Question: What do the films
From Hell,
Silent Hill, and
Disney's The Haunted Mansion have in common?
Answer: All three are based on existing properties that I am a big fan of, I eagerly ate up every press release and rumor about their development as they trickled out to entertainment magazines and websites, I watched them all in theaters on opening weekend...
...and they were all mediocre and disappointing.
Of the three, probably
From Hell (2001), directed by the
Hughes Brothers, fares the best. In fact, if I hadn't gone in knowing this fictionalization of the notorious crimes of Jack the Ripper was based on the brilliant
10-part graphic novel, in which cult genre writer
Alan Moore manages to weave almost every known fact and theory surrounding the case into a wholly original narrative that is part detective procedural, part supernatural thriller, I probably would have rated the film much higher.
Unfortunately, I went in expecting to see Alan Moore's
From Hell, and instead got a serviceable drama that left most of his smart plotting and ambitious themes behind, while still incorporating just enough elements from the comics to remind me how much better they were than what I was watching. (And I'll give you a hint, if you decide to watch
From Hell at home: turn the color on your TV all the way down so that the image is black and white. It looks incredible, and completely enhances the tone of the film).
My expectations weren't so high with
Silent Hill (2006). After all, this is a film based on a videogame, and those rarely succeed. But I was crossing my fingers that this might be one that got it right. I'd first entered the decaying town of Silent Hill in 2001, courtesy of
Silent Hill 2 on the
Playstation 2.
I was instantly captivated by the amazingly detailed world of the game, a ruined town choking in mist, constantly teetering between a dreary and decaying real world, and an even more frightening alternate reality that was like some nightmarish psychological purgatory. Silent Hill is populated with disturbing creatures that limp and stagger out of dark corners of the room (and of the mind), looking like tortured souls rendered as bio-industrial waste, evoking both terror and pity.
I've probably played
Silent Hill 2 from beginning to end almost a dozen times, and would continue to explore its haunted world in sequels
Silent Hill 3,
Silent Hill 4: The Room, and
Silent Hill: Origins.
The film
Silent Hill managed to perfectly captured the atmosphere of the game, from the fog-soaked streets to the repulsive monsters (rendered with practical effects combined with CGI), and director
Christophe Gans(
Brotherhood of the Wolf) was even savvy enough to use composer
Akira Yamaoka's haunting original music from the games.
In fact,
Silent Hill gets so much right, it makes what it gets wrong stand out all the more. It sabotages itself with endless, cumbersome exposition (admittedly some of the games suffer from this as well), a cartoonish supporting cast of superstitious townsfolk that will have you flashbacking to the witch-burning mob from
Monty Python and the Holy Grail, and a third-act twist in which everything we've seen up to that point is framed as being the machinations of some game, with the main character, a mother (
Radha Mitchell) looking for her lost daughter, being congratulated for making it to the next level. This brings the show to a screeching halt faster than an "Intermission" slide, and the film just never recovers.
But my biggest disappointment had to be
Disney's The Haunted Mansion (2003), because the
Disneyland attraction on which it is based has always held a special place for me for as long as I can remember. Media leaks during its production were promising. It was to be directed by
Rob Minkoff (Stuart Little, The Lion King), a self-confessed Mansion fan, and the original attraction design work by Imagineers
Marc Davis,
Claude Coats, and others, was being referenced for the art direction and set design for the film. There was another reason to be optimistic--just a few months prior to
The Haunted Mansion's premier, Disney had exceeded everyone's expectations with a film based on another popular Disneyland attraction, the wildly successful blockbuster
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl.
So what happened?
With the
surprising and exciting announcement at Comic-Con that respected fantasy director
Guillermo Del Toro was going to helm a second attempt at a Haunted Mansion film, I thought it would be a good time to revisit the underwhelming 2003 original to see what it got wrong... as well as acknowledge what it got right.
AN "EDDIE MURPHY" TYPE
Let's cut right to it--casting
Eddie Murphy as the lead was a bad decision, period. And it wasn't anything specific about Murphy's
performance that brought down the
Mansion... it was the
decision to go for an Eddie-Murphy-type leading man in the first place (the fact that it ended up actually being
Eddie Murphy is almost inconsequential.)
It snuffed any hope that
The Haunted Mansion was going to be a true horror film and resigned it to being just another lightweight Disney comedy/fantasy, the kind that, in the 1960s and 70s, would have starred
Don Knotts,
Ken Berry or
Dean Jones.
I CAN'T BELIEVE IT'S NOT EDWARD GRACEY!
The
Haunted Mansion attraction never had an official "origin story" explaining why it was haunted, other than the one offered by
Walt Disney himself, which is that ghosts and spirits from around the world arrived by invitation, to enjoy their retirement at this house built at Disneyland just for them.
Teaser sign from the Haunted Mansion at Disneyland inviting ghosts and spirits to move in (photo borrowed from the Daveland library...)Of course, that wouldn't really work for the film, so instead a new back-story was invented for the Mansion: a curse, revolving around dashing society man Edward Gracey's grief for his lost love, Elizabeth. The Mansion, you see, was
"once filled with so many things... so much life, grand parties, dancing, laughter, and above all, hope."Wah? I'm sorry, but this Beauty-and-the-Beast-meets-Phantom-of-the-Opera lovers-lament nonsense just doesn't belong anywhere near my
Haunted Mansion. And having the "ghost host", if you will, reimagined as a romance-novel pretty-boy isn't scary. It's just lame.
YOU CAN'T GET GOOD HELP THESE DAYS
I'm not sure that the comic relief served up by ghostly butler and maid duo Ezra and Emma (
Wallace Shawn and
Dina Waters) was even necessary, but the fact that their clunky bickering isn't actually, you know,
funny, doesn't help anything. And don't get me wrong--I love
Wallace Shawn, and as far as I'm concerned, he can do no wrong. Except here, where he does wrong. An example of one of their knee-slapping exchanges:
EMMA: (trying to take control of the reins of a carriage) "Let me drive, you're going to kill us all."
EZRA: "That's where you're wrong, because some of us are already dead! Ha ha ha!"
Ouch...
A MERE WISE-CRACKING HEAD INSIDE A MISTY CRYSTAL BALL
Casting
Jennifer Tilly as
Madame Leota could have worked, but the character is pretty much confined to spouting wisecracks (e.g. "I don't make the rules, okay, I just work here.") before the final indignity... reduced to being just another bickering kid in the minivan.
SINGING BUSTS AND ROLLING EYES
There has always been a level of humor present in all versions of the Haunted Mansion attraction. Still, elements like the singing graveyard busts aren't meant for laughs. They're singing, moving, graveyard statuary--it's creepy. But in the film, they are treated strictly as a novelty act that even had Murphy's on-screen daughter rolling her eyes.
That reminds me... you know what else is annoying in movies? Sarcastic kids who roll their eyes.
INSERT ZOMBIES HERE
It's ironic that one of the few genuinely scary scenes in the film involves monsters that seem totally out of place at the Mansion. Achieved mostly with traditional make-up and prosthetics by special effects artist
Rick Baker, these coffin-bursting animated corpses look like they wandered in from another movie, (perhaps one of
Brendan Fraser's
Mummy films). While there are some animated skeletons emerging from coffins in the Phantom Manor version of the attraction at Disneyland Paris, it doesn't change the fact that they just don't seem to belong in
this Haunted Mansion.
A Phantom Manor graveyard corpse.
AND THEY ALL LIVED HAPPILY EVER AFTER
I'm not against happy endings in horror films, but
The Haunted Mansion climax is so sugary sweet they should have added a warning for diabetics to leave the theater. In a conclusion more suited to a fairy tale, the "curse" that causes the Mansion to be haunted is lifted once pretty-boy Gracey reunites with the ghost of Elizabeth, who descends like a fairy godmother on a sparkling ray of light. All the Mansion's spectral denizens, free from their bondage to the house, literally ascend to Heaven in a pretty CGI light show. Finally, Murphy's character is handed the deed to the house, and invited to do with it whatever makes him and his family happy.
Were the filmmakers really so clueless as to think that fans were interested in witnessing the
unhaunting of the Haunted Mansion?
WHOA, NELLY
The final slap in the face is the shoehorning of hip-hop song "IZ-U" by
Nelly over the end credits. Built around a hook sampled from the theme song to the TV show
The People's Court, and boasting incoherent lyrics like
"Gonna pick you up and take you to lunch or sum'hin, Ill leave it up to you if imma touch or sum'hin", not only is it completely inappropriate for the film, its not even a good song.
So is
The Haunted Mansion a complete waste of time, devoid of anything praiseworthy? Not at all. Here's some of the things I liked about the film. Actually, it looks like I've only come up with two... here's both of them:
SEEING THE MANSION RENDERED AS AN ACTUAL HOUSE
For someone who's used to seeing it only as a theme park attraction, with a line of tourists waiting to get in and a churro cart nearby, it's pretty neat to finally see the Mansion rendered as an actual house in a real Louisiana bayou, adjoining a life-size graveyard. Even though it's obvious a lot of this is achieved with CGI, it's done in a style that evokes the classic matte paintings of
Peter Ellenshaw, or of the old
Roger Corman Poe pictures (
Fall of the House of Usher,
The Pit and the Pendulum, etc.)
FAITHFUL RECREATIONS OF SCENES FROM THE ORIGINAL ATTRACTIONIt's fun to see the portrait hall with staring busts, the bulging hallway door, the dangling suicide, and other signature set peices from the attraction recreated in the film.
Hmmm... I seem to have run out of positive things to say about 2003's
I do own it on DVD and drag it out every few years to reflect on what could have been. Let's cross our fingers for Guillermo's reboot.