Greta G's Reviews > Last Things: A Graphic Memoir of Loss and Love
Last Things: A Graphic Memoir of Loss and Love
by
by
Greta G's review
bookshelves: ebook, graphicnovels-comics-manga, owned-in-english, memoir
Oct 16, 2019
bookshelves: ebook, graphicnovels-comics-manga, owned-in-english, memoir
At the end of their sabbatical year in Rome, things start to go wrong. Harvey is tired all the time and gasping for breath. He also starts to stutter. The doctors have no idea what’s wrong. Only months later, he’s diagnosed with ALS or Lou Gehrig’s disease.
Regular ALS starts with weakness in the arms and legs. Eventually you end up in a wheelchair, completely immobile. When you can’t breathe anymore, you die, usually five to seven years after the diagnosis. But Harvey has Bulbar ALS, which starts with the tongue and throat muscles. Death is generally two years after the diagnosis.
The impact of the diagnosis on Harvey is drastic. Harvey retreats in his office and shuts his wife Marissa and their three young sons out. Marissa doesn’t recognize this man anymore.
“Harvey’s not sad. He’s furious. At me. He’s never yelled at me before. Now, in an instant, my warm, loving husband for nearly twenty years is cold with rage.
It’s shock, I tell myself. Later we’ll cry together, hold each other.
But we don’t. I’m sealed off in the Land of the Not–Dying.”
Harvey’s health condition deteriorates quickly, and Marissa is soon consumed with caring for Harvey while trying to keep life as normal as possible for her young children.
“Do the boys understand what’s happening to us? Is it better for them to know or not know? How do you make a father’s dying easier for a child? I have no answers, no idea what to do. And Harvey won’t help. Or maybe he can’t.”
The enormity of what Marissa is responsible for is crushing. Harvey is the one she’d turn to for help with all this. Only she can’t. She has to face it all alone.
Maybe Harvey needs to be distant. Maybe that’s how he faces death.
“Is dying like that? Something that takes all your focus, all your concentration? A physical demand that strips away your sense of self? Have I already lost Harvey to the process of dying?”
Marissa Moss’s sad story hit me hard. This is a poignant story of how she, her husband and their children struggled to cope with Harvey’s terminal illness. Her writing as well as her black-and-white illustrations are straightforward and honest. This is a book that’s impossible to put down once you start reading it.
“The pace of the disease still surprises me. We plunge down its steep slope, flailing desperately to stay upright, until we skid to a halt. Before we have time to assess the new landscape, the ground shifts again, pulling us down with it. There is no status quo to get used to, only the dizzying wrenching of our feet out from under us, the powerful, inexorable avalanche of the disease’s progression.”
In addition to writing this book, she also finished the book Harvey —who was a medieval art historian— had been working on for more than fifteen years, Picturing Kingship: History and Painting in the Psalter of Saint Louis, a book about King Louis IX’s personal psalter.
“Writing is a way for me to find myself again and to reclaim Harvey, who he was before he got sick. Reading his words is like having a conversation with him again, hearing how he thinks, his passion for art and history.”
Regular ALS starts with weakness in the arms and legs. Eventually you end up in a wheelchair, completely immobile. When you can’t breathe anymore, you die, usually five to seven years after the diagnosis. But Harvey has Bulbar ALS, which starts with the tongue and throat muscles. Death is generally two years after the diagnosis.
The impact of the diagnosis on Harvey is drastic. Harvey retreats in his office and shuts his wife Marissa and their three young sons out. Marissa doesn’t recognize this man anymore.
“Harvey’s not sad. He’s furious. At me. He’s never yelled at me before. Now, in an instant, my warm, loving husband for nearly twenty years is cold with rage.
It’s shock, I tell myself. Later we’ll cry together, hold each other.
But we don’t. I’m sealed off in the Land of the Not–Dying.”
Harvey’s health condition deteriorates quickly, and Marissa is soon consumed with caring for Harvey while trying to keep life as normal as possible for her young children.
“Do the boys understand what’s happening to us? Is it better for them to know or not know? How do you make a father’s dying easier for a child? I have no answers, no idea what to do. And Harvey won’t help. Or maybe he can’t.”
The enormity of what Marissa is responsible for is crushing. Harvey is the one she’d turn to for help with all this. Only she can’t. She has to face it all alone.
Maybe Harvey needs to be distant. Maybe that’s how he faces death.
“Is dying like that? Something that takes all your focus, all your concentration? A physical demand that strips away your sense of self? Have I already lost Harvey to the process of dying?”
Marissa Moss’s sad story hit me hard. This is a poignant story of how she, her husband and their children struggled to cope with Harvey’s terminal illness. Her writing as well as her black-and-white illustrations are straightforward and honest. This is a book that’s impossible to put down once you start reading it.
“The pace of the disease still surprises me. We plunge down its steep slope, flailing desperately to stay upright, until we skid to a halt. Before we have time to assess the new landscape, the ground shifts again, pulling us down with it. There is no status quo to get used to, only the dizzying wrenching of our feet out from under us, the powerful, inexorable avalanche of the disease’s progression.”
In addition to writing this book, she also finished the book Harvey —who was a medieval art historian— had been working on for more than fifteen years, Picturing Kingship: History and Painting in the Psalter of Saint Louis, a book about King Louis IX’s personal psalter.
“Writing is a way for me to find myself again and to reclaim Harvey, who he was before he got sick. Reading his words is like having a conversation with him again, hearing how he thinks, his passion for art and history.”
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Last Things.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
October 12, 2019
– Shelved
October 13, 2019
–
Started Reading
October 14, 2019
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Darlene
(new)
Oct 17, 2019 05:38AM
This sounds like a beautifully moving book, Greta! Lovely review! :)
reply
|
flag
Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of Wave and how you loved that one; there was also a passage in the book about her mother which made me think of you. I’ve given up on recommending books to you :) but you really should try this one. It’s a short read. No platitudes, just raw and honest emotions. The art and lettering weren’t especially great, but I got used to it and it worked well for this book.
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of Wave and how you loved that one; there was also a passage in the book about her mother which made me think of you. I’ve given up on recommending books to you :) but you really should try this one. It’s a short read. No platitudes, just raw and honest emotions. The art and lettering weren’t especially great, but I got used to it and it worked well for this book.
Thank you Sarah. It was an intense read, but unsentimental for the major part. Hallmark won’t be picking this up to turn into a movie (but I would if I could!).
Great review. The whole situation sounded utterly devastating, and the author enormously courageous and honest... How dreadful to not only lose your husband, but seemingly to lose him months or years before he died...
Caroline wrote: "Great review. The whole situation sounded utterly devastating, and the author enormously courageous and honest... How dreadful to not only lose your husband, but seemingly to lose him months or yea..."
Thanks Caroline. Yes, this was tragic. Luckily there were also some uplifting moments, yet these moments were few and far between.
You might think this is a depressing book, but it wasn’t. It’s actually quite accessible, and compelling.
Thanks Caroline. Yes, this was tragic. Luckily there were also some uplifting moments, yet these moments were few and far between.
You might think this is a depressing book, but it wasn’t. It’s actually quite accessible, and compelling.
Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of Wave and how you loved that..."
I apologize for my delayed response, Greta! Goodreads hasn't been working for me for a couple of days. It's interesting that you mention 'Wave' because the way in which you wrote about this book reminded ME of that book too! And you're right... I LOVED it! It is still one of my favorites! As you know, I'm not familiar with graphic novels .... I still have the novel 'Maus' on my shelf and my daughter bought that for me overacted year ago. I know... I know! :) I AM interested in this book though. It sounds exactly like one that I would find very moving. (And don't give up on recommending books to me! I've just become so preoccupied with reading about the American prison system , poverty and inequality and war that I sometimes forget that there are other topics and other books to read!! I appreciate your recommendations!) :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of Wave and how you loved that..."
I apologize for my delayed response, Greta! Goodreads hasn't been working for me for a couple of days. It's interesting that you mention 'Wave' because the way in which you wrote about this book reminded ME of that book too! And you're right... I LOVED it! It is still one of my favorites! As you know, I'm not familiar with graphic novels .... I still have the novel 'Maus' on my shelf and my daughter bought that for me overacted year ago. I know... I know! :) I AM interested in this book though. It sounds exactly like one that I would find very moving. (And don't give up on recommending books to me! I've just become so preoccupied with reading about the American prison system , poverty and inequality and war that I sometimes forget that there are other topics and other books to read!! I appreciate your recommendations!) :)
Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of Wave and how ..."
Hi Darlene. No problem. Thanks for mentioning you’ve had computer problems. I was afraid my overly enthusiastic recommendation scared you off. :)
I don’t know exactly why this book reminded me of Wave. It’s something totally different, yet I couldn’t help thinking about that one.
If your library has a copy of ‘Last Things’, don’t hesitate to try it out; I think you won’t regret it. And it will not draw your attention away from your other reading interests for long, because it’s a rather short book.
Possibly you’ll have to explain to your daughter why you didn’t read Maus first though!
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of Wave and how ..."
Hi Darlene. No problem. Thanks for mentioning you’ve had computer problems. I was afraid my overly enthusiastic recommendation scared you off. :)
I don’t know exactly why this book reminded me of Wave. It’s something totally different, yet I couldn’t help thinking about that one.
If your library has a copy of ‘Last Things’, don’t hesitate to try it out; I think you won’t regret it. And it will not draw your attention away from your other reading interests for long, because it’s a rather short book.
Possibly you’ll have to explain to your daughter why you didn’t read Maus first though!
Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of [book:Wave|15..."
Hi Greta! No chance of that happening! I love your enthusiasm and your review was so lovely! :) I installed the new operating system on my Mac last week and I had a couple of issues and Goodreads was one of those problems. My husband thinks the problem was with Goodreads but who knows??! :) Anyway, things seem to be working fine now. As for my daughter and 'Maus'.. well, she is used to my reading obsessions so she hasn't mentioned the book in a while. :) I'm curious... I saw that you read an ebook version of this book. Do you always read graphic novels in ebook form? I will see if I can get a copy of this book. It does sound like one I would like. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of [book:Wave|15..."
Hi Greta! No chance of that happening! I love your enthusiasm and your review was so lovely! :) I installed the new operating system on my Mac last week and I had a couple of issues and Goodreads was one of those problems. My husband thinks the problem was with Goodreads but who knows??! :) Anyway, things seem to be working fine now. As for my daughter and 'Maus'.. well, she is used to my reading obsessions so she hasn't mentioned the book in a while. :) I'm curious... I saw that you read an ebook version of this book. Do you always read graphic novels in ebook form? I will see if I can get a copy of this book. It does sound like one I would like. :)
Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of..."
In fact, the fact that I often read graphic novels in ebook form, has a long history. I’m not a great storyteller, so bear with me. My first graphic novel (GN), fifteen to twenty years ago, was Maus, and I read a Dutch translation. The author’s and narrator’s father was a Jewish immigrant in America and spoke English with an accent. However in Dutch this sounded so annoyingly ridiculous, that I decided to avoid reading Dutch translations of GN’s in the future. At that time, buying on the internet was more difficult and expensive than it is now. And GN’s were even less popular so there weren’t many GN’s that were translated in Dutch anyhow. And the quality of these translations were questionable, I’m afraid. I mostly imported English GN’s through amazon UK. I bought some on amazon.com too, when they weren’t available in Europe, but that was even more expensive, due to customs duties.
So my collection of GN’s costed me a small fortune –GN’s already are ridiculously costly in the first place.
It was only very recently that graphic novels became available for us Belgians through ebooks. It’s not ideal, but I’m used to it now and almost every book in another language is now available to me with one click, at a reasonable price. Another advantage is the possibility of downloading a sample first, so there’s less chance that a book I payed for turns out to be a disappointment. I read a sample of ‘Last Things’ first also, and I was sold...
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only was I reminded of..."
In fact, the fact that I often read graphic novels in ebook form, has a long history. I’m not a great storyteller, so bear with me. My first graphic novel (GN), fifteen to twenty years ago, was Maus, and I read a Dutch translation. The author’s and narrator’s father was a Jewish immigrant in America and spoke English with an accent. However in Dutch this sounded so annoyingly ridiculous, that I decided to avoid reading Dutch translations of GN’s in the future. At that time, buying on the internet was more difficult and expensive than it is now. And GN’s were even less popular so there weren’t many GN’s that were translated in Dutch anyhow. And the quality of these translations were questionable, I’m afraid. I mostly imported English GN’s through amazon UK. I bought some on amazon.com too, when they weren’t available in Europe, but that was even more expensive, due to customs duties.
So my collection of GN’s costed me a small fortune –GN’s already are ridiculously costly in the first place.
It was only very recently that graphic novels became available for us Belgians through ebooks. It’s not ideal, but I’m used to it now and almost every book in another language is now available to me with one click, at a reasonable price. Another advantage is the possibility of downloading a sample first, so there’s less chance that a book I payed for turns out to be a disappointment. I read a sample of ‘Last Things’ first also, and I was sold...
Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only w..."
You're a fine storyteller, Greta! :) It's interesting... you've gone through a long process of trial-and -error to find what works! I have a Kindle but don't read too many books in ebook form. I prefer paper or audiobooks but my husband and kids read almost exclusively on their IPads. I was curious if reading graphic novels on a screen takes anything away from the experience but perhaps it doesn't. And I also like the fact that you can preview a book before you decide to commit!!
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only w..."
You're a fine storyteller, Greta! :) It's interesting... you've gone through a long process of trial-and -error to find what works! I have a Kindle but don't read too many books in ebook form. I prefer paper or audiobooks but my husband and kids read almost exclusively on their IPads. I was curious if reading graphic novels on a screen takes anything away from the experience but perhaps it doesn't. And I also like the fact that you can preview a book before you decide to commit!!
Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading th..."
Since our libraries only have some translated works, ebooks are the best option I have. I still buy favorite ones, or ones that aren’t available in ebook form, on paper, but that doesn’t happen often anymore.
Reading graphic novels on a screen isn’t ideal, I have to admit that, but to me it’s a great opportunity to enjoy books that aren’t easily available to me otherwise.
Also, my eyesight isn’t optimal anymore, and I keep postponing wearing glasses. Even without daylight, I can still enjoy a GN in ebook form, without glasses. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading th..."
Since our libraries only have some translated works, ebooks are the best option I have. I still buy favorite ones, or ones that aren’t available in ebook form, on paper, but that doesn’t happen often anymore.
Reading graphic novels on a screen isn’t ideal, I have to admit that, but to me it’s a great opportunity to enjoy books that aren’t easily available to me otherwise.
Also, my eyesight isn’t optimal anymore, and I keep postponing wearing glasses. Even without daylight, I can still enjoy a GN in ebook form, without glasses. :)
Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while ..."
I understand your eyesight problem, Greta! :) I got a pair of reading glasses a few years ago!!
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while ..."
I understand your eyesight problem, Greta! :) I got a pair of reading glasses a few years ago!!
Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Darlene wrote: "Greta wrote: "Thank you Darlene. :)
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only w..."
What happens to your GNs after you read them? Do you have a large library of them now? Do you keep only your favorites, Greta?
I’m glad you commented, because I’ve been thinking about you a couple of times while I was reading this. Not only w..."
What happens to your GNs after you read them? Do you have a large library of them now? Do you keep only your favorites, Greta?
Greta,
This review really touched me. I think that anyone who knows about ALS is properly terrified of it, and this Marissa Moss did what an artist can do to combat the terror--she turned it into art. So moving! I'm adding it.
This review really touched me. I think that anyone who knows about ALS is properly terrified of it, and this Marissa Moss did what an artist can do to combat the terror--she turned it into art. So moving! I'm adding it.
HBalikov wrote: "What happens to your GNs after you read them? Do you have a large library of them now? Do you keep only your favorites, Greta?”
Erm... I think my children will be happy if I start getting rid of most of my books now. One of them asked me if I would like to be buried with my books later. Obviously, I would want that!
Erm... I think my children will be happy if I start getting rid of most of my books now. One of them asked me if I would like to be buried with my books later. Obviously, I would want that!
Julie wrote: "Greta,
This review really touched me. I think that anyone who knows about ALS is properly terrified of it, and this Marissa Moss did what an artist can do to combat the terror--she turned it into a..."
Thanks Julie. The book was many years in the making, and it was published with the permission of her three sons. Moreover, the eldest son worked as art director for the book. This illness, like all invasive terminal illnesses, cause suffering not only for the patient, but for all family members. This intimate memoir brings home to readers the family’s suffering, something I think is far too often overlooked by people who haven’t experienced something like this.
I’m glad you want to read it Julie, and I’m looking forward to your thoughts on this book.
This review really touched me. I think that anyone who knows about ALS is properly terrified of it, and this Marissa Moss did what an artist can do to combat the terror--she turned it into a..."
Thanks Julie. The book was many years in the making, and it was published with the permission of her three sons. Moreover, the eldest son worked as art director for the book. This illness, like all invasive terminal illnesses, cause suffering not only for the patient, but for all family members. This intimate memoir brings home to readers the family’s suffering, something I think is far too often overlooked by people who haven’t experienced something like this.
I’m glad you want to read it Julie, and I’m looking forward to your thoughts on this book.
Shankar wrote: "Wonderful and touching review. Thanks"
Thank you Shankar. It was a heartfelt, personal story that’s bound to touch everyone who reads it.
Thank you Shankar. It was a heartfelt, personal story that’s bound to touch everyone who reads it.