Task: Enhanced PRD Question System

Description

Enhance the existing /oden:prd command with a deeper, more intelligent question system that generates 5-8 contextual questions instead of the current basic 3-5. Questions should adapt based on feature type, project context, and existing documentation while providing follow-up clarification when needed.

Functional Requirements

• Deeper Question Set: Expand from 3-5 to 5-8 intelligent questions per PRD
• Context Adaptation: Questions adapt based on feature type and project context
• Follow-up Logic: Ask clarifying questions when answers need expansion
• Consideration Prompts: Suggest aspects user might not have considered
• Reference Integration: Include competitive analysis and existing project patterns

Technical Implementation

Files to Modify:

• .claude/commands/oden/prd.md - Enhanced command definition
• lib/commands/prd.js - Extended question generation logic
• lib/prd/enhanced-questions.js - New intelligent question system
• lib/prd/context-adapter.js - Project context analysis for question customization
• data/prd-question-templates.json - Expanded question database

Architecture:

1. Context Analysis: Analyze project type, existing docs, tech stack
2. Question Selection: Choose relevant questions from expanded database
3. Dynamic Follow-ups: Generate clarifying questions based on initial answers
4. Consideration Engine: Suggest additional aspects to consider
5. Integration: Seamless integration with existing PRD workflow

Acceptance Criteria

Core Functionality:

• Enhanced /oden:prd feature-name generates 5-8 contextual questions
• Questions adapt based on detected project type (web, mobile, API, etc.)
• Follows up with clarifying questions when answers are incomplete
• References existing project documentation and patterns
• Maintains backward compatibility with existing PRD structure
• Integrates smoothly with /oden:brainstorm when used together

Question Intelligence:

• Business impact questions (user value, success metrics, ROI)
• Technical complexity questions (scalability, performance, integration)
• User experience questions (accessibility, usability, edge cases)
• Risk assessment questions (security, compliance, dependencies)
• Timeline and resource questions (effort, skills, external dependencies)

Context Adaptation Examples:

E-commerce Features:

• How will this affect conversion rates and user purchase flow?
• What payment processing and security requirements apply?
• How will inventory management integrate with this feature?
• What analytics and tracking capabilities are needed?

Authentication Features:

• What compliance requirements (GDPR, SOC2, HIPAA) apply?
• How will this integrate with existing user management systems?
• What backup authentication methods should be available?
• How will you handle account recovery and security incidents?

API Features:

• What rate limiting and scaling strategies are needed?
• How will you maintain backward compatibility during updates?
• What documentation and developer experience is required?
• What monitoring and alerting capabilities are essential?

Follow-up Logic:

• Detects vague answers and asks for specifics
• Identifies missing stakeholder considerations
• Prompts for success criteria when not provided
• Requests clarification on technical constraints
• Asks about user research or validation plans

Integration Features:

• References competitive analysis data for context
• Incorporates existing project architecture decisions
• Suggests related features or dependencies
• Highlights potential conflicts with existing features
• Recommends complementary functionality

Dependencies

• Internal: Existing /oden:prd command structure
• Integration: /oden:brainstorm for seamless transition
• Data: Competitive analysis files, technical decisions documentation

Implementation Notes

• Maintain all existing PRD generation functionality
• Add question intelligence without breaking current workflows
• Create question templates that can be mixed and matched
• Implement answer analysis for follow-up generation
• Ensure generated PRDs remain compatible with /oden:epic

Enhanced Question Categories

Business & User Value:

• What specific user problem does this solve?
• How will you measure success and user adoption?
• What's the business impact and expected ROI?
• Who are the primary and secondary user personas?

Technical Implementation:

• What technical constraints or dependencies exist?
• How will this integrate with existing architecture?
• What performance requirements must be met?
• What scalability considerations apply?

User Experience:

• What accessibility requirements must be supported?
• How will users discover and learn this feature?
• What error states and edge cases need handling?
• What mobile and cross-platform requirements exist?

Risk & Compliance:

• What security or privacy considerations apply?
• Are there regulatory or compliance requirements?
• What could cause this feature to fail or be rejected?
• What external dependencies pose risks?

Risks

• Medium: Questions might overwhelm users with too much depth
• Medium: Context detection might generate irrelevant questions
• Low: Integration with brainstorming could create redundancy

Mitigation Strategies

• Progressive disclosure: start with core questions, expand based on answers
• Clear categorization so users understand the purpose of each question
• Testing with various project types to refine question relevance
• Integration testing with brainstorming workflow to avoid duplication