenceScheme; when empirical grounding is claimed, the grounding holon, covered claim subgraph, and obtaining C.2.1 EpistemeEmpiricalGroundingRelation; claim scope, optional model-use structure, describing-use viewpoint, reference plane, and observation or witness condition only when current | C.2.1, A.2.6, A.1.1, E.17.0, A.6.4, A.6.3.RT, and A.6.6 only for a separate base-dependence claim |
| Evidence or witness reliance | the evidence-use relation and target claim; provenance, witness publication or observation record, time and currentness when the receiving use needs them; if an evidence graph is current, its graph path remains a mathematical or provenance expression rather than an action route | A.2.4 for evidence-use classification; A.10 when provenance or bounded reliance must remain recoverable; G.6 when a citable evidence-provenance path is needed |
| Mathematical-lens reliance | the mathematical object and its correspondence to the named subject, the structure preserved or lost, and the use and stop conditions needed by the receiving claim; when C.29 is applied, retain its result and any output reference required by the receiving use | C.29 when mathematical representation choice, transfer, or reliance remains unresolved; C.26 only when a residual contextual-model obstruction calls for its quantum-like lens; F.9 only for separately needed cross-context semantic correspondence; the named mathematical-lens pattern for its claims |
| Simulation, generated representation, model, or extracted trace | source episteme and publication when source availability matters, representation or extraction method, validation boundary, preserved structure, lost structure, and any structure-use return condition required by §4.5 | C.29 when a mathematical representation-choice, transfer, or reliance question remains unresolved; E.10.D2 and E.17.0 for description and view claims; E.17 and E.24.PUB for publication; C.2.1 only for episteme identity or a claimed empirical-grounding relation; A.10 for evidence; or the pattern that defines or tests the simulation, extraction, or validation claim |
If the required reliance relation remains unestablished, retain the usable source description or recognition cue with that limit. Do not create a generic reliance record to make the claim look resolved.
U.Structure does not carry description, representation, extraction, mathematical-lens, simulation, or generic reliance state as an internal structure field. Those are source-description, source-use, base-dependence, evidence, lens, extraction, simulation, or publication relations about a structure. PublicationRef is not an admissible substitute for the source episteme, source view, evidence relation, direct-relation assertion, or lens output.