Left Coast Justin's Reviews > The Shadow of the Sun

The Shadow of the Sun by Ryszard Kapuściński
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
28604716
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: essays, travel-africa-middle-east

Mr. Kapuscinski was a reporter, and for a couple of decades was assigned to cover all the news coming from Africa. Except, as he's the first to point out, there's really no such thing as 'Africa' -- the experience of a Rwandan coffee farmer, a fisherman in Mozambique and a Tuareg cattle herder are so distinct that to lump them all together is meaningless.

He shows great skill in picking out specific vignettes to illustrate larger truths. In an essay about Idi Amin, the horrible, greedy, bloodthirsty and allegedly cannibalistic leader of Uganda back in the 1980's:
One day I was wandering in the market in Kampala...Suddenly, a band of children came up the street that led up from the lake, calling, Samaki! Samaki ('fish' in Swahili). People gathered, joyful at the prospect that there would be something to eat. The fisherman threw their catch onto the table, and when the onlookers saw it, they grew still and silent. The fish was fat, enormous. These waters never used to yield such monstrously proportioned, overfed specimens. Everybody knew that for a long time now Amin's henchmen had been dumping the bodies of their victims into the lake, and that crocodiles and meat-eating fish must have been feasting on them. The crowd remained silent. Then, a military vehicle happened by. The soldiers saw the gathering, as well as the fish on the table, and stopped. Those of us standing nearby could see the corpse of a man lying on the truck bed. We saw the soldiers heave the fish on to the truck, throw the dead, barefoot man onto the table for us, and quickly drive away. And we heard their coarse, lunatic laughter.
It's really hard to imagine a society sunk so low, but for millions of people over twenty years, this was their reality.

But, but: Although he was a reporter, and his job was to feed back these sorts of horrific stories about coups and revolutions and despots, he found plenty to admire as well. He was not forced to remain there; he enjoyed living there, and moreover made a point of living the same way as the local populace, renting normal apartments rather than staying at the local Sofitel.
The market in Onitsha is where all the roads and paths of mercantile Africa converge. I was fascinated by Onitsha because it is the only market I know of that has spawned its own literature, the Onitsha Market Literature. Dozens of Nigerian writers live and work in Onitsha and are published by as many publishing houses, which have their own printing presses and bookshops in the marketplace. It is a diverse literature--romances, poems, and plays (the latter staged by the numerous little theatrical companies in the market), folk comedies, farces and vaudevilles. There are many didactic tales, countless self-help pamphlets, such as "How to Fall in Love?" or "How to Fall Out of Love?" Many little novellas like "Mabel, or Sweet Honey that has Poured Away," or "Love Games, and Then Disenchantment." Everything is meant to move you, to make you weep, and also to offer instruction and disinterested advice. Literature must be useful, believe the authors from Onitsha, and in the market they find a huge audience thirsty for wisdom and vicarious experience. Whoever cannot afford the brochure masterpiece (or simply doesn't know how to read) can listen to its message for a penny--the admission fee to authors' readings, which take place often here in the shade of stalls piled high with oranges, yams or onions.

Kapuscinski is no fool, and makes no claims to be 'describing Africa,' an impossible task. He does a very good job of describing the misery of being trapped in heat so brutal that people simply find a patch of shade and stop moving, sometimes for hours; a good job of describing the beauty of the Rwandan landscape and the way people, faced with challenges that we in the Western world can scarcely imagine, find ways to cope. Sometimes he tries to lift his matter-of-fact prose into something loftier, which tends not to work very well.

I enjoyed it, but feel only marginally less ignorant than before.
37 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Shadow of the Sun.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 3, 2023 – Started Reading
September 3, 2023 – Shelved
September 6, 2023 –
page 205
63.08%
September 9, 2023 – Shelved as: essays
September 9, 2023 – Shelved as: travel-africa-middle-east
September 9, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Mwanamali (new)

Mwanamali I think you mean Tuareg. Also fish in Swahili is samaki.


Left Coast Justin mwana wrote: "I think you mean Tuareg. Also fish in Swahili is samaki."

Corrected! Thanks


message 3: by Mwanamali (new)

Mwanamali Left Coast Justin wrote: "mwana wrote: "I think you mean Tuareg. Also fish in Swahili is samaki."

Corrected! Thanks"


Karibu. 😊


message 4: by Candi (last edited Sep 09, 2023 08:26PM) (new) - added it

Candi This sounds pretty interesting. Do you think I would enjoy it, Justin? I’d aim for becoming at least marginally less ignorant myself. Baby steps 😁. Great review!


message 5: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala You've given us just enough to make us want to read this ourselves, Justin—and I needed that little bit off motivation because I've had this book for years but it always seems to sink to the bottom of whatever less urgent pile it's been exiled to.


message 6: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton Great review Justin, you're right about 'there's no such thing as Africa'. What a diverse place it must be. The story about the fish during Idi Amin's period sounds horrible. I loved your closing lines too - great write up mate!


Left Coast Justin Mwana, ni ajabu kiasi gani, kwamba bila kujali ni lugha gani inayonukuliwa, kwamba ninaweza kupata mtu hapa katika GR ambaye ni mzungumzaji asilia na anaweza kufanya ukaguzi wangu kuwa bora zaidi.


Left Coast Justin Candi, I felt that Kapuscinski realized his experience over twenty or thirty years provided him with experiences that people who'd never been to any part of Africa would like to learn about. The quotes show that he can put good sentences together.

Where it's perhaps a bit weaker is just the nature of his job there. Thubron would go to a place simply because he wanted to go there, and he'd find people and speak with them and build up a portrait of people's lives. Kapuscinski went where he was sent, to learn about a specific incident, and the conversations he had with people were mostly in service to his reporting job.

Final verdict is that you don't need to read this all at once -- it's a collection of unrelated essays -- so you can keep it on your nightstand to dip into when the mood strikes.


Left Coast Justin ...and Fionnuala, I guess the same applies to you! The 'less urgent' pile is where it probably belongs, but you might want to have it accessible when you have enough time to read one essay but not sink into an entire book.


message 10: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "Candi, I felt that Kapuscinski realized his experience over twenty or thirty years provided him with experiences that people who'd never been to any part of Africa would like to learn about. The qu..."

I appreciate the advice, Justin! I'm adding it for when I need something sitting there on the nightstand again :)


message 11: by Monica (new)

Monica Really great review, LCJ!!


Left Coast Justin Thank you Monica! Kapuscinscki is actually very adept at sensory descriptions of what he felt, heard, smelled and tasted during his time there -- he really puts the reader in the middle of the scene.


message 13: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Left Coast Justin wrote: "Thank you Monica! Kapuscinscki is actually very adept at sensory descriptions of what he felt, heard, smelled and tasted during his time there -- he really puts the reader in the middle of the scene."

This sentence belongs in your review too! This was the final push for me to add. 😀


Left Coast Justin I think I'll end up reading more by him. He was mentioned in terms of the Nobel Prize, which I think is generous, but he does write well about topics that, at least in his time, were largely unaddressed in the West.


message 15: by carol. (new)

carol. Fascinating. Impossible to be comprehensive, to be certain, but the parts you quote are so evocative!


Left Coast Justin Mark, somehow I missed your comment -- sorry about that. My son spent a couple of months in South Africa and really enjoyed it, and dreams of returning. Maybe he'll invite me to join him on one of his trips :D


Left Coast Justin Carol, I love to write reviews where 90% of the writing was done by the author rather than me.


message 18: by carol. (new)

carol. they're also surprisingly helpful.


message 19: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer nyc What a fascinating review, Justin, wow! That story about the huge fish will stay with me. I’m not completely surprised by what you say about the value of literature in Nigeria—in my own journey through African lit, Nigerian feels easiest to find. Cool about there being a market and special location


Left Coast Justin I learned a whole lot while reading this, Jen, mostly because my baseline going into it was so low. It would be a lot of fun to visit that market!


message 21: by Pedro (new)

Pedro Sometimes I think. Sometimes I don't.

But the story about the fish is quite unforgettable.

Great review, Justin.


Left Coast Justin Yes, Pedro, whether you want to forget it or not! Thanks for dropping by


message 23: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer nyc Left Coast Justin wrote: "I learned a whole lot while reading this, Jen, mostly because my baseline going into it was so low. It would be a lot of fun to visit that market!"

'T'would!


back to top