Skip to content

Conversation

@DoganK01
Copy link
Member

No description provided.

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Dec 18, 2025

Code Review - PR #499: Fix nested f-strings formatting for Python 3.11

Summary

This PR fixes a Python 3.11 compatibility issue by changing nested f-string syntax from double quotes to single quotes in an error message.

Code Quality: ✅ APPROVED

Positive aspects:

  • Correct fix: This change addresses a real Python 3.11 syntax limitation. Python 3.11 doesn't allow nested f-strings using the same quote style (e.g., f"...f"..."), which would cause a SyntaxError.
  • Minimal and focused: The change is surgical - only touches the problematic line without unnecessary modifications.
  • Maintains functionality: The error message output remains identical; only the quote style changes.
  • Location: src/upsonic/tools/schema.py:172

Testing: ⚠️ Needs Verification

Recommendations:

  1. Verify CI passes: The project tests against Python 3.10, 3.11, and 3.12 (per .github/workflows/tests.yml). This PR should ensure Python 3.11 tests pass.
  2. Run existing test: The file tests/unit_tests/tools/test_tool_schema.py contains test test_tool_schema_validation_errors which exercises this code path. Ensure it passes.
  3. Manual verification: Consider testing with a function that has missing annotations to trigger this error message:
def test_func(param):  # Missing type annotation
    """Test function."""
    return param

Best Practices: ✅ GOOD

Observations:

  • The fix follows Python's recommendation to use different quote styles for nested strings
  • Alternative approaches (using "".join(...) or triple quotes) would be more verbose without adding value
  • The change is backwards compatible with Python 3.10+

Security: ✅ NO CONCERNS

No security implications - this is a string formatting change in error messaging.

Performance: ✅ NO IMPACT

Negligible performance difference between quote styles.

Additional Observations

Context check:

  • The error message is part of the tool function validation system at src/upsonic/tools/schema.py:169-173
  • This validation ensures tool functions have proper type annotations
  • The message correctly lists missing annotation parameters

Potential issues to consider:

  1. No other instances found: I searched the codebase and found no other similar nested f-string patterns that would fail on Python 3.11.
  2. Pre-commit hooks: The project uses pre-commit hooks that run pytest. Ensure this passes before merging.

Recommendation: ✅ APPROVE WITH VERIFICATION

This is a valid bug fix that should be merged once CI tests pass. The change is correct, minimal, and addresses a real Python 3.11 compatibility issue.

Action items before merge:

  • Verify GitHub Actions CI passes all Python versions (3.10, 3.11, 3.12)
  • Ensure pre-commit hooks pass
  • No additional changes needed

Great catch on this Python 3.11 compatibility issue! 👍

@DoganK01 DoganK01 merged commit c754cdb into master Dec 18, 2025
4 checks passed
@DoganK01 DoganK01 deleted the nested-strings branch December 18, 2025 09:15
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants