Michael O'Brien's Reviews > The Conquering Tide: War in the Pacific Islands, 1942–1944

The Conquering Tide by Ian W. Toll
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
9496879
's review

it was amazing

An excellent work by Toll, covering the change in the Pacific War's momentum from Guadalcanal when the outcome was in the balance t0 1944 when it was swinging decisively against Japan.

Toll does a great job describing these events from the level of the trenches and the deckplates to the strategic level of the US President and the Joint Chiefs of Staff. I like that it gives much credit to an oft overlooked figure in World War 2 history, Fleet Admiral William D. Leahy, who was crucial as the first JCS Chairman in coordinating with the service branches a coherent strategy for prosecuting the two theater war against the Axis Powers.

Unlike other accounts of the Pacific War, to his credit, he also includes the history of the US submarine fleet in crippling the Japanese war effort.

I also like that Toll does a great job in enaging manner in describing the process by which US commanders developed the strategy for defeating Japan --- as well as their various disagreements and rivalries.

Overall, an outstanding work --- I highly recommend it for anyone desiring to know more about the Pacific War during WW2.
37 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Conquering Tide.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 29, 2024 – Shelved
November 29, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
December 1, 2024 – Started Reading
December 8, 2024 –
page 29
4.22%
December 15, 2024 –
page 88
12.79%
December 22, 2024 –
page 126
18.31%
December 29, 2024 –
page 152
22.09%
January 5, 2025 –
page 192
27.91%
January 12, 2025 –
page 214
31.1%
January 19, 2025 –
page 236
34.3%
January 27, 2025 –
page 282
40.99%
February 2, 2025 –
page 294
42.73%
February 2, 2025 –
page 290
42.15%
February 9, 2025 –
page 320
46.51%
February 16, 2025 –
page 356
51.74%
February 23, 2025 –
page 378
54.94%
March 2, 2025 –
page 412
59.88%
March 9, 2025 –
page 454
65.99%
March 16, 2025 –
page 484
70.35%
March 20, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Sleepy Boy This is so so so good!


Michael O'Brien Yes, I am enjoying it so far!


message 3: by Joe (new)

Joe Krakovsky That was something how the subs went from having torpedoes that didn't work to sinking so many ships. Great review, Michael!


message 4: by Michael (last edited Mar 23, 2025 07:08PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Michael O'Brien Joe wrote: "That was something how the subs went from having torpedoes that didn't work to sinking so many ships. Great review, Michael!" Yes, indeed, the US Navy's poor torpedo performance is one of the least known, but most impactful failure in weapons operational test and evaluation in modern military history. So many crews risked their lives and often even lost them due to the astonishingly poor performance of these dreadful Mark 14 torpedoes. So bad in fact --- Toll recounts the story of USS Trigger that faced certain death when a torpedo it fired upon a Japanese target turned directions and, instead, homed in on them due to a design function in the torpedo's rudder system --- only to be saved from certain death by another design malfunction in it --- the defective magnetic exploder, causing the torpedo to fail to arm when it hit, passing over harmlessly the shaken crew! No enemy could have done better than the Navy Bureau of Ordnance bureaucrats in sabotaging the submarine fleet in the first 2 years of the War.


back to top