Skip to content

Conversation

@opooladz
Copy link

@opooladz opooladz commented Oct 4, 2025

Summary

Enhanced DistillationTrainer with advanced distillation strategies for more effective knowledge transfer from teacher to student models.

New Features

1. Attention Transfer Distillation

  • Matches attention patterns between teacher and student models
  • Uses cosine distance to align attention maps across layers
  • Supports layer-wise selection for targeted matching
  • Properly handles padding with correct normalization

2. Feature Matching Distillation

  • Matches intermediate hidden representations between models
  • Uses MSE loss to align feature spaces
  • Supports layer-wise selection
  • Properly handles padding with correct normalization

3. Automatic Dimension Matching

  • Pooling-based shape alignment for different architectures
  • Handles mismatches in:
    • Number of layers (e.g., 80 → 24)
    • Hidden dimensions (e.g., 8192 → 2048)
    • Attention heads (e.g., 64 → 32)
  • Zero trainable parameters (pooling-only approach)

Files Changed

File Lines Description
distillation_config.py +82 Added 6 new configuration parameters
_fn.py +194 Added 2 new loss functions with proper masking
distillation_trainer.py +6 Updated JIT compilation for new parameters
pooling.py +167 New utility for automatic feature shape matching
DISTILLATION_UPDATES.md +692 Comprehensive technical documentation

Total: ~1,180 lines added

Technical Details

Masking Implementation

Both new loss functions properly handle variable-length sequences:

  • Attention Transfer: Zeros padded keys/queries, normalizes by valid_tokens × num_heads
  • Feature Matching: Normalizes by valid_tokens × hidden_dim for parity with unmasked branch
  • Invariance: Losses are invariant to padding amount, batch size, and sequence length

Design Choices

Feature Implementation Rationale
Dimension Matching Pooling No learnable params, zero overhead
Architecture Direct functions Simpler than strategy pattern
Model Access output_hidden_states/output_attentions Uses existing outputs, no wrapping
Masking Per-loss-type logic Proper normalization for each loss

Usage Example

import easydel as ed

# Basic logit distillation (unchanged)
config = ed.DistillationConfig(
    temperature=2.0,
    alpha=0.9,
)

# With attention transfer
config = ed.DistillationConfig(
    temperature=2.0,
    alpha=0.8,
    use_attention_transfer=True,
    attention_loss_weight=0.1,
    attention_match_layers=(6, 12, 18),  # Match specific layers
)

# With feature matching
config = ed.DistillationConfig(
    temperature=2.0,
    alpha=0.7,
    use_feature_matching=True,
    feature_loss_weight=0.2,
    feature_match_layers=(6, 12, 18),
)

# Combined strategies
config = ed.DistillationConfig(
    temperature=2.0,
    alpha=0.7,
    use_attention_transfer=True,
    attention_loss_weight=0.1,
    use_feature_matching=True,
    feature_loss_weight=0.2,
)

trainer = ed.DistillationTrainer(
    arguments=config,
    student_model=student,
    teacher_model=teacher,
    train_dataset=dataset,
    processing_class=tokenizer,
)
trainer.train()

Backward Compatibility

Fully backward compatible

All new parameters default to False or None, so existing code continues to work without modification.

Testing Recommendations

  1. Backward compatibility: Verify existing distillation code works unchanged
  2. Attention transfer: Test with different model architectures
  3. Feature matching: Test with different hidden dimensions
  4. Dimension mismatch: Test teacher/student with very different architectures
  5. Padding invariance: Test with variable-length sequences
  6. Masking correctness: Verify loss denominators match expected formulas

See DISTILLATION_UPDATES.md for detailed testing procedures.

References

  • Hinton et al., "Distilling the Knowledge in a Neural Network" (2015)
  • Zagoruyko & Komodakis, "Paying More Attention to Attention" (2017)
  • Romero et al., "FitNets: Hints for Thin Deep Nets" (2014)

Documentation

Full technical documentation available in DISTILLATION_UPDATES.md including:

  • Implementation details
  • Code comparisons (before/after)
  • Masking behavior analysis
  • Performance characteristics
  • Future enhancement ideas

Enhanced DistillationTrainer with advanced distillation strategies for more
effective knowledge transfer from teacher to student models.

## New Features

1. **Attention Transfer Distillation**
   - Matches attention patterns between teacher and student models
   - Uses cosine distance to align attention maps across layers
   - Supports layer-wise selection for targeted matching

2. **Feature Matching Distillation**
   - Matches intermediate hidden representations between models
   - Uses MSE loss to align feature spaces
   - Supports layer-wise selection

3. **Automatic Dimension Matching**
   - Pooling-based shape alignment for different architectures
   - Handles mismatches in layers, hidden dims, and attention heads
   - Zero trainable parameters (pooling-only approach)

## Files Changed

- **distillation_config.py**: Added 6 new configuration parameters
- **_fn.py**: Added 2 new loss functions (~200 lines)
- **distillation_trainer.py**: Updated JIT compilation
- **pooling.py**: New utility for automatic feature shape matching (167 lines)
- **DISTILLATION_UPDATES.md**: Comprehensive technical documentation

## Masking Implementation

Both new loss functions properly handle padding:
- Attention transfer: zeros padded keys/queries, normalizes by valid_tokens × num_heads
- Feature matching: normalizes by valid_tokens × hidden_dim
- Losses are invariant to padding amount, batch size, and sequence length

## Backward Compatibility

✅ Fully backward compatible - all new parameters default to False/None

## Usage Example

config = ed.DistillationConfig(
    temperature=2.0,
    alpha=0.8,
    use_attention_transfer=True,
    attention_loss_weight=0.1,
    attention_match_layers=(6, 12, 18),
    use_feature_matching=True,
    feature_loss_weight=0.2,
)
trainer = ed.DistillationTrainer(...)
trainer.train()
@opooladz
Copy link
Author

opooladz commented Oct 4, 2025

lets see how codex did

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant