The Great Locomotive Crash: How Keaton Filmed “The General’s” Most Famous Scene

Day 2 of the 12th Annual Busterthon is in full swing, be sure to check out any new posts! This is my new post for the event; hope you enjoy!

It was the single the most expensive shot in a 1920s film–the mighty train crash in Buster Keaton’s Civil War comedy The General (1926). The climax of a lengthy chase that takes up the majority of the film, it was not only a stunning shot but was a real nail-biter to capture on film.

Anyone acquainted with Buster Keaton’s career is aware of the supposed backstory: a huge crowd of onlookers gathered to watch the filming, not sure exactly what they were going to witness. When the train crashed through the bridge, it was a genuine shock–some women even fainted when the head of a dummy (a stand-in for the engineer) floated by.

This isn’t quite what happened. In reality, onlookers absolutely knew a train stunt was going to happen, hence why the location drew such big crowds. But it was indeed an exciting event that took a ton of planning, a lot of set up on the fateful day itself and more than a little bit of good luck.

Continue reading

Repost: Behind The Scenes Of “The General” (1926)

This is post 1 of 2 that I’m contributing to the Twelfth Annual Buster Keaton Blogathon. I hope you get as much of a kick out of these exciting finds as I did!

The General (1927) - Turner Classic Movies

One of the best-loved films from the 1920s is certainly Buster Keaton’s masterwork The General (1926). Fans are very familiar with the stories behind it–how it was filmed up in sleepy little Cottage Grove, Oregon, how the risky train stunts were pulled off, how the famous train crash into the river was orchestrated, and so on.

While researching an upcoming column on The General for Classic Movie Hub (a slight plug, but it is relevant), I had the happy opportunity to look through some behind-the-scenes photos. I knew a bunch were in circulation, but the more I searched the more kept popping up. There were even a few I swear I hadn’t seen before, chilling on Pinterest as if they were just any other photos or something. Many were on my friend Sara Zittel’s board–credit where credit is due!

A sneak preview (isn’t this cool?).

So I thought we’d look at a few of them today, to get a fuller picture of what it was like to film The General back in that summer of 1926. It was a much more public event than we might realize!

Continue reading

Exploring Max Linder Films–Where To Begin?

January! For many of us it’s the most bone-chilling, gray and lengthy time of the year. Not that I’m complaining, believe it or not. Living in a northern state as I do (I sure wish you could experience Minnesota the way I always have), I’m head over heels for all four of the seasons, even the one with the longest and darkest of nights. There’s no better time to catch up on reading, little projects around the house, and…silent movie watching. (Obviously.)

Might I suggest, for example, exploring the work of the great French comedian Max Linder? If there’s only one thing you need to know about Linder’s significance in film history, it’s that none other than Charlie Chaplin himself referred to him as “the professor.” The diminutive, genial, slightly manic-eyed Frenchman in a silk hat was not only the world’s first major screen comedian, well over a hundred years ago, but he was arguably the very first film star–years before the star system was even in place.

Chaplin and Linder clowning together while finally meeting in person.

There’s dozens and dozens of Linder films, some more readily available than others, and most running about ten minutes or less. These had clean, simple premises such as “Max teaches the tango” or “Max tries to outsmart a romantic rival,” all cranked out quickly and efficiently. As Linder himself described: “We work from nine in ze morning to four in ze afternoon, and zen–she was fineesh!” Where, you might wonder, should you begin with such a lengthy filmography? Here’s a few suggestions:

6. Max Learns to Skate (Débuts d’un patineur, 1907)

This is an easy choice–none other than the little film that introduced Linder to the world as a screen comedian! Its simple premise is a nice little intro to his style of comedy. As the title implies, Max goes ice skating for the first time and naturally, his enthusiasm about the experience quickly turns sour. Doubtless you can fill in the blanks!

Max Learns to Skate also contains an interesting look at a 1900s French skating rink, where apparently you would check your coat (you being quite warm enough in your customary underthings, shirt, and suit) and someone would assist you in getting on your skates. It’s all quite civilized, I must say.

5. Troubles of a Grass Widower (Vive la vie de garcon, 1908)

After Max and his wife get into a quarrel, the wife storms out and goes home to mother. Initially elated to be on his own, Max soon finds out that his clumsy attempts at chores and cooking don’t measure up to his wife’s skills.

Many 1900s comedies tend to capture the action in long shots, but Grass Widower contains a nice example of the camera getting up close and personal as Max is attempting to cook a chicken dinner. Linder’s dexterity and expressive, yet restrained, performance might remind you of the many comedians who proceeded him–who were certainly inspired by films like this.

Note the scene where Max is trudging home from the market and tries to hide his parcels from a neighbor lady–apparently if the man of the house was seen buying groceries, it was a sure sign of domestic troubles! And do enjoy the charming interiors of Max’s home, quite elaborate for this simple short. Those lovely mouldings and wainscoting were brought to your eyes through the magic of trompe l’oeil painting.

4. Max Takes a Bath (Max prend un bain, 1910)

In this delightful little short Max is suffering from a nervous tick. The doctor recommends he treat it by taking a cold bath everyday, so Max eagerly buys a bathtub, his apartment apparently not being equipped with one. I must say, a beautifully-decorated antique tub like that would command a pretty penny nowadays!

Owning a tub is more of a headache than he expected, however. Not only is it difficult to get home, but where is he going to fill it up? His breezy solutions inadvertently lead to chaos. I love this short, for both its cheery simplicity and for one very funny sequence of Max scuttling along with the tub on his back like a turtle shell. You won’t guess where he manages to go!

3. Max’s Hat (Le chapeau de Max, 1913)

Another entry in the category of “beautifully simple,” I bet practically anyone with a pulse can be charmed by this short. Max, dressed to the nines with a silk hat and all, heads out for the day and his beautiful hat promptly gets damaged. Heading to a nearby shop, he buys a new silk hat–but how long will it last? Ah, and how long will the one after that?

Uncomplicated as the plot may seem to us today, consider how film actually gave Linder more freedom than the stage. He goes from his home, to a taxi, to a hat shop, to a city street, back to the hat shop, and so forth. This would be more complicated and less effective if acted out on a stage. But motion pictures? A big advantage.

2. Max’s Vacation (Les vacances de Max, 1914)

The newly-married Max, who’s mad about his young wife, is invited to take a trip with his uncle–but only “as carefree bachelors,” as the invite reads. Since his wife can’t bear being left behind, he hatches a plan to smuggle her along in his trunk.

This short has survived in lovely quality. Just look at the spiffy automobile that takes the couple to the train station, and that shiny two-level passenger train, and all the pretty French bric-a-brac and antique furniture decorating the interior sets. The plot is a bit more involved than some Linder shorts, the absurdity escalating as steadily as a climb up a hill. Linder’s gestures, timing and expressions just might reminded you of Chaplin, too.

1.Max Speaks English (L’anglais tel que Max le parle, 1914)

Most fittingly, this short is named after its best scene. Max sits next to a charming woman on a train, and they share some mutually interested glances. But when Max attempts to flirt, he discovers that she only speaks English. Not to be defeated so easily, they try gesturing instead. Then Max has the idea of communicating with drawings, much like a game of Pictionary.

This delightful sequence takes up most of the ten-minute short with the remaining time devoted to Max visiting the woman at her workplace, which is a bathroom fixture showroom (there’s at least one hijink that ensues). As a bonus, we also get to see my very favorite shot of the silk-hatted Linder, standing outdoors in a nicely-framed medium shot with the Eiffel Tower looming grandly in the background.

I hope you enjoy watching this little, curated collection of Linder’s work! It’s not for nothing that this endearing, manic-eyed little Frenchman was such a cinema star, back in a time when cinema stardom had barely reached its infancy.

Rare Photos From “A Country Hero” (1917) Revealed!

As I’m taking in the Pordenone Silent Film Festival, I wanted to share a very special treat with you all that’s been made possible by a generous reader. Some of you might know that A Country Hero is my #1 most wanted lost silent film, so to all my fellow Buster fans: get excited!!

Recently I was contacted by an independent researcher and fellow Buster Keaton fan about a fascinating discovery she made while researching the lost Comique short A Country Hero at the Margaret Herrick Library in Los Angeles. The two-reel short, which starred Roscoe Arbuckle, Al St. John, Buster Keaton, Buster’s father Joe Keaton, and Alice Lake, was set in a small town called Jazzville and has been completely and thoroughly lost. In fact, it’s the only known piece of the “Buster at Comique” puzzle that’s currently missing. Thus, the mystery of what this film was like and whether it might ever turn up has been tantalizing fans ever since–including me! (Honestly, I’ve been dying to see for years now!)

Much to her surprise, this researcher turned up two crystal-clear photos from the film that were completely unfamiliar to her and did not appear to have been used in books or uploaded onto the Internet at all. In fact, the Herrick library didn’t even have any thumbnail scans on their site (thanks to her request for scans, they do now, but at the time the photos were a complete surprise).

Having made such a fabulous discovery, there was the dilemma of how to share these two photos, since she doesn’t have a site or social media presence of her own. So she reached out to me, Comique fanatic: would I like to share them in a post on Silent-ology? Um, YES PLEASE!! It would be an honor.

Continue reading

Myra Keaton: Wife, Mother, Vaudeville Veteran

This is my own post for the Eleventh Annual Buster Keaton Blogathon. Enjoy, and thank you kindly for reading!

Born in the tiny farm town of Modale, Iowa in 1877, and spending much of her youth performing in her father’s travelling medicine show which barely scraped by on its shoestring budget, Myra Cutler likely never dreamed she’d one day be the mother to one of the 20th century’s most iconic comedians. Yet that was the fate in store, and arguably, Joseph Frank “Buster” Keaton would have had a very different life if it wasn’t for his mother’s hardscrabble upbringing and consistent resilience. Keaton fans can also credit her with literally saving his life on at least one occasion.

Continue reading

The Eleventh Annual Buster Keaton Blogathon

Like a reliable old friend, our annual celebration of the incomparable Buster Keaton is back! Now over a decade old, it’s my blog’s most popular tradition. We’ve had many fine posts over the years on Keaton’s life and career–even fan art and tribute videos–and I know this year will be just as excellent!

Bloggers: I’ll be updating periodically throughout the blogathon, so please send me the link to your post whenever it’s ready today or tomorrow. (And many thanks if you sent the link early!) Don’t forget that I’ll be holding a drawing for all participants on May 28, the winner receiving a copy of Kino/Lobster’s Blu-ray set of The General (1927) and Three Ages (1923).

Readers: Please drop by often to see the latest posts! Feel free to leave comments on your favorites and share them with others–we bloggers appreciate it!

Wondering what the previous Busterthons were like? Here’s all the links in Silent-ology’s Buster Keaton Blogathon Library: the FirstSecond, Third, FourthFifthSixthSeventh,  EighthNinth and the Tenth yearly events! 

The Roster:

Silent-ology | “Myra Keaton: Wife, Mother, Vaudeville Veteran”

Cinematica | “What If: Little Lord Busteroy” essay

Silent Locations | “Buster Keaton’s Three Ages Leap of Faith” article

Realweegiemidget Reviews | Keaton’s Twilight Zone episode “Once Upon a Time”

nitrateglow | Audio commentary for Battling Butler (1926).

Gary McGath | “Accompanying Buster Keaton Films” essay

Welcome To My Magick Theatre | Seven Chances (1925)

Classic Film and TV Corner | “Buster and Eleanor: A Love Story” essay

The Thoughts of One Truly Loved | “More Than a Stoneface” essay

18 Cinema Lane | Speak Easily (1932)

Taking Up Room | Steamboat Bill, Jr (1928)

Big V Riot Squad | Our Hospitality (1923)

Edendale Cyclorama | “Buster Keaton and Homes: Back Stage at Sennett’s with Molly Malone” article

Whimsically Classic | The Navigator (1924)

One Week Until The Buster Blogathon Returns!

Only seven days left until our grand tradition returns…the annual Buster Keaton Blogathon, now over a decade old!

That’s right, eleven years of Buster posts! That means that this blogathon is just entering middle school. It’s only a few years away from being old enough to drive. It’s even starting to think about what it wants to be when it grows up…!

If you’re a blogger who’s also a huge fan of our favorite genius in slap shoes and you’re just hearing about this event, feel free to join in! Any and all entries are welcome. In the past, people have submitted everything from brief essays to lengthy articles to fan art–it’s always quite the tribute!

Update: As many of you know, as a “thank you” to all the blogathon participants I like to host a giveaway. This will be held on May 28th by me literally drawing a name out of a hat (cloche-style, of course). For the 2025 event, I’ve decided to give away Kino/Lobster’s Blu-ray of The General and Three Ages. This set features 2K restorations and bonus content (such as Buster’s Candid Camera segment!) and four different scores to choose from (two per feature).  A nice addition to the movie library for Keaton completists.

And now, here are the articles and essays to look forward to next week!

The Roster:

Silent-ology | Myra Keaton

nitrateglow | Audio commentary for Battling Butler (1926)

Classic Film and TV Corner | Essay on Buster and Eleanor Keaton

Whimsically Classic | The Navigator (1924)

Edendale Cyclorama | The Keystone Film Company’s influence on Buster

Gary McGath | Essay on silent film accompaniment for Buster Keaton films

Big V Riot Squad | Our Hospitality (1923)

Welcome To My Magick Theatre | Seven Chances (1925)

Taking Up Room | Steamboat Bill, Jr (1928)

The Thoughts of One Truly Loved | “More Than a Stoneface” essay

Cinematica | “What Might Have Been” essay

Realweegiemidget Reviews | The Twilight Zone episode “Once Upon a Time”

18 Cinema Lane | Speak Easily (1932)

ANNOUNCING: The 11th Buster Keaton Blogathon!

No doubt some of you were wondering–now when is Silent-ology announcing the next Buster blogathon? Well, the day has arrived–and I hope my fellow bloggers will join in for our eleventh straight year of celebrating all things Keaton!

I decided to have the blogathon a little later this year, near the end of May–one of my favorite months of the year (so beautiful!).

When: Monday, May 26 and Tuesday, May 27 2025.

Where: Right here on Silent-ology!

Continue reading

New Kickstarter! “Rediscovering Roscoe: The ‘Fatty’ Arbuckle Collection” Set

Calling all slapstick fans! A new Kickstarter project was just announced today, and it’s something that’s right up my alley: the 2-disc set Rediscovering Roscoe: The “Fatty” Arbuckle Collection. Curated by historian Steve Massa, author of the wonderful Rediscovering Roscoe book I reviewed awhile back, it’s due to be released by Undercrank Productions in February 2026–with a little help from you!

A major star in his day, comedian Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle was both beloved by audiences and admired as an influential comedy director. This new Blu-ray/DVD set (take your pick) will include ten rare Arbuckle comedies ranging from 1913-1931–well over three hours of content. These include some of his earliest films for Keystone and some of his behind-the-scenes directing work following the infamous Labor Day scandal.

Details: The films will be scored by historian Ben Model and restored by an experienced team of experts, with all Kickstarter funds going towards the production, release, and shipping of the sets. Project backers will receive the first physical discs and future sets will be manufactured on demand.

A rare still from An Incompetent Hero (1914).

Disc One will include:

  • The Gangsters (1913) – Arbuckle’s very first Keystone film.
  • A Noise From the Deep (1913) – The earliest surviving pairing of Arbuckle with Mabel Normand–may also include the first Keystone pie throwing!
  • An Incompetent Hero (1914) – A rarely-seen comedy which also costars Arbuckle’s nephew Al St. John, Edgar Kennedy, and Minta Durfee.
  • The Sea Nymphs (1914) – A two-reeler where Mabel, Roscoe and a seal frolic on the beach on Catalina Island. This is a scan of the sole surviving print.
  • Crazy to Marry (1921) – A 40-minute feature that was yanked from theaters following the 1921 scandal.
  • Bonus: New reconstruction of Fatty and the Broadway Stars (1916)!
Arbuckle’s Educational cast and crew circa 1926.

Disc Two will focus on Arbuckle’s directing:

  • Never Again (1924) – An Al St. John film where Arbuckle reworked the plots of Fatty at San Diego (1913) and A Reckless Romeo (1917). Another film with only one surviving print.
  • Stupid but Brave (1924) – Another slapstick two-reeler starring Al St. John.
  • Dynamite Doggie (1925) – Al St John co-stars with Pete the Pup in a comedy that just might remind you of material in Sherlock Jr. (1924). Luke the dog also makes an appearance.
  • Home Cured (1926) – A short Tuxedo comedy for Educational Pictures, starring Johnny Arthur. He plays a hypochondriac whose obsessions start threatening his marriage.
  • Honeymoon Trio (1931) – A sound short showing Al St John on a never-ending “honeymoon from hell.”
  • Bonus: Video essay on Arbuckle’s life and career.

A few words from Steve Massa on this exciting project:

“We’re very pleased to bring this 2-disc Blu-ray to everyone. It’s a very complex project that’s made up of numerous rare films that have never been on home video before. The selection draws from my relationship with international archives, and we’re extremely grateful to the generosity and collaborative spirit of the Library of Congress, Blackhawk/Lobster Films, Cinematek in Brussels, Danish Film Institute, EYE Filmmuseum, the Museum of Modern Art, and Nationalbiblioteket, as well as collectors and film historian friends.” 

Finding and restoring these elusive films is easier said than done, to say the least, but thanks to crowdfunding it’s not only possible but it allows old movie enthusiasts to play a part in film preservation. We’re in a unique era where anyone with a few extra dollars can help bring projects like this to life. It’s an exciting and easy way to help these films reach new generations.

If you think you’d like to back this project, please do, and please head to this link! Roscoe and Luke will thank you.

Thoughts On: Harold Lloyd’s “Hot Water” (1924)

A Happy Thanksgiving to my fellow American readers! In the spirit of this holiday I thought I’d put a spotlight on…well…something turkey-themed, at any rate. There weren’t a lot of holiday-themed movies in the silent era, but if you’re looking for something funny to amuse your relatives as they digest their turkey dinners then you can’t go wrong with popping in some Harold Lloyd. The big classics like Safety Last! (1923) are the obvious go-tos, but there’s plenty of laughs in his minor classics, too–like Hot Water (1924).

Hot Water was Lloyd’s follow up film to his smash hit Girl Shy (1924), and it also became a blockbuster. The structure is very episodic compared to Lloyd’s more famous features, rather like three two-reel comedies smashed into one. Releasing simpler “gag pictures” like this was a practical measure for Lloyd after the extra time and effort it took to make features like Girl Shy–filling out those release schedules in a timely manner could take some creativity!

Continue reading