Lee Klein 's Reviews > The Morning Star

The Morning Star by Karl Ove Knausgård
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
90786
's review

it was amazing

Theological thriller, philosophical pulp, an extraordinarily well-characterized, dramatized elaboration of the internal/external worlds thematic focus of The Seasons Quartet, perfect for the longer nights and dark mornings of autumn, as neighbors decorate yards with plastic representations of skeletons and ghouls. Through the first two-hundred pages I wasn't sure about it, doubted its page count (666), thought it contrived and manipulated with prevalent one-sentence paragraphs like in a Blake Crouch novel. But then it started to take off, thanks in part to cliffhangers at the end of each section either for the new star or minor natural and some major supernatural oddities that began to proliferate, yet never in such a way as to overwhelm the emphasis on character and interiority -- and I was in it to win it and very much recommend it, not just to Knausgaard fans.

Structured as a series of first-person stories, each titled by the narrator's first name, many of which repeat, two of which (Arne, Egil) resemble Knausgaard, but also a few are women, a middle-aged priest of Norway, a young convenience-store clerk, a night shift worker at a mental hospital married to Jostein, a hideous man-type journalist whose idfulness and general hatefulness charge the pages through the middle and end like booster rockets whenever he appears. There are also two sections -- one about a young rocker named Emil and the other about a 33-year-old curator mother married to a 60-year-old famous architect -- that don't repeat and seem almost like teases for future installments of what seems like it will definitely continue as a series.

Knausgaard proved himself a master of suspense during the rising waters in the Noah section in A Time for Everything, and here it's really the same dynamic on a book-length level. Rising drama threatening everything we take for granted, all the little movements of the day, the common conversations and perceptions we barely register, especially all the time we spend trying to connect with loved ones but also find some time alone. In this there's a bit about a car accident and how the seriously injured family members will never sit around the kitchen again in the same way as they ready themselves for school -- extended over the course of the novel is the same dynamic, which infects the reader (me at least) with a sense of gratitude and amplifies perception of the everyday surrounding world, including thoughts and feelings and dreams, ie, the internal world. But also this achieved simple straightforward spookiness. Yes, I was spooked one night as I put down the book and turned off the light, listening to insects, animals (owls, foxes, our cat), and distant thunder.

Only criticism is the Emil section where he talks about a band called Ohia (presumably it's Songs:Ohia), but I did love when Emil talks about the warmth and effortless licks in David Crosby's "If I Could Only Remember My Name" (cool to see a suggested Garcia reference in a Knausgaard novel). Also liked that it ends with an essay, a la War & Peace, although the similarities end there.

I'll write more later but for now let's just say that I had hopes for this and looked forward to its arrival, thought it maybe a little hokey and underdone through the first two-hundred pages, but then couldn't put it down until the end, reading 100+ pages a day. For a book in part about belief, let's just say I remain a believer in this author -- I'm actually low-key astounded by his ability to meld "high" and "low" literature in a convincing, moving, intellectually satisfying or at least intriguing fashion, all while evoking the world around Bergen, Norway, as well as believably describing worlds of the mind, imagination, and the beyond.

Also, not that any of this matters but this is printed on the softest, silkiest, thin-yet-not-translucent paper, which I noticed immediately when opening the book and again when opening the new Franzen book that arrived as I neared the end -- the paper in the Franzen book seems like it's much lower quality and the book itself is thicker than the Knausgaard book despite having 130 fewer pages. I should also mention that I did achieve a minor silly goal of finishing The Morning Star the day Crossroads arrived -- middle-aged white male reader loser that I am, I want to read these two big fall novels back to back and see if there's anything of interest there in the overlap.
126 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Morning Star.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 3, 2021 – Shelved
September 28, 2021 – Started Reading
October 5, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Paul H. just found out about this, is it good so far?


message 2: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein Twenty pages in, I'd say very good so far. Single lingering impression is that it's printed on the softest, silkiest paper.


Paul H. Glad to hear that things pick up, I'm 50 pages in and so far it feels like a lightly fictionalized version of Spring -- quite good, but not transcendently amazing yet


message 4: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein There’s some overlap at first, yes, particularly with Tove.


message 5: by Heather (new) - added it

Heather Barkley Great review! Am enjoying the beginning!


message 6: by Cody (new)

Cody You and that fucking paper. Are you the survivor of dangerous, thick paper attacks? I got this on deck—wanna be able to give proper attention—but I’m gonna laugh every time I turn a page, thinking: silky-smooth. High thread count. Haha.


message 7: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein The more I think about the paper the more I'm sure the publishers wanted to avoid anyone thinking this was "pulp" and so avoided the grayish rough paper often in crappier novels. But also for a novel with 666+ pages, they chose thin paper that slims the spine to something more befitting a novel of 350 or 400 pages, thereby not losing readers put off by long novels. Or that's what I imagine is behind the all-important paper choice.


message 8: by Marcie (new)

Marcie Thanks for the review. It looks great read the first 16 pages and it has drawn me in. Agree with you the quality of the paper used is unusual but very much appreciated.


Eric Same paper inside my hardcover savage detectives (FSG), I’m pretty sure. Enjoyed reading your preliminary thoughts, Lee, just as I’m about to launch into the concluding essay.


message 10: by Adam (new) - rated it 4 stars

Adam Great review! I've been slowly making my way through My Struggle and using your reviews as a guide of sorts as I go, so I was super happy to see you already had a take on this one.

I'm in the final third and I agree that it's uncanny how spooky it can be. I finished the first Egil section just before bed last night and there's something about the way the kid is acting out (distressing, but still stuff that happens in a life) juxtaposed with the more fantastical imagery happening just at the margins that's genuinely unsettling.

I had the same thought about the Ohia thing - I assume it was an error, perhaps the editor being confused by the name. Not sure if you've seen this, but the official website has extensive playlists for each character: https://themorningstar.no/


message 11: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein Whoa -- thank you! I definitely hadn't seen that and will check out these playlists
https://open.spotify.com/user/pddxhpc...


message 12: by Jane (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jane Vandenburgh I read these two back to back also. I’m a huge fan of KOK, not so much Jonathan Franzen. I’ve actually been off Franzen since the day I finished The Corrections: September 10, 2001. His books frankly evaporate and never call me back for a rereading.

However the writing in the section in which Perry totally decompensates as he’s walking into the frozen world he will set on fire is the best writing I’ve read in a really long time.

Per The Morning Star, I kept seeing KOK self portraits, not only in the lit/writer types but the musician and even the unsavory selfish arts/journ Jostein who shared a feeling with Arne that he is “being watched.”

Of course, I thought, you’re being psychologically occupied by your story’s author who sits like John Barthe did on the train in The French Lieutenant’s Woman, appraising his character, thinking, What am I to do with you now?


message 13: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein Thanks for the comment, Jane -- I think with Knausgaard it's difficult to separate him from the characters, in part because unlike with most authors we've read 4K+ pages of his autobiographical writing, which in part is why at the end of My Struggle I thought when he said he was no longer a writer he meant that he'd revealed all his source material and so in a way no longer had stuff from which to create fiction -- thankfully he realized he could just nudge his way into the supernatural netherworld.

But more importantly, what did you think of the difference in paper quality?!


Christoffer Ladstein Today News arrived this series Will end in at least 5 books! Imagine all those compressed into one tome with biblical paper quality?😉
Anyway, more to come =exciting times for KOK fans!


message 15: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein Whoa -- that's good news. A trilogy seemed lazy for him after series of four and six!


message 16: by Caterina (new) - added it

Caterina Oh no! Lee loved it, so it’s probably great & I’m never going to be able to keep up with old Karl Ove’a output. Ha!


message 17: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein You can do it!


Leslie Disagree on loser remark. Thanks for winning review.


message 19: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein Thank you Leslie — apologies for ending there on a note of obligatory Gen X self-deprecation


message 20: by Andi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Andi Nice review! I read Crossroads first and I loved Morning Star so much more! I'm a Franzen fangirl but I couldn't put The Morning Star down!


message 21: by João (new) - added it

João Reis I'm translating this book into Portuguese. I've never been a fan of KOK, and had only translated Min Kamp #1, but I find Morgenstjernen even worse. Awful, TBH. :D


message 22: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein oh no, your rarefied sensibility offended! I loved it, once it started to take off (same as My Struggle). Maybe wait to read it until October, somewhere where the brujos run and play. Very much looking forward to the second volume, something about the wolves of eternity.


message 23: by Penguin (new)

Penguin Press Hi Lee! I'd love to send you Karl Ove Knausgaard's next novel, The Wolves of Eternity, which we're publishing in September. Feel free to message us or email me at jestratton@penguinrandomhouse.com if you're interested!


switterbug (Betsey) Beautiful review, Lee. It's on my shelf and I do intend to get to it.


message 25: by Melanie (new) - added it

Melanie I’m 289 pages in and already positively spooked… Should I soldier on?! I’m not good with horror for horror’s sake…


message 26: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein Melanie wrote: "I’m 289 pages in and already positively spooked… Should I soldier on?! I’m not good with horror for horror’s sake…"

Proceed, for sure. It's not senseless horror. Some eerie images and scenes but nothing gratuitously graphic from what I remember.


message 27: by Roy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Roy Great review! I didn’t even think about the Jerry Garcia reference. Nice job making that connection, and fun to see as a Head myself.


message 28: by Lee (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lee Klein hey now, kind veggie brother! once in a while you [see Jerry references] in the strangest of places if you look at it right.


back to top