Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) 's Reviews > The Alienist

The Alienist by Caleb Carr
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
22189348
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: big, mystery, historical-mistery, favorites, us

Update: I am so excited. I just found out there's going to be a Tv series after the novel. Here is the trailer and it looks amazing with a great cast. Can't wait.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JcJQn...

I realized that I can usually feel a 5* book from the first 50 pages. There is something in the author’s voice that gets to me. The same thing happened with The Alienist. It just had me at hello.

The novel is historical fiction written by a non-fiction author. Although I could feel that background from the attention to the detail he employed in the description of the historical setting, it was never dull and he did a great job to introduce me in the atmosphere of 1896, New York and its underworld. I particularly enjoyed that he used as characters real people (e.g. Teddy Roosevelt) and he mingled them with fictional ones in a way that they all seemed real to me. I was expecting for Dr. Laszlo Kreizler to be an actual doctor from that time and I was quite disappointed when I found out he never existed.

This is a very well written psychological thriller which focuses more on the whydunit than on whodonit. I loved how the investigation team came up with the psychological traits of the killer and searched for the perpetrator based on them. It is a novel about the early stages of criminal profiling, quite a fascinating subject.

My only regret was that I did not have enough time to read and I had to enjoy this beautiful book in small bites which altered the flow of my experience.
157 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Alienist.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 26, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
June 26, 2014 – Shelved
September 30, 2014 – Shelved as: big
September 30, 2014 – Shelved as: mystery
June 29, 2016 – Started Reading
July 19, 2016 –
page 250
50.2% "I wish I had more time to read. Loving it."
July 25, 2016 – Finished Reading
September 20, 2017 – Shelved as: historical-mistery
February 12, 2018 – Shelved as: favorites
October 10, 2018 – Shelved as: us

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Emma Read this recently and also loved it!


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Emma wrote: "Read this recently and also loved it!"

It was really good. Unfortunately, it seems the author cannot continue in the same style. I saw that he just released a new novel and it does not have good reviews at all.


Supratim It is a pretty good book !


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Travelin wrote: "Would it be giving anything away to explain why it won an award for "Gay Men's Mystery"?"

You should read it to find out ;) . Still, I will help you as it would not give too much away. The victims are boy prostitutes and their clients are men who like boys that wear make-up to look like girls. Also, homosexuality is discussed in the book as a possible treat of the killer.


message 5: by Orient (new) - added it

Orient Great review, Adina :) I have this book on my tbr heaven, so interesting :)


dianne b. i have had this book on my shelf for years - waiting to be read. Your review has moved it up in line!
Thanks for the inspiration, it sounds quite fascinating.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Orient wrote: "Great review, Adina :) I have this book on my tbr heaven, so interesting :)" Yes it is. `definitely worth checking out.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) dianne wrote: "i have had this book on my shelf for years - waiting to be read. Your review has moved it up in line!
Thanks for the inspiration, it sounds quite fascinating."
It was. I enjoyed it a lot. I hope you do too.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Dina wrote: "Great review. It seems like my kind of book, so I need to check it out :)" You should. It was one of my favourite books read last year.


Jie-Ying Read the book because of the upcoming show!


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Jie-Ying wrote: "Read the book because of the upcoming show!" Glad you enjoyed it.


Tammy Nice review, Adina! I read this years ago but I’m looking forward to the TV series, too


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Tammy wrote: "Nice review, Adina! I read this years ago but I’m looking forward to the TV series, too" Thanks, Tammy. I can't wait for it to start as well.


message 14: by ChopinFC (new) - added it

ChopinFC Great review :)
I'm really starting to get into historical fiction..it opened up a whole new exciting genre for me! I need to read this at some point.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) ChopinFC wrote: "Great review :)
I'm really starting to get into historical fiction..it opened up a whole new exciting genre for me! I need to read this at some point."
This one open the Historical Mystery genre to me. Definitely worth reading IMO.


message 16: by ChopinFC (new) - added it

ChopinFC Adina wrote: "ChopinFC wrote: "Great review :)
I'm really starting to get into historical fiction..it opened up a whole new exciting genre for me! I need to read this at some point." This one open the Historica..."


hmmm interesting, Historical mystery huh? Again, just shows how little of the 'historical genre' I still know..hehe.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) ChopinFC wrote: "Adina wrote: "ChopinFC wrote: "Great review :)
I'm really starting to get into historical fiction..it opened up a whole new exciting genre for me! I need to read this at some point." This one open..."
You'll learn :))


message 18: by Caleb hunter (new) - added it

Caleb hunter It's amazing! ERI?


back to top