Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-21 17:07:50 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-21 17:08:47 UTC · last check 2026-11-21 17:25:20 UTC

A.22:4.9 - Resolve a reference to one selected structure

Use SelectedStructureReference when a description, view, transformation account, or architecture claim must refer to the same selected structure. It is a bounded C.3 kind of reference values and an A.6.5 RefKind for this use, not another durable public U-kind. Its target range is the U.Structure individuals identified in :4.1.

A candidate reference value is interpreted as <R, d>: one effective reference scheme and one designation value identified under that scheme. R supplies designation equality and the resolution Method. Designation d includes every registry snapshot/version, temporal qualifier or other input that selects its target under R. A time of inspection or freshness observation that does not select the target remains an evaluation condition. Successful resolutions of one fixed <R,d> must identify the same S; using a lookup basis that selects another target requires an explicit change to d or R.

The reference value remains the same when both components remain the same under those rules. Different reference values can resolve to the same structure; identical printed tokens under different schemes need not. A carrier, description episteme, diagram, or the structure itself is outside this reference-value domain.

The membership criterion requires R to resolve d to exactly one independently identified structure S with all four :4.1 discriminators. The receiving use fixes the declaration edition and C.3.2 judgment slice with explicit versions and a temporal selector. It evaluates resolution using the target-selecting pins already fixed in d under R; a time-independent resolution states that condition. A new assessment can leave the same reference unresolved when its fixed resolution grounds are unavailable, without selecting another target.

For an admissible reference candidate, established unique resolution to S satisfies the criterion; a completed resolution to no target, several targets, or an object outside the target range fails it. An unavailable resolution dependency or unsettled target identity leaves the judgment unknown. An uninterpretable candidate or an inapplicable slice is not-applicable under C.3.2.

In every case without established unique resolution, the structure-dependent use remains unresolved; no negative claim about a purported structure follows. The kind continues while this candidate interpretation and membership distinction remain unchanged.

A returned document can help recover S, but the reader must recover the structure it describes rather than use the document as S. Resolve the four discriminators before testing any additional receiving condition, such as model-use or transformation-flow specialization. Reference membership establishes neither that specialization nor a description, viewpoint, architecture, or reliance relation. A proposal lacking established structure identity remains proposal content under C.2.1.

Retargeting explicitly selects a new <R,d> by changing R or a target-selecting component of d, then repeats resolution and the affected receiving tests. A path whose current content describes a different organization cannot replace S. Preserve the earlier target and dependent conclusions; reopen only uses whose target or required basis changed. A changed carrier or notation can preserve both reference and target when R retains their meanings.

For example, two drawings can designate one pump-flow structure with the same constituents, obtaining connections, applied constraints and use frame. They may use different reference values while resolving to that same S. A new drawing that proposes a replacement connection is proposal content until its required structure basis is established; retaining the old file path does not retarget the earlier reference or make the proposed connection obtain. For a registry reference with d=(CoolingFlow, registry@v1, t1), choosing the same printed path under registry@v2 and t2 changes d and requires explicit selection of that new reference. If the v1 snapshot becomes unavailable, the earlier reference remains the same and its resolution judgment becomes unknown; v2 does not supply a replacement target for it.