BlackOxford's Reviews > War & War

War & War by László Krasznahorkai
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
17744555
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: hungarian

Over-sharing

Breathless, relentless, urgent, a man on a mission; yet Korin is stuck like Baalam’s Ass, unable to move on a railway footbridge over an industrial wasteland, a prisoner of seven thuggish, homicidal children who could actually care less about him. They are his Greek chorus to whom he feels the need to confess his suicidal intentions and from whom he expects counsel. Korin’s fear of being physically harmed is exactly offset by his fear of not being listened to. The children know he is insane and ignore him instead of killing him.

Korin has lost faith in the world. This is a functional definition of his insanity and the reason for his intended suicide. Nothing he perceives, including his own thoughts, can be trusted. He has concluded that his only alternative is acceptance, submission to the power of a universe and its gods which are imaginary but not illusory. Because Korin has already lost his mind, he is desperately afraid of losing his head, of it literally separating gradually from his body before he completes his mission.

So Korin ‘shares’ with the children... and shares... and shares with everyone else he encounters. He wants them to understand what has happened to him, his epiphany of the senselessness of the world and the task he has. His job as records keeper for the Council, and his avocation as local historian, he recognises, were entirely meaningless. Facts, data, reports never approached anything like the truth. But what can accepting all this mean? He had been creating an artificial world in his head; and now he isn’t anymore. So?

Escaping the children, Korin resumes his mission by travelling to “the very center of the world.” He appears somewhat unsure about where that might be and will take the next flight to anywhere. His loquacious intensity is unremitting and it gets him a ticket to New York City, a visa, a stand-by seat, and the care of a beautiful stewardess, who also thinks he is insane, even if benignly so. Customs and Immigration find him eccentric but otherwise harmless, as do the other people he meets on the streets of NYC.

Although he has lost faith in the gods, he remains a devotee of Hermes, the divine messenger and their general factotum. Hermes has a singular function among the Olympians. He tells stories, eloquently. Korin‘s devotion to Hermes is well-placed even if paradoxical. He has a story to tell, a story of men returning to their homes from war. He found it in his municipal archive. His objective is to publicise it to the world... and die.

This is all somewhat spooky. Written two years before the attacks of 9/11, I’m sure that if the book were more popular in the US there would be conspiracy theories in abundance about it. More likely though, it is a literary artist’s expression of a sort of religious faith in literature. Or rather the obsessive, compulsive need to articulate what one finds important. This need is, of course, as silly and neurotic as any other human need. Perhaps it is even insane. One significant advantage, however, is that it does not involve blowing up buildings.
140 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read War & War.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 1, 2019 – Shelved
September 1, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
September 4, 2019 – Started Reading
September 4, 2019 – Shelved as: hungarian
September 5, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jordan (new)

Jordan West It's been about a decade since I read Krasznahorkai's Melancholy of Resistance, but I remember it as an authentic masterpiece; very much looking forward to Baron Wenckheim's Homecoming, supposedly his grand opus, later this month.


BlackOxford Jordan wrote: "It's been about a decade since I read Krasznahorkai's Melancholy of Resistance, but I remember it as an authentic masterpiece; very much looking forward to Baron Wenckheim's Homecoming, supposedly ..."

Good luck. I can take only a limited amount of such rapid-fire intensity at my delicate age.


message 3: by Nick (new)

Nick Grammos Perhaps I’ve read too much Eastern European Russian Beckett Kafka at al
But I never considered Korin insane
Must be me


BlackOxford Nick wrote: "Perhaps I’ve read too much Eastern European Russian Beckett Kafka at al
But I never considered Korin insane
Must be me"


OK. How about, obsessively, suicidally driven to express his innermost feelings? In NYC he might just pass for normal. But I wouldn’t let him anywhere near an explosive device!


message 5: by Lewis (new) - added it

Lewis A bold and relentless review. I will now make it my mission to read this book. Probably after my military tasking this next week.

Thank you for the insight and critique and introduction.


BlackOxford Lewis T. wrote: "A bold and relentless review. I will now make it my mission to read this book. Probably after my military tasking this next week.

Thank you for the insight and critique and introduction."


Good luck with that military thing. Just remember Koran’s experience: war stories cannot be told.


message 7: by Sara (new) - added it

Sara Vidal oh no not another book I just must read!! Gasp. Thanks.


BlackOxford Sara wrote: "oh no not another book I just must read!! Gasp. Thanks."

Be prepared for something different, Sara.


message 9: by Lewis (new) - added it

Lewis That’s so good! I’ll keep that in mind.


message 10: by David (new)

David Yohalem Surely the homicidal children you mention could NOT care less about him.


BlackOxford David wrote: "Surely the homicidal children you mention could NOT care less about him."

They clearly care about him only as a victim. Do you mean something further?


message 12: by David (new)

David Yohalem BlackOxford wrote: "David wrote: "Surely the homicidal children you mention could NOT care less about him."

They clearly care about him only as a victim. Do you mean something further?"


Only that the expression "they could care less", means that they care. If they don't care about him as a person, then they could NOT care less.


BlackOxford David wrote: "BlackOxford wrote: "David wrote: "Surely the homicidal children you mention could NOT care less about him."

They clearly care about him only as a victim. Do you mean something further?"

Only that..."


Point taken. Bad grammar is poisonous isn’t it? I looked at that sentence hard after I wrote it, knowing something was amiss but couldn’t see it. Thanks.


message 14: by David (new)

David Yohalem You are most welcome. And gracious.

It's why it's always good to have someone read anything you may prepare for publication prior to sending it to whatever outlet will publish it: fresh eyes catch silly oversights.


message 15: by David (new)

David Yohalem Nick wrote: "Perhaps I’ve read too much Eastern European Russian Beckett Kafka at al
But I never considered Korin insane
Must be me"


It may sound like nit-picking, but

Beckett was Irish and lived in France (western European);
Kafka was a Jewish Czech (central European) and wrote in German;
(Canetti was a Sephardic Jew, born in Bulgaria (nominally Eastern European, writing in German and lived in Vienna for much of his life);
Krasznoharkai is Hungarian (central European)

So, it's not the Eastern European influence (Russian, Ukrainian, Slovakian) that supports your defense of Korin's sanity (marginal at best) at least among those listed. If there are, indeed, national/geographical characteristics and sensibilities reflected in a literature, shouldn't one be a little more precise in assigning the geography?


BlackOxford David wrote: "Nick wrote: "Perhaps I’ve read too much Eastern European Russian Beckett Kafka at al
But I never considered Korin insane
Must be me"

It may sound like nit-picking, but

Beckett was Irish and live..."


What he said.


message 17: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Sagar Fabulous review, BlackOxford. I really liked the way you ended it with a tinge of wry humor. I read Satantango a few earlier and was hugely affected by it, I read two more books by him after that but this one yet to read by me. Will try it sometime soon. Thanks for sharing :)


BlackOxford Gaurav wrote: "Fabulous review, BlackOxford. I really liked the way you ended it with a tinge of wry humor. I read Satantango a few earlier and was hugely affected by it, I read two more books by him after that b..."

Thanks. Yes, picking one’s neuroses may be the most fundamental freedom of all. Look at America!


back to top