Claude finished @dmitrymomot's task —— View job

Comprehensive Code Review ✅

I've completed a thorough review of this PR that standardizes background worker lifecycle management. Overall, this is an excellent refactoring that demonstrates strong Go idioms and architectural consistency.

Review Summary

✅ Excellent Work:

• Consistent lifecycle management across components
• Strong concurrency safety and graceful shutdown
• Comprehensive test coverage with proper patterns
• Well-designed observability features
• Maintains backward compatibility

🚀 Areas of Excellence:

Go Idioms and Best Practices ✅

Excellent adherence to Go conventions:

• Proper use of functional options pattern for configuration (WithLockCheckInterval, WithMemoryStoreShutdownTimeout)
• Consistent error handling with predefined error variables (ErrMemoryStorageAlreadyStarted)
• Clean separation of concerns between lifecycle, business logic, and observability
• Proper use of atomic operations for metrics and state management
• Interface satisfaction with implicit implementation

Particularly well-done:

• memory_storage.go:414-435 - The Run() method's errgroup compatibility pattern is textbook Go
• Both packages follow consistent naming: Start(), Stop(), Run(), Stats(), Healthcheck()

Error Handling Patterns ✅

Robust error handling:

• Proper lifecycle state validation (memory_storage.go:340-346, ratelimiter/memory_store.go:147-151)
• Graceful degradation with timeout handling in shutdown (memory_storage.go:394-408)
• Clear error messages with context: "shutdown timeout exceeded after %s"
• Consistent error types across packages in errors.go files

Concurrency Safety ✅

Excellent thread safety:

• Proper mutex usage protecting shared state (sync.RWMutex for read-heavy operations)
• Atomic operations for metrics and running state
• WaitGroup for tracking background operations during shutdown
• Context cancellation properly propagated throughout

Notable implementation:

• memory_storage.go:437-449 - The expireLocksWithWait() pattern ensures graceful shutdown waits for active operations
• Protection against double-start with clear error handling

Performance Considerations ✅

Well-optimized implementations:

• Read locks for stats collection minimizing contention
• Atomic counters for high-frequency metrics updates
• Efficient cleanup algorithms with reasonable thresholds (1-hour stale detection)
• memory_store.go:118-119 - Smart overflow protection in token bucket math

Good design choices:

• Default timeouts are reasonable (30s shutdown, 1s lock check)
• Non-blocking stats collection
• Minimal lock contention in hot paths

Test Coverage and Quality ✅

Comprehensive test coverage:

• Lifecycle tests verify Start/Stop/Run patterns work correctly
• Race condition testing with go test -race
• Error condition testing (double start, stop before start)
• Graceful shutdown timeout verification
• Stats and healthcheck validation

Proper test patterns:

• Black-box testing with package_test convention
• Parallel test execution where appropriate
• Proper cleanup and resource management

API Design and Usability ✅

Excellent API design:

• Consistent method signatures across components
• Backward compatibility maintained with deprecated Close() methods
• Intuitive functional options for configuration
• Clear stats structures for observability

User-friendly features:

• Run() method enables errgroup patterns
• Reasonable defaults (30s timeouts, 1s intervals)
• Clear documentation about blocking vs non-blocking operations

Documentation Completeness ✅

Well-documented:

• Clear method comments explaining blocking behavior
• Updated doc.go with comprehensive examples using new lifecycle patterns
• Inline comments explaining algorithmic choices (lock expiration, token bucket math)
• Proper deprecation notices for Close() methods

Specific Observations

Excellent Patterns:

1. Context Handling (memory_storage.go:358-370) - Proper context cancellation with nested select statements
2. Metrics Design - Atomic counters with thread-safe stats collection
3. Shutdown Logic - Timeout-based graceful shutdown preventing deadlocks
4. Interface Consistency - All components follow the same Start/Stop/Run/Stats/Healthcheck pattern

Minor Enhancement Opportunity:
Consider adding a WithEnabled(bool) option for components that might be conditionally disabled, though this isn't necessary for current use cases.

Conclusion

This is a high-quality refactoring that significantly improves the foundation framework's consistency and observability. The implementation follows Go best practices, provides excellent concurrency safety, and maintains backward compatibility. The comprehensive test coverage and clear documentation make this ready for production use.

Recommendation: ✅ Approve

This PR enhances the framework's robustness while maintaining its simple, intuitive API design principles.