Katerina's Reviews > A Court of Mist and Fury

A Court of Mist and Fury by Sarah J. Maas
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5014021
's review

liked it
bookshelves: fantasy, fae, 2017-reads, retellings

I've never been this manipulated in my life.
I was stripped off my free will until there was only a shell left behind, a puppet complying with her master's whim. This is the most vulgar thing Sarah J. Maas could do.

Allow me to elaborate.
•In order to be candid, I have to admit that I enjoyed A Court of Mist and Fury more than I expected, and found some redeeming traits that prevented me from rating it lower. However, I can't hide my rage and utter disappointment since everything we read in A Court of Thorns and Roses vanished into thin air. Remember the sweet love story between Tamlin and Feyre that defied immortal tyrants and resulted in great sacrifices in the name of their love? Well, forget about it. We were warned that this would be a Hades and Persephone retelling, meaning the romantic relationship between Feyre and Rhysand would be inevitable. The way, though, Sarah handled the transition was feeble and infuriating to say the least. I don't think there has ever been a character more mistreated than Tamlin, with Lucien following suit. We get it, Sarah cares about her precious baby Rhysand, but her real talent as an author would be to make me choose him because I found something unique in him, not because she forced him down my throat. Tamlin's inexcusable behaviour suffocated Feyre, and I felt drowning and suffocating along with her. Since I couldn't possibly wish for her to stay in a mentally abusive relationship, Rhysand was the deus ex machina, the only one to save the damsel in distress, given that her friends abandoned her and her fiance suffered from split personality. Sarah dangled Rhysand in front of me, and every reader, saying pick him pick him pick him. She had Tamlin and Rhysand facing identical situations, only for Tamlin to do the wrong thing while precious Rhysand was the impersonation of right, of all that's good in the world. Tamlin locked Feyre? Rhysand set her free. Tamlin forbid Feyre from participating in his activities? Rhysand would always have her by his side. Tamlin extinguished the fire burning in Feyre and left her a hollow version of herself? Rhysand fueled that fire, and so on, so on. Now, I've been on the losing side of a triangle before, but always both love interests had some good qualities. In this case, though, Sarah served you the answer on a silver platter by annihilating the opponent and erasing everything that made the relationship between Feyre and Tamlin good and healthy. Rhysand was always so thoughtful and considerate and knew what Feyre needed, he was her salvation. Of course he was, there was a freaking magic bond between them that allowed him to read her thoughts. Even the lesser fae servant in the Day Court would understand her needs if they were bonded. In every chapter she would chant Rhysand is so gorgeous, Rhysand is so sexy, Rhysand is the most powerful High Lord in the history of Prythian yada yada. We.Get.It. Don't even get me started on the repetition of the word mate, I rolled my eyes so many times I fear I might have a permanent problem.

•Lucien losing his backbone and Tamlin turning into a psycopath a-hole were not the only character mistreatments, though. Rhysand was the victim of his own creator's adoration. In order to make him the perfect match for Feyre, she made him too perfect. Gone is the wicked, morally grey, complex character that intrigued us in A Court of Thorns and Roses. While unveiling this Rhysand, instead of finding shadows and darkness and lust for power, we found a sappy and fluffy bear asking for love and affection. Everything he did was out of love for his friends, for Feyre and his country, and I fail to accept his reasoning behind his actions Under the Mountain. If you don't want the villain to know how you feel about Feyre, you can simply ignore her. But no, why not drug her, grop her while drugged and humiliate her instead?



•Now let's get to the relationship between Feyre and Rhysand. For more than the first half of the book I liked them, with their banters and flirtation and the pent-up tension. But from attraction and friendship Feyre suddenly jumped to declarations of love and then mountains trembled and she started glowing and their sex scenes varied between steamy to cringe-worthy and more eye-rolling ensued (I seriously need to see an ophthalmologist).

•Plotwise, I can't help but notice that some things were very convenient. You suspect the King of Hybern is preparing for war? Let's ask the monstrous ancient creature, who in the span of five minutes will give us all the answers, including the means to defeat the King and the exact location of the weapons to nullify his powers. Wanna convince the mortal queens to give you what you need? Write a mushy letter about your love for Feyre. The result is guaranteed. I mean, really?



•Why three stars then, you may wonder. Well, I became very fond of the secondary characters. Mor, Azriel, Cassian and the ultimate Queen, Amren, were funny and caring and loyal, and I was actually more invested in their stories (which, to be honest, were all sob stories). I also enjoyed Sarah's lush descriptions, you could feel and breathe and walk the streets of Velaris, and the Summer Court. But most importantly, I admire the way Feyre's trauma from her experiences Under the Mountain was depicted. The guilt, the sorrow, the self-loathing were tangible, and the healing was slow and realistic. Her wounds would be there, and she learned to live with them. Feyre became a strong woman who embraced her gifts, her powers, her sensuality and ferociously claimed her place alongside men. She rose from her ashes.
“When you spend so long trapped in darkness, you find that the darkness begins to stare back.”

A Court of Mist and Fury had great potential, but I can't say I loved it. I'm partially sad because I lost some of my respect for Sarah, for shredding to pieces the characters I loved only to show her own favorites are better. I don't know whether I'll read A Court of Wings and Ruin. Before the last chapters it was a big no, but that final confrontation was the book's highlight for me and now I'm considering to dwelve into the third instalment to find out the end of this story-arc.
To all my friends who loved this book, and I know there are many of you, please don't be harsh on me. The magic of reading is precisely the fact that we all read the same book but get something different from it. ❤️

You can find this review and more over at BookNest.eu!
1189 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Court of Mist and Fury.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 11, 2014 – Shelved
December 11, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
July 19, 2017 – Started Reading
July 19, 2017 –
page 150
23.96% "Alright, I succumbed to peer pressure."
July 22, 2017 – Shelved as: fantasy
July 22, 2017 – Finished Reading
October 19, 2017 – Shelved as: fae
January 24, 2018 – Shelved as: 2017-reads
March 26, 2018 – Shelved as: retellings

Comments Showing 1-50 of 140 (140 new)


Katerina Zenki wrote: "Katerina, I just read it and I'm waiting for your review! <3"

I'm not sure when I'll read it, Zenki! :( I've read enough spoilers to know that dramatic changes occur, and I am dubious I will enjoy them! So glad you loved it, though!


Katerina Zenki wrote: "Katerina wrote: "Zenki wrote: "Katerina, I just read it and I'm waiting for your review!

I'm not sure when I'll read it, Zenki! :( I've read enough spoilers to know that dramatic changes occur, a..."


I'm all in to be hypnotized and forget them, all you have to do is commence your studies! Who knows, since you praise it this much I might give it aa try! ;)


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

Great Review!!! Although I rated it higher, I still agree with the things you pointed out. Can't wait for what you think about the third book.


Katerina Lela wrote: "Great Review!!! Although I rated it higher, I still agree with the things you pointed out. Can't wait for what you think about the third book."

Thank you, Lela!! I am so glad you loved it, perhaps if I didn't root for Tamlin in the first book I'd enjoy this one better!


message 5: by Ivy (new) - added it

Ivy Say it again for the people in the back!
This. This! I have been waiting for a review that would match exactly how I feel about this. I agree fully with everything you said! Excellent review! I rate your review 5 stars!


Irene Nice, honest review Katerina. I haven't read the books, yet, so I don't know if I would agree with you, but I do respect your view of the plot. It certainly has me wondering what I'll think about it once I start reading it.


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

Katerina wrote: "Lela wrote: "Great Review!!! Although I rated it higher, I still agree with the things you pointed out. Can't wait for what you think about the third book."

Thank you, Lela!! I am so glad you love..."


As the saying goes 'To each her own'...lol


Katerina Lela wrote: "Katerina wrote: "Lela wrote: "Great Review!!! Although I rated it higher, I still agree with the things you pointed out. Can't wait for what you think about the third book."

Thank you, Lela!! I am..."


That is so true!

Irene wrote: "Nice, honest review Katerina. I haven't read the books, yet, so I don't know if I would agree with you, but I do respect your view of the plot. It certainly has me wondering what I'll think about i..."

Thank you, my dear Irene! I hope you will give them a shot some time, I'm curious to read what you'll think of them! Maybe what troubled me won't bother you that much, like most readers! ;)

Julia (ten_thousand_books) wrote: "Say it again for the people in the back!
This. This! I have been waiting for a review that would match exactly how I feel about this. I agree fully with everything you said! Excellent review! I ra..."


Thank you so, so much Julia!! <3 I kinda felt the odd man out, considering the average rating for this book is 4.72 stars, but it's a relief to know you felt the same way!


message 9: by Alex (new) - rated it 1 star

Alex YES! FRICK YES! I'm so glad that someone finally said it! Thank you Kat!


Katerina Alex wrote: "YES! FRICK YES! I'm so glad that someone finally said it! Thank you Kat!"

You're very welcome, Alex, I am glad I expressed your thoughts and feelings!


Clarissa Emiria Your review have me even more curious to read on now, I read the first one last year in May and promptly bought the first two books for my birthday, but then never got around to continuing reading the story 🤔 But reading your review just now has re-piqued my interest in the series 😆 I, like you, quite liked the first one, so I'll be curious to see how I'll get on with the sequels, now that I've read your, very excellent I might add, review 🤔 I have a tendency to just fall into books and forget to read critically but this time I might 🙂 Thank you for this 🙂🙏


Katerina Clarissa Emiria wrote: "Your review have me even more curious to read on now, I read the first one last year in May and promptly bought the first two books for my birthday, but then never got around to continuing reading ..."

Hello Clarissa! Thank you so much for your kind words! In all honesty I hope you will enjoy this book more than I did, and you won't be biased because of my review! Happy reading! xo xo


message 13: by Einav (new)

Einav I enjoyed this book, but not as much as all the others. I agree with what you wrote about Tamlin and Rhys. I think the shift between the two of them was forced on me. in order to make me love Rhys she demonized Tamlin. you cannot dscribe the love between Feyra and Tamlin as epic - and then just dismissed it. what is the power of true love if it cant last forever? (and now some people will say that Tamlin was not her true love, but in the first book he defently were!!!!)


message 14: by Page (new)

Page Grey (Editor) Great Review Katarina..I think for the first time I read a very realistic and true review of this book. :) :) :)


Catherine Honest and great review! For me, I enjoyed this book but maybe because I didn't really read the first book. I skipped here and there. And yeah, I admit Rhysand and Feyre seems very forced. It is really unfair for Tamlin and Lucien too. Although, I really adore their side characters, esp Az. ❤️ But wait until you got to the third one, even for the one who loved this book, it was really a disappointing to me.


Katrin D Great review, Katerina! :) I felt the exact same way you did, so I'm really glad you've explained it all so well :)


message 17: by Eliza (new) - rated it 1 star

Eliza Rapsodia this book is "manipulate timeee" ;P


Maria I liked the book and Feysand, but I will never forgive Sarah for treating Tamlin like this!


V. A Court of Wings and Ruin is NEW ADULT/EROTICA but Goodreads editors won't tell you to include it in the choice awards Great review, Katerina! Not many reviewers are willing to talk about what you just said so perfectly. Mind you I still love this book to death but I want to highlight some things:

I don't think there has ever been a character more mistreated than Tamlin, with Lucien following suit.
I couldn't agree more. And she keeps the mistreating in the early chapters of ACOWAR when Feyre's already strong and still we have an encore of one of Tamlin's temper fits.

Don't even get me started on the repetition of the word mate, it's even worse in ACOWAR. I suspect that SJM read Shay Savage's transcendence and took the idea from there.

Sarah dangled Rhysand in front of me, and every reader, saying pick him pick him pick him.
Which was unnecessary as 90% of the fandom had already picked him. He's the reason that many of us are willing to give a free pass on the problematic issues of ACOMAF. He's just so perfect that you end up ignoring the problems of the book. At least I do because romance is very important for me.

This is the most vulgar thing Sarah J. Maas could do.

Is it? I think it's more vulgar to allow her publishing company to sell this book with so many erotic scenes to 12-13 YO's. But I don't know, maybe she doesn't have control on that. Anyway sorry, I never miss the chance to say this because so many people still don't know that this is happening. One of my real life friends didnt' believe me until I read aloud page 21 and 22 to her.


Cassie I never really liked Tamlin so I didn't mind the Rhysand switch but I 100% agree with you that it was so unnecessary for it to be so black-and-white TAMLIN IS SO BAD NOW AND RHSYAND IS EVERYTHING HE'S NOT. Would it be so hard to believe that people can fall out of love with someone and then fall in it with someone else instead?


Carolina Hahahaha, what a nice review. I totally agree with you, but I wasn't so good on my review, haha


message 22: by • sel • (new) - added it

• sel • Omg so i actually loved this book when I read it but the more time passes the more I'm thinking about it and I actually don't like this book that much anymore. It's weird that i just saw all my thoughts written down in your review lol but thank you so much. Glad to see that I'm not alone


message 23: by N (new) - rated it 5 stars

N Y Fantastic review, I do agree with almost all of what you've said even though this book still holds a dear place in my heart. ACOMAF will always be my favourite of the trio because I did actually buy Rhy's characterization, but I do agree with you that he barely has any flaws (which is, y'know, ironically what makes me like him so much).

I think I started to see the problems more in the final novel, though. It was like the changes from one book to the other were suddenly too jarring and did not make sense. And all the characters started to grow and spiral into ways that were a bit too OOC for my comfort zone. Book 2 was steaming romance, and book 3 was intensely action heavy. It felt a bit like they were aimed at different audiences rather than one and the same.

Somebody tell me I'm crazy and reading too much into this?


Katerina Selena wrote: "Omg so i actually loved this book when I read it but the more time passes the more I'm thinking about it and I actually don't like this book that much anymore. It's weird that i just saw all my tho..."

Thank you, Selena, for your kind words! :) Sometimes that happens, loving a book but later realising that it had many flaws!

Carolina wrote: "Hahahaha, what a nice review. I totally agree with you, but I wasn't so good on my review, haha"

Thank you, Carolina! :)

Charlotte wrote: "I never really liked Tamlin so I didn't mind the Rhysand switch but I 100% agree with you that it was so unnecessary for it to be so black-and-white TAMLIN IS SO BAD NOW AND RHSYAND IS EVERYTHING H..."

You're so right, Charlotte, it would have been more believable to simply fall out of love instead of ruining a character in order to give Feyre absolution to move on! The switch was not necessary and reflects bad on the author!

Maria wrote: "I liked the book and Feysand, but I will never forgive Sarah for treating Tamlin like this!"

Me neither, Maria, he didn't deserve it! :(

Nina wrote: "this book is "manipulate timeee" ;P"

Lol so true, Nina, so true!

Katrin wrote: "Great review, Katerina! :) I felt the exact same way you did, so I'm really glad you've explained it all so well :)"

Thank you so much, Katrin! It's good to know I was not alone! ;)

Ana wrote: "Great review!"

Thank you, dear!^^

Catherine wrote: "Honest and great review! For me, I enjoyed this book but maybe because I didn't really read the first book. I skipped here and there. And yeah, I admit Rhysand and Feyre seems very forced. It is re..."

Thank you, Catherine! Honestly, what you did was the wisest decision, it turned out there was no point reading the first book after all. I'd love the ability to choose between two equally fascinating characters, but that option was denied and I'm mad about it! (P.S. I love Az! <3)

Einav wrote: "I enjoyed this book, but not as much as all the others. I agree with what you wrote about Tamlin and Rhys. I think the shift between the two of them was forced on me. in order to make me love Rhys ..."

Precisely, Elinav! in order to make me love Rhys she demonized Tamlin, that is so true! ACOTAR was all about the epic love between Tamlin and Feyre, and then she just ruined it to make her favorite character more lovable! Then why did she write the first book anyway?? She made us believe it was true love until she decided it was not!

Lili wrote: "Great Review Katarina..I think for the first time I read a very realistic and true review of this book. :) :) :)"

Thank you, Lili! <3


Katerina Veronica PARENTAL GUIDANCE ALERT: A Court of Mist and Fury is an EROTICA/NEW ADULT but most booktubers won't tell you wrote: "Great review, Katerina! Not many reviewers are willing to talk about what you just said so perfectly. Mind you I still love this book to death but I want to highlight some things:

I don't think t..."


Thank you, Veronica! I am so glad we can agree on many things even though you enjoyed this book more than I did! I just feel really bad for Tamlin, before starting ACOMAF I swore I would not give up on him, but Saraj twisted him so much, and it was not necessary :( I can't believe they tried to sell it to young audiences, the sex scenes were way too graphic! I sincerely hope Sarah had nothing to do with it, I'd hate to find one more thing to blame her for!

N wrote: "Fantastic review, I do agree with almost all of what you've said even though this book still holds a dear place in my heart. ACOMAF will always be my favourite of the trio because I did actually bu..."

Thank you, N! <3 Well, Sarah practically canonized Rhysand in this one, she worships she ground he walks! I mean come on, at least give us a challenge! I haven't read the third book yet, but I don't doubt you're right, judging by the dramatic changes from book one to book two!


Candace Great, honest review, Katerina! :)


Daisy White I just have to say.... Welcome to the World of Sarah J. Maas.... alway expect the unexpected and embrace the twist and turns of her world!!!


Carolina Katerina wrote: "Selena wrote: "Omg so i actually loved this book when I read it but the more time passes the more I'm thinking about it and I actually don't like this book that much anymore. It's weird that i just..."

Hahahaha, you're welcome! :D


Katerina Daisy White wrote: "I just have to say.... Welcome to the World of Sarah J. Maas.... alway expect the unexpected and embrace the twist and turns of her world!!!"

Well, embracing them is the only way to cope with them, I think! :)

Candace wrote: "Great, honest review, Katerina! :)"

Thank you, Candace! :)


message 30: by Sakina (last edited Jul 23, 2017 12:39PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Sakina Omg I agree with you on all accounts!!!! Like seriously, she made Rhysand the perfect choice!! It's like Tamlin wasn't even an option anymore. And goodness gracious that stupid love letter!! Like all the time we are told about how "powerful" Rhysand is and then he goes and does that?!? Like seriously. And everything he did is justified, like WTH? The cunning, dark, flirtatious and mysterious High Lord is gone and instead we get Romeo.
And Feyre is furious with Tamlin, for what? I agree whatever he did was wrong, especially going to Hybern but what was he to do? He thought the love of his life was in danger and he did whatever it took to get her back. Sending him a letter is suppose to convince him you are okay? Especially when you are living with a High Lord that manipulates thoughts and minds? I'll be honest, I didn't like Tamlin in book 1 either. But I hated the author manipulation that made him the villain.

And yes the term "mate" got annoying. You should see how much it is used in A Court of Wings and Ruin. Like I wanted to scream, "I get it!! He is your mate! She is your mate! I get it!! Just please start acting a little normal and reduce the unjustified show of power."
So conveniently Rhysand is the most powerful lord, and his and Feyre's relationship is annoying (in ACOWAR) but even in ACOMAF, the second half, it's annoying.

And I agree that everything happens for them so conveniently. Like lets go to this person to find answers and how Feyre can so easily capture the Suriel when so many powerful others can't.

Seriously SJM books will read quickly because they are intriguing but as soon as you are done, you can see all the faults. I am so irritated that so many better books out there do not get the attention they deserve.

I too only like the side characters and the description and certain phrases.


message 31: by Chia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Chia Whoa! Great review! Agree with everything you said, it was point on! Even though I enjoyed the book, I still found so many problems with it with exactly what you said. Don't even read A Court of Wing and Ruined though, you eyeballs might fall at the end, haha.


Caitlyn I utterly agree. <33 This perfectly encapsulates what is now wrong with Maas' novels—authorial manipulation, clear bias for certain characters, overwhelmingly "flawless" characters, etc. It's a little sad, honestly.


message 33: by Steven (new) - added it

Steven J Very thorough review and analysis--a bit unsettling how your review draws one into pondering too much over the plot though. Certainly makes me want to read the book and find out if I have the same perspective.


Catherine Absolutely!!! I would love to be able to choose between two equally fascinating and interesting love interests, like the infernal devices series. This seems so cray cray.
Also, in the third one, all the sexual tension between two side characters is blown up because of the sexuality of one of them. I'm just sick of Maas reversing her characters to completely new level, even she had a right to do it.


Vanessa Gayle ⚔️ Fangirl Faction I really enjoyed this review! Your honesty is awesome. =]


Charlie The problems you had in this book, are the ones I found in A Court of Wings and Ruin! "Oh Rhys, my mate, and I love him so so much!" Just shut up Feyre! And everything also is just too convenient, making it seem all happy and rainbows and complete fluff!
Your review was very enjoyable to read!:)


Denise Alcaraz I actually liked ACOMAF, but was very disappointed in ACOWAR (#3). It took me a long time to finish it. It was too Mary Sue and deus ex Machina. I thought I loved this series more than Throne of Glass, but TOG at least has more books with a more consistent and realistically progressive story line. Lets just hope it ends well with the last book. I hate to say, Katerina, that you will most likely NOT like ACOWAR. Sorry.


message 38: by Karen (new) - added it

Karen Wonderful, honest review, Katerina. I'm still a huge fan of Tamlin and Lucien. ACOTAR was good, but ACOMAF is just porn for teens.


Despoina  Santorinaiou Great review. I shipped Feysand since acotar but the points you made are accurate and they become even more apparent by the end of the third book (by the end of which I was too annoyed to be able to stand Feyre and I didn't particularly care about Rhysand). Nevertheless I still love the side characters and I am still invested in their story.


Katerina Vanessa wrote: "I really enjoyed this review! Your honesty is awesome. =]"

Thank you, Vanessa!! You're really sweet! :)

Charlie wrote: "The problems you had in this book, are the ones I found in A Court of Wings and Ruin! "Oh Rhys, my mate, and I love him so so much!" Just shut up Feyre! And everything also is just too convenient, ..."

Thank you, Charlie! :) We understood that they're mates the first time, there's no need for repetition, it's getting ridiculous! This series had great potential, why on earth did SJM handle it so awkwardly??

Denise wrote: "I actually liked ACOMAF, but was very disappointed in ACOWAR (#3). It took me a long time to finish it. It was too Mary Sue and deus ex Machina. I thought I loved this series more than Throne of Gl..."

Thank you for the warning, Denise! Maybe I'll read it sometime in the future just to find out the conclusion of the story, but knowing it's even worse is disheartening!

Karen wrote: "Wonderful, honest review, Katerina. I'm still a huge fan of Tamlin and Lucien. ACOTAR was good, but ACOMAF is just porn for teens."

Thank you, Karen! Tamlin and Lucien didn't deserve such treatment, it was so unfair and totally not necessary! Lol that's an accurate description!

Despoina wrote: "Great review. I shipped Feysand since acotar but the points you made are accurate and they become even more apparent by the end of the third book (by the end of which I was too annoyed to be able t..."

Thank you, Despoina! I'm even more cautious about the third book now, if the flaws of ACOMAF are more apparent then it'll annoy the hell out of me! I do love the side characters as well! ;)


Katerina Sakina wrote: "Omg I agree with you on all accounts!!!! Like seriously, she made Rhysand the perfect choice!! It's like Tamlin wasn't even an option anymore. And goodness gracious that stupid love letter!! Like a..."

Thank you, THANK YOU Sakina for summarizing everything that's wrong with this book! Indeed Sarah has her way of getting your attention and hooking you to the story, and generally I'm a huge fan of hers, but ACOMAF was wrong in so many levels!

Chia (sincerelychia) wrote: "Whoa! Great review! Agree with everything you said, it was point on! Even though I enjoyed the book, I still found so many problems with it with exactly what you said. Don't even read A Court of Wi..."

Lol I should start looking for eye transplants, then! :P Thank you, Chia, for your kind words! So many problems that could be avoided because Sarah is a capable author, but she didn't handle matters right!

Caitlyn wrote: "I utterly agree. <33 This perfectly encapsulates what is now wrong with Maas' novels—authorial manipulation, clear bias for certain characters, overwhelmingly "flawless" characters, etc. It's a lit..."

Well said, Caitlyn, I'm so glad we agree! <3 Such manipulation shows utter disrespect towards the readers, it is unforgivable!

Steven wrote: "Very thorough review and analysis--a bit unsettling how your review draws one into pondering too much over the plot though. Certainly makes me want to read the book and find out if I have the same ..."

Thank you so much, Steven! I'd love to read your thoughts about this series, you've seen the contradictions and I'm looking forward to new perspectives!

Catherine wrote: "Absolutely!!! I would love to be able to choose between two equally fascinating and interesting love interests, like the infernal devices series. This seems so cray cray.
Also, in the third one, a..."


Precisely, what I hated the most was the manipulation! Sarah chose to ignore that we have a functioning brain that is actually capable of making decisions! Their sexuality? :O But there is no hint! That's crazy!


Jess (freaks over books) This! I have been waiting for a review like this, I posted something similar in a group for Acotar fans and got tore apart, because Feyre and Rhys are perfect and Tamlin is this instant tool and it's like the first book never mattered at all. I loved Acotar and this book was good but I had a lot of issues with it, same with the third. It went from being a series I really loved to one I find to be mediocre and over hyped. I am unsure whether I want to pick up her Throne of glass series.


Aj the Ravenous Reader Aw. You're one of the chosen few people who didn't love this like everybody else. Hopefully I'll like it more but wonderful review, Kat! <3


message 44: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Can I marry you?


Katerina Lisa wrote: "Can I marry you?"

Lol I pressume we agree, at least regarding some points, Lisa? :)

Aj the Ravenous Reader wrote: "Aw. You're one of the chosen few people who didn't love this like everybody else. Hopefully I'll like it more but wonderful review, Kat! <3"

Thank you, my dear Aj! <3 I do wish you'll like it more, otherwise you'll regret the hours you spent reading it!

Jess (freaks over books) wrote: "This! I have been waiting for a review like this, I posted something similar in a group for Acotar fans and got tore apart, because Feyre and Rhys are perfect and Tamlin is this instant tool and it..."

Thank you, Jess!! :) I'm sorry you got this reaction, ACOTAR is a series that has divided the readers! I'm sad and disappointed Sarah wrote the second and third book as if the first one didn't exist, how could she treat her characters like this? I love Throne of Glass, there was a shocking twist in the ships but generally it's a great series!


Katerina Elise wrote: "Great review kat! You make very good points about why you didn't like the book, and while they didn't bother me personally, I do agree that the situation should have been handled better. Honestly, ..."

Thank you, Elise! <3 Honestly, I've loved SJM's books for years, but the way she handled things in this one was a huge disappointment. I trust your word about ACOWAR, and I hope you'll manage to finish it soon!


message 47: by [deleted user] (new)

A Court of Wings and Ruin is not worth it IMO. But yeah I’m not a fan of Sarah’s writing and characterization


Sunny My BIGGEST problem with SJM is that she doesn’t leave her characters open for interpretation. We’re forced to see her characters only the way she sees them. AND SO MANY PEOPLE FALL FOR IT. They don’t even see that Maas isn’t giving them a chance to like the characters she hates.


Katerina Sunny's Books wrote: "My BIGGEST problem with SJM is that she doesn’t leave her characters open for interpretation. We’re forced to see her characters only the way she sees them. AND SO MANY PEOPLE FALL FOR IT. They don..."

Precisely, dear, you expressed the biggest problem of this series (and Throne of Glass to be honest, considering Sarah's adoration for Rowan). She simply ruins the characters she wants to discard as love interests!

Lily wrote: "A Court of Wings and Ruin is not worth it IMO. But yeah I’m not a fan of Sarah’s writing and characterization"

While I love Throne of Glass, this series has many issues that I ignored in the first book, but I can't anymore. I've heard bad things about ACOWAR even by devoted fans!


Μaria Vrisanaki Αχ Κατερίνα αυτό φοβάμαι κ εγώ!! Θα χάσουν την αξία τους όλα όσα πέρασαν ο Ταμλιν και η Φέιρα 😔😔


« previous 1 3
back to top