Sean Barrs 's Reviews > Stoner

Stoner by John  Williams
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
27788046
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 5-star-reads, favourites, contemporary-lit

THIS WAS MY BEST BOOK OF 2016!

It was a hard decision; it was a choice between this and The Vegetarian by Hang Kang. But I had to think which book taught be the most, and which book helped me the most. I enjoyed them both immensely, I loved them, but this one set me on my path in life; thus, I will always be grateful for John Williams and his Stoner.

******************************************************
He opened the book; and as he did so it became not his own. He let his fingers rifle through the pages and felt a tingling, as if those pages were alive. The tingling came through his fingers and coursed through his flesh and bone; he was minutely aware of it, and he waited till it contained him, until the old excitement that was like horror fixed him where he lay……

William Stoner has a terrible life: his marriage is a disaster; his daughter resembles her damaged mother; his teaching career is hindered by an argument with a fellow faculty member, and he is subjected to continual waves of misery. All in all, it’s a sad life: it’s his life. However, through all the shit times, and the occasional glimpses of happiness, one thing keeps him animated; it’s a thing every reader knows: a love of words, a love of books and a love of the wonderment of literature. I will never forget the journey I shared with Stoner in these pages.

He is a flawed man. When he was a student he had no real ambition or drive. He didn’t know what he wanted to do, but he knew what he didn’t want to do: he didn’t want to be a farmer like his farther. A university lecture inspired him with the marvels of Shakespeare; he asked him a question, a question that changed Stoner’s life. The result was a switch in academic discipline and an enthusiastic perusal of everything literature based. Stoner became engrossed with his work; he quickly forgot about the outside world, and refused to take part in the war effort. This is a feeling I know all too well. When one is completely engrossed in reading, obsessed even, it becomes difficult to pay attention to reality. If you’ve made it this far into my review, then I probably don’t need to tell you that. Stoner had what he needed: he had his books. But, life isn’t always that simple.

“He had come to that moment in his age when there occurred to him, with increasing intensity, a question of such overwhelming simplicity that he had no means to face it. He found himself wondering if his life were worth the living; if it had ever been.”

A profound question to ask oneself, and I truly think this helped to consolidate his decisions. Student life comes to an end for most folk. For Stoner there is no end. University is his home; it is his life; it is his passion and his drive: it is the one and only constant in his existence. So why would he ever leave it? Why would he ever give it up? The student becomes the teacher, and Stoner extends his stay for a lifetime. He has nothing else to cling to, only a love for his field of scholarship. I cannot quite express how much I sympathise with this character here. As a student of literature, and a huge hobby reader, sometimes there seems to be little else on the horizon but to peruse one’s passion. For Stoner though, his choice was the only one he could ever have made. His existence is only really for one purpose, and because of this he realised very early on his consequential fate.

“It’s like it just all goes around and around and keeps on going. It makes you wonder.”

As Stoner gets older his peers begin to die. In this he sees what awaits him; he has the stark realisation that he, too, will die. This may seem trivial and an obvious fact of life, though a realisation of such magnitude can really alter character. Stoner has a midlife crises; he has a glimpse of what his life could have been like had he married his soul mate: his love and intellectual equal. It is a shame for Stoner that such a thing came when he was already settled, but, again, that’s just life. This problematic relationship sets him even further on his course. I don’t need to tell you about the ending. It is an obvious conclusion for such a book, though I will say that its delivery was nothing short of perfection. Never before have I read a book in which the entire thing is embodied in its final few words. I’m amazed. I’m shaken. I’m stunned. I’m numb.

>Why you should read this: I don’t often go as far as to explicitly state something like this in a review. Reading is personal and subjective. My reviews are just my opinion; they may not be shared by others. With this, however, I would go as far to say that this should be read by every reader, every reader who has felt the sharp pangs that literature can evoke. Here is a man who is completely lost; here is a character that has nothing really to live for: here is a man who is lost in the words, and it’s his salvation. And this is his life story. This is not a simple novel. It is a bildungsroman that is tragic, emotive and even inspiring. This book opened my eyes to many things. I learnt a great deal about life and myself in the process. Trust me, fellow bibliophiles, go read it. This is something really special.

description

__________________________________

You can connect with me on social media via My Linktree.
__________________________________
397 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Stoner.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 16, 2016 – Shelved
Started Reading
March 1, 2016 – Shelved as: 5-star-reads
March 1, 2016 – Shelved as: favourites
March 1, 2016 – Finished Reading
March 12, 2016 – Shelved as: contemporary-lit

Comments Showing 1-48 of 48 (48 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Oh!!!! I'm looking forward to your review of this, Sean!! VERY MUCH!! I heard this was great! Happy reading, hope you have a good reading experience to share :)


Peter This is the next on the list after the poor Penguin Black Book hack of Dante's Circles of Hell. ENJOY.


Fabian  {Councillor} Fantastic, Sean! This may very well be my favorite book ever. There was so much insight, so many fascinating aspects to discover in this novel. I hope you like it as much as I (and a lot of others) did. :)


Sean Barrs Anne (Anneshka) wrote: "Oh!!!! I'm looking forward to your review of this, Sean!! VERY MUCH!! I heard this was great! Happy reading, hope you have a good reading experience to share :)"

Me too. I'm expecting a lot out of this, and I don't think I'll be dissapointed :)


Sean Barrs Peter wrote: "This is the next on the list after the poor Penguin Black Book hack of Dante's Circles of Hell. ENJOY."

I know the one you mean. It's a bad edition. It's a shame there's so many poor ones on there (imo). For every good one, there seems to be a bad. But, there are also a few amazing ones too!


Sean Barrs Councillor wrote: "Fantastic, Sean! This may very well be my favorite book ever. There was so much insight, so many fascinating aspects to discover in this novel. I hope you like it as much as I (and a lot of others)..."

That's high praise, indeed.

I think I'm going to like it. So far it's very inviting. I can see myself finishing it quite quickly, and then reading it again if I like it straight after! :)


Leonard Mokos Probably to be counted among the most marvelous things you're going to read in your life. Lolita. Growth of the Soil. Gatsby. Stoner. As close to flawless as it can get. When you're done, start again, it's like sensationally good chocolate cake, you get to the end and it isn't enough because you could never stop wanting more.


Sean Barrs Leonard wrote: "Probably to be counted among the most marvelous things you're going to read in your life. Lolita. Growth of the Soil. Gatsby. Stoner. As close to flawless as it can get. When you're done, start aga..."

High praise indeed!


Holly The simplicity of the book is just amazing, yet so evocative. A wonderful review!


message 10: by Brit (new) - added it

Brit Cheung Excellent review. I guess some books, some words have the magic power to mould people's personality and will permanently resonate with the heart.


message 11: by Mandy (new)

Mandy Great review!


Sean Barrs Holly wrote: "The simplicity of the book is just amazing, yet so evocative. A wonderful review!"

So true- thanks!


Sean Barrs Mandy wrote: "Great review!"

thanks :)


Sean Barrs Brit wrote: "Excellent review. I guess some books, some words have the magic power to mould people's personality and will permanently resonate with the heart."

Yep, most definetlely ;)

and thanks ;)


Joshie Thank you for the fantastic and informative review! Now I'm more than certain that I'll read this book as soon as possible.


message 16: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Wonderful review, Sean! I definitely want to read this. It sounds like a very affective story, a story that's relatable. I'm going to take your word for it and read this book :)


Sean Barrs Joshie wrote: "Thank you for the fantastic and informative review! Now I'm more than certain that I'll read this book as soon as possible."

Glad it helped. Anfd thanks :)


Sean Barrs Bookworm Sean wrote: "Joshie wrote: "Thank you for the fantastic and informative review! Now I'm more than certain that I'll read this book as soon as possible."

Glad it helped. Anfd thanks :)"


Thanks- it's so worth it. This book is wonderful. I feel like it was written for the readers; it's aimed at book nerds. And I love it.

I hope you like it too! ;)


Jenny (Reading Envy) I agree this is a novel everyone should read. I am so glad the person who recommended it to me did so, and I continue to press it into the hands of friends and strangers, especially since I work in academia.


Sean Barrs Jenny (Reading Envy) wrote: "I agree this is a novel everyone should read. I am so glad the person who recommended it to me did so, and I continue to press it into the hands of friends and strangers, especially since I work in..."

I think it would be a great book for those in a similar profession. It is a great book, I should recommend it to people too.


WarpDrive Beautiful review.


Sean Barrs Fortunr wrote: "Beautiful review."

thanks :)


message 23: by Karen (new)

Karen Looks like I shall be checking this out. Wonderful review as usual :)


message 24: by Florence Bernice (new)

Florence Bernice Ok Sean, we trust you. We'll read this.


message 25: by Bellaryn (new) - added it

Bellaryn wow


message 26: by Bellaryn (new) - added it

Bellaryn wow


message 27: by Bellaryn (new) - added it

Bellaryn you make me wanna read this book


This fish likes to read thanks Sean! will be reading this for sure in January.


message 29: by Heather (new) - added it

Heather Hopkins Great review. I will add it to my list.


Margaret I too loved this book, although I found it totally devastating. Stoner, although he does love literature deeply and with total honor, is hardly saved by his noble passion. He remains a stoic and passive bystander to all of life, his own and also the lives of those he loves. It's as if he leaves all love and power on the page; none of it seeps into the world through him. Young as you are, you are already a better lover of the word (and world) than Stoner ever was. Yet he captivates me still. Now that is great literature.


Sean Barrs Karen wrote: "Looks like I shall be checking this out. Wonderful review as usual :)"

thanks- hope you like it too! :)


Sean Barrs This fish likes to read wrote: "thanks Sean! will be reading this for sure in January. "

excellent!


Sean Barrs Margaret wrote: "I too loved this book, although I found it totally devastating. Stoner, although he does love literature deeply and with total honor, is hardly saved by his noble passion. He remains a stoic and pa..."

He is and he isn't. It's almost like literature is his anchor to himself. He never engages with anything or anyone, only books keep him ticking. But, as you say, that ticking is empty.


Cecily It was my best book of 2015! I love your review, and especially your heartfelt exhortation as to why everyone should read it.


John Anthony My favourite book of 2015 and more. Reading your review again Sean brought back so vividly and eloquently why. Thank you!


Sean Barrs Cecily wrote: "It was my best book of 2015! I love your review, and especially your heartfelt exhortation as to why everyone should read it."

It is a special book!


Girish It is my best book of 2017. It gave me goosebumps while reading your reasoning as to why anyone should read this novel.


Sean Barrs Girish wrote: "It is my best book of 2017. It gave me goosebumps while reading your reasoning as to why anyone should read this novel."

i need to read it again soon!


Ann (Inky Labyrinth) This is such a touching review.


Sean Barrs Ann (Little Bear) wrote: "This is such a touching review."

I’m just a sucker for characters who love to read as much as me; it’s why I like Matilda and The Book Thief so much. Stoner though, Stoner just gets it.


Ann (Inky Labyrinth) Bookdragon Sean wrote: "I’m just a sucker for characters who love to read as much as me; it’s why I like Matilda and The Book Thief so much. Stoner though, Stoner..."

Yes, me too! That's why I recently enjoyed Strange The Dreamer so much. When you have a character that doesn't just love to read as a quality, but an integral part of the story.


Jason This is my best book of 2017!
Absolutely fell for Stoner and his story, but especially the way in which it is told. Great review, Sean.


message 43: by Tuti (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tuti fantastic review! have just started reading stoner, looking forward to it


Sarah Brilliant review! My favourite read of 2018 so far.


Uzair Anwar Qureshi Saw it on Pewdiepies Book Review and now reading this review, Want to read list bruh. Thanks!


message 46: by Barb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Barb Thomas I LOVE the Vegetarian, just starting Stoner and hoping I love it just as much!


message 47: by Judy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Judy An excellent review!! A beautiful, important, and necessary book.


Siarl Well! I guess I should go on and read this book then. Wonderful review (as always).


back to top