Luffy Sempai's Reviews > A Good Yarn
A Good Yarn (Blossom Street, #2)
by
by
A Good Yarn is a tired and cliched book about feelings. The fact that many people want their characters to do well in poorly written books indicates that a mint can be made on anything that reassures rather than reveals. Debbie Macomber provides easy answers rather than answering the difficult questions her characters ask throughout the book.
People who cannot survive the genre transfusion that occurs often when middle aged readers dive into YA literature, turn to books like this. Comforting, familiar, repetitive, and ultimately redundant, A Good Yarn is a lazy attempt at writing. The characters here seem to impress upon readers that they will have a HEA. Regardless of the life they are leading.
The type of glandular love that passes for something more divine shows how sanitised and embracing the Romance genre has become. Romance is the only genre whose young writers, fresh out of the workshop of Creative Writing class, never innovate. It's easy money for those who are very visible or have a long career at this type of shilling. I myself have recently been wanting a book about Christmas and love. Oy Vey.
People who cannot survive the genre transfusion that occurs often when middle aged readers dive into YA literature, turn to books like this. Comforting, familiar, repetitive, and ultimately redundant, A Good Yarn is a lazy attempt at writing. The characters here seem to impress upon readers that they will have a HEA. Regardless of the life they are leading.
The type of glandular love that passes for something more divine shows how sanitised and embracing the Romance genre has become. Romance is the only genre whose young writers, fresh out of the workshop of Creative Writing class, never innovate. It's easy money for those who are very visible or have a long career at this type of shilling. I myself have recently been wanting a book about Christmas and love. Oy Vey.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
A Good Yarn.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 24, 2021
–
Started Reading
November 24, 2021
– Shelved
November 24, 2021
– Shelved as:
anti-feminist
November 24, 2021
– Shelved as:
cash-grab
November 24, 2021
– Shelved as:
romance
November 24, 2021
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
DeB
(new)
Nov 26, 2021 08:31AM
A bit unravelled, by your accounts! I’ve never been much of a Macomber fan, but we each seem to have our version of bland escapism. This obviously wasn’t yours- hope the next book is much better, Luffy!
reply
|
flag
Lol, DeB, I must take stock of what counts for bland escapism currently for me. All the previous candidates, e.g. cozies, Blyton books, historical mysteries, have fallen by the wayside.
I too hope that both of our following reads are 5 stars.
I too hope that both of our following reads are 5 stars.
Veronica ⭐️ wrote: "I do love a bit of romantic escapism. Cliched or not :)"
Glad you weren't irked by my review. Thanks for the like and the comment.
Glad you weren't irked by my review. Thanks for the like and the comment.
Debbie Macomber isn't great lit but is kinda like an optimistic old friend that I like to mix in with not so cozy thrillers, non fiction and even some genuine literature. I suppose. Debbie M. found her niche & is sticking with it and doing quite well. A bit of fairytale escape can be like chicken soup to me. Hope you have your own comfort reads you can count on when you need a book-hug. 😆
Mary wrote: "Debbie Macomber isn't great lit but is kinda like an optimistic old friend that I like to mix in with not so cozy thrillers, non fiction and even some genuine literature. I suppose. Debbie M. found..."
Thank you for the kind words and the like. Anyone can write a bad book despite years of experience. Wish you happy reading!
Thank you for the kind words and the like. Anyone can write a bad book despite years of experience. Wish you happy reading!