Diane Barnes's Reviews > The Overstory

The Overstory by Richard Powers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7262060
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: noble-bitches-book-club, favorites

This is quite possibly the most amazing thing I've ever read. It's brilliant, passionate, terrifying and painful. It's too long, it's difficult to read, there are too many characters to follow....and yet, those characters are all of us, at some point in our lives. Let's just say this is The War and Peace of nature.
The novel begins with the story of a chestnut tree in Iowa. It escaped the east coast chestnut blight by virtue of having been brought west in the pocket of a Swedish emigrant. If you can read this beginning chapter without emotion, you're a harder person than I am. Each succeeding chapter is about a person or persons whose lives were changed by a tree, until the book branches off into their efforts to save the Redwoods in California and Oregon. The preceding sentence is a simplistic effort on my part to explain the plot. In reality, this novel can't be explained because it contains worlds, and the creation and destruction of worlds, battles between environmentalists and scientists who see what's happening, and corporations and lawyers who don't care as long as there's one more cent of profit to be made.

This particular novel is about trees and forests, but the same thing is happening to our oceans and rivers and coastlines. Build more houses and condos and roads, allow offshore drilling for oil, because there are more and more of us, and we all need more and more stuff.
If you can read to the end of this novel without fear of what we have done to this earth, and what is yet to come, then you didn't pay attention. The saddest thing of all is that the ones who need the message the most will never read this book, and wouldn't understand it if they did. I don't know how to fix that. Maybe the National Book Award and the Pulitzer Prize will get more readers for The Overstory. Maybe teachers can make it required school reading. Maybe it's too late.............
199 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Overstory.
Sign In »

Quotes Diane Liked

Richard Powers
“What conveys a right, and why should humans, alone on all the planet, have them?”
Richard Powers, The Overstory

Richard Powers
“Love for trees pours out of her—the grace of them, their supple experimentation, the constant variety and surprise. These slow, deliberate creatures with their elaborate vocabularies, each distinctive, shaping each other, breeding birds, sinking carbon, purifying water, filtering poisons from the ground, stabilizing the micro-climate. Join enough living things together, through the air and underground, and you wind up with something that has intentions.”
Richard Powers, The Overstory


Reading Progress

June 7, 2019 – Started Reading
June 7, 2019 – Shelved
June 7, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
June 7, 2019 – Shelved as: noble-bitches-book-club
June 13, 2019 – Shelved as: favorites
June 13, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 59 (59 new)


message 1: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura Great review. I might feel like a lesser reader if I try this book and I don’t like it. But then I might feel like a lesser person if I don’t try at all. It’s downloaded but I think the timing must be right. Again, super review D.


message 2: by Cynthia (new) - added it

Cynthia Dunn Wow! What a review! I'm reading War and Peace right now. Do I dare?


Diane Barnes Laura, if you try this one, pick a down time when you can give it your full attention. You're not a lesser reader if you don't like it.


Diane Barnes Cynthia, If you're reading War and Peace right now, you may need to give your brain a long rest before picking this one up. A lot of details to contend with.


Dianne Terrific review, Diane!


message 6: by Jenna (new)

Jenna ❤ ❀  ❤ What a glowing review and wonderful endorsement for this novel!


message 7: by Cynthia (new) - added it

Cynthia Dunn Diane wrote: "Cynthia, If you're reading War and Peace right now, you may need to give your brain a long rest before picking this one up. A lot of details to contend with."

Okay. You make it sound wonderful.


Cathrine ☯️ 😢 😫 😭 . . . do you think I can get through the book when I could hardly get through your review.


Diane Barnes Thanks, Dianne and Jenna. It's quite a book.


Diane Barnes Cathrine, I'm not an activist or a botanist or a scientist, but those professions get more respect from me than politicians and lawyers. Murdering nature is wrong, and we're all going to pay the price eventually. And now I'll step down off my soapbox.


CindySR "Let's just say this is The War and Peace of nature."
Great way to put it!


message 12: by Wyndy (new)

Wyndy This might be your most passionate review ever. And your first sentence says it all -especially coming from you, one of the most avid readers I know. I hope to tackle this one sometime this summer.


Diane Barnes Thanks Wyndy. Not the kind of passion that would make me sit in a tree for 10 months to prevent its cutting, but book passion I can do. Tell Gil sorry about the lawyer comment....I don't really think of him as one 😂😬😂


Carmel Hanes It was a very unique read, wasn't it? I enjoyed it, too, for the most part. Loved his writing skills and loved that trees were characters. It did get overly long, but much of it was a delight to read. Thanks for sharing your own terrific thoughts on an unusual book!


message 15: by Wyndy (new)

Wyndy Diane wrote: "Thanks Wyndy. Not the kind of passion that would make me sit in a tree for 10 months to prevent its cutting, but book passion I can do. Tell Gil sorry about the lawyer comment....I don't really thi..."

😂


Diane Barnes It was a bit too long, but I'm not sure what he could have cut out without losing something.


Barbara Can't wait to read this!


message 18: by Ron (new)

Ron Great praise you wrote Diana. I have heard how closely tied to nature this story becomes.


message 19: by Linda (new)

Linda excellent review! your last sentence goes straight to the heart.


message 20: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline Fabulous, bone-shaking review, Diane! When you wrote, "Let's just say this is The War and Peace of nature." - I had my first set of chill bumps. Your last paragraph of "maybe's" set off a whole other set - and I'm still experiencing the 'after-shocks'. Wow. This is definitely one I need to find a slot for as soon as possible. As you said, the ones who really need to read this one probably won't. (I'm looking with a stink-eye at the 'far right' in both our countries right now.)


message 21: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi What a powerful review, Diane! I always take notice when you love a book, but you certainly made me sit up even straighter than usual with this one. Going on my shortlist, but will make sure to read it at just the right time :)


message 22: by Fiona (new) - added it

Fiona A wonderful review, Diane. Heartfelt and persuasive.


Diane Barnes I don't think any of you will be disappointed in this one, but it is a time consuming, difficult, intense book. The author has a message and he's not shy about getting it across. The science of trees and what happens underground blew me away.


message 24: by Angela M (new) - added it

Angela M Your first line - what an endorsement! You definitely have me thinking about this one.


Betsy Robinson I'm so glad you read and loved this book and reviewed it so well. This is a book I could not shut up about after I read it, and I too felt what you express in your last paragraph, Diane. However I actually felt comforted by the fact that even if we destroy ourselves, which it looks like we are going to do, short of us blowing up the whole planet so there is nothing left, another kind of life will go on. I like knowing that Life is bigger than we puny destroyers. (If you haven't seen it, I highly recommend watching the PBS movie Radioactive Wolves of Chernobyl (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Op2Z...).


Diane Barnes Thanks, Betsy, I'll look for that documentary. I also felt comforted by the fact that life will go on, even if humans do not. It was pointed out by one of the characters, I think Patricia, that the best thing we can do is to leave nature alone and it will eventually return on its own terms, just like Ray and Dorothy did in their yard.


message 27: by Jeannie (new) - added it

Jeannie Awesome review, Diane. I'm so glad you loved this one. I have it on my TBR.


Betsy Robinson Diane wrote: "Thanks, Betsy, I'll look for that documentary. I also felt comforted by the fact that life will go on, even if humans do not. It was pointed out by one of the characters, I think Patricia, that the..."

Exactly!


message 29: by Sara (last edited Jun 14, 2019 08:57AM) (new) - added it

Sara Wow. This is high praise, coming from you. I will slate it for a time when I'm feeling less harried...maybe in the winter when there are not so many obligations to fill.


Diane Barnes Good thinking, Sara.


Paltia I become ridiculously happy when I read someone else enjoyed this book. Fantastic review.


Diane Barnes A lot of this takes place in your corner of the world, Paltia, so that's another reason for you to appreciate it.


Connie  G Wonderful review, Diane. I loved the book, and would like to reread it some day to catch all the little details I missed the first time around.


Diane Barnes Me too, Connie, but it's so intense I'll have to wait awhile.


Paltia Diane wrote: "A lot of this takes place in your corner of the world, Paltia, so that's another reason for you to appreciate it."

I know. All us tree huggers out here😂


message 36: by Bianca (last edited Jun 15, 2019 06:11PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Bianca Amazing review. I've just returned my unread library copy because the font was too small and too dense and given the large number of pages, I was put off by it. It looks like I'll have to buy the ebook.


message 37: by ☮Karen (new) - added it

☮Karen Yikes, amazing review Diane. I am adding this one too.


message 38: by Roxy (new)

Roxy What a fantastic review, Diane! It is obviously a a very powerful book.


Diane Barnes Bianca, if you don't mind working at a book, you'll be rewarded with pride of accomplishment and a new regard for nature.


Diane Barnes Karen, I wish everyone would read this, but realize they won 't. I hope you're able to get to it.


Diane Barnes Roxy, powerful and heartbreaking too.


Diane Barnes You'll love this, Elyse, but it will break your heart for the trees.


Brooklyn Great review - I’m in the middle of book now and love it’s sense of awe and wonder at the force of nature- I look at trees differently in my walk from the NYC subway to work. This work makes you look at the world differently and that is a rare achievement- can’t wait to see what happens. Because of some feel of magical realism I also am seeing this book as 100 years of solitude of trees


Diane Barnes I think it will be a classic, for sure. Let's just hope we don't look back in 50 years and see it as "the way things were".


Hanlie Pieterse I totally agree with your review, Diane. This is one of the most amazing books I have ever read. BUT, we are already converted. The ones who need to get the message desperately, will probably be bored by the book.


Diane Barnes That's true, Hanlie, and sad, but maybe it can create a few converts.


Katherine Croasdale Great review!


Mohammad Balouchi What a review!


message 49: by Linda (new)

Linda You touched my heart with this moving review, Diane. I wonder how you feel about this one over 2 years past and if it changed how you look at the world since .


Diane Barnes I look at trees in a different way now, as though they are living breathing entities, which they are. When the power company comes through to butcher them for the power lines, it breaks my heart.


« previous 1
back to top