London's Reviews > Breaking Her

Wait, you think Dante slept with someone else after he broke up with her the second time? I think what his brother went back to tell her was something to do with his Mom. Like blackmail or something.

No I mean I hope when he ended things when they were younger (the first time) that he didn't end up actually sleeping with Tiffany. Like if the whole point of breaking up with Scarlett and betraying her was to protect her from whatever is going on he better not have actually touched that bitch. I mean it's bad enough he has hurt her so badly and for so many years. It's completely unforgivable if he ended up sleeping with that bitch when it was supposed to be pretend and to protect Scarlett.

Like I would hope it took him a very very long time to become intimate with someone again and that it wasn't Tiffany. Honestly, my dream would be that he had only bee intimate with Scarlett throughout the years and that she just assumed he had been with others. Because he was he reason they ended to begin with and why they aren't together. That would be super romantic to me lmao

Oh! I get it now. It would be super romantic! I do think he had something to do with her. I mean why all the fuss. Definitely his mom had something to do with it. She's probably blackmailing him along with that bitch Tiffany. It really could be anything because the ending didn't give you much of a clue. I guess we will have to wait and see.

Amen ! If he sleeps with that bitch, I won;t care how well the author writes it. I don't care how helpless or whatever the fuck he was, this book is getting 1 starred.

Hi London! I'm so curious about ur theories but mines are killing me and I remember Scarlet said something like "was certain he had never resorted to her if I hadn't been so far." And I'm scared to say the cheating is a BIG possibility, it seems:( or not? IM SO CONFUSED.

Ag-fucking-reed!!!

I don't want to read this book because I'm 100% sure this will happen what you wrote above London! The end in the first book was just terrible and stupid from the author and ruined all.He will end up with this bitch and he will fuck her and worse Scarlett will chasing him and all will be forgiven....My experience from reading romance is that second book can only get worse

Had to agree with you, if he breaks up with her to protect her, I'm good with it. But if he sleep with the bitch after he broke up with her, then there's nothing to forgive because that's just low.

Had to agree with you, if he breaks up with her to protect her, I'm good with it. But if he sleep with the bitch after he broke up with her, then there's nothing to forgive because that's just low.

Well hopefully the author sees these comments and takes the readers into consideration lol. I'm really excited to read what happens but I'll be raging if that does end up being the case. I mean after Tristan & Danika you can never be too sure with this author.

remember what happen when tristan ended up fucking another woman after he cleaned ..LOL , i think the author will repeat that to make this book more angsty and make reader angry AF

I couldn't disagree with you all, more. I gave five stars to the first book and no matter what happens in the second book I wouldn't touch that rating. To change a rating because you don't like where the story is going in the second book is so unfair and childish. R k lilley is one of the best authors, and I've read every single book she ever wrote. I have complete faith in her and that breaking her will be five plus stars. It's her right as the author to express her story the way she wants. If you really got to know the characters, you'd know that Dante would never hurt Scarlett on purpose. He would have to be tricked, black mailed, or worse. He was always the level headed, reasonable one of the two and from day one made it his job to protect her. He loved and still loves Scarlett and has to be doing all this to protect her from something really horrific. Scarlett, as damaged and insecure as she is on the other hand, might've jumped the gun and done something to sabotage the relationship unintentionally, but because of jealousy and her impulsive, defensive nature, fuck things up even further. For example sleeping with his friend.( can't remember his name but it was the one she mentioned in the end of the book that she thought loved her, and Dante agreed and said go easy on him. The pivotal point of the down ward spiral of their relationship was when she was marking her territory and was all over him In front of his friends, then talked him into doing it in the woods, when he was reluctant and also by convincing him to go bare back. My hunch is that someone got video of them. At the end She also mentions that she wondered if she again didn't get jealous and wasn't sulking and waited for him after practice and didn't walk off home on her own or took a different path that they'd still be together. So something happened that day that changed them forever. The only way Dante would of done anything wrong was because he was trying to protect her and was lied to , manipulated, blackmailed and worse. Scarlett didn't help any of it by creating more damage. Again have faith in your author and this comment and threatening to change your ratings only makes you look silly. The writer can't possible make everyone happy and is telling and creating a story from her heart. No one should get to dictate or even suggest how she ends it. It's her prerogative .
Sorry rant over.

Honey, this is my opinion and my comments. I don't have to change them because you disagree with me. I 100% disagree with you and it's my right. The only person who looks silly is you for trying to insult someone on their own personal opinion about a book. This is what this website is for so kindly take your rude comment and keep it to your own page. Thanks!

First off, don't call me honey, second, I have a right to my opinion, as much as you do. When a review pops up on a BOOK'S page(not your page) and a especially when it's a book not even out yet, which I feel is ridiculous in its self, I have a right to comment. I was trying to show you another perspective and point of view. This book and series is way deeper than who cheated on who. It's about two people who constantly have the world and odds against them, but their unconditional love and loyalty to one another is so strong and intense that no matter what, it never falters or fades. Your review/comment and threat to change your rating of book one, just because someone cheated, in my opinion, is trivial and shallow. In my opinion a rating should be based on the quality of the writing, whether or not it consumes you and you can't put it down, as well a many other literary reasons, not if Dante cheated. This genera is contemporary romance. It's fiction but not fairy tale romance with unicorns and rainbows. RK Lilley's books are dark, gritty, at times violent, mysterious and intense but Even with the ugliest of struggles that her characters go through there's always a happy ending. My suggestion, wait for the second book to come out, before reviewing/commenting on it and your review of your first book should stand as is, no matter what happens in the second. If you're a fan of this author and know how consistent she is, have a little faith she'll come through with this series. As for the first book, maybe you should re read it, really get to know the characters and their story. Try and read between the lines and open your mind a little. As you can tell I'm a huge fan of R K Lilley, and all her books. I can count on one hand how many times I've commented on any page, your so called review/comment simply annoyed me. By posting, commenting or reviewing, your leaving yourself open to responses. No disrespect or insult intended. Have a good day.

Honey, I didn't read anything you wasted your time writing. I'm not interested. Stop trolling. Cya

Not the heroine. we still don't know whether the hero did or not.

In flight was 100% safe on both sides but it's big time BDSM romance. Pretty much a more intense FOSG

My bad, wasting my breath, dealing with a child! Move on from this author, she's not for you. I think Disney has a few books for you. ;)

And the reason you say you're not reading my comments , is because you have nothing valid to say in response. Lol too funny

No it's because I don't like to deal with trolls on goodreads. Stop acting like a psycho it's really quite disturbing. Stop harassing people on goodreads!

The one thing I'm most disturbed about is she said this couple had unconditional love and loyalty. How would he get an erection and have sex with someone else and that be unconditional love and loyalty? Ok next she'll say.. You don't know if he did.. Then I'll say what would her defense be if it shows he did do it? How would this be unconditional love? Unconditional loyalty? As for changing a rating on a previous book you've read? I think that it's showing how you felt for the whole entire story which if it's a cliffhanger series all books can be rated together. I would absolutely hate for an author to tear apart a couple.. My best example that a true romance author who writes loyal characters is Katy Evans. Even though Brooke leaves Remy in book one.. Remy never touched another woman. The author made sure that we found that out. So I pray that this author shows that when a man loves a woman truly that his body belongs to her and she keeps him from being disloyal. I wonder why Michelle didn't say how she'd feel if he slept around while proclaiming he's unconditionally loyal and unconditionally loved the heroine. How would his actions sleeping with someone else prove that? Why not defend an author you love by saying she'd never betray their love? I think Michelle is not even sure if this guy will sleep around.

Great point Nichole! Unconditional love and loyalty means faithfulness and not having sex with others. You can't have it both ways- Michelle isn't making sense. Plus she doesn't know what the next book will bring either. Michelle needs to find something else to do with her time and stop criticizing people's notes and reviews.

Oh wow. Bitches be crazy lol!!! Seriously, you don't like or agree with a comment? Move it along. Are we in high school?? Lawd!

Chillll dude

Yasminaa wrote: "Chillll dude"

Who are you referring to?

I agree a 100%, cheating is an absolute NO-go for me. I won't read this book until I see reviews which deems this book as safe. I really didn't know that Tristan and Danika's book series had cheating in it.. wow I'm super pissed, I wished I had known this before I had bought all the three books of the series. Ugh.. thank god I can return them and get my money back, I'm doing that right after this comment.
I always thought of R.K. Lilley as a safe author..wow the disappointment is just brutal.
Hopefully there is absolutely NO cheating here or else I guess another author will be added to my "no-go authors list".

Thanks for the review.

Ladies, you are good to go :-)

Don't play with my emotions like that!! Really?

(view spoiler)[ yes. He slept with other women in book 1 when him and Danika had already slept with each other several times but weren't official. Then in book 2 his addiction becomes so bad that when she asks for a divorce he's so high/drunk he fucks other women when she leaves him. They were still technically married. He didn't even realize what he'd done until he woke up the next morning. I loved that series but I also was super lenient back then. Id never have touched it today. I will say that book 3 is ALL groveling on his part. Like start to finish is him trying to win her back after he goes to rehab. (hide spoiler)]

So did the heroine in this series here sleep with another man too? while they were separated and while you thought he was sleeping with someone else? So it's true she cheated..and you are trying to make sure He didn't cheat?? Just trying to understand LOL.

(view spoiler)[ She slept with someone else when the hero ended things with her and made it seem (for years) like he cheated on her and immediately became engaged to the other women. She did it to hurt him back. He allowed her to believe he was with that other woman for a few years and then she believed he had been with other women after that girl too. It wasn't like she heard a rumor. He kept hurting her over and over and over again for years and never told her the truth. I didn't blame her for trying to hurt him back because he really REALLY hurts her badly in book one. It's not like other books where you can say oh well why didn't she just wait? Why didn't she ask him? Or heroines that hear a rumor and take it as fact. He legitimately lets her think this is true for years for reasons we don't find out about until this book is released.

I don't think it's fair to hate the heroine in the specific case because he put her through hell. I'm glad he get the amount of pain she felt too! (hide spoiler)]

I am so sick of people trolling on other peoples reviews/comments, everyone has a right to their opinions! London I agree with u 100% I read a few series where I loved the couple but because of them being with other people in the second book I changed my ratings to low, it had nothing to do with the writing but the plot. I can't see a couple in a favourable light if by their actions after they have disappointed my feelings towards him/her. As someone who has spent time and money on reading books I have the right to voice my feelings without troll's getting all defensive!

I wish people would stop trolling on other people's reviews/opinions it's so annoying!

It's just funny because I never go comment on other peoples review and attack them because I don't agree with what they wrote. Whether they liked the book or not it's none of my business. They act like the author is their best friend that needs their honor defended. Like the the hell out of here and crawl out of the authors ass.

I hadn't even rated the book or reviewed THIS book when I wrote my original review. I had only commented on how I WOULD feel should certain things come to light. And now that I know it's safe for me I updated it so it doesn't dissuade others from reading it.

(view spoiler)[ she only slept with the guy friend that one time I believe. She did it AFTER the hero dumps (From what I remember they were actually engaged then) her and makes her think he cheated on her and gets fake engaged to this girl that his mother had been pushing towards him for a long time. She did it to hurt him back for breaking her heart and never even telling her why. She still in book 1 doesn't know why and he won't leave her alone years after he ended things. For me, he deserved to feel some pain too lol (hide spoiler)]

No worries. That's why I put the exception tag.=)

Yeah but I think she really wanted to hurt him badly and that was the best thing that came to mind. It was also when she was much younger and she did feel bad for doing it.

(view spoiler)[ After rehab he contacts her and asks to meet and apologize for something bad that happened to her the night he went on the alcohol/drug binge. She meets him and tells him she wants absolutely no relationship with him at all. She really did mean it too because she felt he was so toxic for her. Anyways, from what I remember he was celibate after rehab for a year or two and then dated a little bit. Then he realized again that he doesn't want those types of relationships and only wanted the heroine. He becomes celibate again until he sees her after a long time and the pursues her. Throughout all those years he also completely changed his life and bought a house and did all these things he thought she would like even before trying to get her back. I will say that it's the ONLY series that had the most epic leave of groveling/winning back the girl. I think I even created by shelf "gives good grovel" for that book. She does move on and dare but it's obviously never what she had with Tristan. I do think you'll want to shoot someone after book 1 & 2 but book 3 was very gratifying. (hide spoiler)]

Tristan & Danika? Yeah

From what I remember the changes occurred (view spoiler)[ while he had been celibate and more when he sees her at a party. He wasn't whoring in book 3 casually no emotional attachment. She did have sex with OM after the divorce (hide spoiler)]

I think only Tristan and Danika was unsafe

Only Danika and Tristan series are unsafe. I read all of hers, except for the present one (not yet, lol), and the rest of her book are safe. One of my all time favorites, In Flight series, is completely safe! I adore that couple! ;)

Thank you, sweetie for all the details and spoilers of this series! ;)

Great review! It sounds like a lot of details were left hanging! So the H never slept with that bitchy OW or any OW?

Cyndi wrote: "Great review! It sounds like a lot of details were left hanging! So the H never slept with that bitchy OW or any OW?"

Apparently he never sleep with anyone since h, not even during separation. ;)

No, she loved him just as much as he loved her. She had no way of knowing he was lying. There were photos of him with Tiffany holding hands and throughout the years he purposely let her see him with other women to make her think he was with them too. She had absolutely no way of knowing that it has nothing to do with her not loving him the same amount. I would have found her pathetic if she stayed celibate thinking he was out living and enjoying other women. If she knew he had been celibate or was protecting her and STILL slept with other men then I'd agree.

The hero even tells her he doesn't blame her because he never let her think otherwise. It's his own fault. Honestly, he could have easily told her what was going on. He was with her in private plenty of times and could have told her to pretend like she doesn't know the truth.

Judging by your review and comments. Sounds to me like these type of stories are not for you, maybe you should just stick to chick lit/contemporary romance or books written by Marian Keyes or Hester Browne?

'Maybe it's wishful thinking to think the author saw our comments and kept us mind when writing this book?' Definitely wishful thinking