Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:25:20 UTC

MDPE.7 - Choose the Next Music-or-Dance Development Work

Status: Stable

Type: DPF pattern body

Primary working result: a recommendation, an authorized choice of further music or dance development work, or an account of an earlier choice. Use the C.11 ChoiceResult or applicable domain decision where available. State what the evidence establishes about a previous choice and its grounds. For a recommendation explain which action, probe, rejection or change of question the comparison supports. Identify the actual chooser and authority for a claim that an authorized decision was made. Describe the work and its conditions if work was selected. Establish what was carried out separately.

MDPE.7:0 - Use This When

Use this method when music or dance observations leave a choice about further work, when advice about possible work is requested, or when someone asks how an earlier choice was made. A performance, class, event, tool or intervention may have succeeded or failed while several different responses remain possible.

An authorized chooser may select a feasible option, choose a further probe, reject the set when no option survives, or identify a different question that needs an answer. Rejection, a change of question and a condition for revisiting an issue describe the outcome of considering the options. A concrete inquiry or reconstruction can itself be a work option when someone can carry it out.

For a present choice, identify its DecisionSubject, the options that answer the same development question and whether each is feasible under the relevant conditions. For an earlier choice, use evidence of the options, conditions, recommendation or decision at that time. Bring in other results when they materially affect the comparison or establish the history.

For example, the decision can be stated in these terms.

Who is deciding or decided? Which options were considered or could address the named practice and use? What evidence, constraints and costs bear on the choice, and what could change an ongoing decision?

For a new comparison, apply the ChoiceRule that relates the options and their consequences to the ChoiceResult. For an earlier choice, recover that rule when the question requires it and the evidence permits. New information can change the comparison. A practitioner without authority to decide can recommend a course of action to the holder. Where authority is unknown, identify the recommendation or reported decision the evidence supports and the limit on claiming an authorized choice. Permission, capability and provision for carrying it out are separate matters.

For selected work, identify the intended result, performer, resources, permission and entry conditions it needs, including any condition still missing. A good performance may justify continuing on the tested stage. A failed trial may justify a narrower use, repair or stopping. Determine which response fits the actual options.

Use A.15.7 when new facts change the next action within work already under way by an identified method. Use the existing result of a domain choice directly when it answers the question. Other useful entry points follow.

  • Use MDPE.8 when the practice subject or question needs identification.
  • Use MDPE.9, C.18 or the direct method when the task is to generate alternatives.
  • Use an applicable C.11 OptionSet, domain rule and choice already made when they supply the answer.
  • For planning or tool calls after a choice, use A.15.2 or C.24.
  • Use MDPE.15 to carry out or investigate a selected local change.
  • Use C.36 or the relevant domain method to establish cultural recognition, transmission, retention or loss.

MDPE.7:0.1 - What counts as a choice of work

TermWhat to establish
next development WorkThe bounded activity proposed for this choice, its intended result, the capability and conditions it needs and any identified performer. Use U.Work for an actual performance when its occurrence matters.
developmentThe particular change sought in material, method, capability, configuration, evidence, repertoire, teaching, recognition arrangements, cultural understanding or continuation. It can be a repair, reduction or suspension.
DecisionSubjectThe agent that makes the bounded choice. Establish the basis of its authority separately and identify who could carry out any selected work when that matters.
practice-developing AgentWho performed the development work. Use E.10.ROLE when role wording is ambiguous, A.2.1 for an actual assignment of a specified kind, and F.6 for precise attribution of dated work under that assignment. For a claim about a dated work occurrence, establish the performer’s agency under A.13 and the work under A.15.1. Check ability, authority and permission where the claim relies on them.
authority and permissionIdentify who has authority for this choice and what permits the action for the specified subject and time. Use A.2.8.PER for permission or non-prohibition. A performer’s skill or an audience’s support can inform a recommendation while the decision belongs to a different holder.
ChoiceResultUnder C.11 the result may select an option, reject the set, select a further probe or identify another current question and its applicable method. Determine separately who authorized, committed, planned or carried out any work the choice occasioned.
recommendationAdvice about what to choose. Its author may have suitable expertise. To report an authorized decision, identify the actual choice and the holder’s decision right. An archive can support a narrower report when authority is unknown.
revisit conditionA change in evidence, configuration, capability, authority, cost, consequences for participants or intended use that would justify reconsidering a continuing choice.

Identify what the decision concerns, such as an account, material, method, capability, performing system, event arrangement or specific work. If the intended subject or deciding body changes, identify it at the new scope.

MDPE.7:1 - Problem Frame

Fluency reported by a performer, a cue read by a partner, a technical reading, applause, a competition result, a class performance and a surviving source can each be evidence about something different. Identify how each bears on this question.

A project may repeat its last successful activity, publish a promising result before learning whether it transfers, or abandon a branch that remains playable with another performer. A visible trend can displace local repertoire. Investigating an interesting lineage can consume the time needed to make a choice it would not change.

Connect the evidence that matters to the options, criteria and authority for the particular choice.

MDPE.7:2 - Problem

Common mistakes include the following.

  1. Treating the latest success, failure, measurement or opinion as a sufficient rule for selection.
  2. Gathering every framework result even when most would leave the choice unchanged.
  3. Giving the performer, human or robotic, the right to choose the project’s work merely because it performed.
  4. Reporting a technically well-founded recommendation as an authorized decision.
  5. Presenting the team’s choice of work as an already achieved change in what a population recognizes, selects or reproduces.

These mistakes can waste preparation time, prompt premature expansion or leave others unable to establish who chose the work and why.

MDPE.7:3 - Forces

Practical questionWhat matters
Evidence and timely actionFor a discretionary probe, compare what an attainable result could add to the decision with its cost, delay and displaced work. Include any qualification required for the intended use.
Local result vs wider horizonAn occurrence can guide a later trial. To establish transfer or retention, relate it to the earlier performance and the relevant change or interval. A trajectory concerns a series.
Creative exploration vs bounded commitmentCreative exploration can generate further possibilities. Compare the finite OptionSet available for the particular choice.
Expert judgementA qualified practitioner can recommend on limited evidence and decide when authorized. State the basis of the judgement, uncertainty and consequences, and identify what would affect continued reliance.
Performing and decidingA performer may operate autonomously while the decision about further development belongs to the project team, a service with delegated authority or another holder. Establish the local arrangement.
Coordinating the workResults from several methods can inform a choice. Use the ones that can make a material difference.
Local action and cultural developmentWork selected locally can change an event or available variant. Identify what it establishes at that scale and use population evidence if wider uptake or loss is at issue.

MDPE.7:4 - Solution

For a present choice, identify the finite options addressing one music or dance development question and the criteria for comparing them. The rule and options together determine which C.11 ChoiceResult the comparison supports. The authorized holder may make the choice. An analyst may report a supported earlier decision or give a recommendation, even when someone else has authority to choose. For a historical question, use the decision and other evidence of what was considered, under which conditions and with what outcome. An adequate record can finish that task. For intended work establish its own permission, capability and resources. Use A.22.CGUS when the branching or return structure itself needs to be selected, recorded or compared.

MDPE.7:4.1 - Name the chooser, subject, and decision extent

Identify what the claim about the choice requires.

  • Identify the DecisionSubject. In a formal comparison, DecisionSubjectGranularity identifies the unit making the choice, such as a solo performer or an ensemble deciding together. State separately which decisions its mandate covers.
  • Who performed or would perform the development work, and any assignment needed for its attribution.
  • The music or dance practice and its configuration at the time in question.
  • The intended consequence and affected participants or systems.
  • The horizon and resource limits for the choice.
  • Relevant authority, permission, consent, safety and ways to decline, or material uncertainty about them.

Identify a role or assignment when the attribution depends on it. A dancer may speak for a pair, a bandleader for an ensemble or a service for its users where the arrangements give that authority. Use the basis for the particular scope before attributing a wider decision to a teacher, founder, robot, platform or majority.

MDPE.7:4.2 - Identify evidence that matters to the comparison

Possible contributions include the following.

SourceWhat it can establish
MDPE.8 development focussubject, scope, affected Systems, or current question
MDPE.1 creation basisintended use, material, performer, style-bearing constraint, or creation decision
MDPE.9 candidate dispositionswhich material or performance branches remain feasible
MDPE.10 capability evidencewhich performer-involving Work is feasible or what development is needed
MDPE.3 performing configurationwhether constituents, interfaces, timing, space, sensing, or coordination support the option
MDPE.11 performed-result and MDPE.5 occurrence resultswhat was proposed, prescribed, performed or presented, and the conditions and evidence for each claim
MDPE.12 observationswhich technical, bodily, partner, audience, recognition, or cultural claims change the comparison
MDPE.13 recognition and selectionWhat an existing rule admitted, what a proposal would admit, any observed use and what a rule change would affect.
MDPE.6 change of useWhether material or a method works under changed conditions, how earlier use went and what reuse, revision, branching, testing or stopping would require.
MDPE.14 conflicts among resultsWhat conflict was established, its consequences, and what supports a selected change, preserving the tension, separate uses, another observation or rejection of the set, including who bears a shifted burden and what remains unresolved.
MDPE.15 local changeWhat changed or failed, what evidence supports the result and any later question that still matters.
MDPE.16 alternativesWhich branches were, are or could become available for this use, what remains uncertain, and what repair, testing or retention would require.
MDPE.17–MDPE.20Evidence about receiving performance, source and lineage, continuation, loss or possible development for the period and population concerned.

Use an adequate existing result directly. Seek a missing contribution when the answer depends on it and the work is justified. Otherwise state the limit or leave the immaterial question aside.

MDPE.7:4.3 - Identify the options for this decision

For a current decision, identify the proposals and assess whether the decision holder can select or test them under the actual conditions. Identify any requirement a proposal fails or any feasibility question that remains open. To examine an earlier choice, establish which options were then available or considered and which remain unknown. Typical work options include the following.

  • continue or vary creation Work;
  • investigate a specific uncertainty through performance, an existing observation or a feasible trial,
  • develop a named capability for representative Work;
  • reconfigure a performing whole, Method relation, interface, or event arrangement;
  • make one selected local change;
  • retain, repair, suspend, or remove a development alternative;
  • teach a method or arrange suitable receiving practice,
  • change the criteria or arrangements for recognition and selection,
  • repair a lineage or continuation account;
  • undertake bounded reconstruction, teaching, archival work or retirement when warranted by the available findings,
  • run one trajectory-discriminating probe;
  • perform or present one bounded Music-or-Dance occurrence under its direct Method;
  • make a chosen edition of a claim or other account available for a particular use through E.24.PUB,
  • stabilize an identified practice subject in a named configuration, or make that subject available for a named use under the applicable direct Method and relation.

For each proposed option, identify the work, intended result, required performing capability, any identified performer, material conditions, cost, affected participants or systems, and any needed stopping or rollback condition. Identify the method and support on which implementation depends where these change feasibility. A bounded inquiry can be an option if the work to answer it is specified. Keep options belonging to different choosers or different decisions in separate OptionSets. Rejecting a set and identifying another current question are comparison outcomes. A revisit condition specifies a circumstance for returning to the choice.

MDPE.7:4.4 - State the Music-or-Dance comparison basis

Compare the characteristics and consequences that mattered, or could matter, to the choice. Examples include

  • musical or movement value for the intended use;
  • performer, partner, ensemble, audience, or participant effects;
  • rhythmic, bodily, instrumental, spatial, interactive, or expressive constraints;
  • safety, consent, accessibility, injury, fatigue, and refusal;
  • capability, transfer, setup, venue, tool, latency, production, and resource demands;
  • source continuity, attribution, rights, repertoire loss, and alternative-space value;
  • recognition, participation, transmission, continuation, and cultural uncertainty; and
  • information value of the next feasible trial or observation.

Use A.19.CPM for a needed formal comparison. Preserve binding constraints, ties, incomparable results and relevant uncertainty. A score, applause count, publication count or institutional judgement can inform the criteria it actually addresses.

MDPE.7:4.5 - Apply or recover the rule for choosing

Use or recover the ChoiceRule for the particular comparison. Under C.11 it can support four results.

  • Choose now. Select one feasible option or the permitted set of tied options when further inquiry would not justify its cost.
  • Reject the current set. No option meets the requirements. Identify a different question if further work is wanted.
  • Probe again. A feasible observation could identify a different preferred option, establish which options meet the requirements or affect whether to reject the set. Its attainable contribution justifies the full burden.
  • Another question is current. Identify what must be resolved, such as generating candidates, planning, performing the work or establishing cultural continuation, and the method suited to that question.

Explain which musical or movement qualities, effects on participants, feasible alternatives, timescale, cultural uncertainty or resource limits mattered to the result. Give the substance and conditions of any practitioner judgement the comparison relies on.

MDPE.7:4.6 - Connect the choice to authority and intended Work

Distinguish the recommendation or choice from authority to make it and from the conditions for doing the work. Identify what the question requires.

  • The right to make the choice. Use the applicable rule, or A.6.RCD to identify a missing governing rule when one is needed.
  • Who undertook or could undertake the development and selected work, and what support was used or would be needed.
  • Permission or non-prohibition under A.2.8.PER for the relevant action, separately from decision authority and the ability to perform.
  • The work and result envisaged, and separate evidence for any actual occurrence.
  • A U.WorkPlan under A.15.2 when planning is required.
  • A tool or call plan under C.24 when that planning is needed.

Some conditions may already have been met before the choice. A valid choice can also leave necessary permission or provision outstanding.

A practitioner commissioned to advise can supply a recommendation and its grounds. An authorized holder decides. If authority for a required decision is missing, identify that limit and any condition that would resolve it. If the decision is established but performance lacks permission, resources or capability, report the choice and the separate obstacle to doing the work. For a past episode, use the evidence for the relations the question concerns at that date.

MDPE.7:4.7 - Identify reasons to revisit, stop or reverse a choice

For a continuing choice identify applicable reasons to reconsider it, such as

  • the intended performer or pair cannot carry out the work under the selected conditions,
  • safety, consent, accessibility, effort, partner readability, musical plausibility, or another must-constraint fails;
  • a changed configuration makes earlier evidence inapplicable to this use,
  • a retained alternative becomes feasible or a source or other material needed for a selected alternative becomes unavailable;
  • the receiving population or event conditions change;
  • a feasible and worthwhile observation could now change the result,
  • authority, permission, capability, or resources change; or
  • the question crosses from local project Work to transmission, retention, loss, or trajectory inquiry.

Specify a safe stop or rollback when the selected work could harm a performer, material, repertoire, event or relationship.

MDPE.7:4.8 - State the finding, recommendation or decision

Report the answer and the grounds and conditions the reader needs. Use the following entries where relevant. For selected work, distinguish what was intended from anything known to have been carried out.

Question about further music or dance work:
  what is known about the deciding agent and its authority for the choice:
  practice subject, configuration, use, and affected Systems:
  options at the time of the choice:
  source findings, relevant conditions and limits:
  comparison basis and domain ChoiceRule:
  finding, recommendation or ChoiceResult and its grounds:
  another current question and applicable Method, when needed:
  authority, permission, consent, and refusal boundary:
  who performed or would carry out the selected work:
  intended bounded Work and result:
  protected characteristics and retained alternatives:
  resource, capability, safety, and evidence limits:
  applicable revisit, stop, rollback or retry conditions:

If the result selects a further probe, specify the work and its conditions. If another question is current, identify that question and an appropriate source or method. The decision to investigate and the resulting observation remain separately identifiable.

MDPE.7:4.9 - What Changes in Practice

A practitioner can explain which options mattered, how they were compared, what was recommended or chosen and what is known about the participants, their grounds and their authority. For selected work, state its feasibility and intended contribution. An earlier report can also establish what was implemented or leave that result open.

MDPE.7:5 - Worked Cases and Boundaries

MDPE.7:5.1 - Music arrangement: presentation or another rehearsal

Suppose a score was revised to restore an antiphonal response. Suppose also that a rehearsal of the revision, assessed as in MDPE.15, supports improved clarity while one articulation judgement remains uncertain. The production team has authority for this choice. Ensemble performers may supply observations or recommendations.

The team can present under the tested conditions, rehearse with the intended room and singer, revise articulation first, or retain the acoustic branch while suspending the electronic one. It can reject the set for this concert if every option fails a necessary condition. Choose another rehearsal when it is feasible, its result could change the assessment of safety or musical plausibility and the expected benefit justifies performer time, cost, delay and displaced work. Otherwise use the supported option or report the outstanding limit.

The rehearsal needs its own available time, venue permission and any required plan. Use existing arrangements where they cover the work.

In the constructed social-dance and live-music application, the organizers select an unfamiliar-partner trial, keep the current event block for one month and defer buying the larger festival slot. The record establishes that decision; observations from the future trial will have their own grounds.

MDPE.7:5.2 - Social dance: decide what a trial with one pair supports

Two dancers perform one Urban Kiz phrase fluently together. In the trial, partner readability declines under the reported faster-tempo and denser-floor conditions. The result establishes what happened to this pair under these conditions. A general class or party involves other partners and conditions.

The teacher or school can compare a varied-partner trial, a cue repair at a slower tempo, an advanced branch and a teaching format for lower floor density. It can reject all proposed options for the crowded floor if none meets the requirement. Identify the dancers’ contribution, venue and relevant practitioner population. Use System for a community or arrangement only when its organization warrants that kind. Select another partner trial when it is feasible and its expected effect on the choice justifies time, effort and displaced practice.

The observations and decision conditions are stipulated for this example.

MDPE.7:5.3 - Movement generation: compare another use, repair the tool or prepare a release

Chédin and colleagues report Dancer-Y’s high-, medium- and low-fidelity comparison. His uses for different outputs can motivate another project’s comparison, while leaving broader dancer preferences open. MDPE.9:4.1 shows how to adapt it when needed. Identify any locally selected branches, their intended uses and the evidence of availability.

To select a dancer trial that uses the branch now, establish access to its output, a capable and permitted performer and whichever model, interface and configuration the named use requires. If a condition is missing, a feasible repair or reconstruction can itself be selected. Compare its required material, rights, skills, costs and expected result. A surviving description can support a proposal without establishing the branch’s present usability. Reject the set if none of the available options meets the requirements.

The project team or other holder decides within its established authority. Making a release available, transmission and cultural recognition each need grounds from the relevant work. A model score that would leave the performer-facing comparison unchanged need not delay the choice.

MDPE.7:5.4 - Shimon: the team chooses a configured trial; the robot performs it

After a changing-tempo Shimon trial, the human project team can compare adjusting gesture timing, changing sensing, accepting a bounded synchronization loss, obtaining another observer’s result or retiring the branch with the necessary documentation and configuration work. Shimon can perform music autonomously in the demonstrated configuration. Identify the basis and scope of the human team’s authority for the particular project decision.

For a selected trial, identify the robot configuration, tempo, observer’s task, musical criteria, noise and gesture limits, authority and stop condition. Use a speed result from another configuration when its applicability to this comparison is established. Adoption elsewhere and a robot’s development authority have separate grounds.

MDPE.7:5.5 - Cultural continuation and a local decision

Across occasions at their event, organizers observe a social-dance variant less often than before. They consider declaring it lost or launching a restoration programme. Their records establish a change in appearances at that event. A claim of population loss needs evidence from that population. A local restoration proposal can identify the work, providers and authority it would require.

If the question is whether the practice continued, use an adequate finding or investigate the relevant population through MDPE.19. If the decision concerns this event, the organizers can recommend or choose to continue or retire their local arrangement within their authority. A further test, observation of a receiver or local experiment is a separate option whose expected contribution must justify its full burden and be feasible. A broader restoration needs the parties, resources and authority that work depends on. Establish wider adoption from what actually happens.

MDPE.7:5.6 - Constructed choice: a useful available trial costs too much for this use

An eight-player ensemble must choose a five-minute item for one concert. Its familiar arrangement A is already playable under the booked conditions. Arrangement B could offer a more responsive antiphonal exchange, but whether the new allocation preserves clarity with this ensemble remains uncertain. The director can use the last ninety-minute rehearsal either for a full-programme run with A or for learning and comparing B. The players, director, room and permissions are available for either use; the comparison is feasible, and success could change the selected item.

The director chooses A. Eight players for ninety minutes would spend twelve player-hours testing B. The director would spend another ninety minutes, and the full-programme run would be displaced. For one optional five-minute item, the director values the coordinated transitions in the full run above the possible improvement. B remains a candidate. The evidence leaves B’s clarity in this ensemble and the result of a further trial open.

Twenty later concert bookings could make the same learning and trial cost worthwhile. Reconsider with actual bookings, available performers and preparation time. More concerts change the potential benefit of the trial. They do not establish B’s quality or the director’s spending authority.

MDPE.7:5.7 - Direct-decision and live-branch stops

Use an existing decision or a suitable direct artistic, rehearsal, teaching, event, curation, operations, strategy or engineering method when it supplies the needed result. Use A.15.7 when conditions change the next action within ongoing work under an identified method.

MDPE.7:6 - Bias Annotation

Bias riskLikely distortionRepair
RecencyApplause, a failed attempt or the latest score settles the comparison without a reason.Compare the material options under the relevant conditions and criteria.
Scale-up biasA local success triggers publication, standardization, teaching, or cultural intervention.Ask what the local evidence supports and which later relation is still missing.
Stage and ballet biasDevelopment is assumed to mean concert, ballet or festival production.Identify the setting and use at issue. It may, for example, be social, improvised, instructional, online or robotic.
Human-only biasOne person is assumed to perform, decide, develop, observe and bear the consequences.Identify the actual performers, decision holder, observers, support and affected parties. A robot, service, ensemble or equipped person can have a specific role. Use an assignment when attribution depends on it.
Founder or expert authorityArtistic contribution or skill is treated as authority to decide.Establish the actual decision right and identify who gave advice. Permission to implement concerns a separate action.
Institutional-source biasAttention from a university, the press, platform, contest or archive is treated as evidence of all practice value.Identify what the source actually establishes and use appropriate evidence or qualified expert judgement for the intended use.
Cultural controlA project decision is reported as binding an entire practitioner population.Identify the holder’s authority and use evidence of wider reception and practice when that is the claim.
Analysis biasEvery missing result triggers another study.Probe only when an obtainable observation can change the choice and its contribution warrants cost, delay and displaced work.

MDPE.7:7 - Conformance Checklist

QuestionWhat the result makes clear
CC-MDPE7-01 — ChoiceThe particular development question, time and scope of the recommendation, decision or historical inquiry.
CC-MDPE7-02 — Chooser identityDecisionSubject, granularity, practice-developing Agent, later Work performer, and affected Systems are separated where needed.
CC-MDPE7-03 — Bounded OptionSetThe options considered for the same question, including which were feasible, could be investigated, failed a requirement or remained uncertain.
CC-MDPE7-04 — Relevant evidenceThe grounds used, the subjects and conditions they cover and how they bear on the comparison.
CC-MDPE7-05 — Domain ChoiceRuleThe rule exposes Music-or-Dance characteristics, must-constraints, affected Systems, uncertainty, probe value, and alternative loss that matter.
CC-MDPE7-06 — ChoiceResultWhere a choice is reported, what the evidence establishes about its outcome and grounds, including selecting an option, rejecting the set, selecting a further probe or identifying a different question.
CC-MDPE7-07 — Authority separationChoice, recommendation, authority, permission, consent, commitment, planning, and Work remain distinct.
CC-MDPE7-08 — Intended workFor a selected activity, identify its intended result and the performer, method and conditions it requires, including anything still to be arranged. Use evidence of actual work for any claim that it occurred.
CC-MDPE7-09 — Cultural boundaryClaims about transmission, recognition, selection, retention, spread or loss use evidence at the stated scale.
CC-MDPE7-10 — Probe disciplineFor a proposed optional probe, its result is obtainable and could improve the decision enough to justify its full burden. A past inquiry can be reported and evaluated on the grounds then available.
CC-MDPE7-12 — Practical returnThe reader can recover the recommendation, authorized decision, earlier choice or limit that answers the question, and any conditions for acting or revisiting it.

MDPE.7:8 - Common Failures and Repairs

FailureWhy it failsRepair
“The last performance went well, so scale it.”A local success shows what happened in the tested setting.Compare the benefits, feasibility, costs and effects of the actual alternatives for the wider use.
“Run every pattern before deciding.”Other work may add expense without changing the comparison.Use the sources and methods needed for the actual question.
“The artist decides.”The creator, performer, developer and holder of authority may differ.Establish who decided or can decide and the scope of that authority. Identify who performed when attributing work. Identify an assignment where the attribution depends on it.
“The robot chose its next development.”Autonomous performance establishes the robot’s action within that task.Identify the actual chooser and grounds for any claimed development authority.
“The community wants this.”The statement leaves the relevant members, representation and grounds unclear.Establish whose views or decisions the available evidence represents. Use an appropriate inquiry for a remaining question that warrants it.
“More data would help.”A useful observation may still cost more than it contributes.Compare the expected effect on the choice with full effort, delay and displaced activity. Use the best supported decision or limit when further inquiry is unwarranted.
“The decision is the plan.”Selecting, committing, planning and performing are distinct activities.Give the established choice. If implementation requires a plan, use the appropriate planning method.
“Next means the next lifecycle stage.”Work can recur, overlap or stop.Relate the choice to the particular holder, question, period and conditions.

MDPE.7:9 - Consequences

A practitioner can relate different types of evidence to a bounded choice and distinguish a performer’s skill, a recommendation, the holder’s decision and subsequent work. A qualified estimate can support a choice where its grounds and limits are known.

The comparison takes time, and a missing right, capability, safe option or observation can limit what can be decided. Exclude questions whose answers would not affect the comparison. A record may establish a former choice even when its implementation conditions no longer hold.

MDPE.7:10 - Rationale

Composition, rehearsal, teaching, event operation, archival work and investigation can overlap, recur or stop under different responsibilities. Compare the next activities for the particular practice and situation. For a past decision, identify the options and conditions that the evidence establishes, to the extent the question requires.

A music or dance decision may depend on a body, instrument, partner, ensemble, rhythm, performance, event, repertoire or stylistic distinction that changes the value, information or harm of the options. Use the general choice procedure in C.11 with those domain criteria.

MDPE.7:11 - SoTA and Source Use

SourceContributionConditions for use
FPF C.11, A.19.CPM, A.15.7, A.15.2, C.24, A.2.8, A.2.8.PER, E.10.ROLE, A.2.1, F.6, A.6.RCD, A.10 and C.36Compare options, choose an action within ongoing work, plan work or tool calls, establish obligation or permission, clarify roles and actual assignments, attribute performed work and trace evidence or cultural relations.Use the applicable rule for decision authority. Use A.6.RCD to identify a missing governing relation. Identify the domain options and what makes a music or dance choice worthwhile.
MDPE methods in §4.2Evidence about creation, candidates, capability, configuration, enactment, performance, reuse, conflicts, changes, alternatives, transmission, lineage, continuation and possible developments.Use a result where its subject, conditions or limits matter to the current or historical comparison.
Chédin et al., co-designing movement-generation models with Voguing and Dancehall dancersPractitioner co-design, model and interface variants, and Dancer-Y’s comparison of their uses in the final study.Use local grounds for a new dancer’s performance, a project release decision or claims about wider adoption.
Timing examples in the Dance profile and local Balboa casesPartner-readable timing, continuous movement, articulation, perceived centers and ways to test a movement under changed conditions.Use the cases for design. Actual capability, decision authority and a teaching sequence need their own grounds.
Shimon project sources in MDPE.14Configuration-specific robotic performances, the human team’s development work and distinct measures of gesture, attention, noise and musical timing.Establish the decision holder and appropriate criteria for a new robot development, and use independent grounds for transfer to dance or wider continuation.

Statements drawn from mutable web sources refer to 26 August 2026. Reconsider a continuing choice when a relied-on source, configuration, result, option, authority or intended use changes. The dated record may still establish the grounds of the earlier choice.

MDPE.7:12 - Relations

  • Use C.11 for the bounded ChoiceResult and A.19.CPM for a needed formal comparison. Establish authority, commitment, planning and execution where the claim concerns them.
  • Use A.15.7 to select the next action within an identified method when new facts change an ongoing branch.
  • MDPE.12, MDPE.15, MDPE.16 and MDPE.20 may supply observations, local-change results, available alternatives or forecasts, respectively.
  • Use MDPE.15 when a change, failure, direct output or trial observation bears on the choice.
  • Use MDPE.16 when availability, the value of a stepping stone, a repair or grounds for removal affect the options or their comparison.
  • Use MDPE.15 to carry out a feasible selected change or examine what happened to a previously selected change, including an unsuccessful attempt. Identify who decided and who could implement it, with relevant assignment, permission, capability and resources. For a claim about actual implementation, use its performance evidence.
  • Use A.2.8 for obligations and prohibitions, A.2.8.PER for permission and non-prohibition, E.10.ROLE for ambiguous role language, A.2.1 for a real assignment of a specified kind and F.6 for attribution of dated work under it. Use the governing rule for the decision right or A.6.RCD for a needed but missing rule. A recommendation may use the same comparison. To establish an authorized decision, identify the actual choice and the authority to make it.
  • Use A.15.2 for a needed work plan, C.24 for tools or calls and A.15.1 for the occurrence of subsequent work.
  • Use C.36 and MDPE.17–MDPE.20 for questions about reception or cultural development. For project work, establish the limits of the decision holder’s authority.

MDPE.7:End

Referenced in the corpus

14 literal mentions in other sections. Read their context to establish the relation.