Repository navigation
[css-counter-styles-3] Korean counter styles fallback #8870
Description
WPT & Chrome & Firefox say that Korean counter styles should fallback to cjk-decimal. WebKit and the spec don't mention a fallback for Korean counter styles.
Given CJK stands for Chinese/Japanese/Korean, I assume this is just the spec overlooking the fallback?
Activity
tabatkins commentedon May 25, 2023
...huh. Okay, doing some archeology, I find that 7ebc754 is the commit that switched the Korean styles from being defined in prose to being defined with
@counter-style; the deleted text clearly said that all of them should usecjk-decimalas fallback, but for some reason I only added that descriptor for the japanese styles.A week prior, this email between me and Koji established that we should fallback to cjk-decimal; that was implemented in 20a3d9c.
So as far as I can tell, I just made a mistake and nobody ever caught it? I suppose I'll put the fallback back in the spec. ^_^
tabatkins commentedon May 25, 2023
Uggggh, this was committed in fd972cf along with some editorial markup fixes; I'd meant to commit these two separately but accidentally typo'd the first commit and didn't realize so instead they got committed together. Oh well.
tabatkins commentedon May 25, 2023
Agenda+ to confirm the change, since this is CR.
[css-counter-styles] Korean counter styles should fallback to cjk-dec…
css-meeting-bot commentedon Jun 21, 2023
The CSS Working Group just discussed
[css-counter-styles-3] Korean counter styles fallback, and agreed to the following:RESOLVED: Accept edits from the issueThe full IRC log of that discussion
<emilio> TabAtkins: real quick rubber-stamp. Several years back we agreed that korean falls back to cjk decimal but I did it wrong<emilio> ... and accidentally default to decimal now
<emilio> RESOLVED: Accept edits from the issue