★ Larissa ~ book crusher ~'s Reviews > The Summer Garden

The Summer Garden by Paullina Simons
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5058045
ALL THE STARS.

So it´s been weeks since I finished The Summer Garden and I haven´t been been able to write this review at all. But why? You ask. What in the world is going on with you? This is your favorite romance of all time. After all, this is Shura we are talking about... Shura with the sled and the copy of Pushkin and Shura with the creme-brulee eyes and delicious tanned skin with that faint scent of nicotine in the morning after endless bouts of hot Lazarevo sex. Didn´t you love this book and rate it ALL THE STARS in the universe? What is wrong with you?

Well, this freaking trilogy is what is wrong with me. Shura wrecked me and now I can't recover. I have spent the last few weeks thinking about this book, getting my hands on as many WW2 wartime romance movies and shows as I can, scouring the internet for recommendations on what to read after this trilogy. And now I come here defeated, head down because, alas, seems like I'm screwed. I wish someone had warned me this series was going to ruin all other romance novels for me.

Like, for real people, who is going to compare to Alexander Barrington? Jamie Fraser you say. Read Outlander, you say. Well, I already read Outlander, Dragonfly in Amber and Voyager years ago and while I enjoyed them very much - Outlander is one of my favorite romance novels of all time after all - let's face it. It's no TBH. Fellow Alexander lovers will understand what I'm talking about. I want Shura in the tent and the cabin in Lazarevo levels of epic romance. That's what I want. I want Tatia with the Red Cross, in the wolves den of the Sachsenhausen Prison Camp trying to hide the emotions ravaging her insides levels of epic angst. I mean, if you don't have potato shelf levels of hotness, I don't know what to tell you.

So I'm going to turn this review, which let's face it, I'm doing an awful job of actually reviewing The Summer Garden, into a desperate plea for recommendations on what to do with my life reading-wise post TBH. I can't pay you, but you'll be doing the Lord's work. I've heard whispers of other books out there, like the Tea Rose series by Jennifer Donnely and The Pillars of the Earth by Ken Follet, or Florencia Bonelli's Year of Fire trilogy. I just don't know, guys. I kind of just want to go reread The Bronze Horseman. I already read From Sand and Ash earlier this year and although a worthy contender, TBH is still better.

Just a quick note regarding The Summer Garden because I will feel guilty if I don't actually touch upon the actual story. No, it did not ruin Alexander for me. Was I close to bitch-slapping the ever loving life out of him (virtually speaking) more than once in the book? Oh hell yes. Not so much for that thing with (view spoiler)

So no, it wasn't that particular issue that threatened to ruin my love for my Shura, but (view spoiler)

That ending did a number in my heart. Damn you, Paullina Simons. Oh, and there was a surprising amount of sex in this one. Guess who you'll find complaining? Yep, not me.

Also, I'm going to need a Napa-sized, brothel bed.

And just one more tidbit. It still surprises me how few people realize what The Bronze Horseman is really about. This book is really about Communism vs. the free world. Take Communist Russia out of it and you've got nothing.
28 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Summer Garden.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 25, 2017 – Started Reading
August 25, 2017 – Shelved
August 26, 2017 –
4.0% "My dear, Shura what is WRONG with you? My heart is breaking <3"
August 27, 2017 –
13.0%
August 27, 2017 –
19.0% "Oh. My. Word. I just melted into a puddle of goo."
September 1, 2017 –
45.0% "Me while reading this book and all that Alexander does or says
"
September 2, 2017 –
60.0% "What the ever loving fuck..."
September 6, 2017 – Finished Reading
September 23, 2017 – Shelved as: great-writing
September 23, 2017 – Shelved as: favorite-heroes
September 23, 2017 – Shelved as: favorites
September 23, 2017 – Shelved as: mind-fucked-into-next-tuesday
September 23, 2017 – Shelved as: sex-sex-sex
September 23, 2017 – Shelved as: total-page-turner

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

⊱✿⊰ Alicia ⊱✿⊰ Sounds good, enjoy Perry ❤ xo


★ Larissa ~ book crusher ~ Thanks, Alicia :) <3


message 3: by Dirty Dayna (new) - added it

Dirty Dayna omg this makes me happy. okay I will read book 3!! I was afraid it would ruin Shura for me!


★ Larissa ~ book crusher ~ Dirty Dayna wrote: "omg this makes me happy. okay I will read book 3!! I was afraid it would ruin Shura for me!"

I will be posting my review sometime today or tomorrow and it will address both the good and the bad. This book did have a strong negative reaction from a relatively small portion of the readership but from what I can see, most absolutely LOVED it, myself included! I hope you're in the latter camp.


Stephanie This one seems to divide TBH fans sometimes. I'm so glad you loved it! It's probably my favorite of the series


Penny Hope the book hangover isn't too bad now that you're done with all the TBH books!!! 💞 It's been almost two years (with countless books read since) and I STILL remember exactly where I was and what I was doing IRL when I was reading them. Simply the best. Also, I LOVED the third book... somehow it made their love even more relatable/believable that they had to navigate those tough patches and come out the other side. HEA books never show those rough spots and I loved that The Summer Garden did.

Can't wait for your review! I'd recommend NOT trying to immediately find a book that compares and instead either go re-read a fluffy/funny favorite or pick a totally different genre :) Like I said, you never forget where you were when you read TBH for the first time but it will ALWAYS be some of the best reading memories of your life! Truly the ultimate gift an author can give a reader.


★ Larissa ~ book crusher ~ Stephanie wrote: "This one seems to divide TBH fans sometimes. I'm so glad you loved it! It's probably my favorite of the series"

Thank you! I adored this trilogy and now can't seem to stop thinking about it. Ugh. I'm ruined.


★ Larissa ~ book crusher ~ Penny wrote: "Hope the book hangover isn't too bad now that you're done with all the TBH books!!! 💞 It's been almost two years (with countless books read since) and I STILL remember exactly where I was and what ..."

Oh my goodness, this is so spot on. I needed these words my friend. I just posted my full review and you'll see why. Thank you. Solid advice, because I'm beyond enthralled and still can't get over this MOTHER of all hangovers.


Stephanie Outlander is one of my favorite romance novels of all time after all - let's face it. It's no TBH. Fellow Alexander lovers will understand what I'm talking about.

ah yes. Outlander was recommended to me to help me out of my post-TBH funk. It helped, but it's no TBH. Jamie is no Shura. I'm sorry but it's true. I dearly love Outlander/Jamie but... this is simply untouchable.

I don't know if you've already read Six Days in Leningrad or Tatiana's Table, but they're a huge help in this recovery process haha.

All I want now in life is an Anthony book!


message 10: by Mimi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mimi This is the best review I’ve ever read about this series. I feel the same way about all of it - and I was pleasantly surprised, in particular, to read your last point. I have an MA in political science and I found myself deeply enjoying, and reflection on, the political aspects of the trilogy which I’ve never seen anyone comment on, other than you. Please add me as a friend - would love to connect and read your other reviews. -Mimi 🖤


back to top