The Twelfth Annual Buster Keaton Blogathon

Featured

Greetings and good morning, everyone, and welcome to the return of Silent-ology’s longest running tradition:

Sharing the love of this great comedian and consummate filmmaker is one of my favorite things, so I’m delighted to not only be hosting this Buster celebration for well over a decade now, but also to be giving a special nod to The General‘s 100th anniversary. While bloggers are welcome to write about any Buster-related topic they choose, this year I’m especially welcoming any and all posts related to this great classic film.

Bloggers: Please send me the link to your post whenever it’s ready today or tomorrow! (Last minute signups are also welcome!) As a “thank you” for your participation I’ll be holding a drawing for all participants on Wednesday, April 15. The winner will be receiving a copy of the excellent new book The Silent Film Universe by Ben Model–it needs to be a part of your home library!

Readers: Please drop by often to see the latest posts and feel free to leave comments! We bloggers love comments the way Buster loved trains–very, very much!

If you’re curious as to what past blogathons were like, here are all the links to the mighty Busterthon Library: the FirstSecond, Third, FourthFifthSixthSeventh,  EighthNinthTenth and Eleventh Annual Buster Blogathon!

The Roster:

Silent-ology | Rare photos from behind the scenes of The General, and

Silent-ology | “The Great Locomotive Crash: How Keaton Filmed The General‘s Most Famous Scene”

Welcome To My Magick Theatre | “The General At 100, And Why It Still Matters”

The Thoughts of One Truly Loved | “Why Buster Loved Trains”

Dakota Albertoni | The Railrodder (1965)

Special Purpose Movie Blog | Review of the book Camera Man by Dana Stevens

Nitrateglow | Marion Mack and The General

leonelvidaurresoto | “Sherlock Jr. and How Cinema Changes Lives”

The Everyday Cinephile | Review of The Silent Clowns by Walter Kerr

Three Enchanting Ladies | “Paris Pursuit: Audrey Hepburn, Buster Keaton and Richard Avedon for Harper’s Bazaar

Whimsically Classic | Attending a showing of The General at the Hollywood Theatre

A Big Thanks To My Fellow Film Bloggers!

As the 12th Buster Keaton blogathon comes to a close (although I’m still reading through your excellent posts, as I’m sure many people are!), allow me and “summer of 1926 Buster Keaton looking completely and totally in his element” say:

I love any and all Buster-related topics, but it sure was fun having all the nods to The General during it’s 100th anniversary. Many thanks to all the bloggers for committing their time and skills to help celebrate that milestone here on Silent-ology! The summer of 1926 was very special for Buster (not to mention the excited residents of Cottage Grove) and I dare say we’re helping to keep a bit of that long-ago spirit alive.

It wouldn’t be a Silent-ology Busterthon without thanking the participants with a “draw a name” style giveaway, so I shall grab my 1920s cloche hat accordingly! One lucky participant gets a copy of Ben Model’s excellent new book The Silent Film Universe, which I highly recommend.

And here we go!

The winner is:

Congratulations to Therese of The Thoughts of One Truly Loved! We will be in touch. And thanks again to everyone who participated in this fine annual tradition!

The Great Locomotive Crash: How Keaton Filmed “The General’s” Most Famous Scene

Day 2 of the 12th Annual Busterthon is in full swing, be sure to check out any new posts! This is my new post for the event; hope you enjoy!

It was the single the most expensive shot in a 1920s film–the mighty train crash in Buster Keaton’s Civil War comedy The General (1926). The climax of a lengthy chase that takes up the majority of the film, it was not only a stunning shot but was a real nail-biter to capture on film.

Anyone acquainted with Buster Keaton’s career is aware of the supposed backstory: a huge crowd of onlookers gathered to watch the filming, not sure exactly what they were going to witness. When the train crashed through the bridge, it was a genuine shock–some women even fainted when the head of a dummy (a stand-in for the engineer) floated by.

This isn’t quite what happened. In reality, onlookers absolutely knew a train stunt was going to happen, hence why the location drew such big crowds. But it was indeed an exciting event that took a ton of planning, a lot of set up on the fateful day itself and more than a little bit of good luck.

Continue reading

Repost: Behind The Scenes Of “The General” (1926)

This is post 1 of 2 that I’m contributing to the Twelfth Annual Buster Keaton Blogathon. I hope you get as much of a kick out of these exciting finds as I did!

The General (1927) - Turner Classic Movies

One of the best-loved films from the 1920s is certainly Buster Keaton’s masterwork The General (1926). Fans are very familiar with the stories behind it–how it was filmed up in sleepy little Cottage Grove, Oregon, how the risky train stunts were pulled off, how the famous train crash into the river was orchestrated, and so on.

While researching an upcoming column on The General for Classic Movie Hub (a slight plug, but it is relevant), I had the happy opportunity to look through some behind-the-scenes photos. I knew a bunch were in circulation, but the more I searched the more kept popping up. There were even a few I swear I hadn’t seen before, chilling on Pinterest as if they were just any other photos or something. Many were on my friend Sara Zittel’s board–credit where credit is due!

A sneak preview (isn’t this cool?).

So I thought we’d look at a few of them today, to get a fuller picture of what it was like to film The General back in that summer of 1926. It was a much more public event than we might realize!

Continue reading

Thoughts On “The Wind” (1928)

Happy weekend, everyone! The 12th Annual Buster Keaton Blogathon is less than a week away, and fellow bloggers are still welcome to sign up. In the meantime, please enjoy this piece on a film that we’re all waiting to be available on a fine Blu-ray/DVD set with a beautiful restoration…we can dream!


“I found a book by Dorothy Scarborough called The Wind, which excited my imagination,” Lillian Gish wrote in her 1969 autobiography. “Its main character is a wind which constantly blows sand, indoors and out, and finally drives the heroine to madness.” It was an unique choice of story, even considering the “man vs. nature” motif baked into our collective consciousness. The Wind would include this motif on a deeply intimate scale, and so skillfully that it’s difficult to discern where the psychology ends and the harshness of nature begins.

Continue reading

Repost: Thoughts On “The White Sister” (1923)

Greetings on this Good Friday and a happy early Easter! In keeping with this spiritual time of the year I’m reposting my review of Lillian Gish’s The White Sister, a film that in many respects suited her to a “t.”

Stay tuned for my next post, a review of another great Gish classic The Wind (1928), and keep in mind that the 12th annual Buster Keaton Blogathon is just around the corner. (Fellow bloggers, feel free to sign up to participate!)

Here’s the link to the post below. Enjoy, and have a fine weekend!

Updates And A Hearty Welcome To New Readers!

It’s been a long time since I’ve done one of these posts! Being that blustery time of the year when spring is just starting to seem like a possibility (at least where I live), in the spirit of the shifting seasons it it feels like a good time to share what Silent-ology’s been up to and what’s coming up next.

By “blustery” I mean it’s basically been this.

Recently I returned from attending the 29th Kansas Silent Film Festival with special guest Melissa Talmadge Cox–Buster Keaton’s granddaughter! It was a lovely event as usual with impeccable accompaniment by the likes of Ben Model and Jeff Rapsis, and the weather was excellent too (70 degrees in Kansas in February–my Minnesota self had a bit of mental whiplash!). The showing of The Wind (1928)–on film!–was a major highlight for me. Plus, if I might add another plug for the event, the whole thing was free–as always.

I’m in this picture!! (Towards the back…you’ll have to take my word for it.)

If you’re a regular reader you might recall that last year I mentioned wanting to do a book compilation of some of my Silent-ology posts. The real-but-maybe-not-100%-permanent-who-knows-really nature of the World Wide Web does make me wary. I’ve since put together a draft of what this book could be, choosing the articles/essays that would work best for various sections and revising them (some Internet-style writing simply doesn’t work in the context of a book). For a section on silent era personalities, for instance, my Clara Bow, Rudolph Valentino and Wallace Reid pieces would be included. I’d like to add a few brand-new essays too.

Other regular readers will recall my interest in the life and career of comedienne Louise Fazenda, a popular and reliable slapstick performer in her day who’s wildly overlooked nowadays. My latest work on Louise is the article “Louise Fazenda: The Forgotten Queen of Slapstick” for the latest issue of Comique: The Classic Comedy Magazine, Issue 3–available to read for free right here. Feel free to check it out!

And now for any new readers–hello and welcome! Silent-ology is my personal “dig” through silent film history, a dig that’s lasted over twelve years now. I cover a bit of everything from silent comedy to Soviet avant-garde to the history of stop-motion animation–whatever piques my interest, which is basically everything to do with this fascinating era of film. My “About” page is a nice little intro to the site, as well as the My Articles page. (Rumor has it that the page, err, really needs to be updated–but never underestimate the power of the Search box.) I host a Buster Keaton Blogathon every year and do the occasional theme month where I deep-dive into a film topic or personality (Mary Pickford Month, for instance).

My writing shows up elsewhere, too–I’ve written for organizations like the San Francisco Silent Film Festival and the Library of Congress, and have a monthly column at Classic Movie Hub. I also contributed to the book CHASE! A Tribute to the Keystone Cops. It’s a growing portfolio, I’m proud to say!

Basically me.

Not sure where to start on Silent-ology? If you’re looking to read about some specific films, here’s an eclectic collection for you:

There’s an awful lot of personalities to read about, too. How about getting acquainted with the following?

I also do book reviews, such as my recent piece on Ben Model’s The Silent Film Universe, and occasionally share commentary on current events such as the Great Fiasco of the 2022 Sight & Sound list, and why modern Hollywood could learn a thing or two from Mary Pickford. And now and then I dig up quirky items from very old film magazines that seem quite baffling out of context.

As demonstrated.

So yes, there’s a little something for everyone on Silent-ology! So settle in, do some browsing, and feel free to share your thoughts–the comment sections are always open!

ANNOUNCING: The 12th Annual Buster Keaton Blogathon!

2026 is a special year for Buster Keaton fans, because we finally get to celebrate the 100th anniversary of one of the all-time greatest comedy films–The General (1926)! Filmed in Cottage Grove, Oregon in the summer of 1926, and released during the winter of 1926-1927, it did respectable business (better than you may have heard) and grew in stature in the subsequent decades. (Trivia: it was released in Tokyo on December 31, 1926 but not put into wide release until February and March of 1927.) Today, it’s widely considered one of the greatest films ever made.

So this year, let’s help celebrate that long-ago summer of The General as we kick off the 12th annual Busterthon! Please read the below details carefully, important info incoming.

When: Monday, April 13 and Tuesday, April 14 2026.

Where: Right here on Silent-ology!

What to write about: Feel free to cover whichever Buster films and Buster-related topics you like (his filmography might give you some ideas). This year, I especially welcome anything concerning The General. You could cover the film’s production in Cottage Grove, do a profile on one of the actors he worked with, review the film itself, share fan artwork…anything and everything that interests you about this great classic!

The Details:

  • If you want to join this blogathon, simply leave a comment on this post to let me know which Buster film or topic you’re going to cover. (You can also send me a message.) It doesn’t have to be about The General, but the topic is encouraged.
  • Please help spread the word about the event by adding one of my banners to your blog!
  • During the blogathon itself, when you publish your post please leave me a comment with the link to it. You can also send me a message. Publish whenever you have time during April 13th and 14th, no pressure!
  • Please don’t forget to mention Silent-ology and the name of the blogathon in your post–it really helps publicize the event!
  • If you publish your post before the 13th, just give me a head’s up and your link will be one of the first ones up during the blogathon!
  • Duplicate topics are 100% allowed! Since everyone has a different perspective, 2-3 posts on the same film–especially The General–are welcome.

And lastly, and very importantly, although it’s sure bizarre that it’s gotten to this point:

Absolutely no AI writing or AI photos are allowed. This is your writing, your thoughts, your efforts. And The General is already a beautiful film with excellent stills to choose from. The siren call of AI is something we’re resisting here on Silent-ology. Be like Buster, who took pride in doing things “for real”!

If you’re ever attempted to “write” using AI, just picture Buster’s face looking at you in this still.
Burn it into your brain!

I will be hosting a drawing for all blogathon participants after the event as my personal “thank you” to everyone who joined. The prize will be announced closer to the event dates.

And as always: Make Buster Proud! There’s a lot of dubious information out there about his life and career, so let’s try and steer clear of those myths and rumors as best we can. So far blogathon participants have fantastic about this–let’s keep it up!

For ideas and inspiration, here’s all the links to the Busterthon Library: the FirstSecond, Third, FourthFifthSixthSeventh,  EighthNinthTenth and Eleventh Annual Buster BlogathonsMy my, what a library!

Banners:

The Roster:

Silent-ology | The story behind The General‘s greatest train stunt, and

A repost of photos from behind the scenes of The General

Whimsically Classic | Piece on a Portland theater showing of The General

Welcome To My Magick Theatre | Essay on why The General still matters 100 years later

The Everyday Cinephile | Walter Kerr’s book The Silent Clowns

Three Enchanting Ladies | Audrey Hepburn and Buster Keaton’s 1959 photo shoot for Harper’s Bazaar

Nitrateglow | Marion Mack and her performance in The General

In Memory Of John Bengtson

This past weekend I saw the sad news about historian John Bengtson, who passed away recently from ALS. Ever since his diagnosis we all knew this day was going to come, but it’s heartbreaking news nonetheless.

John was an incredible historian, and a unique one at that. He specialized in discovering the precise filming locations of many scenes in our most beloved silent films, pinpointing them by analyzing landmarks, surviving buildings, and so on in the backgrounds. His eye for detail was second to none, and it resulted not only in the wonderful website Silent Locations (please give it a visit!) but three excellent books: Silent Echoes: Discovering Early Hollywood Through the Films of Buster Keaton, Silent Traces: Discovering Early Hollywood Through the Films of Charlie Chaplin, and Silent Visions: Discovering Early Hollywood and New York Through the Films of Harold Lloyd.

How many fans of our great silent filmmakers were able to make pilgrimages to these sites, thanks to John? When I first started visiting Hollywood, I took the Silent Echoes book along with me so I could visit a lot of the locations he found. It brought that long-gone era to life for me like nothing else. I walked down the alley Buster Keaton ran down 100 years ago, saw buildings that were recognizable in the background of Harold Lloyd comedies, saw the same hillsides and vistas captured by filmmakers generations before they’d be covered in houses and carved up by freeways.

My 2015 pic of the Chaplin Keaton Lloyd Alley, now a historic landmark thanks to John.

John was also such a kind and supportive friend, someone who would go above and beyond whenever he could. He was happy to share and discuss new film location info as he was discovering it, and he was always very appreciative of my Silent-ology posts (and took part in the annual Buster blogathon a number of times). I’ll always be immensely touched by the fact that shortly before I left to attend the Pordenone film festival for the first time this past October, he sent an email to several other attendees to let them know I was coming and to make me feel welcome. I’m not sure how he did it at that point, perhaps his daughters helped him write it. How incredibly thoughtful–and that’s the sort of thing he did for so many people, as many of you know.

^ Why am I posting this picture of me and Kevin Brownlow, you ask? Because without John I never would’ve gotten it! This was taken back in 2018 at the San Francisco Silent Film Festival. The festival had just ended that Sunday night, and I was outside the theater chatting with friends under the marquee. I had seen Brownlow several times throughout the festival, but couldn’t ever work up the nerve to just go up to him and say hello (being, y’know, the preeminent silent film historian of all time and all). Well, that Sunday evening, John suddenly poked his head out the theater doors and said, “Lea, do you want to meet Kevin?” Err, yes please! How did he know? He brought me up to the mezzanine and I got to meet Kevin at last–and he took the above picture of us without me even having to ask (indeed, I was too starry-eyed to even think of such details!). I will never forget this, either. What a moment, and what great guy John Bengtson was.

It’s hard to know what else to say, but I do want to end this too-brief tribute by sharing one more thing. This is John’s favorite cake recipe which he shared with quite a few people. I’ve made it many times and can confirm that it’s so good that I usually just add the chocolate chips like John did and skip the frosting. Here it is in his own words. Please save it and enjoy it in his memory!

“A rich moist chocolate cake with a chocolate buttercream icing. This is the best cake in the
world!”

Ingredients

 2 cups white sugar I use less – 1 1/3 cups
 1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
 3/4 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
 1 1/2 teaspoons baking soda
 1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
 1 teaspoon salt
 2 eggs
 1 cup milk
 1/2 cup vegetable oil I use less – 3/8 cups
 2 teaspoons vanilla extract I use less – 1 1/2 teaspoons
 1 cup boiling water

Frosting – I sprinkle 1/3 of a package of chocolate chips on top instead

 3/4 cup butter
 1 1/2 cups unsweetened cocoa powder
 5 1/3 cups confectioners’ sugar
 2/3 cup milk
 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Directions

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F (175 degrees C). Grease and flour two 9 inch cake pans. (I
    use a single 9 x 13 pan and bake for 35 minutes. The original recipe seemed too
    sweet, oily, and vanilla-y, hence the changes.)
  2. Use the first set of ingredients to make the cake. In a medium bowl, stir together the
    sugar, flour, cocoa, baking soda, baking powder and salt. Add the eggs, milk, oil and
    vanilla, mix for 3 minutes with an electric mixer. Stir in the boiling water by hand. Pour
    evenly into the two prepared pans.
  3. Bake for 30 to 35 minutes in the preheated oven, until a toothpick inserted comes out
    clean. Cool for 10 minutes before removing from pans to cool completely.
  4. To make the frosting, use the second set of ingredients. Cream butter until light and
    fluffy. Stir in the cocoa and confectioners’ sugar alternately with the milk and vanilla.
    Beat to a spreading consistency.
  5. Split the layers of cooled cake horizontally, cover the top of each layer with frosting, then
    stack them onto a serving plate. Frost the outside of the cake.

Exploring Max Linder Films–Where To Begin?

January! For many of us it’s the most bone-chilling, gray and lengthy time of the year. Not that I’m complaining, believe it or not. Living in a northern state as I do (I sure wish you could experience Minnesota the way I always have), I’m head over heels for all four of the seasons, even the one with the longest and darkest of nights. There’s no better time to catch up on reading, little projects around the house, and…silent movie watching. (Obviously.)

Might I suggest, for example, exploring the work of the great French comedian Max Linder? If there’s only one thing you need to know about Linder’s significance in film history, it’s that none other than Charlie Chaplin himself referred to him as “the professor.” The diminutive, genial, slightly manic-eyed Frenchman in a silk hat was not only the world’s first major screen comedian, well over a hundred years ago, but he was arguably the very first film star–years before the star system was even in place.

Chaplin and Linder clowning together while finally meeting in person.

There’s dozens and dozens of Linder films, some more readily available than others, and most running about ten minutes or less. These had clean, simple premises such as “Max teaches the tango” or “Max tries to outsmart a romantic rival,” all cranked out quickly and efficiently. As Linder himself described: “We work from nine in ze morning to four in ze afternoon, and zen–she was fineesh!” Where, you might wonder, should you begin with such a lengthy filmography? Here’s a few suggestions:

6. Max Learns to Skate (Débuts d’un patineur, 1907)

This is an easy choice–none other than the little film that introduced Linder to the world as a screen comedian! Its simple premise is a nice little intro to his style of comedy. As the title implies, Max goes ice skating for the first time and naturally, his enthusiasm about the experience quickly turns sour. Doubtless you can fill in the blanks!

Max Learns to Skate also contains an interesting look at a 1900s French skating rink, where apparently you would check your coat (you being quite warm enough in your customary underthings, shirt, and suit) and someone would assist you in getting on your skates. It’s all quite civilized, I must say.

5. Troubles of a Grass Widower (Vive la vie de garcon, 1908)

After Max and his wife get into a quarrel, the wife storms out and goes home to mother. Initially elated to be on his own, Max soon finds out that his clumsy attempts at chores and cooking don’t measure up to his wife’s skills.

Many 1900s comedies tend to capture the action in long shots, but Grass Widower contains a nice example of the camera getting up close and personal as Max is attempting to cook a chicken dinner. Linder’s dexterity and expressive, yet restrained, performance might remind you of the many comedians who proceeded him–who were certainly inspired by films like this.

Note the scene where Max is trudging home from the market and tries to hide his parcels from a neighbor lady–apparently if the man of the house was seen buying groceries, it was a sure sign of domestic troubles! And do enjoy the charming interiors of Max’s home, quite elaborate for this simple short. Those lovely mouldings and wainscoting were brought to your eyes through the magic of trompe l’oeil painting.

4. Max Takes a Bath (Max prend un bain, 1910)

In this delightful little short Max is suffering from a nervous tick. The doctor recommends he treat it by taking a cold bath everyday, so Max eagerly buys a bathtub, his apartment apparently not being equipped with one. I must say, a beautifully-decorated antique tub like that would command a pretty penny nowadays!

Owning a tub is more of a headache than he expected, however. Not only is it difficult to get home, but where is he going to fill it up? His breezy solutions inadvertently lead to chaos. I love this short, for both its cheery simplicity and for one very funny sequence of Max scuttling along with the tub on his back like a turtle shell. You won’t guess where he manages to go!

3. Max’s Hat (Le chapeau de Max, 1913)

Another entry in the category of “beautifully simple,” I bet practically anyone with a pulse can be charmed by this short. Max, dressed to the nines with a silk hat and all, heads out for the day and his beautiful hat promptly gets damaged. Heading to a nearby shop, he buys a new silk hat–but how long will it last? Ah, and how long will the one after that?

Uncomplicated as the plot may seem to us today, consider how film actually gave Linder more freedom than the stage. He goes from his home, to a taxi, to a hat shop, to a city street, back to the hat shop, and so forth. This would be more complicated and less effective if acted out on a stage. But motion pictures? A big advantage.

2. Max’s Vacation (Les vacances de Max, 1914)

The newly-married Max, who’s mad about his young wife, is invited to take a trip with his uncle–but only “as carefree bachelors,” as the invite reads. Since his wife can’t bear being left behind, he hatches a plan to smuggle her along in his trunk.

This short has survived in lovely quality. Just look at the spiffy automobile that takes the couple to the train station, and that shiny two-level passenger train, and all the pretty French bric-a-brac and antique furniture decorating the interior sets. The plot is a bit more involved than some Linder shorts, the absurdity escalating as steadily as a climb up a hill. Linder’s gestures, timing and expressions just might reminded you of Chaplin, too.

1.Max Speaks English (L’anglais tel que Max le parle, 1914)

Most fittingly, this short is named after its best scene. Max sits next to a charming woman on a train, and they share some mutually interested glances. But when Max attempts to flirt, he discovers that she only speaks English. Not to be defeated so easily, they try gesturing instead. Then Max has the idea of communicating with drawings, much like a game of Pictionary.

This delightful sequence takes up most of the ten-minute short with the remaining time devoted to Max visiting the woman at her workplace, which is a bathroom fixture showroom (there’s at least one hijink that ensues). As a bonus, we also get to see my very favorite shot of the silk-hatted Linder, standing outdoors in a nicely-framed medium shot with the Eiffel Tower looming grandly in the background.

I hope you enjoy watching this little, curated collection of Linder’s work! It’s not for nothing that this endearing, manic-eyed little Frenchman was such a cinema star, back in a time when cinema stardom had barely reached its infancy.