A 12.
47 kV Medium Voltage Input 350 kW
     EV Fast Charger using 10 kV SiC MOSFET
            Xinyu Liang, Srdjan Srdic, Jehyuk Won, Erick Aponte, Kristen Booth and Srdjan Lukic
                 FREEDM Systems Center in Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering
                                         North Carolina State University
                                         Raleigh, North Carolina, USA
  xliang5@ncsu.edu, ssrdic@ncsu.edu, jwon2@ncsu.edu, eaponte2@ncsu.edu , kegarcia@ncsu.edu, smlukic@ncsu.edu
     Abstract—This paper presents a medium-voltage (MV)         based dual active bridge (DAB) modular approach which
  (12.47 kV), 350 kW electric vehicle (EV) fast charger using   boosts the system switching frequency to 20 kHz. In
  10 kV SiC MOSFETs. Detailed system design procedure           [2], a higher device utilization multi-cell boost (MCB)
  based on the 10 kV SiC MOSFET characterization is
  presented to provide a guide on the 10 kV SiC MOSFET          based modular topology was selected to build a 50 kW
  converter development. Taking the advantage of the 10         MV fast charger using 1.2 kV silicon carbide (SiC)
  kV SiC MOSFET’s high voltage blocking capability and          MOSFETs which achieved 50 kHz switching frequency
  efficient switching performance, a single module high         with smaller number of modules and power density
  power density system is designed with the DC/DC stage         higher than 0.5 kW/L. Though using SiC MOSFETs
  operates at 25 kHz and the simulated system efficiency
  exceeds 98%, input current THD lower than 2%. With            helps improve the system efficiency due to reduced
  all the passive components selected, the designed system      switching and conduction losses, the limited blocking
  power density is 1.6 kW/L.                                    voltage requires the connection of many modules in
     Index Terms—component, formatting, style, styling, in-     series in order to block the MV input. This modular
  sert                                                          approach increases the system complexity and highly
                                                                affects the reliability of the MV fast charger, due to the
                     I. I NTRODUCTION
                                                                increased component count.
     With ever increasing electric vehicle (EV) battery
  capacity, high-power chargers are needed to provide              In recent years, Wolfspeed has developed and pack-
  a gas-station like refueling experience for EVs. Fast         aged 10 kV SiC device prototypes and have made
  chargers with a 150 kW-350 kW capacity have recently          these devices available to researchers. These devices
  been introduced to the marketplace as product offerings       have substantially lower switching loss and specific on-
  [1]. The approach to designing chargers is to supply          resistance compared to the Si IGBT of the same voltage
  low voltage 3-phase service (480 V in the US) to these        level [8]. With the maturity of the device gate drivers
  chargers. This approach requires a step down transformer      and characterization techniques [9], [10], a number of
  and handling of very larger currents on the AC side,          prototypes that use these devices have been developed
  especially on site supplies multiple 350kW chargers.          and demonstrates including 100 kW rating MV ac SST
  Recently [2] researchers have proposed connecting EV          [11], MV dc SST [12], [13] and impedance measurement
  fast charger directly to the MV line, through a solid-        unit [14].
  state transformer, thus improving system efficiency, and
                                                                   Based on the published data, five prospective MV
  reducing system footprint [3].
                                                                rectifier topologies are selected and some of their basic
     Though the SST based MV fast charger eliminates the
                                                                feasures are summarized and compared in Table I. In
  need for a service transformer and provides a significant
                                                                this paper, a modification topology of [2] shown in Fig.
  reduction in system footprint, the direct connection to
                                                                1 is selected to build the standard 12.47 kV voltage level
  MV requires high voltage blocking capability of the
                                                                input 3 phase 350 kW dc fast charger. The 10 kV device
  converters. As a result, many MV fast charger proto-
                                                                blocking capability enables direct connection to the 7.2
  types use high-voltage IGBTs with the overall switch-
                                                                kV line-to-neutral voltage using the topology. In this pa-
  ing frequency lower than 10 kHz with bulky passive
                                                                per we present a detailed design procedure including the
  components and relatively low power density [4]–[6].
                                                                semiconductor selection and characterization, operating
  Researchers in [7] use more efficient silicon MOSFET
                                                                frequency and passive component design as well as the
                                                                system efficiency optimization.
978-1-5386-8330-9/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE                      581
                                                        TABLE I
                           BASIC M ETRICS S UMMARY AND C OMPARISON FOR C ANDIDATE T OPOLOGIES
                 Metric                       CVR          MCB        Active MCB           HB           Single Stage ANPC
            10 kV MOSFETs                      20           18             24               12                   18
           1.2 kV MOSFETs                       0           0              12               12                   12
              10 kV Diodes                     16           12             6                 0                    0
             1.2 kV Diodes                      8           12             0                 0                    0
     SiC Semiconductor Devices Total           44           78             78               72                   66
     Medium Frequency Transformers              2           3              3                 6                    3
        Hard-Switched MOSFETs                  16           12             6                 0                    0
           Control Complexity                 High        Medium        Medium            Medium               High
      Fig. 1. The topology of MV 350 kW EV fast charger
II. E VALUATION AND C HARACTERIZATION OF 10 K V
                 S I C MOSFET S
   The semiconductors selected for the MV fast charger
prototype are shown in Fig. 1. Each input rectifier diode
consists of three series connected silicon SK Na 47/45
diode from SEMIKRON. A boost type and a buck type
connected 10 kV SiC MOSFET and Schottky Diode are
packaged in XHV-9 module to form a three level boost
(TLB) circuit as the front PFC stage. Three separate
half bridge legs are packaged in a XHV-6 module to
form the primary side of the active NPC (ANPC) based
dual active bridge (DAB) converter. Because of the
high voltage conversion ratio, the RMS current on the
secondary side of the ANPC DAB is very large, so two
CAS325M12HM2 module 1.2 kV SiC MOSFET with
RdsON = 12mΩ are used to form a full bridge on the
secondary side.                                                    Fig. 2. (a) Circuit for the double pulse test with parasitic component
   Devices were characterized using the double pulse               values, (b) DPT setup for the 10 kV SiC MOSFETs characterization
tester (DPT) shown in Fig. 2. The DPT was used to
measure the device switching losses so that passive
component values and operating frequencies could be
determined. The DPT uses P6015A high-voltage passive
                                                             582
Fig. 3. (a) 10 kV SiC MOSFETs double pulse test waveforms at 15 A conduction current with variable input voltage, (b) 10 kV SiC MOSFETs
double pulse test waveforms at 7 kV input voltage with variable conduction current
probe for the voltage sensing. A 0.1017Ω SSDN-414-
10 shunt resistor with 2 MHz bandwidth is used for
the current sensing after de-skewing with the voltage
probe. As shown in Fig. 2(a), since the device under
test (DUT) is operating at medium voltage, a large air-
core inductor with a large inductance is needed for the
freewheeling. The air core inductor parasitic capacitance
must be as small as possible so as not to introduce
additional discharging current during the turn OFF test.
Based on [15], the Coss of the DUT is around 160 nF.
By separating the multi-layer distance, a 3 mH inductor
with 25 nF stray capacitance was designed and built.
                                                                      Fig. 5. Switching loss model for the 10 kV SiC MOSFET used in the
                                                                      PLECS simulation
Fig. 4. 10 kV SiC MOSFET switching energy with respect to different   Fig. 6. Die temperature captured by thermal image camera during a
gate resistance, and different current tested at 7 kV, 25◦ C          105◦ C double pulse test
   Complete device characterization considering gating
resistance, input voltage and die temperature was per-                blue trace is half of the input voltage source measured on
formed using the DPT setup. Fig. 3 shows the experi-                  one of the two series connected dc-link capacitor. Figure
mental waveform for the 7 kV double pulse test with                   4 shows that the switching energy decreases significantly
a gate resistor 5Ω at die temperature 25◦ C, where the                as the gate resistance reduces from Rg = 20Ω to
green trace is Vds of the DUT’s lower switch, pink trace              Rg = 5Ω. Further gate resistance reduction does not
is the voltage measured on the shunt resistor and the dark            lead to major loss reduction, while leading to significant
                                                                  583
voltage overshoot during the switching transient, which            must be larger than 10.2 kV. We selected 13.8 kV to
may cause severe EMI issues. As a result, Rg = 5Ω                  provide enough operating margin for the boost converter.
is chosen as the gate resistance. To develop a loss vs             Since each 10 kV device in the NPC configuration
temperature dynamic model of the switching device with             only needs to block half of the voltage 6.9 kV, each
given gate resistance, double pulse tests with variable die        device operates well within its safe operating area. On
temperature have been conducted. In order to regulate              the secondary side of the DAB, the nominal voltage
the die temperature, a die, module and ambient steady              should be close to primary side nominal voltage, so
state is reached by heating up the entire module with              that RMS current and the reactive power is minimized
hotplate. The double pulse frequency is set to 1 Hz so             [18]. With the transformer turn ratio of 8:1, the 850
that the switching and conduction losses don’t provide             V secondary side voltage induces 6.8 kV in the pri-
significant transient temperature change. Thus a device            mary side of the transformer. The electrolytic capacitor
loss look up table model with respect to Vdd , Id and T            500MXH390MEFCSN30X60 of 390 µF /500 V were
is created and is shown in Fig. 5. Fig. 6 shows the die            selected as the dc link capacitors. 16 capacitors are
temperature of the DUT during the testing captured by              connected in series to support the full voltage of 6900
a thermal camera.                                                  V. Two of the electrolytic capacitors are connected in
                                                                   parallel to enlarge the overall capacitance which gives a
   III. S YSTEM PARAMETER D ESIGN AND PASSIVE
                                                                   50 µF dc link capacitance. An additional film capacitor
              C OMPONENT S ELECTION
                                                                   bank which consist of 8 parallel 4 series connected
   Using the thermal model shown in Fig. 5, we devel-              PHE450SD6100JR06L2 capacitors rated at 0.1 µF /2 kV
oped a complete system simulation in PLECS, which                  gives an overall 1.12 µF decoupling capacitance. The
allowed us to select the device switching frequency and            film capacitors 944U470K122AAM of 47 µF /1200V
the values of the passive components. For the control of           were used for the secondary side output voltage filtering.
the TLB PFC stage, the predictive current control method           6 capacitors are connected in parallel to enlarge the
described in [16] is implemented so that low THD could             output capacitance.
be achieved with relatively small input inductance. For               The input inductor and the high frequency transformer
the DAB stage, a traditional triple phase shift (TPS)              were custom designed for the specific application. The
control method [17] is implemented to achieve output               input inductor was made by using 10 stacked MPP toroid
voltage regulation as well as soft-switching. The system           cores 0055868A2 with 120 turns of 10 AWG litz wire.
control scheme is shown in Fig. 7.                                 The designed inductance at 20 A current was around 4
                                                                   mH. The high frequency transformer was made by using
                                                                   10 N87 Ferriet U-shape cores with the transfer ratio of
                                                                   80:10 turns of high voltage side 10 AWG low voltage
                                                                   side 7 thread twisted 10 AWG litz wire. The transformer
                                                                   parameters were measured using AP Instruments’ Model
                                                                   300 Frequency Response Analyzer with a coupling ca-
                                                                   pacitance 57 pF and leakage inductance 2.5 mH. The
                                                                   transformer loss was determined experimentally using
                                                                   the setup and circuit shown in Fig. 8. The single N87
                                                                   core with 10:10 turn ratio is tested with the secondary
                                                                   side opened at both 25 kHz and 50 kHz to determine the
                                                                   magnetic core loss. Fig. 9 shows a testing waveform at
                                                                   50 kHz 300 V input voltage where the dark blue trace
                                                                   is the voltage of the primary side of the transformer,
                                                                   light blue trace is the voltage of the secondary side of
                                                                   the transformer and the purple trace is the current on
                                                                   the primary side. The system hardware and component
                                                                   selection is shown in TABLE. II.
                                                                      Switching frequency optimization has been done
Fig. 7. per phase system control scheme for 10 kV 350 kW EV fast
charger                                                            through the loss model based thermal simulations. Since
                                                                   the boost PFC stage is hard switching, a lower switching
   For the correct operation of the boost converter, the           frequency is preferred. However, the switching frequency
DC-link voltage at the output must be larger than the              can not be too low since the current ripple increases
peak value of the input waveform. Therefore, for the               with the decrease of the switching frequency resulting
rectified 7.2 kV RMS input system, the DC bus voltage              a higher switch off current to provide higher switching
                                                               584
                                                              TABLE II
                                         S YSTEM H ARDWARE AND C OMPONENT S ELECTION R ESULTS
                             ITEM                                     PART NO.                                VALUE
                     Input Diode Heatsink                     Fischer Elektronik K 5 M8                    Rth =5 K/W
                10 kV SiC MOSFET Heatsink                   Fischer Elektronik SK 497 200                Rth =0.55 K/W
                1.2 kV SiC MOSFET Heatsink                   Fischer Elektronik LA 7/150                 Rth =0.75 K/W
                      DC-Link Capacitor                      500MXH390MEFCSN30X60                        390 µF , 500 V
                     Decoupling Capacitor                       PHE450SD6100JR06L2                       0.1 µF , 2000 V
                       Output Capacitor                           944U470K122AAM                         47 µF , 1200 V
                      Input Inductor Core                             0055868A2                          MPP Toroid 026
                       Transformer Core                           B67385G0000X187                      Ferrite U-shape N87
                                                                           Fig. 10. boost stage switching frequency optimization shown in
                                                                           normalized value where heatsink temp base is 70.36◦ C, input current
                                                                           ripple base is 29 A, input diode loss base is 214 W, input current THD
                                                                           base is 19% and boost stage loss base is 716 W
Fig. 8. (a) Circuit for the transformer core loss characterization, (b)
Hardware setup for the transformer core loss test, (c) Transformer built
based on the system design using N87 U-shape cores
                                                                           Fig. 11. dual active bridge stage switching frequency and leakage
                                                                           inductance optimization results
   Fig. 9. Transformer core loss test waveform at 50 kHz, 300V
                                                                       585
               Fig. 12. Detailed system loss breakdown and heatsink temperature of the rated power thermal simulation
losses. Also, low switching frequency results in high
THD which deficit PFC function. Based on electrical and
thermal simulations, the TLB stage switching frequency
was selected to be 10 kHz which is shown in Fig. 10
where a maximum THD and current ripple requirement
is set. High switching frequency helps to reduce the pas-
sive component value which reflects as a lower magnetic
loss in the high frequency transformer. However, higher
switching frequency provides higher switching losses as
well. At the same time, leakage inductance affects the
reactive power which is related to the conduction losses
of the system. The DAB optimization is shown in Fig.               Fig. 14. (a) 3D rendering for one phase of the proposed 350 kW
                                                                   EV fast charger with the proposed design (b) stack design of the
11. Considering the feasibility of the leakage inductance          high voltage side dc bus bar and capacitor bank to minimize the loop
in 90 kV level insulation the DAB stage is chosen to               inductance
operate at 25 kHz to allow sufficient power transfer,
given the moderate (1.5 mH) leakage inductance. With                                 IV. C ONCLUSION
this operating frequency a primary to secondary side                  This paper presents the design procedure of a 12.47
phase shift of 50◦ , delivers the target 350 kW. Fig. 12           kV Input 350 kW EV fast charger using 10 kV SiC
shows the detailed simulated loss breakdown, where the             MOSFET. The 10 kV SiC MOSFET switching perfor-
system shows 98.1% efficiency at rated power.                      mance has been characterized through the double pulse
   Fig. 13 shows the three phase input inductor current            test and loss model of the semiconductor has been
simulation waveform and DAB stage transformer voltage              developed for thermal simulations. A simulation based
and current waveform at rated 350 kW power. Fig.                   system optimization helped determine the correct passive
14 shows the 3D rendering with the designed passive                components and switching frequencies and a high fidelity
components, heatsink and semiconductors where a 1.6                thermal simulation based on the experimental validated
kW/L power density is achieved.                                    loss model has shown the system efficiency exceeds
                                                                   98%.
                                                                                    ACKNOWLEDGMENT
                                                                      The information, data, or work presented herein was
                                                                   funded in part by the Office of Energy Efficiency and
                                                                   Renewable Energy (EERE), U.S. Department of Energy,
                                                                   under Award Number DE-EE0006521 with North Car-
                                                                   olina State University, PowerAmerica Institute.
                                                                                              R EFERENCES
                                                                     [1] J. Peeters, “Ev infrastructure,” in 2017 Electrification of Trans-
                                                                         port in Europe. IEEE, 2017.
                                                                     [2] S. Srdic, C. Zhang, X. Liang, W. Yu, and S. Lukic, “A sic-
                                                                         based power converter module for medium-voltage fast charger
                                                                         for plug-in electric vehicles,” in Applied Power Electronics Con-
                                                                         ference and Exposition (APEC), 2016 IEEE. IEEE, 2016, pp.
        Fig. 13. Simulation waveform at rated 350 kW                     2714–2719.
                                                               586
 [3] S. Srdic, X. Liang, C. Zhang, W. Yu, and S. Lukic, “A sic-            [18] A. Tong, L. Hang, G. Li, X. Jiang, and S. Gao, “Modeling
     based high-performance medium-voltage fast charger for plug-in             and analysis of a dual-active-bridge-isolated bidirectional dc/dc
     electric vehicles,” in Energy Conversion Congress and Exposition           converter to minimize rms current with whole operating range,”
     (ECCE), 2016 IEEE. IEEE, 2016, pp. 1–6.                                    IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, vol. 33, no. 6, pp.
 [4] D. Aggeler, F. Canales, H. Zelaya, D. La Parra, A. Coccia,                 5302–5316, 2018.
     N. Butcher, and O. Apeldoorn, “Ultra-fast dc-charge infrastruc-
     tures for ev-mobility and future smart grids,” in Innovative Smart
     Grid Technologies Conference Europe (ISGT Europe), 2010 IEEE
     PES. IEEE, 2010, pp. 1–8.
 [5] M. Vasiladiotis and A. Rufer, “A modular multiport power
     electronic transformer with integrated split battery energy storage
     for versatile ultrafast ev charging stations,” IEEE Transactions on
     Industrial Electronics, vol. 62, no. 5, pp. 3213–3222, 2015.
 [6] H. Hoimoja, M. Vasiladiotis, and A. Rufer, “Power interfaces and
     storage selection for an ultrafast ev charging station,” 2012.
 [7] S. Wang, R. Crosier, and Y. Chu, “Investigating the power archi-
     tectures and circuit topologies for megawatt superfast electric ve-
     hicle charging stations with enhanced grid support functionality,”
     in Electric Vehicle Conference (IEVC), 2012 IEEE International.
     IEEE, 2012, pp. 1–8.
 [8] S. Madhusoodhanan, K. Mainali, A. Tripathi, K. Vechalapu, and
     S. Bhattacharya, “Medium voltage ( 2.3 kv) high frequency
     three-phase two-level converter design and demonstration using
     10 kv sic mosfets for high speed motor drive applications,” in
     Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition (APEC),
     2016 IEEE. IEEE, 2016, pp. 1497–1504.
 [9] S. Ji, S. Zheng, F. Wang, and L. M. Tolbert, “Temperature-
     dependent characterization, modeling, and switching speed-
     limitation analysis of third-generation 10-kv sic mosfet,” IEEE
     Transactions on Power Electronics, vol. 33, no. 5, pp. 4317–4327,
     2018.
[10] E.-P. Eni, B. I. Incau, T. Kerekes, R. Teodorescu, and S. Munk-
     Nielsen, “Characterisation of 10 kv 10 a sic mosfet,” in Electrical
     Machines & Power Electronics (ACEMP), 2015 Intl Conference
     on Optimization of Electrical & Electronic Equipment (OPTIM)
     & 2015 Intl Symposium on Advanced Electromechanical Motion
     Systems (ELECTROMOTION), 2015 Intl Aegean Conference on.
     IEEE, 2015, pp. 675–680.
[11] S. Madhusoodhanan, A. Tripathi, D. Patel, K. Mainali, A. Ka-
     davelugu, S. Hazra, S. Bhattacharya, and K. Hatua, “Solid-state
     transformer and mv grid tie applications enabled by 15 kv sic
     igbts and 10 kv sic mosfets based multilevel converters,” IEEE
     Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 51, no. 4, pp. 3343–
     3360, 2015.
[12] Q. Zhu, L. Wang, L. Zhang, and A. Q. Huang, “A 10 kv dc
     transformer (dcx) based on current fed src and 15 kv sic mosfets.”
[13] D. Rothmund, D. Bortis, J. Huber, D. Biadene, and J. W. Kolar,
     “10kv sic-based bidirectional soft-switching single-phase ac/dc
     converter concept for medium-voltage solid-state transform-
     ers,” in Power Electronics for Distributed Generation Systems
     (PEDG), 2017 IEEE 8th International Symposium on. IEEE,
     2017, pp. 1–8.
[14] I. Cvetkovic, Z. Shen, M. Jaksic, C. DiMarino, F. Chen,
     D. Boroyevich, and R. Burgos, “Modular scalable medium-
     voltage impedance measurement unit using 10 kv sic mosfet
     pebbs,” in Electric Ship Technologies Symposium (ESTS), 2015
     IEEE. IEEE, 2015, pp. 326–331.
[15] J. Palmour, L. Cheng, V. Pala, E. Brunt, D. Lichtenwalner, G.-
     Y. Wang, J. Richmond, M. O’Loughlin, S. Ryu, S. Allen et al.,
     “Silicon carbide power mosfets: Breakthrough performance from
     900 v up to 15 kv,” in Power Semiconductor Devices & IC’s
     (ISPSD), 2014 IEEE 26th International Symposium on. IEEE,
     2014, pp. 79–82.
[16] X. Liang, C. Zhang, S. Srdic, and S. Lukic, “Predictive control
     of a series-interleaved multi-cell three-level boost power factor
     correction converter,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,
     2017.
[17] M.-T. Tsai, C.-L. Chu, and C.-Y. Chin, “Design a dual active
     bridge converter with symmetrical dual phase-shift strategy,” in
     2018 IEEE International Conference on Applied System Invention
     (ICASI). IEEE, 2018, pp. 1002–1005.
                                                                       587