Paul Bryant's Reviews > Oliver Twist
Oliver Twist
by
by
Oliver Twist THE BOOK is crap and has NO songs in it, I couldn't believe it. So I googled and get this, it turns out they put those in the movie and Dickens had nothing to do with it! But since they were the best bit of the film, you can understand my horror and bereft sense of disappointment when I finally came to pick up the book.
How could Dickens NOT have thought of having little Oliver sing Where Is Love when chucked into the cellar or Who Will Buy This Loverly Morning when he wakes up in his posh house...I mean yeah he was supposed to be good wasn't he? And please note the edition I read was not a Readers Digest Condensed Edition. When you DON'T have Fagin capering about warbling "In this life one thing counts/ In the bank, large amounts/I'm afraid these don't grow on trees/You got to pick a pocket or two" with that pederastic twinkle in his eyes as he surveys his small boys then alas I'm sorry to say that what you're left with is a bit of an antisemitic caricature lashed to a morality tale whose immoral moral appears to be that rich is good, poor is bad, and you better get yourself a deus ex machina in the form of a very unlikely sugardaddy to magic you out of the poorhouse or the rats will eat your bollocks, your bones will turn to dust and be blown away and no one will ever hire cute kids to pretend to be you on stage or screen and melt our hearts and win Oscars and Tonys. Which I think we all knew.
How could Dickens NOT have thought of having little Oliver sing Where Is Love when chucked into the cellar or Who Will Buy This Loverly Morning when he wakes up in his posh house...I mean yeah he was supposed to be good wasn't he? And please note the edition I read was not a Readers Digest Condensed Edition. When you DON'T have Fagin capering about warbling "In this life one thing counts/ In the bank, large amounts/I'm afraid these don't grow on trees/You got to pick a pocket or two" with that pederastic twinkle in his eyes as he surveys his small boys then alas I'm sorry to say that what you're left with is a bit of an antisemitic caricature lashed to a morality tale whose immoral moral appears to be that rich is good, poor is bad, and you better get yourself a deus ex machina in the form of a very unlikely sugardaddy to magic you out of the poorhouse or the rats will eat your bollocks, your bones will turn to dust and be blown away and no one will ever hire cute kids to pretend to be you on stage or screen and melt our hearts and win Oscars and Tonys. Which I think we all knew.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Oliver Twist.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 251-300 of 347 (347 new)
message 251:
by
Dave
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Feb 20, 2019 04:49AM
More straightforward education for you, Paul. Will you never listen?
reply
|
flag
I would say the,well in the film I like the song um papa and Consider yourself. But I defintely like the movie.
this comment make me so angry that some ignorant person is complaining that there are no songs, IN A CLASSIC BOOK!!!!!!
Jojo wrote: "this comment make me so angry that some ignorant person is complaining that there are no songs, IN A CLASSIC BOOK!!!!!!"
He is joking, though you have missed that.
He is joking, though you have missed that.
You are aware since it was a musical adaptation of Oliver Twist, if it wasn't for that crap book you'd never have your masterpiece movie. Can honestly not believe you're calling the book crap for not having songs?
13 year after he wrote, it this review still provokes (totally bonkers) comments, must be some kind of a record.
P.S. I still find the review hilarious
P.S. I still find the review hilarious
I HATE it when I can't hear songs from a book. Charles Dickens should be ASHAMED of himself. You have enlightened me, good sir. /s
Nothing good happens. It is very sad. I found you are buying the book remember that you are wasting your time and money .
Ollie wrote: "It's all kicking off."
Well, it will be a bloody relief from sodding Trump v sodding Biden.
Well, it will be a bloody relief from sodding Trump v sodding Biden.
Cecily, don't forget Of Mice and Men! I am keeping a log of how many helpful people tell me it's quotation from a famous poem.
Periodically I return to this review to be able to laugh aloud, thanks, Paul. But as much for the comments from (humans) calling you an idiot and trying to teach you about the difference between a novel and a movie.
Objection. While the rest of your review is opinion and you are totally entitled to it, I would point out that, in Nancy, good triumphs and her actions do a lot of good. So it's not "rich is good, poor is bad".
Bella McDermott wrote: "Of course there aren't any songs in the book. Have you every read a book with songs? And I cannot understand your horror and bereft sense of disappointment as you should have been expecting songs a..."
You do realise his tongue if firmly in his cheek. He's not being serious at all. It's a joke.
You do realise his tongue if firmly in his cheek. He's not being serious at all. It's a joke.
Of course there are no songs in the book. The book came first. And I cannot understand your horror and disappointment as it is a great book and anyone with sense wouldn't have been expecting songs.
well, i see now that i was wrong to expect songs in the book, but i still think it should clearly say so on the cover. It is very misleading not to say.
I would caution you not to read Les Miserables.
Its almost like Hugo was ignorant of the musical - though he might have just been upset that he didn't get a credit from The Stranglers for Toiler on the Sea
Its almost like Hugo was ignorant of the musical - though he might have just been upset that he didn't get a credit from The Stranglers for Toiler on the Sea
Paul wrote: "i can't think he didn't know, that musical is so famous, it's on th side of buses and everything"
If it was on the side of a bus he probably ignored it - it is usually a sign that someone is telling porkies
If it was on the side of a bus he probably ignored it - it is usually a sign that someone is telling porkies
If you ask me, Shakespeare’s rip-off of The Lion King was the worst. Not a single chord from ‘The Circle of Life’ graces those pages. Thoroughly disappointed. In fact, I’m sure it counts as whitewashing, changing Simba from African to Danish...
Bravo, this review and thread has amused me no end this morning. May the comments keep coming!
Bravo, this review and thread has amused me no end this morning. May the comments keep coming!
I actually am reading the book and am really loving it. But I agree with you on the movie. Jack Wild as the Artful Dodger was pure comedic genius
Ouch! I am going to go back and read it. I did not think it was that bad when I read it before. Dickens wrote for the masses and his observations are still valid today. We treat the poor so badly, money means you have a dwelling to live in-sleep in - get away from the cold. Health, class, money, the horrible court system - you name it, he nailed it and we still have a horrible court system. After I re-read it with a clear head, I will take you on. Save your notes. His stuff has lasted loner than Donald Trump will and people still praise him. Have entire college courses about him. Did you ever read - Our Mutual Friend? Many Dickens scholars consider it his best. I am not a Dickens scholar, I am a scholar of business/organizational systems. And Dickens never included a real song. Maybe a line or two here or there from a character in the book. My copy of your review does not have a date. Perhaps you wrote it before you finished grade school? Paul, I usually love your reviews but you missed it this time. peace, janz