Angela M is taking a break.'s Reviews > A Boy in Winter

A Boy in Winter by Rachel Seiffert
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4685500
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: netgalley-reviews


I held my breath at one point a little more than halfway through this short but extremely powerful story. I was stunned, perhaps expecting it, but not ready for it. Who could be, really ? Certainly not the crowd of Jews rounded up by the Nazis in this small town in Ukraine in 1941 as the German occupation begins. Everything that happens before this slowly leads up to it and everything after it is burdened by it. A few days in the lives of a few people, experiencing fear and confusion, the desire to survive, to save oneself and loved ones is seen through the eyes of a Jewish family, a farm girl, and a German engineer in charge of building roads.

I can't manage to find any other words besides heartbreaking, gut wrenching but there are touching moments and in some way it is also hopeful with the strength and determination, courage and defiance of Pohl, the engineer, Yasia, the farm girl and Yankel, the defiant young boy of the title. He refuses to let the Germans carry off his little brother - " ... no Germans must ever haul Momik. " I can't explain why I read so many holocaust stories. They are so hard to read but yet I am compelled because they are important.

I received an advanced copy of this book from Little Brown through NetGalley.
153 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Boy in Winter.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 11, 2017 – Shelved
May 11, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
June 26, 2017 – Started Reading
June 28, 2017 – Shelved as: netgalley-reviews
June 28, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 59 (59 new)


message 1: by Gemma (new)

Gemma Just seen this is no longer available on netgalley. Shame. Great review, Angela. I know what you mean about holocaust stories. It's like we need someone to explain how it happened but of course no one ever can.


Angela M is taking a break. Gemma, thanks . Yes too bad it's no longer available. I believe it was a "read now " title as Little Brown almost always declines me . Not just the why but I still think we need to be reminded.


Cathrine ☯️ You always tempt with 5 stars A but I have sworn off any more Holocaust stories. At least for several years.


message 4: by Angela M is taking a break. (last edited Jun 29, 2017 08:48PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Angela M is taking a break. Gemma, to illustrate my continued declines from Little Brown, I was just refused a title - oh well , lots to read anyway.


Angela M is taking a break. C, I know they are so hard to read but I am drawn and my heart is broken with every one but I can't help myself.


message 6: by JudiAnne (new) - added it

JudiAnne Angela , Your review is wonderful! I've also been trying to stay away from WWI books but this one I've got to read.


message 7: by Gemma (new)

Gemma I'm flabbergasted you get turned down by anyone, Angela. You write such brilliant reviews. It makes me feel a bit better at how often I get turned down though!


message 8: by Sharon (new) - added it

Sharon Metcalf Great, heartfelt review Angela. I'm trying to resist adding but I think your 5 stars have more power than I have strength to resist.


message 9: by ☮Karen (new) - added it

☮Karen Wonderful review. I'm going with Sharon and adding it.


message 10: by Kathleen (new) - added it

Kathleen Fabulous review, Angela. I'm going with Karen and Sharon and adding this book.


Angela M is taking a break. Judi , Sharon, Karen & Kathleen, thanks . A short but worthwhile read .


Angela M is taking a break. Gemma , you're so kind ! Thanks so much . There are several publishers that always reject me . They have policies on who they approve . Some want librarians, booksellers, bloggers . It only bothers me if it's an author I really like . Can't complain too much as I always have plenty to read . If it's something I really want , I can buy it or borrow it .


message 13: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Masterson This sounds like a must read! Great review, Angela!


Diane S ☔ Wonderful Angela. Your five star reviews are causing me to go and request even more books. Lol


B the BookAddict Angela, I feel the same about reading Holocaust stories. The best I can explain it is to say it is important to bear witness to this vile part of history in the hope that it never occurs again.


message 16: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline So beautiful and heartfelt, Angela, and I feel much like you do. I have to pace them out further, though - I am not as brave as you.


Angela M is taking a break. Jennifer , thanks. Really is .

Diane, thanks . Glad I could reciprocate- lol !

Bette, a good way to put it . Feel the same way .


Angela M is taking a break. Jaline , thank you . Sometimes I need to do that too . Difficult to read but so important.


message 19: by Cheri (new)

Cheri Lovely, heartfelt review, Angela, I've added this, but it will have to wait a bit!


message 20: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline Angela M wrote: "Jaline , thank you . Sometimes I need to do that too . Difficult to read but so important."

I absolutely agree, Angela, and your reviews are always so excellent, I'm sure it is helping to keep the focus and importance alive for others.


Angela M is taking a break. Jaline , thanks so much !


message 22: by Wendy (new)

Wendy Great review Angela!


message 23: by Dem (new) - rated it 3 stars

Dem Great review Angela.


message 24: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen Me too, Angela. There are so many same stories but always with heartbreaking differences that many can reflect something new in such a dark period in history. The courage and bravery so many showed during this time. Thanks for the add.


message 25: by Karen (new)

Karen Wonderful review as always Angela! Another add for me!


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Thanks for sharing this book with us, Angela, and for your beautiful, thoughtful review. I added it too!


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks , Cheri, Wendy , Dem , Jen , Karen and Jennifer- much appreciated!


message 28: by Melanie (new) - added it

Melanie I am going to add this Angela. Thanks for the great review!


message 29: by Carol (new) - added it

Carol I'm adding too. Great review Angela!


message 30: by Helen (new) - added it

Helen Excellent review Angela. I am planning to read this one now.


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks, Melanie, Carol and Helen .


message 32: by Tim (new) - added it

Tim Another very fine review, Angela. Added!


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks Tim . Short but powerful.


message 34: by Jeannie (new)

Jeannie Great review Angela.


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks , Jeannie.


message 36: by Mike (new) - added it

Mike "I was stunned, perhaps expecting it, but not ready for it."

I think that sums up the intrigue for me. Great review, Angela.


Angela M is taking a break. Mike , thanks very much .


message 38: by Deyanne (new)

Deyanne Heartfelt review. Like you, I keep reading holocaust because it is so critical but currently I have reached my saturation for awhile anyway. I acknowledge your fortitude.


Angela M is taking a break. Deyanne, thanks so much . I just am compelled to keep reading these stories,


message 40: by Deyanne (new)

Deyanne I did just pick up The Baker's Secret from the library. I say one thing and yet I, too, am drawn to this reprehensible time in history. It so tugs at all of my deepest emotions. In between, I do need some happy, however.


Angela M is taking a break. Deyanne, I agree . I need others books in between too . I haven't read that one yet but it's on my list .


message 42: by Dana (new)

Dana Touching review, Angela.


Angela M is taking a break. Dana, thanks. The book was also touching.


Fran (Not Receiving Notifications) Excellent review Angela.


message 45: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Terrific review Angela!


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks so much , Fran and Mary.


message 47: by Bianca (new)

Bianca Excellent story. I rarely read Holocaust stories, I find them heartwrenching, it takes me a while to recover.


Angela M is taking a break. Bianca, thanks . I find them heart wrenching as well but some of the stories are uplifting too , especially when focusing on the courage of people in the resistance.


message 49: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Excellent review, Angela!!


Angela M is taking a break. Deanna , thanks so much.


« previous 1
back to top