Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:20:20 UTC

D.4 - Ethical Mediation and Decision Use

Type: D-family ethical mediation and decision-use pattern Status: Stable

Use this when. You need to develop and assess ways of responding to a described ethical conflict.

Not this pattern when. If the conflict has not been described, use D.3. If the issue is only value plurality, use D.1. If the issue is only entry recognition, use D.2. If the work is bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, or ethical assurance, use D.5.

What goes wrong if missed. Naming the conflict or filling in a decision record replaces the work of developing options and judging what each would require or change.

What this buys. The practitioner can compare available ways to act, recognize a useful change to the proposed means, and explain a recommendation or why the choice remains unresolved.

D.4:1 - Problem Frame

Once an interlevel ethical conflict is visible, the next risk is premature closure. A team may declare a compromise before evidence is sufficient, turn an assurance input into ethical permission, use one level’s value as a trump card, or hide a refusal behind technical language.

From the conflict account, ask which continuations can be justified and what remains to be established. Use the subject method for any missing basis.

D.4:1.0 - Problem

Describing the conflict does not develop or compare ways of responding to it. Evidence and formal comparisons contribute to that judgement only within their stated scope.

D.4:1.1 - Forces

ForceTension
Described conflict vs. premature closureA conflict description makes action discussable, but does not by itself decide compromise, refusal, or permission.
Evidence demand vs. decision pressureThe decision may be time-sensitive while a claim it relies on still lacks the required support.
Mediation vs. universal authorityD.4 can guide one bounded use of a described conflict, but cannot become a general decision theory.
Residual acceptance vs. hidden harmProceeding under residual harm requires a justified decision with the consequential residual, affected parties, authority and responsibility basis recoverable. Include a plan, commitment or reconsideration condition when the decision relies on it; an unresolved required basis leaves that action unsupported. When the account asserts performed work, identify that occurrence and its performer; add assignment attribution when that claim is made.
Mathematical allocation vs. ethical decisionA formula or optimization can inform a decision, but it is not the ethical decision by itself.

D.4:2 - Solution

Recover the conflict, develop feasible alternatives, compare their consequences and constraints under the stated value premises, and give a warranted recommendation or decision. Keep the concerns that remain unresolved visible in that result. A short answer can complete this work.

D.4:2.1 - Develop and compare a continuation

  1. Recover the decision and the affected concerns. Use the D.3 account to identify who or what may gain or lose, over which horizon, and why those consequences matter. Check whether the proposed chooser can make the decision in question. Paying for a project, being represented in a survey, being affected by its result and having authority to decide are different relations. Return a consequential missing party to A.1.CSD; return an unresolved value premise to D.1.
  2. Separate the end from the proposed means. A valued result can be pursued through means that create another objection. Ask which feature, condition or operation produces that objection and what could supply the valued result without it. B.5.QD.CF develops that question when an assumed necessary means creates the conflict; C.39 supplies construction of another way. Consider continuing the present work, narrowing the change, changing its conditions or refusing it when those are feasible alternatives. A proposed alternative remains a proposal until its required contributions are available.
  3. Compare the same alternatives under the value premises. Preserve each side’s affected participants, consequences, constraints and uncertainty. An encompassing system’s gain does not by itself establish priority over a constituent’s loss. Where different value frames give different orderings, keep those orderings distinct. An alternative that is no worse under every retained ordering and better under at least one can remove a need to trade those values for this choice. This conclusion is limited to the alternatives, premises and affected concerns compared. If a trade-off remains, state the priority, compromise or other reason proposed for making it. Authority to choose does not make that reason correct or establish others’ agreement.
  4. Resolve only the uncertainty that changes this use. Separate disagreement about consequences from disagreement about which consequences or duties should govern. A causal inquiry can improve the former; it does not by itself settle the latter. Use available support and qualified uncertainty. Where an intended use requires a stronger claim, C.28 or the corresponding subject method supplies its basis; C.11.DUA compares an attainable inquiry with a narrower recommendation, a different option or a stop. Include delay, burden shifted to other parties and displaced work. Preserve a binding requirement’s current force while examining its merits or a feasible revision.
  5. Return the supported recommendation or decision. If the comparison basis and available options are settled, C.11 supplies the local choice. If the value conflict remains unresolved, give the conditional alternatives, the missing agreement or authority, or a refusal or impasse. Do not manufacture a common scalar to force a winner. State a residual consequence and a reconsideration condition when they matter to this use. A recommendation does not establish consent, permission or performed work.

Use the same reasoning when the option is advice, publication, a technical change or a change to a method. Identify how its possible use can affect other participants; describing one’s contribution as analysis leaves that question open. The relevant causal and responsibility relations need their basis.

D.4:2.2 - Retain the decision basis when the work needs it

Use an EthicalMediationDecisionUse account when another participant needs to inspect, compare, authorize or later revise the result. The necessary content can remain in the existing answer or decision record. The following form groups that content; use only the optional detail needed for this decision:

EthicalMediationDecisionUse:
  conflictDescriptionRef: exact C.2.1 U.Episteme identified through D.3
  affectedEntityOfConcernRef
  affectedSystemRefs?
  valuePremises
  valueFrameEditionRefs?
  decisionQuestionRef?
  intendedDecisionUse?
  intendedWorkUse?
  claimScopeRef?: U.ClaimScope
  qualificationWindowRef?
  optionRefs
  proposedMediationRefs?
  refusalOrStopCondition?
  evidenceDemandRefs?
  causalReturnRefs?
  assuranceReturnRefs?
  architectureResidualReturnRefs?
  acceptedResidualRefs?
  decisionRecordRefs?
  decisionOrRepairSystemRefs?: independently admitted U.System refs
  localSystemRoleKindRefs?: exact local U.Kind refs
  systemRoleClassificationAssertionRefs?: FinSet(U.EpistemeRef)
  intendedWorkPlanOrCommitmentRefs?: prospective plan or commitment content
  intendedAssignmentRequirementRefs?: prospective requirement content; creates no assignment occurrence
  performedWorkRows?:
    - performerSystemRef: exact U.System
      workOccurrenceRef: exact dated U.Work
      assignmentSpeciesRef?: exact directly declared species under U.SystemRoleAssignment, when assignment-bound attribution is claimed
      assignmentOccurrenceRef?: obtaining occurrence of that species with participant values, applicability, and extent covering the Work
      f6AttributionRef?: exact performedUnderAssignment occurrence, for that attribution
      holderEquality?: performerSystemRef = assignmentOccurrenceRef.HolderSystemSlot, for that attribution
      methodRef:
      workExtentRef:
      containingSystemRef:
  responsibilityRelationRefs?: direct predicate, participants, applicability, and occurrence identity
  responsibilityMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  authorityRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  authorityMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  permissionRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  permissionMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  commitmentRelationRefs?: direct relation refs
  commitmentMissingGovernorRefs?: A.6.RCD results
  admissibleUse
  inadmissibleOverread?
  strongerSourceReturnCondition?

Name the affected EntityOfConcern and any affected Systems, the value premises and any frame editions used, the decision question and options, and the intended decision or Work use. Add ClaimScope and a qualification window when they delimit that use. State the proposed mediation or refusal and any accepted residuals. If evidence, causal adequacy, assurance, architecture residuals, responsibility, permission, or actual Work remains unresolved, return only that question to the pattern that defines it.

D.4:3 - Mediation Moves

SituationAdmissible D.4 moveNeighboring subject pattern
A compromise is proposed but the D.3 description omits a side, affected entity, scope, value frame, consequence, or horizon.Return to D.3 and complete the affected side or tension.D.3
A causal claim can change the recommendation or decision.Use its C.28 support and retain the uncertainty that changes this use. If stronger support is needed, use C.11.DUA to compare a feasible inquiry with a narrower use, another option or stopping.C.28, C.11.DUA
Evidence is too weak or outdated for the proposed use.Name the affected claim and use. Use C.11.DUA to compare a feasible evidence request with a narrower use, explicit residual acceptance or refusal; obtain stronger or fresher evidence when the selected use needs it.C.11.DUA; the evidence’s subject pattern for support, A.10 when its source-to-use relation is implicit or must be replayable, and C.27 when temporal adequacy changes that use
Assurance claim is being used as ethical permission.Keep assurance as an assurance or evidence relation, not moral authorization.B.3, D.5
Architecture move reduces one residual but creates ethical conflict elsewhere.Return the architecture residual and keep the ethical conflict distinct.C.30.ILC, D.3
A decision must proceed with residual harm.Keep the accepted residual, affected parties, decision basis and material evidence limits recoverable. Include the authority, responsibility, plan, commitment, permission, assignment requirement or return condition that this decision relies on, preserving each claim’s status and any unresolved condition. If Work has occurred, recover each performer’s A.13 core and independently admit the Work under A.15.1; add F.6 only when the decision account also needs assignment-bound attribution.C.11, B.3, D.5, A.2.1, A.13, A.15.1, and F.6 as applicable

When the basis required for a particular claim cannot be obtained, that claim remains unsupported. A narrower recommendation or decision must satisfy its evidence, ethical and authority conditions. Preserve an accepted residual where it changes the use.

D.4:4 - Archetypal Grounding (Worked Slices)

Fair-share case. A service outage plan can protect hospitals, households, or industrial customers, but not all at once. The D.3 conflict description connects each affected scope and value concern to its consequence and horizon. D.4 records the mediation use: the options, accepted residuals and supporting basis, with any evidence demand, decision participant, prospective commitment, responsibility claim or return condition that this decision needs. No assignment or Work is asserted merely because the plan names intended action. If the account reports execution, add the Work occurrence and its performer; add assignment-bound attribution when that further claim is made. A mathematical allocation Method may have a separate C.29 representation or lens-use assertion, but the allocation formula is not the ethical decision, assignment, or responsibility relation.

Override case. An assurance review says a release has the required technical assurance relation, but the D.3 description shows unresolved harm for a subgroup. D.4 does not let assurance override that conflict. It records whether release is refused, conditioned, delayed for evidence, handled under C.28 causal-use analysis, or allowed with an explicit residual and the independently justified authority and responsibility conditions required for that decision. An unresolved required condition leaves that release unsupported.

D.4:4.1 - Change the means, then reconsider when another constraint changes

A team wants colleagues to find an available specialist, while staff want private calendar details to remain private. The initially proposed means publishes every calendar detail to the whole organization. Turning the service off protects those details but loses the intended availability information.

The D.3 tension concerns staff information and the team’s coordination, not two interchangeable scores. Recover the needed contribution: finding somebody available for a question requires neither an appointment title nor its other participants. Suppose an existing feature lets each member publish an availability window without exposing the underlying events; the team has permission and support to offer this voluntary feature. This supplies a third available option.

For this constructed decision, the participants’ stated orderings are:

Value concern and supplied judgementFirstSecondThird
Useful access to a willing specialistVoluntary availability windowsFull calendar publicationService off
Staff control of private event detailsVoluntary availability windowsService offFull calendar publication

Both orderings prefer the voluntary option to either original alternative. The team can recommend it on this basis without adding the ordinal ranks or deciding how much privacy one unit of access is worth. The judgement concerns these supplied preferences and feature conditions. The technical feature, the permitted voluntary arrangement and each participant’s choice are separate contributions to its use.

Now suppose the team instead needs guaranteed coverage of a required shift. Voluntary windows do not guarantee that contribution. The previous recommendation remains an answer to finding a willing specialist, but does not answer the changed staffing question. Return to the staffing arrangement and its affected commitments. A new assignment, another resource or a changed service promise may be needed.

D.4:4.2 - Keep a useful decision when a stronger claim is unavailable

A comparison has two feasible options under an agreed value frame: retain the current arrangement or make a reversible change. The available basis bounds the change’s net benefit between 2 and 4 units for every scenario retained in the comparison; all relevant constraints and affected concerns are already included in this stipulated example. The present question is which option is preferable under that basis, not what its precise effect will be.

The change is preferred throughout the supplied range. A study costing 5 of the same units solely to select between these options cannot improve their choice: its possible refinements within that range leave the selected option unchanged and impose that cost. C.11.DUA therefore supports the bounded recommendation without the study. The conclusion retains its conditional range and makes no precise-effect claim.

If a newly identified consequence can reverse that preference, or the intended use now needs a supported precise effect, the question changes. Examine that missing contribution and the feasible investigation that could supply it. The earlier decision does not authorize a stronger claim or ignore a newly affected party.

D.4:5 - Boundaries

D.4 does not define the conflict description, bias audit, ethical assurance, architecture residual, causal identification, evidence provenance, or decision theory in general. It defines one ethical use of a conflict already described by D.3.

Use a mathematical representation when its operations improve the comparison. Explain its premises and interpret its result under the ethical value frames.

D.4:5.1 - Bias-Annotation

Bias riskFailureMitigation
Conflict description becomes decisionA D.3 description is treated as if it already selected an action.Name the D.4 move and its admissible use.
Assurance becomes permissionTechnical assurance is read as ethical authorization.Keep assurance as an assurance or evidence relation and record the ethical use separately.
Formula becomes ethicsAllocation, optimization, or scoring is treated as the ethical decision.Explain how the calculation’s result and conditions inform the ethical comparison; use C.29 when the representation’s choice, transfer or supported use remains unresolved.
Residual harm disappearsAction proceeds while consequential residuals, affected parties or the authority and responsibility needed for the decision remain unclear.Name the consequential residual and the decision basis, including the authority and responsibility it relies on. Add plans, commitments, permissions, assignment requirements and a return condition where this decision needs them; retain material evidence limits and unresolved claims. Identify Work and its performer when performance is claimed; add assignment-bound attribution when that further claim is made.

D.4:6 - Conformance Checklist

IDRequirementPurpose
CC-D4-1The conflict and its sides are recoverable through D.3; add a stable conflict-description reference when the receiving use needs to cite or revise it.Keeps the decision connected to the tension without requiring a separate record for a short answer.
CC-D4-2The recommendation or decision connects the affected concerns, value premises, feasible alternatives and comparison to its intended use. Retain differing orderings and residuals when they change the conclusion; add scope, qualification window and reference detail when that use needs them.Makes the chosen continuation follow from its basis instead of merely listing decision fields.
CC-D4-3Evidence, causality, assurance, architecture, and decision claims use their subject patterns.Prevents D.4 from becoming universal decision authority.
CC-D4-4When proceeding under residual harm, keep the consequential residual, affected parties and justified decision basis recoverable. Add local kinds, classification assertions, plans, assignment requirements and relation identities only where their distinctions change this use. Every responsibility, authority, permission or commitment claim retains its predicate, polarity or modality and factual basis or unresolved condition; an affirmative occurrence claim requires its obtaining basis. Every Work row first recovers each performer’s A.13 core and independently admits the Work under A.15.1; it adds F.6 only when assignment-bound attribution is also current.Keeps bounded decision use reviewable without deriving responsibility or performance from an assignment or decision.

D.4:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternWhat goes wrongRepair
Decision-ready by mapThe mapped conflict is treated as solved.Choose a D.4 move: mediate, refuse, demand evidence, return, decide with residual, or stop.
Trump-card levelOne level’s value automatically overrides all others.Recover the affected sides through D.3 and compare their consequences and value premises through :2.1; a larger scale alone supplies no priority.
Unsupported stronger useA decision or recommendation relies on a claim whose needed support is missing.Qualify that claim and obtain the required basis for its use, or select a supported narrower continuation through C.11.DUA. An accepted residual does not make the missing claim true.
Permission by assuranceA passed assurance relation is treated as moral authorization.Keep B.3 assurance and D.4 ethical use distinct.

D.4:7 - Consequences

A recommendation can be reviewed against its value premises, alternatives and remaining concerns. Refusal, a justified evidence request and acceptance of an explicit residual remain possible outcomes.

D.4:9 - Rationale

Recognizing a conflict leaves a practical question: what can be done under the stated value premises and available conditions? Developing alternatives can change the means that created the conflict, while comparison can justify a bounded recommendation or show why the choice remains unresolved.

D.4:10 - SoTA-Echoing

For turning a value conflict into a different design, adapt Value Sensitive Design’s joint examination of technical and social arrangements. Against choosing only between the initial proposal and abandoning its aim, :2.1 and :4.1 follow the needed contribution to another means. The VSD Lab’s current account distinguishes designer and stakeholder values, direct and indirect stakeholders, and several levels of analysis. Miller, Friedman, Jancke and Gill’s Value Tensions in Design (2007), §§6.1–6.2, supplies a design comparison: useful usage information need not disclose who searched. Its local survey thresholds are not ethical constants or a voting rule for every project.

The retained contribution is changing the means while keeping the affected values visible. Developing another design costs work; select it when it could improve the available choice. Reopen when the new arrangement fails a retained value or excludes an affected party.

For reasoning with several value frames, adopt the comparison problem made explicit by MacAskill, Bykvist and Ord in Moral Uncertainty (2020), Chapter 3, Introduction and §I: ordinal orderings do not supply comparable numerical differences. Against adding arbitrary ranks, :2.1 preserves separate orderings and uses agreement where it suffices, as in :4.1. Adapt this limited contribution without making the book’s Borda rule or expected-choiceworthiness proposal a universal FPF rule. C.11 already supports a partial ordering; D.4 keeps unresolved ethical aggregation visible rather than duplicating a decision calculus. Reopen when the present choice needs a trade-off or comparison across frames that the available basis cannot justify.

For deciding how much investigation this mediation needs, adopt C.11.DUA’s comparison of attainable information work with its receiving contribution and full burden. Against either an automatic demand for causal certification or ignoring a missing basis, :2.1, :3 and :4.2 distinguish a supported bounded continuation from a stronger unsupported claim. C.28, A.10 and B.3 retain their causal, evidence and assurance meanings; they do not supply moral permission. This comparison can end with required inquiry, a narrower result or refusal. Reopen when a changed consequence, intended claim, requirement or available inquiry can change that continuation. Use C.29 when an unresolved representation choice, transfer or supported-use question can change the comparison; a calculated ranking remains conditional on its ethical premises.

D.4:11 - Relations

  • Uses D.3 to recover the conflict and its sides; identify the description episteme when the receiving use needs that reference.
  • Coordinates with D.1 and D.2 when value frame or multilevel entry is incomplete.
  • Coordinates with D.5 when bias, fairness, impact audit, causal-fairness audit consumption, or ethical assurance is current.
  • Coordinates with A.10, B.3, C.11, C.11.DUA, C.28, C.29, and C.30.ILC when evidence, assurance, choice, inquiry value, causal, mathematical-lens, or architecture-residual questions are current.
  • Uses B.5.QD.CF and C.39 when a conflict over the proposed means calls for another construction; A.1.CSD supplies inquiry into a consequential missing party.

D.4:End

Referenced in the corpus

70 literal mentions in other sections. Read their context to establish the relation.