megs_bookrack's Reviews > The Devil and the Dark Water

The Devil and the Dark Water by Stuart Turton
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
48328025
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: arcs-read

In 1634, passengers and crew begin boarding the merchant ship, Saardam, for a voyage from Batavia to Amsterdam.

On the docks, a leper suddenly appears high atop a pile of crates and issues a warning that the voyage will end in merciless ruin.



He subsequently bursts into flames and dies a very public and painful death. The observers, although chilled by his damning proclamation, shrug it off as the ramblings of a madman.

It's harder to ignore the devil's mark that miraculously appears on the sails, however. The incident, understandably, casts a sense of foreboding over the entire voyage.



Samuel Pipps, a well-respected detective, happens to be aboard for the journey. Surprising to some is the fact that he is being transported as a prisoner, not a free traveler.

Due to this status, he is locked in a grimy, claustrophobic cell, without even enough room to stand up.



Luckily, his faithful bodyguard, and our intrepid hero, Lieutenant Arent Hayes, is also aboard. He just so happens to have a close connection to the Governor General, Jan Haan, also aboard.

Through Arent's suggestion, Samuel earns the right to be taken out of his cell every night to get some fresh air upon the decks.



As mysterious happenings plague the ship, paired with reoccurrences of the devil's mark, Arent teams up with Jan Haan's lovely wife, Sara Wessel, to try to get to the bottom of it.

An important piece of Arent's past, the lore of a demon named Old Tom, plays a large role in this story. Some say Old Tom is aboard the ship; that he's the cause of all the problems.



There's a ghost ship stalking them, the food supply is treacherously low, a storm threatens to sink them, people die, things disappear and throughout it all, Old Tom is trying to recruit passengers to the darkside.

This book has such a vibe. I don't quite have words for what it is, but I love it!



As with The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle, The Devil and the Dark Water is a complex and suspenseful mystery.

The tone of this novel, the is it supernatural, is it not-feel of it all was masterfully done. Additionally, the use of Arent and Sara as an amateur sleuthing team was incredibly executed.



Together they are trying to work out who among them has been possessed by Old Tom. Their investigation has a lot of twists and turns, casting doubts on numerous passengers and crew.

All of the characters were so interesting. Anyone could have been the baddie. I had no clue who to suspect!



The entire story was completely original. I have never read anything quite like it. Turton's imagination knows no bounds.

Apparently, 17th-Century Supernatural Mysteries are now my jam, because I am OBSESSED with this!



Thank you so much to the publisher, SourceBooks Landmark, for providing me with a copy of this to read and review. This was by far, one of my most anticipated reads of the year, so I certainly appreciate it.

I am such of fan of Turton's writing and look forward to seeing what he comes up with next!

521 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Devil and the Dark Water.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 1, 2020 – Shelved
January 1, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
September 13, 2020 – Started Reading
September 14, 2020 –
page 10
2.16% "Well, this starts off with a bang.

"
September 15, 2020 –
page 21
4.54%
September 15, 2020 –
page 32
6.91%
September 17, 2020 –
page 63
13.61% "First comes the mark..."
September 21, 2020 –
page 100
21.6% "This is so unique. I'm really enjoying the sea-faring vibe. Devils and dark marks and cursed ships...oh my!"
September 21, 2020 –
page 110
23.76%
September 22, 2020 –
page 120
25.92% "Apparently, 17th Century Supernatural Mysteries are now my jam, because I am OBSESSED with this!"
September 22, 2020 –
page 146
31.53%
September 23, 2020 –
page 157
33.91% "Let me tell you where I am at:

A demon, who goes by the name Old Tom, has possessed one of the passengers to gain passage onto the ship, but who?
A man named Kers, the last of his witchfinding order, has been lured to the ship by Old Tom himself. This has just been deduced.

If this doesn't intrigue you, I don't know what will!"
September 25, 2020 –
page 176
38.01%
September 28, 2020 –
page 209
45.14%
October 1, 2020 –
page 229
49.46%
October 4, 2020 –
page 238
51.4% "😳😳😳
I'd be jumping overboard at this point.
Peace ✌"
October 6, 2020 –
page 270
58.32%
October 11, 2020 –
page 320
69.11%
October 18, 2020 –
page 351
75.81% "Yessss! Love getting a title reference or explanation 🧡"
October 18, 2020 –
page 407
87.9% "This:

Fear was too brittle a material to make good decisions from.

🙌"
October 19, 2020 – Shelved as: arcs-read
October 19, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Catherine The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle was so great and this one sounds even better!


megs_bookrack Catherine wrote: "The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle was so great and this one sounds even better!"I agree! Really looking forward to it! He's so creative. I am sure it will be fascinating.


message 3: by William (new)

William Thank you for the review!


Audrey I hope this is good!


megs_bookrack William wrote: "Thank you for the review!"
Thanks, William!


megs_bookrack Audrey wrote: "I hope this is good!"me too, Audrey! I sm fairly confident it will be 🖤


Audrey Lucky!


megs_bookrack Audrey wrote: "Lucky!" I feel so lucky!!!


message 9: by Herbie (new) - added it

Herbie Cannot express my jealousy more!!!! 😭


megs_bookrack Herbie wrote: "Cannot express my jealousy more!!!! 😭"
Your jealousy is appreciated, Herbie! hahahahaaa :)


NZLisaM I am in love with this review. 😊👏


megs_bookrack NZLisaM wrote: "I am in love with this review. 😊👏" Ohhh, my heart! Thank you so much. You have no idea how happy that makes me. xx


message 13: by Kyra (new)

Kyra Leseberg (Roots & Reads) Great review! I loved Evelyn and now I'm eager to read this one!


megs_bookrack Kyra wrote: "Great review! I loved Evelyn and now I'm eager to read this one!" Thank you, Kyra! This one is completely different, yet equally as amazing!!! Enjoy -- xx


Kat valentine ( Katsbookcornerreads) Another excellent review meg!!💯😉👊💕💋


megs_bookrack Kat wrote: "Another excellent review meg!!💯😉👊💕💋"
Thank you, my sweet friend. I appreciate your kindness! xx


message 17: by Aisling Zena (new)

Aisling Zena Wonderful review Megs! Very Halloweeny! :) xx


megs_bookrack Aisling Zena wrote: "Wonderful review Megs! Very Halloweeny! :) xx"
Thank you! It is a perfect Halloween read. xx


message 19: by Shell (new)

Shell Hunt How did you feel about his last book. This sounds cool, but I really didn't enjoy his last one.


megs_bookrack Shell wrote: "How did you feel about his last book. This sounds cool, but I really didn't enjoy his last one." I loved them both, but what did you not enjoy about this first one? If you tell me, I can tell you if you would run into the same problem here...they are quite different.


message 21: by Shell (new)

Shell Hunt I was super into the body switching mystery of it all.
The ending was little too wacked out and didn't fit for me.


megs_bookrack Shell wrote: "I was super into the body switching mystery of it all.
The ending was little too wacked out and didn't fit for me."
I think you would like this one. The quality of his writing, as far as the detail, the vast array of well-constructed characters, the ominous feeling, is all there, but without the wacky bit... :)
If you do read it, I would love to hear what you think!


message 23: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Love the visual aids


megs_bookrack Rachel wrote: "Love the visual aids" Hahaha, thank you, Rachel! It's easier for me to express myself that way. My words tend to work correctly... xx


Donna McEachran Great review. Totally agree about Stuart Turton's writing; have loved both his books and look forward to where he takes us next!


megs_bookrack Donna wrote: "Great review. Totally agree about Stuart Turton's writing; have loved both his books and look forward to where he takes us next!" They were so different too! Like there is no way to predict what he will come up with next!


Anita loved the review! I have all those same feelings after finishing! Clever masterpiece


megs_bookrack Anita wrote: "loved the review! I have all those same feelings after finishing! Clever masterpiece"

Thank you so much, Anita! I am glad to hear you loved it as well. I can't wait to see what he comes up with next! 😊💙


message 29: by Janice (new)

Janice Boychuk This just came up as my library virtual book club read for April! Good to see it has favourable reviews 💝


megs_bookrack Janice wrote: "This just came up as my library virtual book club read for April! Good to see it has favourable reviews 💝" I loved it so much. The setting, the characters, the dark, brooding feel of it all. I hope you love it, Janice! It was really unlike anything I had ever read before.


message 31: by Keith (new)

Keith Dooley Great review, as always! I had never heard of the book, but I’ll definitely look into it now!


megs_bookrack Keith wrote: "Great review, as always! I had never heard of the book, but I’ll definitely look into it now!" Awww, thank you so much, Keith. I really, really enjoyed this one. I think you might too actually. If you ever pick it up, I would love to hear what you think!


Matthew Whyndham I used to come to Goodreads as the one place to avoid images, gifs and stickers, but now they are everywhere here as well. Hey ho. Glad you liked the book though.


megs_bookrack Matthew Whyndham wrote: "I used to come to Goodreads as the one place to avoid images, gifs and stickers, but now they are everywhere here as well. Hey ho. Glad you liked the book though." Yep, they are. All of my reviews have GIFs. You may want to block me if you want to avoid them. Have a wonderful day! and yes, the book was fantastic!


Matthew Whyndham I wouldn't go that far, but if someone handed me a gif-suppressor for the browser I might turn it on. I blame the "some html is ok" feature. Probably intended for boring oldies to make things bold or to add Greek letters but the kids have run away with it!

Have a great day too! 🕊


Lorraine Thank you Meg for the wonderful review. I just received it from my local library, can’t wait to start. :)


message 37: by megs_bookrack (last edited Sep 07, 2021 01:52PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

megs_bookrack Lorraine wrote: "Thank you Meg for the wonderful review. I just received it from my local library, can’t wait to start. :)"
Yayee!! I hope you love it, Lorraine! I had never read anything quite like it. It's an adventure 💜


Audrey It was really good!


megs_bookrack Audrey wrote: "It was really good!" So different. It was a breath of fresh air!


Davie I bought this book right after reading the 7 deaths said Evelyn Hardcastle after waiting 6months or more for it to come out I'm only now picking it up seems to be just as good as 1st let's hope n the young librarian who has my 7 1/2 death better get with it and read one helluva a book


megs_bookrack Davie wrote: "I bought this book right after reading the 7 deaths said Evelyn Hardcastle after waiting 6months or more for it to come out I'm only now picking it up seems to be just as good as 1st let's hope n t..."
Haha, I hope you enjoy this one, Davie. It's very different from the first, but the writing is engaging and I loved the plot and atmosphere.


message 42: by Wendy (new)

Wendy Great review meg. Like you said, it is so refreshing when you get a book so different than most of the books out there 1 question did you feel the same about his first book?? I haven’t read either 1 yet!!


megs_bookrack Wendy wrote: "Great review meg. Like you said, it is so refreshing when you get a book so different than most of the books out there 1 question did you feel the same about his first book?? I haven’t read either ..."
Yesss, Wendy! I loved his first book!! It was refreshing as well, but in a completely different way. Both were inventive and definitely hooked me in. I love his writing style. I would recommend either!


back to top