Rosh ~catching up slowly~'s Reviews > Undercover

Undercover by Tamsyn Muir
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
91622714
In a Nutshell: A twisty fantasy-horror short story. Plenty of surprises and also shocks. Too gross for my taste! But might work better for the right reader.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Story Synopsis:
Starr, a newcomer to town, is appointed by a dangerous crime boss to be a bodyguard to her ghoul. The ghoul however turns out to be atypical for her kind, having awareness and control of her surroundings.
I really can’t tell you more. The twists begin very early and it’s better you experience it for yourself.
The story comes to us mostly from the limited third person perspective of Starr.


This short story is a part of ‘Into Shadow’, described by Amazon as ‘an enthralling collection of dark fantasy stories about the lure of forbidden knowledge.’


Y’all! What did I get myself into with this work? 🤢

When I was checking out the ‘Into Shadow’ collection on Prime, I saw that three of the stories had good ratings on Goodreads, and decided to stick only with those. Plus, I have heard much about this author and I found the premise of this tale interesting - what blurb that mentions both ‘burlesque dancer’ and ‘bodyguard to a ghoul’ can be ignored!?

Should have been a memorable work then, right?

Well, it was. But in many of the wrong ways! 👀 I should have taken the word ‘ghoul’ more literally instead of assuming that the blurb writer was being dramatic. What we have in this story is a ghoul. A flesh-eating ghoul. A human-flesh-eating ghoul. Who also eats lizards! Aargh, my poor queasy stomach! 🤢 It’s going to take me a long time to forget the image of a lizard being… let me not describe it else I’ll start grossing myself out once again! It sucks being a visual reader at such times.

As a short story, the plot is pretty appealing. The characters range from underworld gang lord (gang lady, actually) to bodyguards of zombies to… ahem… burlesque ghouls. There is a great lesbian rep in the tale, which is as dark as this author’s works are reputed to be. The relationships are all as twisty as an Indian jalebi.

The title seems innocuous enough, until you realise just how well it suits the story. Quite a few characters are ‘undercover’ in this work, thereby adding a complicated layer to the already tricky plot. It also matches the theme of the ‘Into Shadow’ series well.

I never would have expected a little 59-page story to spring so many surprises. Though it takes a while to figure out the proceedings due to the many characters and the changing narrative point of view, the story is fascinating once you get a handle on things. However, the second half seems to have some big jumps in the plot flow. So much so that I am not even sure I understood the story entirely because I am left with plenty of questions.

I think this was too ambitious for a short work. It has tremendous potential to work at least as a novella, if not a novel. The concept, the characters, and the writing all would have worked better if they had more page space. Of course, I must also admit that were it actually a novel, I would have never read it. Me no do zombie novels. 👀

All in all, excellent imagination, great storyline, good writing, few plot gaps. Might work very well for those built with a strong stomach. The rest of you, go ‘undercover‘ and hide from this little story of horrors!

Hitting the midway mark because I know this just wasn’t my cup of tea but it had its impactful moments.

3 stars.


This standalone work is the fifth story in the ‘Into Shadow’ collection, and is currently available free to Amazon Prime subscribers.





~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Connect with me through:
My Blog | The StoryGraph | Instagram | Facebook | Twitter
68 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Undercover.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 5, 2023 – Started Reading
December 5, 2023 – Shelved
December 8, 2023 – Shelved as: good-book-but-not-my-type
December 8, 2023 – Shelved as: short-story-or-essay
December 8, 2023 – Shelved as: 3-stars
December 8, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

theliterateleprechaun I had a few literary disappointments recently, too. I'm looking forward to getting out of a funk ... 😏


message 2: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Sounds gory Rosh. Great review though 🩵


message 3: by Jayme (new)

Jayme I don’t like gross either! I will stay far away


message 4: by Baba (new)

Baba Such a lovely review to read Rosh, I too am very much not a fun of shlock media whether it be written, drawn or audio-visual.


Sandysbookaday Nope, not for me either Rosh, but i did enjoy your review. 💕📚


message 6: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Oh goodness! Not for me either Rosh!


Chris Lee (away) Whenever I see a horror review from Roshy, I am ready with the popcorn. Great review, my friend. Okay, okay. I know everyone is thinking about it, so I will be the one to ask. What do the burlesque ghouls look like? I am a visual reader as well, and I just cannot place it. :) 


message 8: by Catherine (new)

Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - in a book slump :( No lizard eating for me! 🤢 Terrific review, Rosh! 💖


message 9: by Sportyrod (new)

Sportyrod Omg Rosh. I just thought of the perfect zombie book for you….”Pride and Prejudice and Zombies”. I haven’t read it, but the movie is so tasty.


message 10: by Tina (new)

Tina Oh no this is not for me either! Still, a great review!


message 11: by Thibault (new)

Thibault Busschots If you’re a visual reader, gory horror can be a bit tough to get through. Though it’s cool that you’re trying out some more horror stories. Good review, Rosh.


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

As a person who considers the lizard-kind her mortal enemy, I applaud you for getting through the story.


message 13: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha Ahem... As much as I can stand gore, lizards are not my thing and neither are zombies. Great to see you read this, though. :D
Superb review, Rosh.


message 14: by Navita (new)

Navita Gujral My dear girl, what you got yourself into? 😂
This is what I was thinking too when I read your ‘in nutshell’.
Relationships like Indian jalebi 😬!

This year, I chose many books out of my comfort zone. Your review reminds me of ‘They were here before us’ - Eric Larocca. Warning you against this one too. Extremely effective for the right audience, but gross🤮 . Flies buzzing around corpses and corpses inhabited by creatures, blood filled balloons 🎈 bursting everywhere 😑. You got the idea! 🙈
Also LGBTQ rep feels forced in books these days I feel.


message 15: by Jenny (new)

Jenny Fantastic review Rosh! I was reading your review and thought it seemed like this story have a lot going on lol, you probably right when you said it might have worked better as a novella.
Christmas : Ho Ho Ho
Rosh: Let me read a gross disgusting story. 😂


message 16: by Kat (new)

Kat Nope, nope, nope. No zombies and lizard-eating ghouls for me either! Great review, Rosh! 💕


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Terrific review Rosh 💖


message 18: by Kay (new)

Kay Eww, but because of the length, I might be able to handle it. 😂 Terrific review Rosh!


message 19: by Fiza (new) - added it

Fiza Pathan Great review Rosh! Sorry about your experience with the lizard, I've got a strong stomach so I will be TBRing this one. I wonder whatever happened to the horror genre over the pandemic, it is now filled with more fantasy & romance than actual horror! Maybe fantasy is the new horror?! Wish that it had turned out better for you, but I am aware that you don't usually prefer this genre. I can digest almost anything! Hope your next one is a winner! Happy Reading to you in the near future! That Jelebi reference made my mouth water, it has been a while since I've had a piece of that sweetmeat! :)


message 20: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer nyc I usually like long short stories, so a 59-pager, plus the premise you described would've won me over, too, Rosh. But gosh, I'm so squeamish! Thanks for the warning, I enjoyed your review :)


message 21: by Jayne (new)

Jayne Not my genre but, as usual, I enjoyed your insightful review.


message 22: by Chantel (new)

Chantel Great review, Rosh! Sorry this didn't turn out to be a full winner but, I'm glad that the 5th book wasn't a total floop. As always, really appreciate reading your thoughts :) xx


message 23: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ awesome review, rosh! horror isn’t for me either so i’ll definitely be staying away from this, although i am curious about gideon the ninth by this author.


message 24: by Karen (new)

Karen Great honest review Rosh! Thank you for your help with this one. Like you, my stomach hurts when I'm reading something disturbing. 😊 ❤️ xx


Sujoya - theoverbookedbibliophile Enjoyed your review but not for me!😊


message 26: by Rosh ~catching up slowly~ (last edited Dec 13, 2023 09:54PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rosh ~catching up slowly~ Thanks much for your comments, my friends! 💙 If you can stomach the gore, I still say that this is a great story to read.

@Norma: Thankfully, of the multiple books I had going, two were winners. I hope you get out of your reading funk soon! :)

@Chris: LOL, I know you horror lovers will always be laughing at my "horror" reviews. :D
The author has described the burlesque ghoul excellently in the book, right down to her walk. (Ewwwww!) If you read the book, you will be able to see "her' clearly. :D

@Rod: Rod!!! I thought you were my friend!! Why are you throwing me to the Austen zombies??? 😱 😢 😓

@Thibault: Thank you. I shall limit this adventurous reading spurt only to short stories though. :D

@Sri: Lizards are not at all my thing, so even the thought of eating them.... Yucckkkk!!! No comments about zombies. They are one step next to vampires in my list of avoidables. :P

@Navi: Ewwwww .... Thanks for the warning, darling! I will stay away from that one! Ye story pe galat stop ho gaya. I only looked at the GR rating and jumped in. :D
I completely agree. Though I am happy at the LGBT rep finally becoming common, I think authors are forcing it in even when the storyline doesn't call for it. Not in this case though. This story used it perfectly.

@Jenny: Rosh's holiday calendar is totally messed up, LOL!

@Fiza: Kudos to you and your strong stomach, my dear friend!😱 I am still suffering from indigestion after this one! 😂
You know, I never thought much about it, but yes, many genres have started overlapping nowadays. And fantasy-horror seems to be a common combo. I guess they count ghosts and zombies as fantastical creatures. They should be separate though - both are diverse reading experiences.

@Jennifer: I too am fond of long-short stories, which is why I jumped into this without bothering to take the blurb seriously. Big mistake!


back to top