Lisa's Reviews > The Overstory

The Overstory by Richard Powers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: pulitzer, favorites, persuasive, so-good-it-hurts

To hope, which finds roots in the most infertile of soils! Cheers, my friends on our shared planet!

I sit in silence, holding the paperback copy of The Overstory in my hands, thinking of trees.

Wondering which trees grew to become the books on my shelves. Wondering which ones became the cherry tree desk my grandfather made for me. Wondering how old the oak trees were that turned into the logs that made it into my wooden house, to turn into beloved bookshelves. I wonder at the kind of trees that frame my paintings. That give my brushes shape. I even have jewellery made of wood. And Swedish butter knives. And art.

My fence is made of wood, and my garden holds an oak tree, an acorn, three apple trees, plum trees, three cherry trees (plus a baby cherry trying to make it), AND my garden holds a three-year-old chestnut experiment.

My daughter and I collected chestnuts one autumn and put some of them into a corner of our garden. The following year, we saw a few single sticks with a leaf each coming out of the soil.

Then we had five or six leaves on each of the three tiny chestnut trees - growing in slow motion (human time perception). This year, I have already checked that they are still alive, and I can see there will be more leaves. Will they survive?

I don't know, but I took a picture, imagining while I did so that I was Nick, owner of a family's collected photographic memory of a chestnut tree planted where they usually do not grow. And I felt it made such perfect sense - my tiny gardening project connected to my vast reading life, growing side by side as long as I am around to think and feel.

"What do stories do?" This is what one character asks at a crossroads. "They kill us a bit and make us change."

And that is precisely what happened to me while I read The Overstory. Filled with the pain of the world's development in recent decades, I had grown ready for this book. I would not have had patience ten years ago to follow from roots over trunk to canopy and seeds the stories of people who see what others choose to ignore: that humanity is using up the resources of its own habitat at a speed that nature can't cope with, and that we are unlikely to stop the trend because stopping it means destroying our most cherished religion: the belief in growth and ownership. "We're cashing in a billion years of planetary savings bonds and blowing it on assorted bling".

What to do if we see this happening, and if we don't want to see the world change from diversity to monoculture, from natural life to surviving in an adverse and hostile habitat? I am as guilty of what the psychologist character in the book calls the bystander effect as anyone else. I know we must change our ways to make our planet a sustainable home, but I am unable to break the patterns I was raised and taught to take for granted. Reducing meat intake and plane rides is not enough. We must learn to think beyond commercial benefit and growth of assets if we want to have a future that can remember us.

This book is amazing, like a Tree Of Life! It grew out of the need to verbalise the imminent threat to our species and its unique ability to LOVE nature in all its forms.

Read it. Pulitzer redeemed for as long as it takes a tree to grow!
1810 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Overstory.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 19, 2019 – Started Reading
April 19, 2019 – Shelved
April 19, 2019 – Shelved as: pulitzer
April 19, 2019 –
page 102
16.32% "So far I love it, and it makes me suspicious. It's a Pulitzer, after all, and they usually need brutal editing, and there are 500+ pages left."
May 5, 2019 – Finished Reading
August 6, 2019 – Shelved as: favorites
August 6, 2019 – Shelved as: persuasive
August 6, 2019 – Shelved as: so-good-it-hurts

Comments Showing 1-50 of 175 (175 new)


message 1: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline Wow. This quote you included: "We're cashing in a billion years of planetary savings bonds and blowing it on assorted bling". This stopped me in my tracks. It is so concise and precisely what we have been doing. What a fabulous and inspiring review, Lisa! (And I am so happy that I finally received one of your reviews on my feed again!! :)


Lisa Jaline wrote: "Wow. This quote you included: "We're cashing in a billion years of planetary savings bonds and blowing it on assorted bling". This stopped me in my tracks. It is so concise and precisely what we ha..."

Goodreads hasn'tbeen too kind with my feed either, Jaline! Plenty of my oldest GR friends' reviews are hidden from me and I have to actively look up the profile to see them. I don't know what to do about it. Have tried all kinds of settings but it seems we are part of a big censorship scheme :-/


Lisa (NY) Lisa, wonderful review!


Barbara Great review, Lisa. This is coming up soon on my TBR list.


Lisa Lisa wrote: "Lisa, wonderful review!"

Thanks!


Lisa Barbara wrote: "Great review, Lisa. This is coming up soon on my TBR list."

Enjoy, Barbara!


Julie So there's a Booker finally worth reading, Lisa? ... ooops, sorry, it didn't win, it was only a nominee, so therefore MUST be worth reading. : )

Thanks for this thoughtful review. Am adding it now.

But as an aside, I'm wondering when will we (as a species) stop writing stories, stop singing songs, and just start doing something?

Even in the last couple of generations, Neil Young was singing about mother nature being on the run in the 1970s ... and Joni Mitchell was warning us about parking lots in paradise.

And yet, here we are with mother nature at a full gallop, and hardly any more space for parking lots, because they're already 3-deep and 7 stories high.

But, like you, I continue to plant my trees, and continue despite the odds being against us, now, in these last few seconds before midnight.


message 8: by bajwa (new) - added it

bajwa Heartwarming review. I read The Sixth Extinction a while ago which had the same sort of theme and it was shocking to learn how we are destroying the ecological system of the planet. I guess trees form up a huge part of this natural system. Will be reading this one soon


Barbara Julie wrote: "So there's a Booker finally worth reading, Lisa? ... ooops, sorry, it didn't win, it was only a nominee, so therefore MUST be worth reading. : )

Thanks for this thoughtful review. Am adding it no..."


I so agree.


message 10: by Nocturnalux (new) - added it

Nocturnalux Wonderful review that puts things into perspective.

I remember getting into one of many arguments in Catholic school over trees, of all things. The nun claimed that everything was made for us: cows were created so we could eat them, trees were created so we could cut them down and then use...and at this point I interrupted to point out that the purpose of a tree is to be a tree and that cows are meant to be cows first and foremost.

It ended badly for me, this exchange did, but it is always very heartening to see how one's immature intuitions are, on occasion, very much true.


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Julie wrote: "So there's a Booker finally worth reading, Lisa? ... ooops, sorry, it didn't win, it was only a nominee, so therefore MUST be worth reading. : )

Thanks for this thoughtful review. Am adding it no..."


I know, Julie! It is not enough, and sometimes I curse the fact that deciding to be informed about things actually makes me more responsible for my action than those deliberate ignorants who rule the world on testosterone exclusivity and think that the deluge is an adequate last act in their glorious ego show. No names needed, as it would look like the long acknowledgement list at the end of an apocalypse movie: united in destruction!


message 12: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Nocturnalux wrote: "Wonderful review that puts things into perspective.

I remember getting into one of many arguments in Catholic school over trees, of all things. The nun claimed that everything was made for us: cow..."


Honestly: Catholicism sometimes feels like a reverse Genesis: let's just destroy body and soul of the world and pretend that is God's will. And God created mankind, and he saw that it was rubbish, so he created Catholicism to explain the rubbish to the crowds coming to the vernissage?


message 13: by Karen· (new) - added it

Karen· On my pile. Coming soon.


message 14: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa M wrote: "Heartwarming review. I read The Sixth Extinction a while ago which had the same sort of theme and it was shocking to learn how we are destroying the ecological system of the planet. I guess trees f..."

I have The 6th Extinction on my table. Will read it soon, although it scares me!


message 15: by bajwa (new) - added it

bajwa Lisa wrote: "M wrote: "Heartwarming review. I read The Sixth Extinction a while ago which had the same sort of theme and it was shocking to learn how we are destroying the ecological system of the planet. I gue..."

Your intuition is right. It is a scary book but very well written and knowledgeable. We cannot correct ourselves unless we know what we are doing wrong and are ready to face bitter realities. My favorite part in the book was Intro...


message 16: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa M wrote: "Lisa wrote: "M wrote: "Heartwarming review. I read The Sixth Extinction a while ago which had the same sort of theme and it was shocking to learn how we are destroying the ecological system of the ..."

Yes, you definitely convince me it is time to face the fear... the fear derives from instinctively knowing I guess. Bumping it up to the top of the pile.


message 17: by bajwa (new) - added it

bajwa Haha. Good to know and hope you enjoy it. Good luck with facing the fear


message 18: by Rick (new)

Rick "humanity is using up the resources of its own habitat at a speed that nature can't cope with, and that we are unlikely to stop the trend because stopping it means destroying our most cherished religion: the belief in growth and ownership"

This is my favourite quote of a Goodreads review in years. *Phenomenal* review!


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Rick wrote: ""humanity is using up the resources of its own habitat at a speed that nature can't cope with, and that we are unlikely to stop the trend because stopping it means destroying our most cherished rel..."

Thank you, Rick! The book really got under my skin.


message 20: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala The Pulitzer redeemed? This must be some book! I'm convinced.


message 21: by Nick (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nick Great review.


message 22: by Deea (new) - rated it 2 stars

Deea Wonderful, wonderful review.


message 23: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Fionnuala wrote: "The Pulitzer redeemed? This must be some book! I'm convinced."

Yes, I know! First a lovely pink Booker, now a green Pulitzer. Maybe good literature feeds off the bad news in the world?


message 24: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa ·Karen· wrote: "On my pile. Coming soon."

Enjoy!


message 25: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Nick wrote: "Great review."

Thank you!


message 26: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Deea wrote: "Wonderful, wonderful review."

Thanks!


message 27: by Ilse (new)

Ilse A book like a Tree of Life, wonderful image, Lisa. Powerful review!


message 28: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Ilse wrote: "A book like a Tree of Life, wonderful image, Lisa. Powerful review!"

Thanks, Ilse!


Katalin I absolutely loved this book. It is truly one of my favorite ever!


message 30: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Katalin wrote: "I absolutely loved this book. It is truly one of my favorite ever!"

I agree, Katalin!


message 31: by Tuti (new)

Tuti wonderful!


message 32: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Tuti wrote: "wonderful!"

Thanks!


Ralph Smith Lisa this is one of the most moving and poetic reviews I have ever read. The book deserves it.


message 34: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Ralph F. Smith wrote: "Lisa this is one of the most moving and poetic reviews I have ever read. The book deserves it."

Thank you, Ralph!


message 35: by Pradnya (new) - added it

Pradnya I read a few very unique thoughts here, depressing yet elegantly put forward. Yes, few of us understand and don't understand what can be done apart from being a bystander. Well-penned review, Lisa! :)


message 36: by Forrest (new)

Forrest This sounds amazing. Thanks for the thoughtful review - it's great!


message 37: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Pradnya wrote: "I read a few very unique thoughts here, depressing yet elegantly put forward. Yes, few of us understand and don't understand what can be done apart from being a bystander. Well-penned review, Lisa! :)"

Thanks, Pradnya!


message 38: by Fran (new)

Fran Lisa...what an excellent, well written review. Bravo!


message 39: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Forrest wrote: "This sounds amazing. Thanks for the thoughtful review - it's great!"

Thanks :-)


message 40: by Stephen (new) - added it

Stephen Lee I enjoyed reading your review. I add the book to my read list.


message 41: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Fran wrote: "Lisa...what an excellent, well written review. Bravo!"

Thanks, Fran!


message 42: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline Lisa wrote: "Goodreads hasn'tbeen too kind with my feed either, Jaline! Plenty of my oldest GR friends' reviews are hidden from me and I have to actively look up the profile to see them. I don't know what to do about it. Have tried all kinds of settings but it seems we are part of a big censorship scheme :-/"

Lisa, I have written to GR Help explaining this problem and claiming that many of my book Friends are experiencing the same. However, I think that if more people reported this problem, it might take a higher priority in programming.

Just as you are experiencing, it is about 200+ of my oldest friends whose reviews have vanished from my feed. For quite a while I was going to each person's individual Profile page to find their reviews but that became a full-time job and I just couldn't do it any more.

I suggested that they (GR) program it so that once I have "liked" and commented on a review, it is dropped from my feed and another rolls in to take its place. However, I do suspect that before the programmers will even look at the problem, more people need to speak up.

I think there is a "help" button on the front page where people can notify GR of the problem.

I'm so sad about this because I am missing so much that half the fun is gone as a result.


message 43: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Jaline wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Goodreads hasn'tbeen too kind with my feed either, Jaline! Plenty of my oldest GR friends' reviews are hidden from me and I have to actively look up the profile to see them. I don't kn..."

I couldn't agree more, Jaline, and I will follow your lead here! Thanks for motivating me. After all, the communication with friends is all that GR is about.


message 44: by Cecily (new)

Cecily Lovely review. Especially:

"What do stories do?" This is what one character asks at a crossroads. "They kill us a bit and make us change."


message 45: by Agnieszka (new) - added it

Agnieszka I liked the sound of it, Lisa. Superb review!


message 46: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Stephen wrote: "I enjoyed reading your review. I add the book to my read list."

Thanks, Stephen!


message 47: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Cecily wrote: "Lovely review. Especially:

"What do stories do?" This is what one character asks at a crossroads. "They kill us a bit and make us change.""


Yes, I loved that part of the story so much!


message 48: by Claire (new) - added it

Claire Beautiful review!


message 49: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Agnieszka wrote: "I liked the sound of it, Lisa. Superb review!"

Thanks, Agnieszka!


message 50: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Claire wrote: "Beautiful review!"

Thanks, Claire!


« previous 1 3 4
back to top