len ❀ [small hiatus due to studying]'s Reviews > The Kite
The Kite (The Milvus Files #1)
by
by
N.R. Walker was one of the first MM authors I ever read, and she quickly became an author I counted on, so it pains me to give one of her books 1-star for the very first time.
The potential was there.
We are promised assassins, enemies to lovers, grumpy x sunshine, one-bed trope, us-against-them, and hate sex.
The execution, though, was not.
Somehow, it was these things exactly that disappointed me.
Every time I read a book that is promising a specific thing but ends up being just another loosely marketed one, it reminds me that I probably could write my own enemies to lovers with other favorite tropes and do the bare minimum for it, yet it would likely garner attention due to its marketing strategies. Perhaps it’s because I continue having high hopes for it, but whenever a book is promoted as “enemies to lovers,” I feel I’ll finally find the one I’m looking for. Sadly, it only ends up being the same enemies to lovers book as every other one I’ve read: we have our two main characters who hate each other for the first 10-20%, yet still find each other very attractive, to the point where their hatred is suddenly forgotten and taken over by their attractiveness. It’s such a weak structure. It shows how little development authors put into their relationship. It’s even sad how someone’s looks brainwash you entirely to the point where you find yourself attracted even though you hated every part of them only a little ago. Suddenly you don’t know who you are, everything has changed, and you feel the need to protect them. I wish someone could explain to me how exactly this works.
Enemies to lovers trope is not a superior trope for me. It’s weak, hardly ever developed, and has a repeated formula. In the case of The Kite, our two main characters, Harry and Asher, although they have a similar role, are enemies. Why? I have no fucking idea. We are told they hate each other and have to accept it. The lack of backstory on why they hate each other is one problem I found. We spend the book following them around as they run and hide together, but we never find out why they hate each other. Before we know it, they’re catching feelings. This structure is fragile, underdeveloped, and shows how little info you place on your character’s arcs to let the reader get to know them more. While we learn more about both of them later on, as they tell each other part of their stories, it’s at the point where both are attracted in a romantic and sexual sense. The lack of a backstory between passages didn’t help the characters’ non-existing chemistry. 20% in, one of Harry’s inner monologues is asking himself why Asher affects him and where the patience and indifference he’s prided himself in is. He asks, “What is it about Asher Garin that rankles me so much?” Honestly, I also want to know because we never really find out. Their relationship takes a 360 turn in a matter of pages and moments.
6% - Asher smiled, and good fucking lord, Harry hated him. “I want to put a gun to your head,” Harry mumbled. “So fucking bad.”
And what did Asher do? He laughed.
Harry pulled his pistol. “Tell me why I shouldn’t put a bullet in you.”
Asher didn’t even flinch. In fact, his smile became a smirk. Unbothered. Unbelievable.
(If their banter had continued like this without sex taking over most of the time they had together that wasn’t focused on running and hiding, it would have definitely made it more sexually tense, added to their growing connection, and overall friendship.)
29% - His head was telling him not to be stupid, but his heart was . . . well, his heart was now beginning to make decisions, and that scared the shit outta him.
(Look at how fucking early on his stupid heart got involved.)
31% - It really pissed Harry off that he enjoyed Asher’s company. As much as he annoyed him, as much as Asher infuriated him, Harry absolutely hated that he liked him.
(Okay but why? Why do you like him? What is there to like? He teases you and makes you want to shoot him in the head. Other than that, what development has happened?)
33% - Sure, he trusted Asher. Somewhat. But not that much.
(You trusted him enough to give his mouth your dick, so that’s enough, right?)
37% - “You won’t even look at me,” Asher yelled, this time in English, before he shoved Harry in the back.
(Imagine being in your 30s and throwing a tantrum as you pout because your supposed enemy won’t look at you, give you what you want (sexually) and is denying what his body wants? How pathetic.)
After this, they had a physical fight, Asher wanted to be dominated, so Harry did dominate, they gave in, had sex, went to sleep, woke up in the morning, day moved on.
45% - Asher grinned. “You are jealous.”
Yes, you are. Admit it. As much as you loathe this man, you like him too.
(What is there to like? All you’ve done is have oral and anal sex and bicker.)
46% - Asher laughed. “We’re all bad guys, Harry. You and me, we are the bad guys.” He shook his head, amused. “You kill for your government. I kill for anyone’s government. They might call it service or honourable duty, but it’s all murder.”
(Too bad the roles of being assassins were hardly relevant to the story)
51% - He liked Harry.
Sure, he was grumpy and his sense of humour could use some work, but he was also thoughtful and protective. And Asher knew, without a doubt, that Harry would have his back if and when it came down to it.
(Where can I find someone who likes me for two personality traits—being grumpy and having a boring sense of humor, but also because I’m a generic human being?)
63% - “You still angry? Pissed off? Wanna pummel something, Harry? You know I like it when you’re rough with me.”
(This is (unfortunately) how their relationship developed)
68% - “Please. He is . . . he is everything to me. Please. Did you see anything?”
(Since when?)
92% - “I don’t think my home was ever a place, Harry. I think that’s what this whole mess has taught me. I spent so many years longing for a normal life, for a home. But home for me was never a place or a country or a flag. It’s a person. And wherever he decides feels right for him, that’ll be okay with me.”
(Oh it’s the end already?)
There is no development as they run and hide together. Every moment is either sexual, formed through the desire and arousal they have, or they’re running because they’re being followed to be killed. Yet, in between those moments, there is nothing else being offered. Even though they are entirely and provably sexually attracted to an extreme (which I would have appreciated, along with the “hate sex” if it wasn’t the only thing they could do), the sexual tension between the two is primarily negative in the sense that it feels shameful at first (such as how Harry hates that he wants Asher physically, and Asher even gets mad at Harry because he won’t give in even though they both know he wants to). I’m not a fan of this kind of attraction. Look, I get it. They’re both men in their 30s, have some pent-up anger they want to release, and their hormones act are making them act like teenagers again. They don’t think with their mind but their body most of the time, and it takes only a couple of seconds to get them going. Yet, when it comes to sexual tension, which can lead to the emotional connection, especially in enemies to lovers, I expect it to be more, you know, tense? But it felt like there was no sexual tension. There were none of those moments that books tease us with–eye contact, desire but not giving in, getting closer to each other, wishing for a kiss, subtly making physical contact, admiration, and more. There weren’t any moments that made me believe in growing feelings between the two as we’re more perceptive of the character’s emotions.
I believe this book had a promising start when we met both Harry and Asher. Harry is the grump, always scowling, wishing Asher would shut up, and hardly ever smiles. His cold demeanor comes from the lack of connection he has to the world. He has a job to fulfill, missions to complete, and targets to get rid of. So he does as he says and moves on. On the other hand, Asher is the polar opposite–while not entirely a sunshine personality, his bright self is more prominent. Instead of scowling all the time, he maintains his bright smile to earn himself a good reputation. While he also has a role in fulfilling tasks to care for, he carries scars from his past. Having no loyalty, nationality, family, or home, he sticks to himself with the help of his informant. What starts as a back and forth, push and pull, teasing, bickering, and even fun banter turns into annoyance, repetition, and confusion. Even with suspension of disbelief, which I didn’t need to do here (mostly because I’m used to it already when it comes to military/action media), I couldn’t get behind the relationship. No matter how fun, entertaining, and funny the banter between our protagonists is, it adds nothing when it doesn’t further the attraction they’re trying to deny. Most of it is because it only started a certain way. Still, once things began changing gears and getting steamier, most of their conversations felt the same, with sex added to it. Asher started to push Harry’s buttons sexually, and Harry wanted to deny his sexual attraction but couldn’t resist. Most of the time they spend together is either of them having sex or figuring out their following location to run away to.
I’ve said this before, but for two opposites and “enemies,” the relationship was fast-paced. Not only with the lack of development, but I couldn’t figure out what exactly the two characters liked from each other. It felt like they only acted like their personality traits, and there wasn’t anything else they could offer. It happened too quickly. Sex is also not something that verifies a connection between the characters. Instead, it makes it less believable, underwhelming, and more disappointing overall. If you’re not going to give me a reason to believe in two characters falling in love, especially two men who had never fallen in love before, had trust issues the entire beginning of the book, and have roles that aren’t the exact best spot to be in when you’re vulnerable, I’m not going to be rooting for the couple at all. I know N.R. Walker is known for her low-angst, comforting reads that make love seem easy. Still, considering how she decided to take a different route in her writing here and write something new, it should be expected that there needs to be more growth added. I’ve read books from this author that are shorter and longer than I’ve enjoyed, and I believe in the love between the characters. So there’s no excuse, but it all feels lazy at this point. It’s weak, lacks a lot of substance, and holds no actual value to what the book is trying to pinpoint, mean, and show.
So far, this is my least favorite book by this author. It was underwhelming, disappointing, and didn’t offer anything it promised to give. However, even with the suspension of disbelief, I couldn’t get behind accepting and loving the characters and the relationship. But for anyone who does want to read anything by her, I love and highly recommend The Weight of It All, Galaxies and Oceans, On Davis Row, Exchange of Hearts, and the Missing Pieces trilogy.
The potential was there.
We are promised assassins, enemies to lovers, grumpy x sunshine, one-bed trope, us-against-them, and hate sex.
The execution, though, was not.
Somehow, it was these things exactly that disappointed me.
Every time I read a book that is promising a specific thing but ends up being just another loosely marketed one, it reminds me that I probably could write my own enemies to lovers with other favorite tropes and do the bare minimum for it, yet it would likely garner attention due to its marketing strategies. Perhaps it’s because I continue having high hopes for it, but whenever a book is promoted as “enemies to lovers,” I feel I’ll finally find the one I’m looking for. Sadly, it only ends up being the same enemies to lovers book as every other one I’ve read: we have our two main characters who hate each other for the first 10-20%, yet still find each other very attractive, to the point where their hatred is suddenly forgotten and taken over by their attractiveness. It’s such a weak structure. It shows how little development authors put into their relationship. It’s even sad how someone’s looks brainwash you entirely to the point where you find yourself attracted even though you hated every part of them only a little ago. Suddenly you don’t know who you are, everything has changed, and you feel the need to protect them. I wish someone could explain to me how exactly this works.
Enemies to lovers trope is not a superior trope for me. It’s weak, hardly ever developed, and has a repeated formula. In the case of The Kite, our two main characters, Harry and Asher, although they have a similar role, are enemies. Why? I have no fucking idea. We are told they hate each other and have to accept it. The lack of backstory on why they hate each other is one problem I found. We spend the book following them around as they run and hide together, but we never find out why they hate each other. Before we know it, they’re catching feelings. This structure is fragile, underdeveloped, and shows how little info you place on your character’s arcs to let the reader get to know them more. While we learn more about both of them later on, as they tell each other part of their stories, it’s at the point where both are attracted in a romantic and sexual sense. The lack of a backstory between passages didn’t help the characters’ non-existing chemistry. 20% in, one of Harry’s inner monologues is asking himself why Asher affects him and where the patience and indifference he’s prided himself in is. He asks, “What is it about Asher Garin that rankles me so much?” Honestly, I also want to know because we never really find out. Their relationship takes a 360 turn in a matter of pages and moments.
6% - Asher smiled, and good fucking lord, Harry hated him. “I want to put a gun to your head,” Harry mumbled. “So fucking bad.”
And what did Asher do? He laughed.
Harry pulled his pistol. “Tell me why I shouldn’t put a bullet in you.”
Asher didn’t even flinch. In fact, his smile became a smirk. Unbothered. Unbelievable.
(If their banter had continued like this without sex taking over most of the time they had together that wasn’t focused on running and hiding, it would have definitely made it more sexually tense, added to their growing connection, and overall friendship.)
29% - His head was telling him not to be stupid, but his heart was . . . well, his heart was now beginning to make decisions, and that scared the shit outta him.
(Look at how fucking early on his stupid heart got involved.)
31% - It really pissed Harry off that he enjoyed Asher’s company. As much as he annoyed him, as much as Asher infuriated him, Harry absolutely hated that he liked him.
(Okay but why? Why do you like him? What is there to like? He teases you and makes you want to shoot him in the head. Other than that, what development has happened?)
33% - Sure, he trusted Asher. Somewhat. But not that much.
(You trusted him enough to give his mouth your dick, so that’s enough, right?)
37% - “You won’t even look at me,” Asher yelled, this time in English, before he shoved Harry in the back.
(Imagine being in your 30s and throwing a tantrum as you pout because your supposed enemy won’t look at you, give you what you want (sexually) and is denying what his body wants? How pathetic.)
After this, they had a physical fight, Asher wanted to be dominated, so Harry did dominate, they gave in, had sex, went to sleep, woke up in the morning, day moved on.
45% - Asher grinned. “You are jealous.”
Yes, you are. Admit it. As much as you loathe this man, you like him too.
(What is there to like? All you’ve done is have oral and anal sex and bicker.)
46% - Asher laughed. “We’re all bad guys, Harry. You and me, we are the bad guys.” He shook his head, amused. “You kill for your government. I kill for anyone’s government. They might call it service or honourable duty, but it’s all murder.”
(Too bad the roles of being assassins were hardly relevant to the story)
51% - He liked Harry.
Sure, he was grumpy and his sense of humour could use some work, but he was also thoughtful and protective. And Asher knew, without a doubt, that Harry would have his back if and when it came down to it.
(Where can I find someone who likes me for two personality traits—being grumpy and having a boring sense of humor, but also because I’m a generic human being?)
63% - “You still angry? Pissed off? Wanna pummel something, Harry? You know I like it when you’re rough with me.”
(This is (unfortunately) how their relationship developed)
68% - “Please. He is . . . he is everything to me. Please. Did you see anything?”
(Since when?)
92% - “I don’t think my home was ever a place, Harry. I think that’s what this whole mess has taught me. I spent so many years longing for a normal life, for a home. But home for me was never a place or a country or a flag. It’s a person. And wherever he decides feels right for him, that’ll be okay with me.”
(Oh it’s the end already?)
There is no development as they run and hide together. Every moment is either sexual, formed through the desire and arousal they have, or they’re running because they’re being followed to be killed. Yet, in between those moments, there is nothing else being offered. Even though they are entirely and provably sexually attracted to an extreme (which I would have appreciated, along with the “hate sex” if it wasn’t the only thing they could do), the sexual tension between the two is primarily negative in the sense that it feels shameful at first (such as how Harry hates that he wants Asher physically, and Asher even gets mad at Harry because he won’t give in even though they both know he wants to). I’m not a fan of this kind of attraction. Look, I get it. They’re both men in their 30s, have some pent-up anger they want to release, and their hormones act are making them act like teenagers again. They don’t think with their mind but their body most of the time, and it takes only a couple of seconds to get them going. Yet, when it comes to sexual tension, which can lead to the emotional connection, especially in enemies to lovers, I expect it to be more, you know, tense? But it felt like there was no sexual tension. There were none of those moments that books tease us with–eye contact, desire but not giving in, getting closer to each other, wishing for a kiss, subtly making physical contact, admiration, and more. There weren’t any moments that made me believe in growing feelings between the two as we’re more perceptive of the character’s emotions.
I believe this book had a promising start when we met both Harry and Asher. Harry is the grump, always scowling, wishing Asher would shut up, and hardly ever smiles. His cold demeanor comes from the lack of connection he has to the world. He has a job to fulfill, missions to complete, and targets to get rid of. So he does as he says and moves on. On the other hand, Asher is the polar opposite–while not entirely a sunshine personality, his bright self is more prominent. Instead of scowling all the time, he maintains his bright smile to earn himself a good reputation. While he also has a role in fulfilling tasks to care for, he carries scars from his past. Having no loyalty, nationality, family, or home, he sticks to himself with the help of his informant. What starts as a back and forth, push and pull, teasing, bickering, and even fun banter turns into annoyance, repetition, and confusion. Even with suspension of disbelief, which I didn’t need to do here (mostly because I’m used to it already when it comes to military/action media), I couldn’t get behind the relationship. No matter how fun, entertaining, and funny the banter between our protagonists is, it adds nothing when it doesn’t further the attraction they’re trying to deny. Most of it is because it only started a certain way. Still, once things began changing gears and getting steamier, most of their conversations felt the same, with sex added to it. Asher started to push Harry’s buttons sexually, and Harry wanted to deny his sexual attraction but couldn’t resist. Most of the time they spend together is either of them having sex or figuring out their following location to run away to.
I’ve said this before, but for two opposites and “enemies,” the relationship was fast-paced. Not only with the lack of development, but I couldn’t figure out what exactly the two characters liked from each other. It felt like they only acted like their personality traits, and there wasn’t anything else they could offer. It happened too quickly. Sex is also not something that verifies a connection between the characters. Instead, it makes it less believable, underwhelming, and more disappointing overall. If you’re not going to give me a reason to believe in two characters falling in love, especially two men who had never fallen in love before, had trust issues the entire beginning of the book, and have roles that aren’t the exact best spot to be in when you’re vulnerable, I’m not going to be rooting for the couple at all. I know N.R. Walker is known for her low-angst, comforting reads that make love seem easy. Still, considering how she decided to take a different route in her writing here and write something new, it should be expected that there needs to be more growth added. I’ve read books from this author that are shorter and longer than I’ve enjoyed, and I believe in the love between the characters. So there’s no excuse, but it all feels lazy at this point. It’s weak, lacks a lot of substance, and holds no actual value to what the book is trying to pinpoint, mean, and show.
So far, this is my least favorite book by this author. It was underwhelming, disappointing, and didn’t offer anything it promised to give. However, even with the suspension of disbelief, I couldn’t get behind accepting and loving the characters and the relationship. But for anyone who does want to read anything by her, I love and highly recommend The Weight of It All, Galaxies and Oceans, On Davis Row, Exchange of Hearts, and the Missing Pieces trilogy.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Kite.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
June 14, 2022
– Shelved
June 27, 2022
–
Started Reading
June 28, 2022
–
29.0%
"As he watched Asher sleep, Harry could feel something under his ribs, something he’d never felt before. A need, an ember to begin with but beginning to burn a little warmer.
The need to protect him.
WHEN? WHERE? WHY? HOW?"
The need to protect him.
WHEN? WHERE? WHY? HOW?"
June 29, 2022
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 51-88 of 88 (88 new)
date
newest »
RIP let’s just refrain from reading blurbs and tropes and go in absolutely blind, so we have no expectations and can’t be as disappointed because these new releases haven’t been it 🙃 I was going to wait for the audiobook to come out, but now my desire to actually start on this is at an all-time low 💀 I’m trying to count how many successful 2022 releases I’ve had so far, and uh….let’s just say if it’s a sign for how the second half of the year is going to look, it ain’t promising 🫠 Here’s hoping NR Walker channels the tender scenes in her older works in the future so the relationship doesn’t fall flat! Awesome review, Elena! 💖
Nelly wrote: "Wonderful review, Elena💚 and sorry this was such a disappointment! From what I can see so far this seems to be the prevailing view, but I love how you’ve broken down your criticisms with such detail."
thank you so much, nelly! that means a lot. i always try to be as honest and critical (if i have to) and i’ve recently been writing reviews differently than how i usually do, so it’s been difficult adjusting lol.
thank you so much, nelly! that means a lot. i always try to be as honest and critical (if i have to) and i’ve recently been writing reviews differently than how i usually do, so it’s been difficult adjusting lol.
NRW’s older work is hit or miss. I either absolutely love it absolutely hate it. But what I love I really really love. There are some audios when she still used Joel that I’ve listened to repeatedly. But the bad old stuff and the new stuff makes me wonder if she uses ghost writers. 🥴
NicoleR.M.M. wrote: "I love your review, Elena. Very thoroughly putting your reasons into words. I agree 100% with you. I love the enemies to lovers trope but rarely find the right book either. I hate it when they forg..."
thank you so much, nicole! your words always mean so much to me. <3 i'm glad you understand where i'm coming from lol. it's as if the characters never even hated each other in the first place! makes no sense to me how they stop disliking each other within a few pages. two of the books you mentioned are also two of my favorites, but it seems like many have been having problems with nrw's newest releases. i love her diverse writing and how she writes different themes and tropes, but i've definitely had more luck with her older works (even though it seems like a mix). i'm hoping to read more of her backlist before her future release comes out, and hopefully it will make up for this one.
thank you so much, nicole! your words always mean so much to me. <3 i'm glad you understand where i'm coming from lol. it's as if the characters never even hated each other in the first place! makes no sense to me how they stop disliking each other within a few pages. two of the books you mentioned are also two of my favorites, but it seems like many have been having problems with nrw's newest releases. i love her diverse writing and how she writes different themes and tropes, but i've definitely had more luck with her older works (even though it seems like a mix). i'm hoping to read more of her backlist before her future release comes out, and hopefully it will make up for this one.
aly wrote: "naw sorry u didnt enjoy this. as we agreed upon, enemies to lovers really hard to love to especially when they write something like this, but from the trope itself, the book does sound interesting...."
thank you, aly! it did have potential, especially because it sounded like something completely new from the author and i was really interested in it. even though the enemies to lovers trope wasn't what pulled me it, it still interested me and i was even surprised the author was writing something like this.
thank you, aly! it did have potential, especially because it sounded like something completely new from the author and i was really interested in it. even though the enemies to lovers trope wasn't what pulled me it, it still interested me and i was even surprised the author was writing something like this.
message 57:
by
len ❀ [small hiatus due to studying]
(last edited Jul 01, 2022 10:50PM)
(new)
-
rated it 1 star
Kirsten wrote: "Loved this, and I agree that most enemies aren’t. Do you have a good use of this trope to recommend?"
thanks, kirsten! unfortunately i don't. i don't actively look for books with the trope, but i also still read books with it. however, i still have yet to read one where they're actually enemies and the relationship develops in a believable manner from hate to friends to love. so far, i've heard that Special Forces - Soldiers is actually enemies to lovers. one of my closest friends here loves the tropes and considers it one of her favorites. she's told me she also hasn't really read any enemies to lovers where they actually hate each other except that one. i haven't read it and don't plan to because i heard what happens in book 2 and i don't want to deal with that lol. other than that, unfortunately, i don't have any recommendations.
thanks, kirsten! unfortunately i don't. i don't actively look for books with the trope, but i also still read books with it. however, i still have yet to read one where they're actually enemies and the relationship develops in a believable manner from hate to friends to love. so far, i've heard that Special Forces - Soldiers is actually enemies to lovers. one of my closest friends here loves the tropes and considers it one of her favorites. she's told me she also hasn't really read any enemies to lovers where they actually hate each other except that one. i haven't read it and don't plan to because i heard what happens in book 2 and i don't want to deal with that lol. other than that, unfortunately, i don't have any recommendations.
RoshReviews wrote: "Wonderfully detailed review, Elena! I can sense your frustration over this read so strongly. The enemies-to-lovers trope is anyway overused in this genre nowadays, and looking at your feedback. I w..."
thanks, rosh! it sadly is. i understand how it's a favorite for many, but it would be more appreciated if it was properly executed. but i won't get on board and believe in anything when you give me two "enemies" who no longer hate each other because they're hot for each other. it's overused and really just doesn't make sense to me. but to each their own lol.
thanks, rosh! it sadly is. i understand how it's a favorite for many, but it would be more appreciated if it was properly executed. but i won't get on board and believe in anything when you give me two "enemies" who no longer hate each other because they're hot for each other. it's overused and really just doesn't make sense to me. but to each their own lol.
You really outdid yourself with this review, Elena! As someone who doesn't really read romance I still found myself agreeing with your points! Part of the reason I find the genre so difficult to break into is because the tropes (like enemies to lovers) is underdeveloped & is just the same regurgitation of it being presented in another book. It gives me no pull to want to try another book with the trope because it feels like I'm going to encounter the exact same thing over & over again. I think you should write your own book! If only for the enjoyment of piecing together what you want to see - why not! I'd read that haha :) xx
message 61:
by
len ❀ [small hiatus due to studying]
(last edited Jul 02, 2022 10:19AM)
(new)
-
rated it 1 star
Liya wrote: "Sorry, it was so bad for you. I went into it with no expectations and ended up enjoying it a lot. I don't think they ever hated or have any other deep emotions towards each other before being on th..."
i’ve been going into books with low or no expectations now but even then it doesn’t help. the fact that they never hated each other wouldn’t have been a problem if it wasn’t promoted as it. something on their history would have helped add more to their characters but we were just thrown into everything and i’m not a fan of that. i’m glad this worked well for you though! i’m a fan of these type of books even if i don’t read them often and i don’t take them seriously. the action wasn’t hard to read and suspending disbelief either because i usually do it anyway, but it was the characters themselves. i’m more of a character > plot type of reader anyway so when i don’t like the characters it’s going to be difficult to enjoy the book, even if i like the vibe of it.
i’ve been going into books with low or no expectations now but even then it doesn’t help. the fact that they never hated each other wouldn’t have been a problem if it wasn’t promoted as it. something on their history would have helped add more to their characters but we were just thrown into everything and i’m not a fan of that. i’m glad this worked well for you though! i’m a fan of these type of books even if i don’t read them often and i don’t take them seriously. the action wasn’t hard to read and suspending disbelief either because i usually do it anyway, but it was the characters themselves. i’m more of a character > plot type of reader anyway so when i don’t like the characters it’s going to be difficult to enjoy the book, even if i like the vibe of it.
Florence wrote: "Lovely review elena! So sorry this one didn't work for you, it's such a shame that it didn't meet your expectations because it sounded absolutely perfect, such a shame that didn't deliver on the pr..."
thanks, florence! it really is. i didn’t have high expectations per se, especially with what the book was about, but i still had hoped the book would have delivered on what it said it would.
thanks, florence! it really is. i didn’t have high expectations per se, especially with what the book was about, but i still had hoped the book would have delivered on what it said it would.
suz ~Always Reading~ wrote: "Great review Elena! I am disappointed a lot with enemies to lovers and I always think they act on attraction so fast and then oops they’re in love! All within the first 20% of the book. Nope, that’..."
thanks, suz! i agree 100%. it doesn’t make sense to me at all how fast they start becoming attracted. there’s never any build up, and it feels like it’s only sexually based which makes it even more frustrating because then the characters are only appreciated by their “enemy” on a physical level. i’m not saying you can’t deny finding someone attractive even if you don’t like them, but my problem is how that attractiveness starts becoming the reason they don’t hate each other anymore. somehow. it’s like because they’re so hot, suddenly the hate is gone. i’ve had good and bad experiences with this author with her newest and older works, but mostly with her newer works. i still want to read her books, but it seems like many have felt the same in how her newer works are most disappointing. and sadly i don’t have any enemies to lovers recommendations. i hardly have read the trope because i’ve had this problem since the beginning. i don’t actively seek the trope and the trope doesn’t pull me in when a book is promoted as having it. in fact it makes me less excited lmao cause i know it won’t work out.
thanks, suz! i agree 100%. it doesn’t make sense to me at all how fast they start becoming attracted. there’s never any build up, and it feels like it’s only sexually based which makes it even more frustrating because then the characters are only appreciated by their “enemy” on a physical level. i’m not saying you can’t deny finding someone attractive even if you don’t like them, but my problem is how that attractiveness starts becoming the reason they don’t hate each other anymore. somehow. it’s like because they’re so hot, suddenly the hate is gone. i’ve had good and bad experiences with this author with her newest and older works, but mostly with her newer works. i still want to read her books, but it seems like many have felt the same in how her newer works are most disappointing. and sadly i don’t have any enemies to lovers recommendations. i hardly have read the trope because i’ve had this problem since the beginning. i don’t actively seek the trope and the trope doesn’t pull me in when a book is promoted as having it. in fact it makes me less excited lmao cause i know it won’t work out.
Lilith wrote: "Im sorry that you didn’t enjoy it~ but love your detailed review ! I agree with you that enemies to lovers is troupe that is hard to get right. It’s not one of the troupes I’d say it’s my fave fave..."
thank you, lilith! i can see how and why many people love it, but sadly i always have high hopes for it. it just doesn’t make sense to me, especially when there’s hardly any build up. i avoid it when i can because i know i’ll always be disappointed, so i’d rather not read books with it. i don’t actively seek it either but i still read it since there’s books by authors i like that i want to read. it’s not the trope that makes me curious though. sadly i haven’t found an ETL book that i’ve really enjoyed, especially with that dynamic. i don’t think i ever will if i’m being honest.
thank you, lilith! i can see how and why many people love it, but sadly i always have high hopes for it. it just doesn’t make sense to me, especially when there’s hardly any build up. i avoid it when i can because i know i’ll always be disappointed, so i’d rather not read books with it. i don’t actively seek it either but i still read it since there’s books by authors i like that i want to read. it’s not the trope that makes me curious though. sadly i haven’t found an ETL book that i’ve really enjoyed, especially with that dynamic. i don’t think i ever will if i’m being honest.
I'm sorry this one let you down, Elena. I always love how thoughtfully you break down what you liked and didn't like in your reviews. A stellar one as always! 💕
Amazing review, the enemies to lovers trope is rarely done well it sucks but I loved your review bruh, pure masterpiece.
alyssa wrote: "RIP let’s just refrain from reading blurbs and tropes and go in absolutely blind, so we have no expectations and can’t be as disappointed because these new releases haven’t been it 🙃 I was going to..."
ugh i wish i could but i choose books based off blurbs and authors, sometimes one or the other or both. 😭 you’re right about these new releases being disappointing though. maybe 2022 really isn’t the year for mm romance. 😂 it’s why i like reading books released in previous years bc if i was only reading this years releases my average rating would be suffering even more lmao. i’d say still give this one a shot since i’ve noticed we have different tastes when it comes to these hype of books (temporary partner comes to mind), but overall it’s not an nrw favorite and not one i recommend at all either. hopefully nrw’s future releases make up for this one! and thank you! 💖
ugh i wish i could but i choose books based off blurbs and authors, sometimes one or the other or both. 😭 you’re right about these new releases being disappointing though. maybe 2022 really isn’t the year for mm romance. 😂 it’s why i like reading books released in previous years bc if i was only reading this years releases my average rating would be suffering even more lmao. i’d say still give this one a shot since i’ve noticed we have different tastes when it comes to these hype of books (temporary partner comes to mind), but overall it’s not an nrw favorite and not one i recommend at all either. hopefully nrw’s future releases make up for this one! and thank you! 💖
Rin wrote: "NRW’s older work is hit or miss. I either absolutely love it absolutely hate it. But what I love I really really love. There are some audios when she still used Joel that I’ve listened to repeatedl..."
tbh i feel the same. i’ve read a mix of her older and newer work and have mixed thoughts but i’ve noticed her older books have worked better. she’s someone i can’t easily give up on though. i’m really hoping whatever she releases in the future will make up for this one. i still have yet to read her other newest release of this year, davo, but i also haven’t heard that many great things. it seems like 2022 itself sucks when it comes to these new releases. i’ve seen a few friends express concern over how her writing has changed but i haven’t really noticed or minded too much. 🤷🏻♀️
tbh i feel the same. i’ve read a mix of her older and newer work and have mixed thoughts but i’ve noticed her older books have worked better. she’s someone i can’t easily give up on though. i’m really hoping whatever she releases in the future will make up for this one. i still have yet to read her other newest release of this year, davo, but i also haven’t heard that many great things. it seems like 2022 itself sucks when it comes to these new releases. i’ve seen a few friends express concern over how her writing has changed but i haven’t really noticed or minded too much. 🤷🏻♀️
Denise wrote: "thank you for the honest review dear Elena ! :) We appreciate it !"
always happy to help!
always happy to help!
Chantel wrote: "You really outdid yourself with this review, Elena! As someone who doesn't really read romance I still found myself agreeing with your points! Part of the reason I find the genre so difficult to br..."
thank you so much, chantel! your kind words always mean so much. 💚 in my opinion, you’re not missing out not giving the trope another chance because you’re absolutely correct - it’s always underdeveloped and feels the same all the time. it’s why i don’t actively seek it either and don’t consider it a favorite or one that pulls me into the book. and lol i wish i could write my own book. 😂 if only the elementary school me never gave up on that dream. but thank you! i would definitely put exactly what all these so-called enemies to lovers books are missing.
thank you so much, chantel! your kind words always mean so much. 💚 in my opinion, you’re not missing out not giving the trope another chance because you’re absolutely correct - it’s always underdeveloped and feels the same all the time. it’s why i don’t actively seek it either and don’t consider it a favorite or one that pulls me into the book. and lol i wish i could write my own book. 😂 if only the elementary school me never gave up on that dream. but thank you! i would definitely put exactly what all these so-called enemies to lovers books are missing.
Kat wrote: "I'm sorry this one let you down, Elena. I always love how thoughtfully you break down what you liked and didn't like in your reviews. A stellar one as always! 💕"
thank you so much, kat! 💖
thank you so much, kat! 💖
Pinky wrote: "Amazing review, the enemies to lovers trope is rarely done well it sucks but I loved your review bruh, pure masterpiece."
hehe thank you, pinky! it really is. 🤷🏻♀️
hehe thank you, pinky! it really is. 🤷🏻♀️
Great review - I love how you outlined all the common disappointments with enemies to lovers. I do love the trope but it so often fails, without real tension to start with or too easily resolved. Do you have any favourites mm reads that do a good job?
message 75:
by
len ❀ [small hiatus due to studying]
(last edited Oct 21, 2023 08:31AM)
(new)
-
rated it 1 star
Tia wrote: "Great review - I love how you outlined all the common disappointments with enemies to lovers. I do love the trope but it so often fails, without real tension to start with or too easily resolved. D..."
thank you! 🤍 unfortunately i don’t have any recommendations not only because i don’t really read the trope, but because it’s never done the way i like it. i’ve heard from a few people that Special Forces - Soldiers is accurate in the enemies to lovers trope but i haven’t read it myself.
thank you! 🤍 unfortunately i don’t have any recommendations not only because i don’t really read the trope, but because it’s never done the way i like it. i’ve heard from a few people that Special Forces - Soldiers is accurate in the enemies to lovers trope but i haven’t read it myself.
I read this review when you first published it, but wow, it's a great one. And, it's sadly applicable to many books. I'm feeling similarly about Unhinged (though I was warned of the insta-love). It bothers me so much when character's inner monologue says things about their heart feelings things, and how they like being around them. So often, authors fail at the simple task to "show, don't tell". Anyway, this review is eloquent and thorough as always, Elena. I hope that your next read by this author is more fulfilling. I understand how disappointing it is not not enjoy a work by your favourite author. 💕
I Love NR Walker bur your review is spot on. Harry is the dumbest Assasin I've ever read about. Well, they both are but he takes the cake. And it's all childish talk.
gloria .☆゚. wrote: "I read this review when you first published it, but wow, it's a great one. And, it's sadly applicable to many books. I'm feeling similarly about Unhinged (though I was warned of the insta-love). It..."
i’m sorry for responding so late but better now than never. 😭
but thanks, gloria! i don’t even mind insta love to be honest but yeah, many authors fail to show more than tell. and it sucks even more because this was supposed to be an enemies to lovers story. not enemies with benefits, just enemies. the banter was definitely looking promising at first but it never continues that way. seeing the development go from hate and dislike to lust and confusion to love and adoration would’ve been so good, but this was all just lust and pretend hate.
i’m sorry for responding so late but better now than never. 😭
but thanks, gloria! i don’t even mind insta love to be honest but yeah, many authors fail to show more than tell. and it sucks even more because this was supposed to be an enemies to lovers story. not enemies with benefits, just enemies. the banter was definitely looking promising at first but it never continues that way. seeing the development go from hate and dislike to lust and confusion to love and adoration would’ve been so good, but this was all just lust and pretend hate.
Ula'ndi wrote: "I Love NR Walker bur your review is spot on. Harry is the dumbest Assasin I've ever read about. Well, they both are but he takes the cake. And it's all childish talk."
right!? it was so bad. plus the assassins role was so irrelevant and hardly a part of the story. i even forgot they were apparently these ruthless killers. anyway i’m glad you agree.
right!? it was so bad. plus the assassins role was so irrelevant and hardly a part of the story. i even forgot they were apparently these ruthless killers. anyway i’m glad you agree.
I had the same experience as Rebecca. I'm halfway through but I am not finishing this book. I want to like through characters but not vested enough in them. Too bad. The book had potential.
I don't agree with your opinion of the book in general but your review was really well-written and you made some excellent points in it.
I too wondered about their history. When Harry first noticed that it was Asher pointing a gun at him he did fire his own gun and we have no idea why. They seemed to have met before but there were no mentions of anything like that and we're left wondering why Harry didn't fire the shot. They said that Asher was an enigma and if I recall correctly the people after them didn't even have a photo of him so how did Harry know it was him?
I would love to befriend you so I can get more tips about books I can read, if you're still active here that is.
I too wondered about their history. When Harry first noticed that it was Asher pointing a gun at him he did fire his own gun and we have no idea why. They seemed to have met before but there were no mentions of anything like that and we're left wondering why Harry didn't fire the shot. They said that Asher was an enigma and if I recall correctly the people after them didn't even have a photo of him so how did Harry know it was him?
I would love to befriend you so I can get more tips about books I can read, if you're still active here that is.
Krita wrote: "I had the same experience as Rebecca. I'm halfway through but I am not finishing this book. I want to like through characters but not vested enough in them. Too bad. The book had potential."
agreed.
agreed.
Jennifer wrote: "I don't agree with your opinion of the book in general but your review was really well-written and you made some excellent points in it.
I too wondered about their history. When Harry first notice..."
thank you so much! i wish more people could be like you and understand that peoples opinions are gonna vary.
i’m sorry for replying late but sadly, even with my review, i don’t remember anything lol. but yeah, i do remember asher was described as an enigma, and i’m all for this but i remember not learning a lot of depth about his characters. this story really had potential but sadly it was lacking in everything for me. i found everything so pathetic.
I too wondered about their history. When Harry first notice..."
thank you so much! i wish more people could be like you and understand that peoples opinions are gonna vary.
i’m sorry for replying late but sadly, even with my review, i don’t remember anything lol. but yeah, i do remember asher was described as an enigma, and i’m all for this but i remember not learning a lot of depth about his characters. this story really had potential but sadly it was lacking in everything for me. i found everything so pathetic.
thank you! <3