Sarah's Reviews > The Hidden Flame
The Hidden Flame (Acts of Faith, #2)
by
by
Sarah's review
bookshelves: adult, all-ages-admitted, all-that-buildup-for-nothing, bible-times, beware-of-love-square, beware-of-marty-stu, beware-of-mary-sue, christianity, historical-fiction, ancient-history, a-failed-romance, as-it-began, greece-and-rome, because-marriage, but-the-cover-was-pretty, dark-haired-female-entity, faux-realism, good-idea-gets-lost, heartthrobs-and-heroes, how-do-i-even-rate-this, jewish-history, innocence-is-drowned, imported-from-canada, let-s-talk-about-trauma, nice-jewish-kids, nice-pagan-kids, on-what-planet-does-this-happen, pass-me-that-sequel, pretty-blue-cover, pretty-white-cover, sophomore-slump, super-siblings, the-tepidarium
Mar 11, 2018
bookshelves: adult, all-ages-admitted, all-that-buildup-for-nothing, bible-times, beware-of-love-square, beware-of-marty-stu, beware-of-mary-sue, christianity, historical-fiction, ancient-history, a-failed-romance, as-it-began, greece-and-rome, because-marriage, but-the-cover-was-pretty, dark-haired-female-entity, faux-realism, good-idea-gets-lost, heartthrobs-and-heroes, how-do-i-even-rate-this, jewish-history, innocence-is-drowned, imported-from-canada, let-s-talk-about-trauma, nice-jewish-kids, nice-pagan-kids, on-what-planet-does-this-happen, pass-me-that-sequel, pretty-blue-cover, pretty-white-cover, sophomore-slump, super-siblings, the-tepidarium
The adventures of the very first Christians continue in the second book of T. Davis Bunn and Janette Oke's Acts of Faith trilogy.
Alban and Leah, the titular centurion and wife from the previous installment, have fled Jerusalem and the wrath of both Pilate and Herod. But the action remains in the holy city, witnessed by Leah's best friend Abigail, Alban's army buddy Linux, and Ezra, a Pharisee whose generalized contempt for the nascent Church is about to get really personal.
Abigail is a cheery lass with a servant's heart, and considered a great beauty despite a slight limp (which would have discouraged most suitors in those days). All she wants to do is spread the Gospel and take care of her younger brother, Jacob, now a strapping and sulky teenager whose only interest in life is joining the Roman legionnaires. But Abigail, without being particularly aware of either man's existence, attracts both the lust of the bitter Ezra, and the earnest passion of hot-blooded Linux. Once she becomes aware of the intentions of the two rivals, she quickly dismisses the possibility of marrying the old Pharisee, but the handsome Roman with the piercing gaze spooks her on a level she does not yet understand.
Things are going to get better, but they're going to get very silly first.
In a good classic romance - in the tradition of L.M. Montgomery, etc. - the young lady who does not wish to marry would accordingly be left alone, and perhaps reevaluate when the better of the two suitors steps forward at the crisis point and proves himself a hero. Meanwhile we could get character development and other goodies.
But no, someone has to step in because Abigail cannot be allowed to make her own decisions. And by "someone" I mean Simon Peter, The Big Fisherman himself. You'd think he'd have better things to do with his time, being the head of the Church appointed by Christ Himself and all that, and you would be right.
Especially since the early Christians weren't big on arranging marriages. They believed that Jesus was liable to return and establish the Kingdom in Earth literally any day now, which would entail a certain amount of temporary chaos. "When you see The disastrous abomination set up where it ought not to be..." He had told them before His execution, "those in Judaea must escape to the mountains; if a man is on the housetop, he must not...go into the house to collect any of his belongings; if a man is in the fields, he must not turn back to fetch his cloak. Alas for those with child, or with babies at the breast, when those days come!" (Mark 13:14-18). Not a good environment to start a family in; in fact Jesus seems to be strongly encouraging His listeners not to do so.
In fact, perusing the stories of the ancient martyrs, it appears that many young women joined the Christians partly to escape arranged marriages.
So if Peter were to step in at all, it would be to tell both Ezra and Linux to kindly back off. But nope, he decides for Abigail that she should marry neither of them, but instead an outspoken young believer named Stephen. As if on cue, Abigail abandons her plan to be a consecrated virgin and starts swooning over Stephen because he's so godly and non-problematic. Unlike Linux, who makes her stomach feel weird and might have cooties.
The real St. Stephen was 100% consumed with zeal for evangelization and probably had even less interest in marriage than his fellow Way followers. He could have been married before his conversion, but after? Yeah, not likely. Assuming that this far-fetched thing would happen, he and his wife would probably wind up living as siblings, marriage unconsummated. In fact, that's what I thought happened, until (view spoiler)
While all this anachronistic nonsense goes down in the Christian neighborhood, Linux's army assignments send him across the province. He's in a fine temper, having found out that Abigail has been married off to someone else, and he's also grappling with the drastic changes in his old friend Alban. We get some good character development from him, as he confronts his anger against the world and eventually decides to follow Jesus.
Then Linux returns to Jerusalem and asks Peter to catechize him. Who does Peter assign this task to but Stephen, because that's not rubbing salt in Linux's sounds at all. Seriously, why would you do this?!? You want to make converts, not drive them away! And Linux, being a much better human being than any of the other characters give him credit for, actually comes to admire Stephen, despite this universe's Stephen being kind of smarmy.
The other Scriptural saints don't fare much better. Peter is largely bereft of personality, and as previously discussed, most of his actions are far out of character and unlikely in historical context. Mary Magdalene has vanished from the story. Mary, Mother of Jesus, and John the Beloved aren't even mentioned. Saul of Tarsus is a generic menace who only appears in a few scenes despite being responsible for the most important event in the story.
The one exception is Martha of Bethany, here portrayed as a Marilla Cuthbert-like character who keeps the congregation alive, being the only person who remembers that they still need to eat.The authors seem genuinely fond of her, and it was nice to see this unglamorous Biblical figure get some attention for once.
Unfortunately, the most pivotal events in the book - the deaths of Ananias and Sapphira, the gladiator combat witnessed by Jacob, and the martyrdom of Stephen - are left entirely on-screen (off-page?). The scenes don't need to be gory, although the graphic portrayal of Stephen's death in Taylor Caldwell's Great Lion of God left an indelible mark on my imagination. But there's really no good reason to exclude them from the novel.
No content advisory needed.
Up next: The Damascus Way .
Alban and Leah, the titular centurion and wife from the previous installment, have fled Jerusalem and the wrath of both Pilate and Herod. But the action remains in the holy city, witnessed by Leah's best friend Abigail, Alban's army buddy Linux, and Ezra, a Pharisee whose generalized contempt for the nascent Church is about to get really personal.
Abigail is a cheery lass with a servant's heart, and considered a great beauty despite a slight limp (which would have discouraged most suitors in those days). All she wants to do is spread the Gospel and take care of her younger brother, Jacob, now a strapping and sulky teenager whose only interest in life is joining the Roman legionnaires. But Abigail, without being particularly aware of either man's existence, attracts both the lust of the bitter Ezra, and the earnest passion of hot-blooded Linux. Once she becomes aware of the intentions of the two rivals, she quickly dismisses the possibility of marrying the old Pharisee, but the handsome Roman with the piercing gaze spooks her on a level she does not yet understand.
Things are going to get better, but they're going to get very silly first.
In a good classic romance - in the tradition of L.M. Montgomery, etc. - the young lady who does not wish to marry would accordingly be left alone, and perhaps reevaluate when the better of the two suitors steps forward at the crisis point and proves himself a hero. Meanwhile we could get character development and other goodies.
But no, someone has to step in because Abigail cannot be allowed to make her own decisions. And by "someone" I mean Simon Peter, The Big Fisherman himself. You'd think he'd have better things to do with his time, being the head of the Church appointed by Christ Himself and all that, and you would be right.
Especially since the early Christians weren't big on arranging marriages. They believed that Jesus was liable to return and establish the Kingdom in Earth literally any day now, which would entail a certain amount of temporary chaos. "When you see The disastrous abomination set up where it ought not to be..." He had told them before His execution, "those in Judaea must escape to the mountains; if a man is on the housetop, he must not...go into the house to collect any of his belongings; if a man is in the fields, he must not turn back to fetch his cloak. Alas for those with child, or with babies at the breast, when those days come!" (Mark 13:14-18). Not a good environment to start a family in; in fact Jesus seems to be strongly encouraging His listeners not to do so.
In fact, perusing the stories of the ancient martyrs, it appears that many young women joined the Christians partly to escape arranged marriages.
So if Peter were to step in at all, it would be to tell both Ezra and Linux to kindly back off. But nope, he decides for Abigail that she should marry neither of them, but instead an outspoken young believer named Stephen. As if on cue, Abigail abandons her plan to be a consecrated virgin and starts swooning over Stephen because he's so godly and non-problematic. Unlike Linux, who makes her stomach feel weird and might have cooties.
The real St. Stephen was 100% consumed with zeal for evangelization and probably had even less interest in marriage than his fellow Way followers. He could have been married before his conversion, but after? Yeah, not likely. Assuming that this far-fetched thing would happen, he and his wife would probably wind up living as siblings, marriage unconsummated. In fact, that's what I thought happened, until (view spoiler)
While all this anachronistic nonsense goes down in the Christian neighborhood, Linux's army assignments send him across the province. He's in a fine temper, having found out that Abigail has been married off to someone else, and he's also grappling with the drastic changes in his old friend Alban. We get some good character development from him, as he confronts his anger against the world and eventually decides to follow Jesus.
Then Linux returns to Jerusalem and asks Peter to catechize him. Who does Peter assign this task to but Stephen, because that's not rubbing salt in Linux's sounds at all. Seriously, why would you do this?!? You want to make converts, not drive them away! And Linux, being a much better human being than any of the other characters give him credit for, actually comes to admire Stephen, despite this universe's Stephen being kind of smarmy.
The other Scriptural saints don't fare much better. Peter is largely bereft of personality, and as previously discussed, most of his actions are far out of character and unlikely in historical context. Mary Magdalene has vanished from the story. Mary, Mother of Jesus, and John the Beloved aren't even mentioned. Saul of Tarsus is a generic menace who only appears in a few scenes despite being responsible for the most important event in the story.
The one exception is Martha of Bethany, here portrayed as a Marilla Cuthbert-like character who keeps the congregation alive, being the only person who remembers that they still need to eat.The authors seem genuinely fond of her, and it was nice to see this unglamorous Biblical figure get some attention for once.
Unfortunately, the most pivotal events in the book - the deaths of Ananias and Sapphira, the gladiator combat witnessed by Jacob, and the martyrdom of Stephen - are left entirely on-screen (off-page?). The scenes don't need to be gory, although the graphic portrayal of Stephen's death in Taylor Caldwell's Great Lion of God left an indelible mark on my imagination. But there's really no good reason to exclude them from the novel.
No content advisory needed.
Up next: The Damascus Way .
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Hidden Flame.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 5, 2018
–
Started Reading
March 11, 2018
– Shelved
March 21, 2018
–
Finished Reading
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
adult
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
all-ages-admitted
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
all-that-buildup-for-nothing
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
bible-times
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
beware-of-love-square
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
beware-of-marty-stu
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
beware-of-mary-sue
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
historical-fiction
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
christianity
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
ancient-history
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
a-failed-romance
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
as-it-began
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
greece-and-rome
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
because-marriage
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
but-the-cover-was-pretty
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
dark-haired-female-entity
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
faux-realism
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
good-idea-gets-lost
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
heartthrobs-and-heroes
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
imported-from-canada
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
innocence-is-drowned
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
jewish-history
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
how-do-i-even-rate-this
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
let-s-talk-about-trauma
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
nice-pagan-kids
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
nice-jewish-kids
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
on-what-planet-does-this-happen
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
pass-me-that-sequel
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
pretty-blue-cover
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
pretty-white-cover
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
sophomore-slump
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
super-siblings
April 23, 2018
– Shelved as:
the-tepidarium
Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Hannah
(new)
Apr 23, 2018 07:01PM
reply
|
flag
Agreed, Hannah! They're pretty hit-or-miss :-(
I remember enjoying that show and wishing they hadn't cancelled it. There were so many great stories left to tell!
Agreed 100%, Katie! The whole plotline was so anachronistic and generally aggravating. The child of that union is a little kid in the third book, and there is NO narrative reason that she has to be Stephen's offspring - it would have been much better if she were adopted by Abigail.
I know that some modern Evangelicals find celibacy creepy and "too Catholic" but it was not a denominational thing in the early years of the Church. The authors sacrificed fidelity to the source material in favor of "not triggering the fanbase" I guess. That never works.
*stands up and applauds* Thank you, Hannah! I wasn't trying to generalize about Evangelicals, who are a very diverse group...I was thinking here of the congregations where I grew up, who did profess those opinions. I certainly didn't mean that as a sweeping generalization of such a large and varied branch of Christians. As you astutely pointed out, Paul is quite clear that not every believer is meant to marry.
And agreed about forcing an established Biblical character into a fanfiction-like pairing in the manner of this book. Not cool.
I have definitely run across those sorts...and had a discussion with one a few weeks ago. Paul's discussion can often be swept under the rug by people who are uncomfortable with it.
That's very disappointing to me that they did that, but also very good timing for me to find out about it because I was literally thinking just yesterday that I wanted to get this book on audio when my new Audible credits come in next month. I'm sad that this series isn't one I'll want to finish, but thank you, Sarah, for writing this review and saving me several hours of listening.
You're welcome, E.F.B., and thank you so much for such a kind comment! The third book was an improvement on this one, but the Stephen subplot still dragged it down.
Have you read The Robe ? That's a Biblical novel that does a much better job separating the fictional part from the Scripture, and stays truer to the mindset of the era.
@Sarah and Hannah--yes! St. Paul is very clear about SOME ministers of the Gospel, at least, being called by God to celibacy/singleness; and it's not right for this author to retroactively assume that Stephen wasn't called to celibacy. Especially when the Bible seems to indicate that's how he lived.
I haven't read The Robe, but I'll definitely add it to my list now. Thanks for the recommendation. :)
Great question, J - I hadn't even thought of this! After several internet searches, I could not find record of a single ancient Roman (or Greek) who spelled his name Linux. That spelling appears to have originated with the operating system. In fact, there were barely any Linuses with the standard spelling!
Linus was the name of two rather unfortunate mythological characters, one struck down by Apollo for his hubris, the other a tutor of Hercules whom the latter accidentally killed during a tantrum. I think the authors might have somehow confused Linus with Pollux, who along with his twin brother Castor was a popular deity among Roman soldiers, and might have had more guys named after him.
Interestingly, one of the few historical Linuses was a friend of St. Paul's who was in Rome at the time of the Apostle's execution. He's mentioned in the fourth chapter of 2 Timothy. This Linus is listed as the second Bishop of Rome/Pope and immediate successor of Peter. Is the character meant to be him? This book just got even stranger...
Sources:
https://www.biblestudytools.com/dicti...
http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12272...
https://www.christian-history.org/lis...
I haven't read The Robe, but I'll..."
I think you could skip this one. Really the only thing that's changed is that Jacob is now a young man and no longer wants to be a legionnaire. Also Linux loves Abigail, and she is now raising a cute little girl named Dorcas. Dorcas has no real shared traits with St. Stephen and could easily have been a) Abigail's daughter by a fictional late husband or b) an adopted orphan.
I hope you enjoy The Robe!
Great question, J - I hadn't even thought of this! After several internet ..."
Oh, wow. That's even more weird—I agree.