Public Health Appraisal Impact
Public Health Appraisal Impact
INTRODUCTION
management includes planning and setting goals developing performance appraisal method,
implementing it and reviewing in entire process. While managers uses performance appraisal
system but the outcomes is always disappointment with the process and one of their functions is
to ensure organizations are effective and efficient in order for managers to achieve the
tool. It include operating performance management and monitoring methods process, system
matrices and the application software. Business performance management (BPM), strategy
performance management (CPM) and other forms of appraisal is a crucial aspect of performance
management, which usually result in a serial impression of worker efficiency and effectiveness,
often operating satisfactory in small public sector institutions where the management knows and
interacts with all employees. the information generated through an unsystematic informal
evaluation has limited value for making valid and justifiable human resource management in
public health institutions. In such a context, accurate performance management data obtained
through a standardized process is required for activities such as the growth in planning, training
and development, compensation, career development and succession planning, therefore most
1
public sector institutions have a need for a formal performance appraisal system to play a leading
The essence of the portrait is to asses the effectiveness of the employee performance appraisal as
a tool for the growth of public health institutions and also to evaluate its contribution as a
catalyst to the survival growth and profitability to the public health seek. The motive is basically
iv. To find out how performance appraisal method. Affect the employee performance at
For an organization to ensure continued effectives and efficiency of its employees every
organizations has to carry out staff performance appraisal from time so as to keep employees in
check and replace, retain, motivate and take any other appropriate actions the main challenges
that many organizations faces is how to maximize staff performance. Performance appraisal
therefore seems to be in editable. In the absence of structured, appraisal system can areate
serious ethnical, motivational and legal issues in the organizations. Without a structured
appraisal system there is no chance of ensuring that decisions made are fair, accurate, lawful and
2
defensible federal medical centre Bida has continued with the performance appraisal system
ii. In what ways does performance appraisal process affect employees job performance at
iii. To what extent does a performance appraisal goal affects employee performance at
iv. How performance appraisal method does affects employee’s performance at federal
i. The main objective of this study was to investigate effects of performance appraisal on
employee’s performance in the healthcare sector in federal medical Centre Bida Niger
state.
ii. To determine the relationship between performance appraisal and employees job
satisfaction.
iii. To establish how performance appraisal process affects employee performance at federal
iv. To find out how performance appraisal methods affects employees at federal medical
Centre Bida.
v. To determine how performance appraisal at federal medical centre Bida Niger state
3
1.5 RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS
Ho: there are no significant effects on performance appraisal on employee’s job satisfaction H1:
Hypothesis Two
Ho: there are no significant effects on performance appraisal on employee’s job satisfaction
Hypothesis Three
Ho: performance appraisal method does not affect employees performance at federal medical
Centre Bida.
H1: performance appraisal method affect employee performance at federal medical Centre Bida
Hypothesis four
Ho: performance appraisal goal does not affect employee performance at federal medical centre
Bida.
H1: performance appraisal goal affect employee performance at federal medical Centre Bida.
This study is not just a mere academic exercise it immense benefit. Hence the study will be vary
4
Government: this is one the main stakeholders in the local government. The findings of the
research will help formulate better polices to help the local government and to improve there
quality of life.
International organization: stakeholders who have had a big problem with unsuccessful project in
the past also face better days with publication of the result of this study.
Researcher in the future: These people will also rejoice in the collection of information gathered
in this study while conducting further studies in the future. The direct information collected by
the researcher in this study is used as secondary data, by these researchers in their quest to
Stakeholders: This study tends to facilitate an understanding of performance appraisal and its
The study focused on employee performance appraisal as a tool for the growth ofpublic health
institutions in federal medical Centre Bida. It covered some of the employees of FMC Bida as
respondent conceptually.
Performance:- Doing something successful and using knowledge as distinct from one
possession
5
Performance appraisal: the activity used to determine the employees performance effectively.
Performance appraises the employees systematic appraisal of the efficiency of performance and
Employee:- an individual who was hired by an employer to do specific job and who gets paid on
Health Institutions:-an organization that provides health care and related services to the
provision of inpatient and outpatient care health institution also means government institutions
which is administered under the bureau and deliver health services to the community.
over a particular.
6
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 INTRODUCTION
in this chapter, the researcher try to view literature that explores what has been done on
Literature review comprises documentation of information that relates to the subject under
review. Moreover, it helps to determine new approaches and stimulate new ideas. The chapter
NIGER STATE
The federal medical centre (FMC) Bida is owned by the federal government of Nigeria and built
by the then Sani Abacha military administration, it was built in 1997 in Bida Niger state. The
centre is located in the efu-etsu Yisa ward of the ancient city of Bida, the second largest town in
Niger state. It was established in april 1 st , 1997 following an agreement between the federal
government of Nigeria and the government of Niger state. This agreement in the upgrading of
the former general hospital, Bida into a tertiary health care facility. The physical structure which
fmcb inherited was built by the British colonial general hospital, Bida passed on to the north
western government with the creation of 12 states in 1972 and later the federal government of
Nigeria in 1977. At the times of takeoff, the facilities and equipment had deteriorated and were
in various stages of advanced dilapidation. This situation prompted the new management to
immediately set an initial agenda restricting the facilities, rehabilitation of equipment and the
7
provision of additional facilities to bring the centre to its new status as a tertiary health
institutions. The new management was led by professor P.I Nmadu, a pediatric surgeon from
Abuth (Ahmadu Bello university teaching hospital) who was appointed in pioneer medical
The latest takeover brought about an existing process of transformation in the hospital in terms
of infrastructures, staffing equipment and services. Over the year the hospital has witnessed
The hospital was in under the Niger state government. Ophthalmic, psychiatric and dental
pediatrics, laboratory, pharmacy, radiology and medical also with 450 bed facilities which
offered out the patient care, in addition to these, the social welfare administration and
maintenance department are rendering services. Furthermore, the staff consist of few medical
officer, pharmacist and nurses on ground at that point in time, hospital records were pourly kept
through the use of exercise books (Mainly kept by patient themselves). In 1987 there was a
provision of twin modular theatre for the hospital and the Niger state school of midwifery
training was running on the premise. The physical structure was deteriorating and at various
stages of dilapidation while equipment were obsolete outdated and at various stages of despair.
The second stage was from (1997-2000). This second stage between the Niger state and the
federal government. The takeover was smooth with only five new staffs including the pioneer
medical director (Prof.P.T Nmadu ) the other staff (from farmer general hospital) drew their
salary from Niger state government up to June, 1998, the centre fully took over in july 1998 and
its nurses to doctors, 2pharmacists and 79 supporting staff absorbed from the niger state civil
8
Towards the end of the yearlong the number of specialist had risen to and occasionallylocum
specialist from university of Ilorin teaching and ABU teaching hospital zaria. The hospital who
witness a crisis period that lasted 18 months resulting from displacement of staff and
introduction of hospital fees. During the period, the physical infrastructure development was
stunted by the crisis. The third stage (2001-2006) was characterized by major renovation of
physical structure in area like GOPD, A& E Medical words O& G wards works and maintenance
department, utility vehicle including ambulance and equipment including ECG. Was produced
and put in use in 2003. In 2006 more qualified sub specialist in urology, urology, orbit, anatomy
and community medicine joined the team. More than 87 nurses and a lot of more supporting
staff were also employed during the total institution attained the status of post graduate training
center during the period and was accredited by west Africa post graduate college for training in
general surgery. Obstetrics and gynecology and family medicine. The national post graduate
medicine college of Nigeria has also accredited the centre for training in family medicine, there
were in addition to the relevant council approval for training in terms of medicine, pharmacy,
The plant administration has also witnessed the building of an oxygen plant. The centre is
approved primary and secondary health are provided under the national health insurance scheme
(NHIS). The centre is a baby friendly they also provided a services of VCT and PMTCT and a
national art centre. The federal medical centre Bida is under control of federal minister of health
to which it represents the interest of the federal government of Nigeria in niger state. The
hospital board of management is responsible for formulating polices for the centre and ensuring
the federal government for the policies on health programmed is fully implemented
9
2.3. CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
employees performances and provides guidance or plan for them to achieve the targeted
measure of organizational effectiveness MCshane and von Glinow (2015) further explained that
level of effort, commitment and the amount of creativity that an employee contributed to his or
her jobs in an organization influenced productivity and these items were were also included for
their performance appraisal. This indicates that effort devoted from individual employees are
significant in ensuring that the organization goals are met. Managers played an important role by
continually assessing their employees process often services as a merit or demerit point to
Job satisfaction generally reflects how an employee feels about his or her job. It include how an
employee’s feels about the conditions within which he works and thus influence his attitude
towards his work. It is also concerned with rewards as employees feelings towards their
organization may be influenced by rewards Kim (2005). Schwpkter (2011) defined job
satisfaction is as the place durable emotional state resulting from the appraisal of one’s job as
achieving or facilitating one’s job values. Job dissatisfaction on the other hand, is the
undesirable emotional state an employee encounters if he realize that his value. Satisfaction is
categorized as intrinsic, extrinsic or total. According to wegge et al. (2007). Job satisfaction
10
absenteeism. In like manner, sari (2004) asserts that organizations can identify or track employee
turnover with job satisfaction. It is also indicate of job performance chen (2006). As a result, an
organizations effort in increasing its employees job satisfaction can mitigate undesirable work
attitudes like absenteeism cohen et al (2007). Organization however are cautioned that job
satisfaction may have a negative correlation to productivity on the job as reported by judge et al
(2001) in a meta analysis which repealed low correlations between job satisfaction and
performance. Some factors influence job satisfaction include how complex an employees task is
usually employee who are high complexity tasks have high-complexity task is, usually
employees who have how to moderate complexity task cohen et al. (2007).
Performance appraisal is faced with certain challenges and has also been criticized by
researchers and authors alike. The critics include evaluation criteria, evaluation errors and others
which hinder effectives performance appraisal. Maroney and Buckey (2010) assert that there is a
gap between theory and practice and further criticize HR specialists. For neglecting the used of
criteria as a challenge faced by performance appraisal. He claims that the criteria could be vague
and suggest that performance appraisal criteria be be designed in quantifiable and measurable
team also among the critics in the use of appraisal by management as the main technique used to
develop employees performance bach (2005). According to bach, this techniques does not
encourage the assessment of employees past performance and reward employee based on their
past performance. This criticism is perhaps better summarized as having an entrenched focus on
future performance and placing limited importance on past performance hence giving credence
of training needs and a vivid explanation of objectives and laying down vivid future objective.
Walters (2005) also discusses the lack of competence on the part of evaluations which results in
rating and evaluation errors based on personal biases like stereotying and halo effects. Maroney
and walters (2005) suggests that for reliable data and objectives appraisal process, appraisal
should be trained to carryout performance appraisals. Walters also cites resistance as a challenge
faced by performance appraisal he discusses that due to unfavorable ratings employees may
resists the appraisal process. There employees should get a clear explanation and be well
informed about the appraisal purpose and process. The standards should be clearly
communicated and every employee should be made aware of what exactly is expected from
them. In the light of this challenge, marine and Buckley assert that performance appraisal may
Organizations may adopt different approaches which can be traced to the categorization by
creamer and jansik(1999) which comprise behavior based approach, and result focused approach.
Creama and janosik (1999) describe the behavior based approaches as the type of performance
appraisal that employees the use specific factors of performance in the evaluation of employees
these include rating scales and forced choice method. Another type which fits under the behavior
based approach is the behavioral checklist which outlines specific criteria or target an employee
must meet. The behavior may very according to the particular type of job assessment. This is
method is regarded as favorable because it avoids company the performance of one employee
with the performance of another employee but rather focuses on performance yardsticks for each
employees Dita jose(2013). Secondly results focused approaches lay emphasis on what results
12
the appraisal bring, an example of result based approach which is widely used is management by
appraisals. With MBO, managers and their employees have a discussion and both parties agree
on which goals to achieve and when to achieve them Diya jose(2013). Diya jose (2013) also
discussion 360 degree appraisal and psychological appraisals. She describes 360 degree appraisal
as one which takes in all inclusive approaches. It ensures that all parties related to the employee,
that is the manager, supervisor, and team members gives a feedback on the employee
performance. It also makes use of employee profile and reports. Apart from all these an in depth
feedback from the employee himself is also used. Psychological appraisals, on the other hand,
evaluating the psychological traits such as how an employee analysis issues, his reasoning
PERFORMANCE.
Studies on the impacts of performance appraisal on employees attitudes emphasized the need for
feedback shrivastar & sapra, (2012) and reward Gichuchi, abaja & Ochieng, (2012). Shrivastar
and sapra, (2012). In a study investigate the impacts of performance appraisal on employees
attitude revealed the relevance of performance appraisal to organization but also emphasize the
need to give feedback to employees due to the positive impact that will have on their
performance. They assert that feedback after appraisal helps strength communication between
supervisor and employees and also motivates the employees the study also underscores the role
performance appraisal plays in guiding employees to work towards attaining organizational goals
organization by causing employees to perform worse. The study by Gichuhi, Abaja and Ochieng
(2012) discovered that employees realize little benefit after a performance appraisal. It claimed
that there was little reward as far as performance appraisal is concerned. The study assert that
A recent study by Dadanis (2012) reveals that performance appraisal system strongly affected
the commitment of employees in both positive and negatively ways. She discovered that
employees loyalty are strongly affected hence their initiative in doing their work. It follows that
efficiency and effectiveness of the employees are strongly affected as they claimed that their
motivation in doing their work are affected. On the positive side. Responses by employees
revealed that they positive not mind working extra hours, on the negative side, however,
employees will be unwilling to work for extra hours or beyond the hours for which they are paid
because they feel they are not reward sufficiently. His study gives credence to the assertion by
lee and bruviod (2003) that employees are willing and feel obliged to repay the organization
through high performance level if the organization shows a commitment in terms of reward and
the development of employees. Employee will thus feel motivated to work towards achieving
organizational goals even those which may be super ordinate. And will also cause an increase in
their affective commitment Lathan (2003) finally, a research on sales persons asserts that giving
clear explanations on the criteria. Used in evaluating employees and giving employees the
chance to partake in designed appraisals has a positive relationship with their commitment.
However if the employees role in the organization are not clearly defined it will have a negative
14
2.3.6 ORGANIZATIONAL COMMITMENT
Hers covitch and meyer (2002) define organizational commitment to reflect how devoted an
employees is to his organization which usually comes about if he or she feels that he can identify
with the values and objective of the organization. It goes to show the extent to which an
employee would go to help an organization achieve its goal. And as there may be factors for
which an employee may not give his all in the course of rendering his duties at work. How
committed an employee is plays a role in two he persist in the face of these factors to extert more
effort to which he believe the organization viswesvaran (2005) mention the three vital pillars
which help define organization commitment firstly they cite an employees willingness to evert
more effort to aid organizational success and this exerted effort secondly they ate the willingness
has about his organizations core value and how he identities with it. Organizational commitment
easy goals. They require more effort and typically have lower chance of success than easy goals
do Lathan (2007) for over a period of 30 years several private and public sector organization
have generally focused significantly on researching into organizational commitment an act which
association among variables deemed relevant to the problem situation identified sekaran (2010).
15
2.4.1 EXPECTANCY THEORY
This theory was proposed by victor room in 1964 and it stress and focuses on outcomes.
According to Lucas and diener (2007) expectance theory is a set of decision in econies of
motivation and performance. Perception plays a vital role in this theory because it emphasize on
cognitive ability to anticipate likely consequences that result from behavioral action knetner &
kinniki (2011) as explained by romm (1964) the expectancy theory has two major assumptions
that is individual have a perception about the concerns that result from their interactive
engagements and casuals relations among the outcomes and second assumption is individuals has
effective reactions to certain outcomes that is both positive and negative value (Lucas &
Dienece 2007). According to this theory individual are motived to performance by two
expectations. Expectancy is the probability that the effort will always lead to desired
performance and second expectancy is that particular performance will lead to preferred
outcomes while some effort will not be rewarded the employee will not be motivated with to
performance specific task expectancy theory relived upon motivations to clainfy the causes of
behavior at a work stations external rewards are viewed as motivations that fuel behavior as
opposed to intrinsic motivators when behavior are driven from internal forces.
descriptive label and simply called the theories, theory x and theory y. both of these theories
begin with the premise that management role is to assemble the factors of production, including
people, for the economic benefits of the firm beyond this point, the two theories of management
diverge.
16
THEORY X
2. Has no ambition, want no responsibility and would rather follow than lead.
4. Resist change
6. Essentially theory x and theory y assumes that people work only for money and security.
Under theory x, management approach can range from a hard approach to a soft approach. The
hard approach relies on coercion, implicit threat, close supervision and tight controls, essentially
en environment of command and control. The soft approach is to be permissive and seek
harmony with the hope that in returns employees will co-operate when asked to do so. However,
neither of these extremes is optional the hard approach results in ever measuring request for
more rewards in exchange for ever decreasing work output, the optional management approach
under theory x probably would be somewhere between these extremes. However mc greger
asserts that neighed approaches is appropriate because the assumption of theory x are not correct.
17
THEORY Y
The higher level needs of esteem and self actualization are continuing needs in that they are
completely satisfied as such, it is these higher level need through which employees can best be
ii. People will be self directed to meet their work objectives if they are committed to
them.
iii. People will be committed to their objectives if rewards are in place that addes
v. Most people can handle responsibility because creatority and in genvity are
personal goals with organizational goals by using employees own quest for
not imply a soft approaches. Mc gregor recognized that some people may not
have reached the level of maturity assumed by theory y and therefore may need
18
2.4.3 FEEDBACK INTERVENTION THEORY
Klyger and Denisi feedback intervention theory indicates that feedback recipient may be
indicated to focus their attention on task – motivation e.g. the task itself or on meta-task process.
Involving the self. This theory works in a circle, the success of progressing round which is
performance to an individual.
Equity theory popularly known as Adams equity they aims to strike a balance between an
employees’ input and output in a workplace. If the employee is able to find his or her right
balance it would lead to a more productive relationship with the management. Equity theory
focuses on determining whether the distribution of resources is fair to both relational partners, it
The empirical review highlights the past studies on the variable of the study. This includes the
study conducted on employee performance among employees and performance appraise system.
A reviews the aspect of job performance, employee motivation, staff training and employee
feedback. Succeeding with performance appraisal, the main objective of the paper was to review
the latest trend and management developing across the globe and pinpoints. The practical
implication from cutting edge case studies and research studies the methodology approach was a
preparation by independent writer who added their own impartial comment and placed the
articles in context. The finding indicates that organization which endeavor to constantly impure
19
are best placed to gem competitive edge over their competition and performance appraisal
feedback are critically important because the process offer. Organizations a valuable opportunity
to measure how each staffs will always underperform, therefore organizations must be able to
address the issues to avoid alienating those employees who are willing to pure their weight and
negative feedback remains an important part of appraised mix (emrald publishing limited, 2017)
the methodology used for this study was biased because the approach was a preparation by
independent writers who added their own important comment and need the articles In an text
A though some studies on performance appraisal here been conducted (see kiyaye 2004) arm
study 2010) and the determinants of performance appraisals here been conducted covering trends
in performance which are setting goals, training and development flexibility, inspiring
Independent variables
Variables
appraisal
20
feedback feedback
Measure
feedback
Providing
information to
staff
appraisal
process
Self-review
Forced choice
rating
21
CHAPTER THREE
3.1 INTRODUCTION
In this chapter, the research has to discuss the methodology used to carry out the research work.
Sampling method, and sample size, method of collection of data, method of questionnaire
For the purpose of this study, the questionnaire administered research method there is descriptive
in nature and has the basic characteristics which involves the collection of data to facilitate the
answer of research questions through which the test of hypothesis was adopted, this method will
be considered appropriate because it will helped us to describe, examine, analyze and interpret
Population of the study refer to the entire subject which the research investigating in hight of this
population of FMC Bida the total number of staffs working in FMC Bida is 725 medical
Personel of Federal Medical Center Bida. Administrative Staff of The Federal Medical Centre
Bida,
A sample is a collection of observable group from a parent population for the purpose of a
research study. Here every respondent are given relative equal chance The researcher will
administered seven hundred and twenty five (725) questionnaires to Federal Medical Center Bida
22
random sampling method will be used in this study simply because of the nature of data required
by the researcher. This approach will be used to get the needed information from respondents
The instrument that will be employed for data collection in this research work is the
questionnaire type because the response will be gathered in a standardized way, and
Validity is the extent to which an instrument can be relied upon to do what it purports to do
accurately and is concerned with the soundness and effectiveness of the measuring instrument
(Akinwunmi&Osiki, 2006).
The researcher will use the survey method which the questionnaire is one of its major tools. The
researcher will prepare a questionnaire which will consist of open and closed ended questions
with multiple answers options and he will presented it to the supervisor who will gave necessary
Data will be collected through the questionnaires administered to the targeted respondents and
presented on frequency distribution table for interpretations and analysis. Hypotheses were tested
23
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA PRESENTATION ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION
4.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter illustrates the presentation of data collected, analyzed the data, interpretation and
discussion of findings of collected data. Section 4.2 focused on data analyses and interpretation
Table 1 show that 35 of the respondents representing 58.3% are male while 25 of the respondent
representing 41.7% are female
Table 2
Age
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Cumulative
Percent
representing 16.7% are within 20-39 years, 20 respondents representing 33.3% are within 40-49
years, 10 respondent representing 16.7% are within 50-59 years while 10 respondents
Table 3
Marital Status
Table 3 shows that 35 of the respondents representing 58.3% are married while 25 of the
Table 4
Educational Background
25
Table 4 shows that 10 of the respondents representing 16.7% are PHD holder, 30 of the
respondents representing 50% are Master degree holders, 15 of the respondents representing
25% First Degree holders while 5 respondents representing 8.3% are HND holders
Table 5
Working Experience
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid 0-2 - - - -
3-5 10 16.7 16.7 16.7
6-10 30 50 50 66.7
11-15 15 25 25 91.7
16 above 5 8.3 8.3 100.0
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 5 show that 10 respondent representing 16.7 have work in this organization from 3-5 years
30 respondent representing 50% have 3-5 years experience 15 respondent representing 15 have
11-15 years work experience while 5 respondent representing 8.3% have 16 years and above
experience.
26
Section B
Table 6
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 30 50 50.0 50.0
Agree 20 33.3 33.3 83.3
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree 5 8.3 8.3 91.7
Undecided 5 8.3 8.3 100.0
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 6 show that 30 respondent representing 50% strongly agree that performance appraisal
representing 8.3% Disagree while 5 respondent representing 8.3 undecided it imply that
Table 7
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 20 33.3 33.3 33.3
Agree 30 50 50 83.3
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree 5 8.3 8.3 91.7
Undecided 5 8.3 8.3 100.0
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 7 show that 20 respondent representing 33.3% strongly agree that performance appraisal
affect job performance 30 respondent representing 50% agree 5 respondent representing 8.3%
27
Disagree while 5 respondent representing 8.3 undecided it imply that that performance appraisal
Table 8
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 30 50 50.0 50.0
Agree 20 33.3 33.3 83.3
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree 5 8.3 8.3 91.7
Undecided 5 8.3 8.3 100.0
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 8 show that 30 respondent representing 50% strongly agree that there organization
representing 8.3% Disagree while 5 respondent representing 8.3 undecided it imply that the
Table 9
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 50 83.3 83.3 83.3
Agree 10 16.7 16.7 100.0
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree - - - -
Undecided - - - -
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
28
Table 9 show that 50 respondent representing 83.3% strongly agree that Performance appraisal in
our organization aims at improving employee performance and strengthening their job skills
while 10 respondent representing 16.7% agree. It imply that Performance appraisal in our
organization aims at improving employee performance and strengthening our job skills
Table 10
Table 10 show that 20 respondent representing 33.3% strongly agree that Performance Appraisal
is used as a decision making tool for improving performance and set promotion standard 10
29
Table 11
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 60 100 60 100.0
Agree - - - -
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree - - - -
Undecided - - - -
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 11 show that all the respondent strongly agree that Transfer, demotion suspension an
dismissal is based on performance appraisal
EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE
Table 12
Continuous Formal And Informal Monitoring Of Employee Performance Is A Strategic
Issue In The Organization
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 20 33.3 33.3 33.3
Agree 10 16.7 16.7 50.0
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree 20 33.3 33.3 83,3
Undecided 10 16.7 16.7 100.0
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 12 show that 20 respondent representing 33.3% strongly agree that Continuous formal and
30
respondent representing 16.7% undecided that Continuous formal and informal monitoring of
Table 13
Employee tasks are such that their performance can be clearly define and measured
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 20 33.3 33.3 33.3
Agree 10 16.7 16.7 50.0
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree 20 33.3 33.3 83.3
Undecided 10 16.7 16.7 100.0
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 13 show that 20 respondent representing 33.3% strongly agree that Employee tasks are
such that their performance can be clearly define and measured 10 respondent representing
16.7% undecided.
31
Table 14
Organization ensure comprehensive incentive plans based on employees performance to
Company’s objectives
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 40 66.7 66.7 66.7
Agree 20 33.3 33.3 100
Strongly Disagree - - - -
Disagree - - - -
Undecided - - - -
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 14 show that 40 respondent representing 66.7% strongly agree that Organization ensure
20 respondent representing 33.3% agree. So it imply that the organization ensure comprehensive
Table 15
Cumulative
Frequency Percent Valid Percent Percent
Valid Strongly Agree 10 16.7 16.7 16.7
Agree 10 16.7 16.7 33.4
Strongly Disagree 20 33.3 33.3 66.7
Disagree 10 16.7 16.7 83.4
Undecided 10 16.7 16.7 100.0
Total 60 100.0 100.0
Source: Questionnaire Administered (2022)
Table 15 show that 10 respondent representing 16.7% strongly agree that Employee Tasks are
32
strongly Disagree 10 respondent representing 16.7% disagree while 10 respondent representing
16.7% undecided. It imply that employee tasks are not clearly define
In this section, the researcher validated the hypotheses of the research work. In testing the
DECISION RULE: Accept the null hypothesis (Ho) if the calculated Chi-square value is less
than the critical value of the Chi-square distribution table, otherwise reject the null hypothesis
and accept the alternate hypothesis (Hi). That is; Reject H O if P value ≤ 0.05, otherwise do not
reject.
Ho: There is no significant relationship between performance appraisal feedback and employees
performance
Chi-Square Test
Frequencies
Strongly Disagree - - -
Total 60
33
Test Statistics
Chi-Square 24.300a
DF 1
CONCLUSION: Having run a test statistics of the values, chi-square equates 24.300 a value at a
df of 1 with a significance value of 0.000. Therefore, since P value 0.000 < 0.05, we reject H O
and accept H1 and conclude at 5% level of significant that There is significant relationship
Hypothesis Two
Strongly agree - - -
Total 60
34
Test Statistics
Chi-Square 32.400a
Df 2
CONCLUSION: Having run a test statistics of the values, chi-square equates 32.400 a value at a
df of 2 with a significance value of 0.000. Therefore, since P value 0.000 < 0.05, we reject H O
and accept H1 and conclude at 5% level of significant that There is significant Impact on
Table 6 show that 30 respondent representing 50% strongly agree that performance appraisal
representing 8.3% Disagree while 5 respondent representing 8.3 undecided it imply that
performance appraisal feedback affect employee performance. Table 7 show that 20 respondent
representing 33.3% strongly agree that performance appraisal affect job performance 30
respondent representing 50% agree 5 respondent representing 8.3% Disagree while 5 respondent
representing 8.3 undecided it imply that that performance appraisal affect job performance Table
8 show that 30 respondent representing 50% strongly agree that there organization appraises the
8.3% Disagree while 5 respondent representing 8.3 undecided it imply that the organization
35
appraises the performance of its employee Table 9 show that 50 respondent representing 83.3%
strongly agree that Performance appraisal in our organization aims at improving employee
performance and strengthening their job skills while 10 respondent representing 16.7% agree. It
imply that Performance appraisal in our organization aims at improving employee performance
and strengthening our job skills Table 10 show that 20 respondent representing 33.3% strongly
agree that Performance Appraisal is used as a decision making tool for improving performance
and set promotion standard 10 respondent representing 16.7% agree 10 respondent representing
representing 16.7% undecided Table 11 show that all the respondent strongly agree that
Transfer, demotion suspension and dismissal is based on performance appraisal Table 12 show
that 20 respondent representing 33.3% strongly agree that Continuous formal and informal
representing 16.7% undecided that Continuous formal and informal monitoring of employee
representing 33.3% strongly agree that Employee tasks are such that their performance can be
clearly define and measured 10 respondent representing 16.7% agree 20 respondent representing
33.3% Disagree while 10 respondent representing 16.7% undecided. Table 14 show that 40
respondent representing 66.7% strongly agree that Organization ensure comprehensive incentive
representing 33.3% agree. So it imply that the organization ensure comprehensive incentive
plans based on employees performance Table 15 show that 10 respondent representing 16.7%
36
strongly agree that Employee Tasks are clearly define 10 respondent representing 16.7% agree
37
CHAPTER FIVE
5.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter includes summary of findings, conclusions and recommendations in respect of the
In this study it was show that most of the employee are male which most of them are married and
half of the employee are from 40-44 year and also most of them are master Degree holder and
most of the employee have years of experience working in the organization. In this study it was
show that most of the employee agree that performance appraisal feedback affect employee
performance and also the employee believe that performance appraisal feedback also affect their
Organizational comprehensive plans and also it was also stated by the employee that Transfer,
demotion suspension and dismissal is based on performance appraisal as a result of this most of
the employee put in all their effort in their job it also stated that 90% of the employee
performance are being evaluated by the employer so as to enable the employee improve their
5.3 CONCLUSION
The findings demonstrated that the performance appraisal policy can be an effective tool in
employee performance if it is perceived to be objective and fair. The findings also revealed that
employee participation in the performance appraisal policy was high and this led to employee
performance and perception of the process and outcome as being fair. This finding also
confirmed the observations of Bond and Fox (2017) who highlight that employee performance
38
was transparent in their evaluations and that they were treated fairly in compensation and
promotion.
5.4 RECOMMENDATIONS
The results of the study indicated that most employees preferred performance appraisals to be
used for training and development purposes. It is recommended that managers should improve
on the training and development needs analysis component of performance appraisal policy in
order to meet the aspirations of employees. A well trained and developed workforce is required
for increased employee performance and organizational growth. It would also lead to efficiency
1. Any changes made to ratings of employees during the performance appraisal process
should be communicated clearly and early to all concerned. This would go a long way to
prevent conflict situations and create a healthy atmosphere for team work.
counseling and job rotation as well as transfers should be put in place by top
appraised. This is because, if one waits till the end of the period to do the performance
appraisal policy, the tendency will be to forget some other important positive or negative
behavior the appraise showed in the course of that period under review.
4. Top management and managers, who conduct the performance appraisal needs to be
39
performance. Furthermore, performance appraisal policy creates a learning experience
It is a known fact that researchers encounter a lot of problem, which are inherent in our society
and this research is no exception This problem will range from personal constraints to
environment problems.
Time for instance will be constraints. A lot of time will be consumed before this research could
be carried out. The researcher has to forfeit a lot of appointment, assignments, and other
commitments especially during the collection of information that will be used for the literature
review.
Lack of statistic will be another major setback to this research. It will be due to the impossibility
of obtaining some accurate information required. It should be noted that lack of accurate statistic
limits accuracy of any research work. They seriously guided most information considered
40
REFERENCE
Angelo, S.D. & Robert, D.P (2016) management and organization review, 2(2), 253-277.
Anne, W.G., Poti, O.A., & Isaac, O. (2012) effective of performance appraisal on employees
Armstrong, M., & Baron, A. (2018) performance management; the new realities. London;
Atkins, P., & Wood, R. (2012) self-versus other rating as predictors of assessment centres, rating
validation evidence for 360-degree feedback programs. Personnel psychology, 55(5), 871
-904
Boss weel R., Boudreau, J.w. (2011). How leading companies creates, measure, and achieve
Bowing, N.A. (2017). Is the job satisfaction job performance relationship spurious A meta-
Browing, V.(2016). The relationship between HRM practices and services behavior in south
1321-1338.
41
Cardy R.L. (2018). Performance appraisal in a quality context; A new look at an old problem in
J.W. smither (Ed), performance appraisal; A state of the art in practice (pp.132-162).
Cardy, R.L & Gregory, H.D. (2014). Performance appraisal; Atternative perspectives. Cincinati;
south western.
Chen, S.H., Yang C.C., Shiau, J.Y. & wang, H.H .(2016). The development of an employee
satisfaction model for higher education. The TQM magazine, 18(5), 484-500.
Cohen, D.G., & Wood, G. (2019). Human resource managemen; a critical approach. In D.G.
Collings and G.
Collings, A., & Golan, R. (2017). Predicting absenteeism and turnover intentions by past
Wood (Eds) human resource management; a critical approach (PP. -1-16). London; routledge .
Cooper-Hakim, A., & Viswesvaran , (2015). The construct of work commitment; testing an
Krishnan, S.K., & singh, M. (2010). Outcomes of intention to quit of indian IT professional;
Lathan G.P (2017). Work motivation; history, theory research and practice. Sage, thousand oaks,
Lee, C.H., & Bruvold, N. (2013). Creating ralve for employees investment in employee
241-225
42
Smith, M. (2017). Feedback as a performance management techniques. Management solution,
32, 20-29
Srivastar, U.S.S & Nimisha S. (2012). Impact of performance appraisal on employees attitude.
Steers, M., & Porter, L.W. (2019). Motivation and work behavior. New York; mc grawr Hill
Sullivren, S.E., & Arthur, M.B . (2016). The evoluation of the boundry less career concept;
19-29.
Taylor, M.S., Tracy, K.B., Bernard M.K., Harrison, J.K & carrol S.J. (2015). Due process in
Thompson, E.R., & Phua, F.T.T . (2012). A brief index of affective job satisfaction. Group &
Waal, A.A.D. (2014) Stimulating performance – driven behavior to obtain better results,
43
APPENDIX
Department of Business
Administration and Management
The Federal Polytechnic Bida
October 14 2022
Dear Respondent,
and Management (HNDII). In fulfillment of the basic requirement for the Award of National
limited has been chosen as my company for study. The topic of my research work is centered on
Center Bida
I assure you that any information provided for this study will be treated strictly as confidential
and used solely for this academic work. I shall be grateful if you kindly provide the information
in this Questionnaire.
Thanks.
Yours faithfully
44
QUESTIONNAIRE
EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL AS A TOOL FOR THE GROWTH OF
on employee performance.
In section A: Thick (√) where necessary while in section B, thick the number that represent how
you feel about the statement by using the following scoring system.
Strongly agree 5
Agree 4
Undecided 3
Disagree 2
Strongly disagree 1
45
SECTION ‘B’ PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL
S/N Statements 5 4 3 2 1
46
47