What do you think?
Rate this book
The Obsidian Path #1
Black Stone Heart
A broken man, Khraen awakens alone and lost. His stone heart has been shattered, littered across the world. With each piece, he regains some small shard of the man he once was.
He follows the trail, fragment by fragment, remembering his terrible past.
There was a woman.
There was a sword.
There was an end to sorrow.
Khraen walks the obsidian path.
He follows the trail, fragment by fragment, remembering his terrible past.
There was a woman.
There was a sword.
There was an end to sorrow.
Khraen walks the obsidian path.
380 pages, Paperback
First published March 29, 2020
About the author
Michael R. Fletcher
47 books1,232 followersMichael R. Fletcher is a science fiction and fantasy author, a grilled cheese aficionado, and a whiskey-swilling reprobate. He spends his days choreographing his forklift musical (titled "Get Forked"), and using caffeine as a substitute for sanity. Any suggestions that he is actually Dyrk Ashton in disguise are all lies.
Blog (kinda): http://michaelrfletcher.com/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MichaelRFlet...
Twitter: @FletcherMR
Instagram: fletcher_michael_r
Blog (kinda): http://michaelrfletcher.com/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MichaelRFlet...
Twitter: @FletcherMR
Instagram: fletcher_michael_r
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 411 reviews
June 29, 2020
ARC provided by the author in exchange for an honest review.
4.5/5 stars
Insanely brilliant. Fletcher did it again. Black Stone Heart is one of his best works so far, and Fletcher has finally crafted something as good as his Manifest Delusion series with this one.
I’m starting to feel that Fletcher is becoming the Sanderson of grimdark fantasy. No, none of their works are remotely similar to one another, what do I mean by this statement then? Fletcher keeps pouring out new series without completing them first! I should be annoyed by this fact, but I can’t possibly complain when all of them have been so good in their own way. Black Stone Heart is the first book The Obsidian Path series, and as expected, it’s another incredible grimdark fantasy. Also, if you can, do get the physical edition of this book; there are interior artworks by Stas Borodin, I’ve seen one, and it was gorgeous.
Black Stone Heart follows the journey of Khraen. Khraen wakes up alone and lost; his stone heart has been shattered and littered across the world. Every time he acquires a fragment of his heart, he gains a part of his memory back. Realizing this, Khraen walks the obsidian path to restore his memory. Excluding The Millenial Manifesto, I’ve read all of Fletcher’s work, and although it will sound unbelievable, I truly believe that Black Stone Heart is Fletcher’s most compulsively readable book so far. It’s such an imaginative grimdark fantasy that involves a lot of resonating discussions about memories, identities, xenophobia, consequences, choices, and the nature of evil.
Fletcher has given Khraen such a unique and distinctive voice that made his first-person perspective narration so bloody compelling to read. Mysteries, dark humor, destruction, and moral dilemma filled the pages of this book; I can’t get enough of them. At the beginning of the novel, Khraen was pretty much an empty vessel, but a few people he met in his quest to unlock his past ended up changing him for the better. At least, that’s what he thinks. There are complications in attaining more of his former self, with each fragment gained Khraen recognizes that he may not be as good as his present self. The moral dilemma that Khraen faced felt so genuine; he can’t resist getting more of his fragments back, he needs to know, but knowing more could end up changing him back to his former self. Plus, there’s another possibility, it may not be the revelations of his past that changes him, it could be the cruel surroundings and racism he constantly met on his journey. After all, it’s utterly difficult to continue your intention of being kind-hearted when your environment never stops treating you with hatred. Will he ends up reverting back to his former self? Will he continue to do good despite everyone being hateful and judgmental towards the color of his skin? Read and find out for yourself!
Similar to Fletcher’s Manifest Delusion and City of Sacrifice series, Black Stone Heart contained world-building that, somehow, felt refreshing to read, especially in grimdark fantasy. I’m a bit conflicted on how much I should talk about here, the fantasy elements in the world-building I encountered—like magic, wizards, necromancer, and many more I won’t mention—were surprises to me that I didn’t know about upon reading and they made me amazed by the scope of the story. In order to make sure you retain that wow experience on your reads, I’m gonna close this section by saying the world-building—especially the history of the world—was incredibly bleak and magnificent.
Honestly speaking, I haven’t read any grimdark fantasy for five months, I even thought that I was tired of the genre after finding myself disappointed with The Chronicles of the Black Company series by Glen Cook. As it turns out, I’ve just been reading something that’s not working for me. I can always count on Joe Abercrombie, Steven Erikson, and Michael Fletcher to make me love reading the genre again. Black Stone Heart encapsulates why I love reading grimdark fantasy; it’s brutal, it’s merciless, it’s darkly humorous, it’s thought-provoking, and it’s brilliant. Before reading this novel, I kept on wishing that Fletcher would write the final book in Manifest Delusions first. But now, I don’t even mind if Fletcher suddenly stopped writing his other series and decided to focus on finishing this first. My curiosity to find out what happened next is on a ridiculously high level, and the overall quality of the book—in a different way—is at least as good as Beyond Redemption. Black Stone Heart feels like the beginning of a series that will stick with you long after you’re done reading it. I absolutely recommend this book to every grimdark fantasy readers.
Official release date: 1st April 2020
You can pre-order the book from: Amazon UK | Amazon US
The quotes in this review were taken from an ARC and are subject to change upon publication.
You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions
Special thanks to my Patrons on Patreon for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Devin, Hamad, Joie, Mike, Miracle, Nicholas.
4.5/5 stars
Insanely brilliant. Fletcher did it again. Black Stone Heart is one of his best works so far, and Fletcher has finally crafted something as good as his Manifest Delusion series with this one.
I’m starting to feel that Fletcher is becoming the Sanderson of grimdark fantasy. No, none of their works are remotely similar to one another, what do I mean by this statement then? Fletcher keeps pouring out new series without completing them first! I should be annoyed by this fact, but I can’t possibly complain when all of them have been so good in their own way. Black Stone Heart is the first book The Obsidian Path series, and as expected, it’s another incredible grimdark fantasy. Also, if you can, do get the physical edition of this book; there are interior artworks by Stas Borodin, I’ve seen one, and it was gorgeous.
Black Stone Heart follows the journey of Khraen. Khraen wakes up alone and lost; his stone heart has been shattered and littered across the world. Every time he acquires a fragment of his heart, he gains a part of his memory back. Realizing this, Khraen walks the obsidian path to restore his memory. Excluding The Millenial Manifesto, I’ve read all of Fletcher’s work, and although it will sound unbelievable, I truly believe that Black Stone Heart is Fletcher’s most compulsively readable book so far. It’s such an imaginative grimdark fantasy that involves a lot of resonating discussions about memories, identities, xenophobia, consequences, choices, and the nature of evil.
“Every day we do the things we think we have to do. So rarely do we stop to question our choices. We don’t even see deciding that we ‘have to do something’ is itself a choice. We blunder through life, writing our failures and excuses as we go, defending every choice with justifications made up after the fact. The truth is, we never really consider the consequences.”
Fletcher has given Khraen such a unique and distinctive voice that made his first-person perspective narration so bloody compelling to read. Mysteries, dark humor, destruction, and moral dilemma filled the pages of this book; I can’t get enough of them. At the beginning of the novel, Khraen was pretty much an empty vessel, but a few people he met in his quest to unlock his past ended up changing him for the better. At least, that’s what he thinks. There are complications in attaining more of his former self, with each fragment gained Khraen recognizes that he may not be as good as his present self. The moral dilemma that Khraen faced felt so genuine; he can’t resist getting more of his fragments back, he needs to know, but knowing more could end up changing him back to his former self. Plus, there’s another possibility, it may not be the revelations of his past that changes him, it could be the cruel surroundings and racism he constantly met on his journey. After all, it’s utterly difficult to continue your intention of being kind-hearted when your environment never stops treating you with hatred. Will he ends up reverting back to his former self? Will he continue to do good despite everyone being hateful and judgmental towards the color of his skin? Read and find out for yourself!
“Hating all wizards for the actions of one or two is madness. If a woman breaks your heart, do you hate all women?”
Similar to Fletcher’s Manifest Delusion and City of Sacrifice series, Black Stone Heart contained world-building that, somehow, felt refreshing to read, especially in grimdark fantasy. I’m a bit conflicted on how much I should talk about here, the fantasy elements in the world-building I encountered—like magic, wizards, necromancer, and many more I won’t mention—were surprises to me that I didn’t know about upon reading and they made me amazed by the scope of the story. In order to make sure you retain that wow experience on your reads, I’m gonna close this section by saying the world-building—especially the history of the world—was incredibly bleak and magnificent.
“The past, I decided, was like that. Even the most cherished moments faded, became memories of memories, as we focused on the parts we liked, and forgot the rest. But where individual moments lacked clarity, knowledge was something different.
Honestly speaking, I haven’t read any grimdark fantasy for five months, I even thought that I was tired of the genre after finding myself disappointed with The Chronicles of the Black Company series by Glen Cook. As it turns out, I’ve just been reading something that’s not working for me. I can always count on Joe Abercrombie, Steven Erikson, and Michael Fletcher to make me love reading the genre again. Black Stone Heart encapsulates why I love reading grimdark fantasy; it’s brutal, it’s merciless, it’s darkly humorous, it’s thought-provoking, and it’s brilliant. Before reading this novel, I kept on wishing that Fletcher would write the final book in Manifest Delusions first. But now, I don’t even mind if Fletcher suddenly stopped writing his other series and decided to focus on finishing this first. My curiosity to find out what happened next is on a ridiculously high level, and the overall quality of the book—in a different way—is at least as good as Beyond Redemption. Black Stone Heart feels like the beginning of a series that will stick with you long after you’re done reading it. I absolutely recommend this book to every grimdark fantasy readers.
“There are gods and demons.
There are heavens and hells.
But there is no fate,
there is no force of destiny.
Only you can decide who you are.
Your actions will define you.”
Official release date: 1st April 2020
You can pre-order the book from: Amazon UK | Amazon US
The quotes in this review were taken from an ARC and are subject to change upon publication.
You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions
Special thanks to my Patrons on Patreon for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Devin, Hamad, Joie, Mike, Miracle, Nicholas.
February 4, 2024
Also on littafi.com
This has to be the best Fantasy read I've ever had the pleasure of coming across so far. The only ones that come close are: The Prince of Nothing series by Bakker,
The Children of Chaos by John C. Wright and The Worldbreaker Saga by Kameron Hurley.
"The wizards might win. Tomorrow, the Empire might be theirs to rule. But it was also theirs to lose. And lose it, they would. Short-sighted, they had no idea just how much the Empire relied upon demons. Demons the wizards had no means of controlling."
"That night I dreamed of a strange hell where demons were immaterial spirits that could be bound to steel and iron. They thirsted for death, fed off the essence of the living as it fled the dying body.
I wanted to summon one, to bind it to a sword. But not just any demon, I wanted their master, the Lord of the entire Hell. He had a name, and it was the End of Sorrows."
Another thing I found interesting was how the POV kept recovering his memory through dreams as visions of events millennia in the past as he continued recovering his shattered stone heart through walking the Obsidian Path.
2022 Read
This has to be the best Fantasy read I've ever had the pleasure of coming across so far. The only ones that come close are: The Prince of Nothing series by Bakker,
The Children of Chaos by John C. Wright and The Worldbreaker Saga by Kameron Hurley.
"We fight to the end,” said the man. “To the death.”Phenomenal and highly immersive world-building, top notch characterisation, beautiful, poignant and macabre prose while at the same time self reflective due to the POV, and lastly, a solid magic system that fuses elements of speculative science fiction and fantasy, all interwoven in a highly addictive plotline that keeps you wanting more after every single word uttered from my most beloved anti-hero.
The demon beside him nodded, wizened face sad.
Commands were sent out and the demonic host, bound in servitude to the demonologists, had no choice but to obey.
That night the Empire fell, and the world sank into a thousand years of darkness."
"Something was wrong with the old man; he wasn’t quite the right shape. His skull, a little too oblong, his limbs a little too long. He looked stretched. Eyes, too large, oddly oval, glowed violet as he studied me. He blinked wrong, liquid, one eye at a time."I would highly recommend this to readers of GrimDark Fantasy. Here are some beautiful quotes...
"The demon, in robes of ink, looked like a gaunt old man, bald, bent and near skeletal. “If we break that circle, it might crack the earth to its core. Lava. Ash in the sky for years.”
"Creatures called from a hundred different realities stood waiting. Massive beasts, some dwarfing even the Deredi giants, held formation beside winged nightmares from some distant hell. Many, hailing from closer realities looked human, differing only in some small detail. Purple skin, horns, claws, too many or two few fingers. With this army, he had bound the world under a single rule: His. And now, with this army, he would lose the world."
"The wizards might win. Tomorrow, the Empire might be theirs to rule. But it was also theirs to lose. And lose it, they would. Short-sighted, they had no idea just how much the Empire relied upon demons. Demons the wizards had no means of controlling."
"That night I dreamed of a strange hell where demons were immaterial spirits that could be bound to steel and iron. They thirsted for death, fed off the essence of the living as it fled the dying body.
I wanted to summon one, to bind it to a sword. But not just any demon, I wanted their master, the Lord of the entire Hell. He had a name, and it was the End of Sorrows."
"You. Will. Obey!The explicit humor involved was a highly refreshing counter point to the deep existential dread, violence, gore, etc which the plot hinges on; The somewhat slow and fast pacing (towards the ending) was surprisingly helpful.
Fear. Terror.
The water elemental cowered. It remembered me. It remembered how I brought it here, how I bent it to my will.
“Fill the bowl,” I commanded. “If I ask for water, you give it.”
I opened my eyes to find the bowl filled with cool, clear water. I drank until I puked.
Then I drank more.
“Better?” asked Nhil.
“Yes,” I answered, voice still raw.
“Good,” he said. “Because we have another problem.”
I lay back, belly distended. “What’s that?”
“You’re still going to starve to death before long.”
“Oh.” I released a long belch. “Fuck.”
"Evil.
I didn’t like that word. So judgemental. One man’s evil was another’s righteous. The world wasn’t black and white, right and wrong. That was what the wizard’s preached. Evil, like beauty, was in the eye of the beholder.
I was not evil.
Sure, but was there a way to sacrifice a soul that wasn’t evil?
There must be."
Another thing I found interesting was how the POV kept recovering his memory through dreams as visions of events millennia in the past as he continued recovering his shattered stone heart through walking the Obsidian Path.
2022 Read
January 6, 2020
Read this one (or at least an early draft of it) back in early 2017. I've read over 100 books since then. None was better.
January 28, 2021
* This is one of the finalists for the #SPFBO and I read it as a judge*
This story is dark and tells the tale of a man (well, kind of a man) called Khaern who wakes from within the ground with little memory of his life and legacy. He's sure that he needs to find out more, and begins to slowly do so, but his tale is filled with sadness, death and loss, and he's soon to find out far more than he bargained on.
I want to mention this is definitely a grimdark tale with things like rape, flaying, blood, death, decay and more thrown quite casually into conversation and sometimes into the plot too. This is not a book for the faint of heart, and so I want to be clear that you should only pick this up if those things won't bother you greatly.
Some of the magic in this is pretty cool I admit. We see demons, necromancy, wizards and magical items. Everything fits nicely into this fantastical world, and as you uncover the story we see more of the magic and the different paths.
This is definitely an anti-hero tale told from first person with Khaern as the one who is trying to uncover just who he was and who he is now. Along the way he meets Henka and Shalayn who are two very different women with two vastly different impressions they leave on him.
This really reminded me of books by Mark Lawrence and I certainly think if you've enjoyed his grimdark stories with Jorg then you'll probably enjoy this too. I did see some of the twists coming, but that didn't lessen my enjoyment at all and I found the character easy to engage with even though they do some dispicable things. I enjoyed the journey of discovery, even when it was a dark one.
Overall, the pacing is a lot of fun and the story flows smoothly. This was easy to hook me and quick to engage the imagination, and I definitely think it's one of my more appealing grimdark reads which I think has an awful lot of potential for the rest of the story.
I've heard from many friends and reviewers that this author has a fair few titles in other series and that they're all good and I can definitely believe that after trying this. I fully plan to pick up some more by this author to try out, as I am confident I'll enjoy them too.
This one ended up as a solid 4.5/5*s which is 9/10 for #SPBFO, making it one of my top for the competition this year :)
This story is dark and tells the tale of a man (well, kind of a man) called Khaern who wakes from within the ground with little memory of his life and legacy. He's sure that he needs to find out more, and begins to slowly do so, but his tale is filled with sadness, death and loss, and he's soon to find out far more than he bargained on.
I want to mention this is definitely a grimdark tale with things like rape, flaying, blood, death, decay and more thrown quite casually into conversation and sometimes into the plot too. This is not a book for the faint of heart, and so I want to be clear that you should only pick this up if those things won't bother you greatly.
Some of the magic in this is pretty cool I admit. We see demons, necromancy, wizards and magical items. Everything fits nicely into this fantastical world, and as you uncover the story we see more of the magic and the different paths.
This is definitely an anti-hero tale told from first person with Khaern as the one who is trying to uncover just who he was and who he is now. Along the way he meets Henka and Shalayn who are two very different women with two vastly different impressions they leave on him.
This really reminded me of books by Mark Lawrence and I certainly think if you've enjoyed his grimdark stories with Jorg then you'll probably enjoy this too. I did see some of the twists coming, but that didn't lessen my enjoyment at all and I found the character easy to engage with even though they do some dispicable things. I enjoyed the journey of discovery, even when it was a dark one.
Overall, the pacing is a lot of fun and the story flows smoothly. This was easy to hook me and quick to engage the imagination, and I definitely think it's one of my more appealing grimdark reads which I think has an awful lot of potential for the rest of the story.
I've heard from many friends and reviewers that this author has a fair few titles in other series and that they're all good and I can definitely believe that after trying this. I fully plan to pick up some more by this author to try out, as I am confident I'll enjoy them too.
This one ended up as a solid 4.5/5*s which is 9/10 for #SPBFO, making it one of my top for the competition this year :)
February 23, 2020
I was born in the 80s. I spent much of my childhood in the 80s. Thus, I have a deep love for the cinema of the 80s. I have fond memories of a certain film called Highlander. I'll never forget Sean Connery's complete lack of attempt to put on a Spanish accent, and neither will I forget Christopher Lambert's equal lack of attempt to put on a Scottish accent. And, of course, I can never forget the iconic "There can be only one!" moment from the end of the film. So why do I mention this? Well, have you ever wondered what Highlander might be like if it was written by Michael R. Fletcher? No? I bet you're considering it now though. Well, wonder no more because this is it!
Honestly, this book has such a strong, interesting premise. Khraen wakes up buried alive. A young man with no memories of who he once was, or how he ended up dead and buried six feet under. And also no idea how or why he has been brought back to life. But there's a hint to follow. He's not the only one. There are other Khraens travelling the world, and each one possesses a shard of obsidian in their heart. Whenever a Khraen consumes the obsidian shard, they regain some of their memories of who they once were. So Khraen... the Khraen we follow throughout the book, sets out to kill his other selves, consumes their shards, and remember who he is.
The world is one of magic permeating ever facet of life. Wizards rule, after overthrowing the old, evil demonologist emperor. There appear to be dozens of schools of magic, and each one has its own laws and capabilities. It's a varied world, Fletcher has created with heavens, hells, ancient ruins, and a mystery hidden at its core.
It's a strong start to a new series, and I look forward to seeing where Fletcher takes it next. 4 stars.
Honestly, this book has such a strong, interesting premise. Khraen wakes up buried alive. A young man with no memories of who he once was, or how he ended up dead and buried six feet under. And also no idea how or why he has been brought back to life. But there's a hint to follow. He's not the only one. There are other Khraens travelling the world, and each one possesses a shard of obsidian in their heart. Whenever a Khraen consumes the obsidian shard, they regain some of their memories of who they once were. So Khraen... the Khraen we follow throughout the book, sets out to kill his other selves, consumes their shards, and remember who he is.
The world is one of magic permeating ever facet of life. Wizards rule, after overthrowing the old, evil demonologist emperor. There appear to be dozens of schools of magic, and each one has its own laws and capabilities. It's a varied world, Fletcher has created with heavens, hells, ancient ruins, and a mystery hidden at its core.
It's a strong start to a new series, and I look forward to seeing where Fletcher takes it next. 4 stars.
October 31, 2023
I'm retroactively adding a star after reading the rest of the trilogy. My original review stands below, but the next books redeemed the series for me. In truth, Fletcher gifted us with a wildly original dark fantasy concept and executed it with brutal flair. That might have been part of my initial dislike; it was just so different, standard epic fantasy expectations didn't properly apply. Anyway, it's an interesting ride and I highly recommend the series to grimdark fans.
**************
I expected better. I adored Fletcher's Beyond Redemption and sought out its self-published sequel The Mirror’s Truth, for which he employed the same array of editors and critiquers to produce a book of indistinguishable quality from the traditionally-published original. This book lacked the acknowledgements section that could have illuminated whether the same quality-enhancement steps were employed. I regret this, because my reaction throughout the book was that it just felt too self-published.
It's got a good concept, one that reminded me of the offbeat adventure gamebook Creature of Havoc: a blank slate of a man awakes, at first driven by instinct, then gradually learning more about his world and how he came to be where and what he was at the beginning. It seemed a cool way to worldbuild, letting the reader learn the very basics about the world along with the main character through a natural process. I liked his discovery process and need to disguise his ignorance when we and he learn that, say, mimes have ruled the world for the past 300 years (not a true fact from the book, don't worry), and where the hell have you been that you don't know this?
Sadly the story didn't live up to its potential. The main character barely seemed to develop except in his knowledge of things long lost. He has an ongoing internal ethical debate ("Am I the bad guy?") that doesn't progress; he merely recirculates the same thoughts ad nauseum. The plot progression has a certain litRPG quality to it, which is fine if that's your bag but it doesn't make for great epic fantasy. Technically it's a progression fantasy, a term some apply to stories featuring significant character power growth, but the character barely uses the knowledge and abilities that level him up from his original state. Overall the story arc felt very flat, with a couple of unsurprising twists near the end in place of a satisfying payoff. I can see potential in the sequels for exciting story, brutality, and mind-blowing magic, but I didn't have a good enough experience to push me forward.
I also did not care for the prose. It wasn't just the first-person narration, which is rarely my first choice but not a problem by itself (my beloved Assassin's Apprentice employs it, after all). In this case, I thought the writing was too plain. I'm not a fan of flowery description and generally prefer shorter, simpler sentences, but for this book the prose bored me, with a few isolated exceptions. I entertained the theory that it would mirror the protagonist's growth and become more evocative as he evolved, but this didn't pan out. I found myself fondly missing the Germanic terms that flavoured the author's Manifest Delusions series; this book could have used some of that linguistic flair.
Faith in author shaken but not shattered; maybe I'll try his other series someday. I wish I could give this one at least 3 stars but the "I liked it" designation would be dishonest.
**************
I expected better. I adored Fletcher's Beyond Redemption and sought out its self-published sequel The Mirror’s Truth, for which he employed the same array of editors and critiquers to produce a book of indistinguishable quality from the traditionally-published original. This book lacked the acknowledgements section that could have illuminated whether the same quality-enhancement steps were employed. I regret this, because my reaction throughout the book was that it just felt too self-published.
It's got a good concept, one that reminded me of the offbeat adventure gamebook Creature of Havoc: a blank slate of a man awakes, at first driven by instinct, then gradually learning more about his world and how he came to be where and what he was at the beginning. It seemed a cool way to worldbuild, letting the reader learn the very basics about the world along with the main character through a natural process. I liked his discovery process and need to disguise his ignorance when we and he learn that, say, mimes have ruled the world for the past 300 years (not a true fact from the book, don't worry), and where the hell have you been that you don't know this?
Sadly the story didn't live up to its potential. The main character barely seemed to develop except in his knowledge of things long lost. He has an ongoing internal ethical debate ("Am I the bad guy?") that doesn't progress; he merely recirculates the same thoughts ad nauseum. The plot progression has a certain litRPG quality to it, which is fine if that's your bag but it doesn't make for great epic fantasy. Technically it's a progression fantasy, a term some apply to stories featuring significant character power growth, but the character barely uses the knowledge and abilities that level him up from his original state. Overall the story arc felt very flat, with a couple of unsurprising twists near the end in place of a satisfying payoff. I can see potential in the sequels for exciting story, brutality, and mind-blowing magic, but I didn't have a good enough experience to push me forward.
I also did not care for the prose. It wasn't just the first-person narration, which is rarely my first choice but not a problem by itself (my beloved Assassin's Apprentice employs it, after all). In this case, I thought the writing was too plain. I'm not a fan of flowery description and generally prefer shorter, simpler sentences, but for this book the prose bored me, with a few isolated exceptions. I entertained the theory that it would mirror the protagonist's growth and become more evocative as he evolved, but this didn't pan out. I found myself fondly missing the Germanic terms that flavoured the author's Manifest Delusions series; this book could have used some of that linguistic flair.
Faith in author shaken but not shattered; maybe I'll try his other series someday. I wish I could give this one at least 3 stars but the "I liked it" designation would be dishonest.
November 6, 2020
I was originally introduced to Khraen in Fletcher's short story collection, released last year (among his twelve thousand other releases as of late). Khraen had several stories scattered throughout the book, each picking up at a different point in Khraen's second life. Fletcher prefaced these stories with an explanation that it is all based on a role-playing game that he and his friends played back in the day. (Likely the 1990's, when everyone was whack-o for THAC0.) So when I picked up Black Stone Heart, I thought I had a leg up on what I was in for.
Boy, was I wrong.
Fletch has introduced a dark, massive, and intriguing world that spans millennia. It toys with necromancy, human sacrifice, world-domination, and soul-cannibalism.
But at the at the stone-cold, black heart of it all, lies the question, what is evil? How is it defined? How can its relativity be judged from one man to another? And most interesting is watching the justification of Khraen's sliding scale of morality, as his "I'll never sink that low" to "well, I have to do that for the greater good" becomes a steeper and steeper decline. The horrifying and tricky part that Fletch pulls off is how he got me to nod my head in agreement with Khraen's actions along the way.
Maybe I shouldn't have admitted that out loud. But this is what Fletcher has excelled at throughout his writing career. He has a way of making the reader dig down into a part of us that we don't want to face, but we know exists, and brings feelings that we fear most into focus. How evil would we sink if backed into a corner? How far would be go to survive? To protect the ones we love?
But it's not all doom and gloom. It's a pretty kickass adventure, too. There's heists, and romance (of the Fletcher variety), and knife fights, and wizard magic, and artifacts, and demons, and all sorts of fun stuff.
So, read the book! It's good! And sets up some pretty badass things to come.
Boy, was I wrong.
Fletch has introduced a dark, massive, and intriguing world that spans millennia. It toys with necromancy, human sacrifice, world-domination, and soul-cannibalism.
But at the at the stone-cold, black heart of it all, lies the question, what is evil? How is it defined? How can its relativity be judged from one man to another? And most interesting is watching the justification of Khraen's sliding scale of morality, as his "I'll never sink that low" to "well, I have to do that for the greater good" becomes a steeper and steeper decline. The horrifying and tricky part that Fletch pulls off is how he got me to nod my head in agreement with Khraen's actions along the way.
Maybe I shouldn't have admitted that out loud. But this is what Fletcher has excelled at throughout his writing career. He has a way of making the reader dig down into a part of us that we don't want to face, but we know exists, and brings feelings that we fear most into focus. How evil would we sink if backed into a corner? How far would be go to survive? To protect the ones we love?
But it's not all doom and gloom. It's a pretty kickass adventure, too. There's heists, and romance (of the Fletcher variety), and knife fights, and wizard magic, and artifacts, and demons, and all sorts of fun stuff.
So, read the book! It's good! And sets up some pretty badass things to come.
June 24, 2020
Review now live at Grimdark Magazine
Black Stone Heart is the latest grimdark novel by Michael R. Fletcher. This is a brand-new series, The Obsidian Path, which is set in a bizarre new world unlike those of Fletcher’s other work. There were a couple of stories in A Collection of Obsessions, his short story collection, but this is the first full length novel.
As with all of Fletcher’s work, Black Stone Heart does not shy away from a steady diet of comfort food for the grimdark appetite. His recipe is equal parts violence, gritty happenings, grisly humor, and a dash of bad luck for flavoring.
Khraen just woke up, and he’s starving. He’s confused and disoriented and doesn’t remember much at all of his life before he’d been killed. All he knows now is that he is being drawn to the fragments of his obsidian heart that have been scattered about the world by whoever it was that murdered him.
During the course of this novel, we travel with Khraen as he tells the story in first person, learning what we can of his life before as he does, picking up a bit here and there with each fragment of his stone heart as he finds it. His memories return with each piece, as do his talents and his awareness of who and what he was.
This book is an interesting study of a dark character, a villain from most perspectives, as he comes to grip with what he was, what he is now, and what he hopes to become as he pieces himself back together bit by bit. Will he become the demonist emperor that ruled a vast empire over several millennia, or will he learn to be a better man through his experiences today and forced humility? Sorcery and necromancy abound in the battle for Khraen’s quest and the very nature of his soul.
With twists and turns and the general mindfuckery that we come to expect from Michael R. Fletcher, we go on this wild ride with Khraen, not knowing if we’ll be uplifted or disappointed, or both. Much as Khraen himself must prepare for who he becomes and the legacy he’d left behind during his previous life which hangs over him now. Can he be a better man? Does he truly want to?
Here’s a little example of Fletcher’s writing, the way he can twist a dark happening into a lively bit of humor, still grisly in its content but light in the tone as he spins it:
“After killing the farmer’s horses, we rode them south, exchanging our dead mounts for new ones whenever their appearance decayed to the point they became recognizable as corpses.”
Black Stone Heart doesn’t disappoint the returning Fletcher reader. It’s much different in scope and perspective than earlier work but keeps the consistent tone and writing flow that we’ve come to look forward to with each new story. New readers will be just as entertained and will likely flock to his back catalogue as soon as they finish this one. But all readers will probably wonder about Fletcher’s sanity before it’s all over.
Black Stone Heart is the latest grimdark novel by Michael R. Fletcher. This is a brand-new series, The Obsidian Path, which is set in a bizarre new world unlike those of Fletcher’s other work. There were a couple of stories in A Collection of Obsessions, his short story collection, but this is the first full length novel.
As with all of Fletcher’s work, Black Stone Heart does not shy away from a steady diet of comfort food for the grimdark appetite. His recipe is equal parts violence, gritty happenings, grisly humor, and a dash of bad luck for flavoring.
Khraen just woke up, and he’s starving. He’s confused and disoriented and doesn’t remember much at all of his life before he’d been killed. All he knows now is that he is being drawn to the fragments of his obsidian heart that have been scattered about the world by whoever it was that murdered him.
During the course of this novel, we travel with Khraen as he tells the story in first person, learning what we can of his life before as he does, picking up a bit here and there with each fragment of his stone heart as he finds it. His memories return with each piece, as do his talents and his awareness of who and what he was.
This book is an interesting study of a dark character, a villain from most perspectives, as he comes to grip with what he was, what he is now, and what he hopes to become as he pieces himself back together bit by bit. Will he become the demonist emperor that ruled a vast empire over several millennia, or will he learn to be a better man through his experiences today and forced humility? Sorcery and necromancy abound in the battle for Khraen’s quest and the very nature of his soul.
With twists and turns and the general mindfuckery that we come to expect from Michael R. Fletcher, we go on this wild ride with Khraen, not knowing if we’ll be uplifted or disappointed, or both. Much as Khraen himself must prepare for who he becomes and the legacy he’d left behind during his previous life which hangs over him now. Can he be a better man? Does he truly want to?
Here’s a little example of Fletcher’s writing, the way he can twist a dark happening into a lively bit of humor, still grisly in its content but light in the tone as he spins it:
“After killing the farmer’s horses, we rode them south, exchanging our dead mounts for new ones whenever their appearance decayed to the point they became recognizable as corpses.”
Black Stone Heart doesn’t disappoint the returning Fletcher reader. It’s much different in scope and perspective than earlier work but keeps the consistent tone and writing flow that we’ve come to look forward to with each new story. New readers will be just as entertained and will likely flock to his back catalogue as soon as they finish this one. But all readers will probably wonder about Fletcher’s sanity before it’s all over.
August 23, 2022
Another example of Fletcher's mind-blowing imagination, completely different from his other books except there's also plenty of blood and violence, and with his signature super unique concept at the core of the story.
Our MC wakes without memories but slowly discovers that pieces of his obsidian heart (literally) are scattered throughout the world and hold all of his missing memories. So we Quest. And we battle right and wrong, good and evil, destiny and free will, truth and lies. Leaving innumerable corpses in our wake.
I didn't give it 5 stars because our MC felt too neutral with an almost non-existent personality, making him less fun than previous Fletcher heroes. However, I'm guessing this is because he doesn't have memories and therefore isn't sure who he is. Hopefully he'll flesh out as we go.
Warning: have book 2 at the ready because this ends in a major cliffhanger and you'll want to be prepared.
Our MC wakes without memories but slowly discovers that pieces of his obsidian heart (literally) are scattered throughout the world and hold all of his missing memories. So we Quest. And we battle right and wrong, good and evil, destiny and free will, truth and lies. Leaving innumerable corpses in our wake.
I didn't give it 5 stars because our MC felt too neutral with an almost non-existent personality, making him less fun than previous Fletcher heroes. However, I'm guessing this is because he doesn't have memories and therefore isn't sure who he is. Hopefully he'll flesh out as we go.
Warning: have book 2 at the ready because this ends in a major cliffhanger and you'll want to be prepared.
April 4, 2020
Black Stone Heart is Fletcher's best novel to date, and that is really saying something coming from someone who can't stop talking about Beyond Redemption.
An unforgettable story; one that cuts with the sharpest of blades and heals with the finest of salves. You will not be unmoved.
Khraen may be one of the best protagonists to hit the fantasy scene since Logen Ninefingers.
I had the opportunity to read Black Stone Heart (The Obsidian Path #1) a couple of years ago before it even had a title. The fact that I still remember every aspect of this story should tell you how much of an impact it had on me; not only an immersive read, but an emotionally charged one.
An unforgettable story; one that cuts with the sharpest of blades and heals with the finest of salves. You will not be unmoved.
Khraen may be one of the best protagonists to hit the fantasy scene since Logen Ninefingers.
I had the opportunity to read Black Stone Heart (The Obsidian Path #1) a couple of years ago before it even had a title. The fact that I still remember every aspect of this story should tell you how much of an impact it had on me; not only an immersive read, but an emotionally charged one.
March 23, 2020
A new series by Michael R Fletcher!! This one follows Khraen. We experience the world through his eyes, just one POV. Khraen wakes up under the earth and crawls out, remembering nothing. Some instincts are left, things at the tip of his tongue that he can't seem to reach. And a strange urge, a tug towards something farther away. He finds out he needs to collect these black shards, pieces of his heart that contain memory of who he was. And so he starts his journey, following that strange tug. The shards are not just loose somewhere some are protected, others tucked into a heart. It isn't easy, while he slowly relearns how to be around other people and finding out things about his past he meets a woman who he falls in love with. He is stuck in a 19 year old body and has urges. I didn't entirely connect with this 19 year old body being distracted by sexual urges and exploring ! It wasn't bad either it did go easily in the flow of the story. Subjective matter here. It was a bit much for me. Aside from that there was also loads of magic, wizards....Khraen loaths them. And necromancers with awesome dead companions. I love that we have a necromancer as a larger character in the plot as well. And at some point demons. While Khraen collects more and more about himself he struggles with his past self. He doesn't want to be evil and kill, should he collect all the stones? Will he change when he remembers everything, is it unavoidable to kill...
The story kept me hooked! It started so mysterious with Khraen knowing little of who we was, and as a reader knowing nothing about the world and the MC. It was fun to start collecting his memories, as always the writing is awesome! Loved the gore which is always delivered by Fletcher, fking loved it again! Excited for more demons and Khraen puzzling himself out more. Hope we get some more Nhil, his demon friend from what I remember ( brain mush and headache makes a mess while reading, hence adding some more to the review now ). And I am curious who broke his heart into pieces and hid them away.
The story kept me hooked! It started so mysterious with Khraen knowing little of who we was, and as a reader knowing nothing about the world and the MC. It was fun to start collecting his memories, as always the writing is awesome! Loved the gore which is always delivered by Fletcher, fking loved it again! Excited for more demons and Khraen puzzling himself out more. Hope we get some more Nhil, his demon friend from what I remember ( brain mush and headache makes a mess while reading, hence adding some more to the review now ). And I am curious who broke his heart into pieces and hid them away.
February 24, 2020
When Khraen wakes up, he has almost no memories of his past. It included violence, murder, and hacking his own chest open but other than that? Hard to say.
He doesn’t act like a human being; rather as a savage creature focused on survival, living off bugs and roots. Only after finding an obsidian shard that pierces his skin and finds its way to his heart, he regains parts of his identity.
His integration into the local society gets tricky, especially that he has no marketable skills beyond killing children and women. His actions stem from the urge to follow the remaining shards of his heart scattered around the world. After getting each shard Khraen undergoes a painful process of integration during which he regains some memories of the past. And with them comes a growing sense of unease - it’s possible people hate him for a reason other than the color of his skin. It’s possible his past actions had disastrous consequences.
With its breakneck pace, excellent banter, wild twists and reveals, Black Stone Hearts bullies you into liking it. There’s no time not to. Things happen and they are exciting. Yes, I know that I write vaguely about this book but I do it out of a desire not to spoil it. The plot is fairly simple (protagonist and narrator regains parts of his heart, gets drunk and laid, regains his memories, travels to impossible places, meets old friends and foes, discovers his violent past) and most of the fun comes from experiencing events with Khraen and seeing how they change him. Fletcher has a knack for characterization and, surprisingly, for crafting entertaining and dark comedy. It’s a dark book and yet it made me laugh multiple times.
He brilliantly captures the change of Khraen’s voice as he ponders on his identity and the essence of identity in general. Each new Shard allows Khraen to reassemble himself and regain his memories. If you’ve already read Fletcher, you know better than to expect happy endings and uplifting mood. Here, though, the darker side of the story hides behind the darkly humorous voice.
Make no mistake, Khraen and his companions aren’t good guys (although one question Fletcher asks is about the nature of evil - is a predator evil when it feeds itself to survive?). One of them, a necromancer, harvests people to repair herself. She treats people as a source of parts.
Black Stone Heart is, above all, addictive and compulsively readable - it forced me to prolong my lunch as much as I dared because I couldn’t bear to stop reading it. If anything depended on me, I would forbid Fletcher to work on anything but The Obsidian Path series. I need the sequel.
It’s clear I’m biased. For the sake of objectivity, I have to say it probably won’t appeal to readers tired of over-the-topness, violence, and a certain level of predictability (those two final surprises weren’t really exactly shocking). I loved it too much to care, though, and felt fully immersed in the narrative.
He doesn’t act like a human being; rather as a savage creature focused on survival, living off bugs and roots. Only after finding an obsidian shard that pierces his skin and finds its way to his heart, he regains parts of his identity.
His integration into the local society gets tricky, especially that he has no marketable skills beyond killing children and women. His actions stem from the urge to follow the remaining shards of his heart scattered around the world. After getting each shard Khraen undergoes a painful process of integration during which he regains some memories of the past. And with them comes a growing sense of unease - it’s possible people hate him for a reason other than the color of his skin. It’s possible his past actions had disastrous consequences.
With its breakneck pace, excellent banter, wild twists and reveals, Black Stone Hearts bullies you into liking it. There’s no time not to. Things happen and they are exciting. Yes, I know that I write vaguely about this book but I do it out of a desire not to spoil it. The plot is fairly simple (protagonist and narrator regains parts of his heart, gets drunk and laid, regains his memories, travels to impossible places, meets old friends and foes, discovers his violent past) and most of the fun comes from experiencing events with Khraen and seeing how they change him. Fletcher has a knack for characterization and, surprisingly, for crafting entertaining and dark comedy. It’s a dark book and yet it made me laugh multiple times.
He brilliantly captures the change of Khraen’s voice as he ponders on his identity and the essence of identity in general. Each new Shard allows Khraen to reassemble himself and regain his memories. If you’ve already read Fletcher, you know better than to expect happy endings and uplifting mood. Here, though, the darker side of the story hides behind the darkly humorous voice.
Make no mistake, Khraen and his companions aren’t good guys (although one question Fletcher asks is about the nature of evil - is a predator evil when it feeds itself to survive?). One of them, a necromancer, harvests people to repair herself. She treats people as a source of parts.
Black Stone Heart is, above all, addictive and compulsively readable - it forced me to prolong my lunch as much as I dared because I couldn’t bear to stop reading it. If anything depended on me, I would forbid Fletcher to work on anything but The Obsidian Path series. I need the sequel.
It’s clear I’m biased. For the sake of objectivity, I have to say it probably won’t appeal to readers tired of over-the-topness, violence, and a certain level of predictability (those two final surprises weren’t really exactly shocking). I loved it too much to care, though, and felt fully immersed in the narrative.
March 20, 2020
In “Black Stone Heart” Michael Fletcher has delivered a really dark story that gets deeper the longer you’re in its grasp. Khraen, the main character, starts off knowing basically nothing about himself or the wider world. He is looking for obsidian shards that seem to be holding the secrets of his past. On that quest he slowly starts to explore and learn not just about what happened before, but also about the world. And while we get to follow his plot, and his world, his distinctive voice get stronger and stronger until it feels like you really are inside the story. I especially liked how Khraen feels like a piece of unworked clay and his personality only slowly evolves. Not a bad person, but finding himself alone and without memory he also doesn’t have any imprinted moral code, so it’s very intriguing to see how this character is gaining his own personality. The – expected since this is a book by Michael R. Fletcher – descent into darkness is so naturally and gradually done that you hardly notice how you start to root for someone who definitely is not a hero. But he’s just doing what the situation demands, isn’t he? Is he?
Once again Michael Fletcher manages to spellbind you into this grimdark spiral of madness, and yet it feels so very fluent and logical it makes you take a double take at your own thoughts and emotions. The story is perfectly balanced on a fine edge, it holds the reader’s attention all the way as the characters grow, develop and come alive in your mind.
“Black Stone Heart” is set in a medieval style world with wizards, necromancers and demons. It’s familiar enough to allow the reader to dive right in, and yet has enough new things to discover, so it always keeps up the interest. And it isn’t limited to just that one plane of existence either…
I can’t recommend this one enough for anyone who likes a book without a clear black and white (or really any black and white) world, and isn’t squeamish about gore, sex and violence in their books.
Who was I? The kind of person who thought only of themselves? The kind of person who abandoned those in need?
I realized I’d asked the wrong question. Why let my unknown past define me?
It wasn’t, ‘Who was I?’ but rather, ‘Who am I?’
And still, I hesitated.
Once again Michael Fletcher manages to spellbind you into this grimdark spiral of madness, and yet it feels so very fluent and logical it makes you take a double take at your own thoughts and emotions. The story is perfectly balanced on a fine edge, it holds the reader’s attention all the way as the characters grow, develop and come alive in your mind.
“Black Stone Heart” is set in a medieval style world with wizards, necromancers and demons. It’s familiar enough to allow the reader to dive right in, and yet has enough new things to discover, so it always keeps up the interest. And it isn’t limited to just that one plane of existence either…
I can’t recommend this one enough for anyone who likes a book without a clear black and white (or really any black and white) world, and isn’t squeamish about gore, sex and violence in their books.
July 2, 2022
4.5/5
A fast paced and well written grimdark novel...
Black stone heart, first entry in The Obsidian Path series follows the journey of Khraen who wakes up after a millennia with no past memories and soon finds out that his obsidian heart has been shattered into pieces and has been spread throughout the world. When he consume each obsidian pieces he regains a sliver of his past. On this journey of literal self discovery (😅) he met Shalayn and Henka who leaves a very distinct impression on him and raises a question within himself "Does he want to be his past self ?"
Fair warning though, this book is Dark like really really dark. Brutal killings, Flaying, Sacrifices and much more are mentioned in this book. But I personally believe its necessary for this book to get that immersive feeling of this brutal world.
The author's writing was simple and elegant and the pacing was just spectacular, not a single page felt out of place or unnecessary. Pacing was definitely the strongest aspect of this book without a doubt.
The main character Khraen was written in a way that makes you question his every decisions especially in the last 100 pages but makes you root for him nonetheless. But for the supporting characters, I felt they could've been fleshed out more.
Only thing that bothered me about this book is the revelations. I saw almost all of the revelation a mile ago but it didn't hinder my reading experience at all.
To sum it up, Black stone heart is a near perfect grimdark novel which leaves a lot of territories to be covered in the sequels that I'm too eager to start next.
A fast paced and well written grimdark novel...
Black stone heart, first entry in The Obsidian Path series follows the journey of Khraen who wakes up after a millennia with no past memories and soon finds out that his obsidian heart has been shattered into pieces and has been spread throughout the world. When he consume each obsidian pieces he regains a sliver of his past. On this journey of literal self discovery (😅) he met Shalayn and Henka who leaves a very distinct impression on him and raises a question within himself "Does he want to be his past self ?"
Fair warning though, this book is Dark like really really dark. Brutal killings, Flaying, Sacrifices and much more are mentioned in this book. But I personally believe its necessary for this book to get that immersive feeling of this brutal world.
The author's writing was simple and elegant and the pacing was just spectacular, not a single page felt out of place or unnecessary. Pacing was definitely the strongest aspect of this book without a doubt.
The main character Khraen was written in a way that makes you question his every decisions especially in the last 100 pages but makes you root for him nonetheless. But for the supporting characters, I felt they could've been fleshed out more.
Only thing that bothered me about this book is the revelations. I saw almost all of the revelation a mile ago but it didn't hinder my reading experience at all.
To sum it up, Black stone heart is a near perfect grimdark novel which leaves a lot of territories to be covered in the sequels that I'm too eager to start next.
January 8, 2020
I just finished editing this book and to say it kicked my ass (in the best way) is an understatement. This book is AMAZING and INTENSE and DARK and WEIRD and all those delightful things that Fletcher is known for. However, after reading a whole bunch of his books, and editing a few others, I've come to the conclusion that this is his best book yet.
I can't stop thinking about it, to be quiet honest with you, and I'm frankly a bit pissed off at him that book two isn't ready to be read yet. Selfish, I know, but SERIOUSLY. Dude has to write something THIS GOOD and keep me waiting to see what happens next? Fletcher, I protest the injustice.
I can't stop thinking about it, to be quiet honest with you, and I'm frankly a bit pissed off at him that book two isn't ready to be read yet. Selfish, I know, but SERIOUSLY. Dude has to write something THIS GOOD and keep me waiting to see what happens next? Fletcher, I protest the injustice.
February 21, 2023
“Maybe I worried about nothing. Maybe there was no invisible hand hiding me along this obsidian path”.
Muchas veces lees un libro cuando menos te lo esperas y justamente me ha pasado con este en concreto. A decir verdad, no pensaba leerlo hasta pasado un buen tiempo, sobre todo porque tengo mil trilogías abiertas y quien me conoce sabe que soy un desastre. Sin embargo, se me cruzaron los cables y lo empecé de casualidad cuando leí el prologo y no me parecía que fuese tan difícil de leer en inglés.
“Evil.
I didn’t like that word. So judgemental. One man’s evil was another’s righteous. The world wasn’t black or white, right and wrong. That was what the wizard’s preached. Evil, like beauty, was in the eye of the beholder. ”
Esta novela y, desgraciadamente ninguna de este autor se encuentra traducida al español. Ahora, en cuanto al nivel de inglés de la novela, yo lo encuadro en un B2 (intermedio-avanzado). Justamente, tenía la premisa que sería mucho más denso y complicado, sin embargo, como dije al inicio, fue una sorpresa ver que en realidad era más “fácil” de lo esperado. Me explico: el libro está contado en forma de diario desde el punto de vista del protagonista, no utiliza un vocabulario especifico de la novela ni tampoco se extiende en descripciones minuciosas. Así que, para aquellos que está acostumbrados a leer en inglés o están adentrándose en novelas de este tipo se las recomiendo. Al resto, espero que pronto se presente una traducción.
“Nothing. That’s what scares me. Nothing is more terrifying than nothing. Sometimes I want it, I crave it. And end. But I can’t. I’m too scared. How long I would lie there, bones in the earth, helpless, alone, waiting? What if I never became nothing? What if I was stuck there forever, slowly sinking deeper, further from the light and life of the world, unable to return? I can’t chance it. I need purpose”.
Ahora, en cuanto a la novela en sí, me gustaría decir muchas cosas, pero, siento que destriparía parte de la historia y lo que esconde. Así que voy a intentar ser lo más breve posible porque lo dicho siento que cualquier cosa que se diga pueda considerarse como “spoiler” sobre todo para mí, que a la mínima que se me comenté algo sobre el contenido del libro, por muy banal que sea me molesta. Llámenme “rancia” como se diría coloquialmente, pero soy así y es algo que no soporto.
Asimismo, la historia es interesante y me ha parecido bastante original. Lo único es que me ha faltado un mapa, así como un poco más de desarrollo del wordbuilding. Sin embargo, lo que más destaco son los personajes, nunca me había encontrado con unos personajes tan grises, y yo que pensaba que los de La Primera Ley o los de La Compañía Negra lo eran, pero estos igual están a un nivel superior. Además, me puede que el protagonista se plantee si sus actos son buenos o malos moralmente y las reflexiones sobre ello.
“Pherhaps I can’t win, but I can make their victory expensive. Maybe I can cost them everything”.
En cuanto al desarrollo del argumento se me ha hecho en algún parte un poco lento al mismo tiempo que me esperaba otra cosa. Asimismo, algunos giros de la novela me los he visto venir, mientras que otros no me los quería esperar porque me hubieran parecido demasiado morbosos, por así decirlo. Con eso no digo nada, pero al mismo tiempo lo digo todo (cuando lean la novela me entenderán).
“Maybe even the worst people need someone, need to know they aren’t alone in this world”.
No le pongo las cinco estrellas porque como he dicho antes ha habido cosas que me han faltado, pero me lo he pasado bien leyéndolo. Supongo que ha sido un aire fresco de tanta novela romántica últimamente. Aunque, a decir verdad, me hubiera gustado haberlo leído en otro momento porque no me encuentro en mi mejor momento, pero bueno, lo hecho, hecho está.
“There’s no end to sorrow”.
Muchas veces lees un libro cuando menos te lo esperas y justamente me ha pasado con este en concreto. A decir verdad, no pensaba leerlo hasta pasado un buen tiempo, sobre todo porque tengo mil trilogías abiertas y quien me conoce sabe que soy un desastre. Sin embargo, se me cruzaron los cables y lo empecé de casualidad cuando leí el prologo y no me parecía que fuese tan difícil de leer en inglés.
“Evil.
I didn’t like that word. So judgemental. One man’s evil was another’s righteous. The world wasn’t black or white, right and wrong. That was what the wizard’s preached. Evil, like beauty, was in the eye of the beholder. ”
Esta novela y, desgraciadamente ninguna de este autor se encuentra traducida al español. Ahora, en cuanto al nivel de inglés de la novela, yo lo encuadro en un B2 (intermedio-avanzado). Justamente, tenía la premisa que sería mucho más denso y complicado, sin embargo, como dije al inicio, fue una sorpresa ver que en realidad era más “fácil” de lo esperado. Me explico: el libro está contado en forma de diario desde el punto de vista del protagonista, no utiliza un vocabulario especifico de la novela ni tampoco se extiende en descripciones minuciosas. Así que, para aquellos que está acostumbrados a leer en inglés o están adentrándose en novelas de este tipo se las recomiendo. Al resto, espero que pronto se presente una traducción.
“Nothing. That’s what scares me. Nothing is more terrifying than nothing. Sometimes I want it, I crave it. And end. But I can’t. I’m too scared. How long I would lie there, bones in the earth, helpless, alone, waiting? What if I never became nothing? What if I was stuck there forever, slowly sinking deeper, further from the light and life of the world, unable to return? I can’t chance it. I need purpose”.
Ahora, en cuanto a la novela en sí, me gustaría decir muchas cosas, pero, siento que destriparía parte de la historia y lo que esconde. Así que voy a intentar ser lo más breve posible porque lo dicho siento que cualquier cosa que se diga pueda considerarse como “spoiler” sobre todo para mí, que a la mínima que se me comenté algo sobre el contenido del libro, por muy banal que sea me molesta. Llámenme “rancia” como se diría coloquialmente, pero soy así y es algo que no soporto.
Asimismo, la historia es interesante y me ha parecido bastante original. Lo único es que me ha faltado un mapa, así como un poco más de desarrollo del wordbuilding. Sin embargo, lo que más destaco son los personajes, nunca me había encontrado con unos personajes tan grises, y yo que pensaba que los de La Primera Ley o los de La Compañía Negra lo eran, pero estos igual están a un nivel superior. Además, me puede que el protagonista se plantee si sus actos son buenos o malos moralmente y las reflexiones sobre ello.
“Pherhaps I can’t win, but I can make their victory expensive. Maybe I can cost them everything”.
En cuanto al desarrollo del argumento se me ha hecho en algún parte un poco lento al mismo tiempo que me esperaba otra cosa. Asimismo, algunos giros de la novela me los he visto venir, mientras que otros no me los quería esperar porque me hubieran parecido demasiado morbosos, por así decirlo. Con eso no digo nada, pero al mismo tiempo lo digo todo (cuando lean la novela me entenderán).
“Maybe even the worst people need someone, need to know they aren’t alone in this world”.
No le pongo las cinco estrellas porque como he dicho antes ha habido cosas que me han faltado, pero me lo he pasado bien leyéndolo. Supongo que ha sido un aire fresco de tanta novela romántica últimamente. Aunque, a decir verdad, me hubiera gustado haberlo leído en otro momento porque no me encuentro en mi mejor momento, pero bueno, lo hecho, hecho está.
“There’s no end to sorrow”.
May 9, 2024
Tutti e tre i colpi di scena (piú che altro le rivelazioni) del finale erano largamente prevedibili. Su questo aspetto Fletcher deve impegnarsi di più, ma in linea di massima il libro è stato una lettura valida - dura e cruda - ma valida.
Non so se leggerò il seguito, diciamo che questo "Sentiero di ossidiana" intrapreso dal protagonista è un boccone duro da digerire. Devo capire se mi andrà di percorrerlo con Khraen, oppure una stretta di mano e buona fortuna.
Non so se leggerò il seguito, diciamo che questo "Sentiero di ossidiana" intrapreso dal protagonista è un boccone duro da digerire. Devo capire se mi andrà di percorrerlo con Khraen, oppure una stretta di mano e buona fortuna.
November 16, 2020
Black Stone Heart deserves more than the five stars that the rating scale is limited by. Everything that I love about Fletcher's stories-twisted characters, the intricate world-building, and his imagination - is amplified tenfold in his new series. If you enjoy grimdark, this book should be in your library.
The measure of one's wickedness lies somewhere between their victim's perspective and their own justification. Black Stone Heart is the story of self-discovery within violence and profound immorality. It was a very unique experience reading a character that has been reduced to his most rudimentary foundation. Khraen has been reborn but stripped of his memories and beliefs. As he continues to learn more about his past, his developing character clashes between the man he was and who he desperately wants to be. His character arch explores the bargaining tactics, the lies used to rationalize acts of war.
The land of Taramlae is etched into my mind. It is not all magic that makes this world distinctive, it is the people's hostility and unified xenophobia. With their fears deeply rooted in their own dark history, Khraen is marked and targeted by their discrimination. The scattered pieces of his heart reveal his past, but it is Taramlae's hatred that imbeds into his character.
The measure of one's wickedness lies somewhere between their victim's perspective and their own justification. Black Stone Heart is the story of self-discovery within violence and profound immorality. It was a very unique experience reading a character that has been reduced to his most rudimentary foundation. Khraen has been reborn but stripped of his memories and beliefs. As he continues to learn more about his past, his developing character clashes between the man he was and who he desperately wants to be. His character arch explores the bargaining tactics, the lies used to rationalize acts of war.
The land of Taramlae is etched into my mind. It is not all magic that makes this world distinctive, it is the people's hostility and unified xenophobia. With their fears deeply rooted in their own dark history, Khraen is marked and targeted by their discrimination. The scattered pieces of his heart reveal his past, but it is Taramlae's hatred that imbeds into his character.
May 13, 2022
BOOKS LIKE THIS ARE WHY I READ FANTASY! This is the genre that gives you the ability to do virtually whatever you want, and Fletcher’s imagination knows no bounds. Earlier this year I read the 3 available Manifest Delusions books, then later read Ghosts of Tomorrow. The Manifest Delusions series instantly put Fletcher in my highest tier of authors, and Ghosts of Tomorrow did not disappoint either. I held back on reading the rest of his books because I did not want to run out. But here I am, because I have no self control, and I do not regret it one bit.
I feel like the best way to read this book is to know as little as possible (I didn’t even read the synopsis, I saw Fletcher’s name and said “I’m in!”). I would just give the warning that this book can get pretty horrific and gross, which I happen to love in my fiction. Beyond that, it is hard to describe what exactly makes this book click for me, because I really just find myself loving every decision Fletcher makes. If you’re a lover of dark fantasy and don’t mind following a detestable (but fascinating) protagonist, I would call this a must read. And make sure you check out the metal songs he has made for the book on YouTube. Yeah you read that right… I mean how cool is this guy?
I feel like the best way to read this book is to know as little as possible (I didn’t even read the synopsis, I saw Fletcher’s name and said “I’m in!”). I would just give the warning that this book can get pretty horrific and gross, which I happen to love in my fiction. Beyond that, it is hard to describe what exactly makes this book click for me, because I really just find myself loving every decision Fletcher makes. If you’re a lover of dark fantasy and don’t mind following a detestable (but fascinating) protagonist, I would call this a must read. And make sure you check out the metal songs he has made for the book on YouTube. Yeah you read that right… I mean how cool is this guy?
April 20, 2021
Review is on The Fantasy Hive blog for SPFBO 6
July 31, 2024
Fletcher's Black Stone Heart tells a more 'traditional' grimdark tale than his mind warping Beyond Redemption, but I really enjoyed it as well. Our protagonist, Khraen, starts the tale waking up underground and digging himself out. We soon learn that he survived on bugs and tree sap for over 1000 years, and finally gained the strength to return to the world. Yet, he has no idea who he is (he does not even know his name yet); pure survival instinct. He wanders for some time, living on bugs and roots, until he finds a ramshackle shack. Well, he kills the owner and lives there for a few years, gradually gaining strength after a better diet (he also found traps, a bow, etc.), until one day someone else wanders up to the shack. Strange-- it looks just like him! Confused, he attacks the guy and kills him, cuts out his heart and finds a sliver of obsidian in it, which immediately sinks into his flesh and eventually to his heart. With the new piece of his heart, he learns his name and a few other memories, but so many holes. What an opening sequence!
I will not provide a blow by blow here, but the overall picture soon emerges. 3000 years ago, a great war between the wizards and the Demon Emperor convulsed the world and tore it into fragments. The few survivors gradually organized themselves and now live in a kingdom ruled by the wizards. What started the great war? Who knows. Khraen eventually finds his way south to a small town and begins his real journey-- other pieces of his obsidian heart call to him and he knows that each piece will restore more of his memory...
What makes this so readable concerns the internal struggle Khraen finds himself in. He meets a woman guard on the caravan heading south from the village to the big city and starts to learn about himself. He knows so little! He constantly struggles with his desire to be a good person, which may or may not conflict with the memories of who or what he was. He soon discovers he was the Demon Emperor, who ruled civilization for 10,000 years, but that civilization came with a cost. To summon and bind demons, it takes human souls in sacrifice, and that civilization used demons for just about everything-- water, light, power-- that maintained it, and of course, that took a lot of souls! Do the ends justify the means? What does that say about him?
Wizards, on the other hand, obtain their power from chaos via study and mediation-- no souls needed. People have learned to hate the Demon Emperor and demonologists in general, as well as others associated with the prior realm, such as necromancers and elementalists. Eventually, Khraen meets up with a necromancer and kinda falls in love. Yet, she needs human blood almost daily to 'stay warm' and stave off rot (she is dead herself, even as she can enslave other dead beings). Khraen needs souls to summon demons for his powers, but his morality makes this a challenge. Yes, they can work together, with her getting the blood she need and him the souls, but of course this entails bodies by the score!
My main complaint concerns the ending of the tale, a massive cliff hanger, just as the story started to really heat up. I know this is simply the first installment of a trilogy, but outside of a few key reveals (and boy are they killer!) Fletcher leaves the reader hanging. Superb world building with minimal prose and Fletcher gives this a real visceral feel. I also really enjoyed the occasional illustrations. Looking forward to continuing walking down the Obsidian Path to see where this will go. 4 black stones!
I will not provide a blow by blow here, but the overall picture soon emerges. 3000 years ago, a great war between the wizards and the Demon Emperor convulsed the world and tore it into fragments. The few survivors gradually organized themselves and now live in a kingdom ruled by the wizards. What started the great war? Who knows. Khraen eventually finds his way south to a small town and begins his real journey-- other pieces of his obsidian heart call to him and he knows that each piece will restore more of his memory...
What makes this so readable concerns the internal struggle Khraen finds himself in. He meets a woman guard on the caravan heading south from the village to the big city and starts to learn about himself. He knows so little! He constantly struggles with his desire to be a good person, which may or may not conflict with the memories of who or what he was. He soon discovers he was the Demon Emperor, who ruled civilization for 10,000 years, but that civilization came with a cost. To summon and bind demons, it takes human souls in sacrifice, and that civilization used demons for just about everything-- water, light, power-- that maintained it, and of course, that took a lot of souls! Do the ends justify the means? What does that say about him?
Wizards, on the other hand, obtain their power from chaos via study and mediation-- no souls needed. People have learned to hate the Demon Emperor and demonologists in general, as well as others associated with the prior realm, such as necromancers and elementalists. Eventually, Khraen meets up with a necromancer and kinda falls in love. Yet, she needs human blood almost daily to 'stay warm' and stave off rot (she is dead herself, even as she can enslave other dead beings). Khraen needs souls to summon demons for his powers, but his morality makes this a challenge. Yes, they can work together, with her getting the blood she need and him the souls, but of course this entails bodies by the score!
My main complaint concerns the ending of the tale, a massive cliff hanger, just as the story started to really heat up. I know this is simply the first installment of a trilogy, but outside of a few key reveals (and boy are they killer!) Fletcher leaves the reader hanging. Superb world building with minimal prose and Fletcher gives this a real visceral feel. I also really enjoyed the occasional illustrations. Looking forward to continuing walking down the Obsidian Path to see where this will go. 4 black stones!
March 25, 2023
This was a bit of an odd read for me, probably because it wasn't really what I was expecting. Saying that though, the synopsis doesn't really give you much to go on and the back of the book has even fewer clues, so perhaps I don't know what it was that I was actually expecting in the first place.
There was some weird and interesting stuff in here, in particular with the necromancy, but I quite like the side of the power that was on show here – I felt it was quite different and definitely intriguing.
It's the sort of book that makes you have to piece everything together as you go, with a character who is very much in the dark to start off with. This allowed for some nice little reveals towards the end that I thought worked quite well.
I've heard this called a "romantic grimdark comedy", but I didn't really get any of those individual elements from reading it, or at least not nearly enough to use them as labels for the book. It was however, quite an interesting read overall.
There was some weird and interesting stuff in here, in particular with the necromancy, but I quite like the side of the power that was on show here – I felt it was quite different and definitely intriguing.
It's the sort of book that makes you have to piece everything together as you go, with a character who is very much in the dark to start off with. This allowed for some nice little reveals towards the end that I thought worked quite well.
I've heard this called a "romantic grimdark comedy", but I didn't really get any of those individual elements from reading it, or at least not nearly enough to use them as labels for the book. It was however, quite an interesting read overall.
Read
October 27, 2020I haven't read this book, yet, but it's a finalist in this year's Self-Published Fantasy Blog-Off, so it must be good! #SPFBO
See the finalist board here:
https://mark---lawrence.blogspot.com/...
See the finalist board here:
https://mark---lawrence.blogspot.com/...
July 14, 2020
Black Stone Heart is a captivating grimdark fantasy novel, driven by a morally compromised protagonist in an ambitious setting that feels at once comfortable and arrestingly original.
Black Stone Heart tells the story of Khraen, a young man with the fragmented memories of a world and empire both long-gone. When we first meet Khraen, he is an animal, driven by instinct and ruled by the basic need to survive, no matter the cost. His progression towards something more makes for an engaging initial character arc, though his objective is altogether different – the reconstruction of his obsidian heart. Each piece is a piece of the puzzle of Khraen’s former life, revealing to him lost knowledge and granting him glimpses of a life that used to be.
Despite chasing the shards of his heart, Khraen’s great capacity for change is the driving factor of this novel—I suspect it will permeate the rest of the series, as well. The supporting characters play a part in this, driving Khraen towards or away from his old self. Fletcher has assembled quite the cast – a necromancer who stirs something up in our poor lad’s memories; a caravan guard who treats Khraen like a human being despite the midnight colour of his skin; an old friend who knows everything about Khraen’s former life but is a bit stand-offish when it comes to sharing; and plenty of mages, all of whom Khraen hates in a way that defies reason itself. Strange, that – as he is the victim of just such hatred himself. Everyone in the North, where Khraen awakens, sees the colour of his skin as a mark of the stain of his soul. Derided and loathed, Khraen doesn’t have much of a reason to like the society he discovers in this brand-new world.
This society is one ruled by wizards, those with the ability to stir chaos up and alter the very fabric of reality. But wizards are only one of many magic users – necromancers, I have mentioned, but there are also elementalists, sorcerers, and warlocks. These are schools of magic familiar to anyone who has spent more than an afternoon exploring role-playing games in the vein of D&D, but Fletcher puts a twist on each of them, managing to make them his own in the process, thanks in great part to the visceral, bone-chilling impact that spell-working has across the novel.
Demonology and its myriad practices in particular open up an engaging moral debate about the price of societal efficiency and progress, about crime and punishment, and the horrific cost of power. This practice forces Khraen to face certain aspects of himself, facets which are appalling and frightening for anyone to come to grips with – woven here with great skill by Fletcher.
My big issue with Black Stone Heart is about events that lead up to the finale and certain revelations that are made – twists I saw coming from a mile off. Khraen, who is portrayed as clever if somewhat naive, is blindsided by one revelation after another, discoveries that anyone in his shoes might’ve—should have—guessed at. For a book that contained so many pleasant surprises, the finale came across as a little guided, a little lacking in substance for the sake of shock value.
When I came to the end of my listen-through of Black Stone Heart, I couldn’t help but draw a parallel between it and Abercrombie’s First Law trilogy in one aspect: Fletcher’s work echoes that theme so agonizingly prevalent in Abercrombie, in that people are indeed capable of great change…but they’re as likely to revert to who they used to be than make of themselves something new. The Obsidian Path is just getting started, however – and I am eager to see what direction it will go on before the final stop in this new series.
Listening to the audiobook narration, done by Fletcher himself, is the most engrossed I’ve been with an audiobook in months. The gravelly voice Fletcher opens with eventually reveals a stunning array of nuance –remarkable work, and fun to no end. The audiobook opens and closes with two pieces of original music performed by Fletcher and his band, which did a surprisingly good job of setting the mood for those opening chapters.
Black Stone Heart was riveting, pure and simple. It might be a little flawed—but that does not take away from my excitement at seeing Khraen’s journey continued.
You’ll enjoy this one if you:
*Like all things grimdark—the murdery bits, the stabby-stabby times, the people popping off in clouds of blood like angry little zits;
*Are looking for an actionable manual on demonology;
*Enjoy All Things Dark and Evil™;
*And more! Prob’ly.
Black Stone Heart tells the story of Khraen, a young man with the fragmented memories of a world and empire both long-gone. When we first meet Khraen, he is an animal, driven by instinct and ruled by the basic need to survive, no matter the cost. His progression towards something more makes for an engaging initial character arc, though his objective is altogether different – the reconstruction of his obsidian heart. Each piece is a piece of the puzzle of Khraen’s former life, revealing to him lost knowledge and granting him glimpses of a life that used to be.
Despite chasing the shards of his heart, Khraen’s great capacity for change is the driving factor of this novel—I suspect it will permeate the rest of the series, as well. The supporting characters play a part in this, driving Khraen towards or away from his old self. Fletcher has assembled quite the cast – a necromancer who stirs something up in our poor lad’s memories; a caravan guard who treats Khraen like a human being despite the midnight colour of his skin; an old friend who knows everything about Khraen’s former life but is a bit stand-offish when it comes to sharing; and plenty of mages, all of whom Khraen hates in a way that defies reason itself. Strange, that – as he is the victim of just such hatred himself. Everyone in the North, where Khraen awakens, sees the colour of his skin as a mark of the stain of his soul. Derided and loathed, Khraen doesn’t have much of a reason to like the society he discovers in this brand-new world.
This society is one ruled by wizards, those with the ability to stir chaos up and alter the very fabric of reality. But wizards are only one of many magic users – necromancers, I have mentioned, but there are also elementalists, sorcerers, and warlocks. These are schools of magic familiar to anyone who has spent more than an afternoon exploring role-playing games in the vein of D&D, but Fletcher puts a twist on each of them, managing to make them his own in the process, thanks in great part to the visceral, bone-chilling impact that spell-working has across the novel.
Demonology and its myriad practices in particular open up an engaging moral debate about the price of societal efficiency and progress, about crime and punishment, and the horrific cost of power. This practice forces Khraen to face certain aspects of himself, facets which are appalling and frightening for anyone to come to grips with – woven here with great skill by Fletcher.
My big issue with Black Stone Heart is about events that lead up to the finale and certain revelations that are made – twists I saw coming from a mile off. Khraen, who is portrayed as clever if somewhat naive, is blindsided by one revelation after another, discoveries that anyone in his shoes might’ve—should have—guessed at. For a book that contained so many pleasant surprises, the finale came across as a little guided, a little lacking in substance for the sake of shock value.
When I came to the end of my listen-through of Black Stone Heart, I couldn’t help but draw a parallel between it and Abercrombie’s First Law trilogy in one aspect: Fletcher’s work echoes that theme so agonizingly prevalent in Abercrombie, in that people are indeed capable of great change…but they’re as likely to revert to who they used to be than make of themselves something new. The Obsidian Path is just getting started, however – and I am eager to see what direction it will go on before the final stop in this new series.
Listening to the audiobook narration, done by Fletcher himself, is the most engrossed I’ve been with an audiobook in months. The gravelly voice Fletcher opens with eventually reveals a stunning array of nuance –remarkable work, and fun to no end. The audiobook opens and closes with two pieces of original music performed by Fletcher and his band, which did a surprisingly good job of setting the mood for those opening chapters.
Black Stone Heart was riveting, pure and simple. It might be a little flawed—but that does not take away from my excitement at seeing Khraen’s journey continued.
You’ll enjoy this one if you:
*Like all things grimdark—the murdery bits, the stabby-stabby times, the people popping off in clouds of blood like angry little zits;
*Are looking for an actionable manual on demonology;
*Enjoy All Things Dark and Evil™;
*And more! Prob’ly.
February 23, 2021
tl;dr: 'Black Stone Heart' is a brutal, fast-paced, and engrossing story that you should not miss.
Khraen, our protagonist, wakes up in a grave with no memories of his life. He discovers that there are people who look exactly like him, and who carry an obsidian piece in their heart. Every time he consumes this piece, after killing them, he regains some memories of who he was. The more time he spends in the world, the more he realizes how the population despises him for his dark skin. What Khraen does is covered in part in this book, the first in a new grimdark fantasy trilogy from Michael R. Fletcher.
Black Stone Heart is one of those rare books that will demand your attention from the start and never let's go. You will keep thinking 'one more page, and then I will sleep'. But that one page turns into many; you discover that the book is over and that its 3 AM. You will lie awake thinking about the book and the characters, and possibly a bit miffed because the sequel is not out yet. Yes, Black Stone Heart is that kind of book.
There are multiple reasons for it - the express pacing, the writing, the characters and the moral dilemmas. I am not sure if there is an element of storytelling that the author has not done well. Well, maybe the plot could have been a bit more original and a little less predictable towards the end. But, those two nitpicks will apply only to long-time jaded readers of fantasy like me. The rest of us will find it refreshingly original.
Khraen is the stand-out character, of course. Khraen is in part an archetype who tries to answer two age-old questions.
Why do people end up behaving the way they do - is it nature, or is it nurture? Do people turn out to be good or evil because of their upbringing and environment or it in their innate character to be either one. Khraen struggles with the moral implications of whatever memories he has. He is not able to comprehend how he turned out to be the way he remembers and is repelled by his actions in his memories. But then, the more people treat him like an outcast, the more anger and resentment he starts to feel. The question remains - knowing what little he does, will he continue down the path which will make him like his memories or does he have the freedom and choice to be something else in a cruel world. I found this aspect of the story fascinating. Michael Fletcher portrays this brilliantly. We can see how easy it is for someone to start down the slippery slope where violence justifies violence and evil begets evil. Even though Khraen tries hard to be decent, the environment and the action of the system & people makes him lash out.
The second question is 'What is the nature of evil?'. Is a wolf evil for killing rabbits? Is a predator evil for killing & eating its prey? Unfortunately, I didn't subscribe to the author's point of view concerning this question. He draws a metaphor between an animal in nature and human beings. Obviously, evil as a concept applies only to thinking beings, who chose to behave in an immoral fashion even though they have a choice not to. So there is no question that a necromancer who has chosen to be one or a demonologist who decides to trade in souls, is evil. But the nuance here is what if they do so to protect someone else? Like I said before, I didn't find this argument convincing. But the author does a fantastic job of showing how a small evil deed makes it easier to accept a larger one. Khraen is presented with choices which forced him to choose between evils.
There are more subtle questions posed here. Memories make a person. But, which memories are the priority and is the order important? Khraen's character is dealing with all of these existential questions, and it makes him fascinating. Michael Fletcher ensures that Khraen doesn't become angst-ridden emo but keeps his internal monologue engrossing.
The world-building is above average too. It has the usual share of magic and fantasy tropes, but some elements make it unique that I do not want to spoil here. There are shades of 'The Wheel of Time' as well as 'The Sword of Truth'. The book is also quite brutal and graphic. So be warned. It is not for the squeamish.
A series like 'The Rakkan Conquest' has a similar plot-line - the protagonist waking up with no memories of their past life. But where that series goes clearly in one direction, 'Black Stone Heart' is keeping me guessing.
In conclusion, Black Stone Heart is a brilliant grimdark fantasy. I strongly recommend it.
Khraen, our protagonist, wakes up in a grave with no memories of his life. He discovers that there are people who look exactly like him, and who carry an obsidian piece in their heart. Every time he consumes this piece, after killing them, he regains some memories of who he was. The more time he spends in the world, the more he realizes how the population despises him for his dark skin. What Khraen does is covered in part in this book, the first in a new grimdark fantasy trilogy from Michael R. Fletcher.
Black Stone Heart is one of those rare books that will demand your attention from the start and never let's go. You will keep thinking 'one more page, and then I will sleep'. But that one page turns into many; you discover that the book is over and that its 3 AM. You will lie awake thinking about the book and the characters, and possibly a bit miffed because the sequel is not out yet. Yes, Black Stone Heart is that kind of book.
There are multiple reasons for it - the express pacing, the writing, the characters and the moral dilemmas. I am not sure if there is an element of storytelling that the author has not done well. Well, maybe the plot could have been a bit more original and a little less predictable towards the end. But, those two nitpicks will apply only to long-time jaded readers of fantasy like me. The rest of us will find it refreshingly original.
Khraen is the stand-out character, of course. Khraen is in part an archetype who tries to answer two age-old questions.
Why do people end up behaving the way they do - is it nature, or is it nurture? Do people turn out to be good or evil because of their upbringing and environment or it in their innate character to be either one. Khraen struggles with the moral implications of whatever memories he has. He is not able to comprehend how he turned out to be the way he remembers and is repelled by his actions in his memories. But then, the more people treat him like an outcast, the more anger and resentment he starts to feel. The question remains - knowing what little he does, will he continue down the path which will make him like his memories or does he have the freedom and choice to be something else in a cruel world. I found this aspect of the story fascinating. Michael Fletcher portrays this brilliantly. We can see how easy it is for someone to start down the slippery slope where violence justifies violence and evil begets evil. Even though Khraen tries hard to be decent, the environment and the action of the system & people makes him lash out.
The second question is 'What is the nature of evil?'. Is a wolf evil for killing rabbits? Is a predator evil for killing & eating its prey? Unfortunately, I didn't subscribe to the author's point of view concerning this question. He draws a metaphor between an animal in nature and human beings. Obviously, evil as a concept applies only to thinking beings, who chose to behave in an immoral fashion even though they have a choice not to. So there is no question that a necromancer who has chosen to be one or a demonologist who decides to trade in souls, is evil. But the nuance here is what if they do so to protect someone else? Like I said before, I didn't find this argument convincing. But the author does a fantastic job of showing how a small evil deed makes it easier to accept a larger one. Khraen is presented with choices which forced him to choose between evils.
There are more subtle questions posed here. Memories make a person. But, which memories are the priority and is the order important? Khraen's character is dealing with all of these existential questions, and it makes him fascinating. Michael Fletcher ensures that Khraen doesn't become angst-ridden emo but keeps his internal monologue engrossing.
The world-building is above average too. It has the usual share of magic and fantasy tropes, but some elements make it unique that I do not want to spoil here. There are shades of 'The Wheel of Time' as well as 'The Sword of Truth'. The book is also quite brutal and graphic. So be warned. It is not for the squeamish.
A series like 'The Rakkan Conquest' has a similar plot-line - the protagonist waking up with no memories of their past life. But where that series goes clearly in one direction, 'Black Stone Heart' is keeping me guessing.
In conclusion, Black Stone Heart is a brilliant grimdark fantasy. I strongly recommend it.
August 26, 2022
Repetitive and Navel Gazing
I enjoyed a lot of the aspects of this book. It leaned into its grimdark nature giving us a character who is pretty much a murderous asshole from page 1. I also enjoyed the magical elements in this world.
However, both of those things were kind of dragged down for me by the execution of the story. The narrative is overly repetitive where it feels like it hits the same story beats over and over and over again. Ditto for the characterization. I don't know how many times we had to get inner thoughts from the main character about his conflicted nature. My best estimate is approximately 10,000. I found myself saying "Dude you murdered someone in cold blood right at the beginning. You're a homicidal maniac. Just embrace it." Fletcher had a similar issue with how often we are told people at large dislike the main character because of his skin color. It feels like he belabors this point to absurdity.
Overall I would say I liked this more than I disliked it but just barely. The magic and world are pretty cool as well as the backstory we slowly learn, but the plot and characters seem pretty thin. Add in the writing tics that annoyed me and I don't think I'll be picking up book 2.
I enjoyed a lot of the aspects of this book. It leaned into its grimdark nature giving us a character who is pretty much a murderous asshole from page 1. I also enjoyed the magical elements in this world.
However, both of those things were kind of dragged down for me by the execution of the story. The narrative is overly repetitive where it feels like it hits the same story beats over and over and over again. Ditto for the characterization. I don't know how many times we had to get inner thoughts from the main character about his conflicted nature. My best estimate is approximately 10,000. I found myself saying "Dude you murdered someone in cold blood right at the beginning. You're a homicidal maniac. Just embrace it." Fletcher had a similar issue with how often we are told people at large dislike the main character because of his skin color. It feels like he belabors this point to absurdity.
Overall I would say I liked this more than I disliked it but just barely. The magic and world are pretty cool as well as the backstory we slowly learn, but the plot and characters seem pretty thin. Add in the writing tics that annoyed me and I don't think I'll be picking up book 2.
January 25, 2024
Amazing book.
The premise is very interesting; a man named Khraen awakens alone and without any memories of his previous life. What he knows is that his heart has been shattered and pieces of it are all around the world. But who did this? Who was he? Who is he? And, why?
I loved the writing, I loved the characters, I loved the magic and the way the world is built. It's quite a short read for a fantasy book, just under 400 pages, and one I definitely wasn't able to put down.
You don't know how to root for, who to trust. The man Khraen is? The man he was? What were his intentions? What did he want and what does he want, now? There's a thousand doubts by the end of the book that will make you want to pick the next one up IMMEDIATELY.
Which is exactly what I'm doing.
The premise is very interesting; a man named Khraen awakens alone and without any memories of his previous life. What he knows is that his heart has been shattered and pieces of it are all around the world. But who did this? Who was he? Who is he? And, why?
I loved the writing, I loved the characters, I loved the magic and the way the world is built. It's quite a short read for a fantasy book, just under 400 pages, and one I definitely wasn't able to put down.
You don't know how to root for, who to trust. The man Khraen is? The man he was? What were his intentions? What did he want and what does he want, now? There's a thousand doubts by the end of the book that will make you want to pick the next one up IMMEDIATELY.
Which is exactly what I'm doing.
September 16, 2024
3.75⭐
Chyba taki rodzaj fantasy to grimdark pełną gębą. Do tego można tutaj znaleźć refkeksję nad tym, czy zło żyje w nas od urodzenia, czy napełniamy się nim w czasie naszego życia. Czy faktycznie mamy wybór czy chcemy być dobrzy czy źli, czy niezależnie od tego czego chcemy, stajemy się tym, co nam los daje. Uwaga, miejscami dosyć brutalne opisy.
Chyba taki rodzaj fantasy to grimdark pełną gębą. Do tego można tutaj znaleźć refkeksję nad tym, czy zło żyje w nas od urodzenia, czy napełniamy się nim w czasie naszego życia. Czy faktycznie mamy wybór czy chcemy być dobrzy czy źli, czy niezależnie od tego czego chcemy, stajemy się tym, co nam los daje. Uwaga, miejscami dosyć brutalne opisy.
January 1, 2024
Potevo esimermi dal parlare di Cuore di Ossidiana di Michael R. Fletcher, volume che dà inizio alla trilogia “The Obsidian Path”? Assolutamente no! Prima di cominciare è doveroso ringraziare Letterelettriche per l’ottimo lavoro svolto e per l’impegno profuso nel soddisfare noi lettori avidi di storie oscure.
Khraen, dopo un’eternità di oblio, si risveglia sperduto e abbandonato. È un uomo spezzato, non ricorda nulla della vita precedente, a muoverlo è un’attrazione viscerale verso i frammenti di Ossidiana che compongono il suo cuore. Solo così potrà scoprire il suo passato, un richiamo ossessivo e disperato che porterà Khraen a camminare lungo un sentiero bagnato di sangue.
La narrazione in prima persona permette al lettore di scoprire pagina dopo pagina un mondo dal background affascinante e misterioso, un mosaico che verrà ricomposto insieme alla storia di Khraen. Imperi caduti, città millenarie, divinità dimenticate, necromanti, maghi, demoni, un mix esplosivo che rende Cuore di Ossidiana un Dark Fantasy con i fiocchi.
Michael Fletcher è stato bravo a costruire un personaggio vero, a mettere in risalto luci e ombre del suo carattere. Un protagonista forte, ma tormentato dalla debolezza del dubbio. Chi siamo noi? Cosa definisce il nostro essere? I ricordi o le scelte che facciamo? Khraen plasma la sua identità attraverso decisioni e azioni quotidiane, quando, però, inizia a riacquistare la memoria dell’uomo oscuro e potente che fu, le due personalità si scontrano. Quale prevarrà? Khraen sarà in grado di costruirsi un futuro o sarà destinato a ripercorrere le orme del passato?
Cuore di Ossidiana è stata una lettura ricca e scorrevole che mi ha coinvolto dall'inizio alla fine. Orsù gente, unitevi anche voi alla #fletchermania e percorrete il Sentiero di Ossidiana.
Khraen, dopo un’eternità di oblio, si risveglia sperduto e abbandonato. È un uomo spezzato, non ricorda nulla della vita precedente, a muoverlo è un’attrazione viscerale verso i frammenti di Ossidiana che compongono il suo cuore. Solo così potrà scoprire il suo passato, un richiamo ossessivo e disperato che porterà Khraen a camminare lungo un sentiero bagnato di sangue.
La narrazione in prima persona permette al lettore di scoprire pagina dopo pagina un mondo dal background affascinante e misterioso, un mosaico che verrà ricomposto insieme alla storia di Khraen. Imperi caduti, città millenarie, divinità dimenticate, necromanti, maghi, demoni, un mix esplosivo che rende Cuore di Ossidiana un Dark Fantasy con i fiocchi.
Michael Fletcher è stato bravo a costruire un personaggio vero, a mettere in risalto luci e ombre del suo carattere. Un protagonista forte, ma tormentato dalla debolezza del dubbio. Chi siamo noi? Cosa definisce il nostro essere? I ricordi o le scelte che facciamo? Khraen plasma la sua identità attraverso decisioni e azioni quotidiane, quando, però, inizia a riacquistare la memoria dell’uomo oscuro e potente che fu, le due personalità si scontrano. Quale prevarrà? Khraen sarà in grado di costruirsi un futuro o sarà destinato a ripercorrere le orme del passato?
Cuore di Ossidiana è stata una lettura ricca e scorrevole che mi ha coinvolto dall'inizio alla fine. Orsù gente, unitevi anche voi alla #fletchermania e percorrete il Sentiero di Ossidiana.
May 23, 2021
Another damn entertaining story from one of my favorite authors. Michael Fletcher always finds the right blend of madness and normalcy to make me want more of his brand of fantasy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 411 reviews