|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0743244583
| 9780743244589
| 0743244583
| 3.98
| 59,164
| Nov 12, 2004
| Oct 03, 2005
|
really liked it
|
“I want to be Bob Dylan when I grow up” - Me at 14 “I want to be Bob Dylan when I grow up” - Me as an adult “I want to be Bob Dylan when I grow up” - M “I want to be Bob Dylan when I grow up” - Me at 14 “I want to be Bob Dylan when I grow up” - Me as an adult “I want to be Bob Dylan when I grow up” - Me doing Library story time: [image] Alas, I am not Bob Dylan but ‘sometimes you just have to bite your upper lip and put sunglasses on,’ and I’m glad I’m me and can geek out over some Bob Dylan. Besides, even the dude from The Counting Crows sang "I wanna be Bob Dylan" so at least I'm in good company. I remember being a freshman in college when Bob Dylan Chronicles Vol 1 first came out. I was eagerly anticipating it and ran out to Borders Books & Music (RIP) in Ann Arbor to grab a copy day one and ditched class to start reading it. Like Bob Dylan described reading Bound for Glory, the autobiography of his hero, Woody Guthrie, ‘I went though it from cover to cover like a hurricane. Totally focused on every word, and the book sang out to me like the radio.’ I’d heard all the legends and lore of the great musician who inspired me to start playing music at an early age, but I’d rarely encountered Dylan’s own thoughts on his work and his story. Of course, like most of my heroes at the time (cough cough Roberto Bolaño), Dylan does a lot of self-mythologizing. ‘I didn’t know what age of history we were in nor what the truth of it was. Nobody bothered with that,’ he writes, ‘If you told the truth, that was all well and good and it you told the untruth, well, that’s still well and good.’ And still good it is. He creates a literary portrait of himself that, sure, maybe its what some call a lie but it speaks to this idea of creativity where the truth is beside the point when we come for a story. And with this book, Dylan tells us one hell of a story about himself. [image] ‘Don't ask me nothin' about nothin' I just might tell you the truth ’ —Outlaw Blues Sifting through Chronicles Vol 1 is a fun deep dive through Dylan’s frankness about his own career and creativity. The singer songwriter started his career with a slew of massive hits he would quickly tire of playing and jumped into a full-band electric sound at notoriously upset folks. ‘It was like carrying a package of heavy rotting meat,’ he says about his early hits, ‘I couldn't understand where they came from.’ But Dylan always does Dylan and it is cool to read him talk about it seeing as I had never really read many interviews with him. I’ve always enjoyed that Dylan avoids such things and despite having accepted the Nobel medal from the Swedish academy at an event with no press (thank you to BJ for the correction here!) he rarely acknowledges the award in public (I have recently learned the notion of him not acknowledging it at all is a myth to add to the Dylan persona legend, which makes sense but I'm glad to learn the truth behind it too). There was once even rumor that Bob Dylan was reclusive author Thomas Pynchon due to them both being friends of Richard Fariña (who was Pynchon’s roommate in college). Pynchon was supposed to be the best man at Fariña’s wedding to Mimi Baez, the sister of Joan Baez who was at the time romantically entangled with Dylan though nobody saw Pynchon and nobody had ever seen Pynchon and Dylan in the same place–including at Fariña’s funeral. That Fariña also read the early drafts of both Pynchon’s V. and Dylan’s Tarantula also added to the rumor under claims both novels were rather inscrutable. Pynchon also notoriously didn't show up to collect his National Book Awards for Gravity's Rainbow, so put that in your Nobel win conspiracy theory pipe and smoke it I guess? ‘All I'd ever done was sing songs that were dead straight and expressed powerful new realities. I had very little in common with and knew even less about a generation that I was supposed to be the voice of.’ In a 2017 interview, Dylan was asked if he was the jester from Don McLeans’s song American Pie and replied ‘A jester? Sure…’ and I thought here it is, he’s gonna acknowledge it, he’s gonna say would a Jester win the Nobel Prize, but NO, Dylan said ‘ Sure, the jester writes songs like ‘Masters of War’ – some jester. I have to think he’s talking about somebody else. Ask him.’ And that’s why I continue to love him. He’s always been about doing whatever he wanted to be true to his music however that fit in the moment. ‘All the money you made / Will never buy back your soul’ he sings in Masters of War and while Dylan has raked in more money than I can ever imagine, he’s always come across as the music coming first. As he writes in the book: ‘Songs, to me, were more important than just light entertainment. They were my preceptor and guide into some altered consciousness of reality. Some different republic, some liberated republic... whatever the case, it wasn't that I was anti-popular culture or anything and I had no ambition to stir things up. I just thought of mainstream culture as lame as hell and a big trick. It was like the unbroken sea of frost that lay outside the window and you had to have awkward footgear to walk with.’ Dylan spends a lot of the book trying to convince you he is unremarkable on the coolness factor with an eclectic taste that he is uninterested in cultivating for any sense of being hip or esoteric. Dylan is just Dylan. He likes reading military history, hes into polka, and stresses about being in ‘the bottomless pit of cultural oblivion.’ At all times, Dylan is the Dylan you’ve come to expect. [image] From When Bob Met Woody: The Story of the Young Bob Dylan by Gary Golio When the Scorsese documentary of Dylan, No Direction Home, came out the year after this book, my college friends and I turned it into a drinking game where every time Dylan said something that made no sense or made you say “what the fuck, Dylan?”--Drink. The same can be done with this book. ‘Some people seem to fade away but then when they are truly gone, it's like they didn't fade away at all.’ Drink ‘Even if you don't have all the things you want, be grateful for the things you don't have that you don't want.’ Drink ‘There's only one day at a time here, then it's tonight and then tomorrow will be today again.’ DRINK Its fun and then you should totally put some albums on and jam along! ‘I really was never any more than what I was -a folk musician who gazed into the gray mist with tear-blinded eyes and made up songs that floated in a luminous haze.’ I’ve long loved me some Bob Dylan and this is a great way to get into the head of the musical genius. Also you should just watch the 2003 film he wrote and stars in, Masked and Anonymous because it might not be great but it is great fun. 4/5 [image] Dylan performing with my other favorite: Neil Young ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
0063319586
| 9780063319585
| 0063319586
| 4.39
| 3,160
| Apr 25, 2024
| Apr 23, 2024
|
really liked it
|
‘We are all just trying to find a place to call our own,’ writes author and artist Theo Parish and across their empowering graphic memoir they explore
‘We are all just trying to find a place to call our own,’ writes author and artist Theo Parish and across their empowering graphic memoir they explore how this place to call your own might just be a journey into discovering who you are in your own body. Aptly titled Homebody, this memoir traces the journey to ‘discover what it means to be me’ around concepts of gender and identity that take us from childhood to the present all told through rather adorable and whimsical artwork. There is such a warmth to this rather comforting book that, while telling Theo’s very individual journey towards embracing themselves as non-binary, can be beneficial and affirming for anyone on a similar journey as Theo opens the conversation up to remind readers that there is not a narrow expression of identity. Homebody celebrates the variety of expressions that can help build a more inclusive and supportive community while also looking at the importance of language and stressing self-love as ‘living authentically in a world that takes every opportunity to squeeze you uncomfortably into a box of someone else's design is the most radical act of self love.’ Charming, comforting and full of succinct, but well thought out and nuanced ideas of identity, Homebody is a marvelous graphic novel on trans identities. [image] [Text: Coming home…to myself…wherever that may be.] Author and artist Maia Kobabe has referred to this "all ages version” of their own book, Gender Queer and it does indeed make a great companion read that covers similar subject matter while also having its own unique perspectives. Similarly, this reads well alongside other trans graphic memoirs such as Sara Soler’s Us or Rhea Ewing’s memoir mixed with interviews with others on gender expression in Fine: A Comic About Gender. What is key here is that Theo shows their own individual journey but presents it in a way that can be affirming or instructive for others without trying to say there is only one way to process or express these concepts. [image] [Text: This journey is mine to take as I please one step at a time.] ‘They say that ‘your body is a temple,’’ Theo writes, ‘but mine has felt more like a rental.’ I quite enjoy the metaphor of the body as a home threaded through here and the adorable artwork of people with houses as bodies, but it makes a good point on the idea that who we are is more than just our physical features. They work through part of their journey trying on different personas much like we all do during their teens and drawing inspiration and empowerment from musicians they enjoy (there are some shoutouts to Lunachicks here), but I found it helpful to show that their struggles with gender identification went beyond “trying things out.” The book follows Theo from grade school, through college and beyond in a way that shows the journey can be a lifelong process and can’t merely be dismissed as “just a phase” as some often do. It also shows how one’s own engagement with their expression of gender can change over time or how we are faced with different social situations or obligations (like how to present at work when still unsure of one’s own identity, pronouns or name) that might affect that. They go through ideas like why choosing a name is empowering, why deadnaming is harmful, and more to show how one has individual reasons for what constitutes self-love or important to their journey and we should respect that. Overall this book is about being respectful and giving space for people to grow and be loved, especially by themselves. ‘We are ALL just trying to find a place to call our own. We are ALL deserving of comfort and safety…a place to call home.’ I really liked the emphasis placed on language here. ‘Words are important,’ they tell us, especially when understanding yourself comes from using language as a tool to do so and how rewarding it is when ‘finally grasping the language you’ve been reaching for, to explain this complex and perplexing thing.’ This was a moving point in Lewis Hancox’s graphic memoir Welcome to St. Hell: My Trans Teen Misadventure how the author was experiencing eating disorders and gender dysphoria but lacked the language to express it or comprehend what it was at the time. In Fine: A Comic About Gender, Rhea Ewing discusses how a large issue with book bans targeting primarily LGBTQ+ stories or pushing back on that language being used in schools is that it is an erasure of language people need to decode their own identities. Understanding the words is like ‘finally being able to articulate this thing that for so long you had no idea how to express.’ While it is very different, but still seems adjacent, I was recently reading about actor Adam Driver’s program Art in the Armed Forces which is intended to bring artistic expression to those in the military in order to help give them the language and forms of expression to deal with issues like PTSD and other traumas because the service ‘has acronyms for acronyms but no language for expressing anything abstract.’ Basically having language helps us to understand ideas more deeply and we can use words like tools to pick apart concepts, figure out how they function and assess what to do about it. Not the most comparable maybe but I still like this idea of focusing on language as a tool for self-care. [image] [Text: There is no one way to be transgender…just like there is no one way to be cisgender.] The emphasis on there being more than one way to be transgender is really key. Theo identifies as non-binary (as do I) and spends a lot of time in the book trying to figure out not only what that means but where that fits in on the spectrum of identity. This is a really important issue for author Kit Heyam in their recent book Before We Were Trans: A New History of Gender which looks at different forms of trans expression and argues that ideas around being “trans enough” or gatekeeping identity ownership is rooted in capitalist thought that creates a false idea of scarcity for identity that can be harmful. For that reason they write ‘we're unlikely to share every aspect of our experience with every member of our community, but we have enough in common to create solidarity,’ and this solidarity is important to Theo as well such as their experience at their first Pride where they feel seen, safe, valued and valid amongst ‘a community of those who understood.’ They want that for everyone. Homebody is a really lovely graphic memoir that is accessible and just as valuable for adults as it is for teens. It handles a wide variety of topics in a graceful manner with an emphasis on being welcoming while also being vulnerable to tell their story in a way that can be very affirming. A quick read with rather lovely artwork, I very much enjoyed and would recommend Homebody. 4/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
May 13, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
B0BF5ZHWL3
| 3.96
| 1,172
| Mar 21, 2023
| Mar 21, 2023
|
really liked it
|
‘To me, the world felt simple… …and magical.’ The past often leaves its fingerprints on the present. ‘The past does not haunt us. We haunt the past,’ wr ‘To me, the world felt simple… …and magical.’ The past often leaves its fingerprints on the present. ‘The past does not haunt us. We haunt the past,’ wrote Augusten Burroughs, ‘’ Such is the case in Briana Loewinsohn’s quietly moving graphic novel Ephemera: A Memoir as a young woman returns to her childhood home and finds herself immersed in the ghosts of the past as she haunts them as much as they haunt her while trying to grow something beautiful for the future. Moving through thematic chapters that examine her life in the context of ideas like dirt, water or light as she clears away the weeds growing in both the soil and her memories to let light in and grow herself along with her sprouts. Gorgeously illustrated with a minimal style to match the minimal text and moving like a somber dream, Ephemera is a sparse but heartwrenching book that drags you through the sadness but leaves you to bask in the redemptive warmth of hope and acceptance. [image] The story of Ephemera moves fluidly across time, using a warm color palette to represent the present and cool colors for the past. While this helps ground the reader in the timeline, it often blurs past and present in ways that show how the past haunts us as we haunt the past and makes for a rather moving depiction of memory that recalls something I once read from Jeanette Winterson that ‘memories separated in time are often recalled side by side-there's an emotional connection that has nothing to do with the diary dates and everything to do with the feeling.’ [image] This blurring of time to juxtapose the emotions of past and present, such as watching the adult woman re-experience the traumas of her childhood and reach out to her young self will certainly reach into your own heart to play your heartstrings like a harp. While her childhood self mostly remembers the space and happiness of nature, she realizes how much her mother loomed large casting a somber shadow over everything. Especially in her absence, though even when she was physically present she is shown as still being emotionally absent for the most part. ‘It looked like you would be back any minute but also like you had never been real at all,’ she recalls of her mother’s empty bedroom and how even trying to help her mother was met with reprimands for making it worse. ‘I’m sorry’ seems a mantra of her childhood and that loneliness still rears its head in the present. Even in thoughts such as ‘sometimes I worry about the plants that grow alone.’ [image] Yet, for all the pain, we see how she still loves her mother and tries to emulate her, finding solace in the garden as she often witnessed her mother doing. ‘If i could just…be like you,’ she reflects on her childhood self trying to learn from her mother, ‘or, at least, understand why we weren’t enough.’ The minimal art coupled with minimal text makes this feel rather empty in a way that emphasizes the emotional resonance without making the story feel thin, which is really an impressive accomplishment. It is a sad story, but one that feels rather healing, the way scar tissue is tougher than the skin before a hurt. Gorgeously haunting, Ephemera: A Memoir cuts with memory but heals with self-acceptance and reminds us to love one another while we still can. 4/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
May 01, 2024
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||||
1644213125
| 9781644213124
| 1644213125
| 3.75
| 242
| Jan 01, 2011
| Sep 19, 2023
|
liked it
|
‘I don’t think there is a deeper silence in the world than the silence of water. I felt it then and never forgot it.’ Childhood memories live on inside ‘I don’t think there is a deeper silence in the world than the silence of water. I felt it then and never forgot it.’ Childhood memories live on inside of us, often growing in size and emotional depth as they occasionally resurface in our minds like glimpses into our own mythology of self. Such is the nature of The Silence of Water from Nobel Prize winning writer José Saramago, where ‘the most absurd idea of my entire life’ becomes a lesson in how even our most pure and whimsical wishes and determination must accept the reality of plausible outcomes. Taken from the short memories written in Saramago’s Small Memories—both the memoir and this book are translated by the incredible Margaret Jull Costa—this brief reflection is given new life as a picture book with striking artwork from Yolanda Mosquera. It is a lovely little story that admittedly felt small and trivial upon completion, but the process of writing and thinking about it granted it a new depth and tenderness in my mind that I hadn’t noticed. [image] Set along the banks of the Almonda river in Azinhaga, Portugal where Saramago grew up, it tells the story of a quiet day of fishing the author had as a young boy. After losing a large fish to the frailty of his ‘ridiculous, useless rod,’ he decides to go get a new one to catch the fish again. It is a quiet story about learning to accept reality, that would feel trite though through its simplicity the central line about the silence of water is able to speak loudly. [image] Short but lovely to look at, this is a nice collectors item for fans of the Nobel Laureate. Mosquera’s art is quite beautiful and I think it is cool Seven Stories Press (an amazing publisher, really) put this out with a second selection from Saramago’s memoir getting a similar picture book treatment out later this year: An Unexpected Light. ⅗ [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Apr 25, 2024
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
9798886200379
| B0CJX8434M
| 4.43
| 295
| unknown
| Feb 21, 2024
|
really liked it
|
Having loved Keezy Young’s work in Taproot, I was thrilled to discover they had a new, brief work out this year. Thank you Libraries. And thank you Ke
Having loved Keezy Young’s work in Taproot, I was thrilled to discover they had a new, brief work out this year. Thank you Libraries. And thank you Keezy Young because this short but moving graphic novel, Sunflowers is as gorgeously illustrated as it is emotionally powerful and bravely open. Sunflowers is a brief graphic memoir with Young being open with their perspectives on experiencing both the highs and lows of bipolar disorder. There is an incredible vulnerability and grace shown in the writing, combatting the stigmas of those living with bipolar disorder and also discussing how it isn’t always terrible. It is a really well done read that would be a comfort to those facing similar struggles as well as an excellent examination for those who have not and a reminder to have empathy and patience. ‘It’s isolating,’ Young writes, ‘knowing that even in mental health spaces, even among loved ones, your experiences are too scary or unacceptable to talk about without making it weird.’ This book is a bold and beautiful attempt to help open space for that conversation without making it weird. [image] Image text: And maybe if I share a little bit of what it’s like, someone out there will realize that I’m not a nightmare just because I experience one some of the time Sunflowers is artistically gorgeous as well. The art moves into very abstract and surreal moments that convey a lot of emotion and visually capture the experiences. It is very text heavy but it works on pages that are very busy but so carefully organized that the near overload on the page only adds to the experience. I also liked the yellowed pages that give this a very 80s-zine sort of feel. Innovative and empathetic, this is a lovely little book. ‘the problem isn't that I want to die. The problem is that I want to live too much for the world to contain me, and I need to break free of myself before it kills me.’ [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Mar 19, 2024
|
Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||
1542015855
| 9781542015851
| B07SDPCNHG
| 3.59
| 2,402
| Jul 30, 2019
| Jul 30, 2019
|
really liked it
|
‘Before there was Juliet, there were the women who showed me the way to her,’ writes Jacqueline Woodson in this brief yet touching memoir short piece
‘Before there was Juliet, there were the women who showed me the way to her,’ writes Jacqueline Woodson in this brief yet touching memoir short piece Before Her. Winding her way through memory lane and criss-crossing the timeline of her life, Woodson examines ‘the roads that I had to walk to meet the people who I needed to meet.’ There are roads of love and loss, friends who come and go and people who left this world but never her heart. It is a lovely little look into the life of this prolific author, chronicling not only the ways she changed over the years but the way the world changed as well. Yet amidst all the change and loss, she still finds the journey to be a pathway of life and love. ‘But sometimes living pulls back the skin of another life. A possibility.’ This was a really heartfelt read and I enjoyed learning a lot about Woodson. This brief story is not only about the big events in life, but how all the small ones amalgamate into something far greater and how even small events slowly point us in a fresh direction to new people, experiences, and understandings. Woodson experienced many losses and griefs of family and friends, though has accepted that ‘death tears away the skin of one life, exposing another.’ It is all another doorway to something new even if it means learning to live in the world without someone who had previously been a constant. ‘There were the friends whose deaths opened the doors to new friends I might not otherwise have ever known,’ she says, and it makes for a rather optimistic outlook where even grief can be a way to a fresh start. A lovely read with equal parts sadness and joy. I liked her mention that her mother and grandmother stopped reading her books for being ‘too sad’ but her mother tells her she writes as well as her favorite author, Danielle Steel, but at least with Steel ‘there is a happy ending.’ While we don’t really meet Juliet here, at least we know this pathway lead to a happy ending for Woodson. A lovely book. ‘In this way, I learned to love, to lose, and to live. Living, loving, and dying. A circle unbroken.” ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Mar 08, 2024
|
Kindle Edition
| |||||||||||||||
1984863002
| 9781984863003
| 1984863002
| 3.69
| 818
| Jan 30, 2024
| Jan 30, 2024
|
really liked it
|
‘Art is wrestling with yourself.’ Midway through his graphic memoir, Zodiac, Ai Weiwei states that all artists should also be activists lest they simp ‘Art is wrestling with yourself.’ Midway through his graphic memoir, Zodiac, Ai Weiwei states that all artists should also be activists lest they simply be a ‘dead artist’ even while living. ‘Metamorphosis is the core of art,’ he explains later and sees the importance of creating and experiencing art not only as a transformation of the self but also society at large. This is certainly the case with Ai Weiwei who one cannot mention in terms of his art—be it his sculptures, photographs, documentaries or other installation pieces—without also discussing his activism, as if the two were simply dual appendages of the same body. His arrest in 2011 became a flashpoint for human rights and other activist organizations and as he was held for 81 days without a charge he quickly became a world renown symbol of artistic resistance and the importance of freedoms of speech and expression. Here Ai Weiwei along with Elettra Stamboulis tells his life story in graphic format with illustrations by Gianluca Costantini being both a memoir and a profound and philosophical musing on art, resistance and the importance of making your voice heard despite the powers that would rather have it be silent. This makes a great companion piece to his previous memoir, 1000 Years of Joys and Sorrows: A Memoir from 2021. Told in a conversational style between Ai and his son or with interviewers and other artists, interspersed with mythological tales and framed around reflections on the zodiac signs in relation to activism, this is a fascinating and thought provoking look into the life and mind of this great artist. [image] ‘Art is just the beginning’ I was lucky enough to see an exhibit of Ai Weiwei’s work when several pieces of his collection came to Grand Rapids, Mi in 2017. I’ve long been fascinated with him both as an artist but also as a symbol for the possibilities of art as activism and bold statements of freedom so this was a really engaging and enjoyable look at his life as well as his reflections on his own works. ‘Power is so afraid of art and poets,’ Ai tells us, ‘art has the possibility to defend very essential rights’ and he examines how many pieces of his own work set out to do just that. There are some great commentaries on works like his fairytale project at Documenta 12, the message behind his sunflower seeds, his work on the Birds Nest olympic stadium, or his collection of names of students killed in the Sichuan earthquake about which he says ‘All the silence from the State apparatus cannot erase the persistent memories of the survivors. We have to remember at least their names.’ He reflects upon his imprisonment, the demolition of his studio by the government, his inability to leave China after he was released and more. I also enjoyed that the book was structured around ideas of the zodiac, reflecting his own sculpture piece Circle of Animals/Zodiac Heads. [image] Photo from when I saw the Ai Weiwei exhibit in Grand Rapids ‘Art is against repetition. It’s about leading us toward more dangerous ways of experiencing ourselves.’ Beyond his own life, Ai Weiwei also discusses the works of other important activists such as Nobel Peace Prize laureate Liu Xiabo or Ai Weiwei’s own father, Ai Qing who faced imprisonment and exile as well. Through it all he discusses how art is always a fight for freedom. [image] I really enjoyed this book and learned a lot reading it. It is really well paced and covers a lot of ground, both historically and philosophically. I love his love of poetry and belief in the power of art, it is truly inspiring. The artwork in this collection is wonderful too, often representing famous photographs of Ai Weiwei and his works while also moving into really surreal imagery. This is a great format for this work as it, too, is a work of art but is also very accessible to get the message across to a wide range of readers across a wide age range (this would work great in a high school classroom, for instance). [image] Perhaps my favorite moment of the book comes early on, however, in his discussion on why cats are left out of the Chinese zodiac. He explains to his son that he loves cats because they are ‘n animal that cat open doors, but they are different from human beings because they don’t close the doors behind them.’ He sees this as a symbol of great art: ‘The key is to keep the doors open…like the cats, we have to keep the door that we call freedom of speech and thought open.’ So perhaps we should all be more like the cat and keep the door open for art and freedom of expression. Zodiac is a lovely graphic novel. 4/5 [image] What would a book on Ai Weiwei be without his iconic middle finger? ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1250873738
| 9781250873736
| 1250873738
| 4.22
| 4,508
| Nov 10, 2021
| Oct 17, 2023
|
liked it
|
With equal parts humor and heartbreak, French artist and writer Pénélope Bagieu revisits scenes from across her childhood and into early adulthood in
With equal parts humor and heartbreak, French artist and writer Pénélope Bagieu revisits scenes from across her childhood and into early adulthood in the warm and charming graphic memoir Layers (translated from the French by Montana Kane). Very episodic and bouncing back and forth along the coming-of-age timeline, the Eisner Award winning artist invites us along to experience the ups and downs of life, from first loves and losses, embarrassing experiences, hardships and successes, looking back to discover the tiny narrative arcs we can spot in our lives in hindsight. While this is a bit wandering it is also funny and often rather moving, and Bagieu shows stunning vulnerability and self-awareness here, making this an amusing reflection on the moments that amalgamate into the people we are as adults. Layers is a quick read that manages to hit a wide variety of emotions along the way. Composed of rather short, episodic narratives, Bagieu’s rather reflective narration arranges the events into a sort of learning lesson for herself, though often one she didn’t realize at the time and can only see now. I really enjoyed the story about learning to ski and how much the bear pin she was given upon completing the class gave her incredible confidence to want to tackle other skills and be the best. She would later learn that it was a consolation pin given to the worst student in the class (everyone else got snowflake pins) but by then it was already a great lesson about believing in yourself: ‘It gave me permission to dare to do stuff.’ A lot of these stories have a similar tone, making the best out of bad situations or realizing later how much something meant that, at the time, hardly seemed significant (such as bad boyfriends showing major red flags). Though not all the stories are funny, even the saddest of them are heartwarming. The story about the life of her first cat, which opens the book and is easily a highlight, for instance, or the death of her grandmother, are both handled in rather touching ways. On the flipside, some of the most uncomfortable ones like awkward relationships or going solo to a concert because she has a crush on the musician only to have to end up hanging out with his girlfriend, will have you laughing along. Bagieu can laugh at herself and it just makes you like her all the more, and this becomes a great little collection of stories on girlhood. While I was reading this, I was told a patron complained and asked us to move this to the Adult collection instead of the Teen collection (the intended audience of the book). Interestingly enough, the complaint about a scene with nudity (very not-detailed cartoon boobs appearing on a tv screen) appears in a fairly funny bit about hypocrisy: the grandfather find the Bagieu and her sister looking at tampon instructions to be inappropriate but then watches a topless woman dance on tv (to which it is noted this was just…a normal thing on the French National News in the 80s). So in a way, the patron complaint just felt like an extension of this scene and also reminds me that the US is still very uptight about bodies in ways that just seem laughable. Anyways, Layers is a rather delightful little graphic memoir. A quick read, with a loose art style that isn’t anything special but gets the story across quite efficiently, and one that I enjoyed quite a bit. 3.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Dec 13, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1668009048
| 9781668009048
| 1668009048
| 3.84
| 518,448
| Oct 24, 2023
| Oct 24, 2023
|
really liked it
|
As much as society loves to build up an idol they love to watch one fall and burn. This is especially true when the celebrity icon is a woman and one
As much as society loves to build up an idol they love to watch one fall and burn. This is especially true when the celebrity icon is a woman and one that can become a symbol of castigation such as the case of Britney Spears. Having been molded into an icon that was both highly sexualized yet also virginal and youthful, Spears skyrocketed to stardom and made many rich folks far richer but then that same celebrity image was turned into a weapon against her. But who is Spears behind the image that was created of her? ‘It’s time for me not to be someone who other people want,’ she writes in The Woman in Me, her new memoir, ‘it’s time to actually find myself.’ While it reads like a slow burn horror of a woman exploited, shamed and imprisoned by those closest to her, Spears never comes across as angry and the book feels less like a tell-all than it does a search for who she that is asking the same question her fans have been asking while pouring over her Instagram for clues: is she okay? This book is also an tragic example in the long history of how fragile women's rights over financial and bodily control are and that mental health has long been used against them as a way to remove those rights. A quick read that seems to fly through events at the same pace that her career seemed to be moving, it is hard to not feel compassion and sadness for Spears as she finds her voice and gives us insight into her mind during the whirlwind of a life that practically made as many headlines as the number of records she sold. ‘I wanted to hide, but I also wanted to be seen,’ she says, ‘both things could be true,’ and here we can finally see Spears on her terms as she deserves to be seen. ‘Music stopped the noise, made me feel confident, and took me to a pure place of expressing myself exactly as I wanted to be seen and heard.’ Britney Spears was everywhere when I was growing up, she was impossible to not know and even if you didn’t want to know you couldn’t escape the media’s narrative of her rise and unraveling. I was the right age where I could pretend I didn’t love her music and that I only knew every lyric to every song because my younger sister was a huge fan, but lets face it: Britney was an icon, her music was catchy, she WAS pop culture. There’s no way I’m not reading her memoir, I’m too invested in this story simply from being alive and into music when I was. It’s lovely to know she has been freed from her conservatorship, where her own father and lawyers took complete control over her for 13 years, but the whole story seems a large metaphor for what celebrity means in capitalism: you are less you and more a product to be controlled by corporate lawyers and marketing execs (remember when John Foggerty lost a lawsuit suing him over plagiarising the sounds of John Foggerty, since his voice and style were technically owned by a record company?). While this book leaves a long list of names to be angry and appalled at, Spears never comes across as angry. More sad, almost apologetic, and merely telling what happened. In fact so much of this feels dispassionate, as if she is tired beyond the capacity for rightful rage. But also it seems a lesson long beaten into her that women don’t get to be angry, that anything other than passive acceptance makes her a villain. Which is truly tragic and so much of this book reminds us of the long history of misogyny, of policing women’s bodies, words, tone, actions, and any other aspect of their lives. And how, because of this, women are shamed into feeling they deserve the abuse, as Spears shows when she writes 'the sadness and the loneliness that would hit me felt like my fault somehow, like I deserved unhappiness and bad luck.' Which is just so heartbreaking. ‘Why did my managers work so hard to claim I was some kind of young-girl virgin even into my twenties?’ Much has been written about the way Spears image was to take a young, virginal image of a girl and sexualize her for the sake of men’s lusts. She has often been discussed in comparison with Dolores Haze from Nabokov’s Lolita for the sexualization of a teenage girl (such as the music video with Spears in a risque school girl outfit dancing in the halls of a high school, though Spears admits here that the outfit was her idea). In her article on the recent documentary series, Framing Britney Spears, Grace O’Neil writes that ‘Britney is Dolores and we—the public who voraciously consumed her—are a pack of Humberts,’ and that her image was a “safe” way for men to satisfy a taboo lust. Though Tavi Gevinson, in an article you should definitely read as it is not just about Spears but power dynamics in general, points out that the documentary is ‘ eager to characterize Spears’s early image as an expression of female power rather than the corporation-sanctioned sexualization of a 16-year-old’ Which is a key thing, it was an image created to give the feeling that she was in control and sexually liberated, but as we all saw, it was also the way she was demonized and we should ‘engage the messier implications of the virginal-but-sexy archetype: Here is a girl who can perform sex for an audience’s benefit, but who, thank God, has not yet been tainted by experience. America’s response to Spears was puritanical, but so was the fantasy her image fulfilled.’ We also see in this book how breaking from the 'fantasy' is a reason to condemn her, but also remove her agency. It should be noted that the "hysteria" was a mental disorder that was attributed to women (until 1980), and was often used as a way to strip women of their rights and autonomy. Being labeled as "crazy" did just this to Spears. Spears shows how so much of her life was controlled by a very calculated misogyny, such as the Rolling Stones photoshoot with David LaChapelle that captilazied on the sexualization of a teenage girl. As Gevinson argues that Spears was never in control, and this was also calculated in order to allow people to turn a blind eye from the ways she was abused. ‘There is no need to believe it’s either Everything was Britney’s choice, and therefore she was always a sex-positive feminist or Nothing was Britney’s choice, and the evil adults made all her decisions. Both assertions sound desperate to protect her respectability — another version of her purity, in fact — as a prerequisite for compassion. They remind me of how readily conversations about abuse and assault focus on the moral character of the victim in order to confirm that they have indeed been victimized.’ The first half of Spears book very quickly takes us through her career, though it is less an autopsy of her stardom and more a litany of harms. If this were a film we would cut directly from her telling Ed McMahon on Star Search at age 10 that she doesn’t have a boyfriend because ‘boys are mean’ to a montage of the her relationships with Justin Timeberlake and Kevin Federline. ‘Looking back, I think that both Justin and Kevin were very clever. They knew what they were doing, and I played right into it,” she writes, and shows how her desire to be loved became an opening to be exploited (OKAY but the moment she got to Timberlake being all ‘let me play you some soothing guitar’ as shes crying on the floor from the pain of her abortion she was very much pressured into having--not great JT). We also see how she was just access to fame for Federline and that he had no interest in being a father. And it all ends poorly for Spears, especially once the conservatorship begins. And if there is anyone to truly be mad at, it is her parents and management that failed to protect her and instead capitalized on all the drama. ‘ I was so beaten down by all of it that I just surrendered.’ All these events happened at a time of really heightened celebrity in the US spurred by channels like MTV that shifted the focus away from the actual music and into a celebration of privileged lifestyles. While shows like Jackass turned men with massive drug, alcohol and mental health problems into household names to laugh WITH while celebrity women became icons to laugh AT (and shamed for alcohol, drugs, sex or mental health struggles). Everyone seemed way too eager to see Spears have a public breakdown, everyone was excited for cameras to capture the next Lindsey Lohan binge, everyone enjoyed calling Paris Hilton dumb a bit too much to consider it harmless fun. Being joyful at someone’s supposed shortcomings is never cool but it became a commodity, and much of this seemed to be orchestrated to mock women who rose to stardom almost as some gross patriarchal lesson. It happens all the time but it was practically the focus of US entertainment aimed at youth culture. And it’s because the industry saw them all as products not people. That’s why reading this felt like a damning indictment against the way patriarchal societies objectify, commoditize, consume and control women. Britney was caged into a message to young women to be commoditized, to be docile and nice, to be exploited and happy for it or be punished. In her book Entitled: How Male Privilege Hurts Women, Dr. Kate Manne lays out the various ways men feel entitled to women’s bodies, labor, affection, etc. and this book practically goes through each of her points to check the boxes. On women’s bodies, for example: ‘It was always incredible to me that so many people felt so comfortable talking about my body. It had started when I was young. Whether it was strangers in the media or within my own family, people seemed to experience my body as public property: something they could police, control, criticize, or use as a weapon. My body was strong enough to carry two children and agile enough to execute every choreographed move perfectly onstage. And now here I was, having every calorie recorded so people could continue to get rich off my body.’ There is a similar message in Emily Ratajkowski’s memoir My Body. Sure, people will say that is the price of fame, but that is not okay and is just a way to hold an umbrella for abuse. Hop on social media right now and you’ll see plenty of people shaming Britney for this book and especially for having aborted the baby without acknowledging the emotional pressures put on her to do so or the way her whole life she was coached to not have any agency. She talks about how she notices the questions Timberlake was asked in interviews were very different than the type she got, which often asked about her body. It also plays into Dr. Manne’s idea on himpathy—that is the way people tend to sympathize with a man over a woman even when he is the abuser and demand she prove she isn’t somehow complicit in her own abuse—which we see in the way society rallied around Justin and his Cry Me A River song and began to look at Spears as a heartless heartbreaker when in reality I was shattered…I don’t think Justin realised the power he had in shaming me. I don’t think he understands to this day.’ And when things started to come apart, she was labeled as crazy and deserving of scorn instead of recognizing the mental health issues ‘because I now know that I was displaying just about every symptom of perinatal depression: sadness, anxiety, fatigue.’ What did anyone expect when she was treated as unable to take care of herself and like a perpetual 17 year old sex icon her whole life. ‘I’d begin to think in some ways like a child,’ she admits. But it was also a rage against the world. ‘Shaving my head was a way of saying to the world: Fuck you. You want me to be pretty for you? Fuck you. You want me to be good for you? Fuck you. You want me to be your dream girl? Fuck you. I’d been the good girl for years.’ This book very well explores the way she was built into this image and then silenced for breaking it. And the latter half about the 13 years under the conservatorship are horrifying. ‘For thirteen years, I wasn't allowed to eat what I wanted, to drive, to spend my money how I wanted, to drink alcohol or even coffee,’ she says, but now she has ‘freedom to do what I want to do has given me back my womanhood. In my forties, I'm trying things for what feels like the first time. I feel like the woman in me was pushed down for so long.’ I’m glad to see she is able to feel she has a voice and search for what freedom means for her, but also for who she is. This is a quick read, a sad one too, but it is nice to hear her side and remember how harsh society is on women. Especially the ones they prop up for profit and then profit off of watching them burn down. I hope for nothing but the best and inner peace for Spears. ⅘ ‘I've started to experience the riches of being an adult woman for the first time in many years. I feel like I've been underwater for so long, only rarely swimming up to the surface to gasp for air and a little food. When I regained my freedom, that was my cue to step out onto dry land and, any time I want, to take vacations, sip a cocktail, drive my car, go to a resort, or stare out at the ocean.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Nov 09, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1644213206
| 9781644213209
| 1644213206
| 3.59
| 13,831
| May 05, 2022
| Sep 12, 2023
|
liked it
|
I love that so much of Annie Ernaux’s work is like A.E.: Would you like to hear about a scandelous affair I had? Me: ABSOLUTELY And then I perch eagerly I love that so much of Annie Ernaux’s work is like A.E.: Would you like to hear about a scandelous affair I had? Me: ABSOLUTELY And then I perch eagerly at her feet and we drink the exquisite wine that is her prose and get all the juicy details that often come as an outpouring of emotional intensity like a faucet with both handles on full. Ernaux writes with no shame and an eagerness to explore the philosophical undercurrents of her life and memory—an exquisite quality that made her more than deserving of her Nobel Prize in 2022—and we see this in her latest offering, Young Man, about an affair she had in her mid-fifties with a university student nearly 30 years her junior. A rather slim volume, Young Man feels more like a short biographical story even compared to her usual 90ish page books, perhaps as this one is more tempered in emotions than, say, the volatile passions of The Possession. Here she gives much of the space to probing self-examinations of her actions that still leave you satisfied, and we see in her writing the fulfillment of her epigraph ‘if I don’t write things down, they haven’t been carried through to completion, they have only been lived.’ Complete with several pages of photographs from the time of the affair, a short autobiography, and lovingly translated by Alison Strayer, Young Man is a tiny morsel of delight for Ernaux fan’s that contemplates themes on aging, power and gender dynamics, and they ways we dig at our own perceptions of self through our juxtapositions with others. ‘My main reason for wanting our story to continue was that, in a sense, it was already over and I was a fictional character.’ Ernaux writes biography like a searing character study of a novel, so bold and unabashed in honesty and insights and always delivered on immaculate sentences that arrive as ‘a series of hits or punches,’ as Amina Cain describes her in her book on writing, A Horse at Night. Originally written 20 years ago right after the affair in the book took place and revised for publication in France in 2022, Young Man has Ernaux mapping her emotional introspections of what this affair with a much younger man meant to her. She admits to being aware of the power-imbalance (‘I was in a dominant position’), aware that others consider her relationship inappropriate, and does admit ‘I used the weapons of that dominance, whose fragility, in a romantic relationship, I nonetheless recognized’ but it is less about justifying herself or apologizing or even any moral judgment and more just about capturing what she was feeling. The whole power imbalance is a lot to consider, and while she does discuss this in terms of the double standard that men often date women uncomfortably younger than them without social shame it doesn’t necessarily come across as if she thought she was giving an attempt at subversive feminism or something. Though this does touch on a double standard of aging and, as French writer Mona Chollet says, ‘Men don’t age better than women, they’re just allowed to age,’ which is another aspect of older men dating young women as a sort of status symbol to show for themselves ‘their decay is not counted against them.’ She does admit, however, that her reasoning behind the affair is largely the similar: to recapture her own youth. In looking at the young man’s young face ‘mine was young too’ without the reminder of aging she saw in her own husband. ‘Men have known this forever, and I saw no reason to deprive myself.’ With Ernaux you know you are going to get honesty. ‘A mature woman appeared to be more dangerous than a young woman.’ She discusses the frequent looks of disapproval she gets but doesn’t allow them to bother her but ‘reinforced my determination.’ It becomes a way for her to re-experience youth, such as introducing him to places and art new to him that makes them suddenly new for her as well, and she thrives off it. ‘I felt as if I were the same outrageous girl again,’ she writes in reference to a time when, at age 18, her mother felt scandalized by a tight dress she wore drawing a lot of attention, ‘this time, without the slightest sense of shame, but a sense of victory.’ Though she is still always aware of that age gap and how the relationship often makes them both neither of their own generation or the other’s. Young Man is a bit slight, even for Ernaux, but it is still a nice foray into the aspects of her books that remind me why I keep coming back for more. She is always open and honest, even admitting this whole thing was about her and it wasn’t like she compared him to other men but that all men were basically just one blurr in a photo with herself as the focus. It’s a slice of life shaken up with all its pockets turned out to collect any riches of living that can be examined and valued, and I love that about her works. She charms me every time and I can’t wait for more of her good gossip. 3.5/5 ‘I felt only the sweetness of my own continuity and the consistency of my desire.’ IMPORTANT UPDATE: [image] Thanks to Seven Stories Press for sending me this amazing Annie Ernaux metal font hat for preordering a bunch of her books, because now she and I have matching hats and that pretty much makes us besties, right? ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Sep 08, 2023
|
Sep 08, 2023
|
Sep 08, 2023
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1787740234
| 9781787740235
| 1787740234
| 4.11
| 76
| unknown
| Aug 22, 2023
|
really liked it
|
I’ll never forget when I first heard Gil Scott-Heron. A buddy of mine played me The Revolution Will Not Be Televised one night late into a porch drink
I’ll never forget when I first heard Gil Scott-Heron. A buddy of mine played me The Revolution Will Not Be Televised one night late into a porch drinking session and I knew I had to give this guy’s catalog a good listen. Which is a familiar story for many, such as Thomas Mauceri—author of this incredible graphic memoir In Search of Gil Scott-Heron—who first heard that song in college during the frustrations over the Florida recounts in the Gore/Bush election in 2000. Seb Piquet, who’s gorgeous artwork brings this book to life, delivers that moment perfectly: [image] This memoir will appeal to both long time fans of the artist as well as newcomers who will certainly want to give him a listen after, particularly as Mauceri breaks up the narrative with lovely inserts going into detail about key songs (either his favorites or ones relevant to that point in the story) such as The Bottle, New York Is Killing Me, The Other Side and more. He was an incredible artist, often called the ‘godfather of rap’ (though he found that reductive and preferred to be a ‘bluesologist’) and inspired generations of musicians (we see Kanye West perform a song at Gil’s funeral that he’d written as a tribute to the legend) his is a sad tale that chases the history of Scott-Heron and how it intertwines with Thomas Mauceri’s own life as he spends years trying to finally connect with Scott-Heron for a documentary only to discover he has passed on the day they are supposed to meet. Which is where this memoir begins. A loving tribute to a cherished artist as well as a meditation on place, race, and history unfolding, In Search of Gil Scott-Heron is a heartfelt and gorgeous graphic memoir. [image] This is just as much the story of Thomas Mauceri as it is the history of Gil Scott-Heron, which some readers might be surprised about, but the intertwining of tales really works here. Especially in place of the documentary he was never able to create. We begin with Mauceri coming from France to study in the US, having to leave after 9/11, and returning time and time again for projects, always hoping to connect with Gil in order to do a documentary about him. He wanted to show how much the city and the whole of Black history from the Civil Rights to the present comes alive in his music as much as those elements helped create his music. Piquet’s illustrations of the various places in Harlem and New York really capture this, and there are also some really powerful scenes about political events such as the election of Barack Obama in 2004 while Mauceri was in New York. And while he never meets Gil, we do meet a lot of people important to his life, such as Abiodun Oyewole of The Last Poets. It is a really great narrative that tells the lives of both men and captures how much your inspiring artists leave a mark on your life. [image] Scott-Heron’s words seem reflective of theAudre Lorde poem, A Litany for Survival that ends: when we speak we are afraid our words will not be heard nor welcomed but when we are silent we are still afraid So it is better to speak remembering we were never meant to survive.’ I found In Search of Gil Scott-Heron to be a rather moving and interesting read that, despite not being what I expected, ended up being something really cool and dynamic. I love seeing how much an artist can impact someone and I really liked the way it tied in modern US political history with this story. I remember all these events as well (though I was about a decade younger) so it was a fascinating framing for revisiting them. Do yourself a massive favor and put on some Gil Scott-Heron and raise a toast to the amazing artist now gone, and check this book out if you can! ⅘ [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Aug 30, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1506734189
| 9781506734187
| 1506734189
| 4.35
| 2,349
| May 20, 2021
| Aug 08, 2023
|
it was amazing
|
Sara’s longterm relationship takes a turn in her adorable and informative graphic memoir, Us, when Diana breaks some big news to her. After a lifetime
Sara’s longterm relationship takes a turn in her adorable and informative graphic memoir, Us, when Diana breaks some big news to her. After a lifetime of trying to understand themselves, Diana has realized she is a trans woman and is ready to make the transition but is nervous how Sara will treat her as well as all the social elements that will inevitably come into play. This is a really tender and touching look at Diana’s transition as well as Sara’s journey to realizing she is bisexual, all told through Sara Soler’s cute illustrations and translated into english by Siliva Perea Labayen (Sara and Diana are from Spain). The memoir proceeds with a bubbly and boisterous energy that makes it fast-paced, humorous and very accessible while still productively covering big ideas. From social stigmas and harassment (Sara points out how misuderstandings and disinformation have allowed people to ‘opt harmful attitudes’ that can be very hurtful and dangerous) to the discomforts around how to present oneself and the oppressive weight of social gender roles, Us covers a lot of topics through the story of Sara and Diana’s relationship and experience. It is careful to make room for many different kinds of experiences as well, discussing the topics in the way they related to them but showing that everyone is unique and may have different experiences. ‘There are as many experiences as there are trans people in the world. Each person chooses their own path.’ This is a really lovely graphic memoir and truly shows how much love and support goes a long way. [image] ’You’re not alone’ is one of the most important messages in this book. This story covers several years and does well by showing how coming to terms and transitioning can be a big process. When Diana first brings it up it is a full two years before she is ready to make any changes and the opening of this book dives into a lot of anxieties that can keep people trapped in their own silence and afraid to be themselves. What makes Us really work is how effectively it juggles a lot of big concepts on the intersections along the spectrum of gender and sexuality. It is a good look at how society comes into play as well. For example, Diana notes how finally seeing positive trans representation in media was a big opening for her to finally start addressing what she was feeling inside and Sara discusses how the stereotypes of trans people and usually only being seen as villains or murder victims can be really harmful. Especially in a demographic that has an alarmingly high suicide rate and rate of being victims to violence. Having positive representation isn’t the only thing though, and having the support of loved ones and space to accept yourself positively have shown to be a huge mental health benefit for lgbtq+ people of all varieties. I really appreciate how this book never deadnames or misgenders Diana, even in the scenes before her transition, which shows that it is actually not that difficult to get that correct if you try. And earnestly trying is what is often most important. Through Sara’s journey the book also discusses the stigmas against bisexual people (like myself), which I appreciated being threaded in for a larger scope of discussion on these topics. Perhaps the biggest topic discusses is gender roles and how socially enforced stereotypes around gender can be harmful to everyone. Things like “boys don’t cry” or “girls should be delicate”, for instance, are shown as harmful and how beliefs on how someone of a gender should act are increasingly oppressive if that just isn’t who you are. There are also a lot of interesting looks at how, once she presents as a woman, Diana begins to experience the harassment and misogyny faced by women and it is really eye opening for her. Something I found this book does well is offer information and ideas in a way that reach a large audience and how it applies to them. It’s just a well done book but through all of it, the most important thing we learn about Diana and Sara is: [image] ”We’re happy!” I really enjoyed Us by Sara Soler and I feel this is an important book that many can get a lot out of as well as just enjoy the couple’s really loving relationship and openness about their experiences. Us is fun, funny and quite effectively done while being very heartfelt. 5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Aug 29, 2023
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1770462899
| 9781770462892
| 1770462899
| 4.40
| 32,131
| Sep 13, 2022
| Sep 13, 2022
|
it was amazing
|
‘The worst part for me about being harassed here isn’t that people say shitty things…The worst thing is that your heart breaks.’ Some jobs break more t ‘The worst part for me about being harassed here isn’t that people say shitty things…The worst thing is that your heart breaks.’ Some jobs break more than just your back. Deeply necessary and often devastating, Kate Beaton’s harrowing graphic memoir Ducks: Two Years in the Oil Sands takes a brutal and bluntly honest look at the labor force from the safety risks, harassment to sexual assaults that occurred and puts a spotlight on how the workers are just as exploited as the land. Fresh out of college but also fresh out of money to pay off her loans, Beaton leaves home to take part in the Alberta oil boom becoming yet another in the lineage of those who must leave Nova Scotia to go where the money and jobs are. But in an isolated place where men outnumber the women 50 to 1, she finds this places a target on her for unwanted advances and harassment and all the while the destruction of the land by the oil industry, the unsafe conditions and the deaths of coworkers start assailing her mind as well. She shows how these conditions make sexual assault a near inevitability. Beaton takes a very empathetic look at those caught in this sort of life, and for many readers this might often leave you feeling rather empty inside at points, as if inside you was also a vast frozen land with icy wind being mined like the stolen lands in her narrative. There is a lot to process here and, truthful, this dredged up a lot of complicated emotions and memories of my own past working factories and other male dominated, physical labor jobs that also often took an existential toll on me. Yet there is still beauty within this story of Beaton’s struggles—as well as a rather lovely art style that helps propel the story told in a long series of anecdotes along a 2 year arc—and this is an important plea to understand the toll misogyny, harassment and assault takes on women as well as the mental and physical tolls this line of work can bring. Brilliantly layered themes addressed with plenty of empathy, nuances and addressing many issues as systemic instead of isolated, Ducks is an essential read. [image] This was a really important read done with such heartbreaking honesty and heartfelt integrity. The story really moves along and covers a lot of ground, and while it can seem a bit repetitive it doesn’t bog it down and instead seems a rather authentic representation of just how repetitive the days in this type of work can be. But also really effectively shows how the minor harassments or general creepiness from men start to become an unbearable weight under the constant repetition of examples. This can be a rather difficult read emotionally and also a touchy subject, as one character learns when she tries to write an article about the horrible conditions faced by women there and is told she is trying to vilify honest labor and make all men seem like monsters. Beaton addresses this more head-on in her afterword: ‘I have seen many people quick to become defensive against the suggestion that gendered violence exists in places like the oil sands. They may either work there and are proud of the work they do and the livelihoods they support with it, or they know and love men there, and are insulted by the insinuation of being lumped in with anything to do with something as abhorrent as sexual assault.’ The horrible part is how most of the men don’t see their actions as anything other than “how guys are” and find her frustration to be playful instead of actual disgust. Yet it is damaging and takes a huge toll. As Beaton writes in the afterword about the sexual assault that occurs ‘I was nothing in his life but a short release from the boredom and loneliness endemic in camp life, but he was a major trauma in mine.’ I found it rather effective the way she shows that, even if it isn’t everyone who is harassing (she makes a point several times to talk about how there are plenty of men there who leave her alone) the sheer quantity of it happening is unnerving and how it is practically inevitable that her safety will be violated. Especially in the camps where she keeps her door locked and hears men try to open it in the middle of the night (another woman says one time a man hid in her closet and jumped out at her), and how being taken advantage of while drunk is viewed as being her own fault—even her own friend accuses her of trying to make regrettable sex seem like an assault instead of owning her own decisions. But it is important to remember that there is no such thing as consent in a situation where you cannot say “no”. This includes situations where you feel saying no is a threat to your personal safety. It is addressed multiple times how speaking out even on everyday harassment is almost impossible, from being ignored or told to just take a joke, and if someone is fired over a complaint the woman is viewed by everyone as the villain, a troublemaker just trying to get attention. She constantly hears men saying the women at the camp only work there to get sex in a place with less competition and women who are assaulted are always blamed for it. It’s very distressing. [image] Much of Ducks focuses not only on how these men could be anyone but also on how the conditions of the camps enables it. Of those outside the situation her character says ‘they don't think that the loneliness and homesickness and boredom and lack of women around would affect their brother or dad or husband the same way.’ Which is just tragic and as much an indictment on the management as the men behaving this way. When one is not given a safe space to speak out, these acts become enabled through the culture of silence enforced around them. I used to work in a factory, and later doing a uniform and floor mat delivery at factories and a lot of the depictions of labor hit very close to home. I would go to a good 30some factories a week, some that I knew every time I left I’d have weird allergies or feel ill from physically (I think of Beaton saying there ‘just shit’ in the air and when she asks ‘Do I even want to know what kind of cancer will have in 20 years?’ I think of all the glues and sprays we used in the sign-making factory I once worked at with no ventilation), and the thing that bothered me the most was the odd comments people would make to me during my stops. I think a big part was wondering what made them think I was a person they could say that too, and if they’d say that to a stranger what sort of terrible comments do they make around people they feel comfortable with. And what am I going to do, complain? I’ll just be replaced on that stop on the route. All the homophobic comments when I worked in the factory sure hurt but what was I going to do, out myself as pansexual by complaining? How’s that going to go for me after that? I mean, I can’t possibly truly understand what Beaton went through but I did have a lot of difficult memories about working in physical labor jobs while reading this. It happens everywhere, and part of the problem is that this sort of behavior is almost coded into the image of “tough labor guy.” Though another aspect of this, which Beaton effectively demonstrates, is this is damaging to the men as well. The character Ryan, for example, is going through a difficult period of mental health and suicide ideation but doesn’t feel he can talk about it (it’ll just make him the butt of jokes if he does), and that gets into how toxic masculinity can become a sort of shame chamber where men feel they can’t express any emotion that isn’t anger. [image] The ducks are shown to not only be the literal ducks that die due to environmental destruction from the company, but also to metaphorically be the workers as well, led to what they think is a safe place to land and find themselves exploited. Most of the workers have traveled far to be there where the money is, many from Nova Scotia like Beaton herself. For many, this is all they have, and where will they have to go once the work dries up? ‘I need to tell you this--there is no knowing Cape Breton without knowing how deeply ingrained two diametrically opposed experiences are: A deep love for home, and the knowledge of how frequently we have to leave it to find work somewhere else.’ But there is also the element of the fact that literal ducks die from landing in the water there and the company’s solutions to environmental protection are about the same as their safety policy: lip service and half-assed attempts and looking like you are trying without caring either way. There are endless meetings about safety nobody pays attention to and it is noted how celebrating X amount of hours since a “lost time accident” is a way to gloss over the many injuries that actually are taking place. But then there is the environment being polluted and the indigenous activists speaking out only to be a blip on the media and then never given a voice again. ‘Everything's ruined, our lives around our lands are ruined, our water, the air, everything.Their almighty dollar comes first. That's pretty sad. You can't eat money. At the cost of our lives-as long as they get their money. They don't care how many of us they kill off.’ The part that really broke my heart was when Beaton is able to get away for a while and chase her dream far from the horrible conditions, only to find she can’t afford to do so and has to be plunged back into the oil sands again. I think of doing 80hr weeks in the factory (we wouldn’t know if we worked Saturday and Sunday until Friday afternoon so making plans was not happening) and people saying yea but overtime is great. Sure the money was alright but I was 25, I’d rather see my child and have a life. It’s not like a job I hated was fulfilling. Though then I worked jobs I didn’t hate and found I couldn’t afford to live on it, spending a few years where I was working three jobs, delivering bulk coffee around the Midwest (trading up for the uniform company driver job), picking up bookstore shifts and then bartending weddings every Friday and Saturday night. Just as exhausting (but slightly better pay but hey only 70hr weeks!). I’m not saying I don’t want to work but you shouldn’t have to be rich to not devote your whole existence to making money for someone above you. Beaton shows that very effectively here. And, as one character mentions, it isn’t those making their millions that are doing the dangerous work and away from their families so much. This is a really heartfelt and heart wrenching look at life in that line of work but also a sharp condemnation of the misogyny that occurs there. This is a book I think everyone would benefit from reading and I am amazed at Kate Beaton for being so vulnerable and honest with this work. Ducks is one of the finest graphic memoirs I’ve ever read and while it is emotionally devastating, it is also very necessary. 5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Aug 16, 2023
|
Aug 16, 2023
|
Aug 16, 2023
|
Hardcover
| |||||||||||||||
1524863270
| 9781524863272
| 1524863270
| 4.30
| 6,930
| Sep 27, 2022
| Sep 27, 2022
|
really liked it
|
Some days are just shit. It happens to us all and it feels like the day is out to sabotage you. But then there are times when it feels like your own s
Some days are just shit. It happens to us all and it feels like the day is out to sabotage you. But then there are times when it feels like your own self is trying to sabotage you no matter what you do, even sabotaging your drive to do something about it. Everything Is OK is an honest and soothing graphic novel by Debbie Tung that tackles the latter issue and serves as a memoir opening up about her own depression. As someone that has also struggled with depression off and on throughout life, I found this very relatable and I think that Tung is really wonderful for being able to be so upfront with her own life as a way to reach others and help them through hard times and remember that they are not alone. Because you aren’t alone and even when it seems impossible to go forward or that nobody cares, there are people who do care and you can get through it (also know there are many resources to help and people to provide aid and support), and sometimes half the struggle is just recognizing you need help. Which there is no shame in doing, as Everything Is OK does a great job of demonstrating. This is a playful yet very raw and emotional read and Tung’s adorable artwork helps guide you through the memoir that is perhaps a bit basic with broadstroke advice but nonetheless moving and heartwarming. [image] Relatable I feel like it doesn’t get talked about enough that depression can come in many different forms and can present as individually as we are all unique individuals. Someone smiling and cracking jokes can still be trying to desperately keep their head above water internally, for instance I find I’m usually at my most humorous and quickest with a good one-liner during my darkest times. Which is also something that gets ignored often—depression can manifest in bouts mania or intense activity and creativity. I find I try to push thoughts aside by taking on too much to try to feel better about myself and often make jokes like wow I’m burning through novels super quick I should probably check on my mental health. It’s funny to others because, yep, I read a lot of pretty dark novels and actually because I enjoy them, but in reality it’s not the content its the sudden sleepless drive that I need to watch for. Not that you can really control when depression might strike and it’s often like a Stephen King jump scare showing up on a sunny day in a crowded place. Which is also an aspect I find really tragic about depression is how you can be surrounded by people yet still be feeling really alone. And second guessing every encounter or assuming the worst. For many, getting out of bed can be hard or their inner thoughts are so loud they never feel rested and are anxious about everything to come. And sometimes even though you know you are just down and should get up, get out, maybe go for a run or do something to get out of the rut, you just simply cannot. Or even your favorite things suddenly give you no joy. Debbie Tung captures these feelings quite effectively here. Whew, long interlude but lets talk about this book some more. I quite enjoyed Book Love by her and she has a knack at capturing what makes her, her so I was interested to see how she would handle another very relatable topic. Lately I often wonder ‘is anyone doing okay right now?!’ and I suspect a lot of people will get something out of this book, even if its just a better perspective on depression. It goes through her personal experiences, from panic attacks to worrying her therapist won’t like her and more, all while being supported by a very patient and loving partner so I’m so glad she had that. It really made me feel for her and she really allows herself to be vulnerable here. There are a lot of great messages about recognizing the problem, seeking help, and keeping with it too. [image] Some aspects really hit home. She talks about how there is still such a stigma around mental health, showing how when you have a cold people are quick to be supportive and tell you to feel better. But mental health people often judge you, think you are trying to get attention or make excuses for behavior. We’ve certainly made progress on this front but always can do better and we need to allow people the space to process and be themselves and make room to allow ourselves to feel emotion instead of keeping it bottled up. As a child I was told boys don’t cry and I’m glad I didn’t listen because I fucking love a good cry when needed--hell I just sobbed my eyes out at the Barbie movie. No shame. Cry at movies, its the coolest. But I also really related to the therapist scenes. I’m so bad at therapists, I always just want to tell them ‘you helped me!’ so they feel good about themselves and feel like they are good at their jobs I guess? But also being vulnerable is hard. Lets all make space to let people be more vulnerable. Everything is OK is a sweet little graphic memoir. It gets rather same-y and might be overly long, as well as not really being all that unique despite being her individual story, but all the same it is a lovely read. I would encourage anyone to check it out, especially if any of this sounds relatable. And also take care of your mental health, friends, and check in on each other. 3.5/5 [image] You don’t need permission from anyone to be yourself ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Aug 02, 2023
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
0374515735
| 9780374515737
| 0374515735
| 4.18
| 918
| 1964
| Jul 01, 1980
|
really liked it
|
‘It’s gone too far and at the same time not far enough. We can’t stop now.’ If there is any true magic in the world, it is art. In its many mediums, li ‘It’s gone too far and at the same time not far enough. We can’t stop now.’ If there is any true magic in the world, it is art. In its many mediums, like vibrations of sounds to build a melody, the chess moods of words towards a poem, or the collective brushstrokes to create an image, art captures emotions, narratives and, ultimately, the essence of life in an way that helps us feel more deeply through the abstract imaginings of ideas. While art can be cathartic to create and allow us to open our creative floodgates onto the world, it can also be an arduous task on the soul of an artist concerned about their abilities as a vessel from which beauty can be carried into the world, and such is the struggles of Swiss sculptor and painter Alberto Giacometti in Jame’s Lords A Giacometti Portrait. Chronicling the eighteen days Lord sat as a model for Giacometti for a portrait made with brushes and paints, Lord in turn channels anecdotes of their conversations and his observation on the artist to, in turn, create a portrait of Giacometti in words. Like the way the visuals of a painting is an opening to see into it for so much more, Lord tells us through his book that ‘to see even so little will be to see very much,’ and we are offered what reads like the window into a genius yet self-doubting and tortured artist as he grapples with his techniques ‘to show how things appear to me,’ and ‘explain in visual terms a perception of reality.’ This is a lovely book, one I completed in a single sitting but will certainly turn to again and again for it’s strikingly perceptive looks at artistry and the struggle to create something beautiful. [image] Giacometti working on his portrait of Lord What began as a promise of a one-day session becomes a mutli-week companionship as Giacometti refuses to be satisfied with his representation of Lord, reworking the head again and again as he confesses self-doubt and dissatisfaction. He finds each attempt ‘by definition an inadequate semblance of what he visualized as an ultimately tolerable representation of reality,’ and frets over what he sees is an impossibility to truly capture anything or even finish. ‘That’s the terrible thing: the more one works on a picture, the more impossible it becomes to finish it,’ he says at times, other times claiming ‘it’s impossible ever really to finish anything,’ and those who have created art will certainly empathize with his struggles against overworking a piece versus not doing enough. I myself certainly don’t count as an artist though I do spend a lot of time painting with oil pastels and have this struggle, feeling something is not complete or adequate but worrying any additional touches will spoil the frail beauty it does capture. I think of Bob Ross episodes where you are in awe at a striking landscape he has done and then Ross says it needs one more tree and crosses the entire canvas with a thick brush stroke. “Noooooo!” you want to shout, it was perfect, now it’s marred by this additional flourish yet, a few minutes later, you see it has now become the best part of the painting and tied it all together in ways moments ago you couldn’t ever dream imaginable. When people talk about narrative tension, perhaps this is the most pure of them, knowing you should trust Bob Ross to pull it off but feeling as gashed and dashed as the painting looks the moment he adds that new line. ‘Giacometti is committed to his work in a particularly intense and total way. The creative compulsion is never wholly absent from him, never leaves him a moment of complete peace.’ There is a certain fatalism to Giacometti, seeming rather gloomy and often destroying his work (there is a moment when Lord finds him in the parking lot tearing up a pile of his drawings). And his statements on how he cannot simply move to another part of a painting before completing the head really resonated with me as that is also my struggle with anything I work on. I write these reviews in one go from the top to the bottom and find the introduction to be the hardest part, but I simply cannot just start working on the body until I finish the intro. To do so always makes the rest feel false to me. It’s like when Giacometti tells Lord ‘everything must come of itself and in its own time. Otherwise, it becomes superficial.’ I read this for my book club and we had a discussion on his complaints about futility and while some found him to be frustrating and thought whiny, I felt it was delivered more as self-deprecating humor and likely said with a half smile and not meant fully serious, the type of jokes that hint at the truth but are softened by being said jokingly. Though that comes as someone who often employs self-deprecating humor as well as a means to grapple with one's own volatile self-reflections. Lord seems to see it as a good window into Giacometti’s feelings about himself as well. ‘This constant expression of self-doubt is neither an affectation nor an appeal for reassurance,’ Lord examines about Giacometti, ‘but simply spontaneous outpouring of his deep feeling of uncertainty as to the ultimate quality of his achievement.’ ‘[T]he possibility of reproducing exactly by means of brushes and pigment the sensation of vision caused by a particular aspect of reality. This, of course, is by definition an impossibility and yet for that very reason is endlessly enticing and valid.’ We see Giacometti discuss art and other artists quite frequently as well, often criticizing Cezanne and Picasso (when asked what period of Picasso’s he likes best, Giacometti curtly replies ‘none’). As to his opinions on his own work he responds: ‘I’m the first to think that they’re better than what anyone else does. But then I realize that that has absolutely no relation to what I hope to be able to do, so I conclude that really they’re no good at all.’ I found great value in his thoughts on creating. ‘On might imagine,’ he tells Lord, ‘that in order to make a painting it’s simply a question of placing one detail next to another. But that’s not it. That’s not it at all. It’s a question of resting a complete entity all at once.’ He asserts that painting is not photography, and that even photography is capturing an impression of reality as opposed to “being” reality, and that art lies in the representation of the impression. He compares different styles of statue busts arguing in favor of the less perfect representations saying ‘the more you struggle to make it lifelike, the less like life it becomes. But since a work of art is an illusion anyway, if you heighten the illusory quality, then you come closer to the effect of life.’ This is an idea I really appreciate, and feel in fiction is how things like satire and magical realism, for example, often examine great truths through caricatures or distortions of reality to shake up the truth and see it from a fresh angle. Yet we can’t forget Lord in all this, who plays an important role as the model. ‘To be present by helpless, to be involved but removed,’ Lord says ‘made me uneasy,’ and he discusses how a deep relationship between artist and model often forms. I suppose this touches on the idea of the muse, and at times one wonders if the near-refusal to complete the work might be drawing from a desire to keep Lord near for longer. ‘It is often said that artists of great talent are able, and seek, to convey not only the external appearance but also the inner nature of their models,’ Lord writes, and I find this beautiful as it probes the idea that so much more beyond the visual image is contained in a painting. ‘Everything must be destroyed. I have to start all over again from zero.’ A brief but lasting little memoir on a prolonged session with an artist, A Giacometti Portrait is a blunt little gem of portrait of both artist and model. As well as a lovely look at the act of creating and the ideas that go into it. I will certainly pull this down from my shelf in years to come to revisit some of these fantastic lines, and while it is a book about art many of the ideas can be applied to a variety of life’s pursuits. 4.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Jun 25, 2023
|
Jun 25, 2023
|
Jun 25, 2023
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
1534323864
| 9781534323865
| 1534323864
| 4.19
| 10,161
| Nov 09, 2022
| Nov 15, 2022
|
it was amazing
|
‘Maybe I’d be dead if not for this. But instead I’m going to make something that didn’t exist before. And I think that’s beautiful.’ What is the purpos ‘Maybe I’d be dead if not for this. But instead I’m going to make something that didn’t exist before. And I think that’s beautiful.’ What is the purpose of art? This is a question everyone from philosophers to the drunk next to you at the bar has grappled with since, well, someone first smeared some berries on a wall and someone was affected by it. You can always find the big, heavy quotations that attempt to maximize the beauty into a universal struggle for goodness and connectivity that improves us all, like Leo Tolstoy saying art ‘is a means of union among men, joining them together in the same feelings, and indispensable for the life and progress toward well-being of individuals and of humanity,’ but whew, if this is at a party it’ll kill the vibes pretty quickly. Besides, someone’s got a meme with good graphic design (I’m gonna guess a mountain range) of some shallow quote about Earth just being ‘eh’ without it that will basically cover the same grounds. Sharability, intended audience, subjectivity and what not. What I’m getting at is that maybe the power of art is an artwork all to itself. No, that sounds trite but the idea of letters colliding into a statement that will give a feeling is pretty cool at least, right? I’m getting carried away here What we are gathered for here today is to celebrate Zoe Thorogood and It’s Lonely at the Centre of the Earth, her marvelous ‘auto-bio-graphical novel’ that deals with art, depression, suicide, and just living a life. This is an exciting and wild ride through some heavy territory with a chaos of artistic styles (all of them extraordinary) and stories that form a larger portrait that feels pretty damn…human. There is a frenetic energy that roars forward through this highly metafictional memoir experiment that would feel twee or already well-trodden in lesser hands but becomes this incredible work that feels just as messy and lovely as real life should be. It is a controlled mess, one that is certainly well thought out but reads naturally. Sure, it might be a little over-the-top at times but that’s what makes it work—it pushes everything just a little too far because that zone is where magic is made. You are going to want to read this. [image] This isn’t a light read, but Thorogood blends the harsh introspections with gallows humor and slapstick fun that keeps this bouncing forwards and impossible to put down. The art is fantastic, pivoting between styles and alternating between bright colors to black and white ink frames in a way that feels akin to the ups and downs of moods when struggling with depression. Which, to be fair, is a primary theme of this book. The story follows Zoe writing this book about writing herself for a period of six months, though it sways through the timeline of her entire life as well as into more abstract realms of her creative mind. [image] This is a highly self-conscious book, capturing the very human inner contradictions and inner dialogues we all face, particularly during moments of self-doubt. Thorogood is very open and honest—often under the guise of self-deprecating humor—about her mental health, issues with life and struggles with her family. There is a discussion on depression being passed down through generations while the elder generations view mental health as a ‘dirty secret’ and don’t like how openly she speaks about her own, something I’ve experienced or seen far too often. This is a highly empathetic book, one that you may likely feel is showing you to yourself through the lens of her own self-analysis and so much so that she even jokes about how often people call her work relatable. It is existence exposed in all its messy flaws and joys, a book teeming with life and the feeling that ‘you’re getting older but you don’t know how to grow up.’ Did I mention most people are drawn as people with animal heads? It is awesome. I love her art and vision so much. Some might be quick to dismiss some of the book as naval-gazing or too much pop philosophy, I think that those aspects are some of what makes it work best. Because it is self-conscious about that too, with Thorogood following up bold statements like ‘Reading a book, hearing a song, observing a painting—that’s connection. Sometimes wires get crossed and things get misinterpreted--but that’s pretty damn human, right?’ with a dismissal of it that she is ‘sucking her own dick.’ The self-conscious aspects there are real, and its a great technique (and you can quietly admit to yourself that the lofty moments actually are beautiful while still getting to laugh at yourself for it). This comes across screaming Cool then scowls at the idea of being cool. Which, let’s face it, is pretty cool. But ‘cool’ isn’t the point, because this is about struggling and trying to find your way. It’s so wrapped in layers of self-criticism and sneering at itself that it’s hard to get a hold on, but I think capturing that very thing is what makes this so well done. In the end, this is a book about experiencing and creating art. There are the moments about how it can help or heal, the old Picasso saying stuff like ‘art washes from the soul the dust of everyday life’ vibes. But more importantly the metafictional aspects of creating and how we are in turn created through critical analysis in the minds of others. ‘Zoe was hit with the horrible realization that she was, in fact, a real person. A real person whose art could be perceived and interpreted by other very real people,’ she writes at one point (with a nice line about her book getting polarizing ratings on Goodreads). Art is something we experience, and while it is an individual battle to create, it becomes a social item that everyone consumes, comments on, takes with them in their heart or leaves behind. There is also the fun aspect of realizing how much narratives shape our ideas about life. ‘I didn’t realize until later that the underdog was always the hero because all writers were losers at school,’ she observes at one point on her childhood belief in her own goodness. Which, at heart, is an early lesson on how art reaches out to hold your hand in moments of hardship. She begins to realize her earlier work The Impending Blindness of Billie Scott is very much about creating a narrative of who she is becoming who she wants to be, while this book about writing this very book is more a look at who she is afraid she is becoming. The Covid pandemic figures into the story as well, derailing her success after her first book by canceling her book tour and plunging her into solitude. Connectivity with others becomes a major concept she turns over, examining how much the self is observed as a product of other’s observations, though also how lonely one can be without it. She chronicles friendships, a failed romance and more. While life may not have any answers, what we arrive at here is lovely enough: ‘Someone, somewhere, right now is being impacted by your existence—whether good or bad. That’s what I choose to believe this is all about. Not connection—but how we affect each other. Even at a distance.’ That is as good as any reason to make art. Or to be you and communicate with others. I was touched by this a lot, remembering how I used to leave paintings with favorite poems written on them on trees around my town. Mostly just as an ‘I was here’ but also to hopefully have someone pause, read, and be touched by poetry even for only a moment. And hopefully feel good about the world. So yes, I believe this to be true. Zoe Thorogood’s It’s Lonely at the Centre of the Earth has affected me, I think it is marvelous, and now I am passing it along through this review that might affect you. All without ever really seeing or knowing each other. But I’m also shoving this into the face of every person that walks into the bookstore and library I work at. I hope Thorogood is doing well and will create more art. We can all benefit from being affected by it. 5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 17, 2022
|
Nov 17, 2022
|
Nov 17, 2022
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
4.31
| 59,005
| Mar 14, 2000
| May 14, 2019
|
really liked it
|
Memory becomes a literary playground in the works of Nobel Prize winning author Annie Ernaux, who’s succinct and poetically precise prose ‘helps to co
Memory becomes a literary playground in the works of Nobel Prize winning author Annie Ernaux, who’s succinct and poetically precise prose ‘helps to convey that precise moment when I feel I have bonded with my former life, the one that has gone for ever,’ and navigate the reader through intensely tactile experiences of emotions and painful reminiscence. I have been consistently blown away by her openness and insights, and in Happening Ernaux bravely and directly examines her abortion in 1963 when she was a young college student. While Ernaux writes that she had to ‘guard against lyrical outbursts such as anger or pain’ and removes much of the emotion, the reader is nonetheless threaded along on the emotional currents of fear and socially-induced shame that had undeniably engulfed her during this time. This is a quick read and although it is short in page length at just 93pgs—typical for Ernaux—it looms large in depth and impact: to read Ernaux books is like microdosing emotional devastation and I cannot get enough. Happening is a very heavy book that deals with a highly polarizing subject that, in the US, is once again a very timely subject 20 years after it was written and 60 years after the events within when France still had not legalized women’s reproductive rights. I am in awe of Ernaux for confronting her memories with such grace and openness, dissecting how the ban in the 60s didn’t reduce instances and only made them more dangerous as well as created a social stigma that exponentially piled shame and ostracization on already suffering and terrified women as the ‘sheer experience of life and death gave way to exposure and judgment.’. Ernaux has once again destroyed me with her words. ‘I shall have no more power over my text, exposed to the public just like my body was exposed at the Hôtel-Dieu Hospital.’ What always impresses me most with Ernaux is how in her act of writing her memories, be they intended as memoir or thinly disguised as fiction, they reproduce and investigate the social and emotional contexts of the time period in order to better convey the depicted events. Ernaux is also conscious of how the act of writing informs upon ideas of memoir, each book feeling like those clear models of cars that show the engine running within and remind you how each element is consciously tuned and coordinated for the full effect. ‘After all, imagining and remembering are the very essence of writing,’ she writes and elegantly weds the two. But this is important in a book that is so open and bluntly honest, one she knows will receive as much judgment as the act she recounts and she writes to capture that. ‘Above all I wished to capture the steady flow of unhappiness…The distress I experience on recalling certain images and on hearing certain words is beyond comparison with what I felt at the time: these are merely literary emotions; in other words they generate the act of writing and justify its veracity.’ She tells us she is not writing from a place of regret and has always stood by her decisions as being the right one for her at the time, even stating ‘I know that this ordeal and this sacrifice were necessary for me to want to have children,’ which she would later in life. What is most important is that she adds her voice, one she says is important because once something is legalized ‘former victims tend to remain silent on the grounds that “now it’s all over,”’ and become ‘surrounded by the same veil of secrecy as before.’ She says she can avoid writing as an act of capturing rebellion and ‘face the reality of this unforgettable event,’ but also I believe this act of writing adds her to the list of women who showed empathy, comfort and aid to her during this time and allows her to be that comfort to another who may be reading this because ‘knowing that hundreds of other women had been through the same thing was a comfort to me.’ Many people across the world need that just as much today as ever. ‘As was often the case, you couldn’t tell whether abortion was banned because it was wrong or wrong because it was banned. People judged according to the law, they didn’t judge the law.’ What resonates so urgently in Happening is the social stigmas, shame and danger women face when reproductive rights are denied to them, a right that Simone de Beauvoir claims is essential to women’s liberation in The Second Sex. Potential readers be aware this may be an uncomfortable read for many reasons (inevitably this review as well), and Ernaux addresses that directly: ‘I realize this account may exasperate or repel some readers; it may also be branded as distasteful. I believe that any experience, whatever its nature, has the inalienable right to be chronicled. There is no such thing as a lesser truth. Moreover, if I failed to go through with this undertaking, I would be guilty of silencing the lives of women and condoning a world governed by male supremacy.’ At the time I read this, the United States was less than a week away from an election where in my state reproductive rights were the primary battleground just months after the US Supreme Court overturned Row vs. Wade. This book certainly hit hard, as the dangers and stigmas Ernaux elucidates are becoming a reality in many states. Luckily most states here have shown up in support of reproductive rights, with total bans proving extremely unpopular and losing most elections. Yet, without being codified into the constitution this is still an issue that is always looming. ‘In my diary I wrote: “I am pregnant. It’s a nightmare.”’ Ernaux writes ‘the thing growing inside me I saw as the stigma of social failure,’ and as a college student who wishes to pursue academic arts, she writes that it would deny her access into that world and return her to the working class. Similarly, her pregnancy would be viewed as just another ‘inescapable fatality of the working-class—the legacy of poverty—embodied by both the pregnant girl and the alcoholic.’ She writes that ‘I had stopped being “an intellectual.” I don’t know whether this feeling is widespread. It causes indescribable pain,’ and finds that she had ‘become an emotional outcast.’ The class aspects are interesting, as she knows there are avenues available but her social and financial status are massive barriers to them. Doctors won’t risk helping her (one even prescribed her medicine that prevents miscarriages while giving the impression he is helping), friend’s judge, and men seem to approach her with a sick fascination that unsettles her except ‘the only person who failed to show an interest was the boy who had gotten me pregnant.’ She notes, however, that for all the social ostracization of those who choose to abort, the same, if not worse, is heaped on single mothers that either chose or were forced to carry to term. Remembering the cruel dismissal of a single mother in the hospital by the nursing staff, Ernaux notes ‘Girls who abort and unwed mothers from working-class Rouen were handed the same treatment. In fact, they probably despised her even more.’ We see how either choice ends in a justification for society to devalue anyone who gets pregnant. Most writers on the subject will also mention this only gets worse with each marginalized intersectional identity. ‘So, by all means, don’t have an abortion, if you’re personally opposed to them. But the state policing of pregnant bodies is a form of misogynistic control, one whose effects will be most deeply felt by the most vulnerable girls and women. And this, in my book, is simply indefensible.’ - Kate Manne, Entitled The worst is that, without safe options, Ernaux must enter into dangerous procedures. Her first attempt on her own lands her in the hospital where she is judged by doctors. The procedure she has done on her also ends up with her near death in the hospital, being in complete fear for her life and being shouted at by a doctor so much that ‘I believed he might actually let me die.’ Ernaux does not shirk from directly presenting the events, noting that rarely in fiction does an abortion actually get described. ‘It’s an indescribable scene, life and death in the same breath. A sacrificial scene,’ she says. To write so bluntly and openly, I believe, is Ernaux’s way of being true to herself but also an attempt to pick away at the stigma. She briefly compares those who illegally perform abortions in 1960’s France to those who smuggle refugees across borders in the present day. ‘No one questions the laws and world order that condone their existence,’ she says, but wonders if for both there is ‘a sense of honor.’ For the record, France legalized abortion in 1975. ‘In my student bathroom, I had given birth to both life and death.’ This is an intense read, but one that is courageously and beautifully written. I can’t stop thinking about the divide between those who showed cruelty and those who showed compassion to college-aged Ernaux during this time, and how much the aid of others meant so much to her 30 years later as she wrote the book. This is an excellent examination of memory along with the story, the way she finds what she remembers most shows that ‘true memory has to be material,’ and the way memory swaps in other’s faces on key people who we cannot remember much about. Ernaux continues to amaze me and I am awed at her handling of such a difficult subject in her own life while also allowing her story to shed light on society at large. Nobel committee, you sure picked a good one. 4.5/5 ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Nov 04, 2022
|
Nov 04, 2022
|
Nov 04, 2022
|
Paperback
| ||||||||||||||||||
1583228551
| 9781583228555
| 1583228551
| 3.75
| 6,613
| Sep 2002
| Dec 02, 2008
|
really liked it
|
‘To give a title to the moments of one’s life, the way one does at school for literary passages, is perhaps a way to master them?’ When I first encount ‘To give a title to the moments of one’s life, the way one does at school for literary passages, is perhaps a way to master them?’ When I first encountered Annie Ernaux I was impressed and eager for more, but after the raw intensity that is The Possession I would perch beside her throne and hiss like a cat at anyone who would so much look at her sideways. Ernaux has such a strong, defined voice and personality that it feels as if it's always leaping out from the pages as if her own perfectly chosen words can’t even contain it. What she does best is occupy the space of an emotion and brilliantly map it out like a landscape; here she deftly maneuvers through feelings of jealousy and obsession that have taken hold of her, possessed her every being. ‘I was being inhabited by a woman I had never seen,’ she writes of the ‘Other woman’ with whom her former lover has now decided to live with and over the course of this slim book we witness her project the Other woman into all the women around her as she obsesses with discovering her identity. Brimming with emotional intensity, yet restrained and almost clinical in her examinations of them, The Possession is a sharp book that will sear right into you as she opens the doors to interrogate herself at her most vulnerable and insecure, all while demonstrating the healing power of writing. ‘The strangest thing about jealousy is that it can populate an entire city - the whole world - with a person you may never have met.’ Ernaux’s The Possession manages to be a sweeping portrait restrained into a singular idea and series of events. Framed as being written years later, reflecting upon the past, it opens as her younger lover, with whom she had a lengthy affair, has moved in with another woman and sets the new terms of their friendship. She had been hesitant to commit after divorcing and now he has moved on, once again with a woman older than himself who he refuses to name. ‘This absent name was a hole, a void around which I turned in circles,’ she says as she becomes obsessed with thoughts of this woman and ways in which she could identify her. ‘It seemed to me that to put a name to this woman would allow me to construct, out of what is always awakened by a word and its sounds, a personality type: to hold an image of her—even if a completely false one—inside me. To know the name of the other woman was, in my own deficiency of being, to own a little part of her.’ There is a mutli-faceted idea of possession here, being possessed with wanting to track her down (as it’s own way of possessing her) and the jealousy of no longer being possessed by her lover as the Other woman now is. We see her mind spiraling, the ‘incessant de-coding’ of everything he says to her, her plans and actions of finding out more and obsessive internet rabbit-holes of information to put together an impression of her Other. ‘I discovered that these details by which society defines a person’s identity, which we so easily dismiss as irrelevant to truly knowing someone, are in fact essential,’ she writes, ‘they were the only way to…conjure up a body, a lifestyle; to construct the image of an individual person.’ Much like the way Ernaux examined all the external details of society to discover the shape of her shame in Shame , here Ernaux attempts to define the shape of the Other’s void with personal details. 'It was as if, in this neighborhood which I had filled with the other woman’s existence, there was no room left for my own.' While projecting the Other into every woman she encounters, she finds herself ‘an echo chamber for all pain everywhere,’ and ‘projected myself into all those who—crazier or more audacious than me—had in any way “blown a fuse.”’ A favorite moment is her sort of sick satisfaction in wonderinging--possibly hoping--her own behaviors will be some sort of cautionary tale men whisper in bars when discussing exes. There is a sense that she acknowledges the self-destructive urges that are slowly pulling her closer into action, but she finds a sense of power in them that she seems to find darkly delicious. She restrains herself, usually out of self preservation, but the book always feels teetering on the cliff of scandelous disaster. ‘Writing has been a way to save that which is no longer my reality—a sensation seizing me from head to foot, in the street—but has become “the possession,” a period of time, circumscribed and completed.’ Nothing satisfies and she becomes increasingly frustrated, thinking ‘But something more was needed, and I didn’t know where it would come from—from chance, from the outside, or from within myself.’ An aspect I loved is how she turns to writing as a sort of exorcism that removes the desires from the self and onto a page to share, be it a letter to her former lover or to us, the reader of this very book: ‘it is no longer my desire, my jealousy, in these pages—it is of desire, of jealousy; I am working in invisible things.’ While each page is a gem, it is when she discusses her own memoir mechanics that I was most enraptured by her brilliant mind: ‘I am writing jealousy as I lived it, tracking and accumulating the desires, sensations, and actions that were mine during this period. It’s the only way for me to make something real of my obsession. And I am always afraid to let something essential escape. Writing, that is, as a jealousy of the real.’ This is such an accurate look at what Ernaux seems to do with her autobiographical writing, reconstruction of the real in order to pass the emotional resonance directly into the reader while acknowledging that words are a flawed net with which we can attempt to define the shape of the reality that is forever eluding us as we are plunged forward by time. ‘The existence of this woman had become a reality, indestructible and atrocious. It was like a statue emerging from the mud.’ Short, easily read in a single sitting, but with a raw emotion that lands in blow after blow, The Possession is a real treat. Ernaux has such a gift of voice that makes these relatively plotless investigations of memory into gripping reads that engulf you. Needless to say, I will be reading many more. 4.5/5 ‘In the self-erasure that is the state of jealously, which transforms every difference into a lack , it was not only my body, my face, that were devaluated but also my occupation – my entire being.’ ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Oct 14, 2022
|
Oct 14, 2022
|
Oct 14, 2022
|
Paperback
| |||||||||||||||
4.45
| 1,257,449
| Aug 09, 2022
| Aug 09, 2022
|
really liked it
|
Chances are, if you have a TikTok or Instagram you know what this book is. I mean, I'm Glad My Mom Died was on back order already the morning it was p
Chances are, if you have a TikTok or Instagram you know what this book is. I mean, I'm Glad My Mom Died was on back order already the morning it was published and was a sought after title all August and is a book you just cannot avoid if you have an internet connection or local bookstore. Nor should you. Jennette McCurdy, the former iCarly actress, speaks so openly and candidly about a lifelong cycle of abuse and dependency with her mother (who passed in, as the title likely led you to assume), chronicling trauma and serious mental health struggles such as eating disorders that all were brought upon her through the need to serve her mother’s wishes. It’s one I’ve had right in everyone’s faces at the bookstore since we finally got copies, as the title is sure to solicit reactions and I privately enjoy seeing them, but also it is an important look at abuse and recovery. I had to finally read it. I mean we all deserve a Hot Girl Summer but can I truly say I had one if I didn’t read any Colleen Hoover, Beach Read or at least this, the most popular book of the end of summer? No. And I’m glad I did pick this up to read at work because this deserves all the hype and more, and I hope this is another success on McCurdy's road to improved mental health. While she loved her mother, their relationship was often abusive and left a lot to detangle in adulthood. Deeply personal and moving, this is a look into McCurdy's life as well as a necessary warning about the ways young girls are objectified, commodified and exploited, even by those closest to them. ‘I realize that she’s happy and I’m not. Her happiness came at the cost of mine. I feel robbed and exploited.’ That line says it all, honestly. This is an upsetting account of McCurdy's life, and one where all the warning signs were out in the open and ignored. Especially by Nickelodeon who don’t exactly come across well here. We’ve heard horror stories about the treatment of child actors for as long as there have been child actors, though this isn’t simply another case file of grievances but a really heartfelt self-examination and testimony. McCurdy comes across as very open and honest, and it really paints a positive look at her as a person who has gone through so much. There are times when she discusses the anger she felt, which feels justified and as Soraya Chemaly talks about in the book Rage Becomes Her: The Power of Women's Anger, sometimes anger is the appropriate response in order to not be silenced or ignored. It can be an important tool, or an armor as McCurdy describes: ‘I became an angry person with no tolerance for anyone. I'm aware of this shift and yet have no desire to change it. If anything, I want it. It's armor. It's easier to be angry than to feel to pain underneath it.’ She also expresses feelings of regret for having lashed out in these times, looking at how abuse shouldn’t just beget another cycle of abuse, and these discussions seem to come from a place of maturity and healing. It is likely very encouraging and empowering for victims of abuse to read much of this book, though heads up, it does get into some very triggering situations and topics. ‘Mom only sits in when I’m being the thing she wanted to be.’ McCurdy shows how so much of her life was lived to be what her mother wanted, and much of this became painful. She was raised in a Mormon household and was homeschooled by her mother, a mom who wanted to always present a perfect image and often lashed out hurtfully. In short, McCurdy is open about her mom having narcissistic tendencies, and while she is still caring for her mother (she does make it clear she very much loved her mother), the scars are quickly apparent. From years of life like this, McCurdy felt she lacked an authentic self, and this carried over into struggles with body image from seeing one’s own self as an object that serves others instead of something personally only yours. This is a major theme in the essays in My Body by Emily Ratajkowski for those looking for further reading on the subject. When fearing her breasts would grow during puberty, the mother encouraged extreme calorie reduction and dangerous dieting practices. While discussions of the mother bookend this memoir, the bulk of the middle portion is about eating disorders. Most tragic is the moment in the hospital with her siblings saying goodbye to her mother when she says the one thing she thinks could actually make her mother proud of her: ‘I'm in the ICU with my dying mother, and the thing that I'm sure will get her to wake up, is the fact that in the days since mom has been hospitalized, my fear and sadness have morphed into the perfect anorexia motivation cocktail, and finally I have achieved mom's current goal weight for me: 89 pounds.’ There is a lot to be said about the ways this reflects a general attitude around young women and girls, especially in the entertainment industry and how it robs them of their own agency. ‘I was conditioned to believe any boundary I wanted was a betrayal of her, so I stayed silent,’ she writes, and in this we see how these systems perpetuate themselves: silence. Young women and girls are broken down to believe they are in service to another (we could get into a long discussion on how this is the social framing inflicted by the intersections of misogyny and capitalism) and silence is induced by making them first feel they wouldn’t be believed or listened to but also that they deserve it, it’s for their own good or that they don’t even have the agency to speak out. It is truly tragic how often victims of abuse are silenced when they do speak out, which is another tool in oppression. So this book is a lot, but it is also very good and seems very healing. I was under the impression based on how it was presented and marketed that this was more of a comedic memoir, so heads up if that was what you assumed as well, but the weight and power of her words as she discusses a lifetime of abuse is definitely worth reading for. It does read very plainly, almost like a “class assignment” type of tone recounting events, though they are certainly difficult memories to have to revisit. I hope McCurdy is doing well, and it is very honorable of her to use her experience to reach out and help others in this way. There could have been more depth to some of it, but this is less a look at the causes and social critiques and more at the personal effects she endured. There are great reminders too about how to move forward and not get bogged down in being perfect, such as when she writes that ‘slips are totally normal. When you have a slip, it’s just that. A slip. It doesn’t define you. It doesn’t make you a failure. The most important thing is that you don’t let that slip become a slide‘. I won’t get too much more into it, as you should probably read the book and this is McCurdy's story to tell, but I am very glad I read this. 'My mom didn't get better. But I will.' ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
Sep 27, 2022
|
Sep 27, 2022
|
Sep 27, 2022
|
ebook
| ||||||||||||||||||
1481486667
| 9781481486668
| 1481486667
| 3.62
| 1,252
| Oct 05, 2021
| Nov 02, 2021
|
liked it
|
When our best laid plans go awry, the future can seem a bleak horizon as we struggle to recollect our lives. Tiny Dancer, a bittersweet graphic memoir
When our best laid plans go awry, the future can seem a bleak horizon as we struggle to recollect our lives. Tiny Dancer, a bittersweet graphic memoir from Siena Cherson Siegel and illustrator Mark Siegel explore Siena’s derailed trajectory as a dancer and her journey to find herself again and continue dance. This reads much like an expanded and reworked version of To Dance: A Ballerina's Graphic Novel and the moving story coupled with gorgeous artwork bring the struggles of a ballerina straight into your heart. [image] I have a real fascination with ballet. Have you read Apollo's Angels: A History of Ballet by Jennifer Homans because that is such an amazing book and I find dance to be such an incredible art form. It is poetry of the body and motion as art and narrative built on such precision and skill that is just astonishing. Full disclosure, I cannot dance, like even a little (but I sure will), but the body as a medium is something that will always enchant me. Also, going forward into the review, you should probably cue up the song Tiny Dancer (this version because you already know the original and in this house we jam to Florence + the Machine) for obvious reasons, and because the song is referenced multiple times in the book. The book follows Siena’s life, moving from Puerto Rico to New York City to attend the School of American Ballet. Her life revolves around her dancing, which she excels at, while her parent’s divorce looms in the background. We witness her dreams and joys surrounding dance, while also getting wonderful commentary on famous ballets and stars of the scene during that time period. When an injury derails her progress, and her confidence, she spirals into directionlessness while wondering what to do next as she watches everyone else continue their dreams from the sidelines. Beyond examinations on what life is like in a dance studio and the competitive lifestyle on a path to working in a dance company, Siegel shows how the competitiveness can flow into friendships such as the friend who seems to copy everything she does as if to steal her personality, friends, and overall life. While the story can feel a bit overly long at times, the emotional resonance carries it through. This is likely to be a very relatable book for young readers, with or without an interest in dance, and it is encouraging to see a story where someone is able to reform a life and push forward even without a clear direction. The use of the ‘ghost’ in the story—the ghost of her childhood dreams that follows her in devastation to see her wide-eyed hope for a future in dance may have come undone—is a rather heartbreaking aspect of the book. I quite enjoyed it and the intent, but it also felt underutilized, oddly enough because it appeared too often to be a small nuance to the story but not enough integration or purpose to justify having appeared that often. Either way, it still was a nice touch and the dreamlike sequences work well to build an emotive undercurrent to the story. This is aided by the art, which is quite lovely and all done in purple tones. [image] Overall this is a nice graphic memoir that has some great messages within it. It is fairly melancholy but certainly tugs the heartstrings in a meaningful way and I feel teens would find a lot of inspiration within these pages. 3.5/5 [image] ...more |
Notes are private!
|
1
|
not set
|
not set
|
Apr 29, 2022
|
Hardcover
|
s.penkevich
>
Books:
memoir
(29)
|
|
|
|
|
my rating |
|
|
||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
3.98
|
really liked it
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
Feb 18, 2025
|
||||||
4.39
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
May 13, 2024
|
||||||
3.96
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
May 01, 2024
|
||||||
3.75
|
liked it
|
not set
|
Apr 25, 2024
|
||||||
4.43
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Mar 19, 2024
|
||||||
3.59
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Mar 08, 2024
|
||||||
3.69
|
really liked it
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
Feb 28, 2024
|
||||||
4.22
|
liked it
|
not set
|
Dec 13, 2023
|
||||||
3.84
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Nov 09, 2023
|
||||||
3.59
|
liked it
|
Sep 08, 2023
|
Sep 08, 2023
|
||||||
4.11
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Aug 30, 2023
|
||||||
4.35
|
it was amazing
|
not set
|
Aug 29, 2023
|
||||||
4.40
|
it was amazing
|
Aug 16, 2023
|
Aug 16, 2023
|
||||||
4.30
|
really liked it
|
not set
|
Aug 02, 2023
|
||||||
4.18
|
really liked it
|
Jun 25, 2023
|
Jun 25, 2023
|
||||||
4.19
|
it was amazing
|
Nov 17, 2022
|
Nov 17, 2022
|
||||||
4.31
|
really liked it
|
Nov 04, 2022
|
Nov 04, 2022
|
||||||
3.75
|
really liked it
|
Oct 14, 2022
|
Oct 14, 2022
|
||||||
4.45
|
really liked it
|
Sep 27, 2022
|
Sep 27, 2022
|
||||||
3.62
|
liked it
|
not set
|
Apr 29, 2022
|