Sean Barrs 's Reviews > The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (Chronicles of Narnia, #1)
by
by
“If ever they remembered their life in this world it was as one remembers a dream.”
The real world is boring; it’s mundane, unimaginative and dry. So humans create fantasy as a means of escape. We watch movies or go to the theatre to see something more interesting than the standard realities of the everyday. We paint pictures and gaze up at the stars. We play video games and roleplay. We dream. Authors like C.S Lewis and J.K Rowling show us this miserable world; they show us its tones of grey. Then underneath it all they reveal something spectacular: they reveal fantasy.
So we have four rather ordinary children about to embark on an extraordinary adventure. As a child I used to always daydream. I’ve always been somewhat introverted and would prefer imagining faraway places than existing in the now. I still do this as an adult. And this is why I love fantasy so much because it is so immersive; it literally takes my mind away. Lucy, Susan, Edward and Peter are the lucky ones. When they stumble across the wardrobe, the gateway into a more interesting realm, they experience something spectacular.
“She did not shut it properly because she knew that it is very silly to shut oneself into a wardrobe, even if it is not a magic one.”
Sure, there’s a war going on. And, certainly, there’s an evil witch going around murdering people. But, for me, that’d be a price worth paying. For in Narnia there is also Aslan and a whole bunch of interesting characters. There is hope, magic and companionship. The wise old Aslan though is the star of the show. He sacrifices himself for his friends, for his people. Though one issue I have with the book, and one that makes me very much aware of the text as a construct, is the questions over why Aslan actually needed to the four children. He pretty much deals with the problems by himself. There’s prophecy involved, but on a plot level he clearly could have sorted this mess out without any outside interference.
I’ve seen a lot of hate over these books because of the Christian allegories involved in the storytelling. Now I find this somewhat stupid. I’m not a Christian, far from it, but you can’t really criticise a book because of this. It’s incredibly naïve. It would be like judging Jane Eyre based on its feminism aspects or Shakespeare’s exploration of colonialism in The Tempest. It’s silly. This book is, undeniable, full of Christian dogmatism. But it’s what the author wanted it to be. If you read Tolkien’s work there are so many allusions the world wars; this doesn’t affect the overall storytelling. It’s simply what is there. Read this with an open mind, as an English Literature student, I read the bible. I don’t believe the words inside, but I can still enjoy the experience. And this story is no different. Take it for what it is.
“Wrong will be right, when Aslan comes in sight,
At the sound of his roar, sorrows will be no more,
When he bares his teeth, winter meets its death,
And when he shakes his mane, we shall have spring again.”
And that’s something special. I do, however, much prefer the works of Tolkien. I feel that his writing is more universal in terms of age audience. With this though, I’m very much aware of it as a children’s book. The prose is designed to sound like a children’s bedtime story in places. That’s not exactly a bad thing though. I love Narnia but I can, at least from my perspective, objectively say that Tolkien was a better writer. Though what Narnia does have is Aslan. It’s hard not to Aslan. Wouldn’t it be just wonderful if he met Gandalf? Could you imagine the stories those two could share? I'm dreaming again.
Facebook| Twitter| Insta| Academia
The real world is boring; it’s mundane, unimaginative and dry. So humans create fantasy as a means of escape. We watch movies or go to the theatre to see something more interesting than the standard realities of the everyday. We paint pictures and gaze up at the stars. We play video games and roleplay. We dream. Authors like C.S Lewis and J.K Rowling show us this miserable world; they show us its tones of grey. Then underneath it all they reveal something spectacular: they reveal fantasy.
So we have four rather ordinary children about to embark on an extraordinary adventure. As a child I used to always daydream. I’ve always been somewhat introverted and would prefer imagining faraway places than existing in the now. I still do this as an adult. And this is why I love fantasy so much because it is so immersive; it literally takes my mind away. Lucy, Susan, Edward and Peter are the lucky ones. When they stumble across the wardrobe, the gateway into a more interesting realm, they experience something spectacular.
“She did not shut it properly because she knew that it is very silly to shut oneself into a wardrobe, even if it is not a magic one.”
Sure, there’s a war going on. And, certainly, there’s an evil witch going around murdering people. But, for me, that’d be a price worth paying. For in Narnia there is also Aslan and a whole bunch of interesting characters. There is hope, magic and companionship. The wise old Aslan though is the star of the show. He sacrifices himself for his friends, for his people. Though one issue I have with the book, and one that makes me very much aware of the text as a construct, is the questions over why Aslan actually needed to the four children. He pretty much deals with the problems by himself. There’s prophecy involved, but on a plot level he clearly could have sorted this mess out without any outside interference.
I’ve seen a lot of hate over these books because of the Christian allegories involved in the storytelling. Now I find this somewhat stupid. I’m not a Christian, far from it, but you can’t really criticise a book because of this. It’s incredibly naïve. It would be like judging Jane Eyre based on its feminism aspects or Shakespeare’s exploration of colonialism in The Tempest. It’s silly. This book is, undeniable, full of Christian dogmatism. But it’s what the author wanted it to be. If you read Tolkien’s work there are so many allusions the world wars; this doesn’t affect the overall storytelling. It’s simply what is there. Read this with an open mind, as an English Literature student, I read the bible. I don’t believe the words inside, but I can still enjoy the experience. And this story is no different. Take it for what it is.
“Wrong will be right, when Aslan comes in sight,
At the sound of his roar, sorrows will be no more,
When he bares his teeth, winter meets its death,
And when he shakes his mane, we shall have spring again.”
And that’s something special. I do, however, much prefer the works of Tolkien. I feel that his writing is more universal in terms of age audience. With this though, I’m very much aware of it as a children’s book. The prose is designed to sound like a children’s bedtime story in places. That’s not exactly a bad thing though. I love Narnia but I can, at least from my perspective, objectively say that Tolkien was a better writer. Though what Narnia does have is Aslan. It’s hard not to Aslan. Wouldn’t it be just wonderful if he met Gandalf? Could you imagine the stories those two could share? I'm dreaming again.
Facebook| Twitter| Insta| Academia
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 14, 2014
– Shelved as:
to-read
February 14, 2014
– Shelved
November 15, 2016
– Shelved as:
to-read
Started Reading
December 26, 2016
– Shelved as:
5-star-reads
December 26, 2016
– Shelved as:
children-of-all-ages
December 26, 2016
– Shelved as:
fantasy
December 26, 2016
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-36 of 36 (36 new)
date
newest »
Oh... I cant find it in bookstore anymore.. but I loved watch the movie..still the best from Narnia's series as I know.
Christopher wrote: "That´s something! Are you gonna read all the series ?"
I shall be over the next few months! ;)
I shall be over the next few months! ;)
Nadja wrote: "I can't find it either. The movie made me obsessed with old wardrobes for years as a kid. Lol!"
keep looking ;)
keep looking ;)
I love this book so much that I even choreographed a full-length ballet for the end of year student production back in 1977 for a rural ballet school with eighty-odd children aged four to seventeen (nearly as old as I was!). As it was long before the films came out, this was the first introduction to Narnia for many of the participants and it was fantastic to see so many students and even their families discover the books for themselves. Like 'A Christmas Carol,' I try to reread these pretty regularly as they are part of my internal world.
Rosemary wrote: "I love this book so much that I even choreographed a full-length ballet for the end of year student production back in 1977 for a rural ballet school with eighty-odd children aged four to seventeen..."
What a wonderful story you shared! Thank you.
What a wonderful story you shared! Thank you.
i've sort of avoided this book based on people telling me it's heavy on christian themes. But your review has changed my mind. I'll give it a go :)
Anders wrote: "i've sort of avoided this book based on people telling me it's heavy on christian themes. But your review has changed my mind. I'll give it a go :)"
Glad to hear it. I hope you like it too!
Glad to hear it. I hope you like it too!
Rosemary wrote: "I love this book so much that I even choreographed a full-length ballet for the end of year student production back in 1977 for a rural ballet school with eighty-odd children aged four to seventeen..."
I bet that was lots of fun, rewarding too :)
I bet that was lots of fun, rewarding too :)
The next time someone asks me why fantasy is my favorite genre, I'll just quote the first paragraph of this review. Excellent.
Tori wrote: "The next time someone asks me why fantasy is my favorite genre, I'll just quote the first paragraph of this review. Excellent."
i do love my fantasy ;)
i do love my fantasy ;)
Would you mind if I share your first paragraph on my page ? I share quotes that I love daily and this is beautifully laid out to describe fantasy:)
Ryan wrote: "Would you mind if I share your first paragraph on my page ? I share quotes that I love daily and this is beautifully laid out to describe fantasy:)"
sure that's fine :) please send me a link though so I can see it.
sure that's fine :) please send me a link though so I can see it.
You refute the arguments of those who dislike the unsubtle Christian allegory well. And yet, for adult me, it was still too much for my taste. It's fair enough for Lewis to write it that way, as you say. But that doesn't mean all modern readers can like it in spite of that. And Mr Tumnus taking Lucy back to his home for tea? So much for warning kids of "stranger danger". It's even creepier in the Disney film of a few years ago.
Best review for this book on this site. Actually makes me want to read Narnia, which I've ignored my entire life.
So naughty Bookdragon Sean ! As if I've not got enough books, you've only gone and made me have to order this. ;) lol
Serioysly, I love re discovering childhood faves like the Secret garden which I totally inhaled this year. I will look forward to re reading this when it arrives.
Serioysly, I love re discovering childhood faves like the Secret garden which I totally inhaled this year. I will look forward to re reading this when it arrives.
I've read the entire series, and currently looking for my family's copy of the second book, and I've never gave it much thought that people would avoid an amazing story because it uses a religion they don't understand. Glad to see someone who agrees that it doesn't matter. God bless!
I agree strongly i've seen the film and it's amazing. I think the book would be to hard for some children .
Now i do respect Tolkien, but is he a BETTER writer? No, I don’t think so. Lewis and Tolkien both had their strengths and weaknesses with writing, but I don’t think one writer is better than the other. I personally prefer the Narnia series as books. But that’s just me, I haven’t read TLOTR series, because I couldn’t get past the first book because a little boring.. TO ME. I’m committed to trying again and reading the books completely, but like I said, I don’t think one writer is better than the other
I'm super excited about it! :)